478 | https://historysoa.com/items/show/478 | The Author, Vol. 13 Issue 03 (December 1902) | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=49&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=%3Cem%3EThe+Author%3C%2Fem%3E%2C+Vol.+13+Issue+03+%28December+1902%29"><em>The Author</em>, Vol. 13 Issue 03 (December 1902)</a> | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=51&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Publication">Publication</a> | 1902-12-01-The-Author-13-3 | | | | | 57–80 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=89&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=13">13</a> | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=76&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=1902-12-01">1902-12-01</a> | | | | | | | 3 | | | 19021201 | VOL, SITT_ No. 3.<br />
<br />
DECEMBER Ist, 1902.<br />
<br />
[PRICE SIXPENCE.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
CHANGE OF ADDRESS.<br />
<br />
a<br />
<br />
As mistakes still occur with regard to the<br />
Address of the Society, it has been thought<br />
expedient to continue this Notice, that the Office<br />
of the Society is situated at—<br />
<br />
39, OLD QUEEN STREET,<br />
STOREY’S GATE, S.W.<br />
<br />
The Telephone connection has now been estab-<br />
<br />
. lished, and the Society’s number is—<br />
<br />
374 VICTORIA.<br />
<br />
—_—_____ —~>—_<br />
<br />
NOTICES.<br />
<br />
+<br />
<br />
OR the opinions expressed in papers that are<br />
signed or initialled the Authors alone are<br />
responsible. None of the papers or para-<br />
<br />
graphs must be taken as expressing the opinion<br />
of the Committee unless such is especially stated<br />
to be the case.<br />
<br />
Tue Editor begs to inform Members of the<br />
Authors’ Society and other readers of The Author<br />
<br />
. that the cases which are from time to time quoted<br />
<br />
in The Author are cases that have come before the<br />
notice or to the knowledge of the Secretary of the<br />
Society, and that those members of the Society<br />
who desire to have the names of the publishers<br />
concerned can obtain them on application.<br />
<br />
+<br />
<br />
List of Members.<br />
<br />
TuE list of members of the Society of Authors<br />
can now be obtained at the offices of the Society,<br />
at the price of 6d. net.<br />
<br />
It will be sold to the members of the Society<br />
only.<br />
<br />
You, XIII.<br />
<br />
The Pension Fund of the Society.<br />
<br />
THe Investments of the Pension Fund at<br />
present standing in the names of the Trustees are<br />
as follows.<br />
<br />
This is a statement of the actual stock; the<br />
money value can be easily worked out at the current<br />
price of the market :—<br />
<br />
ORCS Fo ie £816 5 6<br />
Wocal Woans 20.2.3... 404 10 0<br />
<br />
Victorian Government 3 % Con-<br />
solidated Inscribed Stock............ 291 19 11<br />
War dan 252 3 201 9 3<br />
Moual 4. ae. Si7i4 4 8<br />
<br />
There is, in addition, a balance of about £20<br />
in the Bank to cover current expenses and the<br />
payment of pensions. This does not include the<br />
amount received from the special appeal sent out<br />
in November.<br />
<br />
The subscriptions and donations from June 24th<br />
are as follows.<br />
<br />
Further sums will be acknowledged from month<br />
to month as they come to hand.<br />
<br />
DONATIONS.<br />
July 17, Capes, Bernard E. ............ 50 bo: 9<br />
Oct. 28, Evans, Miss May ............ 0.5 0<br />
Noy. 11, Bisiker, Wo 0... 0 5 0<br />
ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTIONS.<br />
July 19, Warden, Miss Gertrude...... 20 8 8<br />
Oct. 21, Thomson, Miss ©. L.......... 0 5 0<br />
Oct. 23, Butter, . 1.7... QO 5. 0<br />
e<br />
<br />
SpeciAL APPEAL.<br />
<br />
Tue Appeal sent out by the Chairman of the<br />
Society at the request of the Pension Fund Com-<br />
mittee has been, so far, very successful.<br />
<br />
Up to and including the 22nd of November, the<br />
list of subscriptions and donations promised and<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
58<br />
<br />
given is set forth below. Further subscriptions<br />
and donations will be acknowledged in the January<br />
<br />
number.<br />
Subscriptions.<br />
<br />
Nov. 14, Tuckett, F. i : : .£1 0 0<br />
» Cox, Miss Roalfe 0 5.0<br />
» Loynbee, William . 010 6<br />
, Anonymous . ’ : 1 0 0<br />
» odd, Miss Margaret, M.D. 1 1 oO<br />
», Pearson, Mrs. Conney 2 2 0<br />
» Seaman, Owen . ; i 0<br />
» Abbot, Rev. Edwin A. D.D.. 1 0 9<br />
» Witherby, Rev. C. . : 0 5 0<br />
» _ salwey, Reginald E. 010 0<br />
» Vacher, Francis 11.0<br />
<br />
Noy. 15, Parr, Mrs. - : Taleo<br />
» Davy, Mrs. E. M. . : 010 6<br />
» Allingham, William, F.R.C.S. 1 1 O<br />
» Armstrong, Miss Frances O b&b 0<br />
<br />
» Holmes, Arthur H. (condi-<br />
<br />
tional) 1 A 0<br />
<br />
» Rattray, Alex. : : 0 5 0<br />
<br />
, Brodrick, The Honble. Mrs. . 1 1 0<br />
<br />
Nov. 17, Nesbit, Hume ; 010 0<br />
<br />
» Keene, H.G.,C081. . 520 07-0<br />
<br />
» Bayly, Miss A. E. (Edna Lyall) 1 1 0<br />
<br />
» Forbes, E. . : 2 2 0<br />
<br />
: Spiers, Victor. : ; 0 5 0<br />
<br />
» Kroeker, Mrs. Freiligrath 0 5 0<br />
<br />
» Burrowes, Miss Elsa 1 1 0<br />
<br />
» Cooke-Taylor, R. W. 1 0. 0<br />
<br />
Noy. 18, Voysey, Rev. Charles 10 0<br />
<br />
» Jones, W. Braunston 0220. 0<br />
<br />
» Anonymous . : 0 5 0<br />
<br />
», Salmond, Mrs. Walter 0 5 0<br />
<br />
,» Anonymous ; 1.0 0<br />
<br />
,, Clough, Miss B. A. 010 6<br />
<br />
5 Stanton, Miss H. M. 0 5 0<br />
<br />
» “Lucas Malet” 2.2 0<br />
<br />
Nov. 20, E.G. . : : 010 0<br />
<br />
» Jenkins, Miss Hadow O50<br />
<br />
» Morrah, H. A. ‘ 010 6<br />
<br />
» Hatton-Ellis, Mrs. . 11.0<br />
<br />
. Bertouch, The Baroness de 0 5 0<br />
<br />
Anonymous 0 2 6<br />
<br />
Nov. 21, Parr, Miss Olive 0. 5 0<br />
<br />
Nov. 22, Forbes, Lady Helen 1200<br />
<br />
», Twycross, Miss M. 0 5 0<br />
<br />
Donatwns.<br />
<br />
Noy. 13, Bullen, F. T.. : : so 0 0<br />
» Roberts, Morley (an annual<br />
<br />
subscriber) . ; 010 0<br />
<br />
Nov. 14, Rossetti, W.M. . -- 4 0 0<br />
<br />
Marshall, Capt. Robert . 5 5 0<br />
<br />
», Hoyer, Miss . ‘ 1.0 0<br />
<br />
oc of MS, D0 0<br />
<br />
» Lefroy, Mrs. . a)<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
Nov. 14, Sinclair, Miss May (an annual<br />
subscriber) . ; : £<br />
, McBride, Capt. E. E.<br />
5, Garnier, Russell .<br />
Noy. 15, Burchell, Sidney H.<br />
5 “Spero” : :<br />
» Cecil Medlicott” .<br />
ss Harker, Mrs. Allen<br />
a Banks, Mrs. M. M.<br />
a Spielmann, M.H. .<br />
» Garnier, Col. J. .<br />
5 Benecke, Miss Ida .<br />
, Atton, Henry :<br />
Nov. 17, Panter, Rev. C. B..<br />
» Keene, H. G., C.8.I.<br />
<br />
a<br />
wore<br />
<br />
ay<br />
<br />
Soo or eococeoNecr aS<br />
Hee =<br />
SB DOW MO OH AUMAAHOSWONS<br />
<br />
oooeo ee<br />
<br />
», Spielmann, Mrs. M. 4H. . 1<br />
» Begbie, Harold 73<br />
4, Stevenson, J.J. . : 10<br />
, Minniken, Miss Bertha M. 0<br />
Noy. 18, From sale of autograph . 1<br />
» Wintle, H. R. : : 0<br />
». Brickdale-Corbett, H.M. . 0<br />
». Defries, Miss Violet , 0<br />
Nov. 19, Stanton, Miss Hannah M. 1<br />
» Warren, Major-General Sir<br />
Charles, K.C.M.G. 1 0<br />
». “Lucas Malet”. : 5 5<br />
Nov. 20, Wynne, Charles Whitworth 5b<br />
Nov. 22, Skeat, The Rev. Prof. W. We. 5 8<br />
<br />
The following members have also made subscrip-<br />
tions or donations :—<br />
<br />
Meredith, George, President of the Society.<br />
<br />
Thompson, Sir Henry, Bart., F.R.C.S.<br />
<br />
Rashdall, The Rev. H.<br />
<br />
Guthrie, Anstey.<br />
<br />
Robertson, C. B.<br />
<br />
There are in addition other subscribers who do<br />
<br />
not desire that either their names or the amount’<br />
<br />
they are subscribing should be printed.<br />
<br />
The total amount of cash actually received is.<br />
£147 18s.<br />
<br />
Mr. Hamilton Drummond, who is a member of<br />
our Society, has offered a subscription of £10 for<br />
<br />
five years, if nine other members of the Society<br />
<br />
will promise the same contribution before 31st<br />
March, 1903.<br />
<br />
We sincerely hope that sufficient members of<br />
the Society will be found to come forward and<br />
meet Mr. Drummond’s generous offer, and that<br />
before the time expires we may be able to print in<br />
the columns of Zhe Author the full list of ten<br />
subscribers of the required amount.<br />
<br />
Subscriptions.<br />
Hawkins, A. Hope . : : .£10 0 0<br />
Barrie, J. M. . . : : 10 0 8<br />
Drummond, Hamilton : . . 10 0 0<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
Tue Pension Funpd COMMITTEE.<br />
<br />
In order to give members of the Society, should<br />
they desire to appoint a fresh member to the<br />
Pension Fund Committee, full time to act, it has<br />
been thought advisable to place in 7he Author a<br />
full statement of the method of election under the<br />
Scheme for administration of the Pension Fund.<br />
Under that Scheme the Committee is composed of<br />
three members elected by the Committee of the<br />
Society, three members elected by the Society at<br />
the General Meeting, and the Chairman of the<br />
Society for the time being, ex officio. The three<br />
members elected at the General Meeting when the<br />
Fund was started, were Mr. Morley Roberts, Mr.<br />
M. H. Spielmann, and Mrs. Alec Tweedie. Last<br />
year, Mrs. Alec Tweedie resigned in due course,<br />
and submitting her name for re-election was<br />
unanimously re-elected. This year, Mr. Morley<br />
Roberts in turn, under the Rules of the Scheme,<br />
tenders his resignation and submits his name for<br />
re-election. The members have power to put for-<br />
ward other names under Clause 9 which runs as<br />
follows :—<br />
<br />
“* Any candidate for election to the Pension Fund Com-<br />
mittee by the members of the Society (mot being a retiring<br />
member of such Committee) shall be nominated in writing<br />
<br />
to the Secretary, at least three weeks prior to the General<br />
Meeting at which such candidate is to be proposed, and the<br />
nomination of each such candidate shall be subscribed by,<br />
at least, three members of the Society. A list of the names<br />
of the candidates so nominated shall be sent to the members<br />
of the Society with the annual report of the Managing<br />
Committee, and those candidates obtaining the most votes<br />
at the General Meeting shall be elected to serve on the<br />
Pension Fund Committee.”<br />
<br />
Tn case any member should desire to refer to the<br />
List of Members, a copy complete, with the excep-<br />
tion of those members referred to in the note at<br />
the beginning, can be obtained at the Society’s<br />
-otfice.<br />
<br />
Tt would be as well, therefore, should any of the<br />
members desire to put forward candidates, to take<br />
the matter within their immediate consideration.<br />
‘The General Meeting of the Society has usually<br />
been held towards the end of February or the<br />
beginning of March. This notice will be repeated<br />
in the January number of Vhe Author. It is<br />
essential that all nominations should be in the<br />
hands of the Secretary before the 31st of January,<br />
1903.<br />
<br />
+<br />
<br />
Sir Walter Besant Memorial Fund.<br />
<br />
THE amount standing to the credit<br />
of this account in the Bank is.:....... £327 15 0<br />
<br />
There are a few promised subscriptions stil<br />
outstanding. The total of these is, roughly,<br />
<br />
59<br />
<br />
about £4. The subscriptions received from March<br />
to the date of issue are given below :—<br />
