350 | https://historysoa.com/items/show/350 | The Author, Vol. 12 Issue 07 (February 1902) | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=49&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=%3Cem%3EThe+Author%3C%2Fem%3E%2C+Vol.+12+Issue+07+%28February+1902%29"><em>The Author</em>, Vol. 12 Issue 07 (February 1902)</a> | | | <a href="https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015006979390" target="_blank" rel="noopener">https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015006979390</a> | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=51&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Publication">Publication</a> | 1902-02-01-The-Author-12-7 | | | | | 109–132 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=89&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=12">12</a> | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=76&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=1902-02-01">1902-02-01</a> | | | | | | | 7 | | | 19020201 | The Author.<br />
(The Organ of the Incorporated Society of Authors. Monthly.)<br />
VOL. XII.—No. 7.<br />
FEBRUARY 1, 1902.<br />
[PRICE SIXPENCE.<br />
CONTENTS.<br />
PAGE<br />
109<br />
PAGE<br />
... 120<br />
***<br />
... 109<br />
109<br />
121<br />
110<br />
113<br />
Notices ...<br />
The Pension Fund of the Society of Authors ...<br />
From the Committee ... ... ... * ***<br />
Book and Play Talk ... ...<br />
Literary, Dramatic, and Musical Property ...<br />
The Desirability of a Set of Standard Rules for Prin<br />
The Journalistic Free Lance... ...<br />
The Authors' Club ... ... ...<br />
General Memoranda ... ... ...<br />
Warnings to Dramatic Authors .....<br />
How to Use the Society<br />
The Reading Branch ... ... ...<br />
Authorities ... ... ...<br />
The Advantages of Commission Publishing<br />
The Nobel Prize for Literature<br />
The Irish Literary Revival ... ...<br />
“Real People" in Fiction ... ...<br />
An Epitaph on a Nameless Grave ...<br />
Schoolboys and Literature ...<br />
Correspondence... ... ...<br />
... 124<br />
... 125<br />
125<br />
***<br />
... 117<br />
129<br />
119<br />
131<br />
120<br />
131<br />
...<br />
120<br />
182<br />
PUBLICATIONS OF THE SOCIETY.<br />
1. The Annual Report for the current year. 1s.<br />
2. The Author. A Monthly Journal devoted especially to the protection and maintenance of Literary<br />
Property. Issued to all Members gratis. Price to non-members, 6d., or 58. 6d. per annum,<br />
post free. Back numbers from 1892, at 10s. 6d. per vol.<br />
3. Literature and the Pension List. By W. MORRIS COLLES, Barrister-at-Law. 38.<br />
4. The History of the Société des Gens de Lettres. By S. SQUIRE SPRIGGE. 1s.<br />
. The Cost of Production. (Out of print.)<br />
6. The Various Methods of Publication. By S. SQUIRE SPRIGGE. In this work, compiled from the<br />
papers in the Society's offices, the various forms of agreements proposed by Publishers to<br />
Authors are examined, and their meaning carefully explained, with an account of the<br />
various kinds of fraud which have been made possible by the different clauses in their<br />
agreements. 38.<br />
Addenda to the Above. By G. HERBERT THRING. Being additional facts collected at<br />
the office of the Society since the publication of the “Methods.” With comments and<br />
advice. 2s.<br />
7. Copyright Law Reform. An Exposition of Lord Monkswell's Copyright Bill of 1890. With<br />
Extracts from the Report of the Commission of 1878, the Berne Convention, and the<br />
American Copyright Bill. By J. M. LELY. ls. 6d.<br />
8. The Society of Authors. A Record of its Action from its Foundation. By WALTER BESANT<br />
( Chairman of Committee, 1888–1892). 1s.<br />
9. The Contract of Publication in Germany, Austria, Hungary, and Switzerland. By ERNST<br />
LUNGE, J.U.D. 28. 6d.<br />
10. Forms of Agreement issued by the Publishers' Association; with Comments. By<br />
G. HERBERT THRING, and Illustrative Examples by Sir WALTER BESANT. 2nd Edition. 1s.<br />
[All prices net. Apply to the Secretary, 39, Old Queen Street, Storey's Gate, S.W.]<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 108 (#504) ############################################<br />
<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
The Society of Authors (Incorporated).<br />
PRESIDENT.<br />
GEORGE MEREDITH.<br />
COUNCIL<br />
SIR EDWIN ARNOLD, K.C.I.E., C.S.I.<br />
A. M, BARRIE.<br />
A. W. A BECKETT.<br />
ROBERT BATEMAN.<br />
H. E. BEDDARD, F.R.S.<br />
SIR HENRY BERGNE, K.C.M.G.<br />
JUGUSTINE BIRRELL, K.C.<br />
THE REV. PROF. BONNEY, F.R.S.<br />
THE RIGHT HON. JAMES BRYCE, M.P.<br />
THE RIGHT HON. THE LORD BURGH-<br />
CLERE.<br />
HALL CAINE.<br />
EGERTON CASTLE, F.S.A.<br />
P. W. CLAYDEN.<br />
EDWARD CLODD.<br />
W. MORRIS COLLES.<br />
THE HON, JOHN COLLIER.<br />
SIR W, MARTIN CONWAY.<br />
MRS. CRAIGIE.<br />
F. MARION CRAWFORD.<br />
THE RIGHT HON. THE LORD CURZON<br />
OF KEDLESTON:<br />
| AUSTIN DOBSON.<br />
A. CONAN DOYLE, M.D."<br />
A. W. DUBOURG.<br />
Sir MICHAEL FOSTER, K.C.B., M.P.,<br />
F.R.S.<br />
D. W. FRESHFIELD,<br />
RICHARD GARNETT, C.B., LL.D.<br />
EDMUND GOSSE.<br />
SYDNEY GRUNDY.<br />
H. RIDER HAGGARD.<br />
MRS. HARRISON (LUCAS MALET).<br />
THOMAS HARDY.<br />
ANTHONY HOPE HAWKINS.<br />
JEROME K. JEROME.<br />
J. SCOTT KELTIE, LL.D.<br />
RUDYARD KIPLING.<br />
PROF. E. RAY LANKESTER, F.R.S.<br />
THE RIGHT HON.W.E, H. LECKY, M.P.<br />
J. M. LELY.<br />
THE REV. W. J. LOFTIE, F.S.A.<br />
SIR A. C. MACKENZIE, Mus. Doc.<br />
PROF. J. M. D, MEIKLEJOHN.<br />
THE REV. C. H. MIDDLETON-WAKE.<br />
SIR LEWIS MORRIS.<br />
HENRY NORMAN, M.P.<br />
GILBERT PARKER, M.P.<br />
J. C. PARKINSON,<br />
A. W. PINERO.<br />
THE Right Hon. THE LORD PIB.<br />
BRIGHT, F.R.S<br />
SIR FREDERICK POLLOCK, Bart.,<br />
LL.D.<br />
WALTER HERRIES POLLOCK.<br />
E. ROSE.<br />
W. BAPTISTE SCOONES,<br />
OWEN SEAMAN.<br />
Miss FLORA L, SHAW.<br />
G. R. SIMs.<br />
S, SQUIRE SPRIGGE,<br />
J. J. STEVENSON.<br />
FRANCIS STORR.<br />
WILLIAM MOY THOMAS.<br />
MRS. HUMPHRY WARD,<br />
Hon. Counsel – E. M. UNDERDOWN, K.C.<br />
COMMITTEE OF MANAGEMENT,<br />
Chairman-A. HOPE HAWKINS.<br />
A. W. A BECKETT.<br />
A. CONAN DOYLE, M.D.<br />
D. W. FRESHFIELD.<br />
SYDNEY GRUNDY.<br />
J. M. LELY.<br />
HENRY NORMAN, M.P,<br />
FRANCIS STORR,<br />
GILBERT PARKER, M.P.<br />
E. ROSE.<br />
OWEN SEAMAN,<br />
SUB-COMMITTEES.<br />
ART.<br />
Hon. JOHN COLLIER (Chairman). I SIR W. MARTIN CONWAY. I M. H. SPIELMANN,<br />
COPYRIGHT.<br />
A. W. À BECKETT,<br />
A. HOPE HAWKINS.<br />
J. M. LELY.<br />
W. M. COLLES.<br />
GILBERT PARKER, M.P.<br />
DRAMA.<br />
HENRY ARTHUR JONES (Chairman). F. C. BURNAND.<br />
A. W. PINERO.<br />
A. W. A BECKETT.<br />
SYDNEY GRUNDY,<br />
EDWARD ROSE.<br />
Sinitore_SFIELD, ROSCOE, and Co., Lincoln's Inn Fields.<br />
1 G. HERBERT THRING, 39, Old Queen Street, S.W.<br />
Secretary-G. HERBERT THRING.<br />
OFFICES : 39, OLD QUEEN STREET, STOREY'S GATE, S.W.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 109 (#505) ############################################<br />
<br />
The Author.<br />
(The Organ of the Incorporated Society of Authors. Monthly.)<br />
FOUNDED BY SIR WALTER BESANT.<br />
.<br />
---<br />
VOL. XII.-- No. 7.<br />
FEBRUARY 1ST, 1902.<br />
{PRICE SIXPENCE.<br />
---<br />
-<br />
-<br />
-<br />
CHANGE OF ADDRESS.<br />
Nov. 21, Balfour, A. .....<br />
Nov. 22, Risley, J. .........<br />
Nov. 25, Walker, W. S........<br />
0<br />
0<br />
1<br />
5<br />
5<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
ha ofice of the Incorporated<br />
The office of the Incorporated Society of Authors<br />
has been removed to-<br />
39, OLD QUEEN STREET,<br />
STOREY'S GATE, S.W.<br />
ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTIONS.<br />
Nov. 25, Vaux, P. ....<br />
Nov. 25, Lambe, Lawrence ........<br />
Jan. 17, Prelooker, J.<br />
....<br />
.......<br />
1<br />
1<br />
0<br />
1<br />
1<br />
5<br />
0<br />
(0)<br />
0<br />
NOTICE.<br />
-<br />
FROM THE COMMITTEE<br />
M<br />
HE EDITOR begs to inform members of the<br />
I Authors' Society and other readers of The<br />
Author that the cases which are from time<br />
to time quoted in The Author are cases that have<br />
come before the notice or to the knowledge of the<br />
Secretary of the Society, and that those members<br />
of the Society who desire to have the names of<br />
the publishers concerned can obtain them on<br />
application.<br />
THE PENSION FUND OF THE SOCIETY<br />
OF AUTHORS.<br />
THE following is the total of donations and<br />
1 subscriptions promised or received up to<br />
the 17th January, 1902.<br />
Further sums will be acknowledged from month<br />
to month as they are received, as it has been con-<br />
sidered unnecessary to print the full list with<br />
every issue.<br />
Donations ..<br />
.......£1439 16 6<br />
Subscriptions .................... 106 7 6<br />
The Work of the Society.<br />
D URING the past month the Secretary has<br />
U taken up seven cases on behalf of members,<br />
three dealing with accounts, three concern-<br />
ing MSS., and one for money due.<br />
So far none of these have been settled, but favour-<br />
able replies have been received in the majority of<br />
cases from the publishers and editors concerned.<br />
From the former cases there are still a few out-<br />
standing which, no doubt, will be<br />
standing which, no doubt, will be settled in due<br />
course. Four cases have gone into the hands of<br />
the Society's solicitors to be carried through the<br />
Courts, one against a publisher for the amount due<br />
and unpaid on an account rendered ; two against a<br />
magazine proprietor for non-payment of the amount<br />
due to the author ; and one, a serious matter of<br />
infringement of copyright.<br />
At the Committee meeting held at the beginning<br />
of the year, Mr. Gilbert Parker, Mr. A. Hope<br />
Hawkins, and Mr. J. M. Lely were re-elected<br />
members of that body. It was decided to re-<br />
publish the inset in the January number as a<br />
pamphlet, and, where possible, with an authorita-<br />
tive statement from the editors of the magazines and<br />
papers concerned.<br />
A serious case of plagiarism was brought to the<br />
notice of the Committee, but it is impossible, as the<br />
question has not yet been settled, to say anything<br />
further on this matter.<br />
The steps taken with regard to the Nobel Prize<br />
are fully set out in another part of the paper.<br />
DONATIONS.<br />
Nov. 9, Dale, Miss ......<br />
Oct. 10, Harrison, Mrs. (Lucas Malet)<br />
Oct. 15, Rossi, Miss L. ....<br />
Oct. 25, Potter, M. H. ............<br />
Oct. 30, Stanley, Mrs. ....<br />
VOL. XII.<br />
2 11<br />
5 5<br />
0 10<br />
0 12<br />
0 10<br />
0<br />
0<br />
6<br />
0<br />
0<br />
IV, 1wObi,<br />
L10.<br />
11.<br />
.<br />
..<br />
.......<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 110 (#506) ############################################<br />
<br />
110<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
.<br />
ON OR<br />
· ·<br />
·<br />
· ·<br />
Infelix<br />
· ·<br />
· ·<br />
NON SONO or error<br />
·<br />
· ·<br />
· ·<br />
·<br />
· ·<br />
At the meeting of the Committee on January 20th, Scoones, W. Baptiste .<br />
seven new members and associates were elected, Sims, George R. i . . . . 5 0 0<br />
making in all for the current year twenty-one Sprigge, S. S. .<br />
elections.<br />
Stevenson, J. J..<br />
. . .<br />
.<br />
2 2 0<br />
Mr. A. Hope Hawkins was unanimously elected Ward, Mrs. Humphry<br />
Chairman for 1902, and it was decided by the<br />
Committee to elect also annually a Vice-Chairman.<br />
Donations from Members and Others.<br />
Mr. A. W. à Beckett was appointed to the post. Bell, Mackenzie .<br />
. . 1 1 0<br />
The Committee, under the Rules of the Pension Bentwich, Herbert<br />
.<br />
..<br />
. . . 1 1 0<br />
Fund Scheme, re-elected Mr. A. W. à Beckett as Boevey, Miss Crawley. . . . ( 10 0<br />
their nominee on the Pension Fund Committee Clarke, Cecil ..<br />
. 1 1 0<br />
for the current year. The Society, at its general Cordeaux, Miss K.<br />
M. . . . ( 10 6<br />
meeting, will elect its nominee in due course. Dale, Miss Nellie<br />
. 0 10 6<br />
Notice of this will be given subsequently.<br />
Davey, Mrs. E. M.<br />
Other matters of business were conducted at E. S. B. .<br />
0 5<br />
the meeting, but owing to their confidential Henderson, Miss Florence<br />
character, there was nothing to report.<br />
. . . . . 5 0<br />
Jacobs, W. W..<br />
Besant Memorial.<br />
Kelly, C. A. . . . .<br />
22<br />
.<br />
Donations from<br />
Lowndes, Mrs. Belloc.<br />
Members of the Council.<br />
Maartens, Maarten .<br />
Meredith, George, President of the<br />
McKinny, S. B. G. .<br />
1 1<br />
Society<br />
£10 0 0<br />
Moncrieff, A. R. Hope<br />
à Beckett, A. W.<br />
. 1 1 0 P. . . .<br />
Barrie, J. M. .<br />
5 5 0 Polkinghorne, Miss Ruby<br />
188 Ruby K.. ,<br />
0 5 0<br />
Bateman, Robert<br />
Spielmann, M. H.<br />
Beddard, F. E. .<br />
. . . 2 20<br />
2<br />
Stanton, Miss H. M. E.<br />
Bonney, Rev. T. G.<br />
Stretton, Miss Hesba .<br />
Caine, T. Hall, amount dependent on<br />
Toynbee, William<br />
. 1 1 0<br />
what sum required<br />
Watt, A. P. & Son ..<br />
. 26 5 0<br />
Clodd, Edward . . .<br />
. 1 1 0 Wilkins, W. H.<br />
. 1 1 0<br />
Colles, W. M. ,<br />
. 5 0 Wilson, Miss Aphra ..<br />
. 1 1 0<br />
Collier, The Honble. John .<br />
1 1 0 Woods, Miss M. A. .<br />
. 1 1 0<br />
Conway, Sir W. Martin<br />
1 1 0 Zangwill, I. . . . . . 1 1 0<br />
Craigie, Mrs. .<br />
2 2 0<br />
Dobson, Austin . .<br />
. 1 1 0<br />
Doyle, A. Conan. .<br />
15 0 0<br />
BOOK AND PLAY TALK.<br />
Dubourg, A. W..<br />
2 2 0<br />
Foster, Sir Michael, M. P.,<br />
Freshfield, D. W.<br />
D<br />
•<br />
R. CONAN DOYLE has just published his<br />
5 0 0 1<br />
Garnett, Richard .<br />
3 3 0 -<br />
important pamphlet, “ The War in South<br />
Gosse, Edmund.<br />
Africa: Its Cause and Conduct” (Smith,<br />
.<br />
Grundy, Sydney .<br />
Elder and Newnes). It is an exhaustive reply to<br />
.<br />
2 2 0<br />
Haggard, H. Rider .<br />
the charges made by foreign and English Pro-Boers<br />
3 3 0<br />
Hardy, Thomas .<br />
.<br />
against our soldiers and our statesmen in connec-<br />
2 2 0<br />
Harrison, Mrs. (Lucas Ma<br />
tion with the war in South Africa. The price of<br />
Hawkins, A. Hope .<br />
. 10 0 0<br />
the pamphlet is 6d. Every public man and every<br />
Jerome K. Jerome .<br />
220)<br />
newspaper in the country will receive a copy.<br />
Keltie, J. Scott .<br />
1 1 0 Further, it is to be translated into five European<br />
Kipling, Rudyard<br />
0 0 languages, and every deputy, statesman, and news-<br />
Lely, J. M.<br />
paper editor is to have a copy. The American<br />
Loftie, Rev. W. J.<br />
1 1 0<br />
rights have been given to the M'Clure Company on<br />
Middleton-Wake, Rev. C.<br />
2 2 0 certain conditions. By wide, selected distribution<br />
Norman, Henry.<br />
1 1 0 Dr. Doyle hopes to place what he is convinced is<br />
Parker, Gilbert.<br />
3 30 the truth before every responsible person who has<br />
Pinero, A. W..<br />
5 5 0 repeated or believed these charges.<br />
Pollock, Sir F..<br />
. 1 1 0 Dr. Doyle has of late been busy with his revised<br />
Rose, Edward .<br />
. 2 20 edition of “ The Great Boer War.” He means to<br />
.<br />
· ·<br />
.<br />
· ·<br />
·<br />
.<br />
.<br />
· · ·<br />
.<br />
·<br />
·<br />
.<br />
·<br />
.<br />
· · ·<br />
·<br />
.<br />
.<br />
· · ·<br />
.<br />
·<br />
·<br />
.<br />
·<br />
.<br />
NOT<br />
8106 - NCN co vs<br />
ONONCS NO CO CO O NON<br />
·<br />
· · · · .<br />
.<br />
.<br />
.<br />
.<br />
....<br />
.<br />
.<br />
.<br />
.<br />
....<br />
.<br />
.<br />
.<br />
co<br />
.<br />
....<br />
.<br />
.<br />
.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 111 (#507) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
111<br />
issue in the near future a complete edition of his road of Life," " Cupid's Toll-Gate," and “ In Many<br />
novels. “A Study in Scarlet” was his first book, a Land” are good examples of the writer in his<br />
then came “Micah Clarke.” His “The White lighter moments.<br />
Company" had a great success. His world-famed The Rev. Cornelius Wetherby, late rector of St.<br />
“Sherlock Holmes,” in its sixpenny form, sold to Paul's, Old Charlton, S.E., has published through<br />
the extent of 150,000 copies in a phenomenally Skeffington & Son a book called “In the Palace of<br />
short time.<br />
Wisdom”: being some modern applications of the<br />
Mr. E. W. Hornung's new story, “The Shadow Book of Proverbs. In his Preface the author says :<br />
of the Rope," is now running in Messrs. Tillotson's In the following pages I speak of Solomon as the author<br />
Syndicate of Papers, and in Munsey's Magazine of the Book of Proverbs, by which I commit myself to no<br />
more than that which is implied in the opening words of it.<br />
across the water.<br />
It is for the critic to determine the question of authorship,<br />
It will be published by Messrs. Chatto and Windus and for the theologian to examine that of inspiration : I<br />
in England, and Messrs. Scribner's Sons in New would come in as a practical person, accepting a book which<br />
York.<br />
the Church has placed in Holy Writ, and endeavouring to<br />
apply its old-world teachings to the problems of our modern<br />
Mr. Kipling's poem, “ The Islanders," which life. Many of these papers were originally sermons ; but<br />
appeared in the Times early last month, has they have been recast into a form more suitable for private<br />
aroused a wide-spread and hotly animated dis- reading, and set free from the restrictions which the pulpit<br />
lays upon illustrations, style, and language.<br />
cussion. In fact, Mr. Kipling has raised a species<br />
of tumult among athletes.<br />
Mr. Poultney Bigelow, who went to Washington<br />
for the Annual Session of the American Historical<br />
Rita's trenchant article on the “ Vulgarity of the<br />
Association, has been invited to give a series of<br />
Age” has created quite a controversy in the<br />
addresses on the German Army and its relation to<br />
columns of the Daily Chronicle. The severity of<br />
American interests before some of the most impor-<br />
her strictures was bound to awaken criticism.<br />
tant Universities. He is due in England this month.<br />
This well-known novelist will publish her new<br />
Mr. Lucien Wolf, who is intensely interested in<br />
novel early in the spring, through Messrs. Hutchin-<br />
international politics, and whose well-informed<br />
