<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="249" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://historysoa.com/items/show/249?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-10-19T00:52:03+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="280">
      <src>https://historysoa.com/files/original/5/249/1891-03-16-The-Author-1-11.pdf</src>
      <authentication>d38546ab86bcdd02dfd0ca03ca67641e</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="87">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="3695">
                  <text>����������������������������������</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="5">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="3615">
                <text>The Author</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="3616">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Author&lt;/em&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="3617">
                <text>A digitised run of the Society of Authors' monthly periodical, &lt;em&gt;The Author&lt;/em&gt;, 1890&lt;span&gt;–&lt;/span&gt;1914, made available together for the first time.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Currently users can browse issues and &lt;a href="https://historysoa.com/items/browse?search=&amp;amp;advanced%5B0%5D%5Bjoiner%5D=and&amp;amp;advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=51&amp;amp;advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&amp;amp;advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Index&amp;amp;collection=&amp;amp;type=&amp;amp;tags=&amp;amp;exhibit=&amp;amp;date_search_term=&amp;amp;submit_search=Search+For+Items&amp;amp;sort_field=Dublin+Core%2CTitle"&gt;indices&lt;/a&gt; (not available for all volumes). Full text search for all issues, and other additional search functionality, will be added in 2022.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="3618">
                <text>1890–1914</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="3619">
                <text>The-Author-Issues</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <itemType itemTypeId="19">
    <name>Publication</name>
    <description/>
    <elementContainer>
      <element elementId="76">
        <name>Date</name>
        <description>The date of an event (in YYYY, YYYY-MM or YYYY-MM-DD format)</description>
        <elementTextContainer>
          <elementText elementTextId="3701">
            <text>1891-03-16</text>
          </elementText>
        </elementTextContainer>
      </element>
      <element elementId="89">
        <name>Volume</name>
        <description/>
        <elementTextContainer>
          <elementText elementTextId="3702">
            <text>1</text>
          </elementText>
        </elementTextContainer>
      </element>
      <element elementId="90">
        <name>Issue</name>
        <description/>
        <elementTextContainer>
          <elementText elementTextId="3850">
            <text>11</text>
          </elementText>
        </elementTextContainer>
      </element>
      <element elementId="91">
        <name>Pages</name>
        <description>Page range in volume</description>
        <elementTextContainer>
          <elementText elementTextId="4094">
            <text>281–308</text>
          </elementText>
        </elementTextContainer>
      </element>
      <element elementId="92">
        <name>Ngram Date</name>
        <description>Version of the date in YYYYMMDD format for use by the Ngram plugin</description>
        <elementTextContainer>
          <elementText elementTextId="6941">
            <text>18910316</text>
          </elementText>
        </elementTextContainer>
      </element>
      <element elementId="94">
        <name>Ngram Text</name>
        <description>Version of the text with no HTML formatting for use by the Ngram plugin</description>
        <elementTextContainer>
          <elementText elementTextId="6964">
            <text>Vol. 1.- No. 11]&#13;
MARCH 16, 1891.&#13;
[Price, Sixpence.&#13;
The Author.&#13;
THE ORGAN OF THE SOCIETY OF AUTHORS&#13;
:: .. (INCORPORATED).&#13;
CONDUCTED BY&#13;
WALTER. BESANT.&#13;
Published for the Society Bë&#13;
ALEXANDER P. WATT, 2, PATERNOSTER SQUARE,&#13;
LONDON, E.C.&#13;
1891.&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 280 (#336) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
ii.&#13;
ADVERTISEMENTS.&#13;
Messrs. METHUEN'S NEW BOOKS.&#13;
| METHUEN'S NOYEL SERIES.&#13;
55.&#13;
English Leaders of Religion.&#13;
Side By S. BARING GOULD.&#13;
URITH : A Story of Dartmoor, By S. BARING GOULD,&#13;
Author of "Mehalah," "Arminell," &amp;c. 3 vols.&#13;
(Ready.&#13;
Three Shillings and Sixpence.&#13;
By HANNAH LYNCH.&#13;
Messrs. METHUEN will issue from time to time a Series&#13;
PRINCE OF THE GLADES. By HANNAH LYNCH, of copyright Novels, by well-known Authors, handsomely&#13;
2 vols.&#13;
(Ready. bound, at the above popular price. The first voluntes (now&#13;
GEORGE MEREDITH. A Study. Crown 8vo. (May. ready) are :&#13;
By W. CLARK RUSSELL.&#13;
F. MABEL ROBINSON.&#13;
A MARRIAGE AT SEA. By W. CLARK RUSSELL,&#13;
1. THE PLAN OF CAMPAIGN.&#13;
Author of "The Wreck of the Grosvenor," &amp;c. 2 vols.&#13;
(Ready, S. BARING GOULD. Author of “Mehalah,” Soc.&#13;
THE LIFE OF ADMIRAL LORD COLLINGWOOD. . 2. JACQUETTA.&#13;
By W. CLARK RUSSELL, Author of "The Wreck of the Grosvenor." Mrs. LEITH ADAMS (MRS. DE COURCY LAFFAN).&#13;
With Ilustrations by F. BRANGWYN. 8vo.&#13;
(Ready.&#13;
3. MY LAND OF BEULAH.&#13;
By W. H. POLLOCK..&#13;
G. MANVILLE FENN. -&#13;
FERDINAND'S DEVICE. By WALTER HERRIES&#13;
POLLOCK. Post 8vo. 1S.&#13;
4. ELI'S CHILDREN.&#13;
- (April&#13;
By R. PRYCE. .&#13;
S. BARING GOULD. Author of " Mehalah," GoC.&#13;
THE QUIET MRS. FLEMING. By RICHARD PRYCE.&#13;
5. ARMINELL: A Social Romance.&#13;
Crown 8vo. 3. 6d.&#13;
. (Ready. EDNA LYALL. Author of " Donovan," Sr.&#13;
By J. B, BURNE, M.A..&#13;
6. DERRICK VAUGHÁN, NOVELIST.&#13;
PARSON AND PEASANT : Chapters of their Natural&#13;
With portrait of Author.&#13;
History. By J. B. BURNE, M.A., Rector of Wasing. Crown 8vo. F. MABEL ROBINSON.&#13;
. [Ready.&#13;
By E. LYNN LINTON.&#13;
7. DISENCHANTMENT.&#13;
THE TRUE HISTORY OF JOSHUA DAVIDSON,&#13;
Other Volumes will be announced in due course.&#13;
Christian and Communist. By E. Lynn LINTON. Tenth and&#13;
Cheaper Edition. Post 8vo. 15.&#13;
(Ready.&#13;
Works by S. BARING GOULD,&#13;
Author of “Mehalah," &amp;c.&#13;
Edited by A. M. M. STEDMAN, M.A.&#13;
OLD COUNTRY LIFE. By S. BARING GOULD. With&#13;
Crown 8vo. 2s. 6d.&#13;
Sixty-seven Illustrations by W. PARKINSON, F. D. BEDFORD, and&#13;
. F. MASEY. Large Crown 8vo, cloth super extra, top edge gilt,&#13;
A series of short biographies, free from party bias, of the&#13;
1os. 6d. Second Edition.&#13;
most prominent leaders of religious life and thought in this&#13;
"Old Country Life, as healthy wholesome reading, full of breezy and the last century.&#13;
life and movement, full of quaint stories vigorously told, will not be&#13;
excelled by any book to be published throughout the year. Sound,&#13;
CARDINAL NEWMAN. R. H. Hutton. (Reair.&#13;
hearty and English to the core."-World.&#13;
JOHN WESLEY. J. H. Overion,&#13;
(Ready&#13;
HISTORIC ODDITIES AND STRANGE EVENTS.&#13;
By S. BARING Govlp. FIRST SEries. Demy Svo, ios, 6d.&#13;
Second Edition.&#13;
"A collection of exciting and entertaining chapters. The whole&#13;
volume is delightful reading." -Times.&#13;
Crown 8vo. 28. 6d.&#13;
SECOND SERIES.&#13;
Under the above title Messrs. METHU EN have commenced&#13;
HISTORIC ODDITIES AND STRANGE EVENTS. the publication of a series of books on historical, literary,&#13;
SECOND SERIES. By S. BARING GOULD, Author of “Mehalah." ] and economic subjects, suitable for extension students and&#13;
Demy 8vo. Tos, 6d.&#13;
(Ready.&#13;
“A fascinating book."- Leeds Mercury.&#13;
home-reading circles.&#13;
SONGS OF THE WEST : Traditional Ballads and Songs&#13;
THE INDÚSTRIAL HISTORY OF ENGLAND.' By&#13;
of the West of England, with their Traditional Melodies. Collected&#13;
H. DE B. GIBBINS, M.A., late Scholar of Wadham College, Oxon.,&#13;
Cobden Prizeman. With Maps and Plans.&#13;
(Ready.&#13;
by S. BARING GOULD, M.A., and H. FLEETWOOD SHEPPARD, M.A.&#13;
Arranged for Voice and Piano. in 4 Parts (containing 25 Songs&#13;
LA HISTORY OF ENGLISH POLITICAL ECONOMY.&#13;
each), 3s, each nett. Part I., Third Edition Part II., Second&#13;
By L. L. PRICE, M.A., Fellow of Oriel College, Oxon., Extension&#13;
Edition. Part III., ready. Part IV., in preparation.&#13;
• Lecturer in Political Econoiny.&#13;
(Ready.&#13;
"A rich and varied collection of humour, pathos, grace, and poetic&#13;
| VICTORIAN POETS. By A. SHARP. (Nearly Keady.&#13;
fancy."-Satunlay Review.&#13;
PROBLEMS OF POVERTY: An Inquiry into the&#13;
YORKSHIRE ODDITIES AND STRANGE EVENTS. Industrial Conditions of the Poor. By J. A. HOBSON, M.A., late&#13;
By S. BARING GOULD. New and Cheaper Edition. Crown 8vo, 6s.&#13;
Scholar of Lincoln College, Oxon., U. E. Lecturer in Economies.&#13;
[Now Ready.&#13;
(Ready.&#13;
| THE FRENCH REVOLUTION. By J. E. Symes, M.A.,&#13;
TWO BOUK'S FOR BOYS. Cr. 8vo.&#13;
Principal of University College, Nottingham. (Nearly Ready.&#13;
MASTER ROCKAFELLAR'S VOYAGE. By W.&#13;
Clark Russell, Author of “The Wreck of the Grosvenor," &amp;c.&#13;
Tilustrated by GORDON BROWNE.&#13;
SYD BELTON; or, The Boy who would not go to Sea. 1. A series of volumes upon the most important topics of social,&#13;
· By G. MANVILLE FENN, Author of “In the King's Namne," &amp;c. economic, and industrial interest-written by the highest&#13;
Illustrated by GORDON BROWNE. .&#13;
TWO BOOKS FOR GIRLS.&#13;
authorities on the various subjects. The first two volumes&#13;
Cr. 8vo. 35. 6d. will be&#13;
DUMPS. By Mrs. Parr, Author of "Adam and Eve," TRADES UNIONISM-New and Old. By G. Howell.,&#13;
“ Dorothy Fox," &amp;c. Illustrated by W. PARKINSON.&#13;
M.P.&#13;
(Ready.&#13;
A GIRL OF THE PEOPLE. By L. T. MEADE, Author POVERTY AND PAUPERISM. By Rev. L. R. PHELPS.&#13;
of “Scamp and I," &amp;c. Illustrated by R. BARNES.&#13;
M.A., Fellow of Oriel College, Oxon.&#13;
(4 pril.&#13;
&#13;
UNIVERSITY EXTENSION SERIES.&#13;
&#13;
SOCIAL QUESTIONS OF TO-DAY.&#13;
METHUEN &amp; Co., 18, Bury Street, W.C.&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 280 (#337) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
AD VER TISEMENTS.&#13;
Zhc Society of Butbors (Jncorporateb).&#13;
PRESIDENT.&#13;
The Right Hon. the LORD TENNYSON, D.C.L.&#13;
COUNCIL.&#13;
Sir Edwin Arnold, K.C1.E.&#13;
II. Rider Haggard.&#13;
Alfred Austin.&#13;
Thomas Hardy.&#13;
A. W. k Beckett.&#13;
Prof. E. Ray Lankester, F.R.S.&#13;
Robert Bateman.&#13;
J. M. Lely.&#13;
Sir Henry Bergne, K.C.M.G.&#13;
Rev. W. J. Loftie, F.S.A.&#13;
Walter Besant.&#13;
F. Max-Mullbr, LL.D.&#13;
Augustine Birrell, M.P.&#13;
George Meredith.&#13;
R. D. Blackmore.&#13;
Herman C. Merivale.&#13;
Rev. Prof. Bonney, F.R.S.&#13;
Rev. C. H. Middleton-Wake, F.LS.&#13;
Lord Brabourne.&#13;
J. C. Parkinson.&#13;
James Bryce, M.P.&#13;
The Earl of Pembroke and Montgomery.&#13;
P. W. Clayden.&#13;
Sir Frederick Pollock, Bart., LL.D.&#13;
Edward Clodd.&#13;
Walter Herries Pollock.&#13;
W. Martin Conway.&#13;
A. G. Ross.&#13;
Marion Crawford.&#13;
George Augustus Sala.&#13;
Oswald Crawfurd, C.M.G.&#13;
W. Baptiste Scoones.&#13;
The Earl of Desart.&#13;
G. R. Sims.&#13;
A. W. Dubourg.&#13;
J. J. Stevenson.&#13;
John Eric Erichsen, F.R.S.&#13;
Jas. Sully.&#13;
Prof. Michael Foster, F.R.S.&#13;
William Moy Thomas.&#13;
Herbert Gardner, M.P.&#13;
H. D. Traill, D.C.L.&#13;
Richard Garnett, LL.D.&#13;
Edmund Yates.&#13;
Edmund Gosse.&#13;
Hon. Counsel—E. M. Underdown, Q.C.&#13;
COMMITTEE OF MANAGEMENT.&#13;
Chairman—Walter Besant.&#13;
Robert Bateman. i W. Martin Conway. I H. Rider Haggard. I Sir Frederick Pollock.&#13;
A. W. a Beckett. | Edmund Gosse. | J. M. Lely. I A. G. Ross.&#13;
Solicitors.&#13;
Messrs. Field, Roscoe, &amp; Co., Lincoln's Inn Fields.&#13;
Secretary—S. Squire Sprigge.&#13;
VOL. I.&#13;
OFFICES.&#13;
4, Portugal Street, Lincoln's Inn Fields, W.C.&#13;
2 A&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 280 (#338) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
AD VER TISEMENTS.&#13;
&#13;
The "Swan" is a beautiful Gold Pen joined to a rubber reservoir to hold any kind of ink, which it&#13;
supplies to the writing point in a continuous flow. It will hold enough ink for two days' constant work,&#13;
or a week's ordinary writing, and can be refilled with as little trouble as to wind a watch. With the&#13;
cover over the gold nib it is carried in the pocket like a pencil, to be used anywhere. A purchaser may&#13;
try a pen a few days, and if by chance the writing point does not suit his hand, exchange it for another&#13;
without charge, or his money returned if wanted.&#13;
There are various points to select from, broad, medium, and fine, every handwriting can be suited, and&#13;
the price of the entire instrument, with filler complete, post free, is only 10/6.&#13;
&#13;
The Gold Pens in the " Swan " are Mabie, Todd &amp; Co.'s famous make; they are 14-carat tempered&#13;
gold, very handsome, and positively unaffected by any kind of ink. They are pointed with selected&#13;
polished iridium. The "Encyclopaedia Britannica" says—"Iridium is a nearly white metal of high&#13;
specific gravity, it is almost indestructible, and a beautifully polished surface can be gained upon it."&#13;
They will not penetrate the paper, and writer's cramp is unknown among users of Gold Pens; one will&#13;
outwear a gross of steel pens. They are a perfect revelation to those who know nothing about Gold&#13;
Pens.&#13;
Dr. Olives Wbsdell Holmes has used one of Mabie, Todd k Co.'s Gold Pens since 1857, and is using the same&#13;
one (his " old friend ") to-day.&#13;
Sydney Grundy, Esq., says—" It is a vast improvement on every Stylograph."&#13;
Moberly Bell, Esq., Manager, The Times, says—" One pen lasted me for six years."&#13;
S. D. Waddy, Esq., Q.C., M.P., says—" I have used them constantly for some years, and, as far as I can remember,&#13;
have never failed me."&#13;
Send Postal Card for Free Illustrated List (containing interesting Testimonials from&#13;
the best people, who have used them for years) to&#13;
MABIE, TODD I BARD, 93, CHEAPSIDE, LONDON.&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 281 (#339) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
%\it JCtttljar.&#13;
(The Organ oj the Incorporated Society of Authors, Monthly.)&#13;
CONDUCTED BY WALTER BESANT.&#13;
Vol. I.—No. ii.]&#13;
MARCH 16, 1891.&#13;
[Price Sixpence.&#13;
CONTENTS.&#13;
Conditions of Membership&#13;
Warnings&#13;
Notes and News&#13;
A Note on the New Act&#13;
In the I.ast Ditch&#13;
Do English People Buy Books 1...&#13;
Un Debut Dans La Vie&#13;
The Signed Article&#13;
In Grub Street ... t&#13;
The Parnassus Publishing Company&#13;
Correspondence and Cases&#13;
The Production of Vouchers&#13;
On Advertisements&#13;
fAGE&#13;
. 281&#13;
. 281&#13;
.. 38a&#13;
. 286&#13;
. 287&#13;
. 288&#13;
. 391&#13;
• 293&#13;
• 294&#13;
.. 298&#13;
• =99&#13;
■ 399&#13;
. 300&#13;
&#13;
Correspondence and Cases—continued—&#13;
Authors and Reviewers&#13;
Accepted...&#13;
Literary Godchildren&#13;
Gratuitous Contributions&#13;
A Coincidence?&#13;
The Authors' Club&#13;
The Author's Book Stall&#13;
New Books&#13;
The Reading of MSS&#13;
Publications of the Society&#13;
Advertisements&#13;
300&#13;
301&#13;
301&#13;
301&#13;
303&#13;
303&#13;
303&#13;
304&#13;
3°6&#13;
306&#13;
307&#13;
CONDITIONS OF MEMBERSHIP.&#13;
The Subscription is One Guinea annually, payable on the&#13;
1st of January of each year. The sum of Ten Guineas for&#13;
life memljership entitles the subscriber to full membership of&#13;
the Society.&#13;
Authors of published works alone are eligible for member-&#13;
ship.&#13;
Those who desire to assist the Society but are not authors&#13;
are admitted as Associates, on the same subscription, but&#13;
have no voice in the government of the Society.&#13;
Cheques and Postal Oiders should be crossed "The Im-&#13;
perial Bank, Limited, Westminster Branch."&#13;
Those who wish to be proposed as members may send&#13;
their names at any lime to the Secretary at the Society's&#13;
Offices, when they will receive a form for the enumeration&#13;
of their works. Subscriptions entered after the 1st of&#13;
October will cover the next year.&#13;
The Secretary may be personally consulted between the&#13;
hours of 1 p.m. and 5, except on Saturdays. It is preferable&#13;
that an appointment should be made by letter.&#13;
The Author, the Organ of the Society, can be procured&#13;
through all newsagents, or from the publisher, A. P. Watt,&#13;
2, Paternoster Square, K.C.&#13;
A copy will be sent free to any member of the Society for&#13;
one twelvemonth, dating from May, 1889. It is hoped,&#13;
however, that most members will subscribe to the paper.&#13;
The yearly subscription is 6s. 6d., including postage, which&#13;
may be sent to the Secretary, 4, Portugal Street, W.C.&#13;
With regard to the reading of MSS. for young writers,&#13;
the fee for this service is one guinea. MSS. will be read&#13;
and reported upon for others than members, but members&#13;
cannot have their works read for nothing.&#13;
In all cases where an opinion is desired upon a manuscript,&#13;
the author should send with it a table of contents. A type-&#13;
written scenario is also of very great assistance.&#13;
It must be understood that such a reader's report, however&#13;
favourable, does not assist the author towards publication.&#13;
WARNINGS.&#13;
Readers of the Author are earnestly desired to make the&#13;
following warnings as widely known as possible. They are&#13;
based on the experience of six years' work upon the dangers&#13;
to which liteiary property is exposed :—&#13;
(1) Never to sign any agreement of which the alleged cost&#13;
of production forms an integral part, unless an&#13;
opportunity of proving the correctness of the figures&#13;
is given them.&#13;
(2) Never to enter into any correspondence with publishers,&#13;
especially with advertising publishers, who are not&#13;
recommended by experienced friends, or by this&#13;
Society.&#13;
(3) Never, on any account whatever, to bind themselves&#13;
down for future work to any one firm of publishers.&#13;
(4) Never to accept any proposal of royalty without con-&#13;
sultation with the Society, or, at least, ascertaining&#13;
exactly what the agreement gives to the author and&#13;
what to the publisher.&#13;
(5) Never to accept any offer of money for MSS., with-&#13;
out previously taking advice of the Society.&#13;
(6) Never to accept any pecuniary risk or responsibility&#13;
without advice.&#13;
(7) Never, when a MS. has been refused by respectable&#13;
houses, to pay others, whatever promises they may&#13;
put forward, for the production of the work.&#13;
(8) Never to sign away American or foreign rights.&#13;
Keep them. Refuse to sign an agreement containing&#13;
a clause which reserves them for the publisher. If&#13;
the publisher insists, take away the MS. and offer it&#13;
to another.&#13;
(9) Never forget that publishing is a business, like any&#13;
other business, totally unconnected with philanthropy,&#13;
charity, or pure love of literature. You have to do&#13;
with business men.&#13;
Society's Offices:—&#13;
4, Portugal Street, Lincoln's Inn Fields.&#13;
vol. 1.&#13;
2 a 2&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 282 (#340) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
282&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
NOTES AND NEWS.&#13;
—4&#13;
THE American Copyright Bill has passed,&#13;
and unexpectedly. Thus ends, we hope,&#13;
happily for all concerned, the long and&#13;
bitter reproach of English authors and the hard&#13;
battle of American authors. We shall no longer&#13;
pirate and plunder and prey upon each other as&#13;
the law permits. Now we begin to look round&#13;
and to ask—what next? First, let us carefully&#13;
consider the following question and answer found&#13;
in the Parliamentary Debates on Saturday, March&#13;
7th.&#13;
"Mr. Vincent asked the following question :—&#13;
Bearing in mind the renewed declaration of the&#13;
Prime Minister, on March 4th, to the Associated&#13;
Chambers of Commerce, that English remonstrance&#13;
on foreign commercial policy prejudicial to British&#13;
trade at home or abroad is wholly futile under the&#13;
present fiscal system, as we have no means of sup-&#13;
porting the remonstrance, or giving any advantage&#13;
in return for favourable concessions, what definite&#13;
domestic action, asdistinguished from remonstrance,&#13;
with a foreign power Her Majesty's Government&#13;
proposes to take to prevent injury being done to&#13;
industry and labour in the United Kingdom, and&#13;
the probable disemployment of many workpeople&#13;
concerned in the book trade, to restrain the transfer&#13;
to America of the productions of the works of&#13;
