334 | https://historysoa.com/items/show/334 | The Author, Vol. 11 Issue 04 (September 1900) | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=49&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=%3Cem%3EThe+Author%3C%2Fem%3E%2C+Vol.+11+Issue+04+%28September+1900%29"><em>The Author</em>, Vol. 11 Issue 04 (September 1900)</a> | | | <a href="https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015006979390" target="_blank" rel="noopener">https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015006979390</a> | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=51&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Publication">Publication</a> | 1900-09-01-The-Author-11-4 | | | | | 61–80 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=89&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=11">11</a> | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=76&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=1900-09-01">1900-09-01</a> | | | | | | | 4 | | | 19000901 | The Author.<br />
(The Organ of the Incorporated Society of Authors. Monthly.)<br />
CONDUCTED BY WALTER BESANT.<br />
VOL. XI.—No. 4.]<br />
SEPTEMBER 1, 1900.<br />
[PRICE SIXPENCE.<br />
-<br />
CONTENTS.<br />
PAGE<br />
61<br />
:<br />
:<br />
... 62<br />
... 64<br />
Memoranda ...<br />
Literary Property-<br />
1. On Titles<br />
2. Copyright in Speeches<br />
3. Merivale v. Harvey ...<br />
Paris Letter. By Darracotte Scott<br />
American Letter. By John Russell Davidson<br />
Notes and News. By the Editor...<br />
PAGE<br />
Another Benefactor ..<br />
72<br />
The Ideal Editor .<br />
American Publishers' Association ...<br />
Reflections ...<br />
Correspondance --1. Good and Bad English. 2. Walter » Lene.<br />
3. English Authors in the United States ...<br />
Book and Play Talk...<br />
Books and Reviews ...<br />
... ... 79<br />
PUBLICATIONS OF THE SOCIETY.<br />
The Annual Report. That for the past year can be had on application to the Secretary.<br />
The Author. A Monthly Journal devoted especially to the protection and maintenance of Literary<br />
Property. Issued to all Members, 6s. 6d. per annum. Back numbers are offered at the<br />
following prices : Vol. I., 108. 6d. (Bound); Vols. II., III., and IV., 88. 6d. each (Bound);<br />
Vols. V. to VIII. (Unbound), 6s. 6d.<br />
3. Literature and the Pension List. By W. MORRIS COLLES, Barrister-at-Law. Henry Glaisher,<br />
95, Strand, W.C. 35.<br />
4. The History of the Société des Gens de Lettres. By S. SQUIRE SPRIGGE, late Secretary to<br />
the Society. IS.<br />
6. The Cost of Production. In this work specimens are given of the most important forms of type,<br />
size of page, &c., with estimates showing what it costs to produce the more common kinds of<br />
books. Henry Glaisher, 95, Strand, W.C. 28, 6d. (Out of print at present.)<br />
6. The Various Methods of Publication. By S. SQUIRE SPRIGGE. In this work, compiled from the<br />
papers in the Society's offices, the various forms of agreements proposed by Publishers to<br />
Authors are examined, and their meaning carefully explained, with an account of the various<br />
kinds of fraud which have been made possible by the different clauses in their agreements.<br />
Henry Glaisher, 95, Strand, W.C. 38.<br />
7. Copyright Law Reform. An Exposition of Lord Monkswell's Copyright Bill of 1890. With<br />
Extracts from the Report of the Commission of 1878, and an Appendix containing the<br />
Berne Convention and the American Copyright Bill. By J. M. LELY. Eyre and Spottis-<br />
woode. 1s. 6d.<br />
8. The Society of Authors. A Record of its Action from its Foundation. By Walter BESANT<br />
(Chairman of Committee, 1888–1892). 15.<br />
9. The Contract of Publication in Germany, Austria, Hungary, and Switzerland. By Ernst<br />
LUNGE, J.U.D. 28. 6d.<br />
10. The Addenda to the "Methods of Publishing." By G. HERBERT THring. Being additional<br />
facts collected at the office of the Society since the publication of the “Methods." With<br />
comments and advice. 28.<br />
11. Forms of Agreement issued by the Publishers' Association ; with Comments. By G. HERBERT<br />
THRING, and Illustrative Examples by Sir WALTER BESANT. 1S.<br />
The Empire Translation Bureau,<br />
25, PRINCE'S STREET, HANOVER SQUARE, W.<br />
All kinds of LITERARY WORK undertaken by Gentlemen of the highest University education.<br />
AUTHORS' MSS. TYPEWRITTEN (Williams Machine).<br />
Rates vary according to the intrinsic difficulties of the MSS. submitted. Write for prospectus.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 60 (#90) ##############################################<br />
<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
The Society of Authors (Incorporated).<br />
PRESIDENT.<br />
GEORGE MEREDITH.<br />
COUNCIL.<br />
SIR EDWIN ARNOLD, K.C.I.E., C.S.I. AUSTIN Dobson.<br />
SIR LEWIS MORRIS.<br />
J. M. BARRIE.<br />
A. CONAN DOYLE, M.D.<br />
HENRY NORMAN.<br />
A. W. À BECKETT.<br />
A. W. DUBOURG.<br />
Miss E. A. ORMEROD.<br />
ROBERT BATEMAN.<br />
SIR MICHAEL FOSTER, K.C.B., F.R.S. GILBERT PARKER.<br />
F. E. BEDDARD, F.R.S.<br />
D. W. FRESHFIELD.<br />
J. C. PARKINSON.<br />
SIR HENRY BERGNE, K.C.M.G. RICHARD GARNETT, C.B., LL.D.<br />
A. W. PINERO.<br />
SIR WALTER BEBANT.<br />
EDMUND GOSSE.<br />
THE RIGHT HON. THE LORD PIR-<br />
AUGUSTINE BIRRELL, M.P.<br />
H. RIDER HAGGARD.<br />
BRIGHT, F.R.S.<br />
THE REV. PROF. BONNEY, F.R.S. THOMAS HARDY.<br />
SIR FREDERICK POLLOCK, Bart., LL.D.<br />
THE RIGHT Hon. JAMES BRYCE, M.P. ANTHONY HOPE HAWKINS.<br />
WALTER HERRIES POLLOCK.<br />
THE RIGHT HON. THE LORD BURGH. JEROME K. JEROME.<br />
E. ROSE.<br />
CLERE.<br />
J. Scott KELTIE, LL.D.<br />
W. BAPTISTE SCOONES.<br />
HALL CAINE.<br />
RUDYARD KIPLING.<br />
Miss FLORA L. SHAW.<br />
EGERTON CASTLE, F.S.A.<br />
PROF. E. RAY LANKESTER, F.R.S. G. R. SIMs.<br />
P. W. CLAYDEN.<br />
THE RIGHT HON. W. E. H. LECKY S. SQUIRE SPRIGGE.<br />
EDWARD CLODD.<br />
M.P.<br />
J. J. STEVENSON.<br />
W. MORRIS COLLES.<br />
J. M. LELY.<br />
FRANCIS STORR.<br />
THE HON. JOHN COLLIER.<br />
THE REV. W. J. LOFTIE, F.S.A.<br />
WILLIAM Moy THOMAS.<br />
SIR W. MARTIN CONWAY.<br />
Sir A. C. MACKENZIE, Mas.Doc. MRS. HUMPHRY WARD.<br />
F. MARION CRAWFORD.<br />
PROF. J. M. D. MEIKLEJOHN.<br />
Miss CHARLOTTE M. YONGB.<br />
THE Right Hon. THE LORD CURZON THE REV. C. H. MIDDLETON-WAKE.<br />
OF KEDLESTON.<br />
Hon. Counsel - E. M. UNDERDOWN, Q.C.<br />
COMMITTEE OF MANAGEMENT.<br />
Chairman-A, HOPE HAWKINS.<br />
A. W. A BECKETT.<br />
J. SCOTT KELTIE, LL.D.<br />
GILBERT PARKER.<br />
SIR WALTER BESANT.<br />
J. M. LELY.<br />
E. ROSE.<br />
EGERTON CASTLE, F.S.A.<br />
HENRY NORMAN.<br />
FRANCIS STORR.<br />
D. W. FRESHFIELD.<br />
'SUB-COMMITTEES.<br />
ART.<br />
Hon. JOHN COLLIER (Chairman). I SIR W. MARTIN CONWAY.<br />
M. H. SPIELMANN<br />
COPYRIGHT.<br />
A. W. À BECKETT.<br />
A. HOPE HAWKINS.<br />
J. M. LELY.<br />
W. M. COLLES.<br />
GILBERT PARKER.<br />
DRAMA.<br />
HENRY ARTHUR JONES (Chairman).<br />
F. C. BURNAND.<br />
A. W. PINERO.<br />
A. W. À BECKETT.<br />
: SYDNEY GRUNDY.<br />
EDWARD ROSE.<br />
Solicitors,<br />
FIELD, Roscoe, and Co., Lincoln's Inn Fields.<br />
C G. HERBERT THRING, 4, Portugal-street.<br />
Secretary-G. HERBERT THRING.<br />
OFFICES : 4, PORTUGAL STREET, LINCOLN'S INN FIELDS, W.C.<br />
A. P. WATT & SON,<br />
LITERARY AGENTS,<br />
Formerly of 2, PATERNOSTER SQUARE,<br />
Have now removed to<br />
HASTINGS HOUSE, NORFOLK STREET, STRAND,<br />
LONDON, W.C.<br />
THE KNIGHTS and KINGS of CHESS. By the Rev.<br />
GA. MACDONNELL, B.A. Price 28. 6d. net.<br />
London: HORACE Cox, Windsor House, Bream's-buildings, E.O.<br />
THE ART of CHESS. By JAMES MASON. Price 58.<br />
net, by post 58. 4d<br />
London: HORACE Cox, Windsor House, Broam's-buildings, E.C.<br />
|<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 61 (#91) ##############################################<br />
<br />
The El u tbor.<br />
(The Organ of the Incorporated Society of Authors. Monthly.)<br />
CONDUCTED BY WALTER BESANT.<br />
Vol. XI.-No. 4.]<br />
SEPTEMBER 1, 1900.<br />
[PRICE SIXPENCE.<br />
For the Opinions expressed in papers that are<br />
signed or initialled the Authors alone are<br />
responsible. None of the papers or para-<br />
graphs must be taken as expressing the<br />
collective opinions of the Committee unless<br />
they are officially signed by G. Herbert<br />
Thring, Sec.<br />
M HE Secretary of the Society begs to give notice that all<br />
1 remittances are acknowledged by return of post, and<br />
requests that all members not receiving an answer to<br />
important communications within two days will write to him<br />
without delay. All remittances should be crossed Union<br />
Bank of London, Chancery-lane, or be sent by registered<br />
letter only.<br />
(6.) Not to bind yourself for future work to any publisher.<br />
As well bind yourself for the future to any one solicitor or<br />
doctor!<br />
III. THE ROYALTY SYSTEM.<br />
It is above all things necessary to know what the<br />
proposed royalty means to both sides. It is now possible<br />
for an author to ascertain approximately and very nearly<br />
the truth. From time to time the very important figures<br />
connected with royalties are published in The Author.<br />
Readers can also work out the figures themselves from the<br />
“ Cost of Production."<br />
IV. A COMMISSION AGREEMENT.<br />
The main points are :-<br />
(1.) Be careful to obtain a fair cost of production.<br />
(2.) Keep control of the advertisements.<br />
(3.) Keep control of the sale price of the book.<br />
GENERAL<br />
All other forms of agreement are combinations of the four<br />
above mentioned<br />
Such combinations are generally disastrous to the author.<br />
Never sign any agreement without competent advice from<br />
the Secretary of the Society.<br />
Stamp all agreements with the Inland Revenue stamp.<br />
Avoid agreements by letter if possible.<br />
The main points which the Society has always demanded<br />
from the outset are :-<br />
(1.) That both sides shall know what an agreement<br />
means.<br />
(2.) The inspection of those account books which belong<br />
to the author. We are advised that this is a right, in the<br />
nature of a common law right, which cannot be denied or<br />
withheld.<br />
Communications and letters are invited by the Editor on<br />
all subjects connected with literature, but on no other sub-<br />
jocts whatever. Articles which cannot be accepted are<br />
returned if stamps for the purpose accompany the MSS.<br />
GENERAL MEMORANDA.<br />
WARNINGS TO DRAMATIC AUTHORS.<br />
TERE are a few standing rules to be observed in an<br />
agreement. There are four methods of dealing<br />
with literary property :-<br />
I. THAT OF SELLING IT OUTRIGHT.<br />
This is in some respects the most satisfactory, if a proper<br />
price can be obtained. But the transaction should be<br />
managed by a competent agent, or with the advice of the<br />
Secretary of the Society.<br />
II. A PROFIT-SHARING AGREEMENT (a bad form of<br />
agreement).<br />
In this case the following rules should be attended to:<br />
(1.) Not to sign any agreement in which the cost of pro-<br />
duction forms a part without the strictest investigation.<br />
(2.) Not to give the publisher the power of putting the<br />
profits into his own pocket by charging for advertisements<br />
in his own organs: or by charging exchange advertise.<br />
ments. Therefore keep control of the advertisements.<br />
(3.) Not to allow a special charge for " office expenses,"<br />
unless the same allowance is made to the author.<br />
(4.) Not to give up American, Colonial, or Continental<br />
rights.<br />
(5.) Not to give up serial or translation rights.<br />
VOL. XI.<br />
1. N EVER sign an agreement without submitting it to<br />
the Secretary of the Society of Authors or some<br />
competent legal authority.<br />
2. It is well to be extremely careful in negotiating for<br />
the production of a play with anyone except an established<br />
manager.<br />
3. There are three forms of dramatic contract for PLAYS<br />
IN THREE OR MORE ACTS :-<br />
(a.) SALE OUTRIGHT OF THE PERFORMING RIGHT.<br />
This is unsatisfactory. An author who enters<br />
into such a contract should stipulate in the con-<br />
tract for production of the piece by a certain date<br />
and for proper publication of his name on the<br />
play-bills.<br />
I 2<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 62 (#92) ##############################################<br />
<br />
62<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
(6.) SALE OF PERFORMING RIGHT OR OF A LICENCE Secretary will always be glad to have any agreements, new<br />
TO PERFORM ON THE BASIS OF PERCENTAGES or old, for inspection and note. The information thus<br />
on gross receipts. Percentages vary between obtained may prove invaluable.<br />
5 and 15 per cent. An author should obtain a 4. Before signing any agreement whatever, send the pro-<br />
porcentage on the sliding scale of gross receipts posed document to the Society for examination.<br />
in preference to the American system. Shoald 5. Remember always that in belonging to the Society you<br />
obtain a sum in advance of percentages. A fixed are fighting the battlos of other writers, even if you are<br />
date on or before which the play should be reaping no benefit to yourself, and that you are advancing<br />
performed.<br />
the best interests of literature in promoting the indepen.<br />
(c.) SALE OF PERFORMING RIGHT OR OF A LICENCE dence of the writer.<br />
TO PERFORM ON THE BASIS OF ROYALTIES (i.e., 6. The Committee have now arranged for the reception of<br />
fixed nightly fees). This method should be members' agreements and their preservation in a fireproof<br />
always avoided except in cases where the fees safe. The agreements will, of course, be regarded as con-<br />
are likely to be small or difficult to collect. The fidential documents to be read only by the Secretary, who<br />
other safeguards set out ander heading (b.) apply will keep the key of the safe. The Society now offers :-(1)<br />
also in this case.<br />
To read and advise upon agreements and publishers. (2) To<br />
4. PLAYS IN ONE ACT are often sold outright, but it is stamp agreements in readiness for a possible action upon<br />
better to obtain a small nightly fee if possible, and a sum them. (3) To keep agreements. (4) To enforce payments<br />
paid in advance of such fees in any event. It is extremely due according to agreements.<br />
important that the amateur rights of one act plays should<br />
be reserved<br />
5. Authors should remember that performing rights can<br />
be limited, and are usually limited by town, country, and<br />
THE READING BRANCH.<br />
time. This is most important.<br />
6. Authors should not assign performing rights, but M EMBERS will greatly assist the Society in this<br />
should grant a licence to perform. The legal distinction isM branch of their work by informing young writers of<br />
of great importance.<br />
its existence. Their MSS. can be read and treated<br />
7. Authors should remember that performing rights in a as a composition is treated by a coach. The term MSS.<br />
play are distinct from literary copyright. A manager includes not only works of fiction but poetry and dramatic<br />
holding the performing right or licence to perform cannot works, and when it is possible, under special arrangement,<br />
print the book of the words.<br />
technical and scientific works. The Readers are writers of<br />
8. Never forget that American rights may be exceedingly competence and experience. The fee is one guinea.<br />
valuable. They should never be included in English<br />
agreements without the author obtaining a substantial<br />
consideration.<br />
9. Agreements for collaboration should be carefully<br />
NOTICES.<br />
drawn and executed before collaboration is commenced.<br />
10. An author should remember that production of a play<br />
is highly speculative : that he runs a very great risk of<br />