son & Co.<br />
political articles in the Fortnightly, signed “ Dip-<br />
Miss Rosa Nouchette Carey, whose last novel,<br />
lomaticus,” are widely known, is now writing a<br />
“ Herb of Grace," is doing so well, has a new novel history of the Triple Alliance. It will be a<br />
in hand. She is not at present writing any short serious study of the diplomatic history of Europe<br />
or serial stories.<br />
during the last thirty years, and will contain a<br />
Allen Raine's new novel, “A Welsh Witch,” is chapter on the question of. alliance as raised by<br />
being published by Messrs. Hutchinson & Co., that recent events.<br />
firm having bought the copyright. Allen Raine's That the author is “ Diplomaticus” should be a<br />
previous novels, “ A Welsh Singer," “ Torn Sails," guarantee that the book will be based on first-hand<br />
By Berwen Banks,” and “Garthowen,” were material. Mr. Wolf hopes to complete it about<br />
brought out by the same firm.<br />
the middle of the year. Anthony Treherne & Co.<br />
Mrs. Alexander's latest novel, “ The Yellow will publish it.<br />
Fiend” (Fisher Unwin), has gone into a second Mr. Archibald Dunn, author of “Bridge, and<br />
large edition. The first edition was exhausted How to Play It," which has already reached a<br />
immediately.<br />
seventh edition, is publishing another volume on<br />
Mr. F. B. Doveton's “Mirth and Music,” a the same subject. It is called “New Ideas on<br />
pretty volume in green (28. 6d. nett), contains Bridge.” In it the author has dealt with the many<br />
verses both musical and mirthful. Some of them points of contention at present agitating the minds<br />
should be set to music, for they are tuneful and of Bridge players. In particular, he advances a<br />
singable. There is, for instance, a charming little novel theory as to “Declarations” and “Doubling,"<br />
thing, “The Rose Bush ”; there are also “ Wasted which is not unlikely to revolutionise existing<br />
Kisses," “ Christmas Roses," “ Rest Thee, Flut methods, and to result in placing these two diffi-<br />
tering Heart," “ The Poppies in the Corn," and culties of the game on a thoroughly sound and<br />
“ My Lost Lady."<br />
solid basis.<br />
“Goldielocks" is a pretty fancy, put into verse Crampton's Magazine is now in the hands of<br />
that goes with a lilt. In “ The Approach of Anthony Treherne & Co. The editor is Mr.<br />
Spring " Mr. Doveton shows that he can write a Harold Tremayne, author of “Dross” and<br />
pretty poem informed with true feeling ; while in “Reminiscences of a Gentleman Horse-Dealer.”<br />
· The Larger Hope," and "To an Orthodox Messrs. Heywood & Company, Ltd., have in hand,<br />
Friend," the author strikes a deeper note. “A and well advanced, a most elaborate subscription<br />
Tale of Two Topers” recalls Hood. “The Rail. work, which has been limited to a comparatively<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 112 (#508) ############################################<br />
<br />
112<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
subjectis brilliantly given us<br />
small number of sets, the subscription being ten form the chief attraction of Japanese works of art. Their<br />
guineas. This work, “ The British Empire in the<br />
wrists are supple; the picture in their minds is sure; they<br />
have learnt it line for line ; it is merely the matter of a few<br />
First Year of the 20th Century : Its Capital Cities<br />
minutes for an artist to sketch in his picture."<br />
and Notable Men," is to be issued in two volumes,<br />
and will contain over 400 illustrations and por-<br />
" Jane Austen : Her Homes and Her Friends,"<br />
traits, produced by various expensive processes. by Constance Hill; illustrations by Ellen G. Hill,<br />
There will be appendices, giving in brief form a and reproductions in photogravure, etc., 21s. nett<br />
mass of statistical, historical, and biographical (John Lane), is a charming addition to Jane<br />
information.<br />
Austen literature. In his review of the volume<br />
The compilation of the work is in the hands of<br />
(Jan. Bookman) Dr. Richard Garnett says :-<br />
(Ja<br />
Mr. W. Eden Hooper, who compiled “ The Stock “What Miss Ellen Hill is in the artistic, Miss Constance<br />
Exchange in 1900," fully subscribed at ten guineas;<br />
Hill is in the literary department of the subject. She pro-<br />
also “ The Stage in 1900.” This latter work in-<br />
fessedly does nothing but glean and piece together; there<br />
is scarcely a detail in her book which is not strictly accurate<br />
cluded amongst its supporters His Majesty the<br />
and matter-of-fact; and yet the result is a more vivid por-<br />
King, who bought it for his Sandringham library. trait of Jane Austen than we have hitherto seen. Probably<br />
The present work is under the direct patronage of this is the only way in which so shy and retiring a character<br />
H.R.H. the Prince of Wales, the Duke of<br />
can be exhibited. With such subjects, conscious attempts<br />
at portraiture become exaggeration ; the only way is to let<br />
Connaught, and a number of distinguished noble-<br />
them speak for themselves, and though Miss Austen has not<br />
men, ambassadors, and statesmen throughout the told us much about herself, the little she does say is deeply<br />
Empire.<br />
significant."<br />
In “ Barry Sullivan and His Contemporaries” In “Robespierre: A Study” (Nisbet, 168.),<br />
(Fisher Unwin; 2 vols., 218. nett), Mr. Robert M. M. Hilaire Belloc has quite recently given us a<br />
Sillard has just given us an exhaustive, accurate, companion volume to his brilliant “Danton."<br />
and extremely interesting account of a famous Though the latter subject, the “sea-green incor-<br />
actor-an actor whom some old play-goers hold to ruptible,” is not at all fascinating, M. Belloc's<br />
be the greatest tragic actor of the last half century. study is of vivid interest. It is a masterly bit of<br />
Helen Faucit declared he was the best actor with historical work on the personal side.<br />
whom she had ever played.<br />
Mrs. Archibald Little, author of “Intimate<br />
There are also accounts of all the celebrated China," etc., etc., has just published “In the Land<br />
actors and actresses of his day in England, America, of the Blue Gown" (21s.). It is profusely illus-<br />
and Australia. These volumes of reference will trated. Mrs. Little, who knows her central and<br />
be of lasting value to all who are interested in southern China, describes the state of affairs up to<br />
theatrical biography.<br />
the moment of the Boxer outbreak. There are<br />
Among the important illustrated books which chapters on unexplained riots in the west of China,<br />
have appeared recently, two are especially note- the results of missionary effort, and the advance<br />
worthy. One is “ The Confessions of a Carica of the anti-footbinding movement. Mrs. Little<br />
turist,” which is the autobiography of Mr. Harry carried credentials owing to which she was received<br />
Furniss (2 vols., 32s.). There are over three by various highly-placed mandarins.<br />
hundred illustrations, many having been made for Mr. John Murray is publishing a volume of<br />
these volumes. The author sketches his career traditional Irish stories, translated by Lady<br />
from his earliest days to his arrival in London at Gregory, widow of Sir William Gregory. The<br />
the age of nineteen, and from that time to his title of this collection is“ Cuchulain of Muirthemne.”<br />
appointment on the staff of Punch. This is a very<br />
Mrs. Edith Wharton's new story is called “The<br />
readable and entertaining book.<br />
Valley of Decision." This accomplished writer<br />
The second is “ Japan: A Record in Colour,"<br />
I in Colour,"<br />
he<br />
has already published “A Gift from the Grave,"<br />
by Mr. Mortimer Menpes (A. and C. Black, 208. "The Greater Inclination,” and “Crucial Instances."<br />
nett). There are a hundred illustrations, carefully<br />
Mr. Thomas Hardy's “Under the Greenwood<br />
reproduced from Mr. Menpes' pictures. The<br />
Tree" is now included in the St. Martin's Library<br />
enthusiastic author's stories, criticisms of and<br />
(Chatto and Windus). Mr. Hall Caine's “The<br />
remarks on Japanese life are piquant, and striking.<br />
Deemster”; R. L. Stevenson's “Familiar Studies<br />
Of Japanese art and artists he says :-<br />
of Men and Books"; and Charles Reade's famous<br />
"We Westerners are taught to draw direct from the<br />
historical novel, “The Cloister and the Hearth,"<br />
object or model before us on the platform, whereas the<br />
Japanese are taught to study every detail of their model, are also published in this series of pocket volumes.<br />
and to store their brains with impressions of every curve (Cloth, 2s, nett ; leather, 3s. nett.)<br />
and line, afterwards to go away and draw that object from<br />
An Exhibition of original Water Colours, and<br />
memory. ... It is this certainty of touch and their<br />
power to execute these bold, sweeping, decided lines that Black and White Drawings and Studies by Gordon<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 113 (#509) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
113<br />
Browne, R.I., is on view at Messrs. Matthews and<br />
LITERARY, DRAMATIC, AND MUSICAL<br />
Brooke's Bijou Art Saloon, Bradford. Mr. Gordon<br />
Browne, a son of the celebrated Hablot Knight<br />
PROPERTY.<br />
Browne (“ Phiz"), is a prolific artist. He is<br />
principally known from his contributions to Punch.<br />
He has illustrated Shakespeare, Defoe, Swift,<br />
I.-Musical Performing Rights.<br />
Bunyan, Stevenson, Scott, Pemberton, Crockett,<br />
Grimm, Andersen, etc., etc. Dexterity, charm,<br />
O WING to the fact that the performing rights<br />
refinement and humour are the distinguishing<br />
U in a piece of music are, as a general rule,<br />
qualities of his art.<br />
looked upon as of less value than the per-<br />
We understand that “ The Serious Wooing," by<br />
forming rights of a drama, it has been brought about<br />
John Oliver Hobbes, is to be translated for “La<br />
that a great many musicians and even composers<br />
Revue des Deux Mondes.” Mrs. Craigie is at<br />
are ignorant that there is any property existing in<br />
musical authorship beyond the copyright-i.e., the<br />
present engaged on a serial for Harper's Magazines. .<br />
• ' right of reproducing copies of the work.<br />
Mr. H. A. Jones's well-known comedy, “ The The reason for this peculiar state of affairs is as<br />
Liars," has been added to the edition of his plays follows: A song or piece of music obtains a large<br />
published by Messrs. Macmillan.<br />
advertisement by being played by musicians and<br />
Mr. Stephen Phillips's new drama, “ Ulysses," others, in consequence of which the composer, as a<br />
will be published in book form this month by Mr. general rule, is only too glad to get his piece per-<br />
John Lane.<br />
formed in order to obtain that advertisement,<br />
Mr. Frankfort Moore has written a one-act play,<br />
thereby securing a large sale of the copies of his<br />
which will be produced at an entertainment in aid<br />
work, on which he receives his royalty, from<br />
of the new Nurses' Home, Charing Cross Hospital,<br />
which he makes his money.<br />
to be held on 10th and 11th inst. in the Ball<br />
With regard to the drama the contrary holds,<br />
Room of the Savoy Hotel. There are also to be namely, that there is practically, no money in the<br />
tableaux designed and arranged by Messrs. George pubi<br />
publication of a dramatic piece in book form, but<br />
Frampton, A.R.A., J. J. Shannon, A.R.A., and<br />
the dramatist obtains his reward by the royalties<br />
J. M. Swan, A.R.A. Miss Viola Tree is to dance.<br />
from the performing rights.<br />
A case recently heard in the Courts (Moul v.<br />
By Royal command, Mr. Martin Harvey and his<br />
Coronet Theatre, Ltd.) brings the point again<br />
company gave a performance of “A Cigarette<br />
strongly before the public, and shows that a very<br />
Maker's Romance" at Sandringham on the evening<br />
large property may be established by the reservation<br />
of Jan. 11th. The scenery was taken from Eaton<br />
of performing rights, if musical composers chose by<br />
Hall, where a performance of this play had been<br />
a strong combination and a firm front to market<br />
given earlier in the week. The play ended shortly<br />
their wares judiciously, instead of giving them<br />
after midnight, and was a distinct success. Mr.<br />
away to the public or the publisher.<br />
and Mrs. Martin Harvey (Miss de Silva) were<br />
In England as also in Germany, it is essential<br />
presented to the King and Queen, who expressed<br />
that, if the musical composer desires to retain his<br />
their pleasure at the performance.<br />
rights, he should have a notice printed on the<br />
Before taking possession of his theatre about<br />
title-page stating that the performing rights are<br />
Easter, Mr. Edward Terry will go on a short<br />
reserved. The Musical Copyright Act of 1882,<br />
provincial tour. On his return he will appear in which is commonly known as Wall's Act, com-<br />
a new play by Captain Basil Hood.<br />
pelled this course. It was passed owing to a pecu-<br />
We understand that Miss Ethel Smyth's new liar method of trickery indulged in by a Mr. Wall<br />
opera, “ Der Wald,” will shortly be produced at that was prejudicial to the public welfare.<br />
the Berlin Royal Opera. Miss Smyth's opera, In sundry cases, however, where a German pub-<br />
“ Fantasio," founded on the play by Alfred de lisher has been asked by an English musician<br />
Musset, is in the repertory of the Weimar and desirous of performing a piece in public whether<br />
Carlsruhe Opera Houses. It has been revived he knew in whom the performing rights of the<br />
frequently.<br />
piece were vested, he has replied that he did not<br />
Madam Sarah Bernhardt's revival of Sardou's know that there was such a thing as performing<br />
“ Theodora” is proving an immense success. rights as distinct from the copyright. It is not<br />
Though it is ten years since she first impersonated likely, judging from experience, that English<br />
this rôle, this marvellous actress and extraordinary musical publishers are equally ignorant, yet it is<br />
woman seems, in the part, younger than ever. The worth while to put strongly before those members<br />
seven scenes of the play form a series of the most of the profession of musical composers the fact<br />
brilliant spectacles yet seen on the French stage. that if they chose to band themselves together<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 114 (#510) ############################################<br />
<br />
114<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
they could create by their efforts, slowly yet ment, to ask for the sale of copyright and other<br />
surely, a large property for themselves and a rights, which may be most valuable, which had<br />
larger property for the younger members of the never been mentioned in the first instance,<br />
profession.<br />
If the author is not full of knowledge as to his<br />
legal position, he is led, trusting to the position of<br />
the firm, to believe that everything is in order.<br />
The attention of the Secretary of the Society<br />
II.-Notes on Agreement Clauses.<br />
has again been drawn to this point, which is really<br />
SOME years ago a curious case was published in a very serious one, and it appears extraordinary<br />
“ the Addenda to the Methods of Publishing" issued<br />
that one of the best houses in London should con-<br />
by the Society, in which an author offered a book<br />
duct their business in such a slack way as to lay<br />
to one of the best known publishing firms in<br />
themselves open to the charge of endeavouring to<br />
London, and the firm offered to publish the book<br />
get the better of an author by methods of this<br />
for him on the royalty basis. The book was an<br />
kind. The usual excuse put forward is that the<br />
exceedingly good one, and the royalty was fair as<br />
terms settled by conversation or by letter were<br />
between author and publisher. The author con-<br />
handed to a clerk in the office to embody in the<br />
sented to the terms, and asked the publisher to<br />
agreement, and that the agreement was the usual<br />
embody them in a formal agreement. A few days<br />
printed form. This does not appear to be a<br />
afterwards he received a printed form of agree-<br />
satisfactory excuse, and the representatives of the<br />
firm must be held responsible for the mistakes of<br />
ment.<br />
This agreement, in addition to other clauses,<br />
their clerks.<br />
contained the following :-<br />
Do these mistakes ever occur in favour of the<br />
author ? We have never seen that this is the<br />
“ The copyright in this work and translations thereof,<br />
case.<br />
including all copyright, foreign, and other rights under<br />
Once more the danger of authors assigning<br />
existing or future treaties or conventions with America or<br />
other foreign countries, and under the Canadian Copyright their copyright without the full knowledge of<br />
Act, 1875, and any other present or future Canadian or what that assignment conveys must be impressed<br />
Colonial Act, and all rights of translation and reproduction,<br />
upon them.<br />
and all other Imperial, Colonial, and foreign rights which<br />
This case, however, affords an additional point<br />
now, or during the continuance of the legal term of copy-<br />
right, shall be or shall become appurtenant to the pro for discussion at the present time. It will be seen<br />
prietor of the copyright of the work, shall be the property that from the latter part of the clause quoted, the<br />
of the said publishers subject to the payment to the said<br />
publisher is entitled to 50 per cent. on the sale of<br />
author of a royalty of per cent. on the retail price of<br />
the first 1,500 copies sold, and in the shilling on the re.<br />
the author's rights. These are the minor rights<br />
tail price of all copies of the English edition sold beyond which are generally dealt with by the agent on<br />
the first 1,500 copies, and one half of any profits which behalf of the author.<br />
may be realised from the rights of translation and re- Mr. Heinemann has been objecting for certain<br />
production, or any other Imperial, Colonial, or foreign<br />
rights, which now, or during the continuance of the legal<br />