British authors desirous of securing American copy-&#13;
tight by the use in the United States of American&#13;
type or plates, and simultaneously enjoying copy-&#13;
right in Great Britain and Ireland.&#13;
"Mr. W. H. Smith.—We have no official know-&#13;
ledge of the measure, and only know from the&#13;
newspapers that it has been passed. It is quite&#13;
impossible for me to express any opinion respecting&#13;
its provisions until we see them. I do not know&#13;
what changes may have been made in the Bill&#13;
during its passage through Congress, and I am&#13;
therefore quite unable to indicate what would be&#13;
the policy or action of the Government with respect&#13;
to it."&#13;
1&#13;
Quite so. We do hot know exactly what changes&#13;
have been made in the Bill during its passage&#13;
through Congress. Therefore we must wait until&#13;
we do know. Meantime we have telegraphed for&#13;
a copy of the Act.&#13;
A meeting of the Council was called on March&#13;
12th, to consider the situation as changed by the&#13;
passing of the International Copyright Act. The&#13;
chair was taken by Sir Frederick Pollock.&#13;
The following Resolutions were proposed and&#13;
adopted:—&#13;
(1.) That at this stage of the long struggle for&#13;
International Copyright carried on in America&#13;
by the Copyright League and other citizens of&#13;
the United States, to secure copyright to foreign&#13;
authors in the States and td remove the long&#13;
existing hindrance to the natural growth of&#13;
American literature, the congratulations of the&#13;
Society be, and hereby are, expressed by the&#13;
Council now assembled.&#13;
(2.) That the Secretary be instructed on the&#13;
arrival of the Act, to have it printed and to send&#13;
a copy to every member of the Society, inviting&#13;
their advice, suggestions, or criticisms on the&#13;
probable working of the Act.&#13;
(3.) That the Copyright Committee be re-&#13;
quested to receive these criticisms and to draw&#13;
up a report on the subject.&#13;
(4.) That authors be warned meanwhile not&#13;
to sign any agreements giving up their American&#13;
rights , and not to accept any offers whatever&#13;
that may be made until the Act shall be in&#13;
working order.&#13;
(5.) That the Society without delay draw up&#13;
a Petition to the House of Lords, urging the&#13;
immediate consideration of Lord Monkswell's&#13;
Bill.&#13;
—*&#13;
Here are a few points which may be of use to u&amp;&#13;
They certainly will not be affected by any amend-&#13;
ments that may have been carried.&#13;
It will be news to many, as it was to me, to hear&#13;
that in many cases it will be unnecessary to take&#13;
out copyright, and that the practice will still con-&#13;
tinue of sending over a whole edition in sheets and&#13;
paying the duty, twenty-five per cent, on the cost&#13;
of production. Take, for instance, a book which&#13;
appeals to the scholarly and cultured class only,&#13;
and therefore cannot possibly have a large sale.&#13;
An edition of a thousand copies in sheets might&#13;
Cost, say ;£ioo. The American publisher would&#13;
pay .£125 for it. He would then produce it just&#13;
as he does now, on the chance that no one else&#13;
will pirate it. Why should they? It is too small&#13;
a market to be interfered with. Or take a book&#13;
with dainty and beautiful plates. This cannot be&#13;
pirated because the plates cannot be cheaply and&#13;
successfully imitated. It must be remembered&#13;
that in considering whether it would pay to take&#13;
out copyright, the cost of production in America&#13;
is a much larger factor than it is in this country—&#13;
wages are much higher, materials are higher. ♦—&#13;
To those who expect a magnificent harvest&#13;
immediately—a warning. Last month there was&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 283 (#341) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
283&#13;
an attempt in the Author to show that America is&#13;
taking rapid strides to the production of nearly all&#13;
her own literature. Hitherto the great mass of her&#13;
books have been of English origin. This is now&#13;
true only of the ten cent novels. These, it is true,&#13;
are English. But who can believe that the American&#13;
will prefer to read of English manners and modes&#13;
depicted in fiction, when he can get his own&#13;
equally well presented and at the same price? At&#13;
the same time, should there be any capable of really&#13;
striking the popular imagination, he will do so in&#13;
all the English-speaking countries alike. For him—-&#13;
unless he gives himself away to the first offer—&#13;
there is indeed hope. How many are there among&#13;
the living who possess this power? In a few months&#13;
we shall see.&#13;
There is another point to be borne in mind.&#13;
On this a word was said last month. The cheap&#13;
libraries, even if they are not enlarged, will have&#13;
another twenty years' run at least. To compete&#13;
with them is like competing with the works of the&#13;
dead, which can be issued by anybody and at any&#13;
price. But they will continue to be enlarged.&#13;
They will say to the English writers who are not&#13;
so much in demand in America as to call for a&#13;
copyrighted edition, "You will get nothing here&#13;
except from us—we will give you twenty dollars&#13;
for your rights." That offer will be accepted, and&#13;
so the ten cent library will be continued. Again,&#13;
even if a writer is popular, people will ask why they&#13;
should give a dollar and a half for his new book&#13;
when they can get all his old books at sixpence.&#13;
The Anti-Jacobin suggests the danger that&#13;
English writers may try to pander to American&#13;
prejudices, manners, and custpms. I do not think&#13;
this is a real danger, first, because no living&#13;
English authors have ever remained long enough&#13;
in the States to learn these prejudices. We know&#13;
the American who travels on the Continent. We&#13;
meet the American gentleman in society. But&#13;
neither the rich American who can travel nor the&#13;
American gentleman represents the great mass of&#13;
the American people, who, again, differ widely&#13;
among each other. There can be little resemblance&#13;
between the prairie farmer and the New England&#13;
lawyer—nor between the white folk of North&#13;
Carolina and the trader of Chicago. Wp cannot&#13;
pander to ordinary American prejudice, because we&#13;
do not know anything about it.&#13;
Lower down will be found a few notes on the&#13;
practical working of the Bill which will not be&#13;
affected by any amendments that may have been&#13;
added. To these notes we add a very serious&#13;
warning. Let the author be more than commonly&#13;
careful in his agreements. He must reserve&#13;
American rights by a special clause. He must&#13;
take care not to accept the first offer that is made&#13;
—men are already in the field trying to "rush"&#13;
the British author, and, if he is wise, he will refuse&#13;
to treat at all until he has seen how the new Act&#13;
works.&#13;
On the evening of the day when President&#13;
Harrison signed the Bill, he received quite a little&#13;
shower of letters and telegrams. They were lying&#13;
on the Presidental pillow when, at midnight, he was&#13;
about to climb into the gilded tour-poster assigned&#13;
to the Chosen of the Caucus. One of them, from&#13;
the shade of John Milton, began as follows:&#13;
"Grandson of my friend the Regicide," it said,&#13;
"I have witnessed with joy thine action of this&#13;
day. Thy Republic at length proves itself a des-&#13;
cendant of my own. Thou hast shaken off" the&#13;
Iniquity of a hundred years. Thou hast set free&#13;
thine own people in doing justice to another nation.&#13;
Lo! I see in my mind a noble and a puissant&#13;
nation rousing herself like a strong man after sleep&#13;
and shaking her invincible locks; a nation npt slow&#13;
and dull, but of a quick, ingenious, and piercing&#13;
spirit; acute to invent, subtile and sinewy to dis-&#13;
course. I see her as an eagle mewing her mighty&#13;
youth, and kindling her undazzled eyes at the ful)&#13;
mid-day beam." The rest need riot be quoted.&#13;
Another was from Charles Dickens. "Fifty years&#13;
ago," he said, "I beat the air with my fists, fondly&#13;
thinking that I was fighting an easy battle against&#13;
ignorance and greed. 'For fifty years the best of&#13;
your own people have been vainly, until now,&#13;
fighting that easy battle. You have shared with&#13;
us our noble inheritance, the literature of the past;&#13;
but the baser sort among you have stolen the&#13;
literature of the present. It was unworthy of a&#13;
nation desirous to be thought great. The loss you&#13;
have inflicted upon us is that of dollars only.&#13;
Upon yourselves you have inflicted the starvation of&#13;
your own literature. Henceforth, however, what is&#13;
yours is ours, and what is ours is yours. Farewell."&#13;
There were also telegrams from Charles Reade,&#13;
Wilkie Collins, Thackeray, George Eliot, and&#13;
others. They were the same in effect, though the&#13;
words differed. "We complain no longer," said&#13;
Charles Reade. "Earthly injustice affects us not.&#13;
Its memory has no longer any sting. Yet we&#13;
rejoice that we stood up for honour and equity&#13;
while we lived. And for those who have followed&#13;
us, we are glad that your people have at last chosen&#13;
the better way." These are noticeable communi-&#13;
cations, and I hear that they are to be preserved&#13;
in the Washington Library.&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 284 (#342) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
284&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
I am very pleased to publish the following com-&#13;
munication from Professor Middleton, of King's&#13;
College, Cambridge :—&#13;
"After the many instructive warnings to authors&#13;
which you have printed, with regard to what might&#13;
politely be called the conventional morality of&#13;
certain publishers, it may be a pleasure to turn to&#13;
the other side of the picture, and receive a state-&#13;
ment which will show that there are publishers in&#13;
Britain whose practice is not only just in the&#13;
highest sense of the word, but even goes beyond&#13;
that, and amounts to real generosity.&#13;
"I had an agreement with a well-known firm that&#13;
they would publish a book of mine, and pay me&#13;
for it a certain sum of money down, as soon as the&#13;
book was printed.&#13;
"This sum I received, expecting nothing further.&#13;
"Some time after, without any suggestion of&#13;
mine, I was informed by my publishers that they&#13;
proposed to give me half-profits in addition to the&#13;
lump sum they had paid me for the copyright of&#13;
my book—a quite voluntary piece of generosity cn&#13;
their part. Since then I have received, as half-&#13;
profits, a sum about equal to the original payment&#13;
for which I had bargained.&#13;
"That is to say, that in consideration of&#13;
my book being a success, the publishers have paid&#13;
me nearly double of what they were bound to do.&#13;
"Though I have no authority to do so, it can, I&#13;
hope, offend no one if I mention that the pub-&#13;
lishers referred to are Messrs. A. and C. Black, of&#13;
Edinburgh and Soho Square, London."&#13;
This document should be read prayerfully by&#13;
certain reverend and revered friends of ours.&#13;
Religion, we know, is not a thing of works, which&#13;
are rags. Yet the carnal man remarks with&#13;
surprise that a thing like this is done by the&#13;
secular, not the sacred, publisher. Messrs. A. and&#13;
C. Black were influenced by that spirit of justice&#13;
which goes beyond the letter of the agreement.&#13;
Professor Middleton, having signed his agreement,&#13;
had no further claim, made none, expected nothing&#13;
more, and entertained no other feeling towards his&#13;
publishers than that of friendly content. Yet they&#13;
went beyond their agreement. One is willing to&#13;
believe that other cases of the kind are not un-&#13;
known, though they are certainly infrequent.&#13;
Personally, I would prefer such a system of&#13;
publishing as would allow both publisher and&#13;
author to know beforehand in what proportion&#13;
results would be apportioned, and such a system I&#13;
hope that we shall arrive at Then indeed will come&#13;
the Golden Age, and we may all crown ourselves&#13;
with garlands, take down our harps and sing&#13;
madrigals by purling brooks, authors and publishers&#13;
together, while the world looks on envious and&#13;
admiring.&#13;
♦&#13;
There was held a dinner, the other day, of Pub-&#13;
lishers and Booksellers. I hope that, before long,&#13;
the other branch, perhaps the lower branch, of&#13;
the Literary Profession—that of the Authors—&#13;
may be admitted, as a branch, to this gathering.&#13;
The chair was taken by Mr. John Murray, Junior.&#13;
A person, whom I once believed to be a friend,&#13;
brought me, the day after the dinner, a paper&#13;
containing what purported to be an extract from&#13;
his speech. I am a credulous creature, and I sent&#13;
it to press. I have since discovered that I was&#13;
the victim of a hoax. These words, in fact, did&#13;
not form part of the speech. Nevertheless, as they&#13;
seem to me brave and honest words, and such as one&#13;
would expect from the heir apparent of the House&#13;
of Murray, I prefer to believe that they were&#13;
spoken. The following, then, is the forged docu-&#13;
ment in question:—&#13;
The Chairman then alluded—it does not appear&#13;
from the reports that he so much as mentioned the&#13;
Society—to the Society of Authors. "This associa-&#13;
tion of writers "—really, he said nothing of the&#13;
kind—" has of late proved that it aims at becoming&#13;
a great power in the world of living literature. It&#13;
has detected and exposed many of the cheats and&#13;
robberies practised by the dishonest members of&#13;
our trade: it has caused restitution to be made to&#13;
many victims; it has diverted a great amount of&#13;
business into the hands of honourable houses.&#13;
For these reasons, gentlemen, we have every cause&#13;
to congratulate ourselves upon its prosperity and&#13;
activity. We ought to welcome any step which&#13;
helps to purify the moral atmosphere and maintain&#13;
the honour of the calling by which we live.&#13;
Recently the Society has issued two books which&#13;
are, I venture to say, the most noteworthy things&#13;
ever done for the higher interests of publisher and&#13;
author. The first of these, called the ' Methods of&#13;
Publication,' shows exactly what is meant by every&#13;
kind of agreement—what the publisher offers the&#13;
author and the author cedes to the publisher. It&#13;
also shows the frauds which are commonly practised.&#13;
This exposure will be new to most of us here present.&#13;
But it cannot fail to do great good. The next book&#13;
is called the 'Cost of Production.' By these two&#13;
books the author is, for the first time, placed in&#13;
the position of knowing what his agreement means,&#13;
namely, what risks his publisher runs, if any, what&#13;
are his reasonable expectations, and how the joint&#13;
venture is shared. Gentlemen, an honourable man&#13;
has nothing—he can have nothing—to conceal.&#13;
We therefore rejoice at the publication of these&#13;
books, and we congratulate the Society upon the&#13;
steps it has taken."&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 285 (#343) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
285&#13;
The enclosed is a sign of the times. It has&#13;
been sent to me by one of the promoters of the&#13;
movement We shall rejoice to learn that the new&#13;
Association is flourishing. Meantime, why women&#13;
alone? Why not men and women?&#13;
"We the undersigned, pledge ourselves as&#13;
authors who believe in pure literature and high&#13;
standards of literary work, to co-operate as members&#13;
of a Society to be known as—&#13;
"The Authors' Guild of American Women.&#13;
"We are convinced that union is strength and&#13;
consultation a source of education; and we hereby&#13;
pledge ourselves to aid each other in all legitimate&#13;
channels of work; to exercise our utmost diligence&#13;
to purify publications; and to insist that literary&#13;
work performed by women, if worthy of publication,&#13;
is also worthy of just remuneration."&#13;
♦&#13;
The following communication needs no com-&#13;
ment. One might, however, point out to the&#13;
people concerned, that these things get talked&#13;
about and do not improve the name of the House&#13;
concerned. Also, that authors are getting more&#13;
shy and suspicious every day, and more inclined to&#13;
inquiry.&#13;
"In December last, induced by a friend, I sent&#13;
a MS. to a certain firm of publishers. Hearing&#13;
nothing about it I wrote in January two letters to&#13;
them, pointing out that delay would destroy my&#13;
chance of publication for the season, and requesting&#13;
their answer or the MS. They did not vouchsafe&#13;
a word of reply for some weeks, when I received a&#13;
curt note informing me that my MS. would be&#13;
returned if I sent stamps for the purpose. I sent&#13;
stamps, and after two or three days I got back the&#13;
MS., all crushed, dirtied, and disordered. On&#13;
putting it to rights I found one section missing, I&#13;
wrote again, and after another delay of some days,&#13;
the missing part was sent to me without one word&#13;
of apology."&#13;
The preceding case of discourtesy on the part&#13;
of a publisher is capped by a case of equal dis-&#13;
courtesy on the part of an editor—a religious paper&#13;
this. Religion, we know, forgives every kind of sin,&#13;
which is why sweaters flourish in religious societies&#13;
and editors of religious papers behave like the&#13;
gentleman mentioned below,&#13;
"In September an author sent to this editor an&#13;
article for his magazine. He was careful to&#13;
enclose a stamped and addressed envelope in&#13;
accordance with the directions to contributors.&#13;
"He waited five months in patience. He then&#13;
wrote, politely pointing out that he had heard&#13;
nothing about it.&#13;
"No reply at all.&#13;
"He waited nine days and then wrote again, say-&#13;
ing that if he obtained no reply he should lay the&#13;
matter before this Society.&#13;
"The MS. was promptly returned, but without a&#13;
single word of explanation or commentary."&#13;
An editor has, no doubt, to wade through a vast&#13;
quantity of rubbish, but that is no excuse for&#13;
absolute discourtesy.&#13;
The preliminary Committee of the Authors' Club&#13;
has been formed, It will begin to meet at once in&#13;
order to draw up a working scheme for the foun-&#13;
dation of the Club on a stable basis. The Authors'&#13;
House will not be forgotten, should there be found&#13;
room for it after the establishment of the Club. I&#13;
beg to announce that I am not a member of this&#13;
Committee, a statement which will perhaps make&#13;
it unnecessary henceforth for the irresponsible&#13;
paragraph writer to call it my club. But I hope&#13;
they will elect me a member.&#13;
The little exhibition of bindings of which&#13;
mention was made last month is at Tregaskis',&#13;
Holborn. It is now open to the public. All those&#13;
who care for binding should visit the place before&#13;
the books are dispersed.&#13;
I once more invite members of the Society to&#13;
consider the Author the natural home for all kinds&#13;
of questions, cases, points, difficulties, anecdotes,&#13;
&amp;c, connected with literature. I do so because&#13;
there is a danger that the paper should be regarded&#13;
as nothing more than the organ of counsel and&#13;
advice as regards agreements. That—most cer-&#13;
tainly. But we are not always signing agreements,&#13;
and in the world of letters there are many&#13;
interests.&#13;
♦&#13;
The lovers of the works of Richard Jefferies are&#13;
rapidly increasing in numbers and in enthusiasm.&#13;
I am sure that a great many of them are on the lists&#13;
of the Society—among our 750. Be it known to&#13;
these that a bust of this great interpreter of Nature&#13;
has been executed, that the Eishop and Dean of&#13;
Salisbury has granted permission to place it in the&#13;
Cathedral—and that the subscriptions still fall&#13;
short of the amount required. Will every reader&#13;
of this note—that is, every reader who can appre-&#13;
ciate the "Pageant of Summer "—send me some-&#13;
thing towards the completion of this work? I do&#13;
not beg in the name of Literature generally, of all&#13;
authors, but only of those who belong with me to&#13;
the company of those who feel that never did any&#13;
man write of field and wood, of hillside and of&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 286 (#344) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
286&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
hedge, as this man wrote. The treasurer of the&#13;
fund is Mr. Arthur Kinglake, but I will receive&#13;
subscriptions and send them on.&#13;
