523 | https://historysoa.com/items/show/523 | The Author, Vol. 23 Issue 03 (December 1912) | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=49&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=%3Cem%3EThe+Author%3C%2Fem%3E%2C+Vol.+23+Issue+03+%28December+1912%29"><em>The Author</em>, Vol. 23 Issue 03 (December 1912)</a> | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=51&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Publication">Publication</a> | 1912-12-01-The-Author-23-3 | | | | | 65–96 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=89&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=23">23</a> | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=76&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=1912-12-01">1912-12-01</a> | | | | | | | 3 | | | 19121201 | Che Hutbor.<br />
<br />
(The Organ of the Incorporated Society of Authors. Monthly.)<br />
<br />
FOUNDED BY SIR<br />
<br />
WALTER BESANT.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
VoL. XXTII.—No. 3.<br />
<br />
DECEMBER 1, 1912.<br />
<br />
[PRIcE SIXPENCE.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
TELEPHONE NUMBER:<br />
374 VICTORIA.<br />
<br />
TELEGRAPHIC ADDRESS :<br />
AUTORIDAD, LONDON.<br />
<br />
Se ee<br />
<br />
NOTICES.<br />
<br />
++<br />
<br />
- the opinions expressed in papers that<br />
_ are signed or initialled the authors alone<br />
<br />
"are responsible. None of the papers or<br />
paragraphs must be taken as expressing the<br />
opinion of the Committee unless such is<br />
especially stated to be the case.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Tue Editor begs to inform members of the<br />
Authors’ Society and other readers of The<br />
Author that the cases which are quoted in The<br />
Author are cases that have come before the<br />
notice or to the knowledge of the Secretary of<br />
the Society, and that those members of the<br />
Society who desire to have the names of the<br />
publishers concerned can obtain them on<br />
application.<br />
<br />
ARTICLES AND CONTRIBUTIONS.<br />
<br />
Tue Editor of The Author begs to remind<br />
members of the Society that, although the<br />
paper is sent to them free of cost, its production<br />
would be a very heavy charge on the resources<br />
of the Society if a great many members did not<br />
forward to the Secretary the modest 5s. 6d.<br />
subscription for the year.<br />
<br />
Communications for The Author should be<br />
addressed to the offices of the Society, 39, Old<br />
Queen Street, Storey’s Gate, S.W., and should<br />
reach the Editor not later than the 21st of each<br />
month.<br />
<br />
Communications and letters are invited by<br />
the Editor on all literary matters treated from<br />
<br />
Vou. XXIII.<br />
<br />
the standpoint of art or business, but on no<br />
other subjects whatever. Every effort will be<br />
made to return articles which cannot be<br />
accepted.<br />
<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
<br />
As there seems to be an impression among<br />
readers of The Author that the Committee are<br />
personally responsible for the bona fides of the<br />
advertisers, the Committee desire it to be stated<br />
that this is not, and could not possibly be, the<br />
case. Although care is exercised that no<br />
undesirable advertisements be inserted, they<br />
do not accept, and never have accepted, any<br />
liability. ‘<br />
<br />
Members should apply to the Secretary for<br />
advice if special information is desired.<br />
<br />
ee<br />
<br />
THE SOCIETY’S FUNDS.<br />
<br />
— +<br />
<br />
‘T\ROM time to time members of the Society<br />
desire to make donations to its funds in<br />
recognition of work that has been done<br />
<br />
for them. The Committee, acting on the<br />
<br />
suggestion of one of these members, have<br />
decided to place this permanent paragraph in<br />
<br />
The Author in order that members may be<br />
<br />
cognisant of those funds to which these con-<br />
<br />
tributions may be paid.<br />
<br />
The funds suitable for this purpose are:<br />
(1) The Capital Fund. This fund is kept in<br />
reserve in case it is necessary for the Society to<br />
incur heavy expenditure, either in fighting a<br />
question of principle, or in assisting to obtain<br />
copyright reform, or in dealing with any other<br />
matter closely connected with the work of the<br />
Society.<br />
<br />
(2) The Pension Fund, This fund is slowly<br />
increasing, and it is hoped will, in time, cover<br />
the needs of all the members of the Society.<br />
<br />
+2<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
THE PENSION FUND.<br />
<br />
—1-—<—+ —<br />
<br />
N January, the secretary of the society laid<br />
before the trustees of the Pension Fund<br />
the accounts for the year 1911, as settled<br />
<br />
by the accountants, with a full statement of<br />
the result of the appeal made on behalf of<br />
the fund. After giving the matter full con-<br />
sideration, the trustees instructed the secretary<br />
to invest the sum of £500 in the purchase of<br />
Antofagasta and Bolivian Railway 5% Pre-<br />
ferred Ordinary Stock and Central Argentine<br />
Railway Ordinary Stock. The amounts pur-<br />
ehased at the current prices were £237 in the<br />
former and £232 in the latter stock.<br />
<br />
The trustees desire to thank the members of<br />
the society for the generous support which they<br />
have given to the Pension Fund. The money<br />
now invested amounts to £4,454 6s.<br />
<br />
Later in the year, at a meeting of the Com-<br />
mittee of Management, a question concerning<br />
the funds of the society was brought up for dis-<br />
eussion, and it was suggested that it would be<br />
a good thing for the Pension Fund trustees, if<br />
they had power, to sell out the Fund’s holding of<br />
-Consols and to invest in some more satisfactory<br />
-security. The suggestion was placed before the<br />
trustees of the Pension Fund, and a meeting<br />
was called, when the chairman of the Committee<br />
ef Management, the trustees, and Mr. Aylmer<br />
Maude, the member of the Committee of<br />
Management who had made the suggestion,<br />
were present. The figures were very closely<br />
eonsidered, and it appeared clear that altera-<br />
tions in the investment of the funds could be<br />
earried out with advantage to the Fund’s<br />
income. It was decided by the trustees, with<br />
the approval of the Committee of Management,<br />
to ‘sell out the holding of Consols.. With the<br />
amount realised, were purchased—<br />
<br />
$2,000 (£400) Consolidated Gas: and Elec-<br />
tric Company of Baltimore 44% Gold<br />
Bonds ; — —<br />
<br />
30 Buenos Ayres Great Southern Railway<br />
<br />
~ 4° Extension Shares, (1914) £8 paid ;<br />
<br />
£250 Edward Lloyd, Ltd., £1 5% Prefer-<br />
ence Shares.<br />
<br />
These amounts are fully set out and added<br />
in the nominal value to the Pension Fund<br />
investments, below.<br />
<br />
The trustees have also, in view of the option<br />
extended to them as holders of £282 Central<br />
Argentine Railway Ordinary Stock, subscribed<br />
for 8 Central Argentine Railway £10 Preference<br />
Shares, New Issue.<br />
<br />
The nominal value of the investments held<br />
on behalf of the Pension Fund now amounts<br />
<br />
to £4,454 6s., details of which are fully set out<br />
in the following schedule :—<br />
Nominal Value,<br />
<br />
Local Loans<br />
Victoria Government 3% Consoli-<br />
dated Inscribed Stock ........<br />
London and North-Western 3%<br />
Debenture Stock<br />
Egyptian Government Irrigation<br />
Trust 4% Certificates ........<br />
Cape of Good Hope 33% Inscribed<br />
Stock 0.665. a<br />
Glasgow and South-Western Rail-<br />
way 4°% Preference Stock ....<br />
New Zealand 34% Stock........<br />
Trish Land 23% Guaranteed Stock<br />
Corporation of London 24%<br />
Stock, 1927-57... ......5..5.<br />
Jamaica 34% Stock, 1919-49<br />
Mauritius 4% 1937 Stock ......<br />
Dominion of Canada, C.P.R. 34%<br />
Land Grant Stock, 1938 ......<br />
Antofagasta and Bolivian Railway<br />
5% Preferred Stock .......5...<br />
Central Argentine Railway Or-<br />
dinary Stock -. 2.2.5. 5.50.5<br />
$2,000 Consolidated Gas and<br />
Electric Company of Baltimore<br />
44% Gold Bonds ............<br />
250 Edward Lloyd, Ltd., £1 5%<br />
Preference Shares<br />
80 Buenos Ayres Great Southern<br />
Railway 4°% Extension Shares<br />
1914 (£8 paid) .......55.2,5%<br />
8 Central Argentine Railway £10<br />
Preference Shares New Issue .<br />
<br />
291 19 11<br />
250 0 O<br />
200<br />
200<br />
228<br />
247<br />
258<br />
438<br />
<br />
132<br />
120<br />
<br />
Oo oac o °<br />
<br />
198<br />
<br />
237<br />
<br />
o o eo Nob ooo eo ¢<br />
<br />
(a ” )<br />
<br />
232<br />
<br />
ig C4454<br />
<br />
Total<br />
<br />
PENSION FUND.<br />
<br />
— oe<br />
<br />
Tue list printed below includes all fresh dona-<br />
tions and subscriptions (i.e., donations and<br />
<br />
subscriptions not hitherto acknowledged)<br />
received by, or promised to, the fund from<br />
April 1st, 1912.<br />
<br />
‘ It does not include either donations given<br />
prior to April 1st, nor does it include sub-<br />
scriptions paid in compliance with promises<br />
made before it. :<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
‘Oct.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
Subscriptions.<br />
1912.<br />
April 6, Bland, J. O. P. :<br />
April 6, Taylor, Mrs. Basil .<br />
April 6, Forrester, J. Cliffe . :<br />
June 6, Probert, W. S. Q .<br />
June 6, Wheelhouse, Miss M. V.<br />
June 6, Acland, Mrs. C. D. Z<br />
June 6, Spurrell, Herbert (from<br />
1912 to 1915).<br />
June 6, Spens, Archibald B. .<br />
<br />
July 18, Liddle, S.<br />
<br />
Aug. 7, Joseph, L. : A ;<br />
<br />
Sept. 6, Garvice, Charles (in addi-<br />
tion to present sub-<br />
scription of £1 Is.)<br />
<br />
2, Todhunter, Dr. John.<br />
<br />
10, Escott, T. H. S. . ‘<br />
<br />
10, Henderson, R. W. Wright<br />
<br />
10, Knowles, Miss M. W. :<br />
<br />
11, Buckley, Reginald .<br />
<br />
12, Walshe, Douglas<br />
<br />
12, ‘‘ Penmark’”’ . :<br />
<br />
15, Sinclair Miss Edith .<br />
<br />
16, Markino, Yoshio :<br />
<br />
Oct. 20, Fiamingo, Carlo. “<br />
<br />
Oct. 29, Henley, Mrs. .<br />
<br />
Nov. 8, Jane, L. Cecil .<br />
<br />
Noy. 14, Gibb, W.<br />
<br />
Oct.<br />
Oct.<br />
Oct.<br />
Oct.<br />
Oct.<br />
<br />
Oct.<br />
<br />
Oct.<br />
Oct.<br />
<br />
1912. Donations,<br />
<br />
April 2, XX. Pen Club<br />
‘April 6, Taylor, Mrs. Basil . :<br />
April 6, Cameron, Mrs. Charlotte .<br />
April 10, Kenny, Mrs. L. M. Stac-<br />
poole : . :<br />
April 10, Robbins, Alfred F..<br />
April 10, Harris, Emma H. .<br />
April 11, Ralli, C. Searamanga<br />
April 11, Aitken, Robert . :<br />
April 16, L. M. F. (£1 per month,<br />
: February, March, April)<br />
April 22, Prior, Mrs. Melton ‘<br />
May 2, Baden-Powell, Miss Agnes<br />
‘May 25, Koebel, W. H. : :<br />
May 28, Harland, Mrs. Henry ‘<br />
May 28, Wood, Mrs. A. E. . .<br />
June 4, Hornung, E. W. i<br />
June 4, Ward, Dudley<br />
June 6, Worrall, Leehmere .<br />
June 13, Robbins, Miss Alice E.<br />
July 5, Hain, H.M. . . :<br />
Aug. 16, Shipley, R. H. . ‘<br />
Sept. 20, Willcocks, Miss M. P..<br />
Sept. 23, Peacock, Mrs. F. M.<br />
Oct. 2, Stuart, James . :<br />
Oct. 14, Diblee, G. Bonney .<br />
<br />
oormooowh<br />
<br />
SOF OF COCOOOCOHH oooo<br />
<br />
noo<br />
<br />
aHwoOom oS<br />
<br />
SCrermnoceroouncoooon<br />
<br />
H<br />
<br />
_<br />
So Ot GOS &<br />
<br />
—<br />
<br />
Or Or Or Or<br />
<br />
Sr or oro ©<br />
<br />
10<br />
10<br />
10<br />
<br />
Or Or = OT<br />
<br />
eeceecscec<br />
<br />
eocococoaccococooeco ooco<br />
<br />
oocoo ooo<br />
<br />
@ASCoancoococooosoaso<br />
<br />
o><br />
~J<br />
<br />
tw<br />
—<br />
a<br />
<br />
Oct. 14, Michell, The Right Hon.<br />
Sir Lewis, C.V.O.<br />
<br />
Oct. 17, Ord, H. W. . i<br />
<br />
Oct. 20, Yorke-Smith, Mrs. .<br />
<br />
Nov. 10, Hood, Francis . i<br />
<br />
Nov. 20, Kennard, Mrs. N. H.<br />
<br />
wood uo<br />
~<br />
<br />
Cure © Ot<br />
<br />
coonanas<br />
<br />
1+<br />
<br />
COMMITTEE NOTES.<br />
<br />
—<br />
<br />
Tue Committee met at the offices of the<br />
Society on Monday, November 4th, and after<br />
the minutes of the previous meeting had been<br />
read and signed, proceeded to the election<br />
of members. Twenty-three were elected,<br />
bringing the total elections for the current<br />
year up to 313. There were two resignations.<br />
<br />
The solicitor reported on the cases with<br />
which he had dealt during the month.<br />
<br />
In two County Court cases judgment had<br />
been obtained, but as the judgments had<br />
not been satisfied he was proceeding to<br />
issue execution. In another case—against a<br />
music publisher—judgment had been obtained<br />
and the publisher had to pay the costs of the<br />
action. A curious case, chronicled in last<br />
month’s Author, against a book publisher, had<br />
arisen, in which the publisher, although the<br />
cost of production of the book had been<br />
defrayed by the author, refused to deliver the<br />
balance of the stock. As it was impossible<br />
to come to any agreement the solicitor<br />
reported he was about to issue process.<br />
In three other cases where no satisfactory<br />
replies could be obtained from the offenders,<br />
the solicitor had issued process. One case<br />
had sone very curious points, for the editor<br />
of a magazine had printed a story as by a well-<br />
known author, who had not, in fact, written<br />
it. The Society is commencing an action<br />
for literary libel and passing off. Two cases<br />
had been settled satisfactorily, the sums<br />
duz to the authors having been paid without<br />
the necessity of going into court, but in two<br />
other claims, as the defendants disputed the<br />
issues, it had become necessary to issue writs.<br />
Another action has had to be taken up against<br />
an American magazine on behalf of a member.<br />
<br />
Two cases involving the bankruptcy of<br />
publishers have occurred during the past<br />
month. In one ease the Society of Authors<br />
was given representation on the Com-<br />
mittee of Inspection, as representing the<br />
interests of authors. It is impossible to deal<br />
with these cases further until the liquidator<br />
68<br />
<br />
has been able to issue a report, but the com-<br />
mittee regret that quite a dozen members<br />
are involved in each bankruptcy, and perhaps<br />
more. In one other case in which a question<br />
had arisen concerning cinematograph rights<br />
the committee gave authority to take counsel’s<br />
opinion, upon which the author will no doubt<br />
act.<br />
<br />
The report of the Copyright Sub-Committee<br />
on the Australian Copyright Bill was laid before<br />
the committee, who authorised the secretary<br />
to present the report to the Premier of the<br />
Australian Commonwealth in the hope that<br />
the Society’s suggestions might meet with<br />
consideration, and, thereby, that the rights,<br />
not only of the Australian, but also of British<br />
authors, might be strengthened imperially<br />
and internationally.<br />
<br />
An important question of United States<br />
Copyright was laid before the committee by<br />
one of the Society’s correspondents in New<br />
York, and the secretary was instructed to<br />
obtain counsel’s opinion on the difficulty<br />
raised, and advice as to what action should be<br />
taken to bring the matter to the notice of the<br />
proper authorities.<br />
<br />
The secretary reported that Newfoundland<br />
had accepted the Copyright Act of 1911, and<br />
also called attention to some difficulties which<br />
had arisen owing to the fact that that Act had<br />
not as yet been proclaimed in India. He<br />
was authorised to take the necessary steps<br />
to draw the attention of the India Office to<br />
the difficulties in question.<br />
<br />
The working of the Copyright Act of 1911<br />
in its relations to our Colonies and Dependencies<br />
will bring, and is bringing, many difficult and<br />
important questions before the committee.<br />
<br />
Matters connected with the new branch of<br />
the Society, the Collection Bureau, were then<br />
discussed. It was decided to accept the<br />
recommendation of the Composers’ Sub-<br />
Committee, to collect the mechanical instru-<br />
ment fees under the Act of 1911, at the rate of<br />
15 per cent. commission, subject to the com-<br />
posers paying for the manufacture of their<br />
stamps. It was also decided to accept the<br />
recommendation of the Dramatic Sub-Com-<br />
mittee to collect the fees under contracts<br />
already entered into by those dramatists who<br />
were.members of the Society. for a commission<br />
of 5 per cent. It was further decided to keep<br />
a register of stamps to he placed on mechanical<br />
instruments at the Society’s office.<br />
<br />
The Composers’ Sub-Committee appointed<br />
two delegates to discuss important questions<br />
<br />
resulting from composers’ contracts with music<br />
publishers.<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
Mr. Maurice Hewlett, who has been a member<br />
of the committee for some years, and was<br />
chairman of that body’ from 1909 till 1911,<br />
having resigned from the committee owing to<br />
pressure of other work, the committee accepted<br />
his resignation with great regret, and instructed<br />
the secretary to write to him. Mr. Stanley<br />
Leathes, C.B., was elected to fill the vacancy,<br />
and has expressed his willingness to undertake<br />
the work.<br />
<br />
The committee then decided on_ the<br />
nominees to be put forward under the constitu-<br />
tion of the Society for election at the end of<br />
the year. The names of these nominees will”<br />
appear in The Author according to the regula-<br />
tions and rules laid down.<br />
<br />
Mr. E. J. MacGillivray was elected a member<br />
of the Council of the Society of Authors.<br />
Mr. MacGillivray has undertaken a_ great<br />
amount of. gratuitous work for the Society<br />
during the passing of the Copyright Bill, and<br />
has freely given his help to the Society on<br />
difficult copyright questions which have arisen.<br />
<br />
The next matter arose in connection with<br />
the advertisements in The Author. This was<br />
carefully considered by the committee, and the<br />
secretary was instructed to take the necessary<br />
steps to give effect to their decision. :<br />
<br />
Certain proposals laid before the committee<br />
by the Associated Booksellers of Great Britain<br />
and Ireland were. next considered, and it was<br />
decided to appoint a small sub-committee to<br />
confer with the Booksellers’ representatives,<br />
and to discuss the matters which their Associa-<br />
tion had raised. Mr. Aylmer Maude and Mr.<br />
G. Bernard Shaw kindly consented to act<br />
as a sub-committee, and the secretary was<br />
instructed to write to the Booksellers’ Associa-<br />
tion and to report progress at another meeting.<br />
<br />
A difficult matter arising out of multiple<br />
book-reviewing was discussed at some length,<br />
and the secretary was requested to write to<br />
the member who had introduced the matter,<br />
stating that the committee were considering it<br />
sympathetically but desired fuller information.<br />
<br />
The committee’s thanks were expressed to<br />
Mr. Thomas Common for a donation of £1 Is.<br />
to the Capital Fund of the Society, as a return<br />
for work accomplished by the Society on his<br />
behalf.<br />
<br />
—<br />
<br />
Dramatic SuB-COMMITTEE.<br />
<br />
Tur November meeting of the Dramatic<br />
Sub-Committee was held at the offices of the<br />
Society on the 15th. 2<br />
<br />
After reading the minutes of the previous<br />
<br />
meeting, the sub-committee considered a<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
proposal placed before them by a gentleman<br />
who is not a member of the Society, for<br />
the re-organization of the dramatic section of<br />
the Society, under certain new articles and<br />
rules that he had drafted for their con-<br />
sideration. These articles and rules had<br />
been circulated to the members of the sub-<br />
committee prior to the meeting. The sub-<br />
committee came to the conclusion that it was<br />
impossible to consider the suggestions and,<br />
after discussion, decided that the matter<br />
should be adjourned sine die.<br />
<br />
The secretary read to the sub-committee<br />
the answer he had received from the Society<br />
of West End Managers in regard to the<br />
Managerial Treaty.<br />
<br />
-- The question of twice-nightly performances<br />
of plays in Music Halls was then discussed,<br />
and the secretary reported information he<br />
had received in regard to the prices which<br />
could be charged for these performances. All<br />
possible information was placed by the<br />
members present at the secretary’s disposal,<br />
that he might be able to advise dramatic<br />
authors who should apply to him for informa-<br />
tion on their contracts.<br />
<br />
~The Translator’s Agreement was next con-<br />
sidered, and, with it, the question of the<br />
appointment of agents in foreign countries to<br />
deal with the work of members of the Society.<br />
<br />
Subject to confirmation by the committee<br />
of management an agent was appointed in<br />
Holland, and another in the United States.<br />
The secretary was instructed, also, to get into<br />
communication with an agent in Germany.<br />
<br />
The names of the agents will be published in<br />
The Author in full, after they have been duly<br />
appointed by the Committee of Management.<br />
<br />
A letter was read from a correspondent in<br />
Portugal who desired to act as agent of the<br />
Society, and the secretary was instructed to<br />
obtain information as to his standing and<br />
position. :<br />
<br />
The arrangements for the election of the<br />
Dramatic Sub-Committee for 1913 were next<br />
consideréd, and the secretary received instruc-<br />
tions to carry out the usual steps in due<br />
course.<br />
<br />