reasons to the employment of the agent by the<br />
term of copyright, shall be or become appurtenant author, and has stated that he considers the<br />
to the propietor of the copyright of the work, or from the agent's charges from the author's point of view<br />
sale of early sheets or stereotype plates of the said work in are too high. He should, however, refer to his<br />
the United States or elsewhere."<br />
own agreements, and authors will see that in the<br />
· The author, on receipt of the agreement, thought, case put before them above the publisher is asking<br />
of course, that it embodied the terms which had 50 per cent.<br />
been previously offered to him, namely, the right It is not likely, therefore, that the author will<br />
of the publisher to publish subject to an agreed ask the publisher to negotiate these rights when<br />
royalty, and was about to sign it. He, however, the agent will negotiate them at the confessedly<br />
asked the advice of the Society before taking this extravagant price of 10 per cent.<br />
step, and was at once shown the important differ- Again, as has already been pointed out, it is the<br />
ence between the original offer and the agreement. agent's business to know all the ready markets<br />
The author thereupon wrote to the publisher, and for these minor and secondary rights, and this is<br />
pointed out the difference. The agreement was not the the case with the publisher.<br />
promptly altered to conform with the original One point more.<br />
statement. There is no objection whatever to the The agent knows the value of his client's<br />
publisher stating that he would offer the author work when selling these secondary rights. The<br />
the royalty subject only to the transfer of all the publisher, as a general rule, does not know, and<br />
copyright and other rights to the firm, but it is cares less.<br />
not fair business to offer to publish a book on a Cases have been brought to this office, which<br />
fixed royalty, and then when sending in the agree- have been mentioned in The Author, where a<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 115 (#511) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
115<br />
publisher has sold serial rights in a book at the paper exchanged for the right one. Then, again,<br />
ridiculously low price of £30, where an author the defendant's was a morning paper, and the sale<br />
was accustomed to obtain at least £100. The of it was practically over before the plaintiffs' was<br />
danger of conveying these rights to the publisher on sale, and therefore it could not be said to come<br />
is very great indeed.<br />
into serious competition with the plaintiffs' paper.<br />
It is bad for the author's market and it is In all the circumstances he came to the conclusion<br />
bad for the author's pocket, and reduces his that the plaintiffs had failed to make out a<br />
chance of success, as well as his rights, to a case for the intervention of the Court, and the<br />
minimum.<br />
action would therefore be dismissed with costs.--<br />
From the Daily Graphic.<br />
III.-Is a Title Copyright ?<br />
In the Chancery Division some little time back<br />
Mr. Justice Swinfen-Eady gave judgment in the<br />
IV.-Continental Piracy.<br />
case of Willox v. Pearson.—The plaintiffs asked for From time to time members of the Society have<br />
an injunction to restrain the defendant from had sound reasons for complaining of the piracy of<br />
publishing, selling, or offering for sale a news their works in foreign countries, but have taken<br />
paper called the North Express, or under any no steps to stop this piracy, chiefly because they<br />
other title in which the word “Express " was used, feel that if the matter was carried to its final issue,<br />
on the ground that it was likely to lead the public it would not be worth while to commence an<br />
to believe that it was an edition of the plaintiffs' action in a foreign country for the recovery of no<br />
newspaper, the Evening Express, both papers very large amount. It is necessary, therefore, to<br />
being published in Liverpool.-The judge said the put before the members that many pirates do not<br />
plaintiffs were the proprietors of the Evening care to have their methods exposed, and rather<br />
Express, an old-established newspaper, with which than run the risk of such exposure will pay a<br />
was associated the Liverpool Courier. Their reasonable sum if they are worried into it, although<br />
paper was known throughout Liverpool and Lan it may well be that the author would not take<br />
cashire as the Express, and it had a large circu- action in the Courts on account of the expense<br />
lation. On December 2nd the defendant, Mr. and trouble involved.<br />
Arthur Pearson, published in Liverpool a paper Members should remember these additional<br />
called the North Express. Since that time the facts, that the Society has a correspondent in<br />
plaintiffs complained that the defendant's paper America, and that it has obtained considerable<br />
had been called out in the streets of Liverpool assistance from the Société des Gens de Lettres in<br />
as the Express, and that it was so folded and Paris, and that only last year it succeeded in ob-<br />
exposed for sale on the bookstalls and counters of taining a sum for the piracy of a story in Madrid,<br />
newsagents that the title “ Express " only was ex- by first applying to the English Consul, and then,<br />
posed to view, and that consequently in some cases through the Consular lawyer, to the pirate.<br />
people who wanted to buy the plaintiffs' paper The same member of the Society for whom the<br />
found that they had got the defendant's. The fact money was recovered in Madrid, has recently re-<br />
of the plaintiffs' paper being known as the Ex- covered a sum for the piracy of a story in Ger-<br />
press did not give them any exclusive right to many. The following is a statement of the case.<br />
that title. Sir John Willox admitted that the He sold to a German publisher the right of pub-<br />
appearance of his paper and the defendant's was lication in that country. Some time afterwards<br />
entirely different, and that there had been no another German publisher who had reproduced<br />
attempt on the part of the defendant to pass. his many translations of the same author's work<br />
paper off as the plaintiffs'. The evidence of the under the usual form of contract discovered that<br />
plaintiffs came to this, that street vendors of the the story referred to was being pirated in a<br />
defendant's paper had sometimes called out Ec- bowdlerised edition. He wrote to the author to<br />
press, and that people intending to purchase the that effect. The German publisher who held the<br />
plaintiffs' paper at bookstalls and newsagents' had rights of translation granted to the author the<br />
taken up or had given to them the defendant's right to take action in the matter, waiving any<br />
paper instead. But people who purchased news claim he himself might have in the book, as he<br />
papers were supposed to be able to read, and if was equally anxious that the pirate should be<br />
they had done so they would have immediately punished.<br />
discovered their mistake, and in the instances in The author employed the publisher who first<br />
which the customers had been deceived they had, discovered the infringement to act for him, and<br />
in fact, within a few minutes discovered their mis- through his agency obtained a sum from the<br />
take, and had come back to the seller and got the pirate. These facts are very interesting and of no<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 116 (#512) ############################################<br />
<br />
116<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
little importance to members, for there is no question was going to be discussed in the Courts, the<br />
doubt that every time a member whose rights are publisher having to pay the costs of the case.<br />
infringed in foreign countries enforces those It would be presumptuous to advise a firm of<br />
rights, or exposes the action of the pirate, to that publishers on their methods of doing business,<br />
extent is the position of literary property strength- but it is surely more economical to pay the<br />
ened in the country, and it is by similar methods amounts due to authors at the proper dates<br />
that the Society gradually strengthened the position than to pay the amounts with additional sums<br />
of literary property in England, and brought to the for costs.<br />
members of the profession of letters, whether It is satisfactory to know that with the<br />
members of the Society or not, knowledge and Society's aid these matters have been settled.<br />
assistance which they had not before.<br />
THE DESIRABILITY OF A SET OF<br />
V.–Cases.<br />
STANDARD RULES FOR PRINTING.<br />
The following cutting is taken from the Daily<br />
Graphic :-<br />
M HE answers I have already received to the<br />
In the Westminster County Court the case of Churton v 1 questions contained in my article in last<br />
Calvert, Kesterton, and Co. was tried, an action by a young month's Author, p. 98, show a much more general<br />
lady living in Norwood to recover one guinea as nominal interest, than I had hoped for, in the subject of a<br />
damages for alleged infringement of copyright. The plain-<br />
tiff's case was that she wrote a tale, and gave to the Favourite<br />
standard set of rules for printing. The unanimous<br />
Magazine the right of publishing it once for the sum of desire for such a set of rules, and the many good<br />
£1, which amount she had been paid. She had since dis- wishes expressed that I may be able to formulate<br />
covered, however, that the defendants had published the one. is indeed most gratifying and will help to<br />
same tale in the Crystal Palace Magazine, and that, she con-<br />
tended, they had no right to do, as she never sold the copy.<br />
cheer me while devoting my best energies to<br />
right.--Mr. Calvert, a member of the defendants' firm, co-ordinate the very valuable suggestions which<br />
appeared, and said that his case was that the plaintiff had have been so kindly sent to me. Some of the<br />
sued the wrong people. The judge held that there was no<br />
suggestions as to details are 80 diametrically<br />
sale to the defendants of the copyright, and that the<br />
Farourite Magazine had no authority to pass the manu.<br />
opposed that I am doubtful-whatever the final<br />
script on. In these circumstances, he gave judgment for result-whether there will be any of those good<br />
the plaintiff for one guinea damages, and allowed her the wishes left for the writer, by the time the final<br />
costs of coming from Norwood.<br />
form is reached !<br />
The action will be interesting to members of As the answers are still coming in, it is of<br />
our Society, because it was undertaken by the course impossible to give at present any analysis<br />
Committee, and because the case bears on the 18th of results. May I beg those who have not yet<br />
Section of the Act.<br />
done so, to send me their opinions as soon as they<br />
The plaintiff's contention is fully set forth. conveniently can ? For as I said in my previous<br />
The defendants maintained that the copyright was article, I should like to have sent to me at<br />
theirs under the 18th Section of the Act, as there Iddesleigh, Torquay, as many answers as possible,<br />
had been no formal agreement, and secondly, that dealing with Mr. Hart's “Rules for Compositors<br />
the plaintiff was suing the wrong person.<br />
and Readers.”<br />
As will be seen, the decision of the judge held I should be glad to have also lists of words that<br />
that there was no sale to the defendants of the are spelt in more than one way, or references to<br />
copyright, and a verdict was given for the plaintiff. such lists, as there seems a general desire to have<br />
The sum recovered was not a large amount, but Mr. Hart's “Rules” considerably expanded in<br />
the principle is one of importance.<br />
this direction : for it to contain if possible the<br />
correct spelling of all such doubtful words as<br />
Hindoo, Hindu ; yelk, yolk; and so forth.<br />
A very distinguished etymologist in a long reply<br />
Two cases have been brought by an author concludes his letter by touching upon a point<br />
against the same publisher in the course of a few which would be out of place in any rules for<br />
months.<br />
compositors only, but which is remarkably in place<br />
The first was for a small sum on an account in the columns of a paper for anthors. He allows<br />
stated, and the publisher paid the amount on the me to quote the paragraph, which is as follows:-<br />
day before the suinmons was returnable.<br />
“There is one rule to observed, which you do<br />
This second matter was for an account and for not notice, though it is of supreme importance:<br />
any further sums that might be due, and again and that is, that the author shall present his copy<br />
the publisher settled the matter only when the in such a state as to be easily legible. There is a<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 117 (#513) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
117<br />
tradition among some authors, that a crabbed is the market in question a large one, but it is also<br />
writing is given to a clever compositor, and there- a remarkably wide one. It is to this circumstance<br />
fore one ought to write badly. The gross selfish- that the contributor who writes on the chance<br />
ness of this is simply shameful, and deserves entire of acceptance, instead of in response to a definite<br />
reprobation. A man who is a gentleman will commission, is indebted for the greater portion of<br />
make his copy legible for the express purpose of his income. This is because if his article be<br />
enabling the compositor to earn more wages (and declined by one paper, there are so many others to<br />
to save his eyesight]. On this account I have which he may submit it, that, sooner or later, he<br />
carefully cultivated a rather coarse kind of writing, is almost bound to find an opening for it. Editors,<br />
which I use especially for press-copy. It may not too, though possessed no doubt of “great minds,"<br />
look æsthetic, but I defy anyone to misread it. most certainly do not “think alike," and it is<br />
Of course, in letters, one is not quite so careful: one of the unattached journalist's most common<br />
but here also it is highly desirable.”<br />
experiences to find that work which is declined<br />
F. HOWARD COLLINS.<br />
with and without thanks by one periodical is<br />
Iddesleigh, Torquay.<br />
effusively welcomed by others. In evidence of<br />
this I would put forward two or three instances<br />
from among a large number of such that have<br />
occurred in my own case.<br />
THE JOURNALISTIC FREE LANCE.<br />
A little time ago when the question of military<br />
(BY ONE OF THEM.)<br />
canteens was absorbing--for reasons which need<br />
not be here referred to--a good deal of public<br />
attention, I wrote a short article on the subject.<br />
CCORDING to the general consensus of The editors of eleven papers rejected it in turn,<br />
A opinion, the way of the “free-lance” being unable apparently to discern its high literary<br />
journalist is very similar to that which we merits. On its twelfth journey through the post,<br />
are authoritatively told is reserved for trans- however, it met with better fortune, for it was then<br />
gressors. On this account innumerable warnings accepted by the Pall Mall Gazette. Among the<br />
have from time to time been delivered against periodicals declining it may be mentioned the<br />
embarking on the career, and “awful examples” Westminster Gazette, St. James's Gazette, Chambers'<br />
of individuals who have done so in defiance of Journal, Daily Mail, and Morning Post. In the<br />
such counsels are continually being dragged into same way, the Pall Mall Gazette has declined<br />
a publicity which they themselves would willingly contributions which have subsequently appeared in<br />
shun. Even such past masters of the craft as the the Westminster Gazette, and Vanity Fair has said<br />
late Mr. Grant Allen and Robert Buchanan had no an uncompromising "No" to matter that the<br />
good words to say for it, although each of them World has hospitably said “Yes” to. Similarly<br />
for many years derived from its practice incomes with regard to the magazines. Two articles of<br />
which to the majority of “free lances" must mine were successively rejected by Pearson's,<br />
seem beyond the dreams of even twentieth century Cassell's, the English Illustrated, and the Windsor.<br />
avarice. The former, for example, once placed it When I sent them to the Strand, however, they<br />
on record as his settled conviction that, so far were promptly accepted. Again, stories declined<br />
as financial results are concerned, the sweeping by the Royal have been purchased by Harmsworth's,<br />
of a crossing offers better prospects, while the and articles that the National Review has printed<br />
opinion of the latter on the same subject was have first suffered rejection at the hands of the<br />
scarcely more encouraging. It is little matter Contemporary. Why these things should be I do<br />
for wonder, then, that when the average man not profess to be able to say: there are more<br />
learns that some friend or acquaintance of his important problems in life to engage one's atten-<br />
has plunged into the maelstrom of “free-lance tion. Consequently, when some few weeks ago<br />
journalism," he straightway laments him as Black and White published an article of mine that<br />
irrevocably lost.<br />
had been declined by twenty-six other periodicals<br />
Now, with all deference to public opinion—which, in turn, I did not think it necessary to question<br />
as a free lance myself, I naturally hold in the the editor as to his reasons for accepting it.<br />
highest esteem--I cannot help thinking that in To the proprietor the most important matter<br />
this particular respect it is somewhat prone to with which to concern himself is to see that his<br />
be unduly pessimistic. The flood of periodical paper pays its way; to the free lance it is to see<br />
literature shows no sign of abating-rather the that it pays its contributors. That the two classes<br />
reverse, indeed, is the case and there is con- of individuals are not in common accord on this<br />
sequently a large market for the unattached point is—to people in my position, at any rate-<br />