On Friday last the first performance at the&#13;
English Free Theatre took place. The piece was&#13;
Ibsen's " Ghosts." The accounts of the play differ a&#13;
good deal. If the critic is an ardent Ibsenite he&#13;
says that it is a most beautiful play. If he is not,&#13;
he says that it has all the faults which an acting&#13;
play ought not to have. If he is a disciple he&#13;
says it is a most wonderful sermon. If he is not,&#13;
he says that sermons are things which can, and&#13;
should, be delivered before the whole people with&#13;
open doors, not with shut doors and in fear of the&#13;
Lord Chamberlain. One thing is agreed upon by&#13;
all, that the piece owed whatever success it ob-&#13;
tained entirely to the acting of one lady. I suppose&#13;
that Ibsen has some message to deliver or he&#13;
would not have so many admirers. Meantime, let&#13;
us for the present suspend our judgment on the&#13;
new Free Theatre.&#13;
Walter Besant.&#13;
*&#13;
A NOTE ON THE NEW ACT.&#13;
ON and after July ist, authors, no matter what&#13;
their nationality, will be able to acquire&#13;
copyright in the United States, to add sixty&#13;
millions to their "public." It is simply impossible&#13;
to exaggerate the importance of such a change, not&#13;
only to "popular" writers, but to the authors&#13;
of all standard works. We hope in the next num-&#13;
berof the Author to give the Revised Statute as it will&#13;
pass into law. But, meanwhile, sundry considera-&#13;
tions suggest themselves. The conditions attached to&#13;
the acquisition of copyright are not a little onerous.&#13;
Imprimis, it is necessary (i) that before the day of&#13;
publication (in any country) the applicant should&#13;
deliver at the office of the Librarian of Congress,&#13;
&amp;c, a printed copy of the title of the "book, map,&#13;
chart, dramatic or musical composition, engraving,&#13;
cut, print, photograph, or chromo, or a description&#13;
of the painting, drawing, statue, statuary, or a model&#13;
or the design for a work of the finearts for which he de-&#13;
sires a copyright"; and (2) "not later than the day&#13;
of publication" (in any country), deliver at the&#13;
office of the Librarian of Congress two copies of such&#13;
copyright " book," &amp;c, or in the case of a painting,&#13;
&amp;c., a photograph of the same. But in the case of a&#13;
"book" it is provided (3) that the said copies shall&#13;
be "printed from type set within the limits of the&#13;
United States, or from plates made therefrom."&#13;
This provision was extended by the famous "chromo&#13;
amendment," so as to require engravings, cuts,&#13;
prints, photographs or chromo lithographs to be&#13;
printed from engravings, cuts, negatives, or drawings&#13;
on stone made within the limits of the United States,&#13;
or from transfers made therefrom. But, according&#13;
to Reuter's cablegram of the 2nd inst., this amend-&#13;
ment was amended by the Conference Committee&#13;
of the Senate and the House of Representatives so&#13;
as to confine its operation to "lithographs, chromos,&#13;
and photographs," all of which, to be the subject of&#13;
American copyright, must, we take it, have been&#13;
"produced" within the States.&#13;
A question at once arises as to the definition put&#13;
by American law upon the term "book." Does it&#13;
include, as in England, "every volume, part of a&#13;
volume, pamphlet, sheet of letterpress, sheet of&#13;
music, map, chart, or plan separately published "?&#13;
If so, obviously, the necessity of securing cony-&#13;
right arises from the commencement of publication.&#13;
It will be necessary, for instance, in order to obtain&#13;
American copyright, to duly deliver each and every&#13;
part of a serial story or work published in parts.&#13;
But as against this it may surely be argued that the&#13;
"day of publication" is the day of first publication&#13;
in complete form. (4) The "person claiming" the&#13;
copyright, may again, it appears, from Section 4952&#13;
of the Revised Statutes, be the "author, inventor,&#13;
designer, or proprietor of any book," &amp;c.—a&#13;
sufficiently wide definition. Is it intended that&#13;
anyone, acquiring priority, should, by going through&#13;
the necessary formalities, become the owner of the&#13;
copyright? Or is it necessary that he must acquire&#13;
rights from the author or his assigns?&#13;
The effect of the Bill upon the English publishers,&#13;
printers, compositors, bookbinders, and paper-&#13;
makers cannot as yet be determined. But the&#13;
fears which are openly expressed that New York&#13;
will become the centre of the book trade, are, we&#13;
believe, exaggerated. If English "stereo" is ex-&#13;
cluded from the States, in the case of copyright&#13;
works, it is practically certain that American&#13;
"stereo" will prove useless in England. The differ-&#13;
ence in typography alone would prove a fatal&#13;
objection. The same remark applies to the im-&#13;
portation of sheets or bound volumes from the&#13;
States.&#13;
It may, too, be remarked that in case it should&#13;
be necessary, there exists a useful machinery under&#13;
the Merchandize Marks Act. If there is any doubt&#13;
as to the "country of origin," the Customs author-&#13;
ities can require this to be declared on every copy.&#13;
"Printed frpm type set within the limits of the&#13;
United States " would pot, in England, be a popular&#13;
line on a title-page, The "cost of production"&#13;
will, too, thanks to the McKinley tariff, remain&#13;
much higher in the States than in England, and&#13;
English papermakers and bookbinders have not&#13;
much to fear.&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 287 (#345) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
287&#13;
IN THE LAST DITCH.&#13;
"/^VNE of the oddest and most unfortunate&#13;
I I phenomena in the history of the copy-&#13;
right discussion," says the New York&#13;
Nation, "is the appearance every now and then,&#13;
when the Pirates are ready to throw up their hands&#13;
and ask for quarter, of some moralist or theologian&#13;
to cheer them up and encourage them to make&#13;
some further resistance, by proclaiming that the&#13;
poor men have done nothing wrong, and that we&#13;
musi not call them hard names or despitefully use&#13;
them."&#13;
The last appearance of the moralist or the-&#13;
ologian, one is pleased to observe, is that of&#13;
an Englishman. Not an American at all. An&#13;
Englishman of letters. A very distinguished man&#13;
of letters. His name is here suppressed because&#13;
he does not appear to have sent his protest to&#13;
any English organ. He has been protesting in&#13;
an American paper against certain harsh language&#13;
used towards the House of Representatives for&#13;
failing to pass the Copyright Bill last session.&#13;
As regards the bad language, it never did any&#13;
good to call names, and it never will. Yet we&#13;
shall always continue to call names because it&#13;
relieves the feelings. Hear, however, the Nation&#13;
further in the matter.&#13;
"But what concerns us now is the reasons Mr.&#13;
A. gives for deprecating vituperation. One of them&#13;
is that all property, and especially literary property,&#13;
is the creation of law, and that copyright is 'a&#13;
purely artificial privilege,' and that, therefore, it is&#13;
highly indecent to speak of persons who publish&#13;
other men's works without paying for them, as&#13;
'thieves' or 'pirates.' That this man should&#13;
offer the world, in such a cause, the plea that&#13;
property is the creation of law is very curious,&#13;
because there is hardly a step in the creation of&#13;
the present English Constitution, from Magna&#13;
Charta down, which was not a protest, in some&#13;
shape, against the doctrine that a man's moral&#13;
right to his goods and chattels is at all dependent&#13;
on the provision made by law for his protection in&#13;
the enjoyment of them. The great doctrine that&#13;
taxation without representation is a thing to be&#13;
resisted with the sword, if necessary, rests on the&#13;
very proposition which Mr. A. denies. When&#13;
Hampden refused to pay the ship-money because&#13;
he had not voted it through his representatives,&#13;
seven of the twelve judges decided against him,&#13;
and his refusal was therefore illegal; but he per-&#13;
sisted in it, nevertheless, to the death, and all&#13;
Englishmen now hold his memory in reverence&#13;
therefor. The amount was trifling, but, as has been&#13;
finely said, if he had paid it he would have been a&#13;
slave.&#13;
"Property, in truth, in its moral aspect, is no more&#13;
a creation of law than justice is. It was created,&#13;
as justice was, by the appearance of a second man&#13;
on the globe. On each of the two there then&#13;
descended that great moral obligation which the&#13;
friends of copyright now seek to have embodied in&#13;
legislation—the obligation not to steal and not&#13;
to covet his neighbour's goods, his ox or his ass,&#13;
his man-servant or maid-servant, his wife, 'or any-&#13;
thing that is his.' This obligation existed before&#13;
either Parliaments or kings, before even the Ten&#13;
Commandments. It arose out of the very nature&#13;
of things. Mr. A. confounds, as do thousands of&#13;
inferior men, the question of right with the question&#13;
of security. Law cannot give a man a moral right&#13;
to the product of his labour, nor can it take it&#13;
away from him, a good illustration of which rule is&#13;
to be found in the institution of slavery. The law&#13;
deprived the negro of all legal rights, but it could&#13;
not touch any of his moral or natural right.'.&#13;
What the law does for property is to give it security.&#13;
It can, by denying security, as in the case of&#13;
literary property, make it worthless, but it cannot&#13;
lessen the owner's right to it. It cannot diminish&#13;
the moral guilt of stealing it from him. What the&#13;
apologists of Pirates mean, therefore, when they&#13;
talk of the law as a 'creator of property,' is simply&#13;
that no man can, without the help of the law, get&#13;
from property the sum of those pleasures which&#13;
make it valuable. This may be true, but how can&#13;
this fact excuse in the forum of morals the man&#13;
who avails himself of this absence of legal defence&#13;
to appropriate as much of his neighbour's goods&#13;
as he takes a fancy to? Is it possible that when&#13;
Arabs strip travellers in the desert, the offence is&#13;
not robbery, but a failure of the law to create pro-&#13;
perty in watches, guns, and camels in that particular&#13;
region?&#13;
"Mr. A., in like manner, when he comes to&#13;
speak of copyright as 'a special privilege,' con-&#13;
founds plagiarism and piracy. This is the most&#13;
fertile source of misunderstanding in the whole&#13;
discussion. What is a plagiarist? It is, says the&#13;
dictionary, a man 1 who purloins the words, writ-&#13;
ings, or ideas of another and passes them off as his&#13;
own.' Now, it is no easy thing to convict a man&#13;
of this offence unless he makes long textual&#13;
extracts. The ownership of an idea, and even of&#13;
forms of expression, is generally very difficult to&#13;
trace. The same idea often occurs to hundreds&#13;
of men at the same time, and often finds very&#13;
similar expression at the hands of hundreds of&#13;
different authors or writers. Therefore defenders&#13;
of literary property have never attempted to set&#13;
up the doctrine of 'property in ideas' which&#13;
opponents of copyright are so fond of attacking.&#13;
They have never maintained that it is or ought to&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 288 (#346) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
288&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
be unlawful to use a thought uttered by one man&#13;
for the moral or mental culture of another man,&#13;
or of forbidding the reproduction, in one man's&#13;
book or speech, of as many ideas of other men as&#13;
he can collect or re-cast to suit his purpose.&#13;
Authors or writers who do this a good deal, un-&#13;
doubtedly incur discredit by it with their fellows&#13;
and the general public. It greatly damages a&#13;
writer's fame to be rightfully accused of want of&#13;
originality, or of imitation, or of getting materials&#13;
at second-hand. But no one has ever proposed to&#13;
punish or restrain this sort of misappropriation by&#13;
law. No one has ever contended for the infliction&#13;
on the purloiners of other men's ideas of any&#13;
penalty but ridicule or disgrace, although their&#13;
name is legion and their depredations ruthless and&#13;
notorious; and yet a very large proportion of the&#13;
Pirates and their apologists expend all their&#13;
strength in showing that one man may lawfully&#13;
appropriate another man's ideas for his own use or&#13;
behoof, or even present them to the world as the&#13;
product of his own brain,&#13;
"What the champions of copyright, both national&#13;
and international, assail is, not the appropriation&#13;
of one man's ideas for another man's use and&#13;
behoof, but the sale of one man's ideas and forms&#13;
of expression in open market by another man in com-&#13;
petition with the author. This is 'piracy,' This&#13;
is what we ask to have stopped and punished by&#13;
law. We do not say to Pirates, You shall not take&#13;
the Blacks' Encyclopaedia to your home and pre-&#13;
pare articles and speeches or even books out of&#13;
its rich stores of information, and, if you are dis-&#13;
honest enough to do so, give them to the world as&#13;
your own, or absorb as much of the facts and&#13;
ideas as your mental powers will permit. What&#13;
we say is, You shall not, while denying the right of&#13;
property in it in the hands of the original author&#13;
or compiler, tseat it as property in your own hands,&#13;
and offer it for sale in competition with the man&#13;
whom you are plundering."&#13;
■ *&#13;
DO ENGLISH PEOPLE BUY BOOKS?&#13;
THE theory that English people never buy&#13;
books has long been a commonplace with&#13;
writers of leading articles and press para-&#13;
graphs. It is one of those fine old truths which&#13;
are not to be questioned: it is taken as proved.&#13;
The undoubted fact that novels are published at&#13;
a price which prohibits their purchase, is held to&#13;
establish the theory, which is irrefutable from a&#13;
certain point of view—that naturally taken by one&#13;
who buys books from him who creates them.&#13;
Without doubt, while the prices of books were&#13;
high, and when the book club provided all the&#13;
new books, very few even of the richer households&#13;
bought books at all. The book clubs, however,&#13;
have nearly all vanished; their place has been&#13;
only partly, not altogether, taken by the Circulating&#13;
Libraries. The country has become very much&#13;
richer than it was a half century since; it has also&#13;
become much more populous: the education&#13;
of the people has been enormously developed, and&#13;
the taste for reading has grown with the education&#13;
of the people. Therefore it would seem as if the&#13;
circulating libraries alone would hardly suffice for&#13;
the wants of the reading public, In addition, the&#13;
last half century has witnessed the growth of the&#13;
colonial empire from a few hundred thousands to&#13;
something like twenty millions. And they have&#13;
no circulating libraries at all. Yet they read.&#13;
Let us, however, for the moment disregard the&#13;
colonial demand. What do we see at first sight?&#13;
Take, first, our own houses. Everybody knows the&#13;
house where the dining room contains a bookcase&#13;
filled with books which are never changed and&#13;
never taken down. Gibbon is there; Robertson is&#13;
there; probablyBlair'ssermons; HumeandSmollett;&#13;
a Gazetteer; an edition of the Spectator. Formerly,&#13;
that is to say, twenty years ago, or so, this book-&#13;
case contained all the books of the house. Now,&#13;
however, there are other shelves—a case in the&#13;
drawing room filled with poetry and pretty editions:&#13;
a bookcase in the school room, or breakfast room,&#13;
filled with modern and new books—there will you find&#13;
Rider Haggard, Stevenson, Lang, Black, Hardy,&#13;
Blackmore, the newest essayist, not to mention&#13;
Dickens, Thackeray, George Eliot, Collins, and&#13;
Reade. There you will find evidence that somebody&#13;
or other in the house not only knows contemporary&#13;
literature but buys it, and that plentifully, and with&#13;
no sparing hand,&#13;
Again, watch the bookstall at a London railway&#13;
station. The place is not a stall, it is a great shop&#13;
filled with new books. Here are all the newest&#13;
works, the biographies, the dozens of Series, the&#13;
novels, the essays—everything, Stand beside the&#13;
place for a quarter of an hour before the departure&#13;
of the express. Look at the people. They crowd&#13;
about the stall: they are all buying books. Con-&#13;
sider that this goes on every hour from morning&#13;
till night—for twelve hours, or thereabouts, the&#13;
people flock to this stall and buy books. Consider,&#13;
further, that there are a dozen such stations in&#13;
London, and that the same thing goes on at every&#13;
big town in the United Kingdom. Will you still&#13;
consider us a nation which does not buy books?&#13;
But—a point which seems to make against the&#13;
extension of the book trade—the country book-&#13;
sellers' shops have certainly decreased in import-&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 289 (#347) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
289&#13;
ance and in profits during the last half century.&#13;
That is quite true. The bookseller of the old&#13;
county town was a person of great weight and con-&#13;
sideration. He had down all the new books, the&#13;
clergy and the reading public of the place looked&#13;
upon his shop as a place where literary news could&#13;
be heard and the new books examined. But then&#13;
there was no other way of getting the literary news.&#13;
The country papers had none, the London literary&#13;
papers went but little out of London, the people&#13;
seldom went to town. They were therefore de-&#13;
pendent upon the local bookseller, who, as one who&#13;
studies his market, provided for his customers the&#13;
things which he knew they would take. Also, a&#13;
thing of the greatest importance, there was no dis-&#13;
count of threepence in the shilling, and the published&#13;
price was high. A bookseller who sold a book for&#13;
1 of. 6d. which he had purchased for 7*., managed&#13;
to do very well. He was a substantial person: on&#13;
the social ladder he ranked first among the trades-&#13;
men: he stood next to the solicitor and the&#13;
doctor. Now, he has to give a discount of three-&#13;
pence in the shilling. His half-guinea volume is&#13;
reduced to three and six, which he sells for two&#13;
and eight, and for which he pays two shillings.&#13;
Therefore, he is fain to sell, in addition to books,&#13;
stationery, photographs, albums, fancy things, and&#13;
perhaps toys. His customers are independent of&#13;
him; they learn easily from the reviews all that&#13;
goes on; they order their books from London, or&#13;
from the railway stall, and they desert the local shop.&#13;
The book trade, in fact, has increased a thousand-&#13;
fold, and yet the bookseller has decayed.&#13;
Consider, next, the publishers' lists. I have&#13;
before me the Athenaum, which contains, I sup-&#13;
pose, more book advertisements than any other&#13;
paper. This single number represents fourteen firms&#13;
of publishers, most, in fact, of what are called leading&#13;
publishers. It is by no means the best publishing&#13;
time of the year. Yet, leaving out the books which&#13;
are announced only, no price being affixed, we find&#13;
an astonishing activity. Of biographical works there&#13;
are 28, ranging in price from 2s. 6d. to £5 55.; of&#13;
essays there are 29, namely, 9 at 2s. 6d., 3 at&#13;
3f. 6d., 3 at 5s., 7 at 6s., 1 at 7*., 1 at 7f. 6d, 1 at&#13;
9f., and 4 at iof. 6d. Of fiction there are some&#13;
90 works, counting new books and new editions,&#13;
viz., 17 at 3 if. 6d., 9 at 2 if., 1 at i7f., 24 at 6s.,&#13;
1 at i2f., 3 at 7f. 6d., 29 at 3f. 6d., 1 at sf., 4 at&#13;
2f. 6d., and two or three at 2f. We may pass over&#13;
art books, histories, and one or two books of&#13;
travel. If we look at this advertisememt sheet in&#13;
another three months, most of these books will be&#13;
changed for others. Now, if you please, for whom&#13;
are these books published? For the circulating&#13;
libraries? They may take all the three volume&#13;
novels. For whom are the other books issued?&#13;
For the general public. These advertisements&#13;
represent the sale of, at least, half a million&#13;
volumes; and, to repeat, the lists will be all changed&#13;
in three months' time. Is that, then, the whole&#13;
life's duration of our modern literature? It is of&#13;
the great majority of books that are published.&#13;