<br />
Anonymous. : : : - £17670<br />
Champneys, Basil . : I)<br />
“ Colonia,” Natal, 8. Africa 1. 0<br />
Fife Cookson, Lt.-Col. F. C. Tet 6<br />
Gunter, Lt.-Col. E. A. : 010 0<br />
Harding, Capt. Claud, R.N. I.0 0<br />
Hurry, A. ; : : : : 010 6<br />
Keary, C. F. (amount not to be men-<br />
tioned)<br />
<br />
Kinns, The Rev. Samuel, D.D. .<br />
Millais; J.G. : :<br />
Quiller Couch, Miss M.<br />
Sterry, J. Ashby 3 :<br />
Temple, Lieut.-Col. Sir R. C.<br />
Underdown, Miss E.<br />
Lockyer, Sir T. Norman<br />
Beale, Miss Mary<br />
<br />
Bolam, Rey. ©. E.<br />
<br />
Egbert, Henry :<br />
Eccles, Miss O’Connor<br />
Darwin, Francis ; :<br />
Montgomery-Campbell, Miss<br />
Medlicott, Cecil<br />
<br />
Saxby, Miss.<br />
<br />
Caine, T. H. Hall<br />
<br />
Marris, Miss Murrell<br />
<br />
S. B. : :<br />
Bloomfield, J. H. .<br />
<br />
F. O. B. (Coventry) .<br />
Seton-Karr, H. W.<br />
<br />
Heriot, Cheyne :<br />
Charley, Sir W. T., K.C.<br />
<br />
“« Hsme Stuart ” ;<br />
Charlton, Miss Emily<br />
Kroeker, Mrs.<br />
<br />
Aflalo, F. G.<br />
<br />
Patterson, A. . ;<br />
Salwey, Reginald EH.<br />
Gidley, Miss E. C.<br />
<br />
Nixon, Prof. J. E.<br />
<br />
a<br />
<br />
—_<br />
SCH OR COOH OHHH OO ONMWOHRFROHS<br />
<br />
—<br />
NOOR NW OOOH OO O19 OOS BS BY OF OTD OD OL HY OL OF<br />
<br />
—ROCCOePecocooeceacooqoorcoocoo Coco oCcoaoaocoooooo Oo<br />
<br />
SocrFNwocoH<br />
KH<br />
<br />
o><br />
So<br />
<br />
— + os<br />
<br />
FROM THE COMMITTEE.<br />
<br />
oe<br />
<br />
T the Committee Meeting held on Monday,<br />
<br />
November 10th, the Chairman reported<br />
<br />
he had heard from Mr. Frampton, R.A.,<br />
<br />
that the Sir Walter Besant Memorial Tablet was<br />
<br />
almost complete. Mr. A. Hope Hawkins and<br />
<br />
Mr. Austin Dobson were appointed as a Sub-<br />
committee to settle the inscription.<br />
<br />
There were one or two cases discussed; but it<br />
<br />
would be prejudicial to their settlement to report<br />
<br />
upon them.<br />
<br />
<br />
60<br />
<br />
The Secretary has dealt with seven cases only<br />
during the past month, two referring to accounts,<br />
two for the return of MSS., and three for payment<br />
of money. ‘They have all been satisfactorily<br />
settled with the exception of one claim for the<br />
payment of money, which is in the course of<br />
settlement.<br />
<br />
The matters that were open from the former<br />
month have all been settled with the exception of<br />
two small cases, in which the negotiations are<br />
rather complicated. They are, however, proceeding<br />
satisfactorily. It has not been necessary to place<br />
any further disputes in the hands of the Society’s<br />
solicitors for settlement in the courts. Neither<br />
have any of the cases already in their hands been<br />
concluded since the last issue of 7’he Author.<br />
<br />
—1—>+<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
November Elections.<br />
<br />
Bannon, Mrs. : . $87, Alexandra Court,<br />
Queen’s Gate, S.W.<br />
Brown, Alan Roderick Lancing College, Shore-<br />
Haig (&. A.). ham, Sussex.<br />
Cecil, George 16, Panton Street, Hay-<br />
market, S.W.<br />
Tournafulla, Newcastle<br />
West, Co. Limerick.<br />
Holly House, Gateshead-<br />
on-Tyne.<br />
6, Lawn Crescent, Kew<br />
Gardens, 8. W.<br />
Macquoid, Mrs. Kathe- The Edge, Lucien Rd.,<br />
rine 8. Tooting Common.<br />
Shorrock, Mrs. S. Hope 39, Kiangse Rd., Shan-<br />
: ghai, China.<br />
<br />
The Manse, Hambledon,<br />
Henley-on-Thames.<br />
Leez Priory, Hartford<br />
<br />
-End, Chelmsford.<br />
Williams, Dawson 2, Wyndham Place, W.<br />
<br />
Only one member of those elected does not<br />
desire publication of his name and address.<br />
<br />
Since the beginning of the year 173 members<br />
and associates have been elected.<br />
<br />
Lane, T. O’Neill .<br />
Lister, Walter H. .<br />
Mackay, Wallis<br />
<br />
Thomas, Rev. G. P.<br />
<br />
Turner-Turner, J.<br />
<br />
tee<br />
<br />
BOOK AND PLAY TALK.<br />
<br />
—1—>— +<br />
<br />
M* and Mrs, Sidney Webb are engaged on<br />
a long investigation into English Local<br />
Government, with a view to describing its<br />
<br />
structure and function during the whole of the<br />
<br />
nineteenth century. The first part of their work,<br />
extending down to 1835, and dealing with ‘The<br />
<br />
End of the Old Order,” may be expected to appear<br />
<br />
next spring.<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
Mr. Max Pemberton is writing a story of the<br />
last days of Venice for the Graphic, and is spend-<br />
ing the winter at Brighton, and afterwards at<br />
Venice to do it. He is also finishing an Old<br />
English comedy which he wrote last summer 3.<br />
he is now re-casting it.<br />
<br />
Mr. William Toynbee has been engaged on a.<br />
<br />
satire, dealing with certain aspects, political and<br />
social, of the present day. This satire, which is.<br />
in dramatic form, will be published almost imme-<br />
diately by Mr. Glaisher, of Wigmore Street, under<br />
the title of “‘ When the Devil Drives.”<br />
<br />
In addition to the series of papers, ‘ Mankind<br />
in the Making,” now appearing in the Fortnightly<br />
Review, and destined to make a companion volume<br />
<br />
to “ Anticipations,” Mr. H.G. Wells has two other<br />
<br />
books in preparation. One is the story ofa draper’s<br />
assistant who rises in the world. It was com-<br />
<br />
menced in 1898, when “ Love and Mr. Lewisham”<br />
<br />
was finished, and is not likely to be ready for<br />
publication before 1904.<br />
<br />
The other was begun last year ; itis the story of<br />
<br />
the most momentous discovery in the world, and<br />
it will probably be ready for serialization by 1904.<br />
<br />
Mr. William Le Queux is very busy. For nearly<br />
a year he has been at work on a new novel which<br />
is to appear as a serial in England and America<br />
next spring. It will run over here in Chambers’<br />
Journal. Some of the action takes place in<br />
Galloway; and as this popular author is extremely<br />
particular about the accuracy of his local colour, he<br />
<br />
has been visiting Mr. Crockett’s country recently.<br />
<br />
Other scenes are laid at Crowland Abbey and in<br />
London.<br />
<br />
The title of Mr. Leonard Williams’ new work.<br />
<br />
on Spain which will shortly be published by<br />
Messrs. Cassell & Co., Limited, has been changed<br />
<br />
from “Madrid: Her Records and Romances” to-<br />
<br />
“Toledo and Madrid: ‘Their Records and<br />
Romances.” The scope of the text has been<br />
enlarged ; the plates will be fifty instead of the<br />
<br />
thirty that were originally projected ; and the-<br />
<br />
price in consequence has been raised from 10s.<br />
net to 12s. 6d. net.<br />
<br />
His many readers will be sorry to learn that<br />
there is no immediate prospect of any new poetical<br />
work from the pen of Sir Lewis Morris. The<br />
thirteenth edition of his ‘‘ Works” is, however, just<br />
published, and contains his last book, ‘ Harvest-<br />
tide.” It comprises everything he has written<br />
<br />
except the Coronation and Installation Odes of<br />
<br />
this year.<br />
<br />
Miss Nethersole has still the refusal of his.<br />
<br />
«“Gycia,” while his other play, “ The Life and<br />
<br />
Death of the Emperor Leo the Armenian,” is-<br />
<br />
under offer to Sir Henry Irving.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
ie<br />
<br />
a<br />
<br />
peek td pk PD<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. 61<br />
<br />
Professor Victor Spiers, of King’s College,<br />
London, has published this year with Messrs.<br />
Simpkins, Marshall & Co. two books, one for our<br />
children, the other for older students. The ‘“‘Second<br />
French Book” is adapted for the upper forms of<br />
preparatory schools, and for the junior forms of<br />
public schools, z.e., for boys and girls of twelve to<br />
fifteen years of age.<br />
<br />
It follows upon the lines of the “ First French<br />
Book,” embodying the best features of the newer<br />
aud successful methods in vogue on the Continent,<br />
and adapting these to British standpoints and<br />
ideals. It contains charming illustrations, anec-<br />
dotes, puns and songs of eminently French stamp,<br />
glimpses into French history and present French<br />
life, as well as a visit to Paris. The practical utility<br />
of learning how to write a letter in French is recog-<br />
nised, and free composition is practised in its three<br />
forms. Outlines of conversations and proverbs are<br />
given in each of the forty lessons. At the same<br />
time all the essentials of French grammar are given<br />
in French at the end of the book.<br />
<br />
The second book is the ‘‘ Senior French Reciter.”’<br />
Professor Spiers believes in phonetic transcript, and<br />
has transcribed some of the finest pages of the authors<br />
of the Golden Age of French literature. The author,<br />
in his Preface, emphasises the fact that in every piece<br />
learned by heart from an ordinary text-book, the<br />
best pupils get into their heads a few mispronun-<br />
ciations hard to eradicate. With the phonetic<br />
transcript, he asserts from his experience, these<br />
mispronunciations are reduced to a minimum. It<br />
is a sequel to his “Junior French Reciter,” and<br />
the phonetic alphabet adopted is that of the M. P.<br />
(Maitre Phonétique), viz., of the International<br />
Phonetic Association.<br />
<br />
Sir Herbert Maxwell has in the press a History<br />
of British Fresh-Water Fish. It is a volume of<br />
Messrs. Hutchinson’s Woburn Library Series. It<br />
is illustrated from photographs.<br />
<br />
This indefatigable author will issue through<br />
Mr. John Murray a most interesting work, “The<br />
Creevey Papers,” compiled from the MSS. of<br />
Thomas Creevey, M.P. 1802-30—the counterpart,<br />
from the Whig and Radical Opposition, to the<br />
Croker papers ex parte the Tory Government.<br />
<br />
Mr. Creevey was in correspondence with all the<br />
leading men of the Whig and Radical parties;<br />
Was an intimate friend of the Prince Regent ; and<br />
was at Brussels in 1815, where he became intimate<br />
with the Duke of Wellington. His papers, which<br />
have been very carefully preserved, contain original<br />
letters from Sir John Moore, Lord Grey, S. Whit-<br />
breafl, Brougham, Sheridan, Romilly, Tierney, etc.,<br />
and throw a vivid light upon the political, social<br />
and literary events of his day.<br />
<br />
Commander the Hon. Henry N. Shore, R.N.<br />
author of “ Smuggling Days and Smuggling Ways,”<br />
has commenced a series of articles in the Kentish<br />
Express dealing with the South Coast Gang, which<br />
operated between Rye and Walmer. There is, too,<br />
an authentic account of the celebrated Aldincton<br />
Gang. :<br />
<br />
Mr. Charles Gleig’s new short novel, entitled,<br />
‘The Misfit Mantle ” (Treherne & Co.), is a light<br />
farcical story dealing with the curious experiences<br />
of an English peer in a fourth-rate boarding-house<br />
at the seaside, in which he had to hide himself.<br />
<br />
A long novel, which has occupied most of the<br />
author’s spare time (he writes short tales for the<br />
magazines and contributes to the naval and military<br />
weeklies) during the past eighteen months, is just<br />
completed. The hero is a naval officer, a physical<br />
coward. The book may be described as a plea for<br />
greater consideration for physical cowardice, on<br />
the ground that cowardice is, in effect, a disease.<br />
Mr. Gleig shows that it may be combined with<br />