It was decided to hold the next meeting on<br />
the second Friday in December, as the third<br />
Friday brought the date too close to Christmas.<br />
<br />
— 1<br />
Composers’ SuB-CoMMITTEE.<br />
<br />
I.<br />
<br />
A SPECIAL meeting of the Composers’ Sub-<br />
Committee was held on Saturday, October 26th,<br />
<br />
69<br />
<br />
in order to re-discuss the relations between the<br />
Society of Authors and the Mechanical-<br />
Copyright Licences Co., and the question of<br />
mechanical instrument fees. The secretary<br />
read to the sub-committee certain letters<br />
which he had written to the representative<br />
of the Mechanical Copyright Licences Co. in<br />
the spring of the year, and the secretary<br />
received instructions to draft a further letter<br />
dealing with the terms of contract.<br />
<br />
The question of performing rights was also<br />
dealt with, and the secretary read a letter he<br />
had received from the Music Publishers’<br />
Association. It was decided not to drop<br />
negotiations, but to persevere in the hope that<br />
some good might, in the end, be achieved by<br />
joint action.<br />
<br />
IT.<br />
<br />
Tue Composers’ Sub-Committee met again<br />
on Saturday, November 16th, at the offices of<br />
the Society.<br />
<br />
The first matter under discussion referred to<br />
a publisher’s agreement and the clauses which<br />
it contained. The secretary laid a letter he<br />
had_reecived from the publishers in answer to<br />
a communication from the Society of Authors,<br />
written under the instructions of the sub-<br />
committee, and the secretary was instructed to<br />
reply to the same, drafting a letter which should<br />
be approved by the chairman.<br />
<br />
The secretary then laid a letter before the<br />
committee that he had received from one of<br />
the directors of the Mechanical-Copyright<br />
Licences Co., Ltd. It was decided, as it was<br />
important for the Society to have agents for<br />
the collection of fees in foreign countries, to<br />
write to those persons who represented the<br />
Society in’ other matters and enquire what<br />
provision was made in France, Germany, and<br />
elsewhere, for the collection of fees on<br />
mechanical instrument reproductions, and the<br />
secretary was instructed, when the information<br />
came to hand, to lay the whole matter again<br />
before the sub-committee with a view to<br />
appointing reliable agents.<br />
<br />
The question of a united combination with<br />
the publishers in order to establish fees<br />
on performing rights was again considered.<br />
The secretary informed the sub-committee<br />
that he had had a conversation with Mr. Dixey,<br />
secretary of the Music Publishers’ Association.<br />
It was finally proposed that the secretary<br />
should write to the secretary of the Music<br />
Publishers’ Association, putting before him<br />
certain matters which could, with benefit to<br />
both parties, be discussed between the com-<br />
posers and the Music Publishers’ Association,<br />
<br />
<br />
@ _Adey, More<br />
<br />
70<br />
<br />
in the hope that the Music Publishers’ Asso- ~ Burnett,<br />
<br />
ciation would be willing to form a small sub-<br />
committee to consider the matter, The four<br />
main points put forward were :—<br />
<br />
1. The main principles of contract.<br />
<br />
2. Performing right fees,<br />
<br />
3. Mechanical instrument reproductions,<br />
<br />
4, Cost of production.<br />
<br />
Finally, the secretary laid a series of letters<br />
from the companies which were reproducing<br />
the composers’ works on mechanical instru-<br />
ments, promising their assistance in cases of<br />
infringement of copyright.<br />
<br />
—_1—~>+ —<br />
<br />
Cases.<br />
<br />
Tue number of cases taken up during the<br />
past month still keeps up the average.<br />
<br />
There have been four cases dealing with the<br />
question of the settlement of the exact terms of<br />
contract. These cases generally involve a<br />
certain amount of negotiation. One case has<br />
been satisfactorily settled, and correspondence<br />
is still going on with regard to the others.<br />
<br />
There have been five cases for the return of<br />
MSS. In three cases the MSS. have been<br />
returned. One case in Australia is necessarily<br />
not yet completed, and the last one has come<br />
only recently into the hands of the secretary.<br />
<br />
There have been five claims for accounts and<br />
money. Three of these have been settled,<br />
one has been placed in the hands of the Society’s<br />
solicitors and the other has only recently come<br />
to hand.<br />
<br />
Of two cases for money one is still in the<br />
course of negotiation and the other has been<br />
placed in the hands of the solicitors.<br />
<br />
Out of sixteen cases, therefore, six have been<br />
settled. This is a good average for one<br />
month.<br />
<br />
The cases still left over from past months<br />
are slowly closing up. Where the secretary<br />
has been unable to deal with them they have<br />
been handed over to the solicitors.<br />
<br />
a oo<br />
<br />
Elections.<br />
<br />
The Burlingion<br />
Magazine, 17, Old<br />
Burlington Street,<br />
W.<br />
<br />
‘* Hillside,” Strath-<br />
cona Park,<br />
Ottawa, Canada ;<br />
Royal Societies<br />
Club, S.W.<br />
<br />
Ami, Henry M., M.A.,<br />
D.Sc., F.R.S. (Canada)<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
Miss Olive<br />
Compton<br />
De Rehyn, Cyril .<br />
Ferguson, Dugald<br />
Florian, A.R., M.A.<br />
<br />
Haig, Kenneth George .<br />
Hare-Dean, Mrs. N.<br />
<br />
Harris, Clement Antro-<br />
bus.<br />
<br />
Lee, George ‘“ Wing-<br />
shaft.”<br />
<br />
MacDonald, Mrs..<br />
<br />
Moore, Edith Mary<br />
<br />
Nesfield, Miss Frances<br />
Emily<br />
<br />
Percival, Archibald<br />
<br />
Stanley<br />
Picciotto, Cyril<br />
Rawlence, Guy<br />
Sichel, Miss Edith<br />
Theobald, Harry.<br />
<br />
Wenyon-Samuel Alex-<br />
ander<br />
<br />
Wriothesley, William,<br />
<br />
Wyton, Mrs. Alice<br />
<br />
Lyceum Club, Pieca-<br />
dilly, W.<br />
<br />
Edinburgh.<br />
<br />
Tapanui, Otago, New<br />
Zealand.<br />
<br />
Priory Lodge,<br />
Shrewsbury.<br />
<br />
7, Brook Street,<br />
Hanover Square,<br />
W.<br />
<br />
Writers’ Club, 10,<br />
Norfolk Street,<br />
<br />
Strand, W.C.<br />
Ellangowan, Crieff, ©<br />
<br />
8, Vale<br />
Spital,<br />
field.<br />
<br />
80, Auckland Road,<br />
Tiford. :<br />
<br />
Glan Aber, Purley;<br />
Surrey.<br />
<br />
c/o Messrs. Edghill<br />
Soulby, Clarence<br />
Park, Weston-<br />
super-Mare.<br />
<br />
17, Claremont Place,<br />
<br />
Newcastle-on-Tyne.<br />
<br />
54, Warrington Cres-<br />
cent, W. :<br />
<br />
The Chantry, Wilton<br />
Salisbury.<br />
<br />
42, Onslow Gardens,<br />
S.W<br />
<br />
37, Essex Street,<br />
Strand, W.C.<br />
<br />
22, Lissenden Man-<br />
sions, Highgate<br />
Road, N.W.<br />
<br />
c/o. Messrs. Brown,<br />
Shipley & Co.<br />
123, Pall Mall,<br />
S.W.<br />
<br />
145, Woolstone<br />
Road, Forest_Hill,<br />
S.E. a<br />
<br />
Terrace,<br />
Chester-<br />
<br />
1 —_—___ —<br />
<br />
BOOKS PUBLISHED BY MEMBERS.<br />
<br />
—_t——+ ——<br />
<br />
While every effort is made by the ccmpilers to keep<br />
this list as accurate and exhaustive as possible, they have<br />
some difficulty in attaining this object owing to the fact<br />
that many of the books mentioned are not sent to the office<br />
by the members. In consequence, it is necessary to rely<br />
largely upon lists of books which appear in literary and<br />
other papers. It is hoped, however, that members will<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
i es ee a ty a es<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. 71<br />
<br />
co-operate in the compiling of this list and, by sending<br />
particulars of their works, help to make it substantially<br />
accurate.<br />
<br />
AGRICULTURE.<br />
<br />
By Frepsrick No&kt-Paton, Director-<br />
Calcutta<br />
<br />
Burma Rice.<br />
General of Commercial Intelligence, India.<br />
Superintendent Government Printing. 94.<br />
<br />
ANTHROPOLOGY.<br />
<br />
THE ORIGIN OF CIVILISATION AND THE PRIMITIVE ConpI-<br />
TION or Man. By Tue Ricutr Hon. toe Lorp AVEBURY.<br />
Seventh Edition. 9 x 6. 484 pp. Longmans.<br />
7s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
ART.<br />
<br />
A History or Enctisn Grass Paryrinc. By Maurice<br />
Drake. Ilustrated by 36 plates from drawings by<br />
Wirrep Drake. 133 x 8. 226 pp. Werner<br />
Laurie. £2 2s. n:<br />
<br />
BIOGRAPHY.<br />
<br />
Tae Diaries or Wiriaam Cuartes Macreapy (1833<br />
ag Edited by Wiutiam Toynser, Chapman &<br />
all.<br />
Scenes anp Memories. By Warsurca Lapy Pacer.<br />
8 x 54. 325 pp. Smith Elder. 7s. 6d. n.<br />
Mary QUEEN oF Scots. By Hirpa T. SKar.<br />
204 pp. Foulis. 5s. n.<br />
<br />
BOOKS FOR THE YOUNG.<br />
<br />
SWEETHEARTS aT Home. By S. R. Crockert.<br />
311 pp. Hodder & Stoughton. 6s.<br />
<br />
Tue Macic Wortp. By E. Nessrr. Illustrations by<br />
H. R. Mintar & Spencer Pryse. 73 x 5}. 280 pp.<br />
Macmillan. 6s.<br />
<br />
Tue Brrv’s Curistmas Carot. By Kare Dovcuas<br />
Wiecin. Illustrated. by Karuartne RB. WISEMAN.<br />
82 x 6}. 90 pp. Gay & Hancock. 3s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
7% x +54.<br />
<br />
8i x 6.<br />
<br />
DRAMA,<br />
<br />
Tur Tria or JEANNE D’Arc, an Historical Play in Five<br />
Acts. By Epwarp Garnerr. 74 x 5. 79 pp.<br />
Sidgwick & Jackson. 3s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
Wacner’s Tristan und Isoxpz, An Essay on the<br />
Wagnerian Drama. By G. A. Hicur. 8} x 53.<br />
281 pp. Stephen Swift. 5s. n.<br />
<br />
ECONOMICS.<br />
<br />
Szasonat Traps. By various writers. Introduction<br />
by Stpyey Wess. Edited by SipNey Wess AND<br />
Agnotp Freeman. 8} x 5}. 410 pp. Constable.<br />
“Ts. 64. n. ,<br />
<br />
ENGINEERING.<br />
<br />
A Primer on THE INTERNAL ComBUSTION ENGINE. By<br />
H. E. Wimperis. 73 x 5. 143 pp. Constable.<br />
2s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
FICTION.<br />
Come Rack! Come Ropz. By R. H. Benson. Ti Xx 5,<br />
<br />
Alston Riyers. 6s. 7 yay<br />
<br />
Barriers. By Tar Hon. Mrs. Juuian Byna. 7% X 5h.<br />
380 pp. Holden & Hardingham.<br />
<br />
Tue Distant Lame. By Harotp Bzcsre. 12 xX 6,<br />
294 pp. Hodder & Stoughton. 6s.<br />
<br />
Tue Private Lire op Henry Maituanp. A Record<br />
Dictated by J. H. Revised and edited by Moruzy<br />
Roperts. 74 x 5. 316 pp. Nash. 6s.<br />
<br />
Mratam Lucas. By Canon Suuguay, D.D. 7% x 5.<br />
<br />
By ANATOLE<br />
9 x 6.<br />
<br />
ASPIRATIONS OF JEAN SERVIEN.<br />
Translation by ALFRED ALIINSON.<br />
Lane. 6s.<br />
<br />
By Frorence L. Barcuay.<br />
3s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
ConstaANCE SMEDLEY (Mrs.<br />
343 pp. Religious Tract<br />
<br />
TE<br />
FRANCE.<br />
234 pp.<br />
<br />
Tue Upas TREE.<br />
246 pp. Putnam.<br />
<br />
Ruty’s Marriace. By<br />
Maxwell Armfield), 8 < St.<br />
Society. 6s.<br />
<br />
THe Woornc oF Miranwy. By Eprru C. Kenyon.<br />
7} x 5}. 344 pp. Holden & Hardingham. 6s.<br />
<br />
Taines THAT Pass. By Atice E. Ropsins. 7} x 5}.<br />
319 pp. Melrose. 6s.<br />
<br />
A Grove or Noster Dames AND THE WetL Betovep. A<br />
Sketch of a Temperament. By Tuomas Harpy.<br />
9 x 6. Macmillan. 7s. 6d. n. each.<br />
<br />
Tue Broap Hignway. A Romance of Kent. By<br />
JEFFREY Farnov. Illustrations by C. E. Brook.<br />
9} x 63. 493 pp. Sampson Low. 10s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
Fotrowinc Darkness. By Forrest Rerp. 7? x 5.<br />
320 pp. Arnold. 6s.<br />
<br />
St. L6 By Dororny Marcarer Sruart. 337 pp.<br />
Holden & Hardingham. 6s.<br />
<br />
Tur Mystertovs Monstrur Dvuvant.<br />
(Author of “ John Merridew,” &c.).<br />
THe JUNE Lapy. By R. E. VeRNEDE. 7} x 5.<br />
<br />
Constable. és.<br />
<br />
Tue Rest Presence. By Una L. SmBERRAD.<br />
55 pp. Hodder & Stoughton. Is. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
Sesarorp’s Snake. By Berrram Mrrrorp.<br />
320 pp. Ward Lock. 6s.<br />
<br />
Corn in Ecypr. By E. Newrox BunNGEY.<br />
286 pp. Lynwood. 6s.<br />
<br />
THe Canusac Mystery. By K. anp HESKeETa<br />
Pricnarp. 74 x 43. 340 pp. Heinemann. 6s.<br />
<br />
At Waat Sacririce? By Annre O. Trppits. 74 x 5,<br />
286 pp. Digby, Lone. 6s. The Caszr or RicHaRD<br />
Meynett. By Mrs. Humenry Warp. New Edition.<br />
7} x 5. 525 pp. Smith Elder. 2s. n.<br />
<br />
No Surrenper. By Constance ExizapetH Mavp.<br />
7k x 5. 328 pp. Cheaper re-issue. Duckworth.<br />
28. 1.<br />
<br />
WINAFRINT, VIRGIN.<br />
Ham Smith. 6s,<br />
<br />
Tue House Opposits.<br />
Eveleigh Nash. 6s.<br />
<br />
Tae Man with tHE Briack FEATHER.<br />
Leroux. Translated by Epaar Jepson. 7}<br />
314 pp. Hurst & Blackett. 6s.<br />
<br />
A Recutar Mapam. By Arice Witson Fox. 7} x 5,<br />
348 pp. Macraillan. 6s.<br />
<br />
Tue Jew or Pracun. By A. Witson Barrert.<br />
31ll pp. F. V. White. 6s.<br />
<br />
A Base iy Bonemia. By FranK Dansy.<br />
288 pp. Stanley Paul. 6s.<br />
<br />
Tar ENLIGHTENMENT oF Sytyrs. By A. D. PrckmRinea.<br />
74 x 5. 310 pp. John Murray. 6s.<br />
<br />
GARDENING.<br />
<br />
Tue Rock GarpEN. By Rearnayp Farrer.<br />
(Present Day Gardening). 84 6}. Jack.<br />
<br />
HYGIENIC,<br />
<br />
Thr PrincipLEs oF HEALTH AND<br />
Mrs, Huns H. Cuapwick. 7} x 5.<br />
& Sons. ls. 3d. n.<br />
<br />
JUVENILE.<br />
<br />
Aunt Pex. A Book for Young Girls. By L. E.<br />
TippEMAN, S.P.C.K. 2s. 6d.<br />
<br />
A Crry Scnoon Girt anp Her Frienps. By May<br />
Batpwin. 74 x 5}. 370 pp. Campers Heart 0’<br />
Gotp, or Tar Lirrte Princess. By KaraaRine<br />
TyNnAN. 7} x 5}. 344 pp. Partridge. 3s. 67.<br />
<br />
72 x Bh.<br />
<br />
By F. ARTHUR<br />
John Murray.<br />
304 pp.<br />
8 x 5h.<br />
72 x SE<br />
<br />
7k x 43.<br />
<br />
By W.SHerReN. 7} x 5. 318 pp.<br />
<br />
By “ Reva.” 72 xf. 306 pp.<br />
<br />
By Gaston<br />
x 4.<br />
<br />
72 x 5.<br />
72 =< Sh.<br />
<br />
Illustrated.<br />
ls. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
TeMPeRANCE. By<br />
Sir Isaac Pitman<br />
72<br />
<br />
A Story of Adventure<br />
<br />
Tue Bravest Boy IN THE CAMP. i re<br />
7% x 5.<br />
<br />
on the Western Prairies. By R. Letcuton.<br />
285 pp. Jarrold. 2s. 6d. n.<br />
Tne Prrate AEROPLANE. By CaprarNn CHARLES GILsoNn.<br />
71 x 5}. 327 pp. Frowde & Hodder & Stoughton. ~5s.<br />
Grayxt Tur Grenapier. His Adventures in the Fighting<br />
Fifth in the Peninsula. By Wattrr Woop. 326 pp.<br />
Routledge. 3s. Gl.<br />
Prerer THE PowpEr-Boy.<br />
of the Days of Nelson.<br />
THE ComMINnG oF CARLINA.<br />
to Twelve. By L. E. TIDDEMAN.<br />
<br />
By Water Woop. A Tale<br />
317 pp. Routledge. 3s. 6d.<br />
A Book for Children from Ten<br />
<br />
Jarrold. 2s. 6d.<br />
<br />
Waerpe THE Ratnsow Enps. A_ Fairy Story. By<br />
Clifford Mills. 7 x 43. 160 pp. Hodder & Stoughton.<br />
1s. n.<br />
<br />
Currosrry Kats. By Frorence Bonz. 7} x 54.<br />
320 pp. Partridge. 2s. 6d.<br />
<br />
ANGELIQUE. By Constance ExizapeTH Maup. 7} x 9.<br />
265 pp. Duckworth. 6s.<br />
<br />
Tue ADVENTURES OF SitveRsuIT. Pictures by ANGUSINE<br />
<br />
Macarecor. Verses by Jxesste Porr. 9} x 7.<br />
Blackie. 1s. 6d.<br />
<br />
Tue Turee Joviat Purrres. By J. A. SHEPHERD.<br />
Rhymes by E. D. Cumtna. 10} x 7}. Blackie.<br />
3s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
Tue Brrps’ Curistmas Caron. By Kate Doveras<br />
Wiccry. 72 pp. Illustrated by F.E. Hiruy. 6} x 4.<br />
Gay & Hancock. 1s, 6d. n. each.<br />
<br />
LAW.<br />
Tre Law or Copyricut. By L. C. D. OLprigLp. Second<br />
<br />
Edition. 350 pp. Stevens & Sons. 26s.<br />
<br />
LITERARY.<br />
<br />
Portraits AND SkETcHES. By Epmunp Goss, C.B.<br />
73 x 5}. 296 pp. Heinemann. 6s. n.<br />
<br />
Persian LIrERATURE. By CLaup FIELD.<br />
Herbert & Daniel. 3s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
LETTERS FROM SOLITUDE AND OTHER Essays. By Fitson<br />
Younc. 73 x 5. 317 pp. Chapman & Hall. 5s. n.<br />
Smrpuiciry anp Torstoy. By G. K. Caesrerton. A<br />
Rocur’s Memorrs, &c. By AvGUSTINE \BrRRELL.<br />
Bexsonrana. By E. F. Benson. 6 x 43. Hum-<br />
<br />
phreys. 2s. 6d. n. each. 4<br />
Srupres anp Apprectations. By Darreut. 3 Freats.<br />
83 x 53. 258 pp. Dent. 5s. n. ;<br />
Tur AcapEmMIc CommiTrer. Browning’s Centenary,<br />
Edmund Gosse, Sir Arthur Pinero, Henry James.<br />
Tuesday, May 7th, 1912. Reprinted from ‘Trans-<br />
<br />
7 x 5. 363 pp.<br />
<br />
actions ot the Royal Society of Literature. Vol.XXXI<br />
Part IV. 8} x 53. 50 pp. Asher. 3s.<br />
Sampnrre. By Lapy Sysm Grant. 7} x 5. 307 pp.<br />
<br />
Stanley Paul. 3s. 6d. n.<br />
ScortisH Lire anpD Porrry. By Lavuciuian MacLean<br />
Warr. 9 x 53. 509 pp. Nisbet. 12s. 6d. n.<br />
MacatLay’s Essay on Appison. By N. L. Hattwarp.<br />
<br />
Lonemans’ Brivisu Ciassics.FoR Inpra. Longmans.<br />
MILITARY.<br />
Can, Germany Invape Enctanp? By Con. H. B.<br />
Hanna. 71 Xx 43. 159 pp. Methuen. 1s. n.<br />
Turiuine Tares oF Great Events. Re-told from<br />
Survivors’ Narratives. By Waurer Woop. 332 pp.<br />
Routledge. 3s. 6d.<br />
MISCELLANEOUS.<br />
UNEMPLOYMENT AND DrsEasus. Caused by Decay and<br />
<br />
Loss of ‘Teeth. Wm. Dawson &<br />
<br />
Sons. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
By a Dental Surgeon.<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
NATURAL<br />
<br />
NERVATION or Pants.<br />
<br />
Illustrated. 74 x 5.<br />
3s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
Basy Brrps at Home. By Ricnarp Kmarton. TIllus-<br />
<br />
trated from Photographs. By CnHEerry and Graok<br />
<br />
HISTORY.<br />
<br />
By Francis Guorce Heats.<br />
186 pp. Williams & Norgate.<br />
<br />
Kearton. 8} x 53. 128 pp. Cassell. 6s.<br />
Tue Brrps or Austrauia. By 8. L. Marnews. Vol. IL.<br />
Part TV. 144 x 10. 359—476 pp. Witherby.<br />
NAVAL.<br />
Tue Barrizsuir. By Waiter Woop. Crown quarto.<br />
309 pp. Kegan Paul. 12s. 6d. n.<br />
POETRY.<br />
<br />
Rivostes of Ezra Pounp. Whereto are appended the<br />
complete poetical works of T. E. Hume, with prefatory<br />
note. 73 x 54. 63 pp. Swift. 2s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
Aw IpyLt AND OTHER Poems. By E. Hamitron Moors.<br />
74 x 5. 112 pp. Melrose. 2s. n.<br />
<br />
Eaypt AND OTHER Porms. By Francis Courts.<br />
122 pp. Lane. 3s. 6d. n/<br />
<br />
Fatvuous FaBies AND OTHER VERSES.<br />
(X.Y,X.).<br />
<br />
Tk x 5.<br />
<br />
By Denis TURNER<br />
6} x 44. 94pp. Fifield. 2s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
REPRINTS.<br />
<br />
Porste VoLGARI DI Lorenzo De®’ MeEpict.<br />
Janet Ross e di Epwarp Huuton. Two volumes,<br />
83 x 6}. 221 + 240 pp. Dent. 2ls. n.<br />
<br />
SeLecteD Waritincs or Wituiam Swarr. Vol. V.<br />
Vistas. THe Gresy Carist, and other Prose Imaginings.<br />
Selected and arranged by Mrs. Witniam SHarRp.<br />
73 x 54. 484 pp. Heinemann. 5s. n.<br />
<br />
SCIENCE.<br />
<br />
Tur Story oF THE Heavens. By Sir Roperr §. Bani.<br />
Illustrated. 93 x 6}. 48 pp. Part. I. To be<br />
completed in 14 fortnightly parts. Cassell. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
Crramic CuEmistry. By H. H. Stepnenson. 10 x 6}.<br />
91 pp. Davis Bros. 6s.<br />
<br />
SOCIOLOGY.<br />
Woman anp To-Morrow. By W. L. Grorcez.<br />
<br />
A Cura di<br />
<br />
72 x 5h.<br />
<br />
187 pp. Herbert Jenkins. 2s. 6d. n.<br />
Tur Servite State. By Hmarre Betioc. 8 X 5}.<br />
189 pp. Foulis. 1s. n.<br />
Wacrs. By A. J. Cantyiz, D.Lirr. 7} x 5. 125 pp.<br />
Mowbray. 2s. n.<br />
SPORT.<br />
Huntinc in THE OtpEn Days. By Witusam ScarTe<br />
Dixon. Constable. 21s, n.<br />
TECHNICAL.<br />
<br />
Tar Businrss oF BooKBINDING.<br />
7k x 4%. 223 pp. Stanley Paul.<br />
<br />
THEOLOGY.<br />
<br />
Mrprrations on Portions or St. Jonn’s Gosprn. By<br />
Mrs. Romanes. 5% x 44. 49 pp. Mowbray. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
Everyman’s History oF THE Prayer Boox. By Tus<br />
Rev. Percy Drarmer, D.D. 74 x 5}. 256 pp.<br />
Mowbray. ls. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
TOPOGRAPHY.<br />
<br />
A Votume on Exeter. Described by Smpney Heats,<br />
with pictures by E. W. Hastenurst. (Black’s<br />
“ Beautiful England’? Series of Colour books.) 9/x 7.<br />
64 pp. A. & C. Black. 2s. n.<br />
<br />
By A. J. Pui.<br />
6s. n. :<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. 73<br />
<br />
[Tur CoTTAGERS AND THE VILLAGE Lire or RURAL<br />
Enetanp. By P. H. Dircurietp. With coloured and<br />
line illustrations by A.R. Quinton. 10} x 8}. 185 pp.<br />
Dent. 21s. n.<br />
<br />
Exurer. By Smyey Huars. Prepared by E. H.<br />
HastEnurst. 9 x 64. 64pp. Blackie. 2s. n.<br />
<br />
TRAVEL.<br />
<br />
THe OLp GarpENs oF ITraty. How to Visit Them. By<br />
Mrs. AvBrEy LE Bronp. 72 x 5. 171 pp. Lane<br />
5s. n,<br />
<br />
————————_+——_—__<br />
<br />
LITERARY, DRAMATIC, AND MUSICAL<br />
NOTES.<br />
<br />
—<br />
<br />
Some three or four years ago it might have<br />
been said that the day of the essay was over.<br />
No publisher would produce a collection in book<br />
form, because it did not pay, and that is the<br />
main point in a properly conducted business ;<br />
but now the book of essays seems to have come<br />
again into popular favour, and we are pleased<br />
to see two volumes from such old friends and<br />
well-known essayists as Mr. Austin Dobson and<br />
Mr. Edmund Gosse. Mr. Dobson’s book is<br />
entitled ‘“‘ At Prior Park and other Papers,”<br />
and is published by Messrs. Chatto & Windus.<br />
It deals in matters of interest in the 18th<br />
century, a period of which the author has made<br />
himself a master. Mr. Gosse’s book is entitled<br />
“* Portraits and Sketches,”’ and is published by<br />
Mr. Heinemann. Its title explains itself. The<br />
author draws with a strong pen portraits and<br />
sketches of some of the famous men he has met.<br />
<br />
Messrs. Methuen & Co. have published<br />
“* Perfect Health for Women and Children,” by<br />
Elizabeth Sloan Chesser, at the moderate price<br />
of 3s. 6d. Whilst in no sense a medical text<br />
book, the book aims at supplying intelligent<br />
women with useful information about health<br />
and sickness. Some of the subjects dealt<br />