M HE Editor of The Author begs to remind members of the<br />
delay and a breakdown in the fulfilment of his contract.<br />
I Society that, although the paper is sent to them free<br />
He should therefore guard himself all the more carefully in<br />
of charge, the cost of producing it would be a very<br />
the beginning.<br />
heavy charge on the resources of the Society if a great<br />
11. An author must remember that the dramatic market<br />
many members did not forward to the Secretary the modest<br />
is exceedingly limited, and that for a novice the first object<br />
68. 6d. subscription for the year.<br />
is to obtain adequate publication.<br />
Communications for The Author should be addressed to<br />
As these warnings must necessarily be incomplete on<br />
the Offices of the Society, 4, Portugal-street, Lincoln's-inn<br />
account of the wide range of the subject of dramatic con.<br />
Fields, W.C., and should reach the Editor not later than the<br />
tracts, those authors desirous of further information are<br />
21st of each month.<br />
referred to the Secretary of the Society.<br />
All persons engaged in literary work of any kind, whether<br />
members of the Society or not, are invited to communicate<br />
to the Editor any points connected with their work whicb<br />
it would be advisable in the general interest to publish.<br />
The present location of the Authors' Club is at 3, White.<br />
HOW TO USE THE SOCIETY.<br />
hall-court, Charing Cross. Address the Secretary for<br />
information, rules of admission, &c.<br />
T VERY member has a right to ask for and to receive<br />
advice upon his agreements, his choice of a pub.<br />
lisher, or any dispute arising in the conduct of his<br />
business or the administration of his property. If the<br />
LITERARY PROPERTY.<br />
advice sought is such as can be given best by a solici.<br />
tor, the member has & right to an opinion from the<br />
1.-ON TITLES.<br />
Society's solicitors. If the case is such that Counsel's<br />
opinion is desirable, the Committee will obtain for him<br />
WING to the fact that during the past two<br />
Counsel's opinion. All this without any cost to the member.<br />
or three months certain cases have been<br />
2. Remember that questions connected with copyright<br />
placed before the Secretary of the Society<br />
and publisher's agreoments do not generally fall within the of Authors touching the infringement of property<br />
experience of ordinary solicitors. Therefore, do not scruple in titles of hooice it he<br />
in titles of books, it has been thought well to<br />
to use the Society<br />
2. Send to the Office copies of past agreements and past repeat in substance, with certain additions, an<br />
accounts with the loan of the books represented. The article that appeared in The Author in 1898.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 63 (#93) ##############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
63<br />
• The first statement it is necessary to make is of the plaintiffs, which product was a well-known<br />
that, speaking generally, there is no copyright in marketable commodity.<br />
titles. This statement, however, cannot be taken In order to obtain this property, one or two<br />
as absolutely true, as in the case of “ Dick v. points therefore are clear :<br />
Yates," which went to the Court of Appeal, where (1) That the product must be actually selling<br />
the title“ Splendid Misery ” was under discussion, on the market and must bave established a posi.<br />
the Master of the Rolls made the following state. tion on the market by continuous sale.<br />
ment:<br />
(2) That products with similar names must be<br />
“Now I do not say that there could not be similar products.<br />
copyright in a title, as for instance in a whole This latter statement would appear self-evident<br />
page of title or something of that kind requiring if confusion had not frequently arisen in cases<br />
invention. However, it is not necessary to decide placed before the Secretary. For instance, a book<br />
that. But, assuming that there can be copyright of poems could not be confused with a philosophical<br />
in a title, what does copyright mean? It means treatise, nor a work of fiction with a book of<br />
the right to multiply copies of an original work. sermons, even though the names were the same.<br />
If you complain that a part of your work has There are also one or two minor points which<br />
been pirated you must show that that part is are very difficult of decision, and are too intricate<br />
original, and if it is not original you have no to be dealt with in a short article.<br />
copyright. How can the title . Splendid Misery' The case in the American court above referred<br />
be said to be original when the very same words to makes it clear that if the book is out of copy.<br />
for the very same purpose were used nearly eighty right, it does not follow there is no trade mark in<br />
years ago ?”<br />
the title. But with whom the right of commencing<br />
This case was fought out mainly on tae basis, an action would lie might need some ingenuity to<br />
“Is a title copyright, and the question of trade determine.<br />
mark law on which the right of property in a title A further point arises for consideration. When<br />
rests, though dealt with, was dealt with as a a book has been produced and is out of print, and<br />
secondary point. The reason for this course in the author is deliberating, or states that he is<br />
this particular case is clear on the facts as re- deliberating, about producing the second edition,<br />
ported. Those who desire the reason are referred how far would the author have the right of<br />
to the report.<br />
stopping the production of a similar book under a<br />
· Again, (1) speaking generally, it cannot be<br />
similar title ?<br />
said there is copyright in a title.<br />
Though each case must be decided on its<br />
(2) If there is copyright, then the title must<br />
separate facts and its separate peculiarities, the<br />
claim distinct originality.<br />
broad general rule would hold that as it was<br />
impossible to buy the first book in the open<br />
That, however, there is property in a title is<br />
market, it was impossible that any of the public<br />
quite clear, and the law bearing on the right of<br />
could be deceived, and therefore the production<br />
such property comes under, and is in some way<br />
of book No. 2 could not possibly be a fraud.<br />
analogous to, trade mark law, but titles cannot be This is an imo.<br />
This is an important point, as cases have been<br />
registered like trade marks.<br />
known to occur where authors have practically<br />
The real question to consider is whether the abandoned their book, their title, and their rights,<br />
infringement amounts to a common law fraud on but have tried to revive both on seeing another<br />
the public.<br />
book produced with a similar name.<br />
This is distinctly pointed out in the case which It might be useful to quote again a case that<br />
is printed in the August number of The Author, was quoted in a former article, as it illustrates<br />
to which the reader is referred. Although decided one or two of the most important points with<br />
in the American courts, it is a case of great regard to property in a title.<br />
importance, and brings into prominence the solid Messrs. Hogg in 1863 registered an intended<br />
principle on which this question rests. There the new magazine to be called Belgravia. In 1866,<br />
Chancellor of the University of Oxford obtained such magazine not having appeared, Mr. Maxwell,<br />
an injunction against the defendant for publish in ignorance of what Messrs. Hogg had done,<br />
ing a Bible termed the Oxford Bible, which was projected a magazine with the same name, and<br />
not the “ Oxford Bible” as known on the market incurred considerable expense in preparing it and<br />
and published by the Clarendon Press. The extensively advertising it in August and September<br />
plaintiffs could not possibly have any copyright as about to appear in October. Messrs. Hogg,<br />
either in the Bible or title, and this is the point it knowing of this, made hasty preparations for<br />
is desired to make especially clear, but the defen- bringing out their own magazine before that of<br />
dant had no right to sell a product as the product Mr. Maxwell could appear, and in the meantime<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 64 (#94) ##############################################<br />
<br />
64<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
accepted an order from Mr. Maxwell for adver- tory way of leaving the question. It gives more<br />
tising his (Mr. Maxwell's) magazine on the covers scope and adaptability, and prevents the stiffen-<br />
of their own publications; and the first day on ing that is often produced when a matter is<br />
which they informed Mr. Maxwell that they statute-bound.<br />
G. H. T.<br />
objected to his publishing a magazine under that<br />
name was Sept. 25, on which day the first number<br />
II.—COPYRIGHT IN SPEECHES.<br />
of Messrs. Hogg's magazine appeared. Mr. The House of Lords gave its decision on Aug. 6<br />
Maxwell's magazine appeared in October. Under in the appeal of Walter v. Lane, which referred<br />
these circumstances, on a bill filed by Mr. Maxwell, to the publication by Mr. John Lane in book form<br />
it was held that Mr. Maxwell's advertisements of nearly verbatim copies of Lord Rosebery's.<br />
and expenditure did not give him any exclusive speeches as they were reported in the Times. The<br />
right to the use of the name Belgravia, and that appellants, who sued on behalf of the proprietors<br />
he could not restrain Messrs. Hogg from publish of the Times, were granted an injunction by Mr.<br />
ing a magazine under the same name (the first Justice North, but he was reversed by the Court<br />
number appeared before Mr. Maxwell had pub- of Appeal (see report in The Author for Decem-<br />
lished his); and on a bill filed by Messrs. Hogg, ber last). Mr. Justice North's judgment has now<br />
that the registration by them of the title of an been restored by the House of Lords.<br />
intended publication could not confer upon them The following is a summary of the LORD<br />
a copyright in that name, and that in the circum. CHANCELLOR's opinion. We have to thank the<br />
stances of the case they had not acquired any editor of the Daily Chronicle for permission<br />
right to restrain Mr. Maxwell from using the to use their report: “I should very much<br />
name as being Messrs. Hogg's trade mark. regret if I were compelled to come to the con-<br />
This case was, contrary to “Dick v. Yates," clusion that the state of the law permitted one<br />
decided almost entirely on the aspect of the trade man to make profit and to appropriate to himself<br />
mark. Certain papers register titles, and pro- the labour, skill, and capital of another. And it<br />
duce periodically dummy copies in the hope of is not denied that in this case the defendant seeks<br />
obtaining some kind of property. Anyone who to appropriate to himself what has been produced<br />
has studied the question would at once know that by the skill, labour, and capital of others. In the<br />
this labour is wasted, and that this kind of pro- view I take of this case, I think the law is strong<br />
perty can only be claimed when a title has enough to restrain what, to my mind, would be a<br />
become associated with a certain commodity by a grievous injustice. The Copyright Act confers<br />
continued public circulation.<br />
what it calls 'copyright,' which means the right<br />
How can a paper of which one copy only is to multiply copies, which it confers on the authors<br />
published even every day claim to be such a of the books first published in this country. That<br />
public commodity ?<br />
the publication in question, namely, ' Reports of<br />
The contention is absurd.<br />
Lord Rosebery's Speeches,' are simply copies of<br />
From the most practical point of view, there what was first printed in the Times is not denied.<br />
fore, it is best for the author not to name the And further, it has not been, and cannot be, denied<br />
title of his book until his book is produced, if he that they were originally as in the Times, a sheet<br />
considers that there is any particular power in or sheets of letterpress, and came within the<br />
the words he is using.<br />
definition of the Act as a book. The speeches,<br />
Those who through personal experience have therefore, and the sheets of letterpress in which<br />
come across the question of title for the first they were contained, were books first published in<br />
time consider the matter as a difficulty but this country, and I confess, upon looking at the defi.<br />
recently discovered, which needs immediate nition and the right conferred, I am wholly unable<br />
amendment; they may, however, rest assured to discover why they are not protected by the statute<br />
that the question of legislating more fully on the from being pirated by unauthorised persons.<br />
point has been deeply and thoroughly discussed I do not understand the explanation the Court<br />
and considered by all those who have attempted of Appeal gives of the application of the word<br />
to legislate on copyright or who are interested in "author' to such publications as directories,<br />
the affairs of authorship. It is not a simple or red-books, maps, &c. If the maker of a direc-<br />
one-sided question. It is exceedingly complicated tory, red-book, or map is an author, one has to<br />
and has many sides.<br />
- analyse what the distinction between the author<br />
At present no remedy has been devised suffi. as thus referred to, and the author of a spoken<br />
ciently satisfactory to embody in any of the speech. If the producer of such a book can be<br />
Copyright Bills, and the solution of each case is an author within the meaning of the Act, I am<br />
based upon the common law. On the whole, it unable to understand why the labour of reproduc.<br />
may be considered that this is the most satisfac- ing spoken words into writing or print and first<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 65 (#95) ##############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
65<br />
publishing it as a book does not make the person qualities, but because, as I have endeavoured to<br />
who has so acted as much an author as the person point out, neither the one nor the other are con.<br />
who writes down the names and addresses of the ditions precedent to the right created by the<br />
persons who live in a particular street. The judg. statute. That right, in my view, is given by the<br />
ment of the Court of Appeal rests solely on the statute to the first producer of a book, whether<br />
use of the word "author,' and I cannot help that book be wise or foolish, accurate or inaccurate,<br />
thinking that some confusion has been created of literary merit or of no merit whatever. It is<br />
between two very different things. One, the said that in the view I have suggested there would<br />
proprietary right of every man in his own lite. be as many copyrights as reporters. I do not see<br />
rary composition, and the other the copyright, the difficulty. Each reporter is entitled to report,<br />
that is to say, the exclusive privilege of making and each undoubtedly would have a copyright in<br />
copies created by the statute. The question is his own published report. But where is the<br />
solely whether this book (to use the language difficulty ? Suppose à favourite view—a dozen<br />
of the statute), printed and published and exist. artists take independently their own representa-<br />
ing as a book for the first time, can be copied tion of it. Is there any reason why each should not<br />
by someone else than the producer of it, by those have his own copyright, or even a photograph,<br />