considerable moral courage.<br />
<br />
Mr. Arthur Paterson has just published through<br />
Mr. Heinemann here and Messrs. Appleton in<br />
America an historical novel called “The King’s<br />
Agent.” The main incident of the story round<br />
which the plot is centred is strictly historical, and<br />
is known as “The Flower-pot Conspiracy.” In<br />
William IIT.’s reign Marlborough was accused of<br />
high treason, and thrown into the Tower, and was<br />
in danger of attainder and the block. He is the<br />
hero, the most prominent figure.<br />
<br />
The book is dedicated to Lord Wolseley (our<br />
latest biographer of Marlborough) from whom<br />
Mr. Paterson has received invaluable information<br />
concerning the details of the conspiracy and the<br />
persons engaged in it.<br />
<br />
A little volume called “ Letters from Ireland,”<br />
by “H. B.,” recently published by Seely, Bryers, and<br />
Walker of Dublin, is exciting much interest in the<br />
sister country. In it a patriotic Catholic Irish-<br />
man, returned from America, describes te a friend<br />
his impressions of his native land as seen after<br />
forty years of absence, by a man of education and<br />
experience who has travelled a great deal and can<br />
compare one country with another. ‘The sincerity<br />
of the writer is manifest, as is his profound love<br />
for Ireland, which bids him in some cases risk<br />
unpopularity in the hopes of removing obstacles to<br />
her betterment.<br />
<br />
Though “H. B.” writes with the utmost impar-<br />
tiality, his sympathies are evidently with the new<br />
Gallic movement for the revival of the Irish<br />
language and industries. He advocates a much<br />
needed system of higher education for the priests,<br />
and of industrial education for the people.<br />
62<br />
<br />
Mr. E. B. Kennedy’s “The Black Police in<br />
Queensland,” published by Mr. John Murray, is a<br />
most interesting account of things that happened<br />
while the author was an officer of the Native<br />
Mounted Police in the early days of the colony.<br />
Incidentally the book deals with other matters<br />
which are of enduring interest, not only to those<br />
who know Queensland, but also to all those who<br />
have at heart the interests of the Empire.<br />
<br />
In this regard special attention may be directed<br />
to what is said as to the capability possessed by<br />
black trackers for scouting services. This, how-<br />
ever, is but one point, briefly treated, in a volume<br />
which, although it deals strictly with matters of<br />
fact, is every whit as exciting and good reading as<br />
Mr. Kennedy’s previous book, “ Blacks and Bush-<br />
rangers,” a work of fiction. The book is capitally<br />
illustrated.<br />
<br />
Mr. Harry A. Spurr’s “Life and Writings of<br />
Alexandre Dumas” (J. M. Dent and Co.), is a<br />
readable volume full of anecdotes and quotations<br />
to the point. Mr. Spurr, who writes com amore,<br />
<br />
visited Paris last July and attended the centenary<br />
fétes at Villers-Cotteréts, and Dieppe, making the<br />
acquaintance of the Dumas family and receiving<br />
much valuable assistance from them and other<br />
authorities on the subject.<br />
<br />
In The Shrine of November there is an interesting<br />
<br />
narrative-article by Miss E. Baker. It is called<br />
“The True Story of Lady Anne Neville and<br />
Richard, Duke of Gloucester.” Miss Baker in the<br />
telling of it adheres strictly to contemporary<br />
authorities ; even in the imaginary conversations<br />
between Anne and Richard she keeps to the spirit<br />
of ascertained facts. Her chief point is that<br />
Richard was not that monster, that devil in body<br />
and soul, he has been represented by tradition and<br />
Shakespeare.<br />
<br />
“The House Building, and other Poems” is a<br />
volume of thoughtful verse by Marshall Bruce<br />
Williams, author of “The Strategy of Nature.”<br />
The poem which gives the volume its title is<br />
mainly a dialogue between a poet and a scientist,<br />
in which the poet has the last word. There are<br />
a number of sonnets, also some poems of which<br />
“The Other Side of the Shield—Olympus” is<br />
particularly good. Mr. R. Brimley Johnson is<br />
the publisher.<br />
<br />
“Bookeeping for Laundries,” by Mr. W. H.<br />
Smith (Simpkin Marshall, 2s. 6d. net), sets forth<br />
a safe and easy system of laundry account-keeping,<br />
dispensing with troublesome ledgers. It has been<br />
revised by Mr. H. Furnival Jones, A.S.A.A.,<br />
Incorporated Accountant. It is a capital book,<br />
concise, lucid, and exhaustive.<br />
<br />
Mr. Arthur H. Holmes has just published a new<br />
novel through Mr. Thomas Burleigh, entitled, “The<br />
Voice of the World.”<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
We understand that Mr. H. VY. Esmond’s new<br />
comedy, “ Imprudence,” produced last month at<br />
the Empire Theatre, New York, has scored a decided<br />
success, and has been highly praised by the critics:<br />
into the bargain. Miss Fay Davis and Mr. William<br />
Faversham, who filled the leading réles, were en-<br />
thusiastically received. Though Miss Davis is an<br />
American, she has never before played in New York.<br />
<br />
Mr. Hall Caine’s “ The Eternal City ” was given<br />
at the Victoria Theatre on the same night, and was<br />
well received by a Jarge audience. In response to<br />
repeated calls, Mr. Hall Caine appeared before the<br />
curtain and made a short speech.<br />
<br />
ee ae<br />
<br />
PARIS NOTES.<br />
meee<br />
<br />
ITH the inauguration of Falguiére’s fine<br />
statue of Balzac all kinds of anecdotes<br />
have been told and retold about the<br />
author of the “ Comédie Humaine.”. It scarcely<br />
seems possible to us now, that a man with such<br />
talent should have been compelled to do all in his<br />
power to boom his own books. We are told tha<br />
this was the case with “Peau de Chagrin” and<br />
<br />
one or two others.<br />
<br />
A yery typical story is told of Balzac when<br />
asked by a publisher to write an article on th<br />
Rue Richelieu. The terms which the author fixe<br />
were so high that the publisher was amazed.<br />
<br />
“Tf I am to describe the Rue Richelieu in<br />
way worthy of the street and of myself, I mus<br />
know it thoroughly, and must not upon an<br />
account fail to investigate all that specially charac<br />
terizes it. I shall have to commence by lunchin<br />
at the Café Cardinal, then I must buy a gun and<br />
cravat pin at the two shops next door to eac<br />
other. After that I must go to the tailor’s at th<br />
corner of the Rue St. Mare :<br />
<br />
“Oh, don’t go any farther than that,” inter<br />
rupted the publisher in alarm. “ You would com<br />
to the Indian shop next, and things there are<br />
fabulous price.”<br />
<br />
M. Gaston Deschamps wrote quite a long articl<br />
recently on French literary women, who of lat<br />
years have certainly come very much to the from<br />
‘As a rule they adopt masculine pseudonyms, bu<br />
their secret 1s very soon an open one.<br />
<br />
Marcelle Tinayre’s novel ‘La Maison du Péché<br />
is one of the most remarkable ones of this seaso:<br />
It is a strong, realistic novel, the story of whic.<br />
reminds one vaguely of the “Ordeal of Richa<br />
Feverel.” Augustin de Chanteprie is educated<br />
most carefully, a tutor who is a rigid Catholi<br />
comes from Syria for six or seven years, and th<br />
boy grows up with no idea of a world outside th<br />
narrow circle of his ancestral home. His widowe<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. 63<br />
<br />
mother spends most of her time in religious<br />
devotions and charitable works. When Augustin<br />
reaches the age of manhood he is almost as austere<br />
and fervent in his religious devotions as his<br />
mother. Unfortunately for his peace of mind a<br />
young widow comes to live in the neighbourhood.<br />
She is an artist, and the daughter of an artist, and<br />
from the date of her arrival commences a new<br />
phase in the existence of Augustin de Chanteprie.<br />
As a study in psychology, this book is a valuable<br />
addition to French literature, but it will not be<br />
appreciated by readers who are unacquainted with<br />
the subtle power and authority of the Roman<br />
Catholic Church. It is a book in which all the<br />
characters live, and each one is drawn with scrupu-<br />
lous accuracy.<br />
<br />
Guy Chantepleure’s new book, “Ames Fémi-<br />
nines,” will probably be appreciated by English<br />
readers. It is what the French describe as a<br />
roman honnéte, and is a careful study of some<br />
types of the new French woman.<br />
<br />
‘Petites Epouses,”’ by Myriam Harry, is the<br />
story of a French Government official, who, while<br />
in exile, married a Japanese wife. The authoress<br />
handles the subject with great skill and delicacy,<br />
so that, as a French critic says, the book is<br />
Quelque chose comme un Loti qui serait femme.<br />
<br />
“T/Aimant,” by Jacques Morian, is another<br />
variation on the usual theme of the modern French<br />
novel. The French author is greatly handicapped<br />
in his choice of a subject by the system of educa-<br />
tion of girls in France. He is obliged to com-<br />
mence where the English novelist leaves off for the<br />
simple reason that the Frenchwoman’s romance so<br />
frequently begins when she is married. ‘ L’Ai-<br />
mant”’ is rather an exception to this rule, as the<br />
most interesting character in the story is a girl<br />
who has her romance before her marriage.<br />
<br />
Brada’s new book tells us by its title what to<br />
expect. “Comme les autres ”’—it certainly is as<br />
far as the subject is concerned. Once more the<br />
eternal theme, but treated in a way which makes<br />
the book fascinating from the first page to the last.<br />
<br />
“ Deux Vies,” by Paul and Victor Margueritte,<br />
is a novel written to show up the injustice of<br />
certain laws. The Margueritte brothers have a<br />
mission, they have recently submitted to the<br />
Chamber a project for the facilitation of divorce,<br />
and this book of theirs is an eloquent appeal in<br />
favour of their project.<br />
<br />
The heroine of the novel has made a most un- ,<br />
<br />
fortunate marriage, and after years of misery she<br />
jeaves her home, and with her little girl takes<br />
refuge with her mother, determined to apply for a<br />
divorce. The mother, who is a staunch Catholic,<br />
opposes her daughter’s idea. She, too, had suffered<br />
a martyrdom, but as her religion does not counte-<br />
nance divorce, she endeavours to persuade her<br />
<br />
daughter that the only happiness left for her is in<br />
resignation to her lot. Francine is not of this<br />
way of thinking, and she at once takes steps to<br />
obtain her divorce. Then follows an account of<br />
all the obstacles she encounters, of all the diffi-<br />
culties and the misery she endures until the day<br />
when the court refuses to grant her divorce, and<br />
she is compelled to return to her husband’s house.<br />
The dénouement is dramatic, for when she is<br />
crushed, humiliated, and desperate, Francine is<br />
persuaded to set aside the laws of Church and<br />
society, and, taking her child with her, to seek for<br />
happiness in another country.<br />
<br />
“* L’ Associée,” by Lucien Muhlfeld, is a book likely<br />
to please English readers. The “Associ¢e” is a<br />
woman whose one idea in life is to be her hus-<br />
band’s right hand. She helps him in every way<br />
possible, but so quietly, so discreetly, that he<br />