journalist to carry his wares to. Then, not only distinctly regrettable. A result of this is that<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 118 (#514) ############################################<br />
<br />
118<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
instead of there being one rate of remuneration however, they hold a contrary opinion, the reverse<br />
for all work of the same description, there are a is the case.<br />
dozen or more. Again, in some editorial offices, Although the exact amount of remuneration<br />
the rule is to pay by the thousand words, in others which the chance contributor will receive for his<br />
by the line, in others by the page, and in others, work when accepted cannot be stated, it is, Dever-<br />
again, “ by arrangement.” Exactly what may be theless, quite possible to say what he may fairly<br />
meant by this last I have never been able to discover. expect in the majority of instances. The follow-<br />
The results of its operation, too, are so curiously ing, for example, are the prevailing rates in those<br />
unequal that they would seem to call for some periodicals in which my own work has appeared :-<br />
explanation. Thus, from the Strand and Harms. National Review, £1 per page; Literature, £3<br />
worth--in each of which the system is in force--I per page ; Strand Magazine, £22s. to £6 per<br />
have respectively received twelve guineas and four 1,000 words ; Pall Mall Magazine, from £3 38.<br />
guineas for articles of precisely the same length. In per 1,000 words ; English Illustrated, Harmsuorth,<br />
the case of another monthly magazine where the “by and Royal Magazine, from £2 2s. per 1,000 words;<br />
arrangement” rule also obtains I was once offered Windsor Magazine and Chambers' Journal, from<br />
in payment of the story with which I brightened £1 11s. 6d. per 1,000 words; the World, Vanity<br />
its pages, the originals of the four pictorial outrages Fair, Pall Mall, Westminster and St. James's Gazette<br />
with which it had been “illustrated.” Presumably, pay by the column, the rate varying from £2 2s. in<br />
the editor proposed to requite the artist by presents the case of the Pall Mall, to 12s. 6d. in that of the<br />
ing him with my original manuscript. In the note St. James's. With morning papers the rule seems<br />
which accompanied this novel form of remuneration, to be to pay by the column for articles of any<br />
the editor-evidently scenting a possible unwilling- length, and by the line for paragraph matter. In<br />
ness on my part to fall in with his ideas—blandly the case of the former the average scale is £2 2s.<br />
remarked that the drawings in question were worth per column; at any rate, this is what I have<br />
at least ten guineas. My reply to this was that, received for contributions to the Daily News,<br />
as I only valued my story at half this amount, I Daily Chronicle, Daily Mail, and Daily Express,<br />
could not conscientiously accept anything that was while for paragraphs one may count on draw-<br />
so much in excess of this, and concluded with an ing threepence a line from the Westminster<br />
application to be favoured with a cheque for the Gazette, and half this amount from the Chronicle<br />
smaller sum. Instead of readily acquiescing in so and News.<br />
reasonable a request, my correspondent curtly As may be imagined, the readiest market for<br />
intimated that my views were preposterous.” the free lance is undoubtedly afforded by those<br />
Of course I may have been wrong, but I remember journals which may be described as belonging to<br />
thinking that this sort of thing was scarcely the Bits class, nearly all of which pay a fixed rate<br />
calculated to foster the formation of those friendly of one guinea per column. The scale is not unduly<br />
relations which should always exist between the extravagant, but then the standard of literary<br />
members of literary circles. From a second excellence demanded by the editors of these<br />
monthly magazine the only description of payment journals does not make any great strain on the<br />
that I was ever able to extract for a contribution writer. Indeed, the practised journalist soon<br />
duly published therein took the form of twelve comes to regard these periodicals as a species of<br />
copies of the number containing my effusion. “sink” into which he can (with the certainty of<br />
Again, the editor of a third periodical for which I receiving a guinea for it) drop, whenever he feels<br />
once wrote an article paid me some very handsome inclined to do so, a column of matter which the<br />
compliments on what he was good enough to more " literary” papers would sternly refuse to see<br />
characterise as its “delightful style.” When, any merit in. It takes some little time, however,<br />
however, I suggested-after a considerable interval to acquire the knack of writing for Queer Bits and<br />
--that a cheque would be more easily negotiable, papers of similar genre, and one's early experiments<br />
he seemed to take it as a personal reflection upon in this direction are almost certain to meet with<br />
himself. He even went, indeed, the length of failure. Strange though it may seem to say so,<br />
remarking that he was “hurt” at my “impor- there is, nevertheless, a distinct art in writing, in<br />
tunity.” That I also might be “hurt" by his a manner that shall suit the limited intelligences<br />
declining to requite my efforts in cash did not of their readers, attractive articles on "How the<br />
seem to enter into his calculations. As the free- King has his Hair Cut” or “ Busmen's Big Break-<br />
lance journalist does not, as a rule, embark on his fasts,” etc. It is an art, too, that the free lance<br />
career as such merely for the benefit of his health, should strenuously strive after, for its acquisition<br />
this question of payment for his work is an means a weekly income which, though small, is<br />
extremely important one. When editors are in none the less welcome.<br />
harmony with this view, all goes well ; when,<br />
(To be continued.)<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 119 (#515) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
119<br />
THE AUTHORS' CLUB.<br />
He has been touched—'tis my impression<br />
This painter of the urban Past<br />
By pangs too tender for confession<br />
M HE January dinners of the Authors' Club<br />
After the Country, free and vast.<br />
have been exceedingly successful.<br />
These Piccadilly flowers we cherish<br />
On January 13th, under the chairmanship of In high Parnassian glens have grown ;<br />
Mr. M. H. Spielmann, Mr. F. C. Gould, the cele This fountain in St. Martin's Parish<br />
brated caricaturist and assistant editor of the Runs here from woody Helicon.<br />
Westminster Gazette, was the guest of the evening.<br />
And we remember great Apollo<br />
Mr. Spielmann, in proposing his health, drew a<br />
Once took a hireling's wage and task,<br />
pleasing picture of his art, stating that his ridicule<br />
To teach us bards a trade should follow,<br />
was kindly, and his satire without malice. He<br />
And lyric Hermes wear a mask.<br />
also put before those present Mr. Gould's great<br />
versatility and imaginative power. Taking his<br />
St. Paul himself—for all his frenzies-<br />
caricatures of Mr. Chamberlain for example, he Made goat-skin Tents to admiration :<br />
pointed out that Mr. Gould bad represented him Spinoza's Spectacles and Lenses<br />
in over one hundred different forms.<br />
Earned him the right to speculation ;<br />
Mr. Gould made a pleasant speech in reply, and<br />
And so some need or necromancy,<br />
pointed out the difference between the political<br />
Some Destiny (I do protest),<br />
cartoonist of the present day in England and other<br />
Veils, to our gross and purblind fancy,<br />
countries.<br />
On January 20th Mr. Austin Dobson was the<br />
The rank and lustre of our Guest :<br />
guest of the evening, and Mr. Herbert Trench the Pan from his mighty forest roof-<br />
chairman. The chairman dealt exhaustively with Pan to our humble Board has strayed !<br />
Mr. Austin Dobson's work, and pointed out the We heard him piping far aloof,<br />
excellence in finish in the art of which the club's But here he comes in masquerade !<br />
guest was such a prominent master. He finally<br />
And though, no doubt, his godship’s proof<br />
read a poem which he stated he had received from<br />
Under this board might be displayed,<br />
the secretary of the club, the title of which was<br />
We cannot see the cloven hoof<br />
“ To Austin Dobson, Esq., begging that he would<br />
That represents the Board of Trade !<br />
write a play.” We have pleasure in printing the<br />
poem below. The authorship of the poem has<br />
For Pan, when he'd a mind to spark it,<br />
not been declared. The secretary's lack of imagina-<br />
Would hie from Alps and pastures down<br />
tive power being so well known, he was reluctantly And fiddle in Verona market<br />
forced to disclaim authorship.<br />
Or lead a hornpipe through the town.<br />
Mr. Austin Dobson made a neat little speech* in<br />
And so our Bard, who will not jeopard<br />
reply, and a very pleasant evening was completed<br />
The name that to a god belongs,<br />
by his reciting a ballad of his own.<br />
Assumes the ribboned Watteau shepherd<br />
TO AUSTIN DOBSON, ESQUIRE, BEGGING THAT<br />
And fobs us off with dainty songs.<br />
HE WOULD WRITE A PLAY.<br />
Ah, if he chose to drop this magic-<br />
Show himself PLAYWRIGHT ! Sweep the stage<br />
A fool might think (and what is worse is<br />
With comedies and humours tragic,<br />
Some of the stupid wise have said it)<br />
How rich were we, and rich this Age!<br />
That Austin Dobson's perfect verses<br />
Achieve no more than courtly credit ;<br />
The Pen that gave us Porcelain Scenes and<br />
Ballades on satin, now, at leisure,<br />
As though the delicate enslavement<br />
Could give us pathos like Racine's, and<br />
Wherewith he keeps the Town in thrall<br />
Satire like Plautus’ at its pleasure.<br />
Ended with suburbs and the pavement<br />
Retired at last to sylvan Arbours,<br />
About St. James' and Whitehall.<br />
Change, Sir, the lute for louder Chords ; ,<br />
Exchange your Board of Docks and Harbours<br />
But one, at least, who closelier reads him,<br />
Sees through the sober cit's disguise<br />
For triumpbs on still greater Boards :<br />
The passion of the heart that leads him,<br />
Sir, write us Plays ! Take sock and buskin !-<br />
The living Pan that in bim lies.<br />
Steele comes to life-Rise, Goldsmith's heir !<br />
Cyrano's windbag stick your tusk in,<br />
* Note, see page 122.<br />
And be our Congreve-our Molière !<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 120 (#516) ############################################<br />
<br />
120<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
GENERAL MEMORANDA.<br />
SERE are a few standing rules to be observed in an<br />
agreement. There are four methods of dealing<br />
with literary property :<br />
I. Selling it Outright.<br />
This is in some respects the most satisfactory, if a proper<br />
price can be obtained. But the transaction should be<br />
managed by a competent agent, or with the advice of the<br />
Secretary of the Society.<br />
II. A Profit-Sharing Agreement (a bad form of<br />
agreement).<br />
In this case the following rules should be attended to:<br />
(1.) Not to sign any agreement in which the cost of pro-<br />
duction forms a part without the strictest investigation.<br />
(2.) Not to give the publisher the power of putting the<br />
profits into his own pocket by charging for advertisements<br />
in his own organs, or by charging exchange advertise-<br />
ments. Therefore keep control of the advertisements.<br />
(3.) Not to allow a special charge for “office expenses,"<br />
unless the same allowance is made to the author.<br />
(4.) Not to give up American, Colonial, or Continental<br />
rights.<br />
(5.) Not to give up serial or translation rights.<br />
(6.) Not to bind yourself for future work to any publisher.<br />
As well bind yourself for the future to any one solicitor or<br />
doctor!<br />
III. The Royalty System.<br />
It is above all things necessary to know what the<br />
proposed royalty means to both sides. It is now possible<br />
for an author to ascertain approximately and very nearly<br />
the truth. From time to time the very important figures<br />
connected with royalties are published in The Author.<br />
Readers can also work out the figures themselves from the<br />
“Cost of Production."<br />
IY. A Commission Agreement.<br />
The main points are :<br />
(1.) Be careful to obtain a fair cost of production.<br />
(2.) Keep control of the advertisements.<br />
(3.) Keep control of the sale price of the book,<br />
General.<br />
All other forms of agreement are combinations of the four<br />
above mentioned.<br />
Such combinations are generally disastrous to the author.<br />
Never sign any agreement without competent advice from<br />
the Secretary of the Society.<br />
Stamp all agreements with the Inland Revenue stamp<br />
Avoid agreements by letter if possible.<br />
The main points which the Society has always demanded<br />
from the outset are :-<br />
(1.) That both sides shall know what an agreement<br />
means. Waaa<br />
(2.) The inspection of those account books which belong<br />
to the author. We are advised that this is a right, in the<br />
nature of a common law right, which cannot be denied or<br />
withheld.<br />
3. There are three forms of dramatic contract for PLAYS<br />
IN THREE OR MORE ACTS :<br />
(a.) SALE OUTRIGHT OF THE PERFORMING RIGHT.<br />
This is unsatisfactory. An author who enters<br />
into such a contract should stipulate in the con-<br />
tract for production of the piece by a certain date<br />
and for proper publication of his name on the<br />
play-bills.<br />
(5.) SALE OF PERFORMING RIGHT OR OF A LICENCE<br />
TO PERFORM ON THE BASIS OF PERCENTAGES<br />
on gross receipts. Percentages vary between<br />
5 and 15 per cent. An author should obtain a<br />
percentage on the sliding scale of gross receipts<br />
in preference to the American system. Should<br />
obtain a sum in advance of percentages. A fixed<br />
date on or before which the play should be<br />
performed.<br />
(c.) SALE OF PERFORMING RIGHT OR OF A LICENCE<br />
TO PERFORM ON THE BASIS OF ROYALTIES (i.e.,<br />
fixed nightly fees). This method should be<br />
always avoided except in cases where the fees<br />
are likely to be small or difficult to collect. The<br />
other safeguards set out under heading (6.) apply<br />
also in this case.<br />
4. PLAYS IN ONE ACT are often sold outright, but it is<br />
better to obtain a small nightly fee if possible, and a sum<br />
paid in advance of such fees in any event. It is extremely<br />
important that the amateur rights of onc-act plays should<br />
be reserved.<br />
5. Authors should remember that performing rights can<br />
be limited, and are usually limited, by town, country, and<br />
time. This is most important.<br />
6. Authors should not assign performing rights, but<br />
should grant a licence to perform. The legal distinction is<br />
of great importance.<br />
7. Authors should remember that performing rights in a<br />
play are distinct from literary copyright. A manager<br />
holding the performing right or licence to perform cannot<br />
print the book of the words.<br />
8. Never forget that AMERICAN RIGHTS may be exceed.<br />
ingly valuable. They should never be included in English<br />
agreements without the author obtaining a substantial<br />
consideration.<br />
9. Agreements for collaboration should be carefully<br />
drawn and executed before collaboration is commenced.<br />
10. An author should remember that production of a play<br />
is highly speculative : that he runs a very great risk of<br />
delay and a breakdown in the fulfilment of his contract.<br />
He should therefore guard himself all the more carefully in<br />
the beginning.<br />
11. An author must remember that the dramatic market<br />
is exceedingly limited, and that for a novice the first object<br />
is to obtain adequate publication.<br />
As these warnings must necessarily be incomplete on<br />
account of the wide range of the subject of dramatic con-<br />
tracts, THOSE AUTIJORS DESIROUS OF FURTHER INFORMA-<br />
TION ARE REFERRED TO THE SECRETARY OF THE SOCIETY.<br />
HOW TO USE THE SOCIETY.<br />
WARNINGS TO DRAMATIC AUTHORS.<br />
N EVER sign an agreement without submitting it to the<br />
Secretary of the Society of Authors or some com<br />
petent legal authority.<br />
2. It is well to be extremely careful in negotiating for<br />
the production of a play with anyone except an established<br />
manager.<br />
1. D VERY member has a right to ask for and to receive<br />
D advice upon his agreements, his choice of a pub-<br />
lisher, or any dispute arising in the conduct of his<br />
business or the administration of his property. If the<br />
advice sought is such as can be given best by a solicitor,<br />
the member has a right to an opinion from the Society's<br />
solicitors. If the case is such that Counsel's opinion is<br />
desirable, the Committee will obtain for him Counsel's<br />
opinion. All this without any cost to the member.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 121 (#517) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
121<br />
' Communications for The Author should be addressed to<br />
the Offices of the Society, 39, Old Queen Street, Storey's<br />
Gate, S.W., and should reach the Editor NOT LATER<br />
THAN THE 21st OF EACH MONTH.<br />
All persons engaged in literary work of any kind,<br />
whether members of the Society or not, are invited to<br />
communicate to the Editor any points connected with their<br />
work which it would be advisable in the general interest to<br />
publish.<br />
2. Remember that questions connected with copyright<br />
and publishers' agreements do not generally fall within the<br />
experience of ordinary solicitors. Therefore, do not scruple<br />
to use the Society.<br />
3. Send to the Office copies of past agreements and past<br />
accounts, with a copy of the book represented. The<br />
Secretary will always be glad to have any agreements, new<br />
or old, for inspection and note. The information thus<br />
obtained may prove invaluable.<br />
4. BEFORE SIGNING ANY AGREEMENT WHATEVER, send<br />
the document to the Society for examination.<br />
5. Remember always that in belonging to the Society<br />