We remark on the price of these books. The&#13;
favourite prices are 6s. and 3f. 6d. The books&#13;
most bought are novels either at that price, or&#13;
those in the cheaper form at 2f., which are not&#13;
generally advertised in the Athenaum. And the&#13;
novels which become popular retain their vitality&#13;
for many years. Not to speak of Scott, Dickens,&#13;
or Marryat, any popular novel of the last forty&#13;
years is popular still.&#13;
But these, remember, are only the advertisements&#13;
of a casual week. Consider, one after the other,&#13;
the general list of a great publisher, that long and&#13;
encyclopaedic document embracing all subjects, and&#13;
all authors, dead and living; think of the lists of the&#13;
religious publishing houses, which cater chiefly for the&#13;
uncultivated class, and administer doctrine disguised&#13;
as fiction; think of the immense lists of books by&#13;
the so-called popular houses, which issue cheap&#13;
literature. One would like to have an enumeration&#13;
and an analysis of all the books at this moment&#13;
offered to the British public by the publishers.&#13;
Certain it is that no shop could contain a tenth&#13;
portion. Yet they are in demand—else they would&#13;
be withdrawn from the list. For whom are these&#13;
thousands of books published, and year after year&#13;
reprinted? For this folk who never buy books.&#13;
In fact, a great change has come over us in this&#13;
as in every other respect. Increased ease in cir&#13;
cumstances with an increased taste for letters has&#13;
caused us to buy books as we never bought them&#13;
before. We are now buyers on a gigantic scale.&#13;
Every good book is caught up eagerly. There is&#13;
no longer the slightest foundation for the old bogie&#13;
of risk; there is no risk about a good book except&#13;
the risk of over-printing, which no prudent man will&#13;
incur; there are novelists, not by ones or twos, but&#13;
by the score, whose books are in demand unknown&#13;
even to such admirable writers as, say, Mrs. Gaskell,&#13;
of thirty years ago. The three volume novel has&#13;
its run as of old; I have not heard that it is&#13;
decreasing in demand; but when the cheap edition&#13;
of it comes out, if it is a favourite, it is bought by the&#13;
very people who have first read it from the library.&#13;
Whether we devote as large a proportion of our&#13;
expenditure to buying books as we should is another&#13;
question. The mind must be nourished as well&#13;
as the body; it requires continual reception of new&#13;
facts, new thoughts, new theories, new lights, new&#13;
arguments. It requires continually to be refreshed&#13;
by the exhibition of the old things. In an ordi-&#13;
nary middleclass household the wife spends ^400 a&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 290 (#348) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
290&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
year on her house ; the husband, ,£75 a year on his&#13;
wine ; the family, jQi 50 a year on clothes ; the same&#13;
amount on travelling; there is also rent; there&#13;
are the hundred and fifty little things in which&#13;
money is wasted all day long. How much is spent&#13;
on books? Formerly, three guineas a year. That&#13;
was all. Only three guineas a year for the circu-&#13;
lating library and for books, nothing, except a&#13;
birthday present or two, and what the children&#13;
bought out of their pocket money. But as for any&#13;
idea that it is the duty of a man of culture to buy&#13;
his mental food as he buys his meat and bread, that&#13;
had not dawned upon their minds, nor has it yet,&#13;
though, for convenience sake, people have begun&#13;
to buy, and will, before long, buy yet more largely.&#13;
It will be now understood from these considera-&#13;
tions why we drew up certain questions and sub-&#13;
mitted them to certain well-known booksellers in&#13;
London; our best thanks are due for the courtesy&#13;
with which these questions have been answered.&#13;
They were not meant to be inquisitive or prying&#13;
questions, but general, and directed mainly to&#13;
finding an answer to the question at the head of this&#13;
paper. Had not the views already expressed been&#13;
confirmed, in the main, by these answers, they would&#13;
not have been advanced.&#13;
The following, therefore, is summarised from the&#13;
replies received. Those received from different&#13;
houses are put together so as to present a con-&#13;
tinuous opinion.&#13;
Every well-educated Englishman buys some&#13;
books. In every house will be found shelves filled&#13;
with books, chiefly new, and in most houses there is&#13;
a library, or study, or school room. Students of all&#13;
kinds have to buy their text books—a large trade&#13;
ir| itself; most professional men have a taste for&#13;
reading, and are frequently very good buyers.&#13;
Schoolboys, besides having to buy school books,&#13;
and young clerks, are great buyers of the cheap&#13;
reprints of Lytton, Ainsworth, Dickens, Jules Verne,&#13;
&amp;c, which are sold at 4^1. a copy. Ladies are&#13;
not, as a rule, good book buyers, except of books&#13;
for children, and for household purposes; when&#13;
they do buy, it is the two shilling novel. Country&#13;
people and visitors buy a great many books. City&#13;
men are often large and constant buyers. Some&#13;
have their favourite authors, and buy everything&#13;
that bears the name. The ordinary middle-class&#13;
Englishman, he who lives by his shop, does not, as&#13;
a rule, buy or read books at all. His daily paper&#13;
is sufficient for him. Yet he will, on occasion, buy&#13;
something that strikes his imagination, or that is&#13;
much talked about.&#13;
Opinions differ as to the best price for selling a&#13;
novel. One, for instance, finds that the price of&#13;
6s. is paid as readily as that of 35. 6d. Another&#13;
says that the best way to treat an author is to&#13;
publish him in uniform binding at 3s. 6d. In the&#13;
case of a really good and lasting work it seems&#13;
best to have several editions at 6.?., at 3s. 6d., and&#13;
at 2s. The 6d. books have an enormous sale.&#13;
They are generally editions of books whose copy-&#13;
right is lapsed. There is, therefore, no author to be&#13;
considered. If 100,000 copies go off, the publisher&#13;
gets id. a copy, and the bookseller id., and so a&#13;
handsome profit is realised.&#13;
There is always a great demand for old works of&#13;
fiction. Dickens, Thackeray, George Eliot, Scott,&#13;
Marryat, Charles Kingsley, and Wilkie Collins,&#13;
still continue in greater popularity than any living&#13;
writers. The bookseller suffers the living writers&#13;
to drop out of his shelves, but always keeps them&#13;
well stocked with these dead writers.&#13;
Books of travel very quickly die when the first&#13;
curiosity is satisfied. Yet there are a few excep-&#13;
tions. Darwin's "Voyage of the Beagle," the&#13;
"Voyage of the Sunbeam," Waterton's Travels,&#13;
Cook s Voyages, are always in steady demand.&#13;
Very few people buy new poetry. Yet for&#13;
Tennyson, Browning, Swinburne, Edwin Arnold,&#13;
Mathew Arnold, and Longfellow there is always a&#13;
steady demand.&#13;
As regards essays: these vary with the subjects.&#13;
For steady demand we may mention John Morley's&#13;
Essays, Charles Lamb, Lubbock's "Pleasures of&#13;
Life," Carlyle, &amp;c, while for sudden popularity&#13;
may be cited Augustine Birrell and Jerome.&#13;
Books of biography possess either a wide interest&#13;
soon satisfied, as in the life of a man recently dead,&#13;
or an abiding interest as is shown in the steady&#13;
demand for the many series now before the world.&#13;
Books of history are always in demand. The&#13;
most popular are Macaulay, Green, and Froude.&#13;
The " Story of the Nations " series is very popular.&#13;
The most popular American authors are, taking&#13;
them in order of demand—Mark Twain, Bret&#13;
Harte. Marion Crawford (if he is to be reckoned&#13;
an American), and Howells, Henry James, Holmes,&#13;
Emerson.&#13;
Foreign books do not compare in popularity&#13;
with native productions. Daudet, Georges Ohnet,&#13;
Boisgobey, Gaboriau, Dumas, Eugene Sue, Jules&#13;
Verne, are largely asked for.&#13;
The discount of $d. in the is. has been much&#13;
discussed by the trade. A Booksellers' Associa-&#13;
tion has been formed to consider this among other&#13;
matters. They have come to the conclusion that&#13;
the discount must be retained, but that it must not&#13;
be increased.&#13;
As regards the extent of the colonial trade, no&#13;
statistics have been furnished, and perhaps one&#13;
cannot expect to arrive at any. But one book-&#13;
seller pertinently points out that many houses are&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 291 (#349) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
291&#13;
engaged in nothing else but the export of books, a&#13;
fact which proves that the trade is very great.&#13;
Enough has been adduced to prove that it can&#13;
no longer be charged against us that we do not&#13;
buy books. On the contrary, we buy vast quan-&#13;
tities. Whether we buy as many as we ought,&#13;
considering the number we read, is another matter.&#13;
In our next number we may perhaps, by some&#13;
analysis of publishers' lists, arrive at a closer&#13;
estimate of the vast national interest of what is&#13;
familiarly called the Trade.&#13;
UN DEBUT DANS LA VlE.&#13;
"OU are now, Martha Londers," said the&#13;
Matron of the Orphanage, "about to&#13;
enter upon the duties and responsibilities&#13;
of life. Your career begins to-day. It depends&#13;
upon yourself where it ends. It may be that you&#13;
will rise to be housekeeper in a mansion, or even&#13;
—such things have happened—to be Matron of an&#13;
Institution."&#13;
Martha Londers blushed; that is to say, a&#13;
naturally rosy face .became fiery red, or even, in&#13;
spots, purple; then she smiled—with breadth;&#13;
then her eyes became humid, and a big tear, not&#13;
of sorrow, but of joyful, emotional hope, swam&#13;
gently over the amplitude of her cheek; and her&#13;
nose, naturally broad, widened and glistenedi The&#13;
occasion was great; the emotion of Martha was&#13;
natural; for the first time in her life she was going&#13;
to leave the retreat of the Orphanage, and to enter&#13;
upon the world. All was before her: she was&#13;
seventeen years of age, and she was beginning her&#13;
career as assistant housemaid. What then? Many&#13;
a field marshal has begun as a common soldier:&#13;
many an archbishop has risen from the plough.&#13;
To have one foot upon the ladder, even it be the&#13;
lowest rung, is something. Martha Londers had&#13;
two—solid and substantial feet they were—and she&#13;
felt as if she must rise.&#13;
"You must be ambitious," continued the&#13;
Matron. "Remember that your present wages—&#13;
they will be ten pounds at first"—Martha gasped&#13;
and choked—" are only a beginning to one who&#13;
is ambitious. She who means to rise must show&#13;
her ambition by her work. She must be active,&#13;
early rising—I think I have detected in you, Martha,&#13;
a tendency to an inclination to love your bed—&#13;
thorough and zealous. Let all that you do be well&#13;
done, thoroughly done—done in earnest—done as&#13;
if you meant it to be so well done that not even&#13;
the most scrupulous housewife could detect a&#13;
fault With these maxims to guide you, Martha&#13;
Londers, I may safely leave you. To some girls I&#13;
should add a warning about beauty being only&#13;
skin deep,"—where, as in Martha's case, it is deeper&#13;
than that, it sinks below the surface and becomes&#13;
invisible.—"To you I would only say that temp-&#13;
tation to all women, beautiful or otherwise, fre-&#13;
quently assumes the shape of Man. Beware,&#13;
therefore."&#13;
"He will be home," said the housemaid, "to&#13;
morrow morning. The Master's study has been&#13;
left to the last. You can do it this morning,&#13;
Martha. As he won't have it touched while he is at&#13;
home, make a good job of it"&#13;
It was eight o'clock in the morning. The day&#13;
was all before her. Martha felt that her work—&#13;
she had only been- in the house two days—was&#13;
already appreciated. She had been kindly allowed&#13;
to scrub the greater part of the house from garret&#13;
to cellar, and she was now entrusted with the&#13;
important mission of cleaning up the Master's study.&#13;
Everybody in the collecting line knows the&#13;
name of that Master. No man had a safer judg-&#13;
ment about Aldines and Elzevirs; his collection of&#13;
Elizabethan poets was almost complete; he knew&#13;
the prices of books better than Mr. Bain himself;&#13;
and he could talk by the hour of the prices which&#13;
books had fetched. Then for bindings, he knew&#13;
the work of everyone, Maioli, Grolier, Eve, Derome&#13;
—all—and he possessed specimens which were the&#13;
envy of all his brother collectors. Again, he had&#13;
books which belonged to the library of Marie&#13;
Antoinette, of Madame Du Barry, Madame de&#13;
Pompadour, and others whose books are valuable&#13;
for their bindings and their rarity. In fine, the&#13;
chase of books was the chief occupation of his life.&#13;
What sayeth "A. L" in his book of the Library?&#13;
"Pour tout plaisir que Ton goute icy-bas&#13;
La Grace a Dieu. Mieulx vaut, sans altercas,&#13;
Chasser bouquin. Nul mat n'en peult s'eh suivre.&#13;
Or sus au livre; il est le grand appas.&#13;
Clair est le ciel. Amis, qui veult me suivre&#13;
En bouquinant?"&#13;
He was a man—say, rather, a collector—of&#13;
catholic tastes, not bounded by books alone&#13;
though his real strength lay in books. He had,&#13;
for instance, on a great study table beside the&#13;
catalogues which formed his library of reference,&#13;
trays of valuable coins; he had Things—he called&#13;
them Things—in bronze, Things in brass, Things in&#13;
silver; panels lay about with wood carvings upon&#13;
them—precious carvings picked up at sales, in&#13;
brie h. brae shops, Things from city churches which&#13;
they were pulling down, Things from Egypt, Things&#13;
from Etruscan tombs, Things from Phoenicia, Things&#13;
from Tunis, Things from Spain, Things ancient,&#13;
Things mediaeval. The study, in short, a large and&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 292 (#350) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
292&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
handsome room on the first floor of a big house&#13;
in Fitzjohn's Avenue, was crammed and crowded&#13;
with old and curious Things.&#13;
And Martha Londers, bursting with impatience&#13;
to show her zeal, was turned into this room to clean&#13;
it up.&#13;
It was the last day of the Master's summer&#13;
holiday. He had spent it wholly among the&#13;
Italian shops. It was never too hot for him, so&#13;
long as he could sit among the Things. Rome&#13;
in August was as pleasant as Rome in April,&#13;
provided there were Things to look at. Where&#13;
are there no Things in Italy—Land of Things?&#13;
It was over, and he was on his way home. And&#13;
Martha Londers was in his study.&#13;
She had the house all to herself, because the&#13;
other servants went out for a holiday and left&#13;
her alone with her work. Alone? No, not alone.&#13;
There sat on a corner of the highest shelf, invisible&#13;
to Martha, a Creature which grinned and mocked&#13;
and laughed, and held its sides and rolled about&#13;
with laughing. But not aloud—so that Martha&#13;
neither heard nor saw, but went on with her work.&#13;
Thorough work; zealous work; work in which&#13;
not the most scrupulous housewife could find the&#13;
least fault or omission. Work methodical and&#13;
complete. Observe that Martha had never before&#13;
seen a study or a library. There were books for&#13;
the girls at the Orphanage ; they were distributed&#13;
for Sunday reading between the three services;&#13;
but a library she had never before seen.&#13;
First she surveyed the whole; then she took&#13;
down a book and found that it was dusty on the&#13;
top, and that the shelf behind was very dusty.&#13;
Then she saw that many of the books presented a&#13;
faded and careworn exterior which she thought she&#13;
could improve; and she observed with concern that a&#13;
great quantity of the Things wanted cleaning badly.&#13;
She went out and returned bearing a mop, a&#13;
bucket of warm water, some soap, a scrubbing-&#13;
brush, a knife for scraping, some plate powder, and&#13;
other ingredients, with the help of which she pur-&#13;
posed to pass a useful and a pleasant time.&#13;
As she was alone in the house she sang over her&#13;
work. At the Orphanage the girls only sang&#13;
hymns. Martha, therefore, in a contented mur-&#13;
murous kind of croon, while she scrubbed with zeal,&#13;
beguiled the time with "Lead, kindly Light."&#13;
She first removed the books from the top shelf;&#13;
then, mounted on a chair, she sluiced that shelf&#13;
with water and scrubbed it with soap, wiping it dry&#13;
with a towel. It was beautifully clean when she&#13;
finished it. No one would blame her, of course,&#13;
because the water dripped through upon the books&#13;
below, lodged and lurked between their bindings,&#13;
and splashed their backs. She took out those of&#13;
the second row, wiped them dry with her towel—&#13;
everybody knows how a book bound in Russia&#13;
leather or Morocco is improved by a splash of&#13;
water and a good rub with a damp towel—and&#13;
proceeded to sluice and scrub the boards; and so&#13;
on until the morning was spent—the shelves&#13;
completely cleaned, and the books, one and all,&#13;
beautified for ever with her towel.&#13;
Martha, well content so far, now retired to the&#13;
kitchen and made a hearty meal off the cold&#13;
mutton and potatoes provided for her by the cook&#13;
before she left the house. She then mounted the&#13;
stairs once more and began the second part of her&#13;
work, singing again; but she changed her tune&#13;
and now encouraged herself with "Art thou weary?&#13;
art thou languid?"&#13;
All day long the Creature who sat on the highest&#13;
shelf laughed and rolled about with laughing.&#13;
But he was invisible to Martha.&#13;
When, about seven in the evening, she com-&#13;
pleted her job, she had scraped and polished the&#13;
bronzes, the coins—for which she used a file—and&#13;
the old silver; she had "restored" the old leather&#13;
bindings with a material commonly used for&#13;
saddles; she had cleaned and wiped the books;&#13;
some, though very old, had never been cut—this&#13;
omission she repaired; others, mostly pamphlets,&#13;
which had ragged edges, she cut even and neat&#13;
with a pair of scissors; the wood carvings she had&#13;
scraped when that process seemed necessary, and&#13;
in all cases had scrubbed so that the panels now&#13;
looked really beautiful. No one would notice&#13;
and, indeed, it could not matter, that a few bits&#13;
had come off—a grape or two, a flower, a flourish,&#13;
the round knob of a cherub's nose. Finally, the&#13;
Things looked now so very, very much better for&#13;
their thorough repair and so different from their&#13;
former grimy condition that Martha's honest heart&#13;
swelled with pride and pleasure. What would the&#13;
Master say when he returned? He would look&#13;
about him with surprised satisfaction; he would&#13;
ask what new hand had done this: he would be&#13;
told that it was the hand of the new under house-&#13;
maid, Martha Londers; and he would nod his head,&#13;
promising himself to keep his eye upon Martha.&#13;
Perhaps he would send for her to express his satis-&#13;
faction and his approbation. When Martha, on her&#13;
knees that night, made the usual confession of her&#13;
sins, she could not help—it was not in human&#13;
nature—feeling that for once the good deeds&#13;
outweighed the bad, and left a balance to carry&#13;
forward. 'Twas a Papistical thought, but she&#13;
knew not the errors of the Roman Church, and&#13;
may be excused.&#13;
The Master, who had been travelling all night,&#13;
arrived about seven o'clock. Martha observed&#13;
him with curiosity. He was an elderly mm,&#13;
somewhere in the fifties or perhaps in the early&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 293 (#351) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
293&#13;
sixties; he was red-faced and of a full habit, but&#13;
he moved with activity—a collector is always&#13;
active; sometimes, to get before other collectors,&#13;
he must even run. He entered the house.&#13;
Martha was dusting the stairs and dropped a&#13;
curtsey which he noticed with a nod. It will be a&#13;
nod and a smile to-morrow, Martha thought. He&#13;
went up stairs—but no—not yet—not into the&#13;
study. He first had a change in his bed room,&#13;
and then he descended to the dining room and&#13;
took breakfast and the morning paper; he then,&#13;
being fatigued with his night's travelling, fell asleep&#13;
in his easy chair and so continued until noon or&#13;
thereabouts.&#13;