who have not produced it themselves, but have where each photograph is taken from the same<br />
simply copied that which others have laboured to point, and in the same state of the light, would<br />
create by their own skill and expenditure. It is be identical in all respects. There is, of course,<br />
admitted, apparently, by the Court of Appeal no copyright in the view itself, but in the supposed<br />
(and, indeed, insisted on as part of the reasons picture or photograph there is. It may be there<br />
for their judgment) that the owner of an unpub. is a confusion of thought between the difficulty<br />
lished manuscript, although not the author of it, of proof of the piracy and the existence of piracy.<br />
acquires copyright in it by first publishing it. There, as I have said before, no such difficulty<br />
And I observe that it is said Lord Rosebery had arises, since it is admitted that the report of<br />
no copyright in his speech, and, although he these speeches is not the result of independent<br />
could have acquired copyright in it by putting it labour, but is taken from the Times. I think<br />
into writing and printing and publishing it, he the judgment of Mr. Justice North was right,<br />
did not do so. Here, again, the implied proposi. and that the only answer sought to be given to it<br />
tion is that the only person who could gain copy. by the Court of Appeal was the restricted use of<br />
right in his speech is the person who spoke it, the word author' with which I have endea-<br />
and that the word original must by construc- voured to deal. I, therefore, move your Lord.<br />
tion be read into the statute—that the true ships that the judgment of the Court of Appeal<br />
analogy is the true and first inventor of the be reversed with costs, and the judgment of Mr.<br />
Patent Laws. I think the analogy is a false one. Justice North restored."<br />
But if it were strictly pursued I think it would Lords Davey, James of Hereford, and Bramp-<br />
not be favourable to the defendant. An importer ton concurred, but Lord Robertson differed, hold.<br />
of a foreign invention is, for the purpose of the ing that, however skilful or well qualified a<br />
Patent Laws, an inventor, and, as Lord Brougham reporter might be, he could not be considered an<br />
said, there were two species of public benefactors author within the meaning of the Act.<br />
-the one, “those who benefit the public by their The injunction to restrain the publication was<br />
ingenuity, industry and science, and invention made perpetual, and the respondents ordered to<br />
and personal capability; the other, those who pay costs.<br />
benefit the public without any inçenuity or inven-<br />
tion of their own by the appropriation of the<br />
III.—MERIVALE v. HARVEY.<br />
results of foreign inventions. Now, the latter is This case has come before the Court of Appeal.<br />
a benefit to the public incontestably, and therefore The plaintiff, Mr. Herman Merivale, agreed to<br />
they renderthemselves entitled to be put upon some. write for the defendant, Mr. Martin Harvey,<br />
what if not entirely the same footing as inventors. a play connected with the exploits of Don<br />
I might paraphrase Lord Brougham's language Juan. Disputes arose with regard to the pro-<br />
by asking whether those who preserve the duction of the play and the plaintiff's fees,<br />
memory of spoken words which are assumed to be and eventually the plaintiff brought the action,<br />
of value to the public are not entitled to the claiming damages from the defendant for his<br />
analogous merit which Lord Brougham attributes breach of contract in refusing to accept the play.<br />
to the importer of foreign inventions ? I have The defence was a denial of the contract, and the<br />
not insisted upon the skill and accuracy of those submission that the non-fulfilment was brought<br />
who produce in writing or print spoken about by the plaintiff's own conduct. Defendant's<br />
words. It is not because I think the less of those counter-claim was for damages for alleged libel,<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 66 (#96) ##############################################<br />
<br />
66<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
which was contained in a letter written by plain sittings awakened much enthusiasm. “Let us<br />
tiff to Mr. Acton Bond. The jury (see The honour and féte Joseph Lister," wrote Dr. de<br />
Author for June) found a verdict for the plaintiff Fleury on the morrow of the banquet given in<br />
on the claim for £500 damages, and with regard the British savant's honour by the Medical<br />
to the counter-claim they found there was no Faculty of Paris ; " ..innovators who<br />
libel. The defendant now appealed.<br />
bring about such complete and magnificent<br />
Sir Edward Clarke, in the course of his argu- upheavals in the sphere of our activity are rare.<br />
ment, said he would agree, in order to avoid a new The work of this scientific son of the great<br />
trial on the counter-claim, that Mr. Merivale Pasteur is of incalculable import; scientific<br />
should submit to a verdict against him in regard surgery dates from him."<br />
to the alleged libel for £50.-Mr. Chambers said As to the Philosophy Congress, a full report of<br />
if this order was coupled with a withdrawal of all communications read therein will shortly be<br />
all imputations on the defendant he would accept published in four volumes respectively entitled :<br />
it.—Sir E. Clarke assented to this, and the court « (1) Philosophie générale et metaphysique; (2)<br />
gave judgment for the plaintiff on the claim for Morale; (3) Logique et Histoire des Sciences;<br />
£500, and for the defendant on the counter. (4) Histoire de la Philosophie." Subscriptions<br />
claim for £50. There were to be no costs of the for the same are being received by the secretary,<br />
appeal.<br />
M. Xavier Léon, 5, rue de Mezières, Paris. Great<br />
poco<br />
Britain is represented on the list of the Honorary<br />
Committee of the Philosophy Congress by the<br />
PARIS LETTER.<br />
names of MM. Balfour, Herbert Spencer, and<br />
Stirling.<br />
4, rue des Beaux Arts.<br />
NHE great Exhibition is, financially, a failure.<br />
A PRODIGIOUS IMAGINATION.<br />
I Nevertheless, congresses, lectures, and The great Balzac was not particularly successful<br />
soirées de gala abound. The extraordi. as a dramatist. Undeterred by this fact, an enter-<br />
nary alternations of the thermometer appear prising playwright has already announced a new<br />
merely to affect the attendance—not the duration play taken from “ Cousin Pons," the copyright<br />
—of the various ceremonies. The seventh Inter of the Balzacian novels having expired on the<br />
national Press Congress (which has, I believe, twentieth of last month. M. Gémier is consider-<br />
chiefly occupied itself in discussing the reduction ing a three-act play, adapted from “ Colonel<br />
of the postal tariff on printed matter and the Chabert" by M. Louis Forest; and several other<br />
minimum fee for Press dispatches) was inaugu. stage-writers are likewise busy in exploiting the<br />
rated under the presidency of M. William Singer, great “Comédie Humaine," which promises to<br />
proprietor of the Neues Wiener Tagblatt, and prove a second El Dorado to needy and skilful<br />
president of the committee of the Central Bureau adapters in search of thrilling situations. The<br />
of Press Associations. Prior to the invariable fertility of Balzac's imagination was extraordinary.<br />
shower of compliments with which each orator In this respect he was never surpassed. The<br />
considers it necessary to asperge the Exhibition, following anecdote (vouched for by M. Barré)<br />
M. Singer explained the object of the present attests the truth of almost incredible narratives<br />
congress.<br />
extant on the subject :<br />
“We have desired," said he, “by an inter. On one occasion, having promised M. Lireux,<br />
national organisation to offer our contribution to manager of the Odéon, a five-act drama, entitled<br />
the advent of concord—if not among the nations - Les Ressources de Quinola,” Balzac duly<br />
themselves, at least among those who form the van appeared at the appointed hour, and-leaning<br />
guard of every people, viz., the journalists. ... carelessly against a window—unhesitatingly read<br />
Thus we have decided to organise a great inter to the committee the promised five acts. After<br />
national fraternity composed of important Press the usual compliments and congratulations<br />
associations, a literary Red Cross union ... had been exchanged, M. Lireux proceeded to<br />
based upon mutual respect and firmly bound examine the manuscript, and found merely four<br />
together by the community of professional acts written—the pages devoted to the fifth act<br />
interests." About 400 persons were present at being still blank. He immediately informed<br />
the inaugural meeting. The tragic death of Balzac of his discovery. The great writer was in<br />
the Italian king prevented the attendance of the no wise disconcerted.<br />
French President.<br />
" It is true,” he blandly acknowledged, “ that I<br />
BRITISH SAVANTS.<br />
have not yet written my fifth act, but I have it<br />
A propos of the International Medical Congress, so well in my head that I am able to repeat it<br />
the appearance of Lord Lister to attend its precisely as if I read it from the manuscript.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 67 (#97) ##############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
67<br />
Besides, I have two other dénouements quite against any subsequent accusation of plagiarism.<br />
ready-in case you are not satisfied with the one The sensible verdict given by the Third Civil<br />
I have just recited to you!”<br />
Chamber a short time ago re the dispute between<br />
We doubt if the dying century can boast a two well-known dramatic authors–MM. Lecocq<br />
similar “record” memory.<br />
and Bisson-is largely responsible for this com-<br />
mendable state of affairs. The chamber pro-<br />
MM. FRANCE AND LOTI.<br />
nounced in the defendant's favour, declaring that<br />
That modern classic, M. Anatole France, is the plaintiff had done his comrade a grave injury,<br />
engaged on a new play entitled “La Gerbe," and one meriting compensation, in thus publicly<br />
destined for the Porte Saint-Martin Theatre. accusing him of plagiarism. It also expressed<br />
This will be M. France's second contribution to its opinion that “the author who knows<br />
the Parisian stage. The brilliant Academician's how to digest the works of others; who knows<br />
name first adorned the theatrical posters in 1899 how to assimilate them in his brain; who, later,<br />
in connection with “Le Lys Rouge,” which was at the moment when he wishes to originate in<br />
highly praised—but hardly popular. M. France his turn, sees them in consequence awake in his<br />
visited London last March. The 'impression imagination; who allows them to mingle in.<br />
left on his mind is scarcely favourable. He sensibly with his own conceptions; that author-<br />
considers the Londoners' enthusiasm automatic, very far from then meriting the reproach of<br />
their loyal demonstrations lacking in warmth, plagiarism-only draws from his reminiscences<br />
richness, spontaneity. The decorations in our the legitimate recompense of a meritorious employ<br />
capital show the puerility of the national taste. of his faculties.”<br />
Even our Rubens' are less powerful than those in For which and other reasons the Third Civil<br />
the Louvre.<br />
Chamber acquitted M. Bisson, ordering the inser.<br />
Nor is M. Pierre Loti a great lover of our race. tion of its judgment in three papers at the plain-<br />
In the description of his Eastern travels lately tiff's expense. Whereby it considerably lightened<br />
published by the Figaro, he expressly states that its future labours.<br />
the harrowing account he gives of the rarages<br />
made by the famine in India is not intended as a<br />
“Gyp” (COMTESSE DE MARTEL).<br />
sinister attack on “nos ennemis les Anglais,” but The novels of “Gyp,” great-niece of Mirabeau,<br />
merely as a new appeal to their charity. At the are highly popular here. Twelve editions of her<br />
present moment M. Pierre Loti-otherwise M. le “Trop de Chic” are reported to have been dis-<br />
capitaine de frégate Viaud—is en route for China, posed of in three days. Her late extraordinary<br />
serving on board the Redoutable as first aide-de- adventure—or hallucination — has proved an<br />
camp to Admiral Pottier. He has already written excellent expedient for whetting public curiosity<br />
several spirited and pathetic sketches dealing anew. At the present moment the sale of “Le<br />
with heroic combats between the French sailor and Journal d'Une qui s'en fiche” bids fair to equal,<br />
the cruel, dastardly Chinese. He will probably if not surpass, that of the most favoured of its<br />
add to these pages on his return. Nor is it impos predecessors. The pages of an ancient confes-<br />
sible that his present experiences may lead to a sional album have given us the following infor-<br />
modification of his opinion re the Britisher abroad. mation respecting the countess' private sentiments<br />
and inclinations.<br />
A SENSIBLE DECISION.<br />
Her favourite occupation is riding; her<br />
Several dramatists have recently notified in the favourite food and drink are fruit and milk.<br />
daily papers a similarity existing between the Solitude forms her beau-ideal of happiness, while<br />
plots or titles of their half-finished productions the principal defect of her nature is her too con.<br />
with those of their brethren of the pen. Amongst fiding disposition. The ass is her favourite<br />
others, M. Lemonnier stated in an open letter animal; the sparrow, her favourite bird. Her<br />
that he bad been engaged for the last year (in · greatest misfortune would be a long life, and she<br />
collaboration with M. Burani) on a four-act considers simplicity the most desirable quality in<br />
play entitled “La Marquise de Pompadour,” a woman. The character of M. Thiers inspires<br />
destined for Réjane. Suddenly he discovers that her with the deepest aversion, her principal trait<br />
M. Emile Bergerat is also engaged in writing a being — ne pas “m'gober" !' Maupassant is<br />
• Pompadour” for Mlle. Bartet. He immediately her favourite prose author; Heine, Baudelaire,<br />
announces the fact in the papers, and the matter and Bouchor are her favourite poets. Berlitz,<br />
ends there. M. Paul Souday has drawn up the Saint Saëns, and Offenbach, are the composers<br />
rough skeleton of a new play when he makes she prefers; while the military feat of arms she<br />
an almost similar discovery. He forthwith most admires is – the Rape of the Sabine<br />
employs the same method of protecting himself Women!<br />
VOL. XI.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 68 (#98) ##############################################<br />
<br />
68<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
· Was the latter penchant a presentiment ? asks<br />
BOOKSELLER 1. STORE.<br />
her witty comrade, Sergines.<br />
The booksellers attribute their troubles to the<br />
APROPOS OF M. ZOLA.<br />
big “ department" stores. They say that so long<br />
Two revivals of plays drawn from this<br />
as books are sold in department stores at prices<br />
author's works (“L'Assommoir” and “ Le<br />
with which the regular bookseller finds it impos-<br />
Rêve") are now being rehearsed—the first at<br />
sible to compete, the regular tradesman cannot<br />
keep his doors open. Take the case, for example,<br />
the Porte-Saint-Martin Theatre, the second at<br />
the Opéra Comique. “La Sorcière” of M.<br />
of an enormously popular novel called “ Richard<br />
Carvel.” “Richard Carvel” was put on the market<br />
Victorien Sardou (who has just been created<br />
by the Appletons to be sold at retail at one dollar<br />