you are fighting the battles of other writers, even if you<br />
are reaping no benefit to yourself, and that you are<br />
advancing the best interests of literature in promoting the<br />
independence of the writer,<br />
6. The Committee have now arranged for the reception<br />
of members' agreements and their preservation in a fire-<br />
proof safe. The agreements will, of course, be regarded as<br />
confidential documents to be read only by the Secretary,<br />
who will keep the key of the safe. The Society now offers:<br />
-(1) To read and advise upon agreements and to give<br />
advice concerning publishers. (2) To stamp agreements<br />
an readiness for a possible action upon them. (3) To keep<br />
agreements. (4) To enforce payments due according to<br />
agreements.<br />
7. No contract should be entered into with a literary<br />
agent without the advice of the Secretary of the Society.<br />
Members are strongly advised not to accept without careful<br />
consideration the contracts submitted to them by literary<br />
agents, and are recommended to submit them for inter.<br />
pretation and explanation to the Secretary of the Society.<br />
For the Opinions expressed in papers that are signed<br />
or initialled the Authors alone are responsible.<br />
None of the papers or paragraphs must be taken<br />
as expressing the opinion of the Committee unless<br />
such is especially stated to be the case.<br />
COMMUNICATIONS AND LETTEKS ARE INVITED BY THE<br />
EDITOR on all subjects connected with literature, but on<br />
no other subjects whatever. Every effort will be made to<br />
return articles which cannot be accepted.<br />
THE SECRETARY OF THE SOCIETY begs to give notice<br />
that all remittances are acknowledged by return of post,<br />
and he requests members who do not receive an<br />
answer to important communications within two days to<br />
write to him without delay. All remittances should be<br />
crossed Union Bank of London, Chancery Lane, or be sent<br />
by registered letter only.<br />
8. Many agents neglect to stamp agreements.<br />
must be done within fourteen days of first execution.<br />
Secretary will undertake it on behalf of members.<br />
This<br />
The<br />
AUTHORITIES.<br />
9. Some agents endeavour to prevent authors from<br />
referring matters to the Secretary of the Society; so do<br />
some publishers. Members can make their own deductions<br />
and act accordingly.<br />
THE READING BRANCH.<br />
CEMBERS will greatly assist the Society in this<br />
branch of their work by informing young writers<br />
of its existence. Their MSS. can be read and<br />
treated as a composition is treated by a coach. The term<br />
MSS, includes NOT ONLY WORKS OF FICTION, BUT POETRY<br />
AND DRAMATIC WORKS, and when it is possible, under<br />
special arrangement, technical and scientific works. The<br />
leaders are writers of competence and experience. The<br />
fee is one guinea.<br />
TE must tender our apologies to the members<br />
of the Authors' Society for the late appear-<br />
ance of the January number of The Author.<br />
The Christmas holidays were, to a small extent,<br />
responsible for this, but the reason of the serious<br />
delay was owing to the fact that the final proofs<br />
were lost in the post on their way from our printers'<br />
London office to their printing works in the<br />
country. It became necessary, therefore, to correct<br />
a second set. Should any palpable errors or<br />
mistakes occur in the articles, we trust that the<br />
members will treat the matter with kind forbear-<br />
ance, as in some cases it was impossible to correct<br />
the final proofs from the original corrections sent<br />
in by the correspondents.<br />
NOTICES.<br />
THE Editor of The Author begs to remind members of<br />
the Society that, although the paper is sent to them<br />
free of charge, the cost of producing it would be a<br />
very heavy charge on the resources of the Society if a great<br />
many members did not forward to the Secretary the modest<br />
58. 62. subscription for the year.<br />
The way of the author is hard. The follow-<br />
ing conversation between a noted patron of all the<br />
arts and master of none, and a celebrated author<br />
largely read by subscribers to Mudie's, bears witness<br />
to this fact. “It is true," said the person of high<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 122 (#518) ############################################<br />
<br />
122<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
ideals, “ that you have attained prosperity by your There may be many explanations of this curious<br />
writings, but you have produced nothing that will coincidence, seeing how translations of foreign<br />
live.” “Well," answered the comfortable litterateur, books sell in England ; but one point strikes us at<br />
"when it came to a question of which should live, once as probable, namely, the fact that so many<br />
myself or my writings, I didn't hesitate to sacrifice Germans can read English and speak English<br />
my writings.”—The Week Enit.<br />
fluently, that they prefer reading their English<br />
novels in the original Tauchnitz edition, rather<br />
than in any other form, however good, whereas<br />
There seems to be a very nice dispute arising<br />
the average Englishman, nothing versed in foreign<br />
between Monsieur Jean Richepin, the French<br />
author, and Mr. David Belasco, the American play-<br />
tongues, prefers to read a translation.<br />
wright.<br />
In a few words the position of the case is as<br />
follows, as far as can be gathered from the state Mr. Austin Dobson's remarks with regard to the<br />
ments of either party which have appeared in the Academy in his speech at the Authors' Club have<br />
papers.<br />
been wholly misreported. What he, in fact, said<br />
Monsieur Richepin says that he was engaged to was : “ We have managed to build up a not<br />
write a play, and was to receive certain sums in unimportant Literature in the past without the<br />
payment; that he wrote the play, which Mr. Belasco assistance of an Academy of Literature, and I<br />
stated was unsuitable ; but the amount was paid think we can do without it in the future. I am<br />
according to the contract. Subsequently Mr. by no means satisfied that in the best Academy the<br />
Belasco produced a play on the same subject which most deserving authors would be members, and<br />
is practically Monsieur Richepin's play.<br />
I fear that it might become a field for wirepulling<br />
Mr. Belasco states that the Frenchman was and intrigue."<br />
asked to write a play from ideas of his own (Mr.<br />
Belasco's), but when he had written the play it<br />
was unsatisfactory, although the money was paid<br />
LIFE: AN ANSWER.<br />
under the contract. Mr. Belasco then proceeded<br />
to write a play on his own ideas.<br />
“A LITTLE PAUSE."<br />
Monsieur Richepin says he will bring an action. But must I pause ?—in this dim plain ?<br />
From this very scanty evidence it is bardly Where clouds return after the rain :<br />
possible to draw any conclusion, even if it were And blinding mists numb heart and brain.<br />
right so to do when an action is pending. We A pause for thought ? But thought is pain.<br />
trust, however, that the dispute will come before A pause for prayer? My prayers are vain.<br />
the Courts, as matters of this kind are of extreme I take my pilgrim's staff again.<br />
importance.<br />
M.<br />
It constantly occurs that complaints come to the<br />
offices of the Society on similar lines, but as<br />
The above has been forwarded by a well-known<br />
sufficient evidence has been lacking to warrant writer, a member of our Society. A thought<br />
taking the matter into Court, nothing has hitherto suggested by the few lines printed in last month's<br />
been done. We can but refer dramatic writers to Author.<br />
the warnings which are constantly printed in The<br />
Author.<br />
A new method of publishing, entitled “ The Unit<br />
Warning 9 runs as follows :<br />
Library," is going to be tried in the London<br />
“ Agreements for collaboration should be care market Books are to be vublished, so we gather<br />
fully drawn and executed before collaboration has<br />
from a pamphlet before us, in the ollowing<br />
commenced.”<br />
manner :-<br />
If the agreement had been sufficiently carefully Every sheet of twenty-five pages is to cost id.<br />
drafted, it would have been impossible for either There will be an extra cost for a paper cover of id.,<br />
party to have made use of the other's ideas on the or of cloth binding 5d., or leather binding 10d.<br />
lines put forward.<br />
Thus, if the book consists of 250 pages, it can be<br />
purchased by the public in paper binding for 6d.,<br />
A very interesting article has appeared in 5d. for the printed matter and id. for the cover. The<br />
Literature from the pen of Herr Lutz, the Stuttgart size of this new publication will be 41 inches by<br />
publisher, with regard to the circulation of 65 inches. It is stated that this size is convenient<br />
translations of English works in Germany, and it to handle, easy to carry about, and not unworthy<br />
will be seen that in none of the cases put forward of a place on the library shelf.<br />
has the circulation reached a thousand copies. Every new departure in the publishing world<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 123 (#519) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
123<br />
must necessarily excite the curiosity of authors.' and one which we hope to deal with at some future<br />
In some ways, however, this form of publication date in The Author. The second point is, if<br />
will not affect the modern author, as it appears an academy is advantageous, is it possible to divide<br />
that only the classics are going to be brought out literature into the literature of science and the<br />
under this system. This limitation is, no doubt, literature of imagination, thus necessitating two<br />
wise. To publish the works of modern authors on academies instead of one ?<br />
the unit system would be impossible, certainly at The academy whose proposed charter is at<br />
such a low price as fd. for twenty-five pages. present lying before the King deals with the<br />
From the artistic point of view also, it is literature of science, and certainly from the names<br />
objectionable to buy the outcome of the artistic supporting the petition, it would appear to be the<br />
brain at so much per piece. Books from new strongly held opinion that such an academy would<br />
authors cannot be valued in this method any be a benefit to the scientific side of the literary<br />
more than a picture can be bought by the square profession, which is composed of a much larger<br />
inch. If you are dealing with the classics, you number of workers than that which deals with<br />
are practically dealing with equality in value ; but imaginative writing.<br />
in the case of modern publications this would not It will be a matter of some import to follow<br />
be the case.<br />
what opposition there is to the charter, and on<br />
We await with interest the result of the what arguments such opposition is based, so that<br />
experiment.<br />
should there at any time be reason for a similar<br />
movement towards an academy of imaginative<br />
literature, it may be possible to deal with the<br />
We see by an extract from the Dundee Courier difficulties of the subject by experience. The<br />
that the Aberfeldy Literary Society has waxed arguments for and against are no doubt numerous.<br />
strong in debate over the following subject : There are a great many people who will tell you<br />
“Which is the greater : the Author or the<br />
that the Royal Academy has not been a benefit<br />
to the artistic profession, and that it does not<br />
Inventor" ?<br />
represent the true artistic spirit in England. No<br />
After an interesting discussion, the inventor<br />
doubt there are many who will argue the opposite.<br />
carried the day by 15 to 14. This is indeed a<br />
The same question has been discussed with regard<br />
blow for authors, and we fear that the country<br />
to the French Academy.<br />
which has produced Scott and Burns shows a sad<br />
Here also we shall await the result with<br />
falling off. The discussion of the Aberfeldy<br />
considerable attention.<br />
Literary Society will no doubt have a bad effect on<br />
the Scottish book trade in the coming year.<br />
Peebles will perhaps follow suit, and carry We see that the American Authors' Society have<br />
a similar motion by a larger majority. If this changed the name of their periodical to the<br />
event should take place the pens of Barrie, American Author. Imitation is always the<br />
Crockett, Ian Maclaren, Neil Munro and others sincerest form of flattery.<br />
will hardly suffice to stem the tide of popular In the first issue of this magazine under its new<br />
feeling, and the desertion of towns like Glasgow, title there is an article giving out the aims of the<br />
or even Edinburgh, may be the result. The Scots Society. These aims appear to be, with one very<br />
must look to their laurels. The odour of the important exception, the aims of our own Society,<br />
inventor's financial success may taint the pure the exception being that no legal work is undertaken<br />
intellectual atmosphere of the country.<br />
at the expense of the American Authors' Society.<br />
As all our members know, a legal opinion from<br />
the Society's solicitors can always be had gratis,<br />
and further, that all expenses for accountant's<br />
We have read the article that appeared in the charges, counsel's fees, and actions carried through<br />
Times with regard to the movement for the the Courts are very often entirely defrayed out of<br />
formation of a British Academy. Any subject our funds; but the sanction of the Committee<br />
dealing with literature naturally calls for the has to be obtained in the first instance for such<br />
fullest consideration from all members of the expenditure.<br />
Authors' Society, and of necessity, one that deals The American Society is very clear on the<br />
with such important branches of literature as question of publishers' accounts, endeavouring to<br />
history, philosophy, and philology.<br />
arrange with publishers to insert in their contracts<br />
One great subject for consideration is how far with authors the following points :<br />
an academy is an advantage in assisting the art to “(a) Semi-annual accounting and settling for<br />
which it belongs. This is an abstract question,<br />
books sold.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 124 (#520) ############################################<br />
<br />
124<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
on 200<br />
(6) The opening of the publishers account publisher, and the publisher considers it quite as<br />
books for examination by authors or their saleable as any of the author's previous works, I<br />
counsel.<br />
do not think he would print a smaller number of<br />
Keeping of the record of sales, so that there copies than had been sold of the writer's latest<br />
will easily appear : (1) the amount of book ; but taking the figures as they stand, it can<br />
paper used in printing of books ; (2) the beshown that even if the whole of an edition does not<br />
number of books printed ; (3) the number sell there is still a profit, and a not unreasonable one.<br />
of books bound ; (4) the number of books For instance, if a commission publisher with a<br />
given away for introductory purposes, and knowledge of the author's circulation, as suggested,<br />
to whom, and the number given away to prints an edition of 2,000, he would be naturally<br />
the press for notices, and to which papers ; disappointed if only 1,200 sold. Yet the figures<br />
(5) the number on hand.”<br />
would turn out as follows:<br />
We fear that, however good the intention of the<br />
£ 8. d.<br />
American Society may be, it will be impossible for 1,200 copies at 38. 4d.<br />
200 0 0<br />
it to make equitable arrangements on these points,<br />
Less :<br />
Cost of production and advertising £ s. d.<br />
unless the Society can show publishers, by the as quoted in former article ...... 135 1 8<br />
effect of one or two successful actions, that these Publisher's.commission 15 per cent.<br />
points are essential to any fair contract. So long<br />
............ 30 0 0<br />
- 165 1 8<br />
as it does not support by action those cases in<br />
A royalty of between 9 and 10 per<br />
which the publishers act contrary to its advice to c ent. on 1,200 copies..........<br />
£34 18 4<br />
the author, so long, we fear, it will be an inefficient<br />
Again, the publisher produces an edition of 3,000,<br />
protector of the profession.<br />
and sells only two-thirds.<br />
It has not even published, so far, an American The figures work out as follows:<br />
“Cost of Production." A book essential to every<br />
£ 8. d.<br />
author, not only if he is dealing on the antiquated 2,000 copies at 3s. 4d.<br />
333 6 8<br />
half profit basis, but also if he desires to calculate Less :<br />
a fair division of profits in the form of royalties.<br />
Cost of production and advertis. £ . d.<br />
ing as quoted in former article 177 2 6<br />
Publisher's commission 15 per<br />
cent, on £333 6s. 8d.............. 50 0 0<br />
227 26<br />
THE ADVANTAGES OF COMMISSION<br />
A royalty of between 17 and 18<br />
PUBLISHING<br />
per cent. on 2,000 copies ......<br />
£106 4 2<br />
And finally, 5,000 copies are produced, and<br />
M R. MACLEHOSE has not apparently<br />
3,300 only are sold.<br />
grasped the main points in the article 3,300 copies at 38. 4d. ............<br />
550 0 0<br />
on « Commission Publishing” which ap- Less:<br />
peared in the December number of The Author. Cost of production and adver-<br />
it is sy enough to produce instances in which tising as quoted in former £ $. d.<br />
article ....................<br />
........... 256 1 8<br />
this form of publishing will not pay, (1) by over- Publisher's commission lo per<br />
estimating the length of the novel, or (2) by cent. on £515 ........<br />
77 00<br />
underestimating its circulation. It would not be<br />
333 1 8<br />
worth the while of a publisher who is prepared to A royalty of over 20 per cent. on<br />
issue a povel on a fifteen per cent. commission, and<br />
3,300 copies.<br />
Say £217 0 0<br />
run the risk of any loss entailed through sales These royalties are better as a whole than most<br />