When he awoke he rose, yawned loudly, and&#13;
walked to the door. Martha was dusting the&#13;
hall clock. Now, at last, he was going into his&#13;
own study.&#13;
He was.&#13;
As he went up the stairs Martha in her agitation&#13;
nearly slipped off the chair on which she was&#13;
standing. She stopped her dusting, and steadied&#13;
herself to listen. Surely, surely he would notice—&#13;
he would not fail to notice—the thoroughness of the&#13;
cleaning, the zeal of the cleaner, the completeness&#13;
of the job. He must notice it; he must ask who&#13;
did it; he must be ready to-morrow with a smile&#13;
of appreciation.&#13;
What was that? The house trembled from&#13;
rafter ridge to basement; the walls rocked to and&#13;
fro; the glass on the side-board vibrated musically&#13;
but strangely; the pictures rocked and swung;&#13;
and Martha's heart stood quite still.&#13;
A roar—a long prolonged roar j another roar;&#13;
a third, louder and more terrifying. Martha's&#13;
cheek turned white and her knees trembled&#13;
beneath her as she stood upon the chair. Then a&#13;
howl—a prolonged howl as of a wild beast in&#13;
agony—and then the ringing of the bell—the study&#13;
bell, as if all the bells in the whole house were&#13;
ringing at once. Then a hasty footstep upon the&#13;
landing, and the Master's head, purple, his eyes&#13;
standing out, his arms outstretched, his fists&#13;
clenched, showed over the balustrade, while he&#13;
cursed and swore with such language as Martha&#13;
had never before heard even from the lowest&#13;
court, while the Orphans took their walks abroad.&#13;
Her head reeled; she fell from the chair headlong&#13;
and lay upon the floor.&#13;
The housekeeper rushed up the stairs. "Good&#13;
Lord !" she cried, "what's the matter?"&#13;
The Master seized her by the arm and dragged&#13;
her into the study. Now reduced to speechlessness,&#13;
save for half articulate interjections which betrayed&#13;
his emotion, he pointed to the trays of coins, to&#13;
the bronzes, to the old silver, to the books—&#13;
to the Things. The woman, who knew what&#13;
Things meant, gazed in stupefaction. The Master&#13;
roared again. He could now do nothing but&#13;
roar.&#13;
Downstairs, in the hall, Martha came to herself&#13;
and sat up sick with fright. What was the&#13;
matter?&#13;
The other servants were gathered at the foot of&#13;
the stairs listening. Presently, the roaring died&#13;
away, and the voice of feminine weeping and&#13;
lamentation, mixed with masculine thunderous&#13;
rumblings, succeeded.&#13;
Still the housekeeper came not down, and still&#13;
they listened awestruck by the unknown disaster.&#13;
No one took any notice of Martha, though she had&#13;
got a lump as big as an egg at the back of her&#13;
head by her fall, and though she was white with&#13;
terror. For now she understood, somehow or&#13;
other, that the trouble overhead was connected&#13;
with herself.&#13;
At last, the housekeeper came down, her eyes&#13;
red with tears.&#13;
"Martha," she said, with an attempt at calmness,&#13;
"go upstairs and pack your box. Not another&#13;
hour shall you stay. Go! You shall have your&#13;
month's wages. Go back to your Orphanage.&#13;
Tell them that sent you out that you're only fit to&#13;
scrub the floors of your Asylum. Go! She's&#13;
ruined," the housekeeper explained, "the whole&#13;
of the Master's collections—the finest collections&#13;
in London. Ruined and spoiled them all, she&#13;
has. That's all. Nothing more. Books and&#13;
coins, and old silver and all. Go, I say, for fear&#13;
I take and slap you. Ruined them all. The&#13;
work of the Master's life ruined, and in a single&#13;
day by a . . by a . . by a Drab." Martha&#13;
screamed and fled. "Oh! it's too much—it's too&#13;
much! Poor dear gentleman! He's quite broken&#13;
hearted. He can never, never get over it. He's&#13;
quieted a bit, at last, and he's sittin' on the floor&#13;
now, with his ruined collections round him."&#13;
This was Martha Londers' entrance upon her&#13;
Career. This was the lamentable fashion in which&#13;
she returned to the Matron that same day,&#13;
*&#13;
THE SIGNED ARTICLE.&#13;
THE proposal of Mr, Atkinson to compel the&#13;
writers of editorial articles to sigh what&#13;
they write has not led to the discussion&#13;
one might have expected. But Mr. George&#13;
Augustus Sala, in his "Echoes of the Week," had&#13;
some very interesting remarks on the merits and&#13;
demerits of the signed article. He says, "I have&#13;
always been a strenuous advocate of the anony-&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 294 (#352) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
294&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
mous in journalism so far as leading articles are&#13;
concerned." Few people are better qualified to&#13;
speak with the authority of so experienced a&#13;
journalist as Mr. Sala. If anything should be&#13;
anonymous surely it is the leading article, which is&#13;
supposed to be the expression of the opinion of the&#13;
whole staff of a paper or party rather than of an&#13;
individual. Nevertheless there seems to be a&#13;
tendency now in favour of signed articles, other&#13;
than editorials in the weeklies, for instance; and&#13;
the monthly reviews are certainly more read than&#13;
the stale confections of the Quarterly and Edin-&#13;
burgh, which, if people ever read at all, they pay&#13;
little heed to. True, there is a pleasant antiquarian&#13;
flavour about the notorious reviews on Keats,&#13;
Byron, Thackeray, Tennyson, and the Brontes.&#13;
They are relics of the haute ecole of scurrility—&#13;
that scurrility which, though like everything else,&#13;
as we are told, is in its decadence, is found not&#13;
in the new journalism^ but in the newest, the&#13;
brand-new journalism. While endorsing the&#13;
opinions of Mr. Sala, it is impossible to agree with&#13;
Mr. W. H. Smith, that " the liberty of the press,"&#13;
with rare exceptions, is far from being abused. The&#13;
most disgusting personalities about eminent men&#13;
are read every day with relish by thousands. We&#13;
hear what an eminent poet eats for breakfast, what&#13;
a politician drinks for dinner, the colour of the hair&#13;
of the eldest daughter of an eminent painter, and&#13;
the details of an internal disease that a well-&#13;
known doctor is suffering from. If this is toler-&#13;
ated would we be any better by knowing who the&#13;
purveyor of such small talk was? What middle-&#13;
man of journalism is responsible for jottings from&#13;
the area, nursery, and servants' hall?&#13;
No, far better to let him or her remain&#13;
anonymous. Again, the question of reviewing&#13;
books is an insurmountable objection to signed&#13;
articles. Some books are bad, and some we do&#13;
not like. A reviewer would be plunged into an&#13;
impossible correspondence, and the editor would&#13;
come in for his share if a review were signed.&#13;
Why review books at all? is the question some&#13;
people ask; but authors, especially young authors,&#13;
like other human beings, are vain, and prefer to&#13;
have their works attacked than not noticed at all.&#13;
Anonymity in an article on some general&#13;
question by an unknown writer, gives that article&#13;
a value it might not otherwise possess. It is a&#13;
distinct blow to learn that some fine piece&#13;
of criticism is not by a Pater or Saintsbury, or&#13;
an Andrew Lang, but the first effort of a Mr.&#13;
Snook, who has just left the University. Then,&#13;
too, there are many really important things a&#13;
journalist might say (personality and scurrility&#13;
barred) that he could not and would not care to&#13;
say if the article were signed. That is why the&#13;
Saturday Review contains so much the best&#13;
reading in the whole of any of the weeklies. The&#13;
signed article should be left to the monthly&#13;
reviews, where we can find out what Mr.&#13;
Gladstone has been reading, and what Mr. Parnell&#13;
is thinking of. This, we believe, is the public point&#13;
of view. Many eminent writers take the other side&#13;
of the question; but in a daily morning paper, at any&#13;
rate, the only signed contributions should be&#13;
Reuter's telegrams and the advertisements, so&#13;
that false news and false witness may be traced to&#13;
their original source. Perhaps the most offensive&#13;
type of the brand-new journalism which is always&#13;
anonymous, is art criticism. Like science, art&#13;
requires a thorough expert, and while anyone is&#13;
at liberty to dislike this or that painting, no one&#13;
should indulge in personal abuse and offensive&#13;
invective of the painter himself.&#13;
In all journalism, where some qualification as&#13;
well as opinion is requisite, it is as well that a name&#13;
should appear; to use Mr. Atkinson's words, "so&#13;
that the public may know in each case how much&#13;
or how little attention is due to each article.''&#13;
F.&#13;
[This is one side of the question. Perhaps&#13;
some readers might like to add, briefly, their views.&#13;
—Editor.]&#13;
*&#13;
IN GRUB STREET.&#13;
—»—&#13;
TH R proprietors of Answers are certainly the&#13;
most generous patrons of literature. They&#13;
have forwarded j£i,ooo, I am told, to the&#13;
widow of a man who was killed on the railway,&#13;
because he had in his possession a copy of their&#13;
entertaining periodical when he met his death.&#13;
The advertisement was certainly a splendid one.&#13;
The widow of any gentleman found dead with a&#13;
copy of the Author on his person, will receive&#13;
either a thousand copies of the current number,&#13;
or a free copy for life. This generosity should&#13;
be encouraged in all grades of journalism and&#13;
letters. The Author, though only costing sixpence,&#13;
is worth quite a guinea a number.&#13;
There are many authors who will not sympathise&#13;
with Ouida's complaint in the Titnes, and who&#13;
would have considered it rather a compliment than&#13;
otherwise to have their nom de plume utilised in&#13;
the interests of commerce. It was an act, however,&#13;
of flagrant literary piracy, and let us hope that the&#13;
company will be courteous enough to find some&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 295 (#353) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
295&#13;
no less musical and attractive sobriquet as that&#13;
which at present belongs to a distinguished&#13;
authoress. Shakespeare's creations have been&#13;
used to advertise soap and pills, so that Ouida&#13;
is certainly in excellent company.&#13;
There is a "melancholy and altogether pathetic&#13;
interest" attaching to the last story of Mr.&#13;
Ignatius Donelly's Great Cryptogam, in which a&#13;
Daniel indeed came to judgment. An American&#13;
farmer, according to Black and White, had pur-&#13;
chased his two volumes under the impression&#13;
that Shakespeare would be exposed; when, how-&#13;
ever, the tallyman came round for payment he&#13;
professed himself unconvinced, and returned the&#13;
books. A law suit followed, and the learned&#13;
judge, who had something of an Arabian caliph in&#13;
him, decided that the farmer would have to disprove&#13;
the cryptogam before he would be exempt from pay-&#13;
ment. Had it gone the other way, a very dangerous&#13;
precedent would have been created. For, on the&#13;
same principle, we might refuse to pay booksellers&#13;
who supplied us with dull or disappointing works.&#13;
The biography of John Wesley, by J. H. Overton&#13;
(Methuen and Co.), is one of the very best of the&#13;
many lives that have been written, and shows the&#13;
great preacher in quite a new light. The compli-&#13;
ments that are being paid by one sect of Christians&#13;
to another now-a-days are very charming. At the&#13;
same time it appears strange for the press, com-&#13;
menting on the Wesley centenary, to say that&#13;
Wesley " belongs as much to the English Church"&#13;
as to the Nonconformists. The same thing has&#13;
been said of Newman lately. Now these two&#13;
eminent divines made themselves famous, either&#13;
by leaving the English Church or causing others&#13;
to leave it. I do not think, therefore, that the&#13;
Anglican Church can lay much more claim to them&#13;
than the Roman Communion can Dollinger or&#13;
Renan.&#13;
♦&#13;
To return once more to Mr. Andrew Lang's&#13;
"Essays in Little." The boldest of us may tremble&#13;
before admitting that we disagree with him.&#13;
There is no more appreciative writer living, unless&#13;
it be Mr. Ruskin; then why cannot he see some-&#13;
thing in the Russian novelists? He is always tilt-&#13;
ing at them : whether he is speaking of Dumas,&#13;
Thackeray, or Dickens. Perhaps it is the admirers&#13;
of Tolstoi that Mr. I^ang objects to. There are&#13;
three ways of taking Tolstoi: one of them is to read&#13;
him, the second way is to admire him, and the&#13;
third way is to abuse him. Mr. Lang has tried a&#13;
vol. L&#13;
combination of all three, but surely one may burn&#13;
incense at the high altar of Shakespeare, let us say,&#13;
and at the same time have a side chapel for Mr.&#13;
Andrew Lang. Cannot the same argument be&#13;
applied to Dumas and Dostoieffsky? In Tolstoi's&#13;
short stories especially there are moments as good&#13;
as any in English literature.&#13;
Speaking of Dickens again, Mr. Andrew Lang&#13;
is very angry with those people who say they&#13;
cannot read Dickens, but it is much better to say&#13;
so than to pretend to an admiration of the&#13;
"darling of the English people." In one of&#13;
Mr. James Payn's delightful essays on the sham&#13;
admiration of literature, he tells several amusing&#13;
stories thereon, one of a lady who confessed she&#13;
could not see the fun of John Gilpin, and a gentle-&#13;
man who preferred the "Earthly Paradise" to&#13;
"Paradise Lost." Even at the expense of cutting&#13;
a poor figure, surely it is better to be honest about&#13;
what you like to read. I much prefer reading, for&#13;
instance (I know many will, but in secret, agree&#13;
with me), "Essays in Little" to Milton's reply to&#13;
Salmasius.&#13;
The death of Poet Close was a local rather than&#13;
a national loss. No doubt some future Mr. Andrew&#13;
Lang will be able to find something as amusing in&#13;
his work, as Mr. Lang has found in that of Haynes&#13;
Baily. Like Mr. Martin Tupper, he belonged to&#13;
the good rather than to the great. The death of&#13;
Fortune1 du Boisgobey, though hardly noticed in&#13;
most of the English papers, received an eloquent&#13;
obituary notice in the pages of the Saturday&#13;
Revieiv. I confess that I envy those people who&#13;
were amused by him. I think Hugh Conway told&#13;
much better stories, and that several other English&#13;
writers of sensational fiction are better than this&#13;
French novelist on his own ground.&#13;
All writers of sensational novels have at one time&#13;
or another been hard pressed for an idea, and the&#13;
mysterious disappearance of a lady from the Law&#13;
Courts the other day is full of suggestion for a&#13;
capital romance. Some enterprising journal might&#13;
offer a prize for the best story founded on the&#13;
incident. It would be very amusing to see how&#13;
each person worked at the explanation of the&#13;
mystery.&#13;
Mr. Egerton Castle, having already distinguished&#13;
himself as an author, has been winning further&#13;
laurels at the Lyceum. "Consequences" has&#13;
2 13&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 296 (#354) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
296&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
reached its second edition, so let us hope it will&#13;
soon appear in one~ volume. If poetry is in&#13;
danger, fiction is certainly safe when Mr. Castle&#13;
has won the public applause. Perhaps he will&#13;
be generous enough to give us also ere long a&#13;
second edition of his delightful lecture.&#13;
The March number of the Fortnightly Revinv&#13;
which, with the exception of the Author, is the best,&#13;
I think, of all the monthly periodicals, is particularly&#13;
interesting. Mr. Swinburne has some splendid&#13;
stanzas for a statue of Marlowe, and Mr.&#13;
Meredith continues "One of our Conquerors."&#13;
Mr. Oscar Wilde gives a very original form of a&#13;
preface for "Dorian Grey," in which he rebukes&#13;
his critics in a series of pregnant aphorisms.&#13;
"Dorian Grey," who shines like an evil thing in a&#13;
very good story, will shortly appear with more&#13;
harmonious surroundings than Lippincotfs Maga-&#13;
zine. Among the many good articles in the&#13;
Fortnightly, that on "Rossetti and the Moralists"&#13;
is unfortunate. The writer seems to me to have&#13;
entirely misconceived Rossetti's genius, and mis-&#13;
understood the position he occupies in literature&#13;
and art.&#13;
Mr. George Moore has reprinted more than a&#13;
dozen articles. They form a most interesting&#13;
volume. It would be pleasant to notice many of&#13;
them at some length. The articles on Balzac,&#13;
Turgenieff, Verlaine, Rimbault, are highly&#13;
suggestive, as is indeed all Mr. George Moore's&#13;
work in this his special field of criticism. With&#13;
regard to Turgenieff, I have never understood the&#13;
disproportionate admiration felt for the least re-&#13;
markable of the new Russian novelists. We have&#13;
again studies on " Le Reve " and Ibsen's "Ghosts."&#13;
The " Notes on Ghosts " has come very opportunely&#13;
before the appearance of the play at the Royalty.&#13;
If there is anything to be said against Mr.&#13;
George Moore's book, it is that the egoism which&#13;
he displays is to be regretted.&#13;
♦&#13;
Perhaps the article on the new pictures in the&#13;
National Gallery is rather out of place in a volume&#13;
on literary subjects, nor can I think that the&#13;
pictures of Mr. Frith are otherwise than eminently&#13;
in their place in the British School. Whether&#13;
that school deserves a place in the Gallery is another&#13;
matter.&#13;
Verlaine is one of the most remarkable&#13;
characters of the second half of the century,&#13;
reminding us, as we are apt now to forget, that strong&#13;
and sincere religious belief has always been found&#13;
compatible with great disorder of life. A considera-&#13;
tion of his life and works would be a wholesome&#13;
occupation for " Moralitarians " of all kinds. They&#13;
cannot do better than begin with Mr. George Moore's&#13;
study. The "Balzac " is an article first printed&#13;
in the Fortnightly, "increased to nearly three times&#13;
its original length," and greatly improved. As a&#13;
realistic critic of Balzac, Mr. George Moore is&#13;
far superior in power and appreciation to any other&#13;
Englishman. His notice of that little appreciated&#13;
and most powerful etude, "La Vieille Fille," is&#13;
masterly, and his remarks on "Le Cure" de Tours"&#13;
entitle him to even higher praise; they are&#13;
peculiarly terse and elucidating, a really fine&#13;
example of appreciative criticism. I cannot wholly&#13;
agree with Mr. George Moore's rubric, "that pro-&#13;
bably the only way to convey a suggestion of the&#13;
genius of the great novelist lies through the minor&#13;
pieces." But certainly the minor pieces have never&#13;
been sufficiently considered, and " La Vieille Fille"&#13;
is one of the finest, superior in every respect to&#13;
the better known" Femme de trente ans."&#13;
Apropos of Balzac, compilers of anecdotes con-&#13;
cerning him generally forget the characteristic&#13;
note of Hans Christian Andersen in his "Mit&#13;
Livs Eventyr." Describing his visit to Paris in&#13;
1843, ne says:—" Balzac, whose acquaintance I&#13;
made at this time, I first saw in the salon of&#13;
Madame laComtesse de Bocarmd, as a fashionable,&#13;
well-dressed personage. His white teeth gleamed&#13;
between his red lips. He seemed a jovial man,&#13;
but he did not talk much, at any rate in that&#13;
circle. A lady who wrote verses fastened herself&#13;
on to him and me; she drew us aside to a sofa&#13;
and sat herself down between us. While she was&#13;
talking with modest hesitation about how small she&#13;
felt between us, I turned my head and caught&#13;
sight behind her back of Balzac's laughing, satirical&#13;
face and half-open mouth, slyly turned towards me.&#13;
This was our first meeting. One day I was going&#13;
through the Louvre. There I met a man in face,&#13;
figure, and gait exactly like Balzac. But the man&#13;
was dressed in shabby, worn-out clothes—really&#13;
dirty they were. His shoes were all burst out, his&#13;
trousers bespattered with dry mud, and his hat all&#13;
misshapen and cracked. I stopped short; the&#13;
man smiled at me, then I went on, but he was so&#13;
incredibly like—I turned back, ran after him, and&#13;
said, 'It can't be Herr Balzac!' The man&#13;
laughed, showing his white teeth, and said only,&#13;
'Monsieur Balzac started for St. Petersburg this&#13;
morning.' He pressed my hand, his own was fine&#13;
and soft, he nodded, and was gone. It must&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 297 (#355) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