with, such as “Nerves and their Cure,”<br />
“Health and .Open Air,” ‘“ Infectious<br />
Diseases,”’ ‘“‘ Winter Ailments,”’ will show the<br />
scope of the work.<br />
<br />
The same publishers have issued a volume<br />
of poems by Mrs. L. F. Wynne Ffoulkes entitled<br />
** Poems of Life and Form.”’ She has repro-<br />
duced most of the old French metres, such<br />
as Roundels, Roundeaux, Triolets, Virelais,<br />
Villanelles, etc. One form, however, is not<br />
present, the “ Chante Royale,”’ perhaps the<br />
most difficult of any of the French metres.<br />
The subjects of her poems vary from poems<br />
of love to poems of mysticism ; from- poems<br />
written in dialogue, such as “ Joe’ and ‘‘ The<br />
Old ’oss,’’ to descriptive verse such as ‘* Ruth,”<br />
a setting of the Bible story.<br />
<br />
Mrs. Walford, the well-known novelist,<br />
has written her ‘‘ Memories of Victorian<br />
London,” and the book has been published by<br />
Mr. Arnold. It deals with certain aspects of<br />
London social life during the latter part of the<br />
last century. Mrs. Walford has new things to<br />
tell us about people like Laurence Oliphant,<br />
Charles Reade, George Macdonald, Wilkie<br />
Collins, and Coventry Patmore.<br />
<br />
Among the most notable of the present<br />
season’s publications, are ‘“‘ The Diaries of<br />
William Charles Macready (1833—1851), edited<br />
by William Toynbee,” which has been issued<br />
by Messrs. Chapman & Hall, Ltd., in two<br />
large volumes, with numerous portraits. These<br />
Diaries contain a considerable amount of<br />
interesting material, hitherto unpublished,<br />
and shed new light not only on Macready him-<br />
self, but on many of his famous contemporaries<br />
in the literary and dramatic world.<br />
<br />
* Our Alty,” by M. E. Francis (Mrs. Francis<br />
Blundell), author of ‘‘ The Tender Passion,”<br />
etc., is the title of a new novel which Messrs.<br />
John Long will shortly publish. Mrs. Blundell<br />
here returns to rural Lancashire, where many<br />
of her readers deem her at her best. The story<br />
deals with the adventures of a typical North-<br />
country lass. The description of the old-world<br />
customs and quaint characters of this corner<br />
of England adds an interest to the tale.<br />
<br />
Mr. Arnold Bennett states in his book,<br />
“Those United States,” published by Martin<br />
Secker, ‘‘ the one possible justification of them<br />
[his views] is that they offer to the reader the<br />
one thing that, in the very nature of the case,<br />
a mature and accustomed observer could not<br />
offer, namely an immediate account (as<br />
accurate as I could make it) of the first tre-<br />
mendous impact of the United States on a<br />
mind receptive and unprejudiced.”” But sure<br />
this view-point put forward as an apology is<br />
after all a great recommendation, when it is<br />
frankly stated by the author. A reader may<br />
object to the dogmatic assertions set down<br />
so often by those whose knowledge is superficial,<br />
and whose study is of the slightest ; but when<br />
he is met by this frank statement, the book<br />
gathers to itself a greater interest, as all those<br />
who have perused the book will readily allow.<br />
<br />
Mr. Morley Roberts will gladden the hearts<br />
of his admirers by the production of ‘“ The<br />
Private Life of Henry Maitland,’”’ published<br />
by Eveleigh Nash. It is presumably a-novel,<br />
but it is an open secret that it is a study of<br />
the life of his old friend George Gissing. There<br />
are no doubt dangers surrounding the writing<br />
a life of a close friend. If the author is<br />
<br />
over-critical or over-conscientious, he may<br />
74<br />
<br />
convey to the world a portrait exactly opposed<br />
to that he may wish to convey, if he is over-<br />
enthusiastic he may idealise. Those interested<br />
in George Gissing as a writer and a man<br />
should certainly read the book. The author<br />
of ‘‘ The Private Papers of Henry Ryecroft ”<br />
deserves a just appreciation.<br />
<br />
Among the illustrated books we are pleased<br />
to see Mr. Rackham’s annual appearance with<br />
a volume of Ausop’s Fables. There is no need<br />
to praise, for Mr. Rackham’s Christmas books<br />
have become an institution. The get-up of the<br />
book in the limjted edition is excellent, and the<br />
new translations of the classicare commendable.<br />
<br />
At the present season of the year fairy<br />
stories sprout up like snowdrops in the grass.<br />
We gladly welcome Mrs. E. Nesbit’s ‘‘ The<br />
Magic World,” published by Messrs. Mac-<br />
millan & Co., with illustrations by H. R.<br />
Millar and Spencer Pryse; and Miss Helen<br />
Margaret Dixon has produced, through Cornish<br />
Brothers, Ltd., Birmingham, “‘ Little Wander-<br />
ing Gil,” and other stories, prettily illustrated<br />
by photogravure reproductions from original<br />
photographs. This effective method of illus-<br />
tration is too seldom utilised. Much, however,<br />
must depend on the artistry of the original.<br />
<br />
Mr. Forbes Dawson has a series of articles<br />
running through the Era entitled ‘‘ Who<br />
wouldn’t be an Actor?’’ He portrays in a<br />
humorous manner the scenes in the life of an<br />
actor who has been stormed, has helped to<br />
build the stage on which he performed, has<br />
written dramas for production, and worked his<br />
way through the French Canadian towns and<br />
along the line to California. They will most<br />
probably be published in book form subse-<br />
quently.<br />
<br />
The relation between modern science and<br />
present day Christianity is a theme of peren-<br />
nial interest. The Rev. Luther W. Caws’ book,<br />
just published by James Clarke & Co. : “‘ The<br />
Unveiled Glory, or Sidelights on the Higher<br />
Evolution,” has come at an opportune moment<br />
when the origin of life discussed at the British<br />
Association meetings has aroused a fresh<br />
public interest in the life-long drama of<br />
evolution.<br />
incredible that the evolution of life, if it really<br />
is so, from the lowest and simplest forms up<br />
to the highest animals, including man, could<br />
possibly have been the offspring of blind<br />
chance.<br />
<br />
We regret an error in our announcement of<br />
Messrs. Everett’s sevenpenny reprint of Miss<br />
Amy McLaren’s novel. The title of the novel<br />
is ‘* Bawbee Jock,” and not as given in our<br />
previous notice.<br />
<br />
The author maintains that it is.<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
Mrs. Wilson Fox’s new story, “A Regular<br />
Madam,” is a tale of the eightecnth century.<br />
Messrs. Macmillan & Co. are the publishers.<br />
<br />
Miss Lillias Campbell Davidson’s new novel,<br />
“Houses of Clay,’ published by Messrs.<br />
Partridge & Co. at 6s., is now out. The<br />
Lady is running its second serial by her this<br />
year: entitled ‘“‘ A Tangled Inheritance,” and<br />
another serial, ‘The Primitive Law,” is<br />
announced to appear in The Lady’s World<br />
in April next.<br />
<br />
Miss L. G. Moberly’s latest novel, ‘‘ Violet<br />
Dunstan,”’ has just been published by Messrs.<br />
Ward, Lock & Co. It ran serially last year in<br />
the Daily Chronicle. Miss Moberly has now<br />
written several serials for the Daily Chronicle<br />
and Lloyd’s Weekly ; and new novels, “‘ Diana ”’<br />
and “ A Very Doubtful Experiment,” both ran<br />
serially in The Lady. She is now writing a<br />
novel for Messrs. Methuen. Many of ther<br />
novels have been translated into the Scandi-<br />
navian languages, and some into French and<br />
German,—amongst the latter, ‘“‘ The Cost,” and<br />
“* Angela’s Marriage.”<br />
<br />
Mr. Charles T. Jacobi, of the Chiswick Press,<br />
whose “ Printing ” is a text book on its subject,<br />
is bringing out a new, revised (fourth) edition of<br />
his guide for Authors, Publishers, and others<br />
—‘‘ Some notes on Books and Printing.”<br />
<br />
At a most opportune moment a book is<br />
announced by Mr. John Lane on “ Austria,<br />
Her People and their Homelands.” It is a<br />
work cn the whole of Austria, and its complex<br />
population, by one who has for over thirty<br />
years studied the country through its<br />
entirety. Mr. James Baker, F.R.G.S., has<br />
already written much on various parts of<br />
Austria, and now this work, which is illustrated<br />
by forty-eight water colours by Donald Max-<br />
well, and completed by a map and full index,<br />
will help many to elucidate the real Austria and<br />
her people.<br />
<br />
Among the many colonial and foreign<br />
criticisms which have appeared on Mr. John<br />
Bloundelle-Burton’s historical work, ‘‘ The Fate<br />
of Henry of Navarre,” France is now con-<br />
tributing her opinions. The latest appears in<br />
the October number of La Science Sociale, a<br />
well-known magazine devoted to_ literary<br />
criticism, and covers three columns. It is<br />
signed Pierre Galichet, and the writer plainly<br />
tells his readers that they will glean a con-<br />
siderable amount of knowledge frcm the book<br />
about the matter in hand, as well as their own<br />
history—restée assez ohscure—which they have<br />
not possessed hitherto. He also laments that<br />
such a livre d'histoire de grande valeur should be<br />
only known at present to those acquainted<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. "5<br />
<br />
with the English language, and expresses the<br />
hope that a French translation will not be long<br />
delayed. ;<br />
<br />
“Ayrshire Idylls” is the title of a book<br />
about to be published by Messrs. A. and C.<br />
Black. It is the affectionate and patriotic<br />
work of two Scottish artists—of Dr. Neil Munro,<br />
whose pen, diverted, for the moment, from the<br />
romance of Highland life and character, redis-<br />
covers the spirit of Ayr as it was in another<br />
and more dramatic age, and of George Houston,<br />
the Scottish landscape painter, who has made<br />
the scenery of Ayr his life-long study. The<br />
author’s sketches reconstruct certain notable<br />
scenes in Ayrshire history, wherein such figures<br />
as Burns, Boswell and the Covenanters are dis-<br />
played at a modern angle ; the artist’s draw-<br />
ings represent, in the main, those landscape<br />
features which remain very much the same<br />
to-day as they have been for centuries.<br />
<br />
The subject of stained glass in England has<br />
never been dealt with in an exhaustive manner.<br />
It is a subject of interest to the public as well<br />
as to artists and antiquarians. It is with<br />
pleasure, therefore, that we see “‘ A History of<br />
English Glass Painting,’ by Morris Drake,<br />
published by Werner Laurie. The work—<br />
illustrated by photographs and drawings in<br />
colour and _half-tone—at the price of £2 2s.<br />
net, attempts to deal with the evolution of the<br />
subject in detail and from every point of view.<br />
<br />
Messrs. Holden & Hardingham have pub-<br />
lished a novel ‘“‘ St. Lé6,’? by Dorothy Margaret<br />
Stuart. Itis aromanceof the fifteenth century,<br />
introducing several historical characters, such<br />
as Maximilian of Austria, Louis XI., and<br />
Margaret of Burgundy. The details as to<br />
costume, heraldry and mise-en-scéne are<br />
derived from French and Flemish sources not<br />
accessible to most English students.<br />
<br />
We have received an announcement from<br />
Mr. Gerald Christy, of the Lecture Agency, Ltd.,<br />
that he is adding a literary agency to his<br />
business. The literary portion is to be under<br />
the conduct of Mr. Leonard P. Moore, who has<br />
had eleven years practical experience of<br />
agency work. The Agency will conduct its<br />
business from the old address, The Outer<br />
Temple, Strand, W.C.<br />
<br />
“* Mrs. Fauntleroy’s Nephew ”’ is the title of<br />
a story of Oxford life, by Beatrice Braithwaite-<br />
Batty. The hero is an undergraduate of<br />
Magdalen, whose pretty sister comes to stay<br />
with an old aunt during the summer term.<br />
During the festivities and gaicties, the sister<br />
draws around her a bewildering number of<br />
admirers. It must be left to the reader to<br />
discover the successful candidate. 5.<br />
<br />
“The Gods of Pegana,” by Lord Dunsany,<br />
for some while out of print, has been re-issued,<br />
and can now be obtained only from Mr. W.<br />
Johnson, The Pegana Studio, 86 Newman<br />
Street, Oxford Street, W.<br />
<br />
A copy of Mr. C. L. Freestons “‘ The Passes<br />
of the Pyrenees,’ has been accepted by<br />
His Majesty the King.<br />
<br />
Monsieur Georges Bazile is translating into<br />
French Mr. Robert Sherard’s ‘‘ The Story of<br />
an Unhappy Friendship,” for publication in<br />
serial form in Gil Blus, the great Parisian<br />
literary daily.<br />
<br />
Dramatic NOTES.<br />
<br />
- Towards the end of October, but too late<br />
for the November issue of this magazine, a<br />
piece entitled ‘“‘ Tantrums,” by Mr. Frank<br />
Stayton, was produced at the Criterion. The<br />
three acts turn around the tantrums of the<br />
spoilt Virginia Halstead. Miss Marjorie Day<br />
takes the part of Virginia, and Mr. Charles<br />
Maude plays the part of wooer and husband.<br />
<br />
Mr. J. T. Tanner’s ‘‘ The Dancing Mistress ”’<br />
was also too late for announcement. The<br />
piece was produced at the Adelphi, backed by<br />
the musie of Lionel Monckton; while Adrian<br />
Ross and Perey Greenbank were responsible<br />
for the lyrics. Miss Gertie Millar and Mr.<br />
Joseph Coyne took the chief parts. To hint<br />
at the plot will be sufficient to show the lines<br />
on which this musical comedy runs, for Naney<br />
Joyce (Miss Gertie Millar) is the dancing mistress<br />
at a finishing school for girls near Brighton.<br />
<br />
At the Garrick Theatre a one-act piece<br />
entitled ‘t Phipps,’”’ by Stanley Houghton, was<br />
produced on the 20th of last month, the<br />
characters were a butler and a recently married<br />
couple, The fact that the husband before<br />
marriage had met a certain young lady whom<br />
the butler had also fallen in with, affords the<br />
author an opportunity of giving the audience<br />
an enjoyable half-hour. Mr. Arthur Bourchier<br />
acted capitally as Mr. Phipps. The same<br />
author on the same night had a longer piece,<br />
“The Younger Generation,”’ produced at the<br />
Haymarket. It represents the eternal quarrel of<br />
the old and the new. The subject is set in a<br />
middle-class Manchester setting. The story is<br />
told with plain directness that carries convic-<br />
tion, and ends, as it was bound to end, in the<br />
triumph of the younger generation. Two<br />
pieces of a very different character were per-<br />
formed on the same night at the same theatre—<br />
““An Adventure of Aristide Pujol,” by W. J.<br />
Locke, which needs no introduction ; and “‘ The<br />
Golden Doom,” by Lord Dunsany, a fantastic<br />
allegory in a legendary kingdom.<br />
76 THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
On the 19th, Miss Marie Tempest produced<br />
three short plays for a series of Tuesday<br />
and Friday matinees. The first entitled<br />
‘‘An Imaginary Conversation,” by Norreys<br />
Connell, represented Kate, a sister of Tom<br />
Moore, endeavouring to turn Robert Emmet<br />
from the thoughts of rebellion to those of love.<br />
Miss Tempest as Kate, though unsuccessful as<br />
a lover, was most successful in her representa-<br />
tion of the part.<br />
<br />
“The Play Boy of the Western World,” by<br />
J.M. Synge, has been translated into German by<br />
Mr. G. Sil-Vara, a Viennese author, journalist<br />
and playwright, who has made London his<br />
second home. Mr. Sil-Vara_ succeeded in<br />
placing ‘The Playboy’ at Professor Rein-<br />
hardt’s ‘‘ Kammerspiele’’ in Berlin at the<br />
‘‘Neue Wiener Buchne ” in Vienna, and at the<br />
‘“‘ Stadttheater”” in Muenster. The German<br />
version, published by George Mueller in Munich,<br />
has just appeared in book form.<br />
<br />
Mr. Sil-Vara has also translated into German<br />
and possesses the German rights of ‘‘ Prunella,”<br />
by Granville Barker, “The Gods of the<br />
Mountain,” by Lord Dunsany, and ‘“‘ 98 and 9,”<br />
by C. B. Fernald, and other plays which have<br />
not yet heen produced; and Mr. Gals-<br />
worthy has just transferred to Mr. Sil-Vara the<br />
German rights of his future plays. Mr.<br />
Galsworthy’s play, a dramatic version of his<br />
novel “ The Eldest Son,” is produced at the<br />
Kingsway under Mr. Granville Barker’s<br />
management.<br />
<br />
““The Triumph,” a play by Florence Eaton<br />
and William Crossing, founded on Florence<br />
Eaton’s book, ‘‘ The White Demon,” was<br />
produced at the Royal Court Theatre. It is<br />
a fairy play, the main motif being the pursuit<br />
of health, and the triumph over the all-<br />
powerful demon “* Consumption.”<br />
<br />
A short play, written by special request of<br />
the Evening News, for their Santa Claus<br />
Doll Fund, entitled ‘‘ The House of Dolls,”<br />
from the pen of Mrs. Irene Osgood, has been<br />
produced at the Opera House, Northampton.<br />
<br />
“* Kitty of Ours,” a military comedy in four<br />
acts, by Emily Taylor, was produced at the<br />
Opera House, Harrogate, on October 30th.<br />
It deals with the love of the Quartermaster’s<br />
daughter for one of the handsomest officers<br />
of the regiment, and her subsequent dis-<br />
illusionment. It has a happy ending, however.<br />
The piece was produced by Mr. Charles<br />
Grattan and played by Miss Haidee Gunn,<br />
Mr. Frank Royde, and a capable company.<br />
A three-act comedy by Leonard Inkster<br />
entitled “The Emancipation ’’ was produced<br />
on October 9th and 11th in Sheffield.<br />
<br />
PARIS NOTES.<br />
ogee<br />
HE new literary convention between<br />
France and Russia came into force<br />
on November 13th.<br />
<br />
For the International Book Exhibition,<br />
which is to take place in Leipzig, in 1914, the<br />
first million is already subscribed. Austria,<br />
Hungary, France, England, America, the<br />
Netherlands, Sweden and Belgium are all to<br />
be represented, and it is believed that China<br />
and Japan will also exhibit.<br />
<br />
Holland has now joined the Berne Conven-<br />
tion with certain restrictions and, at present,<br />
only for European Holland. The Dutch<br />
colonies will be considered later on. The new<br />
arrangements came into force on November Ist,<br />
1912.<br />
<br />
The Nobel prize for Chemistry is to be<br />
awarded to two French chemists : M. Sabatier,<br />
of Toulouse, and M. Grignard, of Nancy.<br />
<br />
** Pages de Critique et de Doctrine,” by Paul<br />
Bourget, is the title of two volumes of studies<br />
on various subjects. The author writes of<br />
Taine, Brunetiére, Lamartine, Sully Prud-<br />
homme, Michelet, Barbey d’Aurevilly.. He<br />
analyses a novel by Léon Daudet and one<br />
by M. Barrés, and gives us portraits of the<br />
Duc d’Alencon, and Madame Taine. He also<br />
compares the past history of France with its<br />
present history. In these pages we have<br />
Paul Bourget’s opinions on matters literary,<br />
psychological, sociological, and political.<br />
<br />
‘“* La Nouvelle Journée’’ is the title of the<br />
latest and last volume by Romain Rolland<br />
relating to Jean-Christophe. Rarely have<br />
we heard so many details of the life of<br />
any individual. This is the tenth volume<br />
which the author has given us concerning his<br />
protégé.<br />
<br />
Madame Marcelle Tinayre’s new novel. is<br />
entitled ‘‘ Madeleine au Miroir.”<br />
<br />
‘Le Maitre des Foules”’ is the title of the<br />
latest novel by Louis Delzons. It will be<br />
remembered that this author was awarded an<br />
Academy prize for his novel “* L’Affaire Nell.”<br />
The present story is a very stirring account of<br />
the love affair of a professor, whose theories<br />
gradually lead him on to action and who is<br />
carried away by his success as an orator.<br />
<br />
An unpublished manuscript of the Goncourt<br />
brothers has been discovered and will shortly<br />
be published. It is a series of notes, giving us<br />
their impressions of Italy on the occasion of<br />
their first visit to that country during the<br />
winter of 1855—1856. The manuscript is<br />
illustrated with about 200 sketches by Jules de<br />
Goncourt.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
The second part of the ‘“‘ Lettres sur ]a Cour<br />
de Louis XIV. (1671—1673) du Marquis de<br />
Saint-Maurice,”” published by Jean Lemoine,<br />
has just appeared.<br />
<br />
‘‘Autour de Saint-Simon ”’ is an interesting<br />
study, by M. Alfred Pereire, of the Saint-<br />
Simon unknown to the general public.<br />
<br />
It is now fourteen years since the Marchand<br />
Mission won its fame, and Dr. Emily, who<br />
accompanied it, now gives his diary in a<br />
volume entitled ‘Le Journal de Route.”<br />
M. Etienne Lamy writes the preface of this<br />
‘* Odyssey, in which are pages of the Ihad.”<br />
<br />
A book by M. Gustave Lanson, entitled<br />
‘“‘ Trois Mois d’Enseignement aux Etats-Unis ”<br />
is most instructive, and will probably be read<br />
by Americans with as much interest as it has<br />
been read by the French. M. Lanson has been<br />
lecturing in America, and he gives us his<br />
impressions and the results of his observation.<br />
<br />
Another book by the Abbé Jules Claraz,<br />
ex-vicaire of Saint-Germain I’ Auxerrois, cannot<br />
fail to attract attention. His ‘‘ Mariage des<br />
Prétres ’’ caused a great sensation, and the new<br />
volume is entitled ‘* La Faillite des Religions.”<br />
<br />
‘‘La Protection internationale des Oeuvres<br />
cinematographiques,’’ by M. F. Potin, is a book<br />
that authors will do well to consult.<br />
<br />
“La Rénovation de VEmpire Ottoman<br />
(Affaires de Turquie),” by Paul Imbert, is a<br />
book which appears at the right moment.<br />
<br />
** La Querelle des Communes et des Lords,”’<br />
by Paul Hamelle, with a preface by M. Augustin<br />
Filon, helps us to see ourselves as others see us.<br />
<br />
** Du Cubisme,” by Albert Gleizes and Jean<br />
Metzinger, the two most notorious artists of<br />