failing to cover the cost of production and adver- authors are in the habit of receiving. So that if<br />
tising, to “ take up” a novel by an author whose the publisher's judgment fails, and the author is<br />
average circulation is under 2,000 copies ; and it unfortunate, the profit is still considerable, and<br />
was on this understanding, and this alone, that the the advantage with the author..<br />
figures were given. It would be necessary for the Mr. MacLehose seems to believe that the length<br />
author to show the past statements of his sales of the average six-shilling novel exceeds 96,000<br />
received from his former publishers, and the com- words, and says that he took up at random ten<br />
mission publisher would naturally be guided by popular novels, and that they each contained about<br />
this information in giving the printing order, and 150,000 words. Mr. MacLehose must have picked<br />
not by the length of the manuscript, as Mr. MacLe- up “at random" novels like “ The Eternal City,"<br />
hose appears to think.<br />
“The Master Christian,” and “Sir Richard Cal-<br />
We all know that authors frequently drop in mady,” all of which are particularly long. In the<br />
their circulation ; but if a writer, whose average course of business I read a very large number<br />
sale is, say, 5,000 copies, sells a new novel to a of manuscripts and novels, and long experience<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 125 (#521) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
125<br />
teaches me that a novel 150,000 words in length is the opportunity or unwilling to respond in a suitable spirit<br />
quite the exception, but a novel of 96,000 words is to the invitation offered by the Swedish Academy. Such a<br />
response is highly desirable, both as a recognition of the<br />
a fair average.<br />
courtesy displayed by the communications made to Mr.<br />
Mr. MacLehose says that I have forgotten “that Gosse, and as an assertion of the position of British<br />
an author always makes corrections in his proofs.” literature.<br />
This is a fact which no one connected with the<br />
I am, Sir, your obedient servant,<br />
publishing business is likely to forget, and in my<br />
ANTHONY HOPE HAWKINS,<br />
estimate allowance was made for this item in the<br />
Chairman of Committee, Society of Authors,<br />
cost of composition.<br />
39, Old Queen Street, S.W., Jan. 6.<br />
THE MAN WHO SUPPLIED THE FIGURES.<br />
The committee thus suggested immediately came<br />
into existence, and held its first meeting at 39,<br />
Old Queen Street, on Tuesday, the 14th inst. Dr.<br />
THE NOBEL PRIZE FOR LITERATURE.' Garnett was in the chair, and both Mr. Gosse and<br />
Mr. Austin Dobson spoke. Lord Avebury was<br />
appointed perpetual chairman to the committee,<br />
N the 3rd of January Mr. Edmund Gosse Mr. G. Herbert Thring was made secretary, and<br />
wrote to the Times on the subject of the the names of Mr. Arthur Christopher Benson, Mrs.<br />
prize of about £8,250 awarded each year John Richard Green, Mr. R. B. Haldane, M.P.,<br />
for the most eminent work in pure literature by K.C., and Sir Robert Giffen, K.C.B., F.R.S.,<br />
the Nobel Committee of the Swedish Academy. were added. The committee, after discussion,<br />
Mr. Gosse had been communicated with by two determined to recommend a certain person of<br />
prominent Swedish academicians as to the reasons the highest eminence to all those persons in<br />
of the total abstention of England from all com- Great Britain who appear, under the Nobel Will,<br />
petition for this prize, which in 1901 was awarded to be qualified to vote for the prize of £8,250<br />
to the French poet, M. Sully Prudhomme. A which will, in November, 1902, be awarded by the<br />
correspondence on this subject was opened up in Swedish Academy. As all votes must be received<br />
the Times, in which Lord Avebury, Professor in Stockholm by the 1st of February, time was very<br />
Sylvanus Thomson, Mr. A.C. Benson, of Eton, and short. The committee, however, acting with great<br />
others took part, and it was also ventilated in the promptitude, drew up a circular which was sent to<br />
Daily Chronicle. There was great confusion in the each member of the Council of the Society of<br />
public mind as to the regulations of the Nobel Authors, and also to each professor of English<br />
Prize, which are highly complicated, and, aided by literature in the universities and principal<br />
the Swedish academicians, Mr. Gosse gave fresh colleges of Great Britaip. To these circulars a<br />
information in successive letters to the Times. very general reply was received, and the voting<br />
On the 8th of January the following letter papers were forwarded to Stockholm by Mr, Thring<br />
appeared in the Times :-<br />
well withiu the necessary margin of time.<br />
“Sir,- The committee of the Incorporate Society of These circumstances, and the correspondence in<br />
Authors have been in communication, through me, with the Times, have awakened an immense amount of<br />
Mr. Edmund Gosse, on the subject of his letter which attention in the Swedish capital. The Swedish<br />
appeared in your columns on the 3rd. As Mr. Gosse indi-<br />
Academy, which has to run the gauntlet of a great<br />
cates, the time available for organizing any expression of<br />
opinion is now very short, but it has seemed to the com-<br />
deal of local criticism, made Mr. Gosse's letters<br />
mittee to be a case in which they might and ought to take the subject of an official communication to the<br />
action as the representatives of a very large and already Stockholm newspapers, and it is quite certain that<br />
organized body of British authors. Accordingly at their<br />
there is no chance of a repetition of the total neglect<br />
meeting to-day they decided to appoint a committee of their<br />
members for the purpose of considering (and if thought<br />
of English opinion which was so uufortunately<br />
proper) of submitting and supporting names of British men manifested in 1901.<br />
of letters with claims on the attention of the Nobel Com-<br />
mittee of the Swedish Academy. Invitations to serve on<br />
this committee are being sent to the following gentlemen :-<br />
THE IRISH LITERARY REVIVAL,<br />
Lord Avebury, Mr. James Bryce, M.P., Mr. Lecky, M.P.,<br />
Dr. Garnett, C.B., Mr. Thomas Hardy, Mr. Austin Dobson,<br />
BY JOHN TODHUNTER.<br />
and Mr. Edmund Gosse—and it is hoped that they will be<br />
able to give their services. They are empowered to add to<br />
their number any persons qualified and willing to give their<br />
“MT HE West's awake, the West's awake!”<br />
assistance, whether members of the society or not.<br />
In the future, and as the existence and conditions of the<br />
This line of the “Young Ireland” poet<br />
Nobel Prizes become fully known, it may be expected that<br />
of '48, Thomas Davis, was prophetic of<br />
other bodies in this country will address themselves to<br />
the more complete awakening of the national<br />
similar action ; but for the purposes of the immediately<br />
spirit in Ireland which has followed upon the<br />
ensuing awards the appointment of this committee will at<br />
least serve to show that our writers are not unmindful of “Home Rule” agitation of more recent times.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 126 (#522) ############################################<br />
<br />
126<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
To understand the true scope and meaning of the bribery and corruption, was the consummation<br />
Literary Revival--but one aspect of that greater of the policy which ignored the unconquerable<br />
movement which seems to be the beginning of a strength of the Irish national spirit, and attempted<br />
true Irish Renaissance—it is necessary to take a the exploitation of the country for the advantage<br />
bird's-eye view of Irish history. What is that of “ English interests.” The nett result has been<br />
“Great Enchantment,” to adopt the picturesque dismal failure. The chronic, and in the main<br />
phrase of Mr. Standish O'Grady, which has held successful, agitation following on the Union, and<br />
Ireland spell-bound for a thousand years, and the extension of the franchise in both countries, has,<br />
from which she is perhaps now at last awaking ? however, done much to open the eyes of all sensible<br />
Ireland is the land of an arrested civilisation. Englishmen, and to convince them that “ force is<br />
In the early centuries of Western Christianity she no remedy" for the “disaffection" of the Irish.<br />
was in the van of progress; the great missionary What seems to me to be a most healthy and<br />
nation, the evangelist and teacher of Europe. hopeful aspect of the present literary revival, of<br />
The Irish Christian civilisation, developed out of which the germs are to be found in the similar<br />
a much earlier pagan one, was destroyed in its one which accompanied the agitation of '48, is<br />
adolescence, with its learning, literature, and art. that love of Ireland is now not so constantly<br />
A nationality, however strong—and Irish nation- expressed merely in terms of hatred of England.<br />
ality was strong enough to absorb and assimilate In much of the work now being done England<br />
her invaders when they obtained a footing on her has retreated into the background of the national<br />
shores-must remain in a semi-organised con- consciousness. We are beginning to delight in<br />
dition until it achieves a stable political system. our own country, to think our own thoughts, and<br />
This the Irish people never quite succeeded in dream our own dreams, without reference to<br />
achieving. It remained in a ganglionic condition, England at all. Ireland is happier in her mind<br />
without a governing brain. The Scotch, with a now that the political nightmare has crossed the<br />
long line of hereditary kings, were enabled to Channel, to brood over the towers of Westminster.<br />
preserve their independence until the crowns of First.—There is the enthusiastic revival of the<br />
England and Scotland were peacefully united Irish language under the auspices of the “ Gaelic<br />
under a Scottish prince. The High King of all League" and the “Literary Societies.” It had<br />
Ireland was never practically the sovereign lord almost died out, but is now rejuvenescent, and has<br />
of all the tributary kinglets who nominally owed apparently come to stay.<br />
him allegiance, for a sufficiently long period to Secondly.—The “ Irish Texts Society," under<br />
establish his power as a hereditary monarch ; and the presidentship of Dr. Douglas Hyde, is doing<br />
when Brian Boru and his sons fell at Clontarf in good work in the editing of texts with translations,<br />
1014, founding no dynasty, the last chance of and in the preparation of a much-needed “ Handy<br />
political organisation was lost. In the century Irish Dictionary.”<br />
and a half between this event and the Norman Thirdly. — The study of Irish History goes<br />
invasion, Ireland, without a settled government, briskly forward. Classes for this have been formed<br />
had receded rather than advanced in civilisation ; in connection with the Irish Literary Society" ;<br />
with the Danes, defeated by Brian, established and a standard History of Ireland based on con-<br />
under their own leaders in the maritime cities temporary documents, each period to be under-<br />
around her coasts.<br />
taken by a writer making it his special study, is<br />
The English conquest begun under Henry II., projected ; though as yet not much has been done, as<br />
and still abortive, has kept the country in chronic such an important piece of work will involve much<br />
discontent, and England in political insecurity. time and labour.<br />
Ireland has been the most dangerous “possession" Fourthly.-National music, dancing, and games<br />
of the British crown ; always in sullen endurance are being cultivated by the “ Gaelic League" all<br />
of English misrule, with frequent paroxysms of over Ireland and in London. The “ Feis Ceoill,"<br />
agitation, conspiracy, and insurrection. Her a musical festival held annually in Dublin and<br />
development along national lines was checked, Belfast alternately, is also doing good work in<br />
while no real assimilation between the two antago- attempting to encourage musical composition, and<br />
nistic nationalities resulted. The old learning, the to raise the standard of vocal and instrumental<br />
old literature, the old art were strangled ; only performances in Ireland.<br />
poetry and music lingering on, like flowers run Fifthly.—Some steps are being taken to improve<br />
wild, after the garden in which they flourished the condition of the schools of art and public<br />
was laid waste-stray survivals of her arrested libraries in Ireland.<br />
civilisation.<br />
Sixthly.—There is a very promising effort, in the<br />
There is the history of Ireland in a nutshell. “Irish Literary Theatre," to create a national<br />
The “Union," procured by the most shameful Irish drama and school of acting.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 127 (#523) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
127<br />
This is not an exhaustive list ; but may serve It has idioms and constructions that seem to have<br />
to indicate the importance of the tributary forces been blown into the hearts of poets by the wind of<br />
which have, within the last ten years or so, given a mysterious inspiration, sowing seeds of sorrow<br />
vigour and volume to the great national revival, and passion and humour. It is still the language<br />
and which tend to make it permanent and pro- of lyrical poetry undivorced from music, and only<br />
gressive.<br />
waits for the art of the poet to mould it into new<br />
Of all these forms of activity the most astonish- and beautiful shapes.<br />
ing and significant is the revival of the national The heart of Thomas Davis would rejoice if he<br />
language, since Elizabeth's time under the ban of had lived, like his friend Sir Charles Gavan Duffy,<br />
penal laws, and in the nineteenth century fast to see the national movement of the present day,<br />
becoming extinct. A national language is the in which Sir Charles himself has played his part.<br />
voice of a nation's life, and it is a true instinct He was one of the founders of the “ Irish Literary<br />
which has led Irish Nationalists to make this last Society," and its first President; and he also pro-<br />
struggle to revive the old Irish tongue as the jeoted and edited the “ New Irish Library" of<br />
vehicle of modern Irish thought and feeling. twelve small volumes by various authors, dealing<br />
“ The language,” says Thomas Davis, “that grows with Irish history, biography, literature, and music;<br />
with a people, is conformed to their organs— the first of these being a reprint of Davis's<br />
mingled inseparably with their history, is fitted “Patriot Parliament,” with an introduction by<br />
beyond any other to express their most profound Sir Charles Duffy himself.<br />
thoughts in the most natural way. To impose Space does not permit me to say much about the<br />
another language on a people is to send their work of the “ Irish Literary Society," which, with<br />
history adrift among the accidents of translation, its monthly lectures, its original nights,” its con-<br />
to tear their identity from all places, to separate certs, its conversaziones, and its classes for the<br />
them from their forefathers by a deep gulf. ... study of history and language, has done much to<br />
To lose your native tongue and learn that of the unite Irish men and women of all classes and shades<br />
alien is the worst badge of conquest—it is the of opinion resident in England, for the pursuit of<br />
chain of the soul.”<br />
a common object.<br />
“In 1872 the language seemed dead," says So far I have dealt only with the broad lines of<br />
Mr. Fahy, in a lecture lately delivered at a meeting the Literary Revival; I must now say something<br />
of the “ Irish Literary Society"; and he goes on about some of the work done by the writers it has<br />
to tell how the present revival came about. In produced. I am sorry I am not able to criticise<br />
July, 1893, the “Gaelic League" was formed, its anything written in the Irish tongue, but must<br />
object being : “ The preservation of Irish as the confine myself to the work done in English, which<br />
national language of Ireland, and its extension Dr. Hyde regards as a prosaic and decadent lan-<br />
as a spoken tongue; the publication of existing guage ; yet there is now a vigorous and interesting<br />
Gaelic literature, and the cultivation of a modern literature in English, in both prose and verse, Irish<br />
literature in Irish.” There are now over two in sentiment, and dealing with Irish subjects.<br />
hundred branches of the league, and the effects of The political poems connected with the Parnell<br />
their work are already evident. “Names of streets movement are legion ; but most of them are news-<br />
and railway stations appear in Irish. Irish paper verses, often spirited and good of their kind,<br />
advertisements, leaders, and stories appear in but of ephemeral interest. Mr. T. D. Sullivan,<br />
papers. Concerts altogether of Irish songs are whose “God save Ireland” has become a sort of<br />
held. Sermons are given and public prayers are Irish national anthem, has written several smart<br />
offered in Irish. Irish speeches are given on skits, terse and to the point, in a light satiric vein<br />
platforms, and one was attempted recently in of his own, his verses being always neatly turned.<br />
Parliament.” I may add that plays have also But the tragic muse of the movement was Fanny<br />
been written and performed in Irish. At the Parnell, a sister of Charles. From a poem of hers<br />
“Irish Literary Theatre,” this year, a play in Irish, entitled “Post Mortem,” I quote a few stanzas, to<br />
“The Twisting of the Rope," founded on a short which her early death in 1882 gives a pathetic<br />
story by Mr. W. B. Yeats, and written by Dr. interest :-<br />
de, was most successfully performed; "Shall mine eyes behold thy glory, () my country?<br />
Dr. Hyde himself taking the principal part, assisted . Shall mine eyes behold thy glory<br />
by an amateur company of members of the “ Gaelic<br />
Or shall darkness close around them ere the sun-blaze<br />
League.” Dr. Hyde has also written many songs<br />
Break at last upon thy story?<br />
in Irish, and he and others are laying the founda-<br />