grand officer of the Legion of Honour) has been<br />
accepted by Mme. Sarah Bernhardt; M. de<br />
and fifty cents. The price at the department<br />
Porto Riche is engaged on two new plays, re-<br />
stores was one dollar and fourteen cents (45. 7d.),<br />
spectively destined for the Comédie Française and<br />
and in some it was sold at eighty-one cents<br />
the Vaudeville; and M. Maurice Donnay is like-<br />
(38. 4şd.), which is the publisher's wholesale price.<br />
wise completing a four-act play for the latter<br />
Now, many of the retailers could not buy in<br />
sufficiently large quantities to enable them to<br />
theatre. M. Jean Richepin has written an his-<br />
torical drama, entitled “La Du Barry," for Mme.<br />
obtain the book at the lowest wholesale price, and<br />
Leslie Carter M. Belasco is responsible for its<br />
as for selling it at eighty-one cents, the proposi.<br />
translation into English.<br />
tion was absurd. Of course, the retailer does not<br />
DARRACOTTE SCOTT.<br />
encounter this difficulty in the sale of every book<br />
on his list, but this condition alone cuts him off<br />
from his readiest source of profit.<br />
It is now for the publishers to determine<br />
whether they can afford to help the regular<br />
AMERICAN LETTER.<br />
retailers at the expense, if necessary, of the<br />
jobbers. One proposed plan is to fix a net retail<br />
New York City, Aug. 13. price for all books published by members of the<br />
CYO ready are the people of these States to cry association. From this price the retailer would<br />
out in horror against any combination of get a certain discount, but before he was permitted<br />
capital, that the recently formed Publishers' to buy a copy of the book he would be required<br />
Association was bitterly pronounced a trust by to agree not to sell any copies at retail for less than<br />
Press and public, and anathematised as an unboly the price stipulated. “In fixing the stipulated<br />
thing. As a matter of fact it would be about as price it would be put at such a figure as experi.<br />
easy to form a “trust” of book publishers as it ence has taught should yield a fair profit to the<br />
has been to communicate with the Legations at retailer of conservative business methods. This<br />
Peking. The essential nature of the business pre- plan would apply only to the publications issued<br />
cludes it. Another wild story concerning the after the plan is adopted; no attempt under it<br />
Publishers' Association ran to the effect that the would be made to regulate the price of old<br />
object of the movement was to reduce the royal publications."<br />
ties and other compensation paid to authors in the Such a scheme would carry the benefit to the<br />
future. This report occasioned so much concern author which always is the producer's when a<br />
that it seemed worth while to the officers of the uniform and fair price is maintained for the<br />
association to disclaim any such unreasonable product.<br />
and absurd motive.<br />
A SCHEME TO REGULATE PRICES.<br />
The real causes of the formal banding together But no bridge yet has been crossed, and the<br />
of American publishers are interesting and in- American Publishers' Association is little more<br />
structive. The association owes its being to the than organised. Mr. Charles Scribner is the<br />
earnest appeals on the part of the retail book- president, Messrs. A. C. McClurg and George<br />
sellers all over the country that the publishers Mifflin are the vice-presidents, Mr. George P.<br />
should try to change existing conditions in the Brett is the secretary, and Col. G. B. M. Harvey<br />
trade so that the retailers could make a living the treasurer. The experiment will be watched<br />
For the past half a dozen years the retailer over with interest. Will the organisation stray from<br />
here has been losing money. His plight has now its present avowed path, and if so, to what end ?<br />
reached a pass where the publisher must act or Will it fall to pieces of its own weight, as similar<br />
the bookseller must close out his business. The organisations have done before it? Whatever the<br />
publishers therefore have organised themselves for outcome, this action of the publishers is certainly<br />
the purpose of helping the men who make it of the greatest significance in our American book<br />
possible for a publishing house to exist.<br />
world, and pregnant with engaging possibilities,<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 69 (#99) ##############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
ho<br />
Along this line a further consideration presents Byron's Profession.'” Mr. Shaw continued : “ It<br />
itself. The encouragement of the retail book. seems to me that the principle involved is worth<br />
seller means the promotion of the reading of affirming by an English author in the only way<br />
better books. A lamentable result of our trade which will convey any solid impression of his<br />
conditions here has been that it is difficult to find being in earnest-namely, when he stands to lose<br />
a good assortment of good books in the retail by it. On the other hand, as American pub-<br />
shop. The dealers, owing to the general cutting lishers as a body have been repeatedly accused<br />
of prices, are all for ephemeral « leaders,” and by Englishmen of letters of "pirating' copy-<br />
they are actually unable to handle works of more rights-an imaginary offence, as that which does<br />
solid merit. Through some reasonable regulation not exist cannot be stolen-it is well that they<br />
of prices the interests of good literature may be too should have a printed instance on record in<br />
furthered so that dealers will be enabled to offer which that viow has been repudiated from this<br />
their customers a wider range of choice. It may side of the Atlantic.”<br />
be that the whole tone of the bookselling trade One need not comment. Harper and Brothers<br />
will be correspondingly raised. This is, at least, refused to accept even this as the proper conclu.<br />
a pleasant picture not only to the buyers of the sion of the correspondence, and so, as a solution<br />
best books, but also to the writers of them.<br />
to the singular deadlock, the honorarium was<br />
finally turned over to the American Copyright<br />
MR. SHAW AND £10.<br />
League, where, let us hope, it rests peacefully<br />
We are talking here over a correspondence, just after its fitful wanderings.<br />
made public, between Mr. Bernard Shaw and the<br />
house of Harper and Brothers. In November BIBLIOGRAPHY OF AMERICAN LITERATURE.<br />
of last year Mr. Shaw offered to return to the The English Bibliographical Society has many<br />
publishers an honorarium of ten pounds which American members, but not one of them has<br />
the publishers, in the eighties, had sent to the ever read a paper at the society's meetings or<br />
author in consideration of such moral claim as contributed a monograph for publication under<br />
he could give them on “Cashel Byron's Pro. its auspices. It is therefore with some gratifica-<br />
fession.” Mr. Shaw was of opinion that this sum tion that we note a strong plea, made in a<br />
should be repaid because a new edition of the magazine article by Mr. Josephson, of Chicago,<br />
novel had since been issued by Messrs. Brentano, for an endowed bibliographical institute here.<br />
of New York, and because the "moral claim” The purpose is to be the preparation of a biblio.<br />
was worth nothing from the date of the Brentano graphy covering the entire field of American<br />
publication. And then he went on to say: "I literature. At the last meeting of the American<br />
entirely disagree with the ideas of twenty years Library, held at Montreal during July, a com-<br />
ago as to the piratical' nature of American mittee reported favourably upon Mr. Josephson's<br />
republications of non-copyright books. Unlike scheme, which is, briefly, a co-operative cata-<br />
most authors, I am enough of an economist to loguing of the various public libraries in this<br />
know that unless an American publisher acquires country. The editing and publishing, as well<br />
copyright he can no more make a profit at my as the scientific direction, of the work would be<br />
expense than he can at Shakespeare's by repub- in the hands of the staff of the proposed biblio.<br />
lishing ‘Hamlet.' The English, when taxed for graphical institute. The realisation of this<br />
the support of the author by a price which plan would surely be acclaimed by English<br />
includes author's royalties, whilst the American speaking readers everywhere, and the results of<br />
nation escapes that burden, may have a grievance such an achievement can hardly be estimated.<br />
against the American nation; but that is a very<br />
John RUSSELL DAVIDSON.<br />
different matter from a grievance against the<br />
American publisher."<br />
The Messrs. Harper were so impressed by this<br />
illumination that they politely declined to retain<br />
the ten pounds; they thought that they had no<br />
NOTES AND NEWS.<br />
right to it. Mr. Shaw, in reply, insisted that<br />
"though you are good enough to say that you N interesting correspondence on the“ Manu.<br />
have no right to it, it is clear that I have no<br />
facture of a Series” has been recently<br />
right to it—and, indeed, never had—though I Ane published in the Athenæum. The author<br />
have ingeniously excused myself from paying you concerned pointed out that he was offered a sum<br />
interest on it, on the ground that the moral of money down—say £50—and after 5000 copies<br />
right' it secured you was respected up to the had been sold, the handsome royalty of a farthing<br />
date of Messrs. Brentano's reprint of Cashel a copy. The price of the book was 18. He<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 70 (#100) #############################################<br />
<br />
70<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
refused indignantly. The editor, however, made but for recreation, we ought surely to be satis-<br />
haste to point out that the price originally con- fied when we hear that they buy the standard<br />
templated was 6d., not is., and that the royalty authors first and fiction next.<br />
would be increased. It does not appear what the<br />
increase really meant. Now, the small sum down,<br />
The extracts from the New York paper, read<br />
followed by the small royalty, after a large sale,<br />
with the remarks of our New York correspondent<br />
has become quite a common offer. Its applica-<br />
on the question of the American Publishers'<br />
tion to a “series,” of which there are so many, is<br />
Association, are of great interest to authors on this<br />
in this way. One or two men, ignorant or vain,<br />
side of the Atlantic. We shall perhaps learn more<br />
are induced to give in their names as contributors<br />
about the work of the Association. Meuntime,<br />
on certain miserable terms. The names are used<br />
it is a pity that the Booksellers of the United<br />
as an inducement to get other well-known men States cannot form their own Association and<br />
to contribute. The sum paid down in advance<br />
manage their business for themselves.<br />
of royalties for each volume of the series<br />
is in many cases absurdly small. That it is<br />
so small is due mainly to the vanity of the<br />
Some of the booksellers are trying to get more<br />
authors, who think themselves honoured and<br />
net books. This is exactly what I expected. The<br />
their reputation advanced by figuring as con.<br />
partial surrender of the Englishman's liberty to<br />
tributors to a twopenny and an unsuccessful<br />
manage his business his own way is leading to<br />
series. The sum of £50 down and a farthing more complete subjection. Since the booksellers<br />
after 5000 copies have been sold is quite muni have been unable to use their own association for<br />
ficent. Of course, when the initial cost has been the regulation of their own trade, they will desire<br />
repaid, the cost of the book is very small indeed, more and more to put their necks under the yoke.<br />
so that the farthing is a hollow mockery. The<br />
Let it be remarked that booksellers seem to be<br />
deferred royalty is, in fact, now being used like the only class unable to associate for trade<br />
the old “ half-profit” method as the easiest way purposes.<br />
to escape paying the author anything and to get Of course, publishers will be very ready to yield<br />
his property for nothing. Let it be understood to pressure so long as the proposed restrictions<br />
plainly that if the royalty is deferred until the are in their own interest; so long as they think<br />
cost of production is paid it should be explained the public will support them; and so long as<br />
at the outset what this cost means, and the<br />
they are allowed by authors to manage the<br />
royalty, when commenced, must be at least half the business for their own profit. The Association<br />
trade price of the book for the rest of the edition.<br />
of Booksellers, if it would only realise the con-<br />
ditions, is in complete command of the situation.<br />
A bookseller has been lamenting, to a represen. It may fix the trade price wbich it will consent to<br />
tative of the Daily Chronicle, the deplorable run pay publishers : it may fix the discount if it<br />
upon fiction. He says that people buy nothing chooses, or, if it prefers, it may leave it to any<br />
else. He also savs, in the same breath. that bookseller to charge the public just what he<br />
everybody buys the English standard authors. pleases. I rejoice to see that Literature remains<br />
Well, but if the latter proposition is true, what sound and firm upon the point: “There certainly<br />
about the former? Granted that the public does not seem to be any reason to expect that<br />
buy the standard authors, they have on their enduring advantage will result from interference<br />
shelves a good corpus of literature: enough to with the competitive tendencies of human nature<br />
last them all their lives : they need not go out in the book trade, any more than in the trade in<br />
side their own shelves at all. What else should bicycles, in boots, in patent medicines, or any<br />
they buy but fiction ? Poetry? The general other commodities.” It is, indeed, obvious that<br />
public has never greatly cared for new poetry. the attempted system of slavish subjection cannot<br />
Essays? There are a few writers-e.g., Louis long continue. It is as impossible for publishers<br />
Stevenson and Augustine Birrell—whose essays to dictate the terms of the retailers' dealings with<br />
are bought and read : the greater number of<br />
the public as for manufacturers of cottons or of<br />
essayists appeal only to scholars. Scientific any other produce. The partial success that has<br />
books? They are bought by scientific men. hitherto seemed to attend the attempt is only<br />
Sermons and religious books? They also are illusory. Being interpreted, it means nothing<br />
bought by religious people, especially Noncon- but the despair, and perhaps also the indebted-<br />
formists. Books of travel, history, biography ? ness, of a decaying trade.<br />
They are mostly too dear. Of philosophy ? They<br />
are above the comprehension of the people. When In Literature of July 28 is a list of thirty-four<br />
we consider also that people read, not for study, novels by the most popular novelists of the day<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 71 (#101) #############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
71<br />
which are announced or understood to be forth. The decision of the House of Lords in the case<br />
coming this autumn. The names of J. M. Barrie of Walter v. Lane has been received with a good<br />
and Conan Doyle are not among them. As deal of difference in opinion. One point cannot<br />
regards the latter there is very good reason for be denied : the report of a speech represents the<br />