the group of Cubists. The volume contains<br />
thirty illustrations, and may serve as a guide to<br />
those who are still seeking to discover the<br />
raison @étre of this extraordinary departure.<br />
<br />
‘*La Coopération neutre et la Coopération<br />
socialiste ’’ is a book that will be read with<br />
interest by all who know the previous works of<br />
M. E. Vandervelde.<br />
<br />
** Aux Pays Balkaniques, Montenegro, Serbie,<br />
Bulgarie,’”” by Alphonse Muzet, is a volume<br />
just published in the collection ‘“‘ Les Pays<br />
Modernes.”’<br />
<br />
Among the recent translations into French,<br />
we would specially mention a volume of essays<br />
and criticisms by Oscar Wilde: ‘‘ Noveaux<br />
Essais de Littérature et d’Esthétique,”’ trans-<br />
lated by Albert Savine, and ‘“ Parmi les<br />
Cheminots de I’Inde,” by Rudyard Kipling, by<br />
the same translator.<br />
<br />
‘“* Prométhée délivré ” is the French title of<br />
Shelley’s fine drama, which has just been given<br />
to the public by Tola Dorian. No poet could<br />
<br />
><br />
<br />
7<br />
<br />
be more difficult to translate than Shelley, and<br />
we must congratulate the well-known writer,<br />
who, under the pseudonym of Tola Dorian, has<br />
given French readers the opportunity of<br />
becoming acquainted with this poem.<br />
<br />
M. Pierre Berton’s death is sincerely regretted<br />
in the theatrical world. He was an excellent<br />
actor and a successful dramatic author. He<br />
came of a family of artistes, as he was the<br />
grandson of Samson of the Comédie Frangaise,<br />
and his father also belonged to the Théatre<br />
Francais. Some of Pierre Berton’s plays are<br />
as well known in England as in France.<br />
Among others, he wrote ‘“‘ Zaza’ with M.<br />
Charles Simon, and the ‘‘ Deux Gosses ”’ with<br />
Pierre Decourcelle.<br />
<br />
At the Renaissance, ‘“‘ L’Idée de Francoise,”<br />
by M. Paul Gavault, is now being played. It<br />
is an excellent piece, with plenty of incident<br />
and dramatic situations.<br />
<br />
The Athenée has become one of the favourite<br />
theatres. The new play, “‘ Le Diable ermite,”<br />
seems likely to have as long a run as its<br />
predecessor.<br />
<br />
Arys HALLARD.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
* Pages de Critique et de Doctrine.” (Plon.)<br />
<br />
“La Nouvelle Journée.”’ (Ollendorff.)<br />
<br />
‘Madeleine au Miroir.” (Calmann-Lévy.)<br />
<br />
“Le Maitre des Foules.” (Calmann-Lévy.)<br />
<br />
“Lettres sur la Cour de Louis XIV. (1671—1673) du<br />
Marquis de Saint-Maurice.’’ (Calmann-Lévy.)<br />
<br />
“La Faillite des Religions.’ (Flammarion.)<br />
<br />
“La Protection internationale des Oeuvres cinemato-<br />
graphiques ’’ (Gauthier-Villais. )<br />
<br />
“La Rénovation de PEmpire Ottoman.<br />
Turquie). (Perrin.)<br />
<br />
“La Querelle des Communes et des Lords.”’ (Plon.)<br />
<br />
“Du Cubisme.” (Figuiére.)<br />
<br />
“La Coopération neutre et la Coopération socialiste.’<br />
(F. Alcan.)<br />
<br />
“* Aux Pays Balkaniques, Montenegro, Serbie, Bulgarie.””<br />
(Roger.)<br />
<br />
*Prométhée délivré.”’ (Lemerre.)<br />
<br />
(Affaires de<br />
<br />
————_+—_+___—_-<br />
<br />
REGISTRATION OF DRAMAS IN THE<br />
UNITED STATES.<br />
<br />
—<br />
<br />
INSTRUCTIONS FOR SECURING COPYRIGHT<br />
REGISTRATION IN THE UNITED STATES<br />
UNDER THE UNITED STATES COPYRIGHT<br />
Act or Marcu 4, 1909.<br />
<br />
(Published with the kind permission of the Register<br />
of Copyrights of the Library of Congress).<br />
<br />
N order to secure the registration of a claim<br />
to copyright in the United States for any<br />
dramatic composition, the following pro-<br />
<br />
cedure is required under the copyright law of<br />
the, United States.<br />
78<br />
<br />
I. If the drama is a new work which has<br />
been printed and sold as a book :<br />
<br />
1. Print upon the back of the title page the<br />
copyright notice in the form prescribed by the<br />
eopyright statute. The usual and a correct<br />
form is the word “ Copyright ” ; the year date<br />
of publication (i.e. the year when copies were<br />
first sold, offered for sale, or publicly<br />
distributed) ; and the name of the person who<br />
claims the copyright ; e.g.<br />
<br />
“ Copyright, 1912, by John Smith.”<br />
<br />
2. Promptly after such publication of the<br />
play send by post prepaid two (2) copies<br />
addressed :<br />
<br />
Register of Copyrights,<br />
Library of Congress,<br />
Washington, D.C., U.S.A.<br />
<br />
3. These copies must be accompanied by a<br />
<br />
claim to copyright in the work, setting out<br />
<br />
(a) The full title of the play.<br />
<br />
(b) The name of the person who claims<br />
the copyright, his nationality and<br />
address.<br />
<br />
[This must be the real name and not the<br />
pen-name, stage name, or pseudonym. It is<br />
this name which must appear in the printed<br />
notice, and the form of the name in the printed<br />
notice should exactly agree with the name<br />
stated in the application for record.]<br />
<br />
(c) The nationality of the author or authors<br />
(i.e. the name of the country of which they are<br />
at the time of making the application citizens<br />
or subjects) must be given, or if permanent<br />
residents of the United States, that fact should<br />
be stated.<br />
<br />
[If the dramatic work is an adaptation or<br />
translation, then it is the name of the country<br />
of which the author of the adaptation or trans-<br />
lation is a citizen or subject that must be<br />
stated. |<br />
<br />
4. The name of the author or authors should<br />
also be given, if printed in the book; or, if<br />
not so printed and no objection exists to placing<br />
the names on record. But it is not obligatory<br />
to disclose the name of the author.<br />
<br />
5. The application must state the exact date<br />
of publication, i.e. “‘ the earliest date when<br />
copies of the first authorised edition were<br />
[ on sale, sold, or publicly distributed<br />
<br />
y the proprietor of the copyright or under<br />
his authority.”<br />
<br />
This application can be made by letter,<br />
provided all the essential facts are clearly set<br />
out. It would, however, be more conveniently<br />
supplied to the Copyright Office by using the<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
application form called “D1,” which will be<br />
sent upon request.<br />
<br />
6. With the application must be sent an<br />
international post-office money order to pay<br />
the statutory registration fee of $1 (= about<br />
4s. 2d.). This fee includes a certificate of<br />
registration under seal of the Copyright Office,<br />
which will be posted free of further charge to<br />
the address indicated in the application. The<br />
money order should be made payable to the<br />
REGISTER OF Copyricuts. Personal cheques<br />
or domestic British money orders or British<br />
postal notes cannot be received.<br />
<br />
The copyright is for a first term of twenty-<br />
eight years from publication, with a right of<br />
renewal for twenty-eight years more. Old<br />
plays which are now first printed as books<br />
cannot be registered to secure the statutory<br />
copyright. The law does not require that the<br />
drama be printed in the United States.<br />
<br />
II. If the drama is a new work and has not<br />
been printed and published, it may be registered<br />
as a dramatic composition “ not reproduced in<br />
copies for sale ” by proceeding as follows :—<br />
<br />
(a) Deposit in the Copyright Office one<br />
clean and complete copy, either manuscript or<br />
type-written ;<br />
<br />
_ (6) Send with it an application for registra-<br />
tion of claim to copyright exactly as above,<br />
omitting only the date of publication. (Appli-<br />
cation form “D2” can beused for this purpose.)<br />
<br />
[If it is the intention presently to print and<br />
sell the drama, there would seem to be no<br />
advantage in registering the manuscript, as<br />
the law expressly requires a second deposit<br />
of two printed copies, and registration when<br />
ay ae has been “‘ reproduced in copies for<br />
sale.”’<br />
<br />
Address all matter to THz REGISTER OF<br />
Copyricuts, CopyricHtT OFrricr, LIBRARY OF<br />
Coneress, Washington, D.C., U.S.A.<br />
<br />
THORVALD SOLBERG,<br />
Register of Copyrights.<br />
<br />
Mopeu or Buank “D1,” Request rok REGISTRATION OF<br />
A PuBLISHED Dramatic COMPOSITION: :<br />
<br />
Rucister or Copyricuts, WasHineTon, D.C.<br />
Date<br />
<br />
Of the Dramatic Composition named herein, two com-—<br />
plete copies of the best edition first published on the date<br />
stated herein are hereby deposited to secure copyright<br />
registration, according to the provisions of the Act of<br />
March 4, 1909. $1 (statutory fee for registration) is also<br />
inclosed. The copyright is claimed by the undersigned :<br />
Name and address of i<br />
<br />
copyright claimant { ee eee eee<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTIIOR.<br />
<br />
Name of Author, but if a trans-<br />
lation, then name of the Translator<br />
<br />
Country of which the author<br />
or translator is a citizen ee<br />
<br />
[An alien author domiciled in the United States should<br />
write here in addition to citizenship “domiciled in U. 8.”’]<br />
<br />
Brief title of work _<br />
Exact date of publication _ __ [Must be stated]<br />
<br />
[Date (day, month, and year) when placed on sale, sold,<br />
or publicly distributed].<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Send certificate of (<br />
registration to | eee ak sia<br />
<br />
Name and address {<br />
of remitter t<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE COLONIAL BOOK TRADE.<br />
<br />
— +<br />
<br />
M* who are acquainted at first hand<br />
with the conditions of modern indus-<br />
try maintain that the problem of<br />
production has been, so far at least, as is<br />
necessitated by existing facts, solved; the<br />
difficulty lies in distribution. To try to deal<br />
in any exhaustive sense with the question I<br />
have raised would be outside my present<br />
purpose. Let me, however, illustrate my<br />
meaning by a concrete example. I use in my<br />
office certain articles which cost me half a<br />
guinea when, as often happens, I have to buy<br />
them, and the manufacturer of which happens<br />
to be an intimate friend. I told him I paid<br />
half a guinea; he replied that he only realised<br />
half a crown, and that on the half-crown he<br />
made a profit of 30 per cent. Where then, do<br />
the other 8s. go ? In trade discounts, travellers’<br />
commissions and advertising. The particular<br />
trade in which my friend is engaged is a lucra-<br />
tive trade; it is highly capitalised and pays<br />
considerable dividends. It fulfils all the<br />
conditions laid down by those who manufacture<br />
under present-day conditions. It produces<br />
but a few articles; it has standardised them,<br />
it employs highly-paid experts to control its<br />
processes, and its principal travellers and<br />
finance men earn large incomes. How does<br />
all this compare with the publishing trade ?<br />
Iwill admit, of course, that the analogy is not,<br />
and cannot be, complete; books will not, they<br />
refuse to, be treated as commodities, and<br />
<br />
49<br />
<br />
disaster awaits, in the long run at least, any<br />
publisher who fails to draw a sharp distinction<br />
between books and pounds of butter. But I<br />
do suggest that the publishing trade fails. in<br />
many important particulars, to satisfy the<br />
conditions met by the manufacturing firm of<br />
which I have just spoken. The publishing<br />
trade is, to my thinking, and to the best of my<br />
knowledge, under-capitalised, and consequently<br />
fails both in production and in distribution ;<br />
in the large commercial sense, it has no<br />
existence. No man who sets out to make<br />
money, as the City, Manchester, or even Fleet<br />
Street understands the word, would waste<br />
time in publishing. The difference between<br />
cost and selling prices is too small.<br />
<br />
And yet—if only the distribution problem<br />
could be solved—publishing should be lucrative<br />
enough ; lucrative enough for the author as<br />
well as the publisher. If the publisher is not<br />
a rich main, then certainly the remuneration<br />
received by the authors of the great majority<br />
of books is ludicrously small. The writing of<br />
books is not a trade, but a form of art, and, like<br />
all artists, the author must take his chance of<br />
finding what he has written to be to the general<br />
liking. Quite true; these things are so. But<br />
the circulation of even the successful author<br />
is not, I suggest, what it might and ought to<br />
be. His publisher breaks down when he comes<br />
to distribution. Despite a dictum of Mr. Wells<br />
to the contrary, publishers would rather<br />
publish good books than bad, the sifting of<br />
manuscripts is close and continuous, and only<br />
a proportion of the books that are written<br />
reach the stage of being printed. It may fairly<br />
be said that production is, allowing for under-<br />
capitalisation, reasonably near the best of<br />
which we, as a nation, are at present capable,<br />
even though much is not written that should<br />
be written, because the publisher cannot afford<br />
to offer the author a pecuniary temptation<br />
strong enough to induce him to abandon other<br />
activities. Here I speak, of course, only of<br />
certain kinds of books. The publisher cannot<br />
afford to pay enough because he has not the<br />
money and he has not, and cannot procure,<br />
the money, because the nation’s book-con-<br />
suming capacity is insufficient to attract<br />
capital.<br />
<br />
Can this capacity be increased? The impor-<br />
tant social changes through which we are<br />
passing so rapidly affect the book trade as they<br />
affect other enterprises. ‘The rich man used<br />
to be the publisher’s main support. Can it be<br />
said that heis sonow? ‘The landed gentry and<br />
the country parson, are, relatively to the rest<br />
of the community, poorer than they were. And<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
80<br />
<br />
the rich man generally has means of spending<br />
his income that formerly did not exist ; he<br />
motors, he golfs, he spends much of his time<br />
in restaurants and other places of amuse-<br />
ment. He is abandoning the family mansion<br />
that used to be his pride, in which he passed<br />
most of his time and which usually con-<br />
tained a well-filled library. We may almost<br />
eliminate the rich man from our calculations ;<br />
the West End supports no bookshop com-<br />
parable with the establishments of New York<br />
“and the other American cities. It is, truly,<br />
only the rich man who can buy the very expen-<br />
sively produced volume, and for de luxe<br />
editions there will always be a demand. But<br />
the publisher should cease to think in terms<br />
of the income-tax paying class. and recognise<br />
the existence of the new public that has been<br />
called into being by compulsory education.<br />
One may approve or disapprove of the social<br />
evolution through which we are passing, but<br />
it is not going to stop because of our dislike,<br />
and the people who write and publish books<br />
will do well to recognise the fact that the<br />
national centre of intellectual gravity has<br />
shifted. Mr. Dent made the discovery some<br />
years back, and Messrs. Williams and Norgate,<br />
if report speaks truthfully of the success of<br />
The Home University Library, have bettered<br />
his example. But to produce books in large<br />
numbers at a cheap price for popular reading<br />
requires two things—more capital than most<br />
publishers can control, and a much more<br />
efficient book-selling machinery. The circu-<br />
lating library, important factor in distribution<br />
asit is, comes rather outside my present purpose ;<br />
let me only say that, if it is to last, its present<br />
unsound economic foundation must be changed<br />
radically, and that its profits should, as is the<br />
case with other middlemen, bear some relation<br />
to the degree of usefulness with Which it<br />
performs its functions. The future is not with<br />
the book specifically aimed at the libraries,<br />
but with the book that is meant to be bought,<br />
and is worth buying. The means of produc-<br />
tion are ready, or practically ready; for the<br />
capital necessary would be forthcoming if the<br />
publisher could sell what he published. At<br />
present he cannot. Most people have never<br />
acquired the bookshop habit. There are,<br />
indeed, not enough bookshops in which they<br />
can learn it. Large areas of London have no<br />
bookshops worth serious consideration, just<br />
as they have no schools other than those<br />
provided by the County Council. Some day,<br />
<br />
perhaps, the middle-class Englishman will be<br />
as sensible as the American, and send his chil-<br />
dren to the ‘ public ’<br />
<br />
?<br />
<br />
schools ; he may then,<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
too, learn to buy books. But the books that<br />
the working, or even middle-class man can<br />
afford to buy must be cheap, and the provision,<br />
both as to production and distribution, must<br />
be far better than anything that is offered now.<br />
<br />
We may leave the future to grapple with its<br />
own problems, though the future is not so very<br />
far distant and wisdom suggests that we do what<br />
lies in our power to hasten its advent. Mean-<br />
time, we seem to be losing our hold on the book<br />
markets of our own Colonies. The American<br />
book—particularly the American novel—is<br />
ousting us. Assuming the truth of the pro-<br />
position, it is as well to consider the reasons.<br />
In the first place, the American book publisher<br />
is helped very considerably by the American<br />
magazine publisher. American magazines are,<br />
it is generally agreed, incomparably better<br />
than ours, and the Colonial prefers McClure’s<br />
and Everybody's to what is offered him from<br />
London. So he gets the American view of<br />
things. And in the second place, when he<br />
comes to choose his books, he finds that the<br />
conditions of life set forth by the American<br />
writer are nearer to what he himself knows<br />
and understands, than the pictures done by the<br />
English novelist, who gathers his material in a<br />
complex civilisation, very remote from New<br />
Zealand or South Africa. It is a common-<br />
place to say that books reflect the intellectual<br />
life of their time, yet the publisher, who must<br />
always be something more than a tradesman,<br />
pays heavily if he forgets it. Here in England<br />
the author has to struggle against a book-selling<br />
machinery which has broken down; in the<br />
Colonies he has to face the invasion of men<br />
who write under conditions more nearly<br />
approximating to Colonial than to English life.<br />
The position at home can be improved, is, in<br />
fact, better than it was a few years ago; the<br />
nett book system has helped the bookseller<br />
materially. As far as the Colonies are con-<br />
cerned, some English writers will always find<br />
a Colonial circle of readers: the others must<br />
wait till America and the Colonies grow up.<br />
<br />
C, F. CAzENOVE.<br />
<br />
——————_1-— > o—__—_<br />
<br />
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND<br />
HUNGARY.<br />
<br />
— oo<br />
<br />
E understand from the Copyright Office<br />
of the Library of Congress that the<br />
following short convention has been<br />
<br />
agreed to between the United States and<br />
Hungary, and came into force on October 16th<br />
of this year.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THB AUTHOR. 81<br />
<br />
Article 1.<br />
<br />
Authors who are citizens or _ subjects<br />
of the two countries or their assigns shall enjoy<br />
in the other country, for their literary, artistic,<br />
dramatic, musical and photographic works<br />
(whether unpublished or published in one of<br />
the two countries) the same rights which the<br />
respective laws do now or may hereafter grant<br />
to natives.<br />
<br />
The above provision includes the copyright<br />
control of mechanical musical reproductions.<br />
<br />
Article 2.<br />
<br />
The enjoyment and the exercise of rights<br />
secured by the present Convention are subject<br />
to the performance of the conditions and<br />
formalities prescribed by the laws and regula-<br />
tions of the country where protection is claimed<br />
under the present Convention; such enjoy-<br />
ment and such exercise are independent of<br />
the existence of protection in the country of<br />
origin of the work,<br />
<br />
Article 3.<br />
<br />
The term of copyright protection granted<br />
by the present Convention shall be regulated<br />
by the law of the country where protection<br />
is claimed.<br />
<br />
Article 4.<br />
<br />
The present Convention shall be ratified<br />
and the ratifications shall be exchanged at<br />
Washington as soon as possible.<br />
<br />
Article 5.<br />
<br />
The present Convention shall be put in<br />
force one month after the exchange of ratifica-<br />
tions, and shall remain in force until the<br />
termination of a year from the day on which<br />
it may have been denounced.<br />
<br />
In faith whereof the Plenipotentiaries have<br />
signed the present Convention in two copies,<br />
each in English and Hungarian languages,<br />
and have affixed thereto their seals.<br />
<br />
Done at Budapest, the 30th day of January,<br />
1912.<br />
<br />
(Seal) Ricuarp C. Krrens<br />
(Seal) Esternazy Pau<br />
(Seal) Tory Gustav<br />
<br />
| Norr.—Ratification advised by the Senate,<br />
July 238, 1912; ratifications exchanged,<br />
September 16, 1912 ; in force October 16,<br />
1912.]<br />
<br />
A CRIMINAL PROSECUTION OF A<br />
LITERARY AGENT.<br />
<br />
——— + —<br />
<br />