never realises how much he owes to her. He is a<br />
doctor, and he becomes a celebrity ; but the whole<br />
interest of the book centres in the struggles and<br />
disappointment of the wife and the perfect egotism<br />
of the man.<br />
<br />
For M. Bataille’s drama, taken from Tolstoi’s<br />
“ Resurrection,” the documents necessary for the<br />
scenery have been sent by Tolstoi’s friends and by<br />
the French consul in Moscow.<br />
<br />
Among other things in this drama are some<br />
Russian popular songs, Siberian chorals, and a<br />
song by Tchaikovsky. The play is an immense<br />
success, and arrangements have been made for its<br />
translation into several languages.<br />
<br />
M. Guitry’s venture with the Renaissance Theatre<br />
appears to be a success. He was fortunate in open-<br />
ing with “La Chatelaine,” by M. Capus, and in<br />
securing Jane Hading for the chief role.<br />
<br />
M. Deval is one of the happy actor-managers<br />
gifted with the “flair” in selecting his plays. “ Le<br />
Cadre,” by Pierre Wolff, was very well received, and<br />
the chief 7éles are admirably suited to M. Deval<br />
and Madame Valdey.<br />
<br />
M. Larroumet’s advice to dramatic authors when<br />
criticizing this and other plays was, that they<br />
should cease writing for stars, and not trouble in<br />
the least, when writing the piece, about the distri-<br />
bution of the ré/es. :<br />
<br />
M. Bour is persevering in his attempt to establish<br />
the International Theatre here. The plays are all<br />
given in French. Italian, Portuguese, and German<br />
pieces already figure in his repertoire.<br />
<br />
Sarah Bernhardt had a hearty welcome on her<br />
return to Paris after her tour abroad.<br />
<br />
A series of delightful afternoon lectures and<br />
readings have been given during the last month,<br />
with Mounet Sully to interpret the various authors.<br />
<br />
These lectures are very much in vogue in Paris,<br />
and one-act plays. are frequently given by way of<br />
variation. At alecture of this kind the other day<br />
<br />
<br />
64<br />
<br />
“Qharles V. et du Guesclin” was put on, and<br />
afterwards ‘ Bourrasque,” by M. Foley, the author<br />
of “ Heard at the Telephone.”<br />
<br />
Auys HALLARD,<br />
<br />
—_—_———+——_+_—_—_——_-<br />
<br />
THE INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS OF<br />
PUBLISHERS.<br />
<br />
——1—~<— + ——<br />
Report from the Permanent Officer at Berne.<br />
<br />
[Printed by kind permission from The Publishers’ Circular. ]<br />
<br />
PYVHE meeting of the Executive Committee of<br />
[ the International Congress of Publishers<br />
<br />
was held at Berne on October 9th and 10th.<br />
The President, M. A. Brockhaus, and Messrs. R.<br />
Fouret, E. Bruylant, and H. Morel were present.<br />
Messrs. F. Brunetiére and J. Murray, regretting<br />
their inability to be present, sent letters of<br />
apology.<br />
<br />
After presentation of the first Annual Report of<br />
the Bureau, and examination of the Statement of<br />
Accounts, which was found correct, the Committee<br />
decided to add the balance in hand to the guarantee<br />
fund organised by Mr. Fairholme, in London. The<br />
Statement of Accounts for the year begins July 1st,<br />
ending June 30th.<br />
<br />
The National Associations contributing to the<br />
expenses of the Permanent Office belong to the<br />
following countries: Austria, Belgium, Denmark,<br />
England, France, Germany, Holland, Hungary,<br />
Italy, Norway, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, the<br />
United States of North America.<br />
<br />
After settling different questions relating to the<br />
administration of the Bureau, the Committee have<br />
taken into consideration the resolutions passed at<br />
the four sessions of the Congress.<br />
<br />
The carrying out of the resolutions concerning<br />
the authors’ rights has been approved of. These<br />
resolutions relate to: (1) the adhesion of Austria,<br />
Hungary, Russia, and the Netherlands to the<br />
Berne Convention ; (2) the improvement of the<br />
international protection in the United States ;<br />
(3) the communication to the different Govern-<br />
ments of the resolutions passed by the Congress at<br />
its several sessions, in view of the improvement of<br />
the national and international protection of the<br />
authors’ and publishers’ rights.<br />
<br />
The Committee have also approved the proceed-<br />
ings of the Bureau with reference to the preparation<br />
and execution of other resolutions (duty on books,<br />
postal service, maintenance of the published price,<br />
new forms, music trade, relations to the press,<br />
metric system, overs in printing, substitution of<br />
parcels, solid packing, on the use of the word<br />
“edition ”’).<br />
<br />
Other resolutions passed at the different sessions<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
have also been discussed by the Committee (national<br />
bibliographies, catalogues of books, professional<br />
schools and classes, interchange of documents be-<br />
tween the different publishers’ associations, tech-<br />
nical libraries, interchange and loan of catalogues,<br />
etc.).<br />
<br />
The Committee, having approved the Statement<br />
of Accounts and Report, have proposed a vote of<br />
thanks to the Permanent (Office, which was carried.<br />
<br />
The Committee have considered the fifth session<br />
of the Congress, which is to take place at Milan.<br />
Mr. Toto Ricordi, President of the ‘‘ Associazione<br />
Tipograficolibraria Italiana,” has been good enough<br />
to be present at the session of October 10th, in order<br />
to converse on the subject with the Executive Com-<br />
mittee. It has been decided that the Committee<br />
would meet at the end of May or beginning of<br />
June, 1903, in order to organise the fifth session.<br />
<br />
Oe<br />
<br />
COPYRIGHT IN PHOTOGRAPHS.<br />
<br />
——<br />
<br />
N the November number of The Author an article<br />
| appeared dealing with the question of photo-<br />
graphic copyright.<br />
<br />
This question is of great and growing impor-<br />
tance to all those members of the Society who<br />
contribute illustrated articles to illustrated maga-<br />
zines. In consequence several remarks have come<br />
to hand from different members. It is evident<br />
that many difficult and complicated issues may<br />
arise. One member has set out his difficulties<br />
in the following series of questions. As it is<br />
possible that others may have similar doubts, we<br />
will endeavour to answer them for the benefit<br />
of all. :<br />
<br />
1. The word “copyright” is stamped across or<br />
printed upon some photographs. Is the absence of<br />
such indication to be regarded as evidence that the<br />
photograph has not been registered ?<br />
<br />
2. Isthere any means of determining whether the<br />
copyright in a photograph has expired, and has<br />
the assignment of the copyright to be registered ?<br />
<br />
3. Can we take it that all photographs taken<br />
before a certain date are public property. If so,<br />
what is the date ?<br />
<br />
4. A man sits to a photographer, at the photo-<br />
grapher’s request, for a “series of celebrities,”<br />
and is presented with a certain number of copies.<br />
The word “copyright” does not appear in the<br />
correspondence. ‘The portrait is used without the<br />
sitter’s consent in a newspaper. Has the photo-<br />
grapher aright to make a charge. Supposing the<br />
photograph to be used without previous application<br />
to the photographer, can he claim damages, or can<br />
he merely send in a bill for half a guinea? Can<br />
the photographer in such a case authorise the<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. 65<br />
<br />
reproduction of a portrait in a paper in which, for<br />
whatever reasons, the sitter does not wish to<br />
appear ?<br />
<br />
5. Supposing a firm, instead of an individual, to<br />
acquire copyright by taking a photograph, can the<br />
copyright expire while the firm continues to exist ?<br />
<br />
6. It would also be useful to state in the<br />
article :—<br />
<br />
(a) What are the countries unprotected in<br />
England, because they stand outside the Berne<br />
Convention.<br />
<br />
(b) At what date did the different countries<br />
acquire protection by adhering to the Berne<br />
Convention.<br />
<br />
(¢) Have foreign photographs to be registered<br />
to acquire copyright? Is there any means of<br />
ascertaining in England whether any given foreign<br />
photograph has been registered or not, and whether<br />
the copyright in any given photograph has expired<br />
or not ?<br />
<br />
(d) Supposing that I buy a foreign photograph<br />
at Spooner’s and use it without referring to the<br />
photographer, what is liable to happen? Does it<br />
make any difference to one’s legal position if one<br />
acknowledges the source of a photograph? This is<br />
important as photographs are generally wanted in<br />
a hurry, and Spooner always says that he has no<br />
authority to treat. Is there no international Union<br />
of Photographers which has anticipated these<br />
difficulties and provided for them by undertaking<br />
always to accede to certain terms ?<br />
<br />
It is evident that these points are of considerable<br />
importance.<br />
<br />
The answers to them, as far as it is possible to<br />
answer them at the present time without further<br />
investigation, will be as follows :—<br />
<br />
(1) According to English law, it is not essential<br />
to stamp or print the word “copyright” on a<br />
photograph in order to obtain statutory protection.<br />
The absence of such note, therefore, cannot be<br />
taken as evidence either way.<br />
<br />
.(2) It is exceedingly difficult to determine<br />
whether the copyright in a photograph has expired<br />
or not. Registration at Stationers’ Hall demands<br />
merely, in the first instance, the name and place of<br />
abode of the author, (2) the name and place of<br />
abode of the proprietor, (3) their description, with<br />
nature and subject of the work, and if desired<br />
(4) sketch outline or photograph of the work.<br />
<br />
As the former article fully explained, the copy-<br />
right lasts from the date of the making of the<br />
work by the author, for the life of the author and<br />
seven years afterwards. If the photograph is not<br />
registered the writer, who is desirous to illustrate<br />
<br />
his article, need have no hesitation in using it, so<br />
far as the law is concerned. No damages can be<br />
obtained for any infringement that occurs prior to<br />
registration. If, however, the work is registered,<br />
<br />
then the would-be reproducer must find out whether<br />
the gentleman described as author is still alive ;<br />
and here lies the difficulty.<br />
<br />
S The latter part of the question is more complex.<br />
That an assignee must register before commencing<br />
action is Clear, bat whether such registration will<br />
cover cases of infringement before registration of<br />
the assignment is doubtful. The safest course in<br />
any event is to register the assignment at once.<br />
<br />
(3) The Act of 25 & 26 Vict. Ch. 68 came into<br />
force on 29th July, 1862. Any photograph made<br />
before that date, it would seem, carried with it no<br />
copyright. The copyright in photographs made<br />
since that date must depend upon the life of the<br />
author.<br />
<br />
(4) The sanction of the man, who sits at the<br />
request of the photographer, is not essential to the<br />
right of reproduction. The photographer (the<br />