his silence. One or two names have since been special expenditure of money and work by the<br />
added to the list. It does not seem, therefore, at proprietors of the paper. It is reasonable at least<br />
first as if the prospects of the season were so very that this special expenditure should be recognised<br />
bad after all. At the same time it must be and respected. The report of a speech, again, is<br />
remembered that in all seasons there is a demand its publication by tacit permission of the author.<br />
for the popular novelist. It is the novel that is He grants this permission to any newspaper<br />
not so much in demand—the novel by the new wbich will go to the expense of paying a reporter<br />
hand, or by the hand which, so far, has shown to take down his words. This understanding is a<br />
promise only—that will suffer by the bad season. kind of agreement. The right of the paper is,<br />
If war does harm to the bookseller, then we have however, now established. Perhaps, if the new<br />
three wars on hand : and the Americans have Copyright Bill is allowed next year to pass, it will<br />
two. But there will be, in all probability, a contain clauses for copyright in news, as well as in<br />
General Election here : and in America there will reported speeches and reports of all kinds. Once<br />
be a Presidential Election. It will surely be the law is established there will be no more diffi-<br />
common prudence to keep back doubtful.books, culties of this kind. It is quite as bad that news<br />
or books whose subjects are out of harmony with obtained at enormous expense should become<br />
the excitement and rush of politics, until the common property as soon as it is published as<br />
elections are over-i.e., until the beginning of the that the report of a speech should be considered<br />
new year. It needs no prophetic spirit to common property.' _<br />
perceive that from the moment of the dissolution<br />
of Parliament to the conclusion of the General I have before me a communication from Miss<br />
Election in this country and from the present to Betham Edwards to the editor of “ M. A. P.,” in<br />
the Presidential Election of the United States which that lady laments over the good old time<br />
there will be nothing heard but the voice of the when there were such cordial relations between<br />
candidate, the roaring of the multitude, and the author and publisher, and the latter was so<br />
exaggerations and distortions of the party courteous and so generous, and invited the poor<br />
speaker.<br />
author to dinner sometimes, as one invites the<br />
poor relation. The paper proves the strength of<br />
A new monthly magazine, the Monthly Review, old traditions. The author formerly was by no<br />
is to be commenced this month by the house of means too proud to be the recipient of the pub-<br />
Murray. Their last venture into the field of lisher's “generosity," which has now become a<br />
monthly magazines was not, apparently, a word of degradation. The relations were cordial<br />
success. The editor of this new venture will be because the author placed his property unre-<br />
Mr. Henry Newbolt, who will be responsible for servedly and without any nasty conditions, and<br />
unsigned" editorials ” which are to form part of without inquiry as to its value, in the hands of<br />
each number. The rest of the magazine will be the publisher. “Take my work," he said to<br />
like the other reviews. It is quite possible that the publisher, who, noble-hearted creature, was<br />
the editor will be able to impress his own person. only too ready to respond in sympathetic vein.<br />
ality upon the editorials, in which case the “Take my work. It is very likely a mine of<br />
success of the review will be assured. Nothing gold. Take it. Give me whatever you please :<br />
belps a paper more than the belief in the power you are always generosity itself. I am very poor.<br />
the principle, and the integrity, of one man. It I am glad and thankful for anything. What?<br />
was the strong personal element in the Spectator In two figures ? Oh! Large-hearted, generous<br />
that created the success of the paper. The patron of literature ! You will ruin yourself in<br />
Cornhill flourished while Thackeray held it. your kindness to the poor author! And a dinner<br />
Other examples might be quoted, but they would as well, at your own hospitable' table—in the<br />
be too personal. As regards the signed articles bosom of your amiable family? With a glass of<br />
they will at least enlarge the field for authors. wine, just as if I was your equal, one of your<br />
There are plenty of capable writers on every ordinary friends ? Too much! It is too much!”<br />
conceivable subject, but on any one subject But Miss Betham Edwards is quite wrong in<br />
there are only two or three writers--perhaps considering that golden age as lost beyond<br />
only one — capable of presenting the subject recovery. The time of confidence and of depen-<br />
attractively. I wish Mr. Newbolt every possible dence is not by any means rendered impossible<br />
success....<br />
· by the Authors' Society or by any syndicate.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 72 (#102) #############################################<br />
<br />
72<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
The author has only to go back to the old con- coupon conferring benefits on young writers, ten<br />
ditions. He must not presume to ask what his times more valuable than the price of the book.”<br />
property means, or what the man who so gene- What can those benefits be ?<br />
rously relieves him of it makes out of it. There If the book contains the whole art of author.<br />
are many publishers living who would be willing ship, what remains ? Something ten times more<br />
to forget and forgive the cruel suspicions of the valuable than the price of the book. That is to<br />
day, and to go back to the old happy conditions. say, ten half-crowns, or £1 58. What is the valu.<br />
Let those who lament the past remember that it able article which can be purchased for 258.? It<br />
is always in their power to restore it. The past must be something useful to the young author-<br />
may come back again, with the courtesy so dear a pair of boots, perhaps, or a silk umbrella.<br />
to the feminine heart, and the tact and good Whatever it is, we thank the spirited and<br />
feeling which prompt the publisher not to speak reverend donor for this spontaneous gift to the<br />
about figures-sordid things !--and fill him with literary profession. We need, it is true, all we<br />
ruinous generosity and the author with tearful can get.<br />
gratitude. Let everyone who laments the past The third appearance of the Rev. J. Meldrum<br />
take these simple steps to recover and to re Dryerre is as an editor. He has already, it<br />
store it.<br />
WALTER BESANT. seems, conveyed into port a barque containing<br />
twenty stories by twenty writers, which can be<br />
obic<br />
had for the ridiculously small charge of 38. 6d.<br />
ANOTHER BENEFACTOR.<br />
The method pursued is as follows :-<br />
1. The stories are not to be more than 2000<br />
TT is now some time since an opportunity was<br />
words in length.<br />
1 afforded us of bringing to notice any of the<br />
2. Each author, if his story is accepted,<br />
benevolent methods by which earnest and<br />
becomes responsible for £1 58. Is it a coin-<br />
disinterested. vessels offer assistance, wealth, and<br />
cidence that this sum is ten times the price of<br />
fame to the aspiring author. It would almost<br />
the half-crown book already offered? Can the<br />
seem as if these persons were weary of well.<br />
wall<br />
P<br />
promised coupon be ten copies of that work?<br />
doing; or as if their offers were met with cold 3;<br />
3. The book of collected stories is to be sold at<br />
distrust. However, we are now favoured with 38.0<br />
one more enterprising and sporting proposal.<br />
4. All the profits to be divided among the<br />
The leader, guide, and friend, the Codlin of the au<br />
his authors. Noble, indeed !<br />
whole business. is a gentleman named " Rey J. 5. The editor to be recouped “necessary<br />
Meldrum Drverre.” He is a " wellknown" expenses," and to receive commission of 2d. a<br />
author-he says so himself, therefore not to<br />
volume.<br />
know him is to confess ignorance and obscurity.<br />
6. Nobody is to be admitted into this fortunate<br />
He appears before us in a four-fold capacity.<br />
company who cannot command among his friends<br />
First as an advertiser. He there describes himself<br />
the sale of at least a dozen copies at 2s. 8d. -<br />
as a “successful” author. It is therefore, one Let us see how the plan works out.<br />
presumes, out of pure Christian benevolence that There are twenty writers at £1 58.; that makes<br />
he undertakes certain duties not generally per- £25, which is two-thirds of the cost of produc-<br />
formed by successful writers. He offers lessons tion. This therefore is £37 108. Very mode-<br />
in authorship-he is so successful that he is rate, too. It would seem to represent an edition<br />
above the restriction of grammar. Why should of 500 copies of an 8vo. volume containing 160 pp.<br />
he aim at grammar when he can make himself of 250 words each--that is to say, five sheets.<br />
understood without ? Thus, who can fail to It can be done for the money, binding and all.<br />
understand the following? “Lessons in Author- If it is done for less who pockets the difference ?<br />
ship offered by a successful author. Terms And what about advertising the book ?<br />
stamp." His next appearance is as the author of But the book is “ pushed” by the authors.<br />
a book on the “ Art of Authorsbip by a well- Beautiful development of the literary life! The<br />
known Author.” He thus describes it—again author has to go round begging his friends to<br />
scorning the trammels of grammar: “This book, give him 28. 8d. each. Well : such a book as<br />
giving the experience of most of our leading “Lorna Doone," or a round score of masterpieces,<br />
authors, is intended to aid those desiring to enter can be had for sixpence apiece—why, then, should<br />
the literary life. Practical and sympathetic- anyone buy, let us say, not a masterpiece, for<br />
characterise it correctly.”<br />
28. 8d.? However, by dint of push and touting<br />
But there is more. “Each book”—this is one of the fortunate twenty gets rid, suppose, of<br />
very mysterious and attractive—"contains a fifteen copies, which at 28. 8d. means 408. If he<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 73 (#103) #############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
73<br />
is wise he will repay himself that 258., and editors and publishers' readers so often reject<br />
forward the rest to the editor. Suppose that the good articles and books is because they are no<br />
whole twenty get rid of fifteen copies each. judges of literature until it is printed and bound.<br />
That means 300 copies, or £40. How does it Even typewriting does not assist their judgement,<br />
work out?<br />
and “ galley” proof but little more. Indeed, the<br />
The editor takes his “necessary expenses "- Ideal Editor prefers handwriting to typewriting ;<br />
say £2 108. The rest goes to the printer, or, if it seems to give him the author's thought more<br />
the cost has been less than the estimate, the fresh and hot; it helps to bring out for him the<br />
margin will pay something towards that ad, a literary physiognomy of the story or article.<br />
copy, which amounts to £2 ios. How much is The Ideal Editor appreciates style, but is no<br />
left for the Company of Twenty? But the stylomaniac. If the subject be of sufficient<br />
British public may buy the volume eagerly. interest he will accept an article and print it as<br />
Perhaps ; on the other hand, perhaps it will not. it stands, even if it be indifferently written.<br />
There is, however, a fourth character in which To give style to a man who has it not is to<br />
this versatile and reverend gentlemen appears. deprive him of marked individuality. Impotence,<br />
He has a “ Literary Bureau ” of which he is inability to express in writing may become an<br />
“Hon. Sec.” It is generally understood that interesting and entertaining phenomenon of which<br />
an “Hon. Sec.” is unpaid. The Bureau buys it would be wrong to deprive readers, as witness<br />
MSS.; sells MSS. at a 10 per cent. commission: many well-known cases. The Ideal Editor does<br />
“ considers " MSS. with a view to publication in not regard it as his business to touch up the<br />
book form : gives lessons in writing short stories : style of articles until they bear no reseinblance to<br />
in writing for the Press generally : and criti. the original. Have we not seen one or two<br />
cises MSS. at 28, 6d. each if not more than 4000 magazines in which each article, however diverse<br />
words in length. The Bureau has been estab the subject, seemed to be the contribution of the<br />
lished for ten years.<br />
same pen? This was the handiwork of a stylo.<br />
One would like to ask a few questions :<br />
maniac. The ideal editor's corrections are con.<br />
(1) Have the authors of the volume already fined to slips in grammar, and even here he uses<br />
published received any of their money back? his power sparingly. It has happened to the<br />
(2) What becomes of the difference when the present writer that a purist editor—the least ideal<br />
cost of production is less than the estimate ? type of them all-has altered the expression<br />
(3) Who makes up the difference when it is “It's me!” into “It is I!" The Ideal Editor has<br />
greater?<br />
been known to make changes in spelling and<br />
(4) What advertising is done?<br />
punctuation, but again only sparingly, for in<br />
(5) What were the details and the amount of both he prefers to leave free play to the individu.<br />
the “necessary expenses”?<br />
ality which both are capable of expressing. He<br />
(6) Whether the Rev. J. Meldrum Dryerre is would never, for instance, alter “shew” into<br />
the unpaid secretary of the Bureau ? If not, “show” or drop the "e" in judgement, but he<br />
why he calls himself “Hon. Sec." ?<br />
tries to preserve for us old friends and pleasant<br />
(7) To what authors or to what works can memories, and changes “ Kalendar" into “ Calen-<br />
he refer as a successful and competent literary dar," and Aachen into Aix-la-Chapelle.<br />
agent? It is customary for literary agents to The Ideal Editor has no other profession and is<br />
produce these references in proof of competence. very diligent in his own. He keeps a MS. but a<br />
short time when it is not his intention to keep it<br />
altogether. The Ideal Editor is a gentleman, and<br />
therefore polite solicitude is another of his many<br />
THE IDEAL EDITOR.<br />
excellencies. A tender consideration, even for<br />
(From the occasional contributor's point of view.) the obscure and troublesome, animates his whole<br />
conduct. If the contributor has sent his MS.<br />
F the Ideal Editor's literary qualification this unfolded in a stiff cardboard case, the editor will<br />
U paper sayeth nought; its object is rather return it in the same case; if the contributor has<br />
to set forth, to the shame of his Philistine folded his MS. the editor will observe the same<br />
compeer, the excellencies of his rule of conduct pleats in folding and not brutally roll and crumple<br />
and the praiseworthiness of his methods of pro. it as his Philistine compeer does ; if only postage<br />
cedure.<br />
stamps and no wrapper accompanies the MS., the<br />
The first general excellency of the Ideal Editor editor in returning it is careful to use wrappers<br />
is that he can judge of the merits of a contribu. that cover the whole width of the MS., so that it<br />
tion in its MS. form. This may sound a truism, may in no way become soiled or defaced by post-<br />