OR a good. many years past a Literary<br />
Agency has been carried on in the<br />
City at 34, Paternoster eae under<br />
the name of ‘“‘ A. M. Burghes.”” A. M. Burghes<br />
himself was made a bankrupt it in July, 1911,<br />
as the result of proceedings taken by a ‘member<br />
with the assistance of the Society, and he has<br />
been during the present month found guilty<br />
at the Old Bailey of fraudulently converting to<br />
his own use a sum of £50 paid to him by an<br />
author for the purpose of making a payment<br />
to a publisher. The Recorder postponed<br />
sentence to next Sessions.<br />
<br />
C. M. Burghes, son of A. M. Burghes,<br />
appears to have carried on the literary agency<br />
for some time past in his father’s name.<br />
C. M. Burghes has also been found guilty of<br />
fraud at the Old Bailey during the present<br />
month. He was convicted of obtaining a<br />
sum of £10 from a firm of publishers by f false<br />
pretences. He represented to the publishers<br />
that he was entitled as agent for an author to<br />
receive this sum and transfer the copyright of<br />
the author’s book, whereas he had no such<br />
authority, and in fact made no communication<br />
to the author at all. The Judge bound him<br />
over to come up for sentence when called<br />
upon.<br />
<br />
Se ee<br />
<br />
MAGAZINE CONTENTS.<br />
<br />
+—>—+-——<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
CONTEMPORARY.<br />
Letters of George Meredith. By Mrs. Sturge Gretton.<br />
Grimm’s Fairy ales: By Miss Constance ‘Spender.<br />
The Relationship Between Music and Life. By Gerald<br />
Cumberland.<br />
CoRNUILL.<br />
<br />
The Poetry of Sir Alfred Lyall. By<br />
MacMunn, D.S.O.<br />
<br />
Andrew Lang and “ X”’:<br />
<br />
Major G. F.<br />
A Working Man.<br />
<br />
EnouisH REVIEW.<br />
<br />
Malthus and the Publishing Trade.<br />
August Strindberg.<br />
<br />
By P. P. Howe.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
SCALE FOR ADVERTISEMENIS,<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
[ALLOWANCE TO MEMBERS OF THE SOCIETY 20 PER CENT.)<br />
Frout Page nak Ne £4 0 9<br />
Other Pages : ae ing ios — ee ae ies : 0 0<br />
Half of a Page ... ae ae ise 28 ae es xe L 10 Y<br />
Quarter of a Page sek ies ce or ee ee so 0 16<br />
Eighth of a Page = 07 °<br />
Single Column ‘Advertisements : per inch 060<br />
Reduction of 20 per cent. made for a Series of Six and of 25 per cent, foT<br />
Twelve Insertions.<br />
<br />
All letters respecting Advertisements should be addressed to J. F.<br />
Betmont & Co., 29, Paternoster Square, London, E.C.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
HOW TO USE THE SOCIETY.<br />
<br />
—-—~<—4—_<br />
<br />
1, PSV VERY member has a right toask for and to receive<br />
K advice upon his agreements, his choice of a pub-<br />
lisher, or any dispute arising in the conduct of his<br />
business or the administration of his property. The<br />
Secretary of the Society is a solicitor; but if there is any<br />
special reason the Secretary will refer the case to the<br />
Solicitors of the Society. Further, the Committee, if they<br />
deem it desirable, will obtain counsel’s opinion without<br />
any cost to the member. Moreover, where counsel's<br />
opinion is favourable, and the sanction of the Committee<br />
is obtained, action will be taken on behalf of the aggrieved<br />
member, and all costs borne by the Society.<br />
<br />
2. Remember that questions connected with copyright<br />
and |publishers’ agreements do not fall within the experi-<br />
ence of ordinary solicitors, Therefore, do not scruple to use<br />
the Society.<br />
<br />
3. Before signing any agreement whatever, send<br />
the document to the Society for examination.<br />
<br />
4. Remember always that in belonging to the Society<br />
you are fighting the battles of other writers, even if you<br />
are reaping no direct benefit to yourself, and that you are<br />
advancing the best interests of your calling in promoting<br />
the independence of the writer, the dramatist, the composer.<br />
<br />
5. The Committee have arranged for the reception of<br />
members’ agreements and their preservation in a fire-<br />
proof safe. The agreements will, of course, be regarded as<br />
confidential documents to be read only by the Secretary,<br />
who will keep the key of the safe. The Society now offers:<br />
(1) To stamp agreements in readiness for a possible action<br />
upon them. (2) To keep agreements. (3) To enforce<br />
payments due according to agreements. Fuller particu-<br />
lars of the Society’s work can be obtained in the<br />
Prospectus.<br />
<br />
6. No contract should be entered into with a literary<br />
agent without the advice of the Secretary of the Society.<br />
Members are strongly advised not to accept without careful<br />
consideration the contracts with publishers submitted to<br />
them by literary agents, and are recommended to submit<br />
them for interpretation and explanation to the Secretary<br />
of the Society.<br />
<br />
7, Many agents neglect to stamp agreements,<br />
must be done within fourteen days of first execution,<br />
Secretary will undertake it on behalf of members,<br />
<br />
This<br />
The<br />
<br />
8. Some agents endeavour to prevent authors from<br />
referring matters to the Secretary of the Society; so<br />
do some publishers. Members can make their own<br />
deductions and act accordingly.<br />
<br />
9. The subscription to the Society is £1 1s.<br />
<br />
per<br />
annum, or £10 10s. for life membership.<br />
<br />
SRN eres os, ee<br />
<br />
WARNINGS TO THE PRODUCERS<br />
OF BOOKS,<br />
<br />
ro<br />
<br />
ERE are a few standing rules to be observed in an<br />
agreement. There are four methods of dealing<br />
with literary property :—<br />
<br />
I. Selling it Outright.<br />
<br />
This is sometimes satisfactory, if a proper price can be<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
obtained. But the transaction should be managed by a<br />
<br />
competent agent, or with the advice of the Secretary of<br />
the Society,<br />
<br />
II. A Profit-Sharing Agreement (a bad form of<br />
agreement),<br />
<br />
In this case the following rules should be attended to:<br />
<br />
C1.) Not to sign any agreement in which the cost of pro-<br />
duction forms a part without the strictest investigation,<br />
<br />
(2.) Not to give the publisher the power of putting the<br />
profits into his own pocket by charging for advertisements<br />
in his own organs, or by charging exchange advertise-<br />
ments. Therefore keep control of the advertisements.<br />
<br />
(3.) Not to allow a special charge for “office expenses,”<br />
unless the same allowance is made to the author.<br />
<br />
ses Not to give up American, Colonial, or Continental<br />
rights.<br />
<br />
(5.) Not to give up serial or translation rights.<br />
<br />
(6.) Not to bind yourself for future work to any publisher,<br />
As well bind yourself for the future to any one solicitor or<br />
doctor !<br />
<br />
III. The Royalty System.<br />
<br />
This is perhaps, with certain limitations, the best form<br />
of agreement. It is above all things necessary to know<br />
what the proposed royalty means to both sides. It is now<br />
possible for an author to ascertain approximately the<br />
truth. From time to time very important figures connected<br />
with royalties are published in The Author,<br />
<br />
IY. A Commission Agreement.<br />
<br />
The main points are :—<br />
<br />
(1.) Be careful to obtain a fair cost of production.<br />
<br />
(2.) Keep control of the advertisements.<br />
<br />
(3.) Keep control of the sale price of the book.<br />
<br />
General.<br />
<br />
All other forms of agreement are combinations of the four<br />
above mentioned.<br />
<br />
Such combinations are generally disastrous to the author,<br />
<br />
Never sign any agreement without competent advice from<br />
the Secretary of the Society.<br />
<br />
Stamp all agreements with the Inland Revenue stamp.<br />
<br />
Avoid agreements by letter if possible.<br />
<br />
The main points which the Society has always demanded<br />
from the outset are :—<br />
<br />
(1.) That both sides shall know what an agreement<br />
means.<br />
<br />
(2.) The inspection of those account books which belong<br />
to the author. We are advised that this is a right, in the<br />
nature of a common law right, which cannot be denied or<br />
withheld.<br />
<br />
(3.) Always avoid a transfer of copyright.<br />
<br />
ee<br />
WARNINGS TO DRAMATIC AUTHORS.<br />
<br />
a<br />
<br />
EVER sign an agreement without submitting it to the<br />
Secretary of the Society of Authors or some com-<br />
petent legal authority.<br />
<br />
2, It is well to be extremely careful in negotiating for<br />
the production of a play with any one except an established<br />
manager.<br />
<br />
3. There are three forms of dramatic contract for plays<br />
in three or more acts :—<br />
<br />
(a.) Sale: outright of the performing right. This<br />
is unsatisfactory. An author who enters into<br />
such a contract should stipulate in the contract<br />
for production of the piece by a certain date<br />
and for proper publication of his name on the<br />
<br />
play-bills,<br />
<br />
<br />
(2.) Sale of performing right or of a licence to<br />
perform on the basis of percentages on<br />
gross receipts. Percentages vary between 5<br />
and 15 per cent. An author should obtain a<br />
percentage on the sliding scale of gross receipts<br />
in preference to the American system. Should<br />
obtain a sum in advance of percentages. A fixed<br />
date on or before which the play should be<br />
performed.<br />
<br />
(c.) Sale of performing right or of a licence to<br />
perform on the basis of royalties (i.c., fixed<br />
nightly fees). This method should be always<br />
avoided except in cases where the fees are<br />
likely to be small or difficult to collect. The<br />
other safeguards set out under heading (0.) apply<br />
also in this case.<br />
<br />
4. Plays in one act are often sold outright, but it 18<br />
better to obtain a small nightly fee if possible, and a sum<br />
paid in advance of such fees in any event, It is extremely<br />
important that the amateur rights of one-act plays should<br />
be reserved.<br />
<br />
5. Authors should remember that performing rights can<br />
be limited, and are usually limited, by town, country, and<br />
time. This is most important.<br />
<br />
6. Authors should not assign performing rights, but<br />
<br />
should grant a licence to perform. The legal distinction<br />
is of great importance,<br />
<br />
7. Authors should remember that performing rights in a<br />
play are distinct from literary copyright. A manager<br />
holding the performing right or licence to perform cannot<br />
print the book of the words.<br />
<br />
8. Never forget that United States rights may be exceed-<br />
ingly valuable. ‘They should never be included in English<br />
agreements without the author obtaining a substantial<br />
consideration,<br />
<br />
9. Agreements for collaboration should be carefully<br />
drawn and executed before collaboration is commenced.<br />
<br />
10. An author should remember that production of a play<br />
is highly speculative : that he runs a very great risk of<br />
delay and a breakdown in the fulfilment of his contract.<br />
He should therefore guard himself all the more carefully in<br />
the beginning.<br />
<br />
11. An author must remember that the dramatic market<br />
is exceedingly limited, and that for a novice the first object<br />
is to obtain adequate publication.<br />
<br />
As these warnings must necessarily be incomplete, on<br />
account of the wide range of the subject of dramatic con-<br />
tracts, those authors desirous of further information<br />
are referred to the Secretary of the Society.<br />
<br />
<> +_ _____<br />
<br />
REGISTRATION OF SCENARIOS AND<br />
ORIGINAL PLAYS.<br />
<br />
—<br />
<br />
we typewritten in duplicate on foolscap paper<br />
forwarded to the offices of the Society, together with<br />
a registration fee of two shillings and sixpence, will<br />
<br />
be carefully compared by the Secretary or a qualified assis-<br />
tant, One copy will be stamped and returned to the author<br />
and the other filed in the register of the Society. Copies<br />
of the scenario thus filed may be obtained at any time by<br />
the author only at a small charge to cover cost of typing.<br />
<br />
Original Plays may also be filed subject to the same<br />
<br />
oa that a play will be charged for<br />
at the price of 2s. 6d. per act,<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
83<br />
<br />
DRAMATIC AUTHORS AND AGENTS.<br />
te<br />
<br />
A ee authors should seek the advice of the<br />
<br />
Society before putting plays into the hands of<br />
<br />
agents. As the law stands at present, an agent<br />
who has once had a play in his hands may acquire a<br />
perpetual claim to a percentage on the author’s fees<br />
from it. As far as the placing of plays is concerned,<br />
it may be taken as a general rule that there are only<br />
very few agents who can do anything for an author<br />
that he cannot, under the guidance of the Society, do<br />
equally well or better for himself. The collection of fees<br />
is also a matter in which in many cases no intermediary is<br />
required. For certain purposes, such as the collection of<br />
fees on amateur performances, and in general the trans-<br />
action of frequent petty authorisations with different<br />
individuals, and also for the collection of fees in foreign<br />
countries, almost all dramatic authors employ agents; and<br />
in these ways the services of agents are real and valuable.<br />
But the Society warns authors against agents who profess<br />
to have influence with managers in the placing of plays, or<br />
who propose to act as principals by offering to purchase<br />
the author's rights. In any case, in the present state of<br />
the law, an agent should not be employed under any<br />
circumstances without an agreement approved of by the<br />
Society.<br />
<br />
——_-—~<—_ —____<br />
<br />
WARNINGS TO MUSICAL COMPOSERS.<br />
ees<br />
ITTLE can be added to the warnings given fur the<br />
assistance of producers of books and dramatic<br />
authors. It must, however, be pointed out that, as<br />
a rule, the musical publisher demands from the musical<br />
composer a transfer of fuller rights and less liberal finan-<br />
cial terms than those obtained for literary and dramatic<br />
property. The musical composer has very often the two<br />
rights to deal with—performing right and copyright. He<br />
should be especially careful therefore when entering into<br />
an agreement, and should take into particular consideration<br />
the warnings stated above.<br />
—— 5 Se<br />
<br />
STAMPING MUSIC.<br />
<br />
a aaa<br />
<br />
The Society undertakes to stamp copies of music on<br />
behalf of its members for the fee of 6d. per 100 or part<br />
of 100. The members’ stamps are kept in the Society’s<br />
safe. The musical publishers communicate direct with the<br />
Secretary, and the voucher is then forwarded to the<br />
members, who are thus saved much unnecessary trouble.<br />
<br />
—__-_—s —___<br />
THE READING BRANCH.<br />
BA ae<br />
<br />
EMBERS will greatly assist the Society in this<br />
| branch of its work by informing young writers<br />
of its existence. Their MSS. can be read and<br />
treated as a composition is treated by a coach. The term<br />
MSS. includes not only works of fiction, but poetry<br />
and dramatic works, and when it is possible, under<br />
special arrangement, technical and scientific works. The<br />
Readers are writers of competence and experience. The<br />
<br />
fee is one guinea,<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
see<br />
<br />
REMITTANCES.<br />
<br />
1<br />
<br />
The Secretary of the Society begs to give notice<br />
that all remittances are acknowledged by return of post.<br />
All remittances should be crossed Union of London and<br />
Smiths Bank, Chancery Lane, or be sent by registered<br />
letter only,<br />
<br />
<br />
84<br />
<br />
GENERAL NOTES.<br />
<br />
—_-—~— + —<br />
<br />
The Editor would be obliged if any<br />
members who do not file the magazine<br />
- could return copies of the last issue, which<br />
is now out of print.<br />
<br />
ANNUAL DINNER.<br />
<br />
Tue Annual Dinner of the Society will take<br />
place on Thursday, December 5th, at the<br />
Hotel Cecil. Mr. Maurice Hewlett will preside.<br />
<br />
AUSTRALIAN CopyriIGuT BILL.<br />
<br />
We understand that this Bill has now<br />
passed into law. As stated elsewhere in these<br />
columns, a report on the Bill had been drafted<br />
by the Copyright Sub-Committee and, with<br />
the approval of the Committee of Management,<br />
was to have been despatched to the Australian<br />
Premier. Unfortunately, the fact that it was<br />
only possible a few weeks ago (and then only<br />
with some difficulty) to procure a copy of the<br />
Bill, has prevented the committee from present-<br />
ing their report in time for it to be of any<br />
practical value. It is satisfactory, however<br />
to state that the Bill, even as originally drafted,<br />
was in many ways favourable to the interests<br />
of authors and dramatists, and unless it has<br />
been considerably altered during its passage<br />
through the Australian House, members of<br />
the Society will have gained stronger protec-<br />
tion for their property in the Australian<br />
Commonwealth than they have hitherto<br />
enjoyed. As soon as a copy of the Act is to<br />
hand we shall hope to publish it in The Author.<br />
<br />
SeconpAry RicuTs IN AUSTRALIA.<br />
<br />
We desire to warn members of the danger<br />
which they run in sending out MSS, to distant<br />
parts of the earth, in response to requests from<br />
agents and others, of whose standing and<br />
position they may know nothing.<br />
<br />
It ought not to be necessary to issue such a<br />
warning at this period of the Society’s existence,<br />
when most authors have learnt the necessity<br />
for prudence, but a case has recently come to<br />
our notice which seems to render a repetition<br />
of the Society’s warning desirable. The mem-<br />
ber in question—a prolific writer of short<br />
stories—was approached by a correspondent<br />
in Melbourne, who expressed a desire to be<br />
furnished with all the member’s published<br />
short stories, and a promise to pay £1 1s. each<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
for any he accepted for publication in<br />
Australian magazines. The writer did not<br />
send all his short stories, but forwarded<br />
half-a-dozen, requesting his correspondent,<br />
if he found three suitable, to forward the money<br />
for these and to return the remaining three.<br />
He also mentioned the terms on which he would<br />
be prepared to continue to deal if further<br />
stories were desired.<br />
<br />
The correspondence took place and the MSS.<br />
were sent early in 1911. Since then the author<br />
has heard nothing of the MSS., and has received<br />
no payment for any of the stories.<br />
<br />
The Society is doing what is possible, but the<br />
distance makes action a little difficult.<br />
<br />
If any of our members have had similar<br />
experiences in the Australian market, we shall<br />
be glad to hear from them, as it is possible that<br />
the Melbourne correspondent referred to may<br />
have been inviting other authors to supply<br />
him with stories, and in that case, some com-<br />
bined action might be possible. But in any<br />
event, the information will be useful in that<br />
it will provide the secretary with evidence<br />
justifying him in warning other writers from<br />
sending their work to the same quarter.<br />
<br />
The Australian magazine market may not<br />
be a very lucrative one to the British author,<br />
but that makes it still more necessary that he<br />
should not lower the rates by supplying<br />
‘copy ” free, and this seems likely to be the<br />
practical result of yielding to the persuasions<br />
of the gentleman whose methods have been<br />
brought thus to our notice.<br />
<br />
“MALTHUS AND THE PUBLISHING TRADE.”<br />
<br />
Ix the November issue of the English Review<br />
an article of some discernment is published<br />
under the above title from the pen of P. P.<br />
Howe. Among the correspondence in_ this<br />
month’s issue will also be found a letter, “ The<br />
Latter Day Novel,” dealing with the same<br />
subject. Both writers are inclined to blame the<br />
publisher for over-production. We do not<br />
think this deduction is entirely correct, for<br />
although the publisher no doubt is responsible<br />
to some extent for the size and the spirit of the<br />
output, there is also the auther’s agent who,<br />
anxious to secure a firm commission on &<br />
number of books without the trouble involved<br />
in placing each one, leads on the author with<br />
specious arguments to bind himself to the<br />
publisher for a_ series of sometimes four,<br />
sometimes six. He then proceeds, with the<br />
least possible labour, to draw in the commis-<br />
sion. If the agent can sell the serial rights<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
as well to the publisher—rights which, of<br />
course, he himself ought to place separately—<br />
he may even succeed in gaining a double<br />
commission, first from the author and secondly<br />
from the publisher, who presently asks him to<br />
sell on his (the publisher’s) behalf the rights<br />
which he has just sold on behalf of the author.<br />
We should put the limit of the agent on the<br />
question of over-production at one-third, and<br />
that of the publisher at two-thirds of the<br />
whole.<br />
<br />
CopyRIGHT QUESTIONS.<br />
<br />
We understand from the Board of Trade<br />
that the Copyright Act of 1911, under sec-<br />
tion 37 (2) (d), has been proclaimed in Ceylon,<br />
but that the proclamation of the act in India,<br />
including Burmah, is still under consideration.<br />
We trust that the Government will carry the<br />
matter through as quickly as possible, as the<br />