“When the nations ope for thee their queenly circle,<br />
tions of a modern Irish literature. Trish, with an<br />
As a sweet new sister hail thee,<br />
Shall their lips be sealed in callous death and silence<br />
elaborate metrical system of its own, has never<br />
That have known but to bewail thee?<br />
lost the innocence of the primitive imagination.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 128 (#524) ############################################<br />
<br />
128<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
“Ah ! the tramp of feet victorious ! I should hear them<br />
“ Our creed is this : "'Twere better starve<br />
'Mid the shamrocks and the mosses,<br />
Than live by others' loss or dole,<br />
And my heart should toss within the shroud and quiver,<br />
And better fail than pathway carve<br />
As a captive dreamer tosses.<br />
Through fraud and wrong to wished-for goal ;<br />
" I should turn and rend the cere clothes round me,<br />
That soon or late the right shall win,<br />
Giant sinews I should borrow,<br />
The weak grow strong, the mighty fall,<br />
Crying, . O my brothers, I have also loved her,<br />
The wicked perish in their sin,<br />
In her lowliness and sorrow.'<br />
The wronged on God not vainly call.'”<br />
· Let me join with you the jubilant procession,<br />
Whether the Irish live up to this counsel of<br />
“Let me chant with you her story ;<br />
Then contented I shall go back to the shamrocks,<br />
perfection much better than their neighbours may<br />
Now mine eyes have seen her glory.'<br />
be questionable. The bitter struggle for existence<br />
Mr. Francis A. Fahy, whose name I have men- is happily tempered by sympathetic helpfulness<br />
tioned in connection with the “Gaelic League,” has among the strugglers in England as in Ireland,<br />
also written some political poems, vigorous, sincere,<br />
where such family feeling as Mr. Faby has described<br />
and full of faith in the future of Ireland. The in his “ Trish Molly 0 !" 18 so often found among<br />
one small volume he has published contains some<br />
the peasantry.<br />
excellent work. The first poem in the book But enough of politics. The best work of the<br />
“ Dreoilin " (pronounced Drole-yeen, and meaning<br />
movement is not in its political satire ; and Mr.<br />
the wren), under which signature many of his Fahy's best things are his songs, which have that<br />
poems first saw the light, strikes the keynote of<br />
true singer's lilt in them so rare nowadays. Like<br />
the whole in the first verse :<br />
Mr. Graves, whose poems are better known in<br />
England, he has written many songs to old or new<br />
“My name is Dreoilin, I'm the smallest of all the birds<br />
That pour forth their notes on Irish hill-side or in grove;<br />
Irish airs. Like Mr. Graves, he has the art of<br />
Light is my song, though my thoughts are too deep for writing singable words. He is a great writer of<br />
words,<br />
love songs, of which “ Little Mary Cassidy " and<br />
My lay is of land, and of light, and of life, and love.” “The Ouid Plaid Shawl,” with their Irish note of<br />
The poem briefly recalls many memories of the humorous tenderness, are perhaps the best known.<br />
loves, sorrows, and sufferings of the Irish people— His “Irish Molly ()!” a narrative in ballad form,<br />
things he has himself seen and brooded over ; but tells how an Irish girl, on the death of her father,<br />
ends with a note of confident hope.<br />
emigrated to make a home for her family, dying<br />
In his political poems his stern sincerity and when she had met them once more. It is a<br />
common sense keep his imagination sane. He is charming poem, admirable in its simple directness<br />
remarkably free from the besetting sins of Irish of expression. Out of many songs of great merit<br />
patriotic poetry, sentimentality and flatulent I have only space for one. “ Drimmin Dhu,” the<br />
eloquence; and when he strikes his blows tell. He title of an old Irish melody, means “The Black<br />
does not regard the Irishman as an immaculate Cow.” In the original it was a lamentation for<br />
and ineffectual angel, and “the Saxon” as a devil the death of the cow ; in Mr. Fahy's poem the<br />
incarnate. Such vapid lines as these of a former lamentation is for the cow's mistress :<br />
generation are not in his manner :<br />
“On our side is virtue and Erin,<br />
“She's gone, oh Drimmin Dhu, that loved you dear,<br />
On theirs is the Saxon and guilt."<br />
No more at milking time her song you'll hear;<br />
Your kind, fond mistress now lies cold and low,<br />
From his “ We're not the same,” in which he Oh, Drimmin Dhu declish, mo bhron go deo ! *<br />
contrasts the ideals of the two nationalities, English<br />
and Irish, satirising the seamy side of the benevo-<br />
"Oh, fair her young face looked that day of pride<br />
When with you, her portion small I called her bride ;<br />
lent English filibuster, I quote a few stanzas :<br />
No King I envied then on earth below-<br />
“ We're not the same, we're not the same-<br />
Oh, Drimmin Dhu declish, mo bhron go deo!<br />
In thought, or mind, or soul, or heart;<br />
Our likenesses are but in name,<br />
“ Who now, my Drimmin Dhu, our joy will be ?<br />
We're severed as the poles apart.<br />
The world is desolate, for you and me,<br />
We've both our theme of rightful pride,<br />
Life's lost for evermore its summer glow,<br />
We've both our cause for blush of shame,<br />
Oh, Drimmin Dhu deelish, mo bhron go deo!<br />
But here our paths diverge, divide-<br />
We're not the same, we're not the same.<br />
“Oh, voice of gentleness ! oh, looks of light !<br />
“Our creed is not the Briton's creed-<br />
Oh, heart of tenderness, noon, morn, and night!<br />
Soon, soon, in search of you, from earth I'll go,<br />
Of barter keen and money lent,<br />
Oh, Drimmin Dhu declish, mo bhron go deo?”<br />
With roots deep down in selfish greed,<br />
And branching wide in cent. per cent. ;<br />
With maxims smooth of .might makes right,'<br />
(To be continued.)<br />
'He keeps who can-he takes who needs,'<br />
'Woe to the weak in life's tough fight,<br />
* Pronounced : “On, Dhrimmin Dhoo dheelish, mavrone<br />
And Nothing like success succeeds.'<br />
udh-yeo !”-“Oh, dear black-cow, my grief for ever!"<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 129 (#525) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
129<br />
“ REAL PEOPLE IN FICTION.” nil nisi bonum is a discarded axiom, even in<br />
these days of the whitewash brush. If it is<br />
legitimate to write novels dealing with the seven-<br />
teenth century, it is equally legitimate to deal<br />
with the eighteenth, and if with the eighteenth,<br />
why not with the nineteenth and the twentieth ?<br />
M HE author of the article on “ Real People in Surely the sorites must apply. So, too, for<br />
1 Fiction,” which appeared in the last number the one thing hinges upon the other, must<br />
of The Author, has issued a useful warning to the argument apply when considering ques-<br />
writers of a certain class of novel ; but there are a tions of general interest as the subject matter of<br />
few points arising out of his little essay upon which novels. If one may write tales of adventure round<br />
some comment may not be unacceptable.<br />
the Boer war, one may write them round the<br />
It is not unfair to say that his remarks apply kidnapping of missionaries by brigands, or round<br />
more particularly to a very inferior type of novel. the coronation, or may write sociological stories<br />
There are many writers who, by giving verbal round conscientious objection or the collection by<br />
portraits of their acquaintances, recording their Methodists of a million sovereigns to commemorate<br />
actual words uttered in situations analogous to the dawn of a new century. Neither in subject<br />
those employed in the stories, and using their nor in period is there any precisely defined re-<br />
imagination only to the extent of giving these striction imposed upon the novelist, and it is<br />
acquaintances fictitious names, are simply follow difficult to see why, if in the adoption of some<br />
ing the line of least resistance, quite regardless of contemporary event as the theme of a story the<br />
at what point they may ultimately arrive. To introduction of contemporary personages is in-<br />
such as these Mr. Armstrong's words of warning volved, there need be any other objection than<br />
may be useful, but if numerically they are a large that already indicated of some conséquent limita-<br />
class, artistically they are an insignificant one. tion in the use of their creative faculty. It would<br />
The mere fact that they do thus follow the line of be easy to particularise, but the point is doubtless<br />
least resistance predicates a lack of imagination sufficiently clear.<br />
and of that creative power which distinguishes the It is when one leaves the historical or quasi-<br />
good from the bad novelist.<br />
historical novel and comes to those dealing only<br />
But, on the other hand, there are a not in- with modern social life that the issue becomes more<br />
considerable number of authors, who must be vague, and it is, of course, to the writers of these<br />
taken seriously on their merits, in whose books that Mr. Armstrong primarily refers. The value<br />
characters are drawn from life and presented of this class of story when well done, whether for<br />
under the thinnest of disguises. Are allt hese purposes of satire or of throwing light upon our<br />
to be included in your contributor's indict- times, or again of mere amusement, will hardly be<br />
ment? Not necessarily; not even if the result. questioned. An author who is a master of tech-<br />
ing picture is not so flattering as a less honest nique, and possesses a sense of humour in addition<br />
photographer might make it by judicious touching to the seeing eye, can do as good service with his<br />
up.<br />
pen as Du Maurier or Tenniel or Phil May have<br />
Consider, for instance, the historical novel, done with their pencil. Was Du Maurier less<br />
intended not only to interest as a story, but good because he employed his own family as<br />
to throw light upon a period or an event of models than Phil May, who individualises types ?<br />
general interest. "In all these books characters This is not to suggest any comparative estimate of<br />
are, of course, taken from life, and the question the merit of their work ; it is merely asking the<br />
arises, On this side of what point in time are question à propos of the use by the one of real<br />
stories dealing with historical facts to be ruled people who were known to a wide circle of ac-<br />
out of order?<br />
quaintances; and the general verdict can be<br />
There is scarcely any law-with the possible readily anticipated.<br />
exception of the law of copyright-in which there Moreover, the question might be wisely limited<br />
is so much latitude of interpretation as the law of so as to exclude caricature; wisely, because the<br />
libel. But in practice it works tolerably well, and limitation serves to clear the atmosphere. It<br />
no novelist of average ability need live in a state might be difficult for a satirist who desired by<br />
of chronic apprehension of its terrors. The ridicule to kill some grotesque fashion to escape a<br />
chronological point, therefore, on the hither side charge of having caricatured some more or less<br />
of which novelists must not use real people as well known exponent of the cult, but he might be<br />
figures in their books, is not a legally ascertained held entitled to an honourable discharge if while<br />
one. Nor, again, can it be fixed by the date of achieving the object he had in view his caricature<br />
death of the real persons concerned. De mortuis were artistically well done ; but books of this sort<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 130 (#526) ############################################<br />
<br />
130<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
are a class apart, and it is seldom that a Dunciad amount of good feeling in the world as it is, but<br />
is required.<br />
also a vast amount of practical common sense<br />
But to the abstract question of the legitimacy which gets its own way in the end.<br />
of the device of employing real people as characters<br />
in fiction, it would seem that for all practical<br />
CRANSTOUN METCALFE.<br />
purposes the answer is sufficiently simple. The<br />
justification of a work of art must always be its<br />
own artistic qualities, and no amount of mere<br />
technique can compensate for lack of the imagina-<br />
tive or poetic power which ought to prompt the<br />
artist to expression, or atone for lack of taste.<br />
I think one of the reasons why writers of fiction<br />
“ Taste,” it is true, is a word as difficult to be<br />
are so constantly accused, whether rightly or<br />
defined as “gentleman”; but its significance here<br />
wrongly, of “putting real people into their books”<br />
is obvious. If in a novel describing life in London<br />
is partly owing to the conviction-deep-rooted as the<br />
to-day there is not a word which can hurt the<br />
forest oak—in the minds of unimaginative persons<br />
feelings of, or cause the slightest pain to the most<br />
that character is only a servile photograph from<br />
refined and sensitive man or woman alive at the<br />
life. They do not believe, and it seems improba-<br />
moment, it may be argued that the author has<br />
ble they ever will believe, that a study of character<br />
committed a very venial offence if, as we watch the may be a creation.<br />
figures moving in the pretty comedy, we turn with<br />
Many persons have explained to me at enormous<br />
a kindly smile to our neighbour and say, “Ah ! length that every person in my own stories must<br />
there is So-and-So.” And the belief that the<br />
be taken from among my acquaintances, because<br />
author's good taste finds its equivalent in the good<br />
in the cood that was the only way to make characters seem<br />
taste of his unconscious model is not born of<br />
lifelike.<br />
unreasoning optimism. The price every public<br />
When I lived in the country the unimaginative<br />
personage pays for his public character is a certain<br />
among my friends discovered, to my embarrassment,<br />
limitation of his private rights, and not many<br />
when I brought out a book, that each individual<br />
public personages would resent being used to point<br />
in it, hero and villain alike, dwelt within a radius<br />
a moral or adorn a tale, provided the moral be<br />
of five miles from our front door. I remember a<br />
sound, and the tale be told with propriety and<br />
friend saying to me reproachfully, “ We all saw at<br />
taste.<br />
once that you took Mrs. Alwynn (a tiresome person)<br />
For the author who has no taste there always<br />
from Mrs. — And we all say that it is not the<br />
remains the law of libel. For the rest there<br />
least like her."<br />
is an unwritten law which is pretty generally<br />
It certainly was not.<br />
understood. For a vulgar success of scandal no<br />
When Mrs. Clifford produced her brilliant novel,<br />
detestation is too intense, no condemnation too<br />
“ Aunt Anne," several of my relations wrote to me<br />
severe ; but many people would regret a condition<br />
in great bitterness to protest against my ruthless<br />
of things which would prevent the publication of,<br />
delineation of my own great-aunt, who had but<br />
say, “ The New Republic.”<br />
recently “passed away." They had recognised Aunt<br />
It inay not be inopportune to add the suggestion<br />
Anne at once; and there is no doubt the “ Aunt<br />
Anne ” of the novel bore a certain resemblance to<br />
that a more serious danger to literature than the<br />
this relation.<br />
use of real people in fiction is the employment of<br />
fiction in the biography of real people. It is<br />
I at once wrote back, and so did my father, to<br />
always pleasant to be in good company, and Lord<br />
explain that that clever book was not written by me.<br />
Rosebery will doubtless value this tribute of<br />
(I only wish it could have been.) But<br />
approval of his recent wise words on the subject.<br />
Relations convinced against their will<br />
There is too much romance in biography nowadays,<br />
Are of the same opinion still.<br />
and no one need lament the decay of imagination<br />
in face of what is called “ personal journalism." They were not for a moment deceived by the feeble<br />
Some of the writers of these biographical personal falsehoods into which I had even dragged my<br />
remarks are magnificent liars. Lord Rosebery hitherto respected parent. And they remained<br />
made some suggestions as to the method of dealing convinced that I was the author of “ Aunt Anne.”<br />
with the crime, and regretted that his reforms They died thinking so.<br />
were Utopian. Many people are of opinion that<br />
MARY CHOLMONDELEY.<br />
any Utopia would be an exceedingly dull place,<br />
but if this discussion can be carried on a little<br />
further, it is more than probable that it will have<br />
a beneficial effect. For there is not only a vast<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 131 (#527) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
131<br />
AN EPITAPH ON A NAMELESS GRAVE. standpoint a man was better equipped if he had<br />
some command of that instrument with which all<br />
Ούνομα μοι· τί σε τούτο; πάτρις δε μοι· ες τι δε τουτο business has to be done-his own language.<br />
Κλείνου δ' είμι γενους· ει γαρ αφαυροτάτου;<br />
Mr. Bernard Shaw also spoke. He was, as one<br />
Ζήσας δένδοξώς έλιπον βίον· ει γαρ αδοξώς και<br />
would have expected, an optimist for pessimistic<br />
Κείμαι δ' ενθαδε νυν τίς τίνι ταυτα λέγεις ;<br />
reasons. He thought that boys cared nothing for<br />
PAULUS SILENTIARIUS.<br />
books, "and a very good thing too.” That boys<br />
should know less about literature now than they did<br />
My name and country were—what's that to thee ?<br />
formerly he held to be impossible; but this he in no<br />
My birth was noble-what, if it were low?<br />
wise deplored, as there was a great deal too much<br />
With fame I lived, then died—what, if without ?<br />
reading done. “Why should boys,” he asked, “be<br />
I now lie here—who to whom speaketh so ? expected to read Wordsworth, one of the dullest<br />
J. M. LELY. men who ever lived ?" And he hoped that the<br />
class mentioned by Mr. Storr would long remain in<br />