author of the likeness) has a right to make a<br />
charge, and has a right to claim damage for<br />
infringement, supposing that the work is repro-<br />
duced without his sanction. If he commenced<br />
action it would be for damages for infringement<br />
of copyright. If he had already sent in a bill he<br />
would most probably be bound by the amount<br />
stated in that bill, as the limit of damages he could<br />
claim. If however the amount was exorbitant it<br />
would lie with the Judge or Jury to assess the<br />
amount. The sitter would not be entitled to stop<br />
the republication of his likeness unless the circum-<br />
stances were exceptional. The readers of Zhe Author<br />
are referred to an amusing story in the May number,<br />
in which the dangers of the sitter’s position are fully<br />
set forth. It will be as well to impress upon those<br />
desirous of having their photographs printed in<br />
public papers, that they should in all cases retain<br />
the copyright in the photograph, or limit the photo-<br />
grapher to reproduction in papers authorised by<br />
themselves.<br />
<br />
The answer to question (5) is clear from the state-<br />
ment of the former article which has already been<br />
referred to. It is impossible for a firm to be the<br />
original makers of the photograph, in the sense<br />
conceived in the Act, and the date of the copyright<br />
would run from the life of the maker of the photo-<br />
graph. ‘The principal countries unprotected in<br />
England because they stand outside the Berne<br />
Convention are Sweden, Holland, Russia, the<br />
United States of America, Austria-Hungary,<br />
Turkey, Egypt, 8. American Republics, China.<br />
With the United States England has a Oopy-<br />
right Arrangement, and with Austria-Hungary a<br />
Copyright Treaty, very much on the lines of the<br />
Berne Convention.<br />
<br />
The names of the principal countries belonging<br />
to the Convention, and the dates of their joining<br />
are as follows :— ae<br />
<br />
Germany, Belgium, Spain, France, Italy, Switzer-<br />
66<br />
<br />
land and Tunis. These signed the original Con-<br />
vention of 1886, and the additional Act of Paris,<br />
1896.<br />
<br />
Norway joined on the 15th of April, 1896,<br />
signing the Convention of 1886, and Japan joined<br />
in July, 1899, signing both the Convention of 1886<br />
and the subsequent Convention of 1896.<br />
<br />
The answer to the two subsequent paragraphs<br />
(c and d) requires deep study and a profound know-<br />
ledge not only of International law, but of the laws<br />
of each country. It would appear in most coun-<br />
tries that registration is necessary, and it may also<br />
be stated that in most countries, copyright in<br />
photographs is of very limited duration, and does<br />
not last anything like the length of time that<br />
it lasts in England and France. Mere acknowledg-<br />
ment of the reproduction of a photograph would<br />
make no difference to the legal position. It might<br />
however be evidence of the fact that there was no<br />
wilful intent to defraud.<br />
<br />
—_—____+——+ —___——__<br />
<br />
LITERARY, DRAMATIC, AND MUSICAL<br />
PROPERTY.<br />
<br />
— to<br />
<br />
Royalty Agreement: A Warning.<br />
<br />
OT so long ago a publisher, in submitting his<br />
<br />
agreement to authors, stated that it had been<br />
<br />
approved by the Society, and thereby, no doubt,<br />
induced writers to sign a document which, under<br />
other circumstances, they might have hesitated to<br />
do. The Secretary of the Society remonstrated<br />
when this fact came to his notice. The publisher<br />
replied, that the transaction referred to had never<br />
taken place. Unfortunately, he had so far forgotten<br />
himself on one occasion as to commit himself in<br />
writing on this point, and the letter was in the<br />
Secretary’s hands. Accordingly, he was bound to<br />
apologise, and promised that it would not occur<br />
again.<br />
<br />
There is another method of inducing an author<br />
to sign, which is very commonly adopted in another<br />
publishing house. ‘The man of business affirms that<br />
the agreement submitted to the author, is similar<br />
in every respect to that signed by his other authors.<br />
Tf this statement was correct, there would be nothing<br />
to say on the subject, except that the other authors<br />
must have been extraordinarily lax in their methods<br />
of disposing of their property ; but unfortunately,<br />
the Secretary of the Society happens to know full<br />
well, that although no doubt the agreement, as<br />
drafted, is offered for signature to other authors,<br />
on occasions too numerous to specify, the authors<br />
have refused to sign without considerable alteration.<br />
<br />
The agreement is, in substance, with a few minor<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
alterations, the royalty agreement drafted on behalf<br />
of the Publishers’ Association, about which so<br />
much has been written from time to time in Zhe<br />
Author.<br />
<br />
Owing to the frequent recurrence of the circum-<br />
stances stated above it would, perhaps, be no dis-<br />
advantage to quote the form of agreement with<br />
some comments, in order to put authors on their<br />
guard. Some of the objections are vital, others<br />
are of minor importance, but should be insisted<br />
upon if the position of the author is strong enough<br />
to carry them.<br />
<br />
MEMoRANDUM OF AGREEMENT made this<br />
day of between<br />
<br />
(hereinafter termed the author) of the one part,<br />
and<br />
<br />
(hereinafter termed the publisher) of the other<br />
part, whereby it is mutually agreed between the<br />
parties hereto for themselves and their respective<br />
executors, administrators, and assigns (or succes-<br />
sors, as the case may be), as follows :—<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
1. The publisher shall at his own risk and<br />
expense, and with due diligence, produce and<br />
publish the work at present intituled<br />
<br />
by<br />
and use his best endeavours to sell the same.<br />
<br />
2. The author guarantees to the publisher that<br />
the said work is in no way whatever a violation<br />
of any existing copyright, and that it contains<br />
nothing of a libellous or scandalous character, and<br />
that he will indemnify the publisher from all suits,<br />
claims and proceedings, damages, and costs which<br />
may be made, taken, or incurred by or against him<br />
on the ground that the work is an infringement<br />
of copyright, or contains anything libellous or<br />
scandalous.<br />
<br />
3. The Publisher shall during the legal term<br />
of copyright have the exclusive right of producing<br />
and publishing the work in England, the Colonies,<br />
and United States of America. The Publisher<br />
shall have the entire control of the publication<br />
and sale and terms of sale of the book, and the<br />
Author shall not during the continuance of this<br />
agreement (without the consent of the Publisher)<br />
publish any abridgment, translation, or dramatised<br />
version of the work.<br />
<br />
4. The Publisher agrees to pay the Author the<br />
following royalties, that is to say :—<br />
<br />
(a) The first copies shall be free of royalty,<br />
<br />
<br />
hae Nese<br />
<br />
pant<br />
phi hee<br />
<br />
1%)<br />
2<br />
<br />
Ca<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
ie<br />
if<br />
as<br />
i<br />
<br />
(Ook ee<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. 67<br />
<br />
aroyalty of ten per cent. uponthe next — thousand<br />
copies sold, and fifteen per cent. upon the next<br />
thousand copies, and twenty per cent. upon all sub-<br />
sequent copies, thirteen being reckoned as twelve<br />
throughout.<br />
<br />
(0) Upon the American edition the first<br />
copies shall be free of royalty, ten per cent. upon<br />
the next thousand copies sold, fifteen per cent.<br />
upon the next thousand copies, and all sub-<br />
sequent copies sold.<br />
<br />
(c) In the event of the Publisher disposing of<br />
<br />
copies or editions at a reduced rate for sale in the<br />
Colonies or elsewhere, or as remainders, a royalty<br />
of ten per cent. of the amount received by such<br />
sale.<br />
<br />
(d) In the event of the Publisher realising profits<br />
from the sale, with the consent of the author, of<br />
serial or Continental rights, or from claims for<br />
infringement of copyright, a royalty of fifty per<br />
cent. of the net amount of such profits remaining<br />
after deducting all expenses relating thereto.<br />
<br />
(e) No royalties shall be paid on any copies<br />
given away for review or other purposes.<br />
<br />
(f) The Author shall be entitled to six gratuitous<br />
copies, and any further copies required at trade<br />
price.<br />
<br />
5. The Author agrees to revise the first, and,<br />
if necessary, to edit and revise every subsequent<br />
edition of the work, and from time to time to<br />
supply any new matter that may be needful to<br />
keep the work up to date.<br />
<br />
6. The Author agrees that all costs of corrections<br />
and alterations in the proof sheets exceeding twenty<br />
per cent. of the cost of composition, shall be deducted<br />
from the royalties payable to him.<br />
<br />
7. In the event of the Author neglecting to<br />
revise an edition after due notice shall have been<br />
given to him, or in the event of the Author being<br />
unable to do so by reason of death or otherwise,<br />
the expense of revising and preparing each such<br />
future edition for press shall be borne by the<br />
Author, and shall be deducted from the royalties<br />
payable to him.<br />
<br />
8. During the continuance of this agreement,<br />
the copyright of the work shall be vested in the<br />
Author, who may be registered as the proprietor<br />
thereof accordingly.<br />
<br />
9. The Publisher shall make up the account<br />
annually to<br />
and deliver the same to the Author within<br />
months thereafter, and pay the balance due to the<br />
Author on same date.<br />
<br />
10. If the Publisher shall at the end of three<br />
years from the date of publication, or at any time<br />
thereafter, give notice to the Author that in his<br />
opinion the demand for the work has ceased, or if<br />
the Publisher shall for six months after the work<br />
is out of print decline or, after due notice, neglect<br />
<br />
to publish a new edition, then and in either of<br />
such cases this Agreement shall terminate, and, on<br />
the determination of this Agreement in the above<br />
or any other manner, the right to print and pub--<br />
lish the work shall revert to the Author, and the<br />
Author, if not then registered, shall be entitled to<br />
be registered as the proprietor thereof, and to pur-<br />
chase from the Publisher forthwith the plates or<br />
moulds and engravings (if any) produced specially<br />
for the work, at half cost of production, and what-<br />
ever copies the Publisher may have on hand at<br />
cost of production, and if the Author does not<br />
within three months purchase and pay for the said<br />
plates or moulds, engravings, and copies, the Pub-<br />
lisher may at any time thereafter dispose of such<br />
plates or moulds, engravings, and copies, or melt<br />
the plates, paying to the Author in lieu of royal-<br />
ties ten per cent. of the net proceeds of such sale,<br />
unless the Publisher can prove from his books that<br />
the publication has resulted in loss to him, in<br />
which case he shall be liable for no such payment.<br />
11. If any difference shall arise between the<br />