matter for certain technical reasons is of vital<br />
importance to all English authors.<br />
<br />
We understand also that there has been some<br />
difficulty about Crown copyright in The Board<br />
of Trade Journal, and that Mr. Sydney Buxton<br />
has decided that the journal shall be issued in<br />
future with the following notice attached :<br />
‘“* Crown Copyright Reserved : extracts may be<br />
published if the source is duly acknowledged.”<br />
<br />
We also have much pleasure in reporting<br />
that Newfoundland, as a self-governing Colony,<br />
has passed a short Act which came into force<br />
on July Ist, 1912, practically incorporating<br />
in the Statute Book of Newfoundland the<br />
Act of Great Britain of 1911. We should have<br />
been glad if the Newfoundland Government had<br />
passed some severer penal clauses for infringe-<br />
ment of dramatic and other rights, as some of<br />
the Colonies propose to do.<br />
<br />
———_ +§ —~< ¢<br />
<br />
PUBLISHERS’ ROYALTY AGREEMENTS.<br />
<br />
—_+— +<br />
LIMITATIONS.<br />
II.<br />
<br />
‘FAST month we dealt with the first point<br />
of the Limitations set out in that article,<br />
namely, the limitation ‘‘as to country,”<br />
<br />
in this article the remaining limitations are<br />
<br />
dealt with.<br />
<br />
The second, then, for consideration when<br />
dealing with the book rights is limitation as<br />
to time.<br />
<br />
85<br />
<br />
It has been decided that apart from any<br />
express arrangement the publisher will have the<br />
right to sell any copies printed before the<br />
expiration of the time limit. It is possible,<br />
therefore, that in the last year the publisher<br />
might overprint. This would not matter much<br />
in a technical work that needed much altera-<br />
tion and supervision, for the old edition could<br />
hardly command an extensive sale, but it<br />
might possibly be inconvenient. In the case,<br />
however, of the writer of imaginative literature,<br />
who was anxious to regain control of his work<br />
after a certain time, the position would be<br />
impossible, and the time fixed in the contract<br />
would be really no limit at all. One well-<br />
known ease came before the courts in which an<br />
author, who had a time limit in his contract,<br />
was always confronted by his publisher making<br />
the statement that he was still selling books<br />
printed prior toits expiration. At last the author<br />
decided to take action, and found that the<br />
publisher’s assertion was incorrect. He had<br />
printed after the time limit was at an end and<br />
had continued to sell. The author got judg-<br />
ment accordingly.<br />
<br />
If the work is a technical work it is not likely<br />
that a large and prolonged sale of a book,<br />
admittedly out of date, would continue. Over-<br />
printing on the part of the publisher would<br />
therefore be a waste of money.<br />
<br />
But in the case of a novel the author would<br />
either have to buy up all the stock, or run the<br />
risk that his work in the hands of a new pub-<br />
lisher would be constantly undersold. Indeed,<br />
it is doubtful whether, in the circumstances, he<br />
would be able to get another publisher to<br />
produce the work.<br />
<br />
What remedy, then, is there against this<br />
dilemma ?<br />
<br />
The author must insert a clause by which<br />
the publisher can only print and bind a certain<br />
number of copies, and no more, without the<br />
author’s consent during the final years of the<br />
author’s contract.<br />
<br />
This number is generally determined by the<br />
number of sales in the previous year, supposing<br />
at the end of the previous year there are not<br />
sufficient copies still on hand to meet the<br />
demand.<br />
<br />
The author must have another clause giving<br />
him the right to purchase the sheets and bound<br />
copies at the termination of the contract at a<br />
valuation, the price in no case to exceed the<br />
cost of production.<br />
<br />
With these safeguards the clause with its<br />
time limitation is well worth the consideration<br />
of the author.<br />
<br />
Thirdly, there is the limitation as to edition.<br />
86<br />
<br />
This method of,limitation in the case of a<br />
book that is likely,to sell speedily is, no doubt,<br />
the best form of limitation, for the publisher’s<br />
right can easily be renewed by a letter for a<br />
further number of copies.<br />
<br />
But as the former method—limitation by<br />
time—was pointed out, except with proper<br />
protective clauses, to be a danger to the writer<br />
of imaginative literature, rather than to the<br />
technical writer, limitation by edition is likely<br />
to be more irksome to the writer of technical<br />
works whose books sell slowly.<br />
<br />
If the sales are slow it is possible that the<br />
writer may want to make alterations, additions,<br />
and emendations before the edition is sold,<br />
this he would be forbidden to do under his<br />
agreement. He ought, therefore, to protect<br />
himself so that he may be able to regain control<br />
of his work. This is sometimes done by a<br />
clause enabling him to purchase the stock on<br />
hand at a reasonable figure, or by putting an<br />
alternative limitation of edition and time by<br />
which, if the edition is not sold out within a<br />
fixed time from the date of publication, then<br />
the author may regain control.<br />
<br />
As we pointed out to technical writers, in<br />
Article No. I., this power to control their own<br />
work is of paramount importance. Yet,<br />
curiously enough, the publishers of technical<br />
books are less willing to grant it to them<br />
than the publishers of fiction.<br />
<br />
Lastly, there is the limitation by price and<br />
format.<br />
<br />
Limitation by format may, in some cases,<br />
be left to the publisher, but it is best that it<br />
should be settled mutually between author and<br />
publisher. The form and get-up of a book is<br />
of great importance to both parties.<br />
<br />
One very important point arises under this<br />
heading, namely the insertion of advertise-<br />
ments, either the publisher’s own, or general<br />
advertisements in the book. This point<br />
arises usually in the cheap reproduction of<br />
fiction, and is not likely to become prominent<br />
in other kinds of reproduction. Some pub-<br />
lishers have been known to insert advertise-<br />
ments in cheap 6d. reprints, opposite the last<br />
twenty or thirty pages of reading matter. If<br />
an author has no voice in the format he has<br />
no remedy, however strong may be his<br />
objection.<br />
<br />
There are two main causes for objecting,<br />
either that such a method is a degradation of<br />
Literature with a big L—a very reasonable<br />
objection—or that the publisher is making a<br />
profit in which the author should share. In<br />
the first case the author should have every<br />
<br />
_ Tight of control; in the second case he should<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
have every right to share the profit, for it is<br />
conceivable that in the second case an energetic<br />
publisher might obtain so many advertise-<br />
ments that the cost of production would be<br />
completely covered. Then the author should<br />
obtain a proportionately high financial return.<br />
<br />
From the point of view of format, therefore,<br />
the author should have the power to stop any<br />
unreasonable “ get-up.”<br />
<br />
Some authors object even to the insertion of<br />
advertisements of the publisher’s own publica-<br />
tions, all bound together at the end of the<br />
book. Again, they should have the power of<br />
control should they desire.<br />
<br />
Limitation as to price is by no means the<br />
least important limitation under consideration,<br />
for what royalty an author can ask must often /<br />
depend upon the price which the public give. |<br />
An author’s royalty will vary if a book is a<br />
<br />
nett book or a book published subject to<br />
<br />
discount. Again, some publishers, especially<br />
music publishers, state that they give a fixed<br />
sum per copy. The sum might be a fair<br />
royalty if the book was published at 1s., but<br />
a very unfair royalty if the publisher produced<br />
it at 5s.<br />
<br />
If the publisher has the right to publish in<br />
book form, unlimited as to price, he may not<br />
only produce at a high price, but after the issue<br />
at that price may then proceed to issue a cheap<br />
edition, without reference to the author at a<br />
most unseasonable time.<br />
<br />
The reasons against giving an unlimited<br />
licence as to price are many.<br />
<br />
First, in the matter of fiction it is often<br />
impolitic to issue cheap editions at all. It is<br />
certainly impolitic to issue them within two<br />
years from the publication of the original.<br />
Secondly, many authors, who do not mind<br />
republication in cheap paper-bound editions<br />
that are read and thrown away, object to the<br />
cheap cloth-bound edition which is read and<br />
then transferred to the book-shelves.<br />
<br />
Cheap editions sometimes ruin an author’s<br />
financial returns. 5<br />
<br />
Booksellers who know that an author will<br />
never appear in cheap form can afford to invest<br />
their capital by stocking and continuing to<br />
stock an expensive edition. They cannot do<br />
so if their investment will be robbed of its<br />
value by a cheap issue within six months.<br />
<br />
Again, some publishers who have made a<br />
speciality of the cheap issue get a wider market.<br />
It is well, therefore, for an author to be able to<br />
place his cheap issue in those publisher’s hands,<br />
as he will be able to get a higher price and<br />
larger returns.<br />
<br />
It is just as important to consider the<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
expensive edition, ‘* the edition de luxe,” as the<br />
cheap edition. Many authors, writers of bio-<br />
graphies, histories, travels, “et hoc genus<br />
omne,’? may wish to have a more expensive<br />
edition produced with more numerous illus-<br />
trations, better print and paper, but, if the<br />
matter is left under the control of the pub-<br />
lisher, cannot insist.<br />
<br />
An author should always remember that it<br />
is easy to cheapen a work subsequently, but<br />
when it is once issued in a cheap form, it is<br />
almost impossible to raise the price.<br />
<br />
To sum up, then, an author should employ a<br />
publisher as his agent to produce his work in<br />
book form only in the English language. This<br />
licence can be further limited, and in many<br />
ceases should be,<br />
<br />
1. As to country.<br />
<br />
2. As to time.<br />
<br />
8. As to edition.<br />
<br />
4, As to price and format.<br />
<br />
To give a publisher an unconditional licence<br />
to publish in book form is in most cases silly,<br />
in some cases ruinous, and in any case shows a<br />
deplorable ignorance of the rights and powers<br />
an author holds.<br />
<br />
There are two main reasons why authors<br />
make bad contracts—ignorance and conceit.<br />
it is hoped that this article may to some<br />
extent dispel the former.<br />
<br />
FRENCH PUBLISHERS AND CIRCULATING<br />
LIBRARIES.<br />
<br />
By W. L. Grorce.<br />
<br />
YY DO not, in this article. give the exhaustive<br />
details of French publishing methods<br />
which some may hope to find in it, partly<br />
<br />
because the facts are jealously guarded, and<br />
<br />
partly because they are not, as facts, inter-<br />
esting to British authors. Our almost in-<br />
<br />
variable method is to sell foreign rights for a<br />
<br />
lump sum, and I do not think that a perusal of<br />
<br />
the following notes will induce any English or<br />
<br />
American writer to depart from the practice.<br />
<br />
My main object is to compare literary con-<br />
<br />
ditions in two countries with reference to the<br />
<br />
circulating library, of which it may almost be<br />
said that it does not exist in France. It is<br />
because I look upon the circulating library as<br />
<br />
a useful and beneficial link between author and<br />
<br />
reader that I ask my fellow authors to consider<br />
<br />
the régime under which books are issued in<br />
<br />
France.<br />
<br />
87<br />
<br />
Broadly speaking it may be said that in<br />
France many writers who have made a name,<br />
and all the new writers, must, if they wish to<br />
attain publication, lay down the cost of the<br />
first edition. For 1,000 copies of a novel<br />
(paper bound) at 2s. 10d. nominal, this amounts<br />
to £36 to £48.* The book is sold to the public<br />
at 2s. 74d., by a few enterprising booksellers at<br />
2s. 5d. The division of the selling price is<br />
approximately as follows :—<br />
<br />
Cost of the book,<br />
Bookseller’s discount<br />
Publisher’s commission<br />
Author’s profit<br />
<br />
about 10d. 10d.<br />
id 1<br />
» 3dkd.to 7d.<br />
» 8d. to 44d.<br />
<br />
In a few cases the publisher charges the author<br />
a small fee for warehousing, also postages on<br />
copies sold, but this is not usual among the<br />
best firms. Advertisements, if any, are, how-<br />
ever, paid for by the author.<br />
<br />
These terms must not be taken as rigid ;<br />
they are subject to variation from firm to firm,<br />
and are greatly influenced when the publisher<br />
controls a printing office; in those cases he<br />
often supplies the books at a little over cost<br />
price, which may save the author 2d. a copy.<br />
They are not, however, unusual terms, and<br />
show that the author must sell a considerable<br />
proportion of his first edition before he begins<br />
to make profits. For instance, when the<br />
publisher makes the minimum charge of 33d.<br />
the author must sell 55 per cent. of an edition<br />
of 1,000 copies to clear expenses, after which<br />
he makes Is. 6d. a copy clear profit; in the<br />
second case he must sell nearly 70 per cent.<br />
before he begins to earn 1s. 24d. a copy. The<br />
author’s profits are a little larger on dearer<br />
books, published at 4s. and 6s., for the cost of<br />
production is not much greater.<br />
<br />
It may appear surprising that the cost of<br />
production should be 10d. a copy, but it must<br />
be borne in mind that I refer exclusively to new<br />
books, of which very small editions are printed<br />
in the first instance. Few “ first books ”<br />
appear in first editions of over 1,000; 500 is a<br />
common. figure, while 200 is not unknown.<br />
This, and the high cost of paper (more or less<br />
trust-controlled) makes it difficult to bring the<br />
cost down. I may therefore point out in<br />
passing that we must not too readily be im-<br />
pressed when offered a French book for trans-<br />
<br />
* French novels are seldom bound in the first instance ;<br />
the paper ‘‘ yellow cover”’ is the rule. The author, there-<br />
fore, benefits slightly when copies go to pieces, but this<br />
advantage must not be exaggerated, for well-to-do house-<br />
holders willingly fill their libraries with novels broken up<br />
into two or three segments.<br />
88<br />
<br />
lation ; 23rd edition may mean 100,000 copies,<br />
but it may mean 10,000 to 15,000.<br />
<br />
When a book is issued at publisher’s risk,<br />
and I repeat that “ first books ” are not often<br />
taken up on these terms, it frequently happens<br />
that the book is sold outright, and it is sig-<br />
nificant that several of Zola’s early works, of<br />
which I understand ‘“ L’Assommoir ”’ was one,<br />
were sold for £80. Where the publisher grants<br />
a royalty he pays 34d. to 7d. a copy, but 7d. is<br />
a large royalty, which was paid Zola, and is<br />
to-day given only to the most popular novelists.<br />
These are, in my opinion, very bad terms, and<br />
they are not offset by particularly large-sales :<br />
it is true that Zola repeatedly attained 200,000,<br />
but Messrs. Mirbeau, Bourget, Prévost, Anatole<br />
France, have not yet touched this figure.<br />
They may earn £1,000 to £3,000 a book, which<br />
does not compare very favourably with the<br />
£7,500 which an English author may earn on a<br />
100,000 sale. French sales are not large; the<br />
figures I have quoted apply to a few favoured<br />
books, and they are not greatly exceeded by<br />
those of detective fiction, but the newcomer,<br />
however brilliant, very seldom attains them.<br />
It is true that about 90,000 copies of ‘‘ Marie-<br />
Claire ’” have, so far, been sold, but it is also<br />
Jamentably true that ‘“‘ a new author who has<br />
sold 1,000 copies has not done badly and is a<br />
rising man.” That statement was made to me<br />
by a French publisher, and, it seems to me,<br />
proves that the career of letters does not in<br />
France carry great material rewards.<br />
<br />
The newcomer is therefore not dissatisfied if<br />
he makes £30 to £40 on a first novel ; thus only<br />
can he become known and hope to begin to<br />
reprint his earlier works. There is nothing to<br />
help him, for the buying public of France is no<br />
larger than our own, while it is both avaricious<br />
and poor; it buys if it must, and it has of late<br />
years been corrupted by reprints at 94d., 63d.,<br />
6d., 4d. and 3d, The Frenchman, equally with<br />
the Englishman, will pay for two stalls at the<br />
theatre, but he does not readily part with<br />
2s. 74d. for a book; he buys as little as he can,<br />
and assiduously exchanges books with his<br />
friends, thus constituting a small circulating<br />
library, but he does not buy from the new-<br />
comer; that one must fight his way into<br />
success, by repeated failure and loss, by jour-<br />
nalistic prowess, by scandal or length of time,<br />
before the buying public takes him to its heart.<br />
The French do not, I think, read as much as the<br />
English ; their railway carriages and restaur-<br />
ants are filled with people who read, not the<br />
equivalents of Temple Classics or Sevenpennies,<br />
but newspapers.<br />
<br />
With such a system as this it is not wonderful<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
that new authors are crushed out, fleeced of<br />
their capital or driven into journalism. There<br />
are no circulating libraries to help‘ them, that<br />
is, nO great organisations to which well-to-do<br />
households subscribe as automatically as they<br />
order coal. The ‘‘ Cabinet de Lecture ” is not<br />
the splendid British institution, which so reck-<br />
lessly orders thirteen copies of a first book and<br />
several hundreds of a favourite; the Cabinet<br />
de Lecture is, as a rule, a wretched shop kept<br />
by an elderly spinster; it charges “‘ so much a<br />
book,” generally 1d. to 23d. for four days ; it<br />
buys one Marcel Prévost, two or three under<br />
popular pressure ; it buys one copy of certain<br />
reviews, and remainders, and the derelicts in<br />
second-hand bookshops! As for the new<br />
writer, the publisher’s traveller knows better<br />
than to waste time over him; the Cabinet de<br />
Lecture will buy his work only if pestered by<br />
ten subscribers. There are in Paris two or<br />
three fairly large Cabinets, but they are inter-<br />
ested mainly in science, philosophy, and artistic<br />
theory ; their purchases are not liberal and<br />
their membership is. small. I questioned a<br />
number of well-to-do persons, who informed<br />
me that they did not belong to a library and<br />
that they knew very few people who did.<br />
Beyond Paris is literary emptiness ;_ Versailles,<br />
55,000 inhabitants, equivalent to Lincoln, or<br />
Oxford, is said to have three Cabinets: I<br />
expect there are twenty in Lincoln; a reliable<br />
informant told me that in Bordeaux, 250,000<br />
inhabitants, the principal Cabinet was not<br />
likely to have purchased more than 10 copies of<br />
“Les Dieux ont Soif,” by Anatole France.<br />
That is an amazing statement, for it means<br />
that Mudie’s bought more of this foreigner’s<br />
book than the biggest Cabinet of a French town<br />
equivalent to Leicester or Nottingham. The<br />
object of the Cabinet is to level the demand, to<br />
prevent the public from having what it wants<br />
by trebling the reading fee; it might, for<br />
instance, charge 5d. for two days in the case of<br />
‘“Les Dieux ont Soif,’” so as to force its<br />
members to take “ something of our own.” In<br />
other words, the fraud of the label.<br />
<br />
The upshot of this enquiry is, therefore, that<br />
there are two sides to the library question. In<br />
France, where the people are poor, and in-<br />
credibly inhospitable and mean, it is clear to<br />
me that the literary profession is gravely<br />
hampered by the lack of libraries ;_ the libraries<br />
alone can help the young writer, in a country<br />
where books are not reviewed. There is<br />
practically no book-reviewing in France: let<br />
it not be urged against me that there are<br />
reviews in the Revue de Paris, the Mercure,<br />
the Revue des Deuxa-Mondes, etc., for these<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
deal mainly with ‘serious books,” and are<br />
inclined to favour their own publishing houses ;<br />
nor must the objector lay stress on the poor<br />
scraps of space granted on certain days by<br />
Le Temps, Le Matin, L’Ewcelsior, etc. There<br />
is not a single newspaper in Paris which can<br />
put forward a service to literature equal to the<br />
minimum ten columns a week of the Daily<br />
News, the full pages of the Morning Post and<br />
Daily Telegraph, the column of the Daily<br />
Chronicle.<br />
<br />
The new writer is, in France, absolutely<br />
helpless. Because there are no circulating<br />
libraries he has nothing before him but a<br />
desperate struggle : this would be our fate also<br />
if we could not sell half our first editions to the<br />
libraries. It may be said that, if there were in<br />
France a demand for libraries the libraries<br />
would arise: that I cannot answer, but the<br />
French are cautious speculators, and it may be<br />