ignorance of “Locksley Hall.” The desire to teach<br />
SCHOOLBOYS AND LITERATURE. literature, Mr. Shaw maintained, arose from the<br />
habit of book fancying, or collecting, which was<br />
A T the well-known King Alfred School in just as useless an idiosyncrasy as pigeon fancying,<br />
A Hampstead a discussion was lately held on and led to such absurdities as the banning of split<br />
the question—vital to authors of the infinitives, though it was the genius of the English<br />
near future—whether the study and love of litera- language to split everything. Fanciers always<br />
ture were decaying in schools ; by which the opener wanted to force their particular fancies upon other<br />
of the discussion explained himself to mean boys' people, and so it was with the literary fancier :<br />
schools, though at the King Alfred School boys and but Mr. Shaw declared that no one had any right<br />
girls stand on an equal footing.<br />
to force any education upon a child, except techni.<br />
It appeared that there were both optimists and cal education, in the sense of education that would<br />
pessimists in the King Alfred Society, especially be useful. Latin and Greek used to come within<br />
pessimists. Mr. Francis Storr, who took the chair, that category in the days when everything that had<br />
and spoke with all the weight of many years to be read was written in them ; but that was not<br />
experience of practical schoolmastering, was for the the case now, and the teaching of those languages<br />
prosecution, and gave recent and gloomy instances was only supported by the fraud of pretending that<br />
of a class of big boys (average age seventeen), not they were necessary to the understanding of English,<br />
one of whom had ever read “Locksley Hall," nor and the “ hallmark of a gentleman,” Every other<br />
had any appreciable knowledge of Wordsworth. form of education should be the spontaneous out-<br />
“ With him” was Mr. Edward Rose, who read a come of a child's character. To talk of forming a<br />
paper on school papers. He had examined the child's mind was an outrage, and Mr. Shaw gave<br />
magazines of many schools, as Eton, Harrow, Win- it as his experience that teachers were more de-<br />
chester, Rugby, Marlborough,Shrewsbury, St. Paul's, moralised than any other class, which he supposed to<br />
.Dulwich, Tonbridge, Ipswich, and so forth, and had be due to their continual contact with defenceless<br />
tabulated the results of his investigations. A priori, minds. Their only justification, he said, lay in<br />
it had seemed likely that schoolboys cared less for the necessity for the grown-ups to defend themselves<br />
literature now than they did say thirty years ago; against the young, lest the latter should turn the<br />
a posteriori—after examining the magazines—it world upside down ; so they deceived them until<br />
appeared certain. His a priori reasons for thinking they became grown up themselves, and joined the<br />
this decline and fall probable were, first, the enormous ranks of the deceivers.<br />
interest now taken by boys in “paper athletics "— It need hardly be said that the King Alfred<br />
for example, the study of averages and the contents Society did not, as a body, accept Mr. Shaw's views :<br />
of newspapersentirely devoted to sport—and second, indeed, Mr. Ernest Rhys put in a formal protest<br />
the amount of time now taken up in schools by more against their spirit, and the Headmaster of the<br />
obviously “paying” subjects, such as modern lan- School—Mr. John Russell—spoke some wise and<br />
guages and physical science. His proofs of actual hopeful words on the side of the optimists. He<br />
decay were drawn from theschool magazines, written said, among other things, that the increasing demand<br />
by the boys themselves, which formerly were in the for good cheap literature—which was, as he believed,<br />
main literary reviews, but had now become for the largely purchased by boys-seemed to be the evi.<br />
most part mere reports of cricket matches, concerts, dence of a continuing love for it. He had always<br />
and other school news. And Mr. Rose ended by found that if a master approached literature in a<br />
protesting against the purely utilitarian view of spirit of sincerity, and not of convention or dog-<br />
education, while he added that even from this matism, recognising, for instance, that some parts<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 132 (#528) ############################################<br />
<br />
132<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
even of Shakespeare were very dull, and would read<br />
literature with his pupils in that spirit-guiding<br />
the youthful taste rather than dictating to it—he<br />
would have no difficulty in interesting them.<br />
And so, with a measure of hopefulness, the King<br />
Alfred Society ceased for the moment to consider<br />
how much its children cared for literary things.<br />
CORRESPONDENCE.<br />
“A Winter Pilgrimage ') takes credit to himself<br />
for the identification of Golgotha with Skull<br />
Hill,' not knowing, it would seem, &c., &c.”<br />
I have not seen the paragraph referred to by the<br />
reviewer, but if it can be construed in such a sense,<br />
I beg that it may be contradicted in your next<br />
issue of The Author. My real attitude on the<br />
matter of the site of Calvary will be proved<br />
sufficiently by the extract which I append. Why<br />
the writer of the notice, in the teeth of the text<br />
of the book with which he was dealing, should<br />
choose to make so peculiarly unpleasant an imputa-<br />
tion upon myself on the sole strength of a paragraph<br />
he had read in The Author, is a question which I<br />
will not discuss, since to do so without irritation<br />
would not be easy.<br />
I am, Sir, your obedient servant,<br />
H. RIDER HAGGARD.<br />
Ditchingham,<br />
3rd January.<br />
AUTHOR AND LITERARY AGENT.<br />
DEAR SIR,–I cannot accept without protest<br />
“Omega's” statement, endorsed by Mr. Heinemann,<br />
to the effect that “authors are all in competition<br />
against one another.” Publishers may be animated<br />
by the competitive spirit ; each one is naturally<br />
anxious to secure the greatest number of popular<br />
writers ; this is business, and publishing is a com-<br />
mercial affair — it is highly interesting, and few<br />
ways of money-making are more agreeable to men<br />
of taste, with a certain courage in speculation,<br />
But the “sales” of one author are in no way<br />
affected by the success of his confrère. M. Anatole<br />
France is not consumed by envy, we may be<br />
certain, because Paul Bourget has a larger public<br />
than the creator of “Monsieur Bergeret"; nor do both<br />
gentlemen join in a common hatred of Zola, who<br />
can beat them magnificently any day in the matter<br />
of editions. All educated readers read these three<br />
authors; the sentimental half-educated, who can-<br />
not understand the irony of Anatole France, read<br />
Bourget only; every class of reader can find some-<br />
thing in Zola. Each one of these writers knows<br />
perfectly the particular group he is addressing, and<br />
the idea of rivalship between them is ridiculous. I<br />
could tell a hundred instances where English authors<br />
me<br />
have taken trouble, and written reviews, to assist<br />
publications already more successful, financially,<br />
than their own, and they have so written, not in<br />
obedience to a forced or Quixotic impulse, but<br />
because they appreciated the books, and wished to<br />
shed to<br />
add a specialist's praise to the less critical commen-<br />
dations of casual readers.<br />
Yours faithfully,<br />
PEARL MARY TERESA CRAIGIE.<br />
FROM "A WINTER PILGRIMAGE," PAGE 310, IST EDITION,<br />
BY H, RIDER HAGGARD.<br />
“This is the case, put briefly, but as clearly as I can set<br />
it out. It is not for an amateur like myself upon the<br />
strength of only two examinations, although these were<br />
careful, to be dogmatic, or express any positive opinion,<br />
and I express none on this or other disputed sites and<br />
matters connected with the Holy Land. How can I.<br />
who, lacking an extended experience of these problems,<br />
must rely mainly upon my powers of observation and de-<br />
duction, such as they may be, to guide me to the truth? I<br />
only venture to point out, not knowing whether or no this<br />
has been done in works already published, that, as I saw it<br />
in the year 1900, the surface of this cliff has a quaint and<br />
ghastly resemblance to a human skull. Taken in connec-<br />
tion with the traditions of that place, with its undoubted<br />
suitability to the dread purposes of public death, and with<br />
suitability to the dread pu<br />
the name by which the true spot was known, wherever it<br />
may have been, I submit that this resemblance is, to say<br />
the least, exceedingly suggestive."<br />
"<br />
P.S.-Since despatching the above letter I have<br />
looked through the chapter in my book headed<br />
“ Gordon's Tomb and Golgotha." I find that it<br />
contains the following<br />
already quoted :-<br />
already quo<br />
“ This, at least, is sure, that if the true Calvary was where<br />
many believe it to have been, among them myself, on the<br />
traditional site of the Place of Stoning.” (p. 305.)<br />
"But if the true Calvary was just without the wall on<br />
the borders of the Mahommedan cemetery, as think Otto<br />
Thenius, General Gordon, Colonel Conder, Doctor Merrill,<br />
and many more.” (p. 306, 1st edition.)<br />
Now this “true Calvary” whereof I speak is<br />
the same as the “Skull Hill ” of the identification<br />
of which, with the site of the Crucifixion, the<br />
reviewer suggests that I have taken the “ credit."<br />
How much credit I have taken to myself can be<br />
gathered from these extracts (to which I have<br />
added the italics only).-H. R. H.<br />
REVIEWING_NEW STYLE.<br />
SIR, -Among a packet of reviews of my book<br />
* A Winter Pilgrimage,” received by me this<br />
morning, is one which appeared in the Pall Mall<br />
Gazette that contains the following passage :-<br />
“It is to be inferred from a paragraph in this<br />
month's Author that he (that is, the writer of<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 132 (#529) ############################################<br />
<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
111<br />
SALE OF MSS. OF EVERY KIND.<br />
Literary Advice, Revision, Research, etc.<br />
ARRANGEMENTS FOR<br />
Printing, Publishing, Illustration, Translation, etc.<br />
THE LITERARY AGENCY OF LONDON,<br />
5, HENRIETTA STREET, W.C.<br />
G. H. PERRIS.<br />
C. F. CAZENOVE.<br />
TYPEWRITING COMPANY, Oswald House, Queen Victoria Road, Coventry.<br />
Typewriting of every description, from Ninepence per Thousand Words<br />
(including good paper). Specimens on application.<br />
Special Work undertaken (not necessarily for publication); neatly and carefully executed<br />
in Two Colours, at Special Charges.<br />
Testimonial.-“Undoubtedly the finest piece of work I have ever seen produced on a Typewriter."<br />
6 REMINGTON STANDARD" up-to-date Instruments.<br />
DARLINGTON'S HANDBOOKS<br />
MRS. GILL,<br />
TYPE-WRITING OFFICE.<br />
35, LUDGATE HILL, E.C.<br />
(ESTABLISHED 1883.)<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully copied from 1s. per 1000 words. Duplicate<br />
copies third price. Skilled typists sent out by hour, day or week,<br />
French MSS. accurately copied, or typewritten English translations<br />
supplied. References kindly permitted to Messrs. A. P. Watt & Son,<br />
Literary Agents, Hastings House, Norfolk Street, Strand, W.C.<br />
THE WEST KENSINGTON TYPEWRITING AGENCY.<br />
SIKES and SIKES,<br />
13, Wolverton Gardens, Hammersmith Road, W.<br />
ESTABLISHED 1893.<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully and promptly copied. Usual Terms.<br />
Legal and General Copying.<br />
Typewritten Circulars by Duplicator.<br />
LESSONS GIVEN. AUTHORS' REFERENCES.<br />
“Sir Henry Ponsonby is<br />
commanded by the Queen to<br />
She thank Mr. Darlington for a<br />
w copy of his Handbook."<br />
“ Nothing better could be wished for."-BRITISH WEEKLY.<br />
“Far superior to ordinary guides."-LONDON DAILY CHRONICLE.<br />
Edited by RALPH DARLINGTON, F.R.G.S. 18. each. Illustrated.<br />
Maps by JOHN BARTHOLOMEW, F.R.G.S.<br />
THE ISLE OF WIGHT.<br />
THE CHANNEL ISLANDS.<br />
THE VALE OF LLANGOLLEN. THE NORFOLK BROADS.<br />
BRECON AND ITS BEACONS. THE SEVERN VALLEY.<br />
BOURNEMOUTH AND THE NEW FOREST. THE WYE VALLEY<br />
BRIGHTON, EASTBOURNE, HASTINGS, AND ST. LEONARDS<br />
ABERYSTWITH, TOWYN, BARMOUTH, AND DOLGELLY.<br />
MALVERN, HEREFORD. WORCESTER, AND GLOUCESTER.<br />
LLANDRINDOD WELLS AND THE SPAS OF MID-WALES.<br />
BRISTOL, BATH, CHEPSTOW, AND WESTON-SUPER-MARE.<br />
LLANDUDNO, RHYL, BANGOR, CARNARVON, ANGLESEA.<br />
CONWAY, COLWYN BAY, BETTWS-Y-COED, FESTINIOG,<br />
SNOWDON.<br />
TYPEWRITING.<br />
Authors' MSS. accurately copied from 8d. per 1,000<br />
words. Experienced in all kinds of scientific and<br />
difficult MSS. Reduction for large quantities.<br />
MISS CARRINGTON,<br />
27, Kelmscott Road, Clapham, S.W.<br />
'THE AUTHOR."<br />
SCALE FOR ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
(ALLOWANCE TO MEMBERS OF THE SOCIETY 20 PER CENT.)<br />
“The best Handbook to London ever issued."-LIVERPOOL DAILY Post.<br />
“THE Handbook to London--it very emphatically tops them all."-<br />
DAILY GRAPHIC.<br />
3rd Edition, Revised, Bs. 60 Illustrations, 24 Maps and Plans.<br />
LONDON AND ENVIRONS.<br />
By E. C. Cook and E. T. Cook, M.A.<br />
Fcap. Svo. 1s. THE HOTELS OF THE WORLD.<br />
A Handbook to the leading Hotels throughout the world.<br />
Llangollen : DARLINGTON & Co. London: SIMPKIN, MARSHALL & Co.<br />
LTD. Railway Bookstalls and all Bookseliers.<br />
PHOTOGRAPHS.--BIRTHDAY and SEASON CARDS from negatives by<br />
RALPH DARLINGTON, F.R.G.S., of Scenery, Ruins, &c., in Italy, Greece,<br />
Asia Minor, and Egypt, ls., 1s. 6d., 28., and 28. 6d. List, post free, of<br />
DARLINGTON & Co., LLANGOLLEN.<br />
C6<br />
Front Page<br />
... ..£4 0<br />
Other Pages<br />
0<br />
... ... 3 0 0<br />
Half of a Page ...<br />
... ... ... 1 10 0<br />
Quarter of a Page<br />
... 0 15 0<br />
Eighth of a Page<br />
0 7 6<br />
Single Column Advertiseme<br />
per inch 0 6 0<br />
Bills for Insertion ...<br />
per 2,000 3 0<br />
Reduction of 20 per cent. made for a Series of Six and of 25 per cent. for<br />
Twelve Insertions.<br />
Advertisements should reach the Office not later than the 20th for<br />
insertion in the following month's issue.<br />
All letters respecting Advertisements should be addressed to the<br />
ADVERTISEMENT MANAGER, The Author Office, 39, Old Queen Street,<br />
Storey's Gate, S.W.<br />
TYPEWRITING.<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully and promptly copied, from 9d.<br />
per 1,000 words. Two copies, 1/-.<br />
Specimen of Work on application.<br />
Miss PARKER,<br />
7. BAILLIE ROAD, GUILDFORD.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 132 (#530) ############################################<br />
<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
ESTABLISHED)<br />
(XVII. CENT.<br />
The Athenæum Press, Taunton.<br />
BARNICOTT & PEARCE<br />
INVITE ENQUIRIES RESPECTING PRINTING.<br />
ESTIMATES OF COST, AND OTHER DETAILS, PROMPTLY GIVEN.<br />
TYPEWRITING.<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully and accurately copied. Plays and Scientific MSS. & speciality. Contract prices for books or<br />
permanent work. Machines and operators sent out to all parts of London or the Provinces.<br />
Miss RANSOM, 2, Westbourne Grove, London, W.<br />
Close to Paddington, Royal Oak, and Queen's Road Stations (Tube and Metropolitan).<br />
THE BUSH LANE HOUSE TYPEWRITING & SHORTHAND OFFICE,<br />
Principal:<br />
Bush Lane House, Bush Lane,<br />
MISS MORGAN<br />
Cannon Street, London, E.C.<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully and promptly copied from 10d, per 1,000 words. General Typewriting, Shorthand and<br />
Translations executed by skilled workers. Privacy and accuracy guaranteed.<br />
Special Terms for large quantities or contract work. Estimates and Specimens free on application.<br />
THE WHITEFRIARS PRESS, LONDON AND TONBRIDGE.<br />
BRADBURY, AGNEW, & Co. LD.<br />
Will give Estimates for and undertake the production of any description of<br />
BOOK AND MAGAZINE PRINTING AND BINDING.<br />
Telegrams: Charivari, London ; Charivari, Tonbridge.<br />
Telephones : 28 Holborn; 19 Tonbridge.<br />
AUTHORS' TYPEWRITING, TYPEWRITING. 9d. per 1,000 words.<br />
Novels typewritten, from 9d. per 1,000 words;<br />
ACCURACY AND DISPATCH.<br />
two copies, 11-.<br />
PRICE LIST AND AUTHORS OPINIONS ON APPLICATION. Miss RISDON,<br />
L. A. ST. JOHN, 104, Churston Av., Upton Park, E.<br />
6, Racquet Court,<br />
114, Fleet Street, E.C.<br />
AUTHORS' MSS. CAREFULLY TYPED. AUTHORS' MS, TYPED<br />
REASONABLE TERMS.<br />
By Experienced Hand. 9d. thousand words.<br />
M. J. C., 31, LAMMAS PARK ROAD, EALING, W.<br />
Miss M. T. DOYLE,<br />
Literary Agents.-Authors are warned against dealing with<br />
any Literary Agent without referring to the Society for infor-<br />
201, Barcombe Avenue, Streatham Hill, S.W. |<br />
mation. Authors are also warned not to sign Agreements on the<br />
advice of Literary Agents alone. All Agreements should be<br />
submitted to the Society for advice.<br />
TYPEWRITING<br />
By Order, G. HERBERT THRING,<br />
Secretary Society of Authors,<br />
39, Old Queen Street, Storey's Gate, S.W.<br />
With Accuracy and Despatch.<br />
Authors' MSS. 9d. per 1000 words. In duplicate, 1s.<br />
The "Forms of Agreements" issued by the Publishers/<br />
Association can be obtained at the Office, with a full explanat<br />
per 1000. Plays, Translations, General Copying, Samples of their meaning, price 1s. post free. Authors and<br />
LOE<br />
and References on Application.<br />
to sign any agreement which may embody the Clauses exposef<br />
without submitting it first to the Society.<br />
MISS JANET WAY,<br />
By Order, G. HERBERT THRING,<br />
Secretary Society of Authors,<br />
33, Ossian Road, Stroud Green, N.<br />
<br />
39, Old Queen Street, Storey's Gate. S.W.<br />
Printed by BRADBURY, AGNEW, & Co. LD., and Published by them for THE SOCIETY OF AUTHORS (INCORPORATED)<br />
at 10, Bouverie Street, London, E.C. | https://historysoa.com/files/original/5/350/1902-02-01-The-Author-12-7.pdf | publications, The Author |