297&#13;
have been Balzac; perhaps he had been on one of&#13;
his exploring expeditions among the mysteries of&#13;
Paris. Or was the man someone else, who,&#13;
being extremely like Balzac, and having often&#13;
been taken for him, was amusing himself by&#13;
mystifying a foreigner? Two days afterwards,&#13;
when I was talking to Madame Bocarml, she&#13;
gave me a message of farewell from Balzac—he&#13;
had gone to St. Petersburg."&#13;
As we might have expected, a delicate, half-&#13;
satiric sense of humour was the point of contact&#13;
between the all-comprehensive Balzac and the&#13;
charming, childlike Dane. How delighted Balzac&#13;
would be with the exquisite blending of pathos&#13;
and humour in the tale, " En Hjertesorg," the grief&#13;
of a little child who had no trouser button to pay&#13;
the toll the other children exacted to attend the&#13;
funeral of a dead pug.&#13;
Everyone knows the story which Byron told&#13;
Medwin. Shortly before Shelley's death he had a&#13;
horrible nightmare. "He thought that a figure&#13;
wrapped in a mantle came to his bedside and&#13;
beckoned him; he got up and followed it; when&#13;
in the hall the phantom lifted up the hood of his&#13;
cloak, showed Shelley the phantasm of himself,&#13;
and saying ' Siete satisfatto ?'—vanished. Shelley&#13;
had been reading a strange drama, which is&#13;
supposed to have been written by Calderon,&#13;
entitled, "El embozado, 6 el encapotado." It is&#13;
so scarce that Washington Irving told me he had&#13;
sought for it without success in several of the&#13;
public libraries of Spain."&#13;
Where did Shelley obtain this play? Was it a&#13;
Spanish play at all which he had read? Were&#13;
Byron or Medwin correct? Does Washington&#13;
Irving throw any further light on the subject?&#13;
The authorship of Calderon is immaterial; so&#13;
many plays by other authors were printed as his in&#13;
his lifetime that it was necessary for him to make&#13;
a list of his works. This list is known to be&#13;
incomplete, but the point for remark is that no&#13;
play entitled "El embozado " or "El encapotado"&#13;
is mentioned in any of the exhaustive editions of&#13;
Calderon among plays erroneously attributed to&#13;
him. The title, again, is not mentioned in the&#13;
lists of anonymous Spanish dramas. On the other&#13;
hand there is a play of Agustin Moreto which&#13;
in certain details suggests that he may have&#13;
known some such story. The subject is a fasci-&#13;
nating one, suggesting, as it must have done, one&#13;
of the finest tales of the greatest of English writers&#13;
vol. 1.&#13;
of short tales, and again brought to our memory&#13;
by the wonderful pen and ink sketch of Rossetti&#13;
called "How they met themselves." The well-&#13;
known stories of Theophile Gautier and Robert&#13;
Louis Stevenson represent a similar but not the&#13;
same idea; at any rate the point of view from&#13;
which they regard the idea is different. Can any&#13;
of our readers give any information concerning the&#13;
play?&#13;
Miss E. S. G. Saunders is bringing out a volume&#13;
entitled, " Thoughts for the present Lectionary; or,&#13;
the New Christian Year."&#13;
Mr. Stanley Little contributes an article entitled,&#13;
"The Camera's Service to Art," to the April&#13;
number of the Photographic Quarterly.&#13;
Mr. Hume Nisbet is producing this month, (1)&#13;
"A Colonial Tramp: Being Adventures through&#13;
Australasia and New Guinea." 2 vols. 32^.&#13;
Ward and Downey. (2) "The Black Drop."&#13;
2s. 6d. Trischler and Co. (3) The third edition&#13;
of " Bail Up!" Chatto and Windus.&#13;
He has also an article on "The Papuan and&#13;
his Master," in the Fortnightly Review.&#13;
Under the pseudonym of Evelyn Ballantyne,&#13;
Mr. Eustace R. Ball has contributed on Continental&#13;
Music Halls to the March number of the&#13;
Theatre.&#13;
An article on " Weighing the Stars," by Mr. J.&#13;
E. Gore, F.R.A.S., appears in the Gentleman's&#13;
Magazine for February, and another on "Planetary&#13;
Nebula;" in the February number of the Monthly&#13;
Packet.&#13;
♦&#13;
A new and cheaper edition of Mr. James Sully's&#13;
"Pessimism," with a review of pessimistic literature&#13;
up to the present date, has just been issued by the&#13;
publishers, Messrs. Kegan Paul, Trench and Co.&#13;
Mr. William Westall has written a one volume&#13;
story, entitled "Back to Africa: A Confession."&#13;
It will be published by Ward and Downey in the&#13;
course of the present month. R.&#13;
*&#13;
2 B 2&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 298 (#356) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
298&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
THE PARNASSUS PUBLISHING&#13;
ASSOCIATION.&#13;
THE Association consists of one man, Mr.&#13;
Joseph Haggerston Dalston. With him&#13;
are associated as many literary aspirants&#13;
as he can persuade to publish with him at their cost&#13;
and risk.&#13;
Here is my experience with Mr. Joseph Hag-&#13;
gerston Dalston. Some time ago, while I was con-&#13;
cluding a novel with which I intended to astonish&#13;
the world, I received a letter from Mr. Dalston,&#13;
stating that he was an author's agent, and as he&#13;
enclosed what appeared to be bonA fide testimonials,&#13;
I replied to his letter. This reply doubtless war-&#13;
ranted him in assuming my inexperience of&#13;
business.&#13;
In subsequent letters he offered to read my&#13;
story for a fee of one guinea. This, for what&#13;
he called himself, "an editorial expert whose&#13;
opinion should be at once authoritative and final,"&#13;
was not expensive. Before closing with his offer,&#13;
however, I asked for proof that he had that&#13;
influence with publishers which he claimed. By&#13;
return came a letter enclosing one of recent date,&#13;
from a publishing house of the highest standing,&#13;
which was to the effect that they were very much&#13;
obliged to him for having brought them the MS.&#13;
of Mr. •, which they were prepared to publish&#13;
immediately, paying the author a royalty. This&#13;
proof seemed to me sufficient, especially when&#13;
read in connection with the following wail of Mr.&#13;
Dalston. "Unfortunately, however, even in large&#13;
London publishing houses of assured authority and&#13;
repute, few follow religiously the 'reading' of a&#13;
new MS. by an unknown writer, while so many&#13;
knmvn (yet not always repeatedly successful)&#13;
authors are at the ' beck and call' of the majority&#13;
of the large publishers to go on at any time&#13;
mechanically writing 'to order'—too often a curse&#13;
to the 'pot-boiling' reputation of the author, and&#13;
ergo lesseningly attractive to these authors' favourite&#13;
readers—a majority of the stupid reading public,&#13;
too easily and too stupidly satisfied, to the&#13;
oft-time exclusion of a new writer waiting with&#13;
better work, but unable to pass with it through&#13;
the barrier that too often bars the way to talent&#13;
and genius in other directions than 1 literary&#13;
land."'&#13;
The "rough copy" of my manuscript I for-&#13;
warded to his address for an opinion.&#13;
Nearly a month elapsed before I obtained any&#13;
reply, but repeated applications elicited the follow-&#13;
ing: "Your MS. has really demanded from me&#13;
more attention and deliberate care than I had at&#13;
first anticipated. In the first place, I may say,&#13;
that I did not like your introduction, but the con-&#13;
cluding chapters minimise my first objection, which&#13;
we may now let pass. The opening is clever and&#13;
startling, and prepares the reader's mind with a&#13;
powerful piquancy for the more attractive artistic&#13;
'actualities' so skilfully drawn throughout the&#13;
book; and the successive chapters increasing, as&#13;
they do in interest, will hold the reader in sensa-&#13;
tional subjection—fascinated by that mental mes-&#13;
merism which enthralls at every turn of your&#13;
pages.&#13;
"Splendidly subjective and appalling are Chaps,&#13;
xxi and xxii. 'The Captain' also is interestingly&#13;
introduced and cleverly conducted to his doom!&#13;
"Other chapters teeming with touches of talent&#13;
will gain 'good words' for your work from the&#13;
Reading World and Critics, even as fine present-&#13;
ments of human passion, the littleness of life, and&#13;
the greatness of death pourtrayed by your pen, inter&#13;
alia in , , , have never been formed&#13;
in the one time ever-praised pages of Bulwer!&#13;
Dickens!! and Wilkie Collins!!!&#13;
"So swayed in this connexion, then, I hold to&#13;
the belief that there are 'situations' in your nar-&#13;
rative that will awaken attention from many who&#13;
are now steeped in sluggish 'society' stupor, whilst&#13;
the psychological problems still awaiting solution&#13;
will invite keener study from the scientist, and 'set&#13;
the mind thinking'!&#13;
"The lurid light of English intellectuality, quick-&#13;
ening in its intensity by recent remarkable revela-&#13;
tions in the Press, now searchingly turns toward&#13;
what little is known of lawless life in Africa, that&#13;
mysterious and uncivilized clime—and in the near&#13;
future, perhaps, when we can discern more truths&#13;
—coming to us, though they may, through the&#13;
thinly-veiled romanticism of another Hanwell—&#13;
then your and other philanthropic warning words&#13;
shall stir the public pulse into indignation or re-&#13;
volt, until the lightning message of rnercy, release,&#13;
and reform is flashed from England to Mashona!"&#13;
I am still inclined to think that this gratifying&#13;
opinion is worth the guinea it cost me, especially&#13;
when it is compared with the trivial comments of&#13;
friends who have begged my books, or of critics whom&#13;
I have feasted, treated, and entertained at a much&#13;
greater cost. The indefatigable Mr. Dalston did&#13;
not, however, expect to rest with one guinea, for&#13;
with the letter which accompanied his opinion, was&#13;
one with "Suggestions for Publishing," in which&#13;
I was reminded that, "Looking at the immediate&#13;
interest that would probably result from bringing&#13;
out the book at once, it may be considered ex-&#13;
pedient to publish the book on the author's own&#13;
account! Mr. Haggerston Dalston, trading as the&#13;
Mongoose Publishing Co., and publisher of the&#13;
Muses' Herald, will undertake the work. "The first&#13;
cost would be ^ioo (the actual cost of producing&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 299 (#357) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
299&#13;
the first edition of a book in same form as pro-&#13;
posed by Mr. Dalston is £23 17-r.), after sending&#13;
100 copies for reviews, &amp;c, the sale of 900 books,&#13;
1 vol., at 6s. (less discount to trade, &amp;c), would&#13;
leave about £80 net profit. A smaller size type&#13;
and vol. would cost £60, first edition, and leave&#13;
about £40 net profit. The total editions of the&#13;
first twelve months would probably leave a net&#13;
profit (if published as suggested) of ,£1,000 to&#13;
It would be interesting to know the figures upon&#13;
which the estimated profits are based; there is a&#13;
preciseness about the £1,575 greatly at variance&#13;
with the round sum of £100, the estimated cost&#13;
of production.&#13;
I did not close with the offer, and directed my&#13;
man to "place" the story with a good firm of&#13;
publishers.&#13;
A few days later he wrote making a further offer&#13;
to publish on same terms as had been accepted&#13;
by an author whose agreement (!) he forwarded to&#13;
me. "You will forward me a cheque for £10,&#13;
agreeing to pay a further £10 on receipt of proofs,&#13;
and a final £10 when the book is in your hands,&#13;
remaining risk and profits will be equally divided&#13;
between publisher and author."&#13;
Returning the stamped agreement of the author&#13;
who had accepted these terms (his book has not&#13;
yet appeared), 1 again asked Mr. Dalston to get my&#13;
MS. accepted by a publisher. He wrote me that&#13;
his offer was not "unworthy of acceptance," seeing&#13;
that, for the gradual outlay of ^30, an edition of&#13;
1,000 copies would have expeditiously followed,"&#13;
then for six weeks failed to reply to any of my letters.&#13;
"Respecting your MS.," he wrote in the last&#13;
letter I received from him, "I am greatly dis-&#13;
appointed at receiving it back from , whose&#13;
manager I had seen before submitting yours and&#13;
two other MSS.—all now returned.&#13;
"When unaccepted, the daily consensus of suc-&#13;
cessful scribblers seems to be—publish on your&#13;
own account; but of course, this, as you know,&#13;
is not an easy matter. However, I shall venture&#13;
to publish the three MSS. (yours and the com-&#13;
mercial's, and that written by a doctor's wife) under&#13;
the following conditions, namely:—£10 in ad-&#13;
vance, £10 further to be paid to me when proofs&#13;
are in the hands of author, and £10 when the&#13;
book is published and distributed, profits after&#13;
publication to be equally divided between author&#13;
and publisher."&#13;
This being a similar offer to the one already&#13;
proffered and refused, I determined to call upon&#13;
the man and to secure my MS.&#13;
The gentleman who is manager of the Mongoose&#13;
Publishing Company, manager of the Muses' Pub-&#13;
lishing Association, editor and publisher of the&#13;
Muses' Herald, must surely be a busy man, yet I&#13;
had to call many times at the room—it was on the&#13;
second floor back—before I found the room occu-&#13;
pied. Mr. Dalston is not a. young man, and he has&#13;
a pleasing manner of address. He rarely speaks&#13;
to the point, but abuses in general terms all the pub-&#13;
lishing houses and their readers, and he never&#13;
allows you to leave his presence without asking&#13;
you for a money contribution to one or other of&#13;
his ventures.&#13;
As for the contents of his office there were two&#13;
chairs, a table, a set of pigeon holes and MSS.&#13;
In fact, the room was entirely furnished with MSS.&#13;
It was simply full of "copy" piled from floor to&#13;
ceiling, lying upon chairs and table, and floor, and&#13;
fender. By a lucky chance my packet was upper-&#13;
most of a newly made file, and was rescued without&#13;
difficulty.&#13;
Mr. Haggerston Dalston is now manager and&#13;
everything else of a brand new association called&#13;
the Parnassus Publishing Association. A clean&#13;
sweep has been made of the MSS., and the name&#13;
plate at the house and the Muses' Herald being&#13;
defunct, with the Mongoose Publishing Company,&#13;
a new plate is in preparation showing that here are&#13;
the Central Offices (second floor back) of the&#13;
"Parnassus Publishing Company" and of "Par-&#13;
nassus Slopes," its magazine. Authors are now&#13;
being invited by such papers as will take the ad-&#13;
vertisements, to send their MSS. to the Company,&#13;
and the old game has begun apain. The bait is&#13;
the offer of "remunerative openings" and the&#13;
promise that " suitable MSS.J' are promptly paid for.&#13;
As for the magazine, every contributor must pay&#13;
in advance for a whole year—it will probably&#13;
collapse in a month or two, as happened with&#13;
"Parnassus Slopes."&#13;
Then the Company will disappear too. What&#13;
becomes in the end of all the MSS., nobody knows.&#13;
Perhaps not one in a thousand is worth anything.&#13;
Yet that such an end—disappearance in this sink&#13;
of low cunning—should be the fate of MSS. about&#13;
which so many glowing hopes were formed, is&#13;
melancholy indeed.&#13;
*&#13;
CORRESPONDENCE AND CASES.&#13;
( The Editor is not responsible for the opinions expressed or&#13;
the statements made by correspondents.)&#13;
The Production of Vouchers.&#13;
ACASE has been lately brought before a&#13;
London Court which promises to become&#13;
interesting and useful. It was to this&#13;
effect. A certain publisher transferred his business&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 300 (#358) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
to another firm. Two of the authors whose books&#13;
he had published on the "half-profit" system,&#13;
moved by Counsel that the second firm should&#13;
be called upon to find vouchers for all the items of&#13;
receipts and expenditure supplied to the authors.&#13;
Their Counsel argued that the first firm only was&#13;
responsible for any claims. The judge, however,&#13;
granted the order asked for, reserving the question&#13;
of costs. We hope to publish the further history&#13;
of this case.&#13;
»&#13;
On Advertisements.&#13;
I wish to draw the attention of your readers to&#13;
two points which are generally lost sight of by an&#13;
author when signing his contract. When disposing&#13;
of a book upon the royalty system, one of the usual&#13;
clauses is, "That all expenses of advertising shall&#13;
be borne by the said publishers."&#13;
It is by paying out monies for advertisements in&#13;
addition to disbursing the cost of production that&#13;
the publisher earns his right to his lion's share, i.e.,&#13;
the amount of cash that remains after paying the&#13;
royalty to the author.&#13;
Now let us suppose the case of an author who&#13;
is pretty well known and whose three volume novels&#13;
will be assuredly subscribed, we will say, to be well&#13;
within the mark, to five hundred copies. If the&#13;
publisher does not advertise at all he nets the&#13;
entire difference between the trade price and the&#13;
cost of production less the author's royalties—upon&#13;
the five hundred copies. Therefore the less he&#13;
advertises the better for it.&#13;
But this is not all, the author who is absolutely&#13;
in the hands of his publishers in the matter of&#13;
advertising, often finds his book a sort of Christian&#13;
thrown to the lions. The reason is not far to seek;&#13;
somebody has to be "gibbeted," somebody has to&#13;
be "guyed," and naturally the books that are not&#13;
advertised go upon the black list, and the reviewer&#13;
is given a free hand and told to work his wicked&#13;
will upon them.&#13;
The result of such "gibbeting" is probably not&#13;
felt by the author till he comes to dispose of his&#13;
next venture, say to some other publisher. "Your&#13;
last book was very severely reviewed, Mr. Nibbs,"&#13;
says the publisher, " and we have sent over to our&#13;
friends, Messrs. Barabbas, who tell us that only five&#13;
hundred copies were subscribed."&#13;
It is thus that an author may lose ground, all&#13;
for the want of a ha'porth of tar in the shape of&#13;
having a cut and dried clause as to hoto much is to&#13;
be spent in advertisements, and where it is to be&#13;
spent.&#13;
For novels, at all events, a certain amount of&#13;
advertisement is necessary; reviews even very&#13;
favourable reviews, and the mere fact that the book&#13;
is on Messrs. Smith's and Mudie's lists to be&#13;
issued to first class subscribers only is not enough&#13;
to keep the book before the public.&#13;
Then where advertisements are to appear is m&#13;
portant.&#13;
The writer once published an eight and sixpenny&#13;
book, on the half-profit system, which ran into a&#13;
second edition. There were no profits, because the&#13;
book was advertised not wisely, but too well. "If,"&#13;
thought the writer, "that mighty firm went on with&#13;
a second edition, surely there must be profits, some&#13;
profits, at all events, upon the first." Not a bit of&#13;
it; the book was said to be swamped by advertise-&#13;
ments. The writer went through the list of&#13;
advertisements, and he found that his book had&#13;
been advertised in the " Piscatorial Bulletin." He&#13;
innocently wondered at this selection; when he&#13;
found who the Bulletin belonged to, his wonder&#13;
ceased. Perhaps after all the Fishing Fraternity&#13;
are fond of oriental experiences. Who knows but&#13;
that they may buy up the whole second edition?&#13;
Not that the writer cares one brass button, because&#13;
even if it were so, he feels certain that no half&#13;
profits would ever accrue to him, because of course&#13;
they'd be all mopped up by judicious advertise-&#13;
ments in the " Piscatorial Bulletin," &amp;c.&#13;
Pachyderm.&#13;
[The writer will find the subject of advertising&#13;
treated in Mr. Sprigge's "Methods of Publishing."&#13;
—Ed.]&#13;
Authors and Reviewers.&#13;
There are two questions I should like answered.&#13;
First—Do reviewers conscientiously read the books&#13;
with which they deal? Second—Do their criti-&#13;
cisms honestly reflect the opinions that they have&#13;
formed?&#13;
Now any author worthy of the name must value&#13;
and appreciate criticism which, however adverse,&#13;
is nevertheless honest, discriminating, and intelli-&#13;
gent. So far, at any rate, even if no farther, do I&#13;
consider myself worthy to be called an author. I&#13;
like being told what points in a work of mine are&#13;
good, and what are bad. It is an intellectual&#13;
satisfaction to me, and I feel precisely the same&#13;