but it is none the less a fact that the reason why marks or postage stamps. He has a kind heart,<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 74 (#104) #############################################<br />
<br />
74<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
AMERICAN PUBLISHERS' ASSOCIATION.<br />
1.<br />
TNDIANAPOLIS, July 20. — The Bowen-<br />
| Merrill Company of this city, the largest<br />
publishing firm in the State, has received a<br />
circular letter from Eastern publishers asking<br />
representatives to attend a meeting to be<br />
held in New York on Wednesday next to<br />
consider a plan of co-operation whereby author's<br />
royalties may be decreased. The circular says<br />
that “if the publishers and booksellers can<br />
arrange matters satisfactorily, the sellers will<br />
not handle books of publishers not in the<br />
association and the publishers will not sell to<br />
outsiders.”<br />
Nothing is said in the circular of capitalisation<br />
or the number which it is proposed to take into<br />
the combine. —New York Sun, July 21, 1900.<br />
the Ideal Editor, and knows that one journey<br />
through the post will often give a MS. a sadly<br />
rejected look. Moreover, he is acquainted with<br />
the postal regulations; he can distinguish between<br />
home and foreign ; he is aware that the minimum<br />
for MSS. abroad is 2 d. and not—as the Philis-<br />
tines all think-id. It would grieve him to the<br />
soul to be instrumental in inflicting a postal fine<br />
on a starving contributor or to add to the<br />
exchequer of a rapacious foreign Government<br />
Further, he never sends proofs or MSS. abroad in<br />
an open gummed envelope, for he knows that<br />
certain foreign postal officials, whose patriotism<br />
gets the better of their honesty, are quite<br />
capable of closing the gummed envelope and<br />
no upon the unfortunate. perhaps' stary.<br />
ing, contributor a postal fine of the value of a<br />
luncheon.<br />
When he has made up his mind to accept an<br />
article, the Ideal Editor does not selfishly nurse<br />
the fact in his bosom for six months or a year ;<br />
he is a humane man, and immediately informs<br />
the contributor of the good news. It is asking<br />
too much, but there does exist a high-souled<br />
editor-creature almost of another world—who<br />
acknowledges every MS. as he receives it. promis<br />
ing “attention in due course.” This of itself<br />
softens the blow when the “attention ” eventually<br />
does not take the form of retention ; and, when<br />
accepted, the contributor has not over long to<br />
wait for an appearance. The Ideal Editor accepts<br />
with judgement; therefore his pigeon-holes are<br />
never unduly cluttered up, not even with<br />
“ middles.”<br />
The Ideal Editor always sends two proofs-one<br />
to be returned and one to be retained. The con<br />
tributor corrects both, and is thus able to see for<br />
himself that the proof is actually printed as it<br />
leaves his hands. For I need scarcely say that if<br />
the Ideal Editor makes any changes-suggestions<br />
he would prefer me to call them—they are always<br />
made in the proof, which is never touched again<br />
after it leaves the author's hands. (N.B. The<br />
two proofs are invariably accompanied by the<br />
MS., without which a writer cannot comfortably<br />
correct the proof of a difficult article). The<br />
Philistine editor never returns the MS., even if<br />
.the substance of the article is composed of intri.<br />
cate statistics.<br />
Such, then, set forth without hyperbole, are<br />
some of the excellencies of the Ideal Editor. All<br />
honour to him. When the Philistine who is<br />
encamped over against the Sion of his sanctum<br />
shall hatte been subdued to a like rightmindedness<br />
and gentlemanliness of procedure, then the lite-<br />
rary millennium will be nigh, and the contribut.<br />
ing lamb may lie down without fear by the side<br />
of the once-dreaded editing lion. M, C.<br />
II.<br />
The American Publishers' Association was<br />
formed on last Wednesday, Charles Scribner<br />
being elected president. The news of the forma-<br />
tion of the association was printed on the follow-<br />
ing day, together with many reasons for its being.<br />
Nearly every reason given was incorrect and quite<br />
at variance with the real purpose of the organisa-<br />
tion. The story most widely circulated was sent<br />
out from Chicago and was to the effect that the<br />
principal book publishers of the United States<br />
had decided to band themselves into a trust, and<br />
that the formation of an association was the first<br />
number on their programme. Another story sent<br />
out from Chicago or some more windy Western<br />
town, had it that the main object of the new<br />
organisation was to reduce the compensation to be<br />
paid to authors in the future.<br />
So far as the promoters of the organisation<br />
have read, not one of the stories printed relative<br />
to the reason for organisation and the plans for<br />
the future is correct. And right here it may be<br />
well to correct one or two of these stories. In<br />
the first place, it was never the intention of any<br />
of the publishers who had a hand in organising<br />
the association to form a trust. Anyone at all<br />
familiar with the business of book publishing<br />
knows that it would be about as easy to form a<br />
trust of book publishers, on account of the very<br />
nature of the business, as it has been to com.<br />
municate with the legations in Peking. Further-<br />
more, the association was not formed for the<br />
purpose of buying manuscripts at reduced rates<br />
or for the purpose of reducing royalties. In fact,<br />
the relations of author and publisher were not<br />
even considered in the formation of the new<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 75 (#105) #############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
75<br />
association. It was not even suggested that booksellers as well as the regular retailers, and,<br />
these relations were any part of the business or furthermore, the department stores bought many<br />
concern of such an association.<br />
more new books for which there was a popular<br />
So much for the reasons that didn't lead to the demand than most of the regular retailers. The<br />
formation of the association and for the plans department stores were good customers, and the<br />
which it never had any intention of carrying out. publishers did not feel inclined to interfere with<br />
Now, as a matter of fact, this association was their business. The demands and the pleadings<br />
formed at the request of retail booksellers all over and the requests of the retailers kept coming in,<br />
the country and after repeated and earnest plead. however, and finally, a few months ago, some of the<br />
ings on the part of the retailers that the pub publishers decided that they must do something.<br />
lishers try to do something to change existing Some of them made individual investigation as to<br />
conditions in the trade, and work out some scheme the extent to which the business of the regular<br />
by which the retailers could at least make a dealer was impaired by the book shops in the<br />
living. They have been requesting for the last department stores.<br />
two or three years. More recently they have Their investigation led them to inquire about<br />
fairly demanded some assistance from the pub. the sale of some of the popular novels. They found<br />
lishers, representing that, if they didn't get it, that the sale of “ David Harum,” for instance, had<br />
many retail booksellers would either have to close reached, at the time the investigation was made,<br />
out their business or be sold out. It was as a 500,000 copies; of “Richard Carvel,” 438,000<br />
somewhat tardy answer to this cry for help, copies had been sold. “To Have and to Hold,”<br />
coming from all parts of the country, that the 200,000; “ Janice Meredith,” 250,000; and “Red<br />
association was formed.<br />
Rock," 84,000 copies. It has not been deter-<br />
Therefore, instead of banding together to do mined just what percentage of the total sale of<br />
the public or do the authors, the publishers have the books mentioned must be credited to the<br />
really organised themselves for the purpose of department stores, but it is known to be large.<br />
helping the men who make it possible for a pub. The investigators then tried to get at the loss to<br />
lishing house to exist. It was simply a case of somebody by the cut rates at which these books<br />
helping others and thereby helping themselves. were sold in the department stores. They took<br />
For the benefit of those not familiar with the “Richard Carvel ” for their purpose because<br />
book trade it may be said that during each certain department stores were advertising this<br />
succeeding year for the past five or six years and book extensively. The book was put out by the<br />
more, the retail bookseller's business has been Appletons to be sold at retail for i dollar 50 cents.<br />
growing poorer and poorer. The inventory at the It was found that the price in many department<br />
close of each year has shown that the profit from stores was i dollar 14 cents., while at some it was<br />
the sale of books alone was less than the sold as low as 81 cents., the publisher's price at<br />
year before. The retailers saw that this thing wholesale. The cut from the regular retail price<br />
must stop or they would have to do something was therefore 36 cents. a copy in some cases and<br />
else to make a living. And yet they could see no 69 cents. in others.<br />
way by which they could change the conditions. They saw at once that the volume of business<br />
because they knew the chief cause and they were done by many retailers who had to compete with<br />
powerless to remove it.<br />
these department stores was not such as to make<br />
The alleged chief cause of the decline in the it possible for tbem to meet even the higher of<br />
trade of the retail booksellers has been the alleged the two cut prices. In the first place, many of<br />
cause of decline in other particular lines of trade the retailers could not buy in sufficiently large<br />
for many years. The booksellers laid all their quantities to enable them to buy the book at the<br />
troubles to the department store, as the shoe lowest wholesale price. From all the information<br />
dealer and the butcher and the greengrocer and that could be gathered it seemed to be true that,<br />
the þardware dealer had done before them. They in the case of many of the retailers, they could<br />
asserted to the publisher that, so long as book's not realise a decent profit and cut under i dollar<br />
were sold in department stores at prices with 50 cents. As for selling the book at 81 cents.,<br />
which the regular bookseller found it utterly the price made by the publishers to jobbers and<br />
impossible to compete, the regular men in the others who bought in large quantities, that was<br />
trade could not do business at a profit. It was to utterly out of the question. It was then for the<br />
save them from the department stores that the publishers to determine whether they could afford<br />
retailers appealed to the publishers.<br />
to help in some way the regular retailers at the<br />
For some time the publishers could not see expense, if necessary, of the department store.<br />
their way clear to assist the retailers. They were What determination was reached may be inferred<br />
compelled to look upon the department stores as from the forming of the association.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 76 (#106) #############################################<br />
<br />
76<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
You couldn't get a publisher to admit that the<br />
association intends to antagonise a single depart.<br />
ment store in a single city in the country. On<br />
the contrary, they say they are going to get the<br />
department store to help them in the work they<br />
have undertaken. Just how they are going to do<br />
this they do not say, and it is probably true that<br />
they do not yet know. As a matter of fact, the<br />
publishers haven't got that far yet. They have<br />
really only effected an organisation and elected<br />
officers. A committee has been appointed to<br />
draft articles of association, and when it is ready<br />
to report, another meeting of the association will<br />
be held.<br />
Although no plan for aiding the retailers is now<br />
under consideration by the association as a body,<br />
the individual members are considering a scheme<br />
proposed by a man who has been in the publish.<br />
ing business over forty years in New York. At<br />
present the plan is looked upon with much favour,<br />
and it looks now as if it, or some slight modifica-<br />
tion of it, would be adopted by the association.<br />
Under this plan a net retail price for all books<br />
published after the adoption of the plan would be<br />
fixed by the association. The general scale of the<br />
prices fixed would be much lower than the retail<br />
prices now suggested by publishers to be charged<br />
for books. For instance, a book that would sell<br />
at retail, without any requirement from the pub:<br />
lisher, at I dollar 50 cents, would then be<br />
required to be sold at i dollar 25 cents.<br />
From this price the retailer would get a certain<br />
trade discount, but before he was permitted to<br />
buy a copy of the book he would be required to<br />
agree not to sell any copies at retail for less than<br />
the price stipulated by the publisher. In fixing<br />
the stipulated price it would be put at such a<br />
figure as experience has taught should yield a fair<br />
profit to the retailer of conservative business<br />
methods. This plan, as has been stated, would<br />
apply only to the publications issued after the<br />
plan is adopted. No attempt under it would be<br />
made to regulate the retail price of old publica<br />
tions. When this plan was outlined to a Sun<br />
reporter yesterday, the reporter asked the man<br />
who explained it if he expected such a scheme to<br />
be readily accepted by the department stores. His<br />
answer was:<br />
“I think we can show the department store<br />
proprietors that it will not be a bad thing for<br />
them. Of course, the publishers will continue to<br />
give the largest discount to the purchasers of the<br />
largest bill of goods, and the department stores<br />
will get the benefit of that discount. The regular<br />
retailers can find no fault with that. But it is a<br />
question of live and let live. The publishers can't<br />
live off the department stores alone, and the<br />
regular retailers can't live with the department<br />
stores under the present conditions. I think the<br />
whole thing can be laid before the department<br />
store men in such a way that they will accept it.<br />
If they don't, why we shall have to treat them, if<br />
this plan be adopted, just as we would have to<br />
treat a regular retailer who refused to accept the<br />
terms of the plan. We should then be compelled<br />
to refuse to sell to them.<br />
“But there are others to be considered besides<br />
the department stores. It is not well, for instance.<br />
to forget altogether the public. The adoption of<br />
this plan, or one something like it, would be of<br />
great benefit to the buyers of books. In the first<br />
place, the majority will be able to get their books<br />
cheaper than they would if no such plan were in<br />
force, because the majority of the buyers of high-<br />
class books, such as the members of this associa-<br />
tion publish, do not buy them from department<br />
stores. Therefore, if the plan were not in force,<br />
the majority would buy their books at the present<br />