Author and the Publisher touching the meaning<br />
of this Agreement, or the rights or liabilities of<br />
the parties thereunder, the same shall be referred<br />
to the arbitration of two persons (one to be named<br />
<br />
_by each party) or their umpire, in accordance with<br />
<br />
the provisions of the Arbitration Act, 1889.<br />
<br />
12. The term “ Publisher” throughout this<br />
Agreement shall be deemed to include the person<br />
or persons or company for the time being carrying<br />
on the business of the said<br />
under as well its present as any future style, and<br />
the benefit of this Agreement shall be transmissible<br />
accordingly.<br />
<br />
As witness the hands of the parties.<br />
<br />
COMMENTS ON THE AGREEMENT.<br />
<br />
Firstly, then, the parties to the agreement. “It<br />
is agreed for themselves, their respective adminis-<br />
trators, executors, and assigns, or successors, as<br />
the case may be.”<br />
<br />
It is the greatest mistake for an author to con-<br />
tract with the executors, administrators, and<br />
assigns or successors of a publisher. The contract<br />
is between principal and agent, and is a personal<br />
contract, and should be maintained as a personal<br />
contract. Supposing an author were dealing with<br />
one of the best publishing houses in England, and<br />
the partners of that publishing house, for some<br />
reason or other, desired to retire from the busi-<br />
ness ; to clear up matters they might put up the<br />
contracts for sale by auction or otherwise. Under<br />
those circumstances an author might find the right<br />
to publish his work purchased by some enterpris-<br />
ing tradesman, who would bring it out in a manner<br />
and form which would be utterly repulsive to the<br />
author, and he would have no means of stopping<br />
<br />
<br />
68<br />
<br />
him ; and the same thing might occur should a<br />
firm go bankrupt. Tt is, therefore, a most dan-<br />
gerous thing to allow the agent who is dealing<br />
with the property to have a right to assign his<br />
agency.<br />
<br />
In Clause 1 the publisher undertakes to produce<br />
the work with due diligence. These words, as far<br />
as they go, are satisfactory, but the clause is not<br />
nearly comprehensive enough. The following points<br />
are suggested for consideration : that a date ought<br />
to be fixed on or before which the book should be<br />
produced ; that the form in which the edition is to<br />
appear should also be stated, and the price at which<br />
it is to be sold to the public; and further, it is best<br />
to limit the publisher to the production of a certain<br />
number of copies or editions, with the option of<br />
renewal, or to assign the right to publish, subject<br />
to proper safeguards, for a limited number of years.<br />
Several authors adopt this course.<br />
<br />
Clause 2 may, on the whole, be passed, with the<br />
single exception of the words “incurred by.” It<br />
is fair as between the parties that the publisher<br />
should be protected from all suits against him, but<br />
there is no reason why the author should indemnify<br />
him from all expenses incurred by him, as he might<br />
incur unnecessary expenses without the sanction of<br />
the author. There ought, therefore, to be some<br />
words of limitation by which the author has a<br />
voice in any action taken by the publisher. This<br />
Clause is a distinct improvement on the Clause<br />
put forward by Mr. Absolute, and quoted in the<br />
October number.<br />
<br />
Clause 3.—It is difficult to deal with Clause 3<br />
without, in fact, re-drafting the whole of the<br />
agreement, but it should be pointed ont that the<br />
rights which the author is expected to transfer by<br />
this agreement include the rights of production in<br />
the United States. Such rights are generally left<br />
in the hands of an agent, and much better so than<br />
in the hands of publishers, for this reason—that a<br />
publisher does not, as a general rule, undertake the<br />
work of the literary agent ; that his office is not<br />
to place literary work in other hands, but to<br />
produce literary work for the author ; that work<br />
of this kind left in the hands of publishers is not<br />
likely to receive anything like the same attention<br />
as it isif left in the hands of a literary agent ; that<br />
the publisher is the only person who gains by<br />
having control of this work, and that the author<br />
loses by leaving it in his hands. It should be<br />
further pointed out that the publisher does not<br />
anywhere in the agreement undertake to secure<br />
the United States copyright for the author, nor<br />
even to do his best to obtain it. It may pay an<br />
English publisher better to sell sheets or stereos<br />
and pay the author a royalty, as per Clause 4, but<br />
the result is hardly satisfactory to the author.<br />
<br />
It should be added that for this agency work,<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
while the literary agent charges 10 per cent., the<br />
publishers actually make 50 per cent. (see sect. (d)<br />
of clause. 4). Out of a large series of agreements<br />
from all sorts and conditions of publishers the<br />
lowest charge for this literary agency business has<br />
been 25 per cent., and this only in one case.<br />
<br />
The last part of the clause is extraordinary. It<br />
seems astounding that the author should not be<br />
allowed to deal with the translation.and dramati-<br />
sation of his own work without the consent of the<br />
publisher. An author must be of a curious Jrame of<br />
mind to part with his dramatic rights, perhaps more<br />
important than all the rest put together. With<br />
regard to the question of abridgment even, it is<br />
not fair that the author should be bound not to<br />
abridge the work unless the publisher is recipro-<br />
cally bound not to obtain an abridgment or to run<br />
any other work which is likely to conflict with the<br />
author’s. So far, this clause has been considered<br />
from the general point of view, but from the point<br />
of view of the writer of technical works, educa-<br />
tional, medical, theological, &c., &c., the clause is<br />
still more disastrous.<br />
<br />
Under no circumstances should a writer of<br />
technical books hand over to his publisher so large<br />
a right of publication. It should be limited<br />
especially as to the number of the edition, giving,<br />
if the author thinks fit, an equitable right to<br />
produce further editions.<br />
<br />
A technical writer must keep the command of<br />
his work, must be able if necessary, to alter,<br />
amend, amplify. He cannot do this with a free<br />
hand if he does not keep undivided control,<br />
<br />
The publishers’ answer will be: ‘“ But this is<br />
provided for by Clauses 5 and 7.”<br />
<br />
But it is submitted that it is one thing for the<br />
author to have unfettered judgment, and another<br />
thing to be forced to revise at request of his<br />
publisher or see his work arbitrarily revised by<br />
another. Whilst considering this question, it<br />
should be mentioned that one of the peculiarities<br />
of publishers’ contracts is, that in the case of<br />
technical works a clause is nearly always intro-<br />
duced conveying the copyright to the publisher.<br />
<br />
An agreement containing such a clause should<br />
never be signed by an author.<br />
<br />
Clause 4.—In Section (a) the royalty is to be<br />
paid thirteen copies as twelve. Royalties should<br />
never be calculated on this basis. All the royalty<br />
accounts put forward by the Authors’ Society have<br />
been (wrongly) reckoned on the basis that the<br />
royalty is paid on every copy sold, as it had been<br />
previously taken into account in the Cost of Pro-<br />
duction that the publisher had to sell thirteen for<br />
twelve to the booksellers. This they do not really<br />
do, except they sell in quantities, and a great many<br />
booksellers are unable to afford to buy in quan<br />
tities ; therefore, in taking the royalty to be paid<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. 69.<br />
<br />
as in Section (a), the publisher is not only<br />
profiting by the liberal estimates of the Society<br />
with regard to royalties, but is also endeavouring<br />
to take in an extra 8 per cent., and the extra<br />
amount on those copies, of which there are many,<br />
sold in less numbers than twelve. The reader is<br />
referred to the October Awthor, where there is an<br />
article entitled ‘‘ Thirteen as Twelve.”<br />
<br />
The clause is also drafted that a certain number<br />
of copies should be free of royalty. This seems to<br />
imply that no book can afford to have a royalty<br />
paid on it from the beginning. Of course this is<br />
not the case, but when such an arrangement is<br />
placed before an author as an equitable agreement,<br />
these points of equity should be clearly explained.<br />
<br />
If the royalty is to be paid after the sale of a<br />
certain number (in this case such a number whose<br />
sale will amply cover the cost of production), then<br />
the author must take care (1) that a number<br />
beyond the number specified is printed ; (2) that<br />
he gets a proportionately higher royalty for fore-<br />
going it so long—e.g., he must then get 50 per<br />
cent. of the trade price, or over 25 per cent. of the<br />
published price.<br />
<br />
If a royalty agreement cannot bear a high<br />
<br />
royalty from the beginning, then a royalty<br />
<br />
increasing with the sale is certainly a fair<br />
arrangement as between author and publisher.<br />
<br />
The same remarks about the royalty refer to<br />
Section (2) and the American sales. It should be<br />
clearly understood whether or not the publisher<br />
intends to obtain United States copyright. He<br />
ought not to be allowed to have the option, as it is<br />
frequently the fact that it pays a publisher better<br />
to sell sheets or plates to the United States than<br />
to go to the trouble to negotiate for the copyright.<br />
If the publisher secures the copyright, it must be<br />
fully understood that it is secured in the name of<br />
the author.<br />
<br />
Section (c).—It is a common thing for a pub-<br />
lisher to pay a royalty on the net amount received<br />
from the sale of a remainder, but under no circum-<br />
stances should the author allow such a loose clause<br />
as the one put forward. If the publisher sells at a<br />
reduced rate to the Colonies, 10 per cent. is an<br />
exceedingly small amount to pay to the author.<br />
On the ordinary 6s. book sold to the Colonies in<br />
sheets, the author will get between 2d. and 4d. a<br />
copy; 10 per cent. is only a fraction over a penny.<br />
The words “ at a reduced rate” and “ or elsewhere ”<br />
are fatal. Who is to decide what is a reduced<br />
rate? There are many methods of selling books<br />
to the trade. Thus, one and all may be called<br />
“books at a reduced rate.’ Would it be fair,<br />
therefore, to pay the author merely a share of the<br />
amount realised? The royalty should always be<br />
paid on the published price, except in the case of<br />
remainders. The section, therefore, should be<br />
<br />
drafted so that a fixed price is paid on the sales to<br />
the Colonies, and a royalty on the net amount<br />
realised from Joné fide remainder sales. The rest<br />
should be deleted. The case of remainder sales<br />
should be distinguished with great care from the<br />
sale of books at a reduced price. The clause, as<br />
worded, cannot but tend to confuse the two issues.<br />