sort of gratitude to any reviewer that an intelligent&#13;
student of painting or music unquestionably feels&#13;
towards an able teacher, however severe his stric-&#13;
tures occasionally may be. But my faith in critics,&#13;
and consequently my good disposition towards&#13;
them, have been considerably shaken of late. I&#13;
find they contradict each other so wildly, that it&#13;
is impossible for the most humble-minded writer&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 301 (#359) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
301&#13;
to learn anything from them; and they occasionally&#13;
give grave grounds for the suspicion that they&#13;
have never even read the book they are professing&#13;
to review.&#13;
Let me give an instance from my own experience.&#13;
Two years ago or thereabouts, I published a novel.&#13;
The book was widely reviewed, and I, a tyro in&#13;
the art of fiction, felt very curious indeed to see&#13;
how my first effort would be received by experts.&#13;
Here are some of the verdicts.&#13;
The Saturday said it was undeniably a clever&#13;
book—satirical, humorous, and amusing; appa-&#13;
rently the work of a man who had observed and&#13;
thought; an original and readable novel.&#13;
The AthetuBum said that it was the most com-&#13;
pletely worthless novel the editor had seen for a&#13;
long time.&#13;
The Manchester Examiner said that were the&#13;
critic compelled to characterise it by one epithet,&#13;
that epithet would be "vivacious." Unflagging&#13;
vivacity was its great charm.&#13;
The Sunday Times, on the other hand, con-&#13;
demned it as " always dull."&#13;
The Manchester Examiner, again, praised my&#13;
"constructive ability"; while—&#13;
My publisher's reader informed me that a lack&#13;
of constructive ability was my chief weakness.&#13;
I might fill two columns of your paper with&#13;
similar examples. But surely these are enough—&#13;
enough to bewilder anybody. Am I dull, or am I&#13;
vivacious? Am I clever, or am I a fool? Is my&#13;
book original, satirical, humorous, &amp;c, or is it&#13;
the most completely worthless novel out? Surely&#13;
I am not unreasonable in asking whom I am to&#13;
believe.&#13;
One word more. I spoke to my publishers about&#13;
one of the notices—a notice which appeared to me&#13;
gratuitously and unintelligently insolent. "Oh!"&#13;
replied the worthy man I was addressing, "I think&#13;
I can explain that. The gentleman who wrote&#13;
that review of your book threatened to 'slate'&#13;
whatever we might send him, unless we advertised&#13;
in his paper. We did not give him an advertise-&#13;
ment, and you, unfortunately, are made to suffer."&#13;
Perhaps this may throw some light on my second&#13;
question. An Obscure Novelist.&#13;
—»~—&#13;
Accepted.&#13;
In January, 1889, a MS. was accepted for a&#13;
certain periodical. In May the publisher was&#13;
changed. In July, the new publisher accepted&#13;
three other MSS. and "also the one sent to the&#13;
late Editor," the price of the whole being stated&#13;
by letter. My writing name was published among&#13;
the other contributors, and I was urged in different&#13;
ways to help to make the magazine known.&#13;
None of the MSS. appearing, after eighteen months&#13;
I wrote to ask the cause, and was coolly informed&#13;
that the Editor had more MSS. on hand than he&#13;
could use, and he would return them.&#13;
I offered to wait, but positively declined to have&#13;
them back, but by return of post they arrived in a&#13;
very tattered condition. There was neither&#13;
"smash " nor "crash " in this case—the periodical&#13;
is said to be flourishing. M. J. D. S.&#13;
Literary Godchildren.&#13;
There is a literary Nemesis when a popular&#13;
author suffers from the intrusion of the manuscripts&#13;
of aspirants after fame. But when an unknown&#13;
writer—who finds a difficulty in having an article&#13;
accepted, and as great trouble to get paid for it—&#13;
is troubled for advice and assistance in getting the&#13;
work of others placed and remunerated—then the&#13;
Furies are the old women one blames for the mis-&#13;
management of affairs.&#13;
Fifteen years ago a friend of mine wrote a play and&#13;
demanded my opinion of it. I did not dare to give&#13;
anyexpression of criticism of a tragedy thathe assured&#13;
me was more tragical than Scott's "Bride of Lam-&#13;
mermoor," and more impregnated with humour&#13;
than Schiller's "Wallenstein." I was even able to&#13;
refuse when I knew that one of the poet's friends&#13;
said, "No such work of genius had been written&#13;
since Shakespeare's plays first saw the light." For-&#13;
tunately, I escaped without much censure in this&#13;
case. My friend said that he regretted my decision,&#13;
because he "had a certain amount of respect for&#13;
my taste." He did not insist on submitting his&#13;
proofs to me.&#13;
The next experience was more amusing, if a little&#13;
more costly. A schoolboy who had got into debt&#13;
wrote to a member of my family asking for 7*.,&#13;
stating that he was about to write a three volume&#13;
novel, that he had money owing for a short story,&#13;
and enclosing some of his essays. The money was&#13;
sent without any literary advice. And by the next&#13;
post came a request for 1is. more " to save him&#13;
from disgrace."&#13;
Another manuscript was submitted to my judg-&#13;
ment by a young woman who wished to make a&#13;
profession of letters. It was clearly written, well&#13;
paragraphed, and fairly interesting in matter. I&#13;
had great pleasure in encouraging the writer, and&#13;
urging her to perseverance. Now, I am glad to&#13;
write, she is successfully supplementing her income&#13;
by her pen.&#13;
The last case is perhaps the most painful. In&#13;
my desk at this moment there lies a morocco&#13;
bound volume, in whose pages a beautiful, unfortu-&#13;
nate girl has written part of her life experience. She&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 302 (#360) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
302&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
asks my opinion of her confession. It has origin-&#13;
ality and observation, but otherwise it is unreadable.&#13;
The writer is sensitive, and so much spoiled by&#13;
the flattery of her friends, that it will be puzzling&#13;
for me to speak the truth without giving some&#13;
pain. A.&#13;
Gratuitous Contributions.&#13;
I lately offered a short story to the editor of a&#13;
popular magazine. It was accepted, but when I&#13;
came to ask what was the scale of remuneration&#13;
for such contributions I was blandly informed that&#13;
ladies and gentlemen were usually willing to supply&#13;
the magazine in question with " copy," without hope&#13;
of any other remuneration than the pleasure and&#13;
glory of seeing themselves in print! Now this is&#13;
by no means a rare instance of a practice on the part&#13;
of authors which I think cannot be better described&#13;
than as the process of " cutting their own throats."&#13;
The lamentable weakness with which writers&#13;
consent to give away the work of such brains as they&#13;
possess is one to be severely deprecated. It is to&#13;
my thinking an act of arrant folly, injurious not only&#13;
to those who indulge in it, but to others. I can,&#13;
in fact, conceive nothing more mischievous, as&#13;
lowering the price of literature in the market, than&#13;
this habit, widely spread as it is, of gorging the&#13;
pages of periodical publications with gratuitous con-&#13;
tributions to the exclusion of matter that would&#13;
otherwise be paid for. For is it to be expected&#13;
that the proprietor of a magazine would pay for the&#13;
stories, articles, &amp;c, offered to him by some writers&#13;
when he is able to get any quantity of such com-&#13;
positions from others at no cost whatever?&#13;
The scale of pay allowed by many magazines is&#13;
poor enough as it is. It is not uncommon for&#13;
certain very well-known periodicals to offer such&#13;
miserable remuneration as 2s. and 2s. 6d. a page,&#13;
while 5*. a page is considered in such quarters as&#13;
something magnificent in its liberality. I have&#13;
really been surprised to find how strictly moderate&#13;
are the views on the subject of payment entertained&#13;
by the conductors of magazines which might be&#13;
expected to offer at any rate something like ade-&#13;
quate compensation for one's time and trouble.&#13;
The reason of this parsimony is of course "gratuit-&#13;
ous contributions." It is poor stuff for the most&#13;
part, no doubt, that is thus given away, but it seems&#13;
to be good enough for the editor's purpose. But,&#13;
I contend, everything, whether good, bad or&#13;
indifferent, should have its price. It is not to be&#13;
expected that the magazines should be filled in&#13;
every page, every month, with first-class literature.&#13;
Many of these periodicals are circulated among a&#13;
class of readers who are not over particular as to&#13;
the quality of the wares supplied to them, just as&#13;
in other markets people are content with cheap and&#13;
inferior articles. Yet everything is surely worth&#13;
something, if it can be sold, and every story, or&#13;
other lucubration, which is worth printing ought to&#13;
be worth paying for.&#13;
I am afraid it must be said that ladies are the&#13;
worst offenders in this particular. I do not greatly&#13;
blame them. They have, as a rule, little experience&#13;
or knowledge of the business side of literature, and&#13;
though some of them dream of making fortunes by&#13;
their pens, too many, with an excess of diffidence,&#13;
think they can hardly aspire so high as to be paid&#13;
like what they call "a regular author." It is these&#13;
amateurs who cheapen the literary market, and&#13;
many of them are worth a price, even though it be&#13;
a small one. Let them at any rate not be content&#13;
with the mere acceptance of their stories and&#13;
sketches, but ask for pay, and, when refused, with-&#13;
draw their contributions and send them elsewhere.&#13;
Many an article which would be eagerly taken by&#13;
one of those editors who never pay when they can&#13;
help it, would be found acceptable by others of&#13;
more liberal habit. At the worst, failing to get&#13;
their contributions into the paying magazines, they&#13;
could fall back upon the non-paying ones. These&#13;
last only deserve to have the very dregs of the&#13;
scribbling art.&#13;
I therefore raise my voice in earnest protest&#13;
against this pernicious custom of offering contri-&#13;
butions for nothing, or allowing them to be pub-&#13;
lished without any remuneration whatever. The&#13;
Society of Authors, I think, could do no greater&#13;
service to the cause at least of periodical literature&#13;
than by making it as widely known as possible that&#13;
all contributors to magazines, &amp;c, will be duly paid&#13;
for if only the contributors are firm enough to&#13;
refuse to write for nothing. If such an appeal did&#13;
not put a stop to this practice it might at least&#13;
diminish the mischief arising from it. Pray then&#13;
advise all authors, amateur and otherwise, whenever&#13;
it is proposed to print their contributions for noth-&#13;
ing, to return the reply so often received by some&#13;
of them—" declined with thanks."&#13;
No Pay, No Pen.&#13;
—*—&#13;
A Coincidence?&#13;
Will you allow me to draw attention to a case of&#13;
curious similarity between two stories—the one by&#13;
Mr. Ernest Rhys, entitled "The Last Drearn of&#13;
Julius Roy," which appeared in Macmillan's Maga-&#13;
zine last month, and the other signed by my name,&#13;
which appeared in the Newbery House Magazine&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 303 (#361) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
3°3&#13;
of July, 1890, and which was entitled, "A Great&#13;
Success"? I sketch the outline of the two stories&#13;
in parallel columns :—&#13;
Mr. Ernest Rhys's story.&#13;
My story.&#13;
"A GREAT SUCCESS."&#13;
THE LAST DREAM OF&#13;
TULIUS ROY."&#13;
July, 1890.&#13;
An author after a long life&#13;
of failure starts from Trafalgar&#13;
Square in a condition of ab-&#13;
normal excitement, and rushes&#13;
down the .Strand, intent upon&#13;
lunching at a Tavern, Fleet&#13;
Street being suggested. He&#13;
orders a lunch which for him&#13;
is unusually sumptuous. He&#13;
has been full of unreal inflated&#13;
hope, but overhears a con-&#13;
versation in which he realises&#13;
for the first time the abject -&#13;
ness of his own failure. He&#13;
has had ale with his lunch.&#13;
He throws his arms over the&#13;
table, lays his head on them,&#13;
falls asleep and dreams. The&#13;
dream takes the form of his&#13;
own troubled experience.&#13;
Again he is "hurrying through&#13;
the streets of the great city."&#13;
He is on his way to the&#13;
palace of Fame. There is a&#13;
gate which has to be passed&#13;
through; before he gets in he&#13;
has to present a gift. This&#13;
gift he holds in his hand, but&#13;
it dwindles and vanishes.&#13;
He falls before the door at&#13;
last, defeated and in despair.&#13;
Then the dream changes;&#13;
the door is unexpectedly&#13;
opened by an unseen hand,&#13;
and he beholds a face known&#13;
yet unknown, which smiles&#13;
upon him. The poor author&#13;
enters in to find the aspiration&#13;
of his life satisfied in ways&#13;
not looked for by him. When&#13;
found by the people of the&#13;
Tavern, he is dead.&#13;
February, 1891.&#13;
An author after ten years&#13;
of failure, starts from Trafal-&#13;
gar Square, goes to Pall Mall&#13;
to put on a dress coat, and&#13;
finally returns in an abnormal&#13;
state of excitement on his way&#13;
to a Tavern ("The Three&#13;
Friars") in Fleet Street, to&#13;
have supper there. He orders&#13;
an unusually sumptuous me al&#13;
He has been realising the&#13;
abjectness of his own failure,&#13;
but on his way he meets with&#13;
his old love, who gives him a&#13;
flower, and he i« now in a state&#13;
of wild, unreal hope. He has&#13;
wine with his supper, and he&#13;
throws his arms over the table,&#13;
falls asleep, and dreams. The&#13;
dream takes the form of his&#13;
own troubled experience.&#13;
He is "being whirled rapidly&#13;
through the streets of a dark&#13;
and unknown city," in a car-&#13;
riage with the beloved woman&#13;
by his side. He gets to a&#13;
place which is a Theatre, and&#13;
sees a phantasm of himself on&#13;
the stage struggling in vain&#13;
to pass in at a Gate; the&#13;
phantasm falls down at last&#13;
before the Gate, baffled and&#13;
defeated. He goes on to the&#13;
Stage to look after his own&#13;
Phantasm. He himself knocks&#13;
at the Gate, and it is thrown&#13;
open, and the beloved woman&#13;
stands before him smiling.&#13;
Then he receives in unex-&#13;
pected ways the desire of his&#13;
life. When the waiter comes&#13;
to rouse him, he is dead.&#13;
E. Fairfax Byrrne.&#13;
The Authors' Club.&#13;
I am in favour of an Authors' Club. I think it&#13;
would be greatly to the advantage of authors to&#13;
come together oftener than once a year at a big&#13;
dinner, and to have more frequent opportunity&#13;
of exchanging ideas and "comparing notes." Of&#13;
this I can give an illustration. Two years ago&#13;
at our annual dinner, I sat next to a brother&#13;
novelist, whose acquaintance I then made for the&#13;
first time. That morning I had received from the&#13;
vol. 1.&#13;
editor of a weekly magazine of whose financial&#13;
position I knew nothing, a request to write a&#13;
Christmas story for him. Thinking my neighbour&#13;
might be better informed, I inquired whether he&#13;
had ever done ought for the periodical in question.&#13;
"Yes," says he, "I did a Christmas story for it&#13;
last year but one, and I have not got paid for it&#13;
yet."&#13;
On this hint I acted; when I answered the&#13;
editor's letter, I named my price, and made it a&#13;
condition that I should be paid on his receipt of&#13;
my MS. With this condition he did not see fit&#13;
to comply, and I did not see fit to write the story.&#13;
Again, the other day I chanced to meet a&#13;
member of the Society of Authors at the office in&#13;
Portugal Street, to whom I mentioned that I had&#13;
been requested to write a story for a well known&#13;
magazine. "Be sure you make a bargain before-&#13;
hand," he observed, "or you will get a good deal&#13;
less than you expect." On this hint also I acted.&#13;
I named my price, and was offered half—which I&#13;
did not accept. Observe that in neither of these&#13;
cases did the editor make any mention of terms.&#13;
That, presumably, was to be left an open question,&#13;
and would have proved a troublesome one for me,&#13;
a trouble from which I was saved by being a&#13;
member of the Society of Authors.&#13;
The chief difficulty in the formation of an&#13;
Authors Club' seems to me to lie in the defini-&#13;
tion of "author." Will every man and woman&#13;
who has written a trashy novel or volume of&#13;
poetry, and paid for its production, be eligible&#13;
for admission? And if not, where will you draw&#13;
the line? W.&#13;
[The line must be drawn by the Committee or&#13;
the managing body of the Club.—Editor.]&#13;
THE AUTHOR'S BOOK STALL.&#13;
[This column is open for lists of books wanted, books&#13;
offered for exchange and books offered for sale. Initials&#13;
must be given for reference, not for publication, and the&#13;
editor will place correspondents in communication with each&#13;
other. Books must not be sent to the office of the Society.&#13;
Letters enclosing list may be addressed "X,"care of the&#13;
Editor. It must be understood that no responsibility rests&#13;
with the Editor or with the officers of the Society.]&#13;
Books for Sale.&#13;
Atalanta in Calydon. Original Edition.&#13;
Leckie's Leader of Public Opinion in Ireland.&#13;
Berzelin's Jahresbericht der Chemie. Complete set.&#13;
vols. Address "E.A.&#13;
2 C&#13;
27&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 304 (#362) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
3°4&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
Henry Irving Shakspeare. 8 vols. Edition de luxe, un-&#13;
cut, in original cases. 11 guineas.&#13;
The Odyssey. Translated by William Morris. I edition.&#13;
2 vols.&#13;
Viollet le Due. Dictionnaire. Mobilier Francais. 6 vols.&#13;
Half calf gilt edges.&#13;
Ionica I and II. The very rare first edition with author's&#13;
corrections; handsomely bound.&#13;
Aucassin and Nicollette. Translated by Andrew Lang.&#13;
(Nutt.)&#13;
Cupid and Psyche. With an Introduction by Andrew Lang.&#13;
(Nutt.)&#13;
La Morte D'Arthur. H.O.Sumner. (Nutt.) 2 vols.&#13;
Musa Protova. A. H. Bullen. Privately printed; small&#13;
paper.&#13;
Lyrics of the Elizabethan Age. A. II. Bullen. Small paper.&#13;
(Nimmo.)&#13;
For Exchange.&#13;
The English in Ireland. By J. A. Froude. Library Edition.&#13;
3 vols. Exchange for Cabinet Edition of Froude's&#13;
History of England.&#13;
Address1' E. A."&#13;
Morris' Vision of Saints, for Epic of Hades.&#13;
Kingsley's At Last.&#13;
Trollope's Decade of Italian Women.&#13;
Emerson's Representative Men.&#13;
Lufcadic Hearn's Two Years in the French West Indies.&#13;
M. Life and Letters of the Princess Alice.&#13;
List for Sale or Exchange.&#13;
Bell's Chaucer. 1782.&#13;
Lord Lytton's Poems and Dramatic Works. 1853.&#13;
Original Edition.&#13;
Life of Conde\ By Lord Mahon. 1846.&#13;
Massinger's Plays. Edited by W. Gifford. 1853.&#13;
Schiller's Werke. 10 vols. Very handsomely half-bound.&#13;
Stuttgart. 1844.&#13;
Oeuvres de Moliere. 6 vols. With old engravings; au 13&#13;
de Republique. Paris.&#13;
Chansons de Victor Hugo. 1865.&#13;
Would Lend.&#13;
Works of Peter Pinder. Vol. II. London. 1816.&#13;
Stories of Apparitions (Duchess of Mazarine, Mrs. Veal&#13;
&amp;c. Title lost, old.)&#13;
Pritchard's Heroines of Welsh I listory.&#13;
Address G. M. Williams,&#13;
Aberclydack, Nr. Brecon.&#13;
NEW BOOKS AND NEW EDITIONS.&#13;
Theology.&#13;
BELL, C. D. The Archbishop's Judgment on the Ritual&#13;
Case. With some Thoughts on Public Worship: a&#13;
Sermon Preached in St. Matthew's Church. Cosserts&#13;
Cheltenham). Simpkin. yl.&#13;
Brooke, Rev. Stopford A. The Fight of Faith: Ser-&#13;
mons Preached on Various Occasions. 6th Edition.&#13;
Paul, Triibner and Co. 5J.&#13;
Carpenter, W. Boyd. The Permanent Elements of Re-&#13;
ligion: Eight Lectures Preached Iwfore the University&#13;
of Oxford in the Year 1887, on the Foundation of the&#13;
late Rev. John Bampton. 2nd Edition. Macmillan.&#13;
6j.&#13;
Fowle, Rev. Edmund. We Praise Thee, O God: The&#13;
Choir Boy's Little Book. Skeffington. 6d.&#13;
Gore, Charles. Lux Mundi : a Series of Studies in the&#13;
Religion of the Incarnation. Edited by. nth Edition.&#13;
Murray. 14J.&#13;
Jeaffreson, H. H. Magnificat: a Course of Sermons.&#13;
Paul, Triibner and Co. 2s. 6d.&#13;
Pollock, T. S. Vaughton's Hole: Twenty-five Years in&#13;
It. Mowbray, is.&#13;
Stearns, L. F. The Evidence of Christian Experience:&#13;