higher scale of retail prices.<br />
“Another class that would be benefited by such<br />
a scheme would be the authors. In showing that<br />
the scheme would benefit them, I show how silly<br />
was the story that the publishers were combining<br />
against them. When it can be brought about<br />
that a uniform and fair price can be maintained<br />
for a product, the producers are always benefited.<br />
This applies to authors as well as mill hands, and<br />
the adoption of some such scheme would enable<br />
us to pay better instead of poorer rates to authors,<br />
even had we ever thought of trying to get authors<br />
to work for less."<br />
ſt was recalled by another publisher that, so far<br />
as authors are concerned, they, as a class, are not<br />
so dependent on the publishers as the publishers<br />
are on them. Of poor authors, it was said, there<br />
are plenty, but good ones are rare, and high-class<br />
publishers can never afford to work against their<br />
interests, and never have since books were pub.<br />
lished. As showing the character and standing<br />
of the publishing houses represented at the<br />
organisation of the association, it may be stated<br />
that the following were represented :<br />
D. Appleton and Co.; Bowen-Merrill Company,<br />
of Indianapolis ; Century Company; Henry T.<br />
Coates and Co, of Philadelphia ; Thomas Y.<br />
Crowell and Co.; Dodd, Mead, and Co.; Double-<br />
day, Page, and Co.; Funk and Wagnalls ; Harper<br />
and Brothers; Houghton, Mifflin, and Co.; John<br />
Lane; Lee and Shepard, Boston; the J. B.<br />
Lippincott Company, of Philadelphia; Little,<br />
Brown, and Co., of Boston; Longmans, Green,<br />
and Co.; McClure, Phillips, and Co.; the Mac-<br />
millan Company; Thomas Nelson and Sons ;<br />
G. P. Putnam's Sons; James Pott and Co.;<br />
Fleming H. Revell Company; R. H. Russell;<br />
Charles Scribner's Sons; Silver, Burdett, and<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 77 (#107) #############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
77<br />
Co.; Mays, Maynard, and Co.; and Frederick A.<br />
Stokes and Co.—New York Sun, July 29, 1900.<br />
The weakest wills are often hardest to forecast<br />
—like the weather.<br />
Virtue cannot be defined by code, for it is<br />
infinite.<br />
FINLAY GLENELG.<br />
REFLECTIONS.<br />
RT'S chief end is not to teach, but to touch.<br />
CORRESPONDENCE.<br />
Genuine gospels are not sad.<br />
The only irony in Nature lies in our.<br />
selves.<br />
1.-GOOD AND BAD ENGLISH.<br />
It is often easier to blame Providence than to MAN YOU explain what vexes my old-fashioned<br />
learn wisdom.<br />
I mind-namely, the use of the adverb once<br />
Microbes of misfortune thrive in the malaria of to mark time without its former companion<br />
misunderstanding.<br />
“when." Taken alone, it means simply that an<br />
Disease is due to lower lifeincluding our event happened on only one occasion.<br />
own.<br />
I have been obliged to look back or forward to<br />
Lower life may help the higher—to under see whether“ once" meant“ once on a time " long<br />
stand.<br />
ago, or whether it was used as showing that when<br />
Pessimism is a symptom of disease, sometimes some object was completed the rest followed. I<br />
canonised as natural science.<br />
have often met with it in books, and passed it as<br />
All genius, like all love, is miraculous.<br />
slip-slop-perhaps American; but I have just<br />
All science is superficial, and so is even religion. found it in a leading article in a contemporary.<br />
Genius never produces unhappiness—in the “Once, moreover, the decision has been taken,<br />
wisest.<br />
very little time is required to send out, &c.”<br />
Good artists enjoy life—when free and wise. Surely it would have cost even less time to begin<br />
Freedom alone cannot guarantee wisdom. the sentence with “ When once," instead of com.<br />
Absolute freedom is only for the perfectly wise mitting a barbarism of which no quotation in<br />
—the unknown.<br />
Webster's dictionary gives an instance.<br />
No one is ever too good, or even too bad, for<br />
ONCE AND EVER A LOVER OF GOOD<br />
this world.<br />
ENGLISH<br />
The absolutely impossible is unknown to us.<br />
The unwise will blame Nature for their own<br />
vain visions.<br />
II.-WALTER v. LANE.<br />
We do not know the effect of too much wisdom, The decision of the House of Lords in the case<br />
for we have never tried it.<br />
of “Walter v. Lane” goes far to carry the point<br />
Were disease always ugly, its career would be that I first urged at a meeting of the Authors'<br />
shorter.<br />
Society in the year 1891, as reported in The<br />
When Nature seems unjust, or Providence Author for Feb. 1891. What I claimed was a<br />
unwise, we only see our own images.<br />
copyright in literary style in news description ;<br />
The sub-human often mistakes itself for the i.e., I see an event, or railway accident, or fire, or<br />
supernatural.<br />
a Tsar's coronation, and I describe it in a certain<br />
The unique is only the usual.<br />
fashion; in fact, putting myself into the descrip-<br />
It is often harder to improve ourselves than to tion, and for such work I claim a copyright. Others<br />
reprove society.<br />
may describe the same event or incident, but if<br />
Love cannot fail, even when inexpert lovers they copy or choose my words, my mannerisms,<br />
must.<br />
my style, then they infringe my copyright. This<br />
All art must succeed when wise—however is just what the Times claims for its report<br />
invisibly.<br />
of Lord Rosebery's speeches. Since 1891 I have<br />
All worries are born of our weaknesses.<br />
used every opportunity for urging this claim to<br />
Facts are poor without reasons, and reasons copyright in literary style in news description, and<br />
seem poorer without sympathies.<br />
have spoken upon it at the International Press<br />
Humour is the offspring of sense and of senti. Congress at Bordeaux, Rome, &c., and at Rome<br />
ment.<br />
the International Press Bureau accepted the pro-<br />
Ideal justice is still beyond human ken.<br />
position, and it will be embodied in a bill to<br />
Novel truth may become dangerous when be laid before the Berne Convention; so that in<br />
wisdom does not pilot us.<br />
time the paragraphist, who from his local know-<br />
The nether side of unhappiness is unhealthiness. ledge gives true colour or scientific insight into<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 78 (#108) #############################################<br />
<br />
78<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
a descriptive note, will be able to prevent dozens Mr. Mackenzie Bell's poem, “Lord, teach us to<br />
of journals immediately seizing upon his well Pray," has just been published by Mr. Charles<br />
written “ par.”—for surely England, that suffers Vincent, arranged as an anthem by Herr Georg<br />
most from such “commandeering,” will not be Liebling, Court pianist to the Duke of Saxe.<br />
bebind the internationalists in journalist legisla- Coburg and Gotha.<br />
tion.<br />
- JAMES BAKER. Dr. Conan Doyle's history of the South African<br />
War is in preparation, and will be published by<br />
III.-ENGLISH AUTHORS IN THE UNITED STATES.<br />
Messrs. Smith, Elder and Co.<br />
Surely the comment upon “ Maxwell Gray's ".<br />
After the flood of books on mountaineering<br />
experience is quite obvious. There are various<br />
which recent seasons have witnessed, there is<br />
justifications for the role of literary agent, but<br />
evidently to be a cessation now. So far, the only<br />
no part of his function can be, for writers of any<br />
my book of the kind announced for publication in<br />
standing, more important than knowledge of and<br />
the autumn is “In the Ice World of the Himalaya,”<br />
a hold upon the whole international market. If<br />
by Mrs. Fanny Bullock Workman and Mr.<br />
“ Maxwell Gray's" affairs had been in the bands<br />
William Hunter Workman, who had many<br />
of a competent agent-by which is implied an<br />
interesting adventures in their travels.<br />
agent with, among other things, an American<br />
representative-none of these troubles could have<br />
“The Slaves of Society” is the title of an<br />
arisen. And surely, if the Authors' Society is<br />
anonymous satire on modern social life and<br />
wise enough not to undertake agent's work in this usages, which Messrs. Harper are to publish.<br />
country there can be no call for it to attempt to Mr. J. Ashby-Sterry is issuing through Messrs.<br />
do it in New York, where, it being a civilised Sands a new collection of his essays.<br />
place, the business of literary agent is perfectly Mrs. Humphry Ward's new novel will be pub.<br />
well understood. THE LITERARY AGENCY. lished in the autumn. It has been appearing in<br />
5, Henrietta-street, London, W.C.<br />
Harper's, and is called “ Eleanor.” The scene is<br />
laid in Italy.<br />
The novel upon which John Oliver Hobbes is en-<br />
gaged will be called “Love and the Soul Hunters.”<br />
BOOK AND PLAY TALK.<br />
Mrs. Mary E. Mann has written a novel<br />
entitled “ Among the Syringas,” in which a<br />
M HE Rev. C. Dudley Lampen's new story, to country clergyman is the chief character. The<br />
be published by Messrs. Everett and Co. book will be published by Mr. Fisher Unwin.<br />
shortly, is entitled “Barcali, the Mutineer: M. Leroy-Beaulieu, the well-known French<br />
a Tale of the Great Pacific.” It deals with the economist and authority on colonial affairs, has<br />
discovery of a strange colony and the doings of recently published in Paris a work of great<br />
a clever but exceedingly wicked chief engineer. interest at the present time, entitled “La Renova-<br />
Messrs. Methuen and Co. are publishing at tion de l'Asie." An English translation of this<br />
once Mr. J. Bloundelle-Burton's new romance,<br />
book is to be brought out by Mr. Heinemann. It<br />
entitled “Servants of Sin,” the action of which will be edited, with a preface, by Mr. Henry<br />
takes place during the regency of the Duke of Norman, of whose “Peoples and Politics of the<br />
Orleans, and during the time of the downfall of Far East” Mr. Fisher Unwin is now publishing<br />
Law's Mississippi scheme and that of the Great a new edition.<br />
Plague of Marseilles. The main incidents of this The first number of a new half-a-crown review,<br />
story are founded upon fact, and many of the edited by Mr. Henry Newbolt, will be published<br />
characters are, under other names, persons who by Mr. Murray on Sept. 19. The founders “wish<br />
actually existed at the period; while the actual it to take its place among its old competitors in a<br />
facts themselves were unearthed by Mr. Bloun. modest and orderly manner, believing that neither<br />
delle-Burton in the libraries of Paris while 'pushfulness' nor loud promises are likely to<br />
engaged in writing a history of the “ Three attract the readers they desire." It is to be<br />
Louis” (Louis XIII., XIV., and XV.), on which called the Monthly Review.<br />
he has for some years been occupied.<br />
Mr. Frederick A. Cook, who acted as surgeon,<br />
Mr. F. S. Ellis, who was closely associated anthropologist, and photographer to the “Belgica”<br />
with William Morris, has since the death of his expedition to the Antarctic region, is writing an<br />
friend been engaged upon a translation of “The account of that adventure. It will be published<br />
Romance of the Rose." This work will form three by Mr. Heinemann.<br />
volumes of the Temple Classics, and the first of A cheap issue of Dr. George Macdonald's novels<br />
these is just being published by Messrs. Dent. has been begun by Messrs. Kegan Paul.<br />
.._-- ---<br />
-----<br />
-<br />
-<br />
------<br />
---<br />
-<br />
-<br />
-<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 79 (#109) #############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
79<br />
A new book by Mr. F. C. Selous, entitled “ English Nell,” the new pla y by Mr. Anthony<br />
“ Sport and Travel, East and West,” will be pub- Hope and Mr. Edward Rose-founded on “ Simon<br />
lished in the autumn.<br />
Dale”—was produced at the Prince of Wales's<br />
Mr. Leslie Stephen's work « The English Theatre on Aug. 21. The heroine, as in the<br />
Utilitarians,” will be published in a few days. It Haymarket production referred to above, is Nell<br />
is in three volumes (Duckworth).<br />
Gwynne.<br />
In the July number of The Author a reference<br />
A play by Mr. T. P. O'Connor, M.P., entitled<br />
was made to the American novel “ To Have and<br />
“ The Lost Leader,” will be produced shortly at<br />
to Hold,” by Miss Mary Johnston. It should be the Crown Theatre, Peckham. It is founded<br />
explained, however, that the title this book bears upon incidents in the career of Mr. Parnell. The<br />
in England is “ By Order of the Company.” The leading part will be played by Mr. Laurence<br />
former title was used in England by Miss Irving.<br />
Sarah Stredder, who published a novel entitled In Mr. Cecil Raleigh's new drama, “ The Price<br />
“ To Have and to Hold ” sixteen years ago. of Peace,” the opening scene is placed in a ward<br />
The first long novel that Mr. Louis Becke has of St. Thomas's Hospital; then the action passes<br />
written will be published shortly by Mr. Fisher to the Houses of Parliament, and it is under-<br />
Unwin. It will be called “ Edward Barry, South stood that the play has a political interest<br />
Sea Pearler.”<br />
throughout. Mr. Henry Neville and Miss Lettie<br />
A collection of articles on European sport is Fairfax will take the chief parts, and it is hoped<br />
being edited by Mr. F. G. Aflalo for publication to produce the play at Drury Lane on Sept. 15.<br />
by Messrs. Sands in a volume which will be called Mr. Barrie has written a new play, “ Two<br />
“Sport in Europe." Among the contributors are Kinds of Women," with which Mr. Arthur<br />
Prince Demidoff, Sir Henry Pottinger, Bart., and Bourchier will reopen the Garrick Theatre.<br />
Mr. W. A. Baillie Grohman.<br />
Mrs. Alec Tweedie is leaving shortly for Canada<br />
The Rev. H. N. Hutchinson's new work on the and the United States to pay several visits, and<br />
living races of mankind is to appear in fortnightly she purposes spending next winter in Mexico in<br />
parts, beginning immediately. Mr. Hutchinson order to write a new book on that country. Mrs.<br />
has been assisted by Mr. Lvdekker, Mr. J. W. Alec Tweedie's book, “Through Finland in<br />
Gregory, and other authorities.<br />
Carts,” is just ready in a new edition. An up-to-<br />
Collectors will be interested to note the prices date political chapter has been added, and a<br />
realised by Mr. Swinburne's books in the auction portrait of the author. Finland is of particular<br />
rooms. The following copies which were sold by interest at the moment, in consequence of the<br />
Messrs. Sotheby were presented by the author to Tsar's strange attempt to rob that interesting<br />
the late Dr. Grosart, and bore inscriptions to that country of the political rights which he himself<br />
effect :- SONGS OF THE SPRINGTIDES (1880),<br />
swore to uphold when he ascended the throne.<br />
£5 128. 6d.; MARY STUART (1881), £5 158.; The Russian language is being introduced ;<br />
TRISTRAM OF LYONESSE (1882), £5 178. 6d.; Finnish newspapers are suppressed ; the stamps<br />
A CENTURY OF ROUNDELS (1883), 26 128. 6d.; and the currency are in jeopardy. Indeed, Russia,<br />
MARINO FALIERO (1885), £5 178. 6d. ; LOCRINE in spite of her peace manifesto, is doing her best<br />
(1887), 26; A STUDY OF BEN JONSON to exterminate the independence of poor Finland.<br />
(1889), £6 29. 60.; A Tale OF BALEN (1896), It is an interesting struggle.<br />
£5 178. 6d.<br />
Miss Julia Neilson is just producing at the<br />
Haymarket (Aug. 30) Mr. Kester's “Sweet Nell<br />
of Old Drury." Mr. George Alexander also is<br />
BOOKS AND REVIEWS.<br />