<br />
Section (d) is amusing. It is best to take these<br />
rights out of the hands of the publisher, and place<br />
them in the hands of the agent, if for no other<br />
reason than the fact that the agent would charge<br />
10 per cent. where the publisher charges, as in this<br />
case, 50 per cent. It is absurd to think that the<br />
publisher, as stated above, should assert that all<br />
his authors signed this agency clause. Anyone<br />
acquainted with the marketing of literary property<br />
would confidently deny such a statement, or come<br />
to the conclusion that the publisher had nothing<br />
but veritable tyros to deal with. This is not the<br />
case with the publisher whose agreement is printed<br />
above. If the author is willing to allow the pub-<br />
lisher to have the marketing of these rights, he<br />
should pay him the usual 10 per cent. commission,<br />
and he might also be entitled to 10 per cent. com-<br />
mission if he was mainly instrumental in recover-<br />
ing money for infringement of copyright.<br />
<br />
Section (f) of Clause 4 is a little vague. Of<br />
course, no royalty ought to be paid to the author<br />
on copies given away or sent for review, but the<br />
words “other purposes’? might cover a good deal<br />
more than this, and are insufficiently precise.<br />
<br />
Clause 5.—The wording of the fifth clause is not<br />
very satisfactory. In the case of technical works,<br />
to which a clause like this specially refers, the<br />
publishers should in the first instance be only<br />
given a right to publish a limited number of<br />
copies, and the author might give him the<br />
option of producing further editions, subject to<br />
certain limitations. Under those circumstances<br />
the right to revise would lie within the author’s<br />
hands, as it should do with the creator of any<br />
work, who alone ought to have power to add or<br />
subtract from what he has already put before the<br />
world. This has all been explained when com-<br />
menting on Clause 8, but the principle is of such<br />
importance that it is worth while to repeat it. In<br />
the case of the publication of ordinary works of<br />
fiction or travel, etc., this clause should be deleted.<br />
It does not apply, and it is bad draftsmanship to<br />
retain it.<br />
<br />
Clause 6.—The author is not safeguarded here.<br />
Could it not be provided that periodically (say |<br />
weekly) during the printing the author be in-<br />
formed of the cost of corrections? He must in<br />
any case be informed what is the cost of composi-<br />
tion, and what is the connection between corrections<br />
and shillings.<br />
<br />
Clause 7 might, under certain circumstances—<br />
<br />
<br />
70<br />
<br />
that is if the publisher has purchased the copy-<br />
right—be inserted in an agreement, but in the<br />
present form of royalty agreement it should be<br />
struck out. There is no need for it. Its imprac-<br />
ticability with regard to technical writers during<br />
their lifetime, and its inapplicability to ordinary<br />
fiction at any time has been mentioned. It should<br />
be either altered or deleted.<br />
<br />
Clause 8.—There is no need either for the inser-<br />
tion of Clause 8. The copyright is the author’s,<br />
and must remain so. The clause is inserted evi-<br />
dently with the idea of the copyright being vested<br />
in the name of the publisher. This would be a<br />
mistake.<br />
<br />
Clause 9, the account clause, is so beautifully<br />
vague that it is hardly worth while to comment<br />
upon it, except to point out that it is a mistake to<br />
have accounts made up annually, and delivered<br />
and paid three months after they are made up, as<br />
it makes it possible for the publisher to retain the<br />
author’s money for nearly fifteen months. This is<br />
a common account clause among publishers, and<br />
no doubt they find it exceedingly useful to have<br />
the control of the author’s money for so long a<br />
period. But the inconvenience to the author, not<br />
to mention the danger of bankruptcy or similar<br />
contingencies to the firm, is very considerable.<br />
<br />
Clause 10.—The first part of Clause 10 is cer-<br />
tainly necessary for the protection of the author,<br />
as it would be very awkward supposing the pub-<br />
lisher refused to produce the book when the author<br />
had a certain market for it. If, however, as in<br />
the case of some educational works, the publisher<br />
desired still to maintain the control of the market,<br />
so as not to allow the author to republish a book<br />
in competition with one which the publisher had<br />
already before the public, it would be easy to evade<br />
the clause by having afew copies ready on hand.<br />
The latter part of the clause, however, could not<br />
possibly be equitable as between author and pub-<br />
lisher. It is quite possible that the moulds and<br />
engravings might be so worn that they would not<br />
be worth half the cost of production, and the<br />
copies of the book that the publisher had on hand<br />
might not be worth the whole cost of production,<br />
_ as it is quite possible that they might have been<br />
damaged or otherwise defaced. If, therefore, the<br />
author refused to purchase the books at the cost of<br />
production on account of some damage that they<br />
had received, it would be possible for the author in<br />
reproducing the work with some other publisher to<br />
be undersold. The author should have the option<br />
of taking over the stock and plates at a valuation.<br />
The danger, however, is not a very large one, as if<br />
the book was in such a condition that the author<br />
desired to bring out a new edition and the pub-<br />
lisher did not, it would most probably argue that<br />
the book had very nearly reached the end of its sale,<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
in which case there would most probably be only a<br />
few copies on hand. The danger, however, is one<br />
that should be guarded against.<br />
<br />
Clause 11 ought to be struck out, as, until a<br />
dispute arises, it is impossible to say whether it is<br />
a fit subject for arbitration ; besidés, arbitration<br />
is more expensive than an action at law, and a<br />
publisher thereby avoids that publicity which is<br />
essential for the interests of authors and the puri-<br />
fication of the trade, which no doubt all publishers<br />
desire.<br />
<br />
Clause 12 should on no account stand. It is<br />
most important, as explained when discussing the<br />
parties to this agreement, that the contract should<br />
be a personal contract, and this point should always<br />
be before authors when signing agreements. They<br />
should under no circumstances allow such a clause<br />
to pass.<br />
<br />
This is a fair comment on the royalty agreement<br />
as it stands. Many suggestions might be made as<br />
to the insertion of various clauses, and the protec-<br />
tion of the author on other points. But these are<br />
faults of omission, and the agreement has only<br />
been dealt with as regards the drafted clauses. It<br />
might be well to mention that some definite time<br />
should be fixed on, before which a publisher should<br />
not be allowed to make remainder sales.<br />
<br />
Finally, it must be repeated, do not be taken in<br />
by the apparently plausible statement that all a<br />
publisher’s authors sign the agreement submitted.<br />
As a rule, where such a suggestion is made, it may<br />
be taken that the statement is not strictly in<br />
accordance with fact.<br />
<br />
ee<br />
<br />
American. Copyright.—A Copyright Decision,<br />
<br />
Cuicaao, Ill., October 31.—An important copy-<br />
right decision was given to-day in the United<br />
States Court of Appeals, which established the<br />
principle that the owner of a copyrighted manu-<br />
script cannot be deprived of his exclusive rights<br />
of publication by the error of one who prints the<br />
article with his consent, but who carelessly omits<br />
the notice to the public provided for by law.<br />
<br />
“And After,” a story written by Julia Truitt<br />
Bishop, was in contention. It had been copy-<br />
righted by the Daily Story Publishing Company.<br />
One of the patrons of that firm is the St. Louis<br />
Globe-Democrat, which published “And After”<br />
without the copyright notice. The American<br />
Press Association appropriated the article and<br />
distributed it among its subscribers.<br />
<br />
The owners of the copyright threatened to sue<br />
the patrons of the Press Association for damages.<br />
The Press Association applied for a bill to restrain<br />
such suits. It was denied by Judge Kohlsaat, and<br />
his ruling was affirmed by Judges Jenkins and<br />
Baker.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
a<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. 71<br />
<br />
GENERAL MEMORANDA.<br />
— +<br />
<br />
ERE are a few standing rules to be observed in an<br />
agreement. There are four methods of dealing<br />
with literary property —:<br />
<br />
I. Selling it Outright.<br />
<br />
This is in some respects the most satisfactory, if a proper<br />
price can be obtained. But the transaction. should be<br />
managed by a conipetent agent, or with the advice of the<br />
Secretary of the Society.<br />
<br />
Il. A Profit-Sharing Agreement (a bad form of<br />
agreement). :<br />
<br />
In this case the following rules should be attended to :<br />
<br />
C1.) Not to sign any agreement in which the cost of pro-<br />
duction forms a part without the strictest investigation.<br />
<br />
(2.) Not to give the publisher the power of putting the<br />
profits into his own pocket by charging for advertisements<br />
in his own organs, or by charging exchange advertise-<br />
ments. Therefore keep control of the advertisements.<br />
<br />
(3.) Not to allow a special charge for “ office expenses,”<br />
unless the same allowance is made to the author.<br />
<br />
(4.) Not to give up American, Colonial, or Continental<br />
rights. :<br />
<br />
(5.) Not to give up serial or translation rights.<br />
<br />
(6.) Not to bind yourself for future work to any publisher.<br />
As well bind yourself for the future to any one solicitor or<br />
doctor !<br />
<br />
III. The Royalty System.<br />
<br />
It is above all things necessary to know what the<br />
proposed royalty means to both sides. It is now possible<br />
for an author to ascertain approximately and very nearly<br />
the truth. From time to time the very important figures<br />
connected with royalties are published in The Author.<br />
Readers can also work out the figures themselves from the<br />
** Cost of Production.”<br />
<br />
IY. A Commission Agreement.<br />
<br />
The main points are :-—<br />
<br />
(1.) Be careful to obtain a fair cost of production.<br />
(2.) Keep control of the advertisements.<br />
<br />
(3.) Keep control of the sale price of the book.<br />
<br />
General.<br />
<br />
All other forms of agreement are combinations of the four<br />
above mentioned.<br />
<br />
Such combinations are generally disastrous to the author.<br />
<br />
Never sign any agreement without competent advice from<br />
the Secretary of the Society.<br />
<br />
Stamp all agreements with the Inland Revenue stamp.<br />
<br />
Avoid agreements by letter if possible.<br />
<br />
The main points which the Society has always demanded<br />
from the outset are :—<br />
<br />
C1.) That both sides shall know what an agreement<br />
means.<br />
<br />
(2.) The inspection of those account books which belong<br />
to the author. We are advised that this is a right, in the<br />