Being the Ely Lectures for 1890. Nisbet. 75. 6d.&#13;
Wesley, John. The Father of Methodism; or, Life of&#13;
Rev. John Wesley. Written for Children by Nehemiah&#13;
Curnock. Centenary Edition. Wesleyan Conference&#13;
Office. 6d., gd., is. By J. H. Overton. Portrait. {English Leaders of&#13;
Religion.) Methuen. 2s. (ul. By Francis Kevan. 5th Edition. (True Stories of&#13;
God's Servants.) J. Holness. zs.bd.&#13;
History and Biography.&#13;
Cruickshank, George. Memoir. By Frederic G.&#13;
Stephens; and an Essay on the Genius of George&#13;
Cruickshank by W. M. Thackeray. (Great Artists.)&#13;
Low. 3-r. 6d.&#13;
Drake, Sir Francis. By Julian Corbett. Portrait.&#13;
(English Men of Action.) Macmillan. is. 6d.&#13;
Ericsson, John. The Life of. By W. C. Church.&#13;
With 50 Illustrations. Low. 2 vols. 24X.&#13;
Gladstone, W. E. Life of. By George Barnett Smith.&#13;
12th Edition. Ward, Lock and Co. 3/. 6d.&#13;
Grace, W. G. A Biography. By W. Methven Brownlee.&#13;
Together with a Life-like Portrait and a "Treatise on&#13;
Cricket " by W. G. Grace.&#13;
Holland, C. Gleanings from a Ministry of 50 years.&#13;
E. Stock. 5s.&#13;
Kingsford, William. The History of Canada. Vol. IV.&#13;
1756-1763. With Maps. Paul, Triibner and Co. 15-t.&#13;
Thackeray, W. M. Life of. By Herman Merivale and&#13;
Frank T. Marzials. (Great Writers.) W. Scott.&#13;
is., 2s. 6&lt;/.&#13;
General Literature.&#13;
Allfn, Grant The Tents of Shem: a Novel. New&#13;
Edition. Cliatto and Windus. 2s.&#13;
Besant, Walter. To Call Her Mine, &amp;c. New Edition.&#13;
With 9, Illustrations by A. Foreslier. Chatto and&#13;
Windus. 3^. 6V/.&#13;
Black, Willi am. Stand Fast, Craig Royston! 3rd&#13;
Edition. 3 vols. Low. 31*. 6d.&#13;
Buchheim, C. A. Materials for German Prose Composi-&#13;
tion. 14th Edition. With a List of Subjects for&#13;
Original Composition. Bell and Sons. 4!. 6d.&#13;
Caine, Hall. The Bondman: a New Saga. New&#13;
Edition. Heinemann. 3*. 6d.&#13;
Cameron, Mrs. Lovett. This Wicked World: a Novel.&#13;
4th Edition. F. V. White, is., is. 6d.&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 305 (#363) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
THE A UTIIOR.&#13;
3«5&#13;
3 vols. 2nd Edition.&#13;
Castle, Egerton. Consequences.&#13;
Bentley. 31*. 6d.&#13;
Cobb, T. On Trust. 3 vols. Hurst and Blackett. 31s. 6 J.&#13;
S. M. Beyond Cloudland. Cheap&#13;
Gardner. 5*.&#13;
The Freaks of Lady Fortune. F. V.&#13;
Crawley-Boevf.y,&#13;
Edition. Ale&#13;
Crommelin, May.&#13;
White. 2s. 6d.&#13;
Fakjeon, B. L. The Mystery of M. Felix : a Novel.&#13;
New Edition. F. V. White. 2s. 6d.&#13;
Garnier, R. M. Land Agency. With Illustrations.&#13;
"Estate Gazette " Office. lot.&#13;
Gibney, Somerville. The Maid of London Bridge. A&#13;
Story of the Time of Kett's Rebellion. Illustrated.&#13;
Jarrold and Sons. y. 6d.&#13;
Graham, Scott. A Bolt from the Blue. Sampson Low.&#13;
31s. 6d.&#13;
Haggard, H. R. Cleopatra. New Edition. Longman&#13;
and Co. y. 6d. The Witch's Head. With 16 full page Illustrations&#13;
by Charles Kerr. New Edition. Spencer Blackett.&#13;
y- 6,1.&#13;
Hardy, T. Two on a Tcwer: a Romance. New Edition.&#13;
Low. 2S., 2S. 6d.&#13;
Harte, Bret. A Sappho of Green Springs, &amp;c. With&#13;
Frontispiece and Vignette by Hume Nisbet. Chatto&#13;
and Windus. 3*. 6d.&#13;
James, Henry. The Tragic Muse. New Edition. Mac-&#13;
millan. 3*. (xi.&#13;
Keary, C. F, The Vikings in Western Christendom.&#13;
A.D. 789 to A. D. 888. Fisher Unwin. 15s.&#13;
Xenyon, Edith C. Little Knight. Chambers, is.&#13;
Kipling, Rudyard. Wee Willie Winkle, and other Stories.&#13;
Low. 3*. 6d.&#13;
Knowles, R. B. S. Glencoonoge. 3 vols. Blackwood&#13;
and Sons. 25.1. 6.7.&#13;
Lang, Andrew. Essays in Little. With Portrait of the&#13;
Author. (Whitefriars Library of Wit and Humour.)&#13;
Henry and Co. 2s. 6d.&#13;
Lamb's Adventures with Ulysses. With an Introduc-&#13;
tion by Edward Arnold, is. 6d., 2s. 6d.&#13;
Leland, C. G. Gypsy Sorcery and Fortune Telling.&#13;
Illustrated by numerous Incantations, Specimens of&#13;
Medical Magic, Anecdotes and Tales. Copiously&#13;
Illustrated by the Author. Fisher Unwin. ids.&#13;
Lovell, Arthur. The Ideal of Man. Chapman and&#13;
Hall. y. 6d.&#13;
Lowell, J. Russell. Political Essays and Writings. VoL&#13;
V. Macmillan. 6;.&#13;
McCarthy, Justin, M.P. Sir Robert reel. Being the&#13;
3rd vol. in the Queen's Prime Ministers Series. Edited&#13;
by Stuart J. Reid, with Photogravure Portrait. Samp-&#13;
son Low. y. 6d. Doom : an Atlantic Episode. New Edition. Chatto&#13;
and Windus. is.&#13;
Mitford, Bertram. A Romance of the Cape Frontier.&#13;
Popular Edition. Heinemann. y. (xi.&#13;
Murray, D. Christie, and Herman, Henry. He Fell&#13;
among Thieves. 2 vols. Macmillan. 12s.&#13;
NlSBET, Hume. A Colonial Tramp: Adventures through&#13;
Australia and New Guinea. 2 vols. Illustrated by the&#13;
Author. Ward and Downey. 30s.&#13;
The Black Drop. Trischler and Co. 2s. (xi.&#13;
Bail Up! 3rd Edition. Chatto and Windus. 3-r. (xi.&#13;
The Papuan and his Master. (Fortnightly Rcviezu.)&#13;
Oliphant, Mrs. Janet. 3 vols. Hurst and Blackett.&#13;
31s. 6d.&#13;
Payn, James. The Burnt Million. New Edition. Chatto&#13;
and Windus. 3.5. 6d.&#13;
Pryce, R. Just Impediment. 2 vols. Ward and Downey.&#13;
2ls.&#13;
Quiet Mrs. Fleming. Melhuen. ior. 6./.&#13;
St.&#13;
Reade, Mrs. R. H. The Goldsmith's Ward: a Tale of&#13;
London City in the Fifteenth Century. With 27 Illus-&#13;
trations. Chapman and Hall. 6s.&#13;
Robinson, F. W. Her Love and His Life. 3 vols.&#13;
Hurst and Blackett. 31J. 6d.&#13;
- No Man's Friend. Hutchinson. 2s. 6d.&#13;
Aubyn, A. A Fellow of Trinity. New Edition. With&#13;
a Note by Oliver Wendell Holmes and a Frontispiece.&#13;
Chatto and Windus. y. 6d.&#13;
Thomas, Annie. That Affair. 3 vols. F. V. White.&#13;
Vacher, F. Le Dragon Rouge: a short Story. 2nd&#13;
Edition. Simpkin. 2s. (xi.&#13;
Whitby, Beatrice. The Awakening of Mary Fenwick.&#13;
Hurst and Blackett. 6s.&#13;
Wills, C. J. John Squire's Secret. 5 vols. Ward and&#13;
Downey. 31 J. 6d.&#13;
Woods, Katharine. A Web of Gold. Cassell. 6r.&#13;
Poetry and the Drama.&#13;
Arnold, Sir Edwin. The Light of the World ; or, The&#13;
Great Consummation. Longmans. 7/. 6&lt;z*.&#13;
Austin, Alfred. Savonarola. A Tragedy. Macmillan.&#13;
Austin, Alfred. Prince Lucifer. 3rd Edition. Mac-&#13;
millan. 5*.&#13;
Gibbs, W. A. What Next? or, The Power of Gold. A&#13;
Glimpse of the World as it will be. Portrait. J. Boul-&#13;
ton. is.&#13;
Ibsen, Henrik. Hedda Gabler. A Drama in Four Acts.&#13;
Translated from the Norwegian by Edmund Gosse.&#13;
Portrait. Heinemann. $s.&#13;
Mackail, J. W. Select Epigrams from the Greek An-&#13;
thology. 2nd Edition, with a Revised Text, Intro-&#13;
duction, Translation and Notes. Longmans. 16s.&#13;
Shelley, P. B. Poetical Works. Edited by Edward&#13;
Dowden. Macmillan. 7s. 6d.&#13;
Stevenson, A. L. Raymond: a Story in Verse of London&#13;
and Monte Carlo. Paul, Triibner and Co. 3^. 6d.&#13;
Stevenson, R. L. Ballads. Chatto and Windus. 6s.&#13;
Tennyson. The Coming of Arthur and the Passing of&#13;
Arthur. With Introduction and Notes by F. J. Rowe.&#13;
Macmillan. 2s.&#13;
Art and Architecture.&#13;
Jopi.ing, Louise. Hints to Amateurs: a Handbook on&#13;
Art. Chapman and Hall, it, 6d.&#13;
Loftie, W. J. Landseer and Animal Painting in England.&#13;
With Reproductions of Celebrated Pictures by George&#13;
Morland, Sir E. Landseer, H. W. B. Davis, Briton&#13;
Riviere, and Walter Hunt. Practical Hints for Draw-&#13;
ing and Painting Animals by Stephen T. Dadd. (Vere&#13;
Foster's Water Colour Series.) Blackie and Sons.&#13;
Is. (xi.&#13;
Rhead, G. WOOLLISCROFT. Etching. With Illustrations&#13;
by the Author. (Darton's Manuals for Home Work.)&#13;
Gardner, Darton and Co. is. 6d.&#13;
Slater, J. H. Engravings and their Value : a Guide Tor&#13;
the Print Collector. L. W. Gill. 7s. 6d.&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 306 (#364) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
306&#13;
THE AUTHOR.&#13;
Educational.&#13;
Berkeley. Selections from Berkeley. With Introduction&#13;
and Notes for the use of Students in the Universities, by&#13;
Alexander C. Fraser. 4th Edition, Revised. Claren-&#13;
don Press. 8/. 6d.&#13;
Dixon, Edward T. The Foundations of Geometry.&#13;
Deighton Bell and Co.&#13;
Sidgwick, A. Greek Sentence Construction. Percival and&#13;
Co. is. 6,1&#13;
STEDMAN, A. M. M. First Latin Lessons. With Vocabu-&#13;
lary. New and Enlarged Edition. Methuen. 2s.&#13;
Music.&#13;
Barrett, William Alexander. English Folk Songs.&#13;
Collected, arranged, and provided with Symphonies&#13;
and Accompaniments for the Pianoforte. Novello.&#13;
2s. 6d.&#13;
Sizer, Kate T., and Kern, K. A. The Concert at Home:&#13;
a Collection of Two-Part Songs for Schools and for&#13;
General Use by Young People. Curwen. 2s.&#13;
Law.&#13;
Holland, S. L. The Juryman's Handbook. E. Wilson&#13;
and Co. is.&#13;
Lely, J. M. Copyright Law Reform : an Exposition of&#13;
Lord Monkswell's Copyright Bill now before Parliament.&#13;
With Extracts from the Report of the Commission of&#13;
1878, and an Appendix containing the Berne Convention&#13;
and the American Copyright Bill. Eyre and Spottis-&#13;
woode. is. 6rf.&#13;
*&#13;
THE READING OF MANUSCRIPTS.&#13;
WE beg to call attention to the following,&#13;
which we reprint from the report of&#13;
1890 :—&#13;
Regulations concerning the Reading of&#13;
Manuscripts.&#13;
The fee for this service will for the future be&#13;
one guinea, unless any special reason be present&#13;
for making it higher or lower. The amount must&#13;
then be left to the Secretary's discretion.&#13;
For this sum a report will be given upon MSS.&#13;
of the usual 3 vol. length, or upon collections of&#13;
stories making in the aggregate a work of that&#13;
length.&#13;
In every case the fee and stamps for return&#13;
postage must accompany the MSS.&#13;
The fee will be given entirely to the Reader.&#13;
The Reader will not attempt to give an opinion&#13;
upon works of a technical character.&#13;
It is requested that a label may be sent with the&#13;
MSS., having upon it the Author's name, the nom-&#13;
de-plume (if any) under which the work is written,&#13;
and the address to which the MSS. is to be&#13;
returned. This communication will be held as&#13;
confidential.&#13;
PUBLICATIONS OF THE SOCIETY-&#13;
1. The Annual Report. That for January,&#13;
1891, can be had on application to the&#13;
Secretary.&#13;
2. The Author. A Monthly Journal devoted&#13;
especially to the protection and maintenance&#13;
of Literary Property. Issued to all members.&#13;
3. The Grievances of Authors. (Field &amp;&#13;
Tuer.) 2s. The Report of three Meetings&#13;
on the general subject of Literature and its&#13;
defence, held at Willis's Rooms, March,&#13;
1887.&#13;
4. Literature and the Pension List. By&#13;
W. Morris Colles, Barrister-at-Law.&#13;
(Henry Glaisher, 95, Strand, W.C.) 3-f.&#13;
5. The History of the Soctetd des Gens&#13;
de Lettres. By S. Squire Sprigge,&#13;
Secretary to the Society, is.&#13;
6. The Cost of Production. In this work&#13;
specimens are given of the most important&#13;
forms of type, size of page, &amp;c, with&#13;
estimates showing what it costs to produce&#13;
the more common kinds of books. 2s. 6d.&#13;
7. The Various Methods of Publication.&#13;
By S. Squire Sprigge. In this work,&#13;
compiled from the papers in the Society's&#13;
offices, the various kinds of agreements&#13;
proposed by Publishers to Authors are&#13;
examined, and their meaning carefully ex-&#13;
plained, with an account of the various&#13;
kinds of fraud which have been made&#13;
possible by the different clauses in their&#13;
agreements. Price 3*. (A new Edition in&#13;
the Press.)&#13;
8. Copyright Law Reform. An Exposition&#13;
of Lord Monkswell's Copyright Bill now&#13;
before Parliament. With Extracts from&#13;
the Report of the Commission of 1878,&#13;
and an Appendix containing the Berne&#13;
Convention and the American Copyright&#13;
Bill. By J. M. Lely. Eyre and Spottis-&#13;
woode. is. 6d.&#13;
Other works bearing on the Literary Profession will&#13;
follow.&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 307 (#365) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
AD VER TISEMENTS.&#13;
307&#13;
Telegrams a Cablegrams:&#13;
LONGEVITY. LONDON.&#13;
&#13;
TO AUTHORS.&#13;
In view of the passing of the Copyright Bill in America,&#13;
allow me to draw your attention to the fact that this measure,&#13;
by securing Copyright to you there, will greatly increase the&#13;
value of your future work, provided proper arrangements are&#13;
made on your behalf in the United States.&#13;
As you are no doubt aware, I have for many years acted as the Literary Agent, and conducted&#13;
the entire commercial dealings, of many of the most eminent British Authors. I have friendly business&#13;
relations with all the leading Publishers, both in this country and in America, and am, therefore, in the&#13;
best position to take advantage of the present state of affairs, and obtain in both countries the very best&#13;
terms for Authors.&#13;
As Author's Agent—and, I may say, the first and only one to act in this capacity—I make it my&#13;
study to advance the Author's interests, my remuneration being a commission on the amount received&#13;
through my exertions.&#13;
Should you decide to place your future work in my hands, I shall be glad to put my services at&#13;
your disposal, and do my best in your interest.&#13;
Among the Authors who have entrusted me with the negotiation of their literary business are:—&#13;
The Right Hon. the Earl of&#13;
Lytton, G.C.B., &amp;c.&#13;
George McDonald, LL.D.&#13;
D. Christie Murray.&#13;
Mrs. Oi.iphant.&#13;
W. Clark Russell.&#13;
Stanley J. Weyman.&#13;
&amp;c, Sec, &amp;c.&#13;
Grant Allen.&#13;
Walter Eesant.&#13;
William Black.&#13;
Mrs. W. K. Clifford.&#13;
Author of " Mrs. Keith's Crime."&#13;
The Ven. Archdeacon Farrar.&#13;
F. Anstey Guthrie.&#13;
Capt. A. C. P. Haggard.&#13;
H. Rider Haggard.&#13;
Bret Harte.&#13;
H. Herman.&#13;
Henry James.&#13;
Rudyard Kipling.&#13;
Mrs. Lynn Linton.&#13;
Edna Lyall.&#13;
2, Paternoster Square, London, E.C.&#13;
\th March, 1891.&#13;
A. P. WATT.&#13;
&#13;
1. WORIt—Always in sight.&#13;
2. SPEED—Highest Record, 181 words per minute.&#13;
ALItfSMEJT-Perfect and Permanent.&#13;
3. TYPE—Instantly interchangeable (21 kinds). ,&#13;
IBUPlHaMHMMf— Uniform, being independent of touch.&#13;
4. PAPER—Takes any width, also 20 yards in length.&#13;
THE HAMMOND TYPEWRITER CO.,&#13;
50,QUEEN VICTORIA ST., E.C.&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 308 (#366) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
308&#13;
ADVERTISEMENTS.&#13;
TYPE-WRITING. I MISS ETHEL DICKENS,&#13;
TYPE-WRITING OFFICE,&#13;
AUTHORS' MSS. CAREFULLY TRANSCRIBED.&#13;
26, WELLINGTON STREET, STRAND&#13;
Writings by Post receive prompt attention.&#13;
(Over the Ofice of “ All the Year Round”).&#13;
SCIENTIFIC &amp; MEDICAL PAPERS A SPECIALITY.&#13;
MSS. copied. Price List on application.&#13;
EDITED BY&#13;
A New Vol. commenced&#13;
MRS. GILL,&#13;
MISSES ERWIN,&#13;
TYPE-WRITING OFFICE,&#13;
13, DORSET STREET, PORTMAN SQUARE, W. ST. PAUL'S CHAMBERS, 19, LUDGATE HILL, E.C.&#13;
Authors' MSS. carefully copied from&#13;
CHARLES DICKENS. I/- per 1,000 words. One additional copy&#13;
(carbon) supplied free of charge.&#13;
References kindly permitted to many&#13;
The MSS. of Two Important Poems&#13;
well-known Authors and Publishers.&#13;
Further particulars on application.&#13;
for Sale.—Apply,&#13;
TYPE - WRITING &amp; SHORTHAND.&#13;
A. P. WATT,&#13;
2, Paternoster Square.&#13;
JO. DARKE, M.T.S.,&#13;
LION – CHAMBERS, * BROAD – STREET,&#13;
“The best of all Journals."&#13;
BRISTOL.&#13;
Published every FRIDAY, price 2d.&#13;
The advantages of Type-written Manuscript are LEGIBILITY,&#13;
NEATNESS, RAPIDITY, and EASE of Manifolding.&#13;
DR. ANDREW WILSON, F.R.S.E.&#13;
Now is the time to subscribe.&#13;
AUTHORS' MANUSCRIPTS, &amp;c., prepared for the&#13;
Publisher.&#13;
4th April, 1890.&#13;
Companies* Reports and patent agents&#13;
Specifications Written up and&#13;
Post-card for&#13;
Specimen Copy.&#13;
Manifolded.&#13;
LITHOGRAPHY froin TYPING done in the best&#13;
To be had at all Railway Bookstalls and&#13;
Style.&#13;
Newsagents, or direct from the Publisher-&#13;
MEMORY LESSONS IN TYPING GIVEN BY&#13;
2, PATERNOSTER SQUARE, LONDON, E.C.&#13;
POST. WRITE FOR TERMS.&#13;
ESTABLISHED 1851.&#13;
BIR KBE C K BANK,&#13;
SOUTHAMPTON BUILDINGS, CHANCERY LANE.&#13;
THREE per CENT. INTEREST allowed on DEPOSITS, repayable on demand.&#13;
TWO per CENT. INTEREST on CURRENT ACCOUNTS, calculated on minimum monthly balances, when not drawn&#13;
below £100.&#13;
STOCKS, SHARES, and ANNUITIES purchased and sold.&#13;
SAVINGS DEPARTMENT.&#13;
For the encouragement of Thrift the Bank receives small sums on deposit, and allows Interest, at the rate of THREE&#13;
per CENT. per Annum, on each completed £i. Accounts are balanced and Interest added on the 31st March annually.&#13;
FRANCIS RAVENSCROFT, Manager.&#13;
W TO PURCHASE A HOUSE FOR TWO GUINEAS PER MONTH, OR&#13;
A PLOT OF LAND FOR FIVE SHILLINGS PER MONTH, with immediate&#13;
possession. Apply at Office of the BIRKBECK FREEHOLD LAND SOCIETY.&#13;
THE BIRKBECK ALMANACK, with full particulars, post free on application.&#13;
FRANCIS RAVENSCROFT, Manager.&#13;
Send&#13;
H E AIT HI.&#13;
A WEEKLY JOURNAL OF SANITARY AND DOMESTIC SCIENCE,&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 308 (#367) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
ADVERTISEMENTS&#13;
1&#13;
I&#13;
SA&#13;
THANHH VERWALTAFUGEGUIDELIAM&#13;
INHA&#13;
&#13;
W&#13;
THE&#13;
HAIN&#13;
HET&#13;
PIRIT OF&#13;
110&#13;
WE USE&#13;
&amp; The&#13;
BAR-LOCK&#13;
TYPE&#13;
WRITER.&#13;
/ PROGRESS IS THE&#13;
27&#13;
HARIA&#13;
Hull&#13;
HUH!&#13;
HOME&#13;
A&#13;
DMIN&#13;
THE BAR-LOCK' TYPE-WRITER&#13;
Is the only Machine combining the following Advantages&#13;
PERFECT AND PERMANENT ALIGNMENT.&#13;
AUTOMATIC LINE SPACING. A DUPLICATE KEY-BOARD.&#13;
ADJUSTABLE BALL BEARINGS TO THE TYPE-BAR JOINTS.&#13;
And it is the ONLY Type IVriter&#13;
HAVING ABSOLUTELY VISIBLE WRITING,&#13;
Some Type-Writers may have one or two of these Advantages, but no other combines them all.&#13;
SOLD FOR CASH; ALSO ON THE EASY PAYMENT SYSTEM.&#13;
THE TYPE-WRITER CO., LTD.,&#13;
12, QUEEN VICTORIA STREET, LONDON, E.C.&#13;
MANCHESTER: 25, Market Street. LIVERPOOL: 40, North John St. CARDIFF: Exchange Building.&#13;
GLASGOW : 22, Renfield St. SHEFFIELD: 39, Norfolk St. MELBOURNE: 385, Little Collins St.&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
## p. 308 (#368) ############################################&#13;
&#13;
ADVERTISEMENTS.&#13;
NEW MODEL REMINGTON&#13;
STANDARD TYPEWRITER.&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
&#13;
For Fifteen Years the Standard,&#13;
and to - day the most perfect&#13;
development of the writing&#13;
machine, embodying the latest&#13;
and highest achievements of&#13;
inventive and mechanical skill.&#13;
We add to the Remington every&#13;
improvement that study and&#13;
capital can secure.&#13;
EMINGTON STANDARD TYPEWRITERN&#13;
WYCKOFF, SEAMANS &amp; BENEDICT,&#13;
Principal Office-&#13;
LONDON: 100, GRACECHURCH STREET, E.C.&#13;
(CORNER OF LEADENHALL STREET).&#13;
Branch Offices,&#13;
LIVERPOOL: CENTRAL BUILDINGS, NORTH JOHN STREET.&#13;
BIRMINGHAM : 23, MARTINEAU STREET,&#13;
MANCHESTER : 8, MOULT STREET.&#13;
Printed for the Society, by HARRISON &amp; SONS, 45, 46, and 47, St. Martin's Lane, in the Parish of St. Martin-in-the-Fields, in the City&#13;
of Westminster.</text>
          </elementText>
        </elementTextContainer>
      </element>
    </elementContainer>
  </itemType>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="3696">
              <text>The Author, Vol. 01 Issue 11 (March 1891)</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="3697">
              <text>&lt;em&gt;The Author&lt;/em&gt;, Vol. 01 Issue 11 (March 1891)</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="48">
          <name>Source</name>
          <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="3698">
              <text>&lt;a href="https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015031017927&amp;amp;view=1up&amp;amp;seq=20" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015031017927&lt;/a&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="51">
          <name>Type</name>
          <description>The nature or genre of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="3699">
              <text>Publication</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="43">
          <name>Identifier</name>
          <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="3700">
              <text>1891-03-16-The-Author-1-11</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="66">
      <name>publications</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="4">
      <name>The Author</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