that the project has often been considered and<br />
abandoned. Personally I do not think that a<br />
large circulating library would succeed in<br />
Paris; two-thirds of my life have been spent<br />
in that city, and I am not sure that there are<br />
many Parisians prepared to lay down for books<br />
even so small an annual sum as a guinea. The<br />
French have been grossly over-rated by the<br />
British ; if we exclude the intellectuals there<br />
is nothing to show that the great bourgeoisie is<br />
one whit more liberal or cultured than our own.<br />
It is perfectly well contented with social inter-<br />
course as an alternative to reading, and is<br />
taking to its heart the illustrated press ; it is<br />
given over to sensationalism, which is abun-<br />
dantly provided by the dailies, and it is not in<br />
the main inclined to accord its literary men a<br />
treatment much superior to that enjoyed by<br />
its bank clerks.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Ope<br />
<br />
THE DISGRACE OF NOVEL WRITING.<br />
<br />
—+—~<—+—<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
7 novelists are in disgrace; there can<br />
be no doubt about it. Some naughty<br />
ones have been writing foolish books<br />
<br />
and, for their fault, we are all being punished.<br />
For years we have been steadily losing favour<br />
and dignity, and now, unless we can manage<br />
to strike the taste of a large section of the<br />
public, or obtain some special press patronage,<br />
we have to take a very back seat indeed.<br />
<br />
There was a time, not so very many years<br />
ago, when a good novel received as much atten-<br />
tion from reviewers as any other well-written<br />
book. My own early work, for instance, far<br />
inferior to my later and more mature, was<br />
<br />
89<br />
<br />
taken seriously and criticised as fully as<br />
biography and essays are criticised to-day.<br />
But when a new novel of mine appears now<br />
it goes with a batch of pot-boilers (by all the<br />
nobodies who ere writing ‘slush’ novels for<br />
the uneducated) to some novice in the difficult<br />
and delicate art of criticism, who emasculates<br />
it, outlines vulgarly its mere story and washes<br />
out all its true colours in the few inches of print<br />
allowed ; side by side with crude sensationalism<br />
and sentimentalism.<br />
<br />
My fate is the fate of all novelists who strive<br />
after a high ideal. Their striving is never<br />
recognised by those who are set up to guide and<br />
lead literary taste. No distinction whatever<br />
is made between the best and the worst in<br />
fiction; indeed it is not rare to find obvious<br />
pot-boilers well reviewed at length, while<br />
sincere, talented works of art are practically<br />
ignored. For it has become a rule with editors<br />
to give a large amount of space to those<br />
novelists who have ‘arrived,’ whether their<br />
arrival be due to the excellence of their work<br />
or to the bad taste of the general public. In<br />
short, the critics of our day are led by public<br />
taste and follow the lead of the average reader<br />
rather than point the way.<br />
<br />
In arecent number of The Author, Mr. Harold<br />
Thomson drew a moving picture of the author<br />
who, to gain his daily bread, is obliged to “* write<br />
down” to the level of the lowest intelligence of<br />
readers. ‘* You must either,” he said, “ wait<br />
for long years before your work *‘ gets there,’<br />
or you must learn to tickle the palates of your<br />
masters in the gallery.” No doubt. But<br />
has he realised, I wonder, how much quicker<br />
the true artists eculd “get there.” if they<br />
received a little more assistance from those<br />
who ought to be willing and anxious to help<br />
such writers as strive to maintain a high<br />
standard of English fiction ?<br />
<br />
We know the excuse that is always given for<br />
treating all novels alike, that is, as beneath<br />
notice. Their enormous output and the lack<br />
of time and space. Hundreds of novels are<br />
dumped into newspaper offices every week,<br />
and one is not without sympathy for the<br />
harassed men who have to decide who shall<br />
review them. The average editor has no time<br />
to discriminate, we are told, and so the novels<br />
go out in batches, the good, bad and indifferent<br />
all well mixed up, to the young ladies and<br />
gentlemen who essay novel reviewing as a<br />
work of no importance, requiring no special<br />
training.<br />
<br />
Very true, of course, but surely it does not<br />
need much time to recognise a good book from<br />
a paltry one. A glance over the first pages,<br />
90<br />
<br />
or a dip anywhere, should be enough to tell an<br />
expert in literature what is the quality of the<br />
entire work, even when the name of the writer<br />
tells nothing. It is so very easy to distinguish<br />
Great A from a Bull’s Foot, handcraft from<br />
machine-made, art from rubbish? And this<br />
distinction should, in justice, be made. The<br />
well-written, the strongly-conceived and care-<br />
fully executed novel ought to have an assured<br />
place, to be treated seriously in criticism.<br />
<br />
For a novel is, at its best, no less a work of<br />
art than a picture, an opera, or a biography.<br />
<br />
There is always plenty of room in a paper for<br />
long reviews of biographies, of essays, historical<br />
works and travels. There is always room for a<br />
column about the novel of a popular favourite,<br />
irrespective of its merit. Such books are<br />
sent to expert reviewers at once, and receive<br />
the highest attention. But a novel by a<br />
comparatively unknown author—‘only a<br />
novel ’"—chuck it anywhere; let any tyro<br />
criticise it; shove it into some odd corner<br />
where it won’t be noticed ; lump it in with all<br />
the worst ‘slush’ that comes out at the same<br />
time, till it is buried under the mass of rubbish :<br />
and if any reader can dig it out, let him !<br />
<br />
This is the spirit in which the novelist is<br />
treated to-day, and I protest against the rank<br />
injustice of it.<br />
<br />
Is it any wonder that our chance of finding<br />
our own special public (which, though smaller<br />
than the mass public, is not very small and<br />
steadily increasing) diminishes year by year?<br />
Can anybody be surprised if we are tempted to<br />
‘write down’? We believe that our art isa<br />
noble one ; that it is inspiring and educational ;<br />
that it is conducive to a better understanding<br />
of our fellow-creatures in every part of the<br />
world. But a class that is treated con-<br />
temptuously tends to become contemptible.<br />
And what is to be our fate when publishers<br />
will no longer spend their capital on producing<br />
our despised and neglected books ?<br />
<br />
The present system is very hard on us; it<br />
is also very hard on those publishers who still<br />
cherish an ideal of becoming noteworthy<br />
through the high quality of the books they<br />
publish. And when they have printed, dis-<br />
persed and advertised a novel that they feel<br />
is worthy of their name as a firm, they naturally<br />
expect to be assisted in their enterprise by the<br />
papers to which they pay such huge sums for<br />
advertising. Must they not often despair at<br />
the press snippings sent to them concerning<br />
some novel they have ventured upon. And<br />
how long will they be able to publish ws—the<br />
unarrived but ardent strivers after the best.<br />
<br />
It is a pregnant question, my fellow-strivers.<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
Let us face our unhappy position frankly. It<br />
is no good blinding ourselves to it. Can we<br />
not make some appeal to the editors of literary<br />
papers, at least, for justice and discrimination ?<br />
We do not fear criticism, but we have a deadly<br />
fear of ‘ faint praise’ in an inch of print ; of<br />
being ignored or classed with the illiterate.<br />
<br />
We would be taught, corrected, shown the<br />
way to improve, to mend our many faults ;<br />
but we slacken and despair under the foolish<br />
reviews of ignorance. Give us back our old<br />
position. Let the novelist of quality again<br />
take his place in the world of letters, as the<br />
companion of biographists and essayists—<br />
“Else are we very wretched ! ”<br />
<br />
ONE OF THE D1IsGRACED,.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
—t$—— +<br />
<br />
THE LETTERS OF GEORGE MEREDITH.*<br />
<br />
+<br />
<br />
ne HE Letters of George Meredith” will be<br />
<br />
welcomed by all who appreciate the<br />
<br />
works of a great author as well as by<br />
those who find his style too severe for their<br />
taste. We venture to think they will come as<br />
a surprise to many who only knew him through<br />
the pages of his books, which are totally<br />
different in style from the letters.<br />
<br />
“Dulce est disipere in loco.” For pure<br />
bubbling fun and “ chaff ”’ it is difficult to beat<br />
those written to “Friar Tuck” (Sir W.<br />
Hardman) and other friends of early days.<br />
<br />
Full of humour, lightly tossed off, free from<br />
sting unde: the most exasperating cireum-<br />
stances, they make the most refreshing reading<br />
a man could wish for.<br />
<br />
A delightful description of a fellow-traveller,<br />
which will appeal to all who have gone abroad<br />
in un‘ongenial company: |<br />
<br />
“We walked from Innsbruck to Landek in three days.<br />
W. does not walk in rain, or when it’s to be apprehended,<br />
nor whea there’s a chance of nightfall; nor does he like<br />
it in the heat; and he’s not the best hand in the world<br />
at getting up in the morning, and he’s rather excitable.<br />
But still thoroughly kind and good. So we did not come<br />
at a great rate.<br />
<br />
“Somehow or other dear old W. isn’t at all the right<br />
sort of companion. He say’s he thinks it his stomach.<br />
{ tell him that it is not fair for a man to throw his stomach<br />
jn one’s face.”<br />
<br />
It is impossible to lay the volume down as<br />
letter follows letter—brimful of healthy, genial<br />
humour, trenchant criticisms and whole-<br />
hearted gencrous friendship.<br />
<br />
In the second volume they have lost some of<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
* «The Letters of George Meredith,” in two volumes,<br />
Published by Messrs. Constable & Co. :<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
'<br />
‘<br />
<br />
eS ee. Lan of oe<br />
<br />
_ ©<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. 91<br />
<br />
the fresh buoyaney of youth, but they gain<br />
in interest with the wider outlook. So many<br />
subjects of public importance came under<br />
Meredith’s notice owing to his intimate friend-<br />
ship with such men as John Morley, Admiral<br />
Maxse, and others, that he is peculiarly fitted<br />
to write as the looker-on who sees most of the<br />
game.<br />
<br />
There are letters on the Irish question,<br />
Women’s Suffrage and French politics, which<br />
show how much he was in touch with the times<br />
whilst sufficiently aloof to be unhampered in<br />
his judgment.<br />
<br />
On all literary points he is doubly interesting,<br />
especially to those who know his works, for<br />
he writes freely of his difficulties and successes.<br />
His criticism of his fellow authors is marked<br />
by a generous appreciation of their merits.<br />
<br />
Throughout the two volumes we retain the<br />
impression of a vivid personality. The letters<br />
are so unstudied—so spontaneous—being<br />
written almost entirely to intimate friends—<br />
that the real man, tender-hearted, strong to<br />
bear, faithful and courageous, impresses one<br />
as few biographies can do.<br />
<br />
When we consider the storm his writings<br />
roused in religious circles when first published,<br />
the following extract from a letter written to<br />
his son Arthur, in 1872, is noteworthy. Few<br />
will cavil at such words as these.<br />
<br />
“Virtue and truth are one. Look for the truth in<br />
everything, and follow it and you will then be living<br />
justly before God. Let nothing flout your sense of a<br />
Supreme Being, and be certain that your understanding<br />
wavers whenever you chance to doubt that He leads to<br />
<br />
ood. We grow to good as surely as the plant grows to the<br />
ight. The school has only to took through history for a<br />
scientific assurance of it. And do not lose the habit of<br />
praying to the unseen Divinity. Prayer for worldly<br />
goods is worse than fruitless, but prayer for strength of<br />
<br />
soul is that passion of the soul which catches the gift it<br />
seeks.”<br />
<br />
It was long before his writings met with their<br />
due in England. They were received with<br />
more enthusiasm in America, and this fact<br />
doubtless helped him to bear the miscon-<br />
ceptions of his fellow-countrymen with more<br />
philosophy, though at no time did he show<br />
himself over-sensitive to their opinions. In a<br />
letter to G. P. Baker he sets forth his aims,<br />
and comments on the attitude of the public<br />
towards himself.<br />
<br />
“ For I think that all right use of life, and the one secret<br />
of life, is to pave ways for the firmer footing of those who<br />
succeed us. . . . In England I am encouraged but by a<br />
few enthusiasts. I read in a critical review of some verses<br />
of mine the other day that I was ‘a harlequin and a per-<br />
former of antics.’ I am accustomed to that kind of<br />
writing, as our hustings orator is to the dead cat, and the<br />
brickbat flung in his face—at which he smiles politely ;<br />
<br />
and I too; but after many years of it my mind looks else-<br />
where.”<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
There is little reference in the letters to his<br />
connection with the society of which, after<br />
Lord Tennyson, he was the second President,<br />
but in his appreciation of Sir Walter Besant,<br />
at his death, July, 1901, he has written words<br />
that might with little alteration, well apply<br />
to himself. He gave a generous tribute to<br />
our founder’s character and force.<br />
<br />
“Tt is hard to speak of him within measure when we<br />
consider his devotion to the cause of authors and the con-<br />
stant good service rendered by him to their material<br />
interests. We have lost in him the very beating heart of<br />
our Society.”<br />
<br />
Yet in a different way the loss sustained<br />
by the death of George Meredith was as great.<br />
Though his health prevented the active union<br />
his wishes were always strong to support the<br />
efforts of his fellow toilers.<br />
<br />
It is difficult to realise at first what a long<br />
struggle his life must have been, but as time<br />
goes on it becomes fully apparent—not in<br />
weakness or complaint, but in the breadth<br />
and depth of his sympathy with others, his<br />
indifference to the world’s opinion, his stead-<br />
fast front under trials that would utterly have<br />
broken a weaker spirit.<br />
<br />
Through all the fun and frolie of his early<br />
letters, up to the quiet courage of the end,<br />
it is the living man that stands forth, no<br />
pranked out image set up by a partial bio-<br />
grapher. It is this which makes the two large<br />
volumes seem all too short, and gives them their<br />
fascination and their value. Jn the preface we<br />
are told that the collection is very incomplete.<br />
Nevertheless it is of wide range and far-reaching<br />
intertst, as must needs be when drawn from<br />
such a source. :<br />
<br />
‘** Verily there were giants in those days,”<br />
and George Meredith was not the least of them.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE GREEK GENIUS.*<br />
<br />
—_+-~ + —<br />
<br />
“rW\HE Greek Genius and its Meaning<br />
to us’? is a work which deserves<br />
che immediate attention not only of<br />
<br />
every one who reads, or ever has read, more or<br />
<br />
less Greek, but also of all to whom the word<br />
<br />
“Greek”? has a meaning of any kind. The<br />
<br />
author has been at so great pains to make all<br />
<br />
that he has to say lucid, not to classical scholars<br />
alone, but also to the many who make no<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
and its<br />
<br />
* R. W. Livingstone. “The Greek Genius :<br />
vo.<br />
<br />
Meaning to us.” Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1912.<br />
92<br />
<br />
pretension to classical scholarship, that every-<br />
thing, from one end of the book to the<br />
other, is presented in a shape that brings it<br />
within the reach of any reader who may wish<br />
to understand what ‘‘ Greek Genius”? means.<br />
Above all, the very many who, in these days<br />
find a great deal of pleasure in putting forward<br />
their views about the value, or the want of<br />
value, of a Greek education, will be without<br />
excuse for the things which they are pleased<br />
to advance, if they have not taken the trouble<br />
to inform themselves from a work so luminous,<br />
and so replete with scholarship, before stating<br />
their opinions respecting the importance of<br />
Greek.<br />
<br />
So powerful is the presentation of the dif-<br />
ferent aspects of Greek genius in this book, that<br />
it may be asserted without hesitation that no<br />
plea for Greek has been yet put forward so<br />
cogent as the impression which Mr. Living-<br />
stone’s pages produce, nor any reply to those<br />
who object to “compulsory Greek” so<br />
absolutely crushing. Yet to write an adequate<br />
snotice of the book is difficult, or, to say the<br />
truth, impossible. Mr. Livingstone holds out<br />
his guiding hand at the same time to “* students<br />
or teachers of the classics,’ and to “ the<br />
considerable public who take a humane<br />
interest in what Greece has done for the world,”<br />
although they themselves may possess no<br />
Greek. Now, no one can be at the same time<br />
acquainted with Greek and not acquainted<br />
with Greek; and so no human being can<br />
justly say what impressions this book will<br />
make upon minds whose standpoints are so<br />
diverse. All that can be here noted must,<br />
therefore, be accepted as a part only of the<br />
just appreciation of a book of a widely extended<br />
significance.<br />
<br />
What the width of that significance is may<br />
at once be seen from the opening words of the<br />
preface. ‘‘ When I began to teach Latin and<br />
Greek,’ writes Mr. Livingstone, ‘‘ a friend<br />
asked me what I supposed myself to have<br />
learned from them, and what I was trying to<br />
teach others.”<br />
<br />
Does a man exist, who has all his life clung<br />
with affection to the Greek that is in him<br />
(though it be but little), who has not, times out<br />
of number, been assaulted with that same silly<br />
question; and has regretted his inability to<br />
answer it as he would have wished ; because,<br />
as Mr. Livingstone justly puts it, the reply is<br />
*““an arduous task.”’ From this arduous task,<br />
however, so far as Greek is concerned, the<br />
author has not shrunk.<br />
<br />
How the answer is planned, and how it deals<br />
successively with the notes of beauty, freedom,<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
directness, humanism, and others, can be under-<br />
stood only from the work itself, whose exhaus-<br />
tiveness and profundity would be merely<br />
misrepresented in epitome. The book is one<br />
to be read. In page after page the supremest<br />
problems of art and ethics rise spontaneously<br />
to view, and meet with a treatment worthy<br />
of a man whose culture has a Greek basis.<br />
<br />
Witness the significance of this: ‘‘ The<br />
Greeks were not esthetes .... yet they<br />
were the authors of the most beautiful statues,<br />
the most beautiful buildings, and the most<br />
beautiful poems in the world. In mere beauty<br />
their art and literature has never been<br />
equalled.”<br />
<br />
“Why ?” is the word that will instantly<br />
spring from the lips of the modern. But the<br />
author makes no attempt to reply to that<br />
unanswerable ““ Why?’ He contents him-<br />
self, more wisely, with unfolding the central<br />
phenomena of Greek beauty, and thereby<br />
awakens more reflections than could arise from<br />
any effort to define the indefinable. For until<br />
the modern can attain Greek beauty he cannot<br />
know what it is. ‘‘ He that is without an art<br />
cannot rightly know the things of that art.” *<br />
<br />
Of an entirely different description is the<br />
author’s treatment of a _ subject directly<br />
interesting to authors—the contrast between<br />
classical conciseness, and modern lavish<br />
amplification—the quagmire of words that<br />
renders much at present named “ literature ”<br />
so repulsive to the classical scholar. Respect-<br />
<br />
ing this, Mr. Livingstone remarks, ‘‘ The<br />
classic shows us the scene... . and leaves<br />
<br />
us to find the appropriate emotions; and<br />
because many readers have no emotions to<br />
supply, they are apt to find the classics unfeel-<br />
ing and cold.’’ We would like to add, ‘* And<br />
many modern books delightful, because they<br />
are written exactly to suit the people for whom<br />
it is waste of time to write.” ~<br />
<br />
Mr. Livingstone has also a happy knack of<br />
picking out plums. On Xenophon’s mention<br />
of ‘* physique eminently comely to the outward<br />
eye” as a qualification for high political office,<br />
he remarks, ‘‘ How few modern statesmen<br />
would satisfy this condition ! ”<br />
<br />
Of quotations from this book there would be<br />
no end; and they must be here foreborne for<br />
the sake of a few lines on the concluding<br />
chapters in which the author deals with<br />
‘* The Exceptions,” as he declares them to be,<br />
Plato and Euripides, and with “ The Fifth<br />
Century and afterwards.” Here, if the term<br />
may be permitted ‘“‘ The Greek Genius” is<br />
<br />
* Plato, Ion. IX.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
beginning to droop ; and we perceive a move-<br />