now (Sept. 1) producing “A Debt of Honour,”<br />
(In these columns notes on books are given from reviews-<br />
Mr. Sydney Grundy's new play.<br />
which carry weight, and are not, so far as can be learned,<br />
logrollers.)<br />
A special matinée has been organised by Mr.<br />
Penley in aid of Mr. Arthur Pearson's Fresh Air<br />
DARTMOOR, by S. Baring Gould (Methuen, 68.), for a.<br />
Fund for the Poor, and will take place at the<br />
holiday tourist of some reading and imagination, will be<br />
says the Daily News, “a most delightful book. Soenic<br />
Great Queen-street Theatre on Sept. 15. Two<br />
description, anecdotes racy of the Devonian soil, antiquities,<br />
new plays by Mr. Edward Jones will be produced are here poured forth with a profusion which Mr. Baring<br />
on this occasion.<br />
Gould's lightness of touch and sense of order prevent<br />
Mr. Stephen Phillips's forthcoming play,<br />
from being for an instant wearisome." The Daily Chronicle<br />
says the book “is in many respects a model of its sort. Mr.<br />
“ Herod the King," will follow “ Julius Cæsar" at<br />
Baring Gould has lived all his life in the neighbourhood<br />
Her Majesty's.<br />
which he describes Dartmoor has been to him, as he says,<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 80 (#110) #############################################<br />
<br />
80<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
'a passion,' and he has indulged that passion in intimacy<br />
and sympathy.”<br />
ESSAYS OF JOHN DRYDEN, selected and edited by W. P.<br />
Ker (Clarendon Press, 108. 6d.), consists, for the most part,<br />
of essays which were furnished as prefaces to plays or<br />
poems. “Professor Ker's introductions," says the Daily<br />
Chronicle," have grip and suggestiveness. The notes are<br />
concise and always to the point.” Literature says that<br />
“ Professor Ker has earned the gratitude of all who love<br />
English literature by collecting and editing these scattered<br />
prefaces. His part of the work is conspicuously good.”<br />
i There is a bibliography and an index, and in some cases<br />
various readings are added from later editions which are<br />
most instructive.” “Here at last,” says the Spectator," the<br />
work of Dryden is set forth with learning, taste, and<br />
restraint."<br />
AMERICA'S WORKING PEOPLE, by Charles B. Spahr<br />
(Longmans, 5s. net), “is an interesting book," says the<br />
Daily Chronicle. “Mr. Spahr draws with a firm hand and<br />
a loving touch, broadly, yet not without detail, the varieties<br />
of the great Labour class as he has studied them in different<br />
parts of his own land. He has a passion, all too rare<br />
amongst economists, for knowing about things as they are ;<br />
and in his pages we find the old factories and the new,<br />
the border community, the iron centre, and above all, the<br />
northern farm, sketched from the life, with other studies of<br />
contemporary industries and communities, alike vivid and<br />
instructive."<br />
A SPORTSWOMAN IN INDIA, by Isabel Savory (Hutchin.<br />
son, 168.) “No better written book on Indian sport has<br />
come our way these ton years," says the Daily Chronicle.<br />
“The romance of the gorgeous Eastern cities," says the<br />
Spectator, “is told with much picturesqueness, but the<br />
author is far more at home in the lonely hill.camp or beating<br />
in the jungle. To anyone who wishes to live for some hours<br />
in a fascinating world of sport and adventure nothing could<br />
be better than this gallant and light-hearted book.” The<br />
book, says the Guardian, is "simply a record of a most<br />
enjoyable visit to India by a young lady, full of high spirits<br />
... and with plenty of sound common sense and &<br />
temperament that enabled her to think as well as to enjoy.<br />
The result is this extremely pleasant volume, for the author,<br />
as the guest of Sir George Wolseley, had every opportunity<br />
of seeing the best and brightest aspects of the country.”<br />
Many of the personal adventures she records, says the<br />
Daily Telegraph, are “ worthy of a hardened Nimrod.”<br />
THE UTTERMOST FARTHING, by P. B. Neuman (Black.<br />
wood, 68.), “is a very clever piece of work,” says Literature.<br />
** The story, though trivial and unimportant, is well put<br />
together and well told, though the probabilities are not very<br />
carefully respected.” The Daily Chronicle calls it “clever<br />
and decidedly original.” Medlett and Crofts are two City<br />
men, apparently good friends, who become bitter enemies<br />
through the issue of a speculation which ruins one of them.<br />
The main theme of the story, says the Daily News, " is a<br />
family fead, its leading sentiment revenge-revenge, how-<br />
ever, not of the Corsican quality, but the plain English<br />
middle-class brand.” It is “a good wholesome story, told<br />
in a plain onadorned and yet forcible manner.”<br />
ON ALIEN SHORES, by Leslie Keith (Hurst and Blackett,<br />
68.), is described by the Daily Chronicle as "altogether a<br />
well-studied and interesting story.” “There is something<br />
of Datoh fidelity in the author's painting of the Edinburgh<br />
home.” “It is a quietly amusing story," says the Spec-<br />
tator, " not too short, written with great care, and, above<br />
all, with a real power of describing human nature ; and<br />
people who like these qualities will find this novel more than<br />
merely readable.” “The heroine, brought up in luxury in<br />
Portland Place, and then making the best of her stolen<br />
marriage with a City clerk, is well-drawn and lifelike.”<br />
Mis’ESS Joy, by John Le Breton (Macqueon, 68.), “ is<br />
as steeped in irony,” says the Daily Chronicle," as Mr.<br />
Hardy's masterpiece Tess,' though hardly of so intense<br />
and tragic a cast.” “The story is a remarkable one, and well<br />
as Mr. Le Breton has already written, it is by far the best<br />
work we have had from his pen."<br />
A GIFT FROM THE GRAVE, by Edith Wharton (Murray,<br />
28. 6d. net), is "a work of great interest," says Literature.<br />
“The book is a purely introspective study. A man of<br />
delicate fibre commits a coarse act. He publishes the<br />
letters-practically the love-letters-of a woman who wrote<br />
them in utter confidence.” “The book is chiefly concerned<br />
with his repentance after his shabby deed has brought him<br />
all the good things he wanted, and the study in souls,” says<br />
the Spectator, “is well and cleverly done. Readers who<br />
like motives, emotions, and soul-searchings will be much<br />
interested in the story."<br />
THE STRONG ARM, by Robert Barr (Methuen, 6s.), con-<br />
sists, says the Daily Chronicle, " of one longish story and<br />
several short ones, more or less connected together by a<br />
continuous thread of interest.” “There are robber barons<br />
and outlaws, and intriguing archbishops, and love, and war<br />
and all sorts of exciting things.”<br />
A PRINCE OF SWINDLERS, by Guy Boothby (Ward,<br />
Lock, and Co., 68.) is a series of stories, linked together by<br />
the identity of the hero. “Mr. Gay Boothby gives us,"<br />
says the Spectator, " the portrait of a magnificent impostor<br />
who unites the salient points of Messrs. Lecoq, Sherlock<br />
Holmes, and Charles Peace, the whole seen through a<br />
powerful magnifying glass.” “The stories are ingenious if<br />
not very convincing, and readers who like sensationalism<br />
and plenty of it will very likely be amused by the book.”<br />
THE CRIMSON WEED, by Christopher St. John (Duck-<br />
worth, 68.), is, says the Daily Chronicle, "a study of one of<br />
those passions that can ruin a lifetime." Revenge is the<br />
"crimson weed,” which takes root in the mind of Luke<br />
Grey. The book “gives evidence of considerable literary<br />
and dramatic power. The scenes are vividly realised, and<br />
the characters live, and the story, such as it is, is told with<br />
no little passion and spirit.”<br />
THE DESCENT OF THE DUCHESS, by Morley Roberts<br />
(Sands, 38. 6d.), is “& thoronghly admirable piece of<br />
fooling," in the opinion of the Daily News. “It does not<br />
palpitate with actuality," says the Daily Chronicle, “but<br />
for the filling up of an hour's leisure in a shady corner of<br />
the garden on a hot afternoon it will do extremely well."<br />
THE DEAN'S APRON, by C. J. Wills and Godfrey<br />
Burchett (Ward, Lock, and Co., 38. 6d.) is described by the<br />
Daily Telegraph as “an exceptionally clever story of<br />
clerical life in a cathedral town, abounding in graphic and<br />
convincing word-pictures of envious persons and scandal.<br />
mongers, obviously sketched from life.”<br />
THE AUTHOR.'<br />
SCALE FOR ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
Front Page<br />
**<br />
Other Pages<br />
.. ... £4 0 0<br />
Hall of & Page ...<br />
... ... ... 300<br />
Quarter of a Page<br />
... ... 1 100<br />
...<br />
Eighth of a Page<br />
... 015 0<br />
Single Column Advertisements.<br />
per inch<br />
Bills for Insertion<br />
0 6 0<br />
...<br />
per 2000 3 0 0<br />
Reductions made for a Series of Six or Twelve Insertions.<br />
All letters respecting Advertisements should be addressed to the<br />
ADVERTISEMENT MANAGER, The Author Office, 4, Portugal-street<br />
London, W.O.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 80 (#111) #############################################<br />
<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
THE LITERARY AGENCIA<br />
SALE OF MSS. OF EVERY KIND.<br />
Literary Advice, Revision, Research, etc.<br />
ARRANGEMENTS FOR<br />
Printing, Publishing, Illustration, Translation, etc.<br />
<br />
THE LITERARY AGENCY OF LONDON,<br />
5, HENRIETTA STREET, W.C.<br />
G. RADFORD.<br />
G. H. PERRIS.<br />
DARLINGTON'S HANDBOOKS<br />
AUTHOR'S HAIRLESS PAPER-PAD<br />
THE<br />
(The LEADENHALL PRESS LTD., Publishers & Printers,<br />
50, Leadenhall Street, London, E.C.)<br />
Contains hairless paper, over which the pen Blips with perfect<br />
freedom. Sixpence each. 58. per dozen, ruled or plain. New Pocket<br />
Size, 38. per dozen, ruled or plain. Authors should note that THE<br />
LEADENHALL PRESS LTD. cannot be responsible for the loss of MSS.<br />
by fire or otherwise. Duplicate copies should be retained.<br />
"Sir Henry Ponsonby 18<br />
Scommanded by the Queen<br />
to thank Mr. Darlington for<br />
a copy of his Handbook."<br />
"Nothing better conld be wished for."-British Weekly.<br />
"Far superior to ordinary guides."-London Daily Chronicle.<br />
Edited by RALPH DARLINGTON, F.R.G.S. ls. each. Illustrated.<br />
Maps by John BARTHOLOMEW, F.R.G.S.<br />
THE ISLE OF WIGHT.<br />
THE CHANNEL ISLANDS.<br />
THE VALE OF LLANGOLLEN. THE NORTH WALES COAST,<br />
BRECON AND ITS BEACONS. THE SEVERN VALLEY.<br />
BOURNEMOUTH AND THE NEW FOREST. THE WYE VALLEY.<br />
BRIGHTON, EASTBOURNE, HASTINGS, AND ST. LEONARDS.<br />
ABERYSTWITH, TOWYN, BARMOUTH. AND DOLGELLY.<br />
MALVERN, HEREFORD, WORCESTER, AND GLOUCESTER.<br />
LLANDRINDOD WELLS AND THE SPAS OF MID-WALES.<br />
BRISTOL, BATH, CHEPSTOW, AND WESTON-SUPER-MARE.<br />
"The best Handbook to London ever issued."-Liverpool Daily Post.<br />
2nd Edition Enlarged, 58. 60 Illustrations, 24 Maps and Plang.<br />
LONDON AND ENVIRONS.<br />
By E. C. Cook and E. T. Cook, M.A.<br />
F'cap. 8vo. Is.<br />
THE HOTELS OF THE WORLD.<br />
A Handbook to the leading Hotels throughout the World.<br />
Llangollen: DARLINGTON & Co. London: SIMPKIN, MARSHALL & Co.<br />
LTD. Railway Bookstalls and all Booksellers.<br />
PHOTOGRAPHS.-BIRTHDAY and SEASON CARDS from negatives by<br />
RALPH DARLINGTOX, F.R.G.S., of Scenery, Ruins, &c., in Norway, Sweden,<br />
Denmark, Russia, Italy, Greece, Asia Minor, and Egypt, ls., 1s. 6d., 28.,<br />
28. 6d. Complete list, post free.<br />
DARLINGTON AND CO., LLANGOLLEN.<br />
<br />
AUTHORS' TYPEWRITING.<br />
Careful work with Yobt machine on good paper. Inclusive prices.<br />
Novels and Stories, 8d. per 1000 words; in duplicate, Is.<br />
Plays, Poems, &c., Is. per 1000 words ; in duplicate, Is. 3d<br />
Also Technical and Scientific work; French and Spanish.<br />
Specimen of work and Extracts from Testimonials on application.<br />
L. A. ST. JOHN, 20, Lucas Avenue, Upton Park, London, E.<br />
TYPEWRITING.<br />
Beference, MISS BEATRICE WHITBY.<br />
MS. Typed at ls. per 1000 words.<br />
Address Mrs. KAY, Crossmead, Exeter.<br />
SECRETARIAL WORK.<br />
LADY DESIRES<br />
TEMPORARY ENGAGEMENTS.<br />
Experienced Typist (owns machine).<br />
Also COPYING MS., DUPLICATING, &c. References<br />
MISS W. KEMPSON,<br />
ROATH HOUSE, CARDIFF.<br />
TYPEWRITING BY CLERGYMAN'S DAUGHTER AND ASSISTANTS.<br />
70 3JTTON A<br />
MISS E, M. SIKES,<br />
<br />
The West Kensington Typewriting Agency,<br />
13, Wolverton Gardens, Hammersmith, W.<br />
(ESTABLISHED 1893.)<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully and promptly copied. Usual Ternis.<br />
Legal and General Copying.<br />
Typewritten Circulars by Copying Process.<br />
AUTHORS' REFERENCES.<br />
-10 8.ba<br />
MRS. GILL,<br />
TYPE-WRITING OFFICE,<br />
35, LUDGATE HILL, E.C.<br />
(ESTABLISHED 1883.)<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully copied from 18. per 1000 words. Duplicate<br />
copies third price. Skilled typists sent out by hour, day, or week.<br />
French MSS. accurately copied, or typewritten English translations<br />
supplied. References kindly permitted to Sir Walter Besant; also<br />
to Messrs. A. P. Watt and Son, Literary Agents, Hastings House.<br />
Norfolk-street, Strand, W.0.<br />
HTAOW 21<br />
ЗИUTHO3 тазаОМ А<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 80 (#112) #############################################<br />
<br />
iv<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
<br />
T HAS NEVER BEEN SERIOUSLY QUES-<br />
TIONED BY ANY HONEST TYPEWRITER<br />
INVENTOR, MECHANICAL EXPERT, OR<br />
USER THAT THE FUNDAMENTAL LINES<br />
UPON WHICH THE SMITH PREMIER IS BUILT<br />
ARE FAR IN ADVANCE OF ANY OTHER TYPE-<br />
WRITER. THAT ALONE WOULD NOT MERIT<br />
SUCCESS, BUT THAT FOUNDATION TOGETHER<br />
WITH BEST MATERIAL, BEST WORKMANSHIP,<br />
AND EXPERT INSPECTION<br />
OF ALL THE PARTS AS<br />
WELL AS THE FINISHED<br />
PRODUCT, HAVE CAUSED<br />
THE SMITH PREMIER TO<br />
WIN. THIS IS THE EX.<br />
PLANATION OF ITS PHE-<br />
NOMENAL RECORD OF<br />
SUCCESS.<br />
SEND FOR ART CATALOGUE.<br />
The Smith Premier Typewriter Co<br />
14, Gracechurch Street, LONDON, E.C.<br />
<br />
Smith Prema<br />
<br />
ESTABLISHED] The Athenæum Press, Taunton. (XVII. CENT.<br />
BARNICOTT & PEARCE<br />
INVITE ENQUIRIES RESPECTING PRINTING.<br />
ESTIMATES OF COST, AND OTHER DETAILS, PROMPTLY GIVEN.<br />
T Y P E WRITING<br />
(Authors' MSS.)<br />
Undertaken by highly educated women of Literary experience (Classical Tripos ; Higher Cambridge<br />
Local; thorough acquaintance with modern languages). Authors' References.<br />
Terms, 1s. 8d. per 1000 words; over 5000 words, 1s.<br />
S. R., 1, LINGARDS ROAD, LEWISHAM, S.E.<br />
THE VICTORIA TYPEWRITING COMPANY.<br />
18, BOROUGH HIGH STREET, LONDON BRIDGE, S.E.,<br />
Have adopted a NEW STYLE, very effective, and attracting attention. Authors' MSS. copied from<br />
10d. to 1s. 3d. per 1000 words. Kindly send for specimen.<br />
CAREFUL AND ACCURATE WORK GUARANTEED.<br />
Second Edition. Orown 4to., cloth, price 38. 60.; by post, 38, 9d. Crown 8vo., with illustrations, price 68., to be had of all booksellers.<br />
DAIRY TALES. By BASIL FIELD. Beautifully I TOR HIS COUNTRY'S SAKE; or, Esca, a British<br />
Illustrated by C. E. Fripp.<br />
1 Prince at the Court of Trajan. By L. M. P. BLACK.<br />
HORACE Cox, Windsor House, Bream's-buildings, London, E.O. T HORACE Cox, Windsor House, Bream's-buildings, London, E.O.<br />
D. Beautifully<br />
Flomack Cox, Windows and more<br />
Printed and Published by HORACE Cox, Windsor House, Bream's-buildings, London, E.C. | https://historysoa.com/files/original/5/334/1900-09-01-The-Author-11-4.pdf | publications, The Author |