ment in the direction of the thought of other<br />
jands and other times. The supreme things of<br />
beauty, directness, and sanity are drifting<br />
into the past. Are they ever to be revived ?<br />
That appears to be beyond hope. The Greek<br />
had no sentimentality. He “stood on the<br />
earth’?; but he was not “ of the earth,<br />
earthy”; and this is just what the modern<br />
cannot achieve. Among the thoughts which<br />
Mr. Livingstone’s book awakens is a regret for<br />
the passing away of a sense of beauty and<br />
stability that can never be again; buta regret<br />
accompanied by an infinite thankfulness for<br />
the preservation of but a fragment of the<br />
marvellous Greek world; whilst on this the<br />
author is to be wholly congratulated, that he<br />
had built for the defence of Greek a bastion<br />
that ignorance may choose to disregard, but<br />
which no attack can demolish.<br />
<br />
—————_—$_$§_e— > ——__<br />
<br />
ANDREW LANG’S LAST BOOK.*<br />
<br />
—_—+<br />
<br />
TTAVUIS book is likely to be the more rather<br />
[' than the less popular because it is not<br />
exactly the sort of book that the title<br />
might seem to indicate, Andrew Lang did not<br />
approach his subject in the spirit of a professor,<br />
put rather in that of an artist of the impres-<br />
sionist school, who paints just what he sees,<br />
without troubling overmuch about the other<br />
things which he knows to be there, though they<br />
do not happen to catch his eye. Only a man<br />
of great natural gifts and wide reading could<br />
tackle so large a theme acceptably in that<br />
manner; but he possessed both qualifications<br />
jn an eminent degree. For pretentious syn-<br />
thesis we must go to other writers—there are<br />
many professors who excel him in that depart-<br />
ment of endeavour, and are more helpful to<br />
the student who desires to stock his mind with<br />
ready-made generalisations of the kind which<br />
discover and penctrate the weak points in the<br />
armour of examiners. Impersonal exposi-<br />
tion was foreign to the habit of his mind. In<br />
whatever he wrote, there was always quite as<br />
much of himself as of his subject, and some-<br />
times a good deal more. He travelled among<br />
books for his pleasure ;_ and this is the relation<br />
of his journey. We find him no Baedeker among<br />
guides, apportioning his space according to<br />
the requirements of the conventional, but one<br />
“who digresses when he chooses, and does not<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
* «History of English Literature from ‘ Beowulf’ to<br />
Swinburne,” by Andrew Lang. Longmans.<br />
<br />
93<br />
<br />
hesitate to leave Yarrow unvisited if he fears<br />
that Yarrow will be tedious.<br />
<br />
There is no existing “History of English<br />
Literature ” which it is more pleasing to open at<br />
random, and dip into in the hope of pulling out<br />
a plum. On page after page, one is reminded<br />
of those delightful leading articles which Lang<br />
used to contribute to the Daily News in the<br />
days before the Dawn of the Cocoa Age, when<br />
English journalism was as yet neither brace<br />
to the strenuous life nor watered by the tears<br />
of sensibility. Apposite allusiveness was<br />
always the chief charm of those compositions ;<br />
and it is also the chief charm of the manual now<br />
under review. In the old days, it will be<br />
remembered, Lang could not write of Aristotle<br />
without dragging in John Lillywhite, or of<br />
John Lillywhite without dragging in Aristotle.<br />
One could always spot his essays without<br />
reading them, by looking out for the unlikely<br />
name—unlikely, that is to say, in other<br />
leaders—in small capitals. So now, in the<br />
present volume, the individuality of the<br />
handiwork is marked by constant references—<br />
unnecessary from the academic point of view,<br />
but none the less entertaining—to other matters<br />
in which the author has interested himself<br />
in the course of a life rich in the variety of his<br />
interests. The mention of “* Peregrine Pickle,”<br />
for instance, suggests a mention of Pickle the<br />
Spy. Resemblances are pointed out between<br />
the plots of modern novels and the legends<br />
prevalent among aboriginal savage tribes. A<br />
quotation illustrative of Macaulay's hammer-<br />
and-tongs prose style is further illuminated by<br />
a comment on William III.’s treatment of the<br />
Scots. The Covenanters are also incidentally<br />
characterised; an error in the printed report<br />
of Bryon’s score in the Eton and Harrow match<br />
is corrected ; doubts are suggested as to the<br />
exactitude of Charles Kingsley’s account of<br />
the training of the Cambridge cight in the<br />
fifties; and of course the Maid of Orleans is<br />
defended against those who have assailed her<br />
memoryand treated her visions as hallucinations.<br />
<br />
It is to be noted, moreover, that writers are,<br />
for Andrew Lang, almost always human beings<br />
as well as writers. They, as well as their books,<br />
have been the travelling companions of his<br />
literary pilgrimage. He gossips about them,<br />
and even quizzes them, especially when he<br />
approaches modern. times. Both his method<br />
and his point of view may be illustrated by<br />
his remark on the limitations of George<br />
Meredith’s popularity : ‘‘ The writer has seen<br />
quite unaffected young girls absorbed in The<br />
Egoist or Diana of the Crossways, while he,<br />
after gallant efforts, was defeated by both ina<br />
94<br />
<br />
very early round, tripped up on every page by<br />
the leg of Sir Wilfrid the Egoist. Too much<br />
seemed to be made of that limb.” All the<br />
characteristic flavour of the book is in those<br />
sentences.<br />
<br />
F. G.<br />
———_-+ > -<br />
THE PROBLEM OF EDWIN DROOD.*<br />
—— 1<br />
<br />
HE problem of Edwin Drood has been<br />
much discussed of late, and there is little<br />
reason why the discussion should not<br />
<br />
continue, inasmuch as a vast field of criticism<br />
iS now opened up by the statements and de-<br />
ductions of various writers in their attempts<br />
to elucidate the mystery. A whole literature<br />
may rise around not what Dickens wrote,<br />
but around the various and varying inter-<br />
pretations of both his words and his implica-<br />
tions. The moment criticism reaches this<br />
point Dickens’s personal equation as man and<br />
as worker comes into consideration, and Sir<br />
W. Robertson Nicoll’s book is largely made up<br />
of an enquiry into the methods of Dickens as<br />
a story-teller, so that the probability of his<br />
intentions with regard to his unfinished book<br />
may be estimated in the light of his other<br />
works. The result is an interesting essay<br />
both for those who love Dickens and those<br />
who feel the fascination of unravelling a riddle.<br />
<br />
“The Mystery of Edwin Drood ”’ is a triple<br />
one, as has often been pointed out. Assuming<br />
that all who care anything about the book<br />
know the story, it will be sufficient to say that<br />
the first unanswered question is—Has Edwin<br />
Drood been murdered at all? the second is<br />
—wWho is Datchery, the detective who is left,<br />
as the pen dropped from Dickens’s dying hand,<br />
engaged in bringing home either a murder or<br />
an unsuccessful attempt at murder to Jasper,<br />
Edwin’s uncle; and the third is (speaking<br />
generally )—How was the book planned to end ?<br />
Obviously the answer to the third question<br />
to some extent depends upon the answer to<br />
the first, for, insignificant a character as<br />
Edwin is, still he is the centre around which<br />
the book turns, and if he has not been mur-<br />
dered, his position on re-entering the drama<br />
has to be accounted for. Sir W. Robertson<br />
Nicoll takes the view that Edwin has been<br />
murdered, and sums up all the evidence,<br />
supplied by the book and its numerous com-<br />
mentators, to arrive at this conclusion. If<br />
Edwin is not murdered, Dickens, anxiously<br />
<br />
* «The Proklem of Edwin Drocd,” Ly Sir W. Robertson<br />
- ce —_ Icndon: Hedder & Stcugkton. 212 pp.<br />
s, Od, net.<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
reticent as he was about his plot, would seem<br />
to have unnecessarily deluded personal friends<br />
as to his intention, This argument alone<br />
seems to us to be conclusive in favour of the<br />
now popular view that Jasper actually accom-<br />
plished his design; in addition to which, if<br />
Edwin is not murdered, his silent absence,<br />
leaving the innocent Landless under suspicion,<br />
is inexplicable ; while the part that remains<br />
for him to play in the story is puzzling, as<br />
his hero’s right to the affections of the heroine<br />
has been taken from him by a subsidiary<br />
leading gentleman, Tartar. The second ques-<br />
tion, the identity of Datchery is settled by<br />
Sir W. Robertson Nicoll in favour of Helena<br />
Landless, disguised as a man. This is the<br />
fascinating suggestion which was made by<br />
Mr. Cuming Walters six or seven years ago, and<br />
which has since been vigorously combated by<br />
many, and ultimately adopted by many of the<br />
combatants. The superficial improbabilities of<br />
this theory are large, though the actual written<br />
suggestions of Dickens can be made to support<br />
it. Its main strength depends upon the fact<br />
that Dickens in no way conceals the fact that<br />
Datchery is a disguised person keeping a watch<br />
over Jasper, while no other person in the<br />
book appears able to fill this part. Helena<br />
Landless is thus arrived at by exhaustion of the<br />
alternatives—all but one. The late Mr. R. A.<br />
Proctor suggested that Datchery was Drood<br />
himself; until Mr. Cuming Walters made his<br />
brave proposition, the accepted idea was<br />
either Proctor’s, or that Bazzard, a comic<br />
clerk, was playing the part; Bazzard’s aged<br />
master,Grewgious, has obtained some suffrages ;<br />
and lastly there is the possibility that Datchery<br />
may be anew character altogether, introduced<br />
by Dickens when the book was half complete<br />
—for we know that the “ Mystery of Edwin<br />
Drood,”’ was to appear in twelve numbers,<br />
and of these we have six numbers all but<br />
two pages. This last theory is the one that<br />
obviously cannot be dealt with as probable<br />
or improbable in connection with any events<br />
narrated ; therefore it presents the least<br />
difficulty, but it does imply a considerable loss<br />
of concentration in the plot.<br />
<br />
Sir William Robertson Nicoll does not<br />
support it, and shows that at any rate in some<br />
of Dickens’s best-known works, no really<br />
important character is ever introduced when<br />
the book is half written. ‘That is true, but<br />
there is some proof that Dickens was a little<br />
worried over the development of his last story,<br />
and in many ways, to suppose Datchery to<br />
be a new character, is the safest solution.<br />
For, indeed, it is hard to believe in the ability<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
a<br />
:<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. 95<br />
<br />
of Helena Landless, a girl recently arrived in<br />
England from Ceylon, to exhibit the aplomb<br />
and experience necessary if she is to counterfeit<br />
successfully a middle-aged idle Englishman<br />
during a sojourn in hotels and lodgings.<br />
<br />
Concerning the final course of the story,<br />
there seems no reason to suppose that the<br />
little which Dickens actually said was other<br />
than his real intention. Jasper was to be<br />
convicted of his crime and to suffer for it.<br />
Jasper was himself to tell the story while<br />
in prison, and in this way, or owing to Datch-<br />
ery’s investigations, an explanation would<br />
be forthcoming of the actual circumstances<br />
of the crime, and of the various steps taken<br />
to bring it home to the doer. Jasper’s past<br />
life had passages in it, we may easily suppose,<br />
which would make clear the part in the story<br />
played by the “ Princess Puffer,’ and the<br />
“Deputy”; and we agree with Sir W.<br />
Robertson Nicoll, that these passages, con-<br />
cerning which we have no information and<br />
few hints, might furnish the material for<br />
finishing the book, logically drawing all the<br />
numerous loose threads tightly.together.<br />
<br />
Lovers of Dickens will thank Sir William<br />
Robertson Nicoll for an able exposition of an<br />
ever exciting question; the bibliography will<br />
possibly stimulate many readers to examine<br />
the evidence for themselves; no one can<br />
read the book without being impelled to read<br />
** Edwin Drood,”’ a result which we are<br />
sure the latest writer on the mystery would<br />
love.<br />
<br />
CORRESPONDENCE.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
LITERATURE—ITS SupPLY AND DEMAND.<br />
<br />
Sir,—Complaints of the inevitable penury<br />
of the writer of books are frequent in the<br />
correspondence columns of The Author; for<br />
which state of things remedies such as “ co-<br />
operative publishing ”’ are suggested, publishers<br />
are blamed, and a vacuous public censured.<br />
<br />
It seems to me the explanation is quite<br />
simple. If, to-day, all living authors suddenly<br />
ceased to write, there would yet be books<br />
enough in the world to last to the Millennium.<br />
The English reader, living to old age, and<br />
following Dr. Johnson's advice to read for<br />
five hours a day, would have his work cut out<br />
to consume the masterpieces of his own<br />
language, from the Canterbury Tales to Tono<br />
Bungay.<br />
<br />
The creators of books cannot hope to prosper<br />
in ease and comfort in a business in which the<br />
supply so exceeds the demand; wnless their<br />
work either supplies some special and definite<br />
demand, or rises by dint of its own merit superior<br />
to the flood of mediccrity amidst which it must<br />
take its chance.<br />
<br />
Of course, there are, and always will be,<br />
hard cases ; such as the man who is too much<br />
in advance of his age. However, he has his<br />
small, but enthusiastic, public. He must rest<br />
content with that. Its smallness is responsible<br />
for his poverty; its enthusiasm, for his<br />
ultimate, and often posthumous, success.<br />
But these are the exceptions and not examples<br />
of the rule.<br />
<br />
There is no need for the army of admirable<br />
esthetes to complain, from one generation to<br />
another, of the extreme vulgarity of the age.<br />
To be cultured is the privilege of the elect,<br />
and of the leisured. And it is just as well,<br />
perhaps, that the greengrocer is mostly occu-<br />
pied with greengroceries. If his activities<br />
were employed upon the problems of bi-<br />
metallism we should have to be satisfied with<br />
indifferent vegetables.<br />
<br />
As a matter of fact, with such a world of books<br />
to choose from, fastidiousness—rather than<br />
vulgarity—in the public has been encouraged.<br />
They will have nothing but the best—that is<br />
to say, what they regard as the best. This<br />
applies not only to the scholar and the man<br />
of taste, but even to the reader of the feuilleton<br />
in the halfpenny paper. And why blame the<br />
last? He is most certainly your own green-<br />
grocer who, in his own humble department,<br />
supplies your wants, as punctiliously as the<br />
writer of the feuwilleton supplies his. And if<br />
you ventured to recommend to his notice the<br />
psychological studies of Mr. Wells, the mys-<br />
ticism of M. Maeterlinck, or the exquisite<br />
sensibility of Mr. Barrie, he would consider<br />
you utterly mad. And yet these three gentle-<br />
men, in their senility, are hardly likely to be<br />
found upon the doorsteps of the workhouse.<br />
<br />
As for the author who strives to excel in the<br />
highest representation of his art, he is much to<br />
be commended. But, if he fails, in 99 cases<br />
out of 100, he does so, not because his is the<br />
exceptional case of genius unrewarded, but<br />
because, in his profession—perhaps more than<br />
any other—it is only the fit who survive.<br />
Instead of laying the blame at the doors of<br />
publishers and public, it seems to me it would<br />
be well to recognise, not necessarily defeat,<br />
but the power of the forces we must combat<br />
before we can hope to win.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
C. L. GrILson.<br />
96<br />
<br />
Tue Latrer-Day Nove.<br />
<br />
Dear Avutuor,—Concerning Dean Inge’s<br />
generally resented attack in his recent speech<br />
to the Library Assistants’ Association on the<br />
inferiority of present-day novels, their ‘“‘sloven-<br />
liness,’’ ete.—referred to in The Standard of<br />
October 18th, under the heading of “‘ A Novelist’s<br />
Revenge ’—the writer notes one clause that<br />
provokes the following comment. It reads<br />
as follows :<br />
<br />
‘No publisher wants, or would publish<br />
just now, works such as Thackeray’s if pre-<br />
sented in MS. The same thing applies to<br />
Dickens, Hugo, and many of our giants.<br />
“Les Misérables ’ would never be accepted by<br />
a publisher’s reader,”’ etc.<br />
<br />
From the above may one not be forgiven for<br />
wondering if perhaps the mass of trivial<br />
‘“* popular ” fiction upon the market is not as<br />
much the fault of the publisher or publisher’s<br />
reader—who, like the author, ‘‘ must live ”—<br />
as indicative of the “ degeneracy ”’ of writers,<br />
or the “ public taste” ?<br />
<br />
The writer is not a wholly disgruntled author,<br />
having been read for some years both in America<br />
and England; but an experience with the<br />
MS. of a recent novel has opened her eyes to<br />
a state of things which may not seem lacking<br />
in pith to authors.<br />
<br />
The aforesaid MS. was the result of five<br />
years’ labour, during which other MSS. had<br />
been successfully launched. When sent out<br />
in its search of a “ convinced ”’ publisher it<br />
secured a totally different reception from its<br />
predecessors.<br />
<br />
Every publisher praised it, but no publisher<br />
wanted it. Instead of coming back with the<br />
customary printed slip, it invariably returned<br />
accompanied by apologies for its refusal<br />
appended to unqualified appreciation. Four<br />
pages from one well-known house explained<br />
that although acknowledging the MS.’ distinc-<br />
tion and capacity to excite nothing but praise<br />
from the leading reviewers—the publishers<br />
“could not assure it a sufficient sale to<br />
warrant,”’ ete.<br />
<br />
Another publisher, with a letter of high<br />
praise, gratuitously forwarded a copy of the<br />
reader’s “behind the scenes” report, which<br />
advised a curtailment of about 100 pages.<br />
<br />
Although no longer a novice—and therefore<br />
as incredulous of Jthe infallibility of the<br />
accredited reader as of the infallibility of the<br />
Pope—the author nibbled at the bait. To be<br />
opportune that novel, if published at all,.must<br />
be published at once. The work of curtailment<br />
was carried through with an aching heart, and<br />
the MS. found itself back with that publisher—<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
to be immediately returned. It was 80,000<br />
words in length. It was returned in three days.<br />
<br />
The MS. then accompanied its author to<br />
America and was sent to a “ foremost ”<br />
publishing house. The unfavourable slip that<br />
ushered it back this time was also coated with<br />
sugar,<br />
<br />
“It is with real regret that we find ourselves<br />
forced to return your MS,” it read, ‘‘ as it has<br />
claims to great distinction of style, is altogether<br />
excellent, and treats of its subject—a difficult<br />
one—with engaging skill; but owing to the<br />
present overstocked state of the market we<br />
cannot undertake,”’ etc., ete.<br />
<br />
In an hour that writer found herself at that<br />
publishers in conversation with ‘the head of<br />
the firm ’”—to whom she had until this kept<br />
a personal letter up her sleeve.<br />
<br />
“If publishers that place themselves on<br />
record as believers in the excellence of a MS.<br />
won’t publish it?” she asked, ‘‘ who will?<br />
Can’t you see that you are the people who are’<br />
overstocking the market with trash, and<br />
underrating public intelligence for buying<br />
it, because, by. your own confession, you<br />
daren’t publish ‘ excellence ’ ?<br />
<br />
‘* Publishers consider all novels a_ wild<br />
speculation ’’ was the answer. ‘“‘ The books<br />
they bank on must be sure to excite a demand.<br />
Such publications as, for instance, ‘The<br />
Flora of Patagonia’ or ‘The Encyclopedia<br />
Britannica’ are no risk. . . . There are novels<br />
which secure a phenomenal success—such as ”<br />
—he mentioned thename of a “‘record-breaker,”’<br />
which his house had launched. .. .<br />
<br />
“Singular how the enthusiasm of our<br />
‘younger group’ put that through,” he<br />
vouchsafed, ‘“‘ andthow such enthusiasm prods<br />
the salesmen to big efforts. But it must be<br />
unanimous to make the salesmen take hold.<br />
In cases where it is not the salesmen in con-<br />
sequence are slack, and the book fails.”<br />
<br />
“You mean,’’ I exclaimed, ‘‘ that when the<br />
enthusiasm of one or two of ‘the group’<br />
wavers, ‘the salesmen’ make little effort to<br />
sell it 22<br />
<br />
‘* Precisely.”<br />
<br />
Might not the remedy for too ephemeral<br />
literature be found between the lines of the<br />
following ? :<br />
<br />
‘“* How do you keep your dog so healthy ?”<br />
inquired one sportsman of another.<br />
<br />
‘“* T feed him on oatmeal,” was the reply.<br />
<br />
“But my dog howls continually for meat,”<br />
protested the first sportsman.<br />
<br />
“Starve him of all food but oatmeal,”<br />
insisted the second, “and he’ll be only too<br />
glad to eat It.” | https://historysoa.com/files/original/5/523/1912-12-01-The-Author-23-3.pdf | publications, The Author |