nature of a common law right, which cannot be denied or<br />
withheld,<br />
<br />
ge<br />
<br />
WARNINGS TO DRAMATIC AUTHORS.<br />
me<br />
<br />
EVER sign an agreement without submitting it to the<br />
Secretary of the Society of Authors or some com-<br />
petent legal authority.<br />
<br />
2. It is well to be extremely careful in negotiating for<br />
the production of a play with anyone except an established<br />
manager.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
3. There are three forms of dramatic contract for PLAYS<br />
IN THREE OR MORE ACTS :—<br />
<br />
(a.) SALE OUTRIGHT OF THE PERFORMING RIGHT,<br />
This is unsatisfactory. An author who enters<br />
into such a contract should stipulate in the con-<br />
tract for production of the piece by a certain date<br />
and for proper publication of his name on the<br />
play-bills.<br />
<br />
(.) SALE OF PERFORMING RIGHT OR OF A LICENCE<br />
TO PERFORM ON THE BASIS OF PERCENTAGES<br />
on gross receipts. Percentages vary between<br />
5 and 15 per cent. An author should obtain a<br />
percentage on the sliding scale of gruss receipts<br />
in preference to the American system. Should<br />
obtain a sum in advance of percentages. A fixed<br />
date on or before which the play should be<br />
performed.<br />
<br />
(¢.) SALE OF PERFORMING RIGHT OR OF A LICENCE<br />
TO PERFORM ON THE BASIS OF ROYALTIES (i.é.,<br />
fixed nightly fees). This method should be<br />
always avoided except in cases where the fees<br />
are likely to be small or difficult to collect. The<br />
other safeguards set out under heading (b.) apply<br />
also in this case.<br />
<br />
4, PLAYS IN ONE ACT are often sold outright, but it is<br />
better to obtain a small nightly fee if possible, and a sum<br />
paid in advance of such fees in any event. It is extremely<br />
important that the amateur rights of one-act plays should<br />
be reserved.<br />
<br />
5. Authors should remember that performing rights can<br />
<br />
- be limited, and are usually limited, by town, country, and<br />
<br />
time. This is most important.<br />
<br />
6. Authors should not assign performing rights, but<br />
should grant a licence to perform. The legal distinction is<br />
of great importance.<br />
<br />
7. Authors should remember that performing rights in a<br />
play are distinct from literary copyright. A manager<br />
holding the performing right or licence to perform cannot<br />
print the book of the words,<br />
<br />
8. Never forget that AMERICAN RIGHTS may be exceed-<br />
ingly valuable. ‘hey should never be included in English<br />
agreements without the author obtaining a substantial<br />
consideration.<br />
<br />
9. Agreements for collaboration should be carefully<br />
drawn and executed before collaboration is commenced.<br />
<br />
10. An author should remember that production of a play<br />
is highly speculative: that he runs a very great risk of<br />
delay and a breakdown in the fulfilment of his contract.<br />
He should therefore guard himself all the more carefully in<br />
the beginning.<br />
<br />
11. An author must remember that the dramatic market<br />
is exceedingly limited, and that for a novice the first object<br />
is to obtain adequate publication.<br />
<br />
As these warnings must necessarily be incomplete on<br />
account of the wide range of the subject of dramatic con-<br />
tracts, THOSE AUTHORS DESIROUS OF FURTHER INFORMA-<br />
TION ARE REFERRED TO THE SECRETARY OF THE SOCIETY.<br />
<br />
——<br />
<br />
HOW TO USE THE SOCIETY.<br />
<br />
— > —<br />
<br />
1. VERY member has a right toask for and to receive<br />
advice upon his agreements, his choice of a pub-<br />
lisher, or any dispute arising in the conduct of his<br />
<br />
business or the administration of his property. If the<br />
adyice sought is such as can be given best by a solicitor,<br />
the member has a right to an opinion from the Society’s<br />
solicitors. If the case is such that Counsel’s opinion is<br />
desirable, the Committee will obtain for him Counsel’s<br />
opinion. All this without any cost to the member.<br />
<br />
<br />
72<br />
<br />
2. Remember that questions connected with copyright<br />
and publishers’ agreements do not generally fall within the<br />
experience of ordinary solicitors. Therefore, do not scruple<br />
to use the Society.<br />
<br />
3. Send to the Office copies of past agreements and past<br />
accounts, with a copy of the book represented. The<br />
Secretary will always be glad to have any agreements, new<br />
or old, for inspection and note. The information thus<br />
obtained may prove invaluable.<br />
<br />
4, BEFORE SIGNING ANY AGREEMENT WHATEVER, send<br />
the document to the Society for examination.<br />
<br />
5. Remember always that in belonging to the Society<br />
you are fighting the battles of other writers, even if you<br />
are reaping no benefit to yourself, and that you are<br />
advancing the best interests of literature in promoting the<br />
independence of the writer.<br />
<br />
6. The Committee have now arranged for the reception<br />
of members’ agreements and their preservation in a fire-<br />
proof safe. The agreements will, of course, be regarded as<br />
confidential documents to be read only by the Secretary,<br />
who will keep the key of the safe. The Society now offers :<br />
—(1) To read and advise upon agreements and to give<br />
advice concerning publishers. (2) To stamp agreements<br />
in readiness for a possible action upon them. (3) To keep<br />
agreements. (4) To enforce payments due according to<br />
agreements.<br />
<br />
7. No contract should be entered into with a literary<br />
agent without the advice of the Secretary of the Society.<br />
Members are strongly advised not to accept without careful<br />
consideration the contracts submitted to them by literary<br />
agents, and are recommended to submit them for inter-<br />
pretation and explanation to the Secretary of the Society.<br />
<br />
8. Many agents neglect to stamp agreements. This<br />
must be done within fourteen days of first execution. The<br />
Secretary will undertake it on behalf of members.<br />
<br />
9. Some agents endeavour to prevent authors from<br />
referring matters to the Secretary of the Society ; so do<br />
some publishers. Members can make their own deductions<br />
and act accordingly.<br />
<br />
THE READING BRANCH.<br />
<br />
—-—~——9 —<br />
<br />
EMBERS will greatly assist the Society in this<br />
branch of its work by informing young writers<br />
of its existence. Their MSS. can be read and<br />
<br />
treated as a composition is treated by a coach, The term<br />
MSS. includes NOT ONLY WORKS OF FICTION, BUT POETRY<br />
AND DRAMATIC WORKS, and when it is possible, under<br />
special arrangement, technical and scientific works. The<br />
Readers are writers of competence and experience. The<br />
fee is one guinea.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
ee<br />
<br />
NOTICES.<br />
<br />
—<br />
<br />
VHE Editor of The Author begs to remind members of<br />
<br />
the Society that, although the paper is sent to them<br />
<br />
free of charge, the cost of producing it would be a<br />
<br />
very heavy charge on the resources of the Society if a great<br />
<br />
many members did not forward to the Secretary the modest<br />
5s. 6d. subscription for the year.<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
Communications for Zhe Author should be addressed to<br />
the Offices of the Society, 39, Old Queen Street, Storey’s<br />
Gate, §.W., and should reach the Editor NOT LATER<br />
THAN THE 21st OF EACH MONTH.<br />
<br />
All persons engaged in literary work of any kind,<br />
whether members of the Society or not, are invited to<br />
communicate to the Editor any points connected with their<br />
work which it would be advisable in the general interest to<br />
publish.<br />
<br />
te<br />
<br />
COMMUNICATIONS AND LETTERS ARE INVITED BY THE<br />
EDITOR on all subjects connected with literature, but on<br />
no other subjects whatever. Every effort will be made to<br />
return articles which cannot be accepted.<br />
<br />
—<br />
<br />
THE SECRETARY OF THE SOCIETY begs to give notice<br />
that all remittances are acknowledged by return of post,<br />
and he requests members who do not receive an<br />
answer to important communications within two days to<br />
write to him without delay. All remittances should be<br />
crossed Union Bank of London, Chancery Lane, or be sent<br />
by registered létter only.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
AUTHORITIES.<br />
<br />
—1+—~>—+ —<br />
<br />
N this number we publish a report of the doings<br />
of the International Congress of Publishers.<br />
Such a combination may do useful work not<br />
<br />
only to their own trade, but for the better securing<br />
of the author’s property.<br />
<br />
There is also a possibility that such a combina-<br />
tion may at some future date be a very serious<br />
menace to author’s rights, backed as it is by large<br />
capital, Money, at all times, is a great power to<br />
enforce an opinion or to pass a law. Would it not<br />
be possible for those societies which represent<br />
the trade side of literature from the author’s point<br />
of view, to form an international combination, in<br />
order to counteract any ill effect which may be<br />
produced by the combination of the trade ?<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
We must congratulate Mr. John Murray that<br />
his historic house in Albemarle Street has escaped<br />
the ravages of the Tube disease, which he has<br />
aptly termed Tube-Yerke-ulosis.<br />
<br />
The Nobel Prize Committee of the Society of<br />
Authors, of which Lord Avebury is the ‘chairman,<br />
met on the afternoon of November 19th, at<br />
39, Old Queen Street.<br />
<br />
Inthe unavoidable absence of Lord Avebury, the<br />
chair was taken by Mr. Edmund Gosse. Mr. G.<br />
Herbert Thring acted as secretary. A letter was<br />
read addressed by the Director of the Swedish<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR. 73<br />
<br />
Academy, the poet, ©. D. af Wirsen, to Lord<br />
Avebury as Chairman of the Committee, expressing<br />
the hope that the English Nobel Committee would<br />
not be discouraged if the prize of £8,250 should<br />
this year be awarded to a foreign poet or poets, since<br />
any imaginative writer, strongly supported by the<br />
authors of England, “‘has every prospect of gaining<br />
the Nobel Prize for Literature at some future time.”<br />
Dr. Garnett suggested that unanimity and persist-<br />
ence were of the greatest importance, and that<br />
the Committee should not be impatient if the prize<br />
were not immediately given to the English candi-<br />
date. At the suggestion of Mr. Austin Dobson, it<br />
was agreed that the Committee should take the<br />
same steps as were taken last year to collect the<br />
votes of the qualified British voters.<br />
<br />
We are glad to see that the literary activity of<br />
the Canadian is constantly on the increase.<br />
<br />
A Tennyson Club has just been started at<br />
Toronto, under the auspices of the Victoria<br />
University and the Canadian Society of Authors.<br />
The Honorary President is Professor William<br />
Clark, and the Active President, Professor Pelham<br />
Edgar.<br />
<br />
We hope to have further particulars, and to be<br />
able to follow the course of the club’s labour and<br />
work.<br />
<br />
The editor of La Revue has obtained the opinions<br />
of some leading French authors on the following<br />
subject: “ Would you regret to die? Why?”<br />
<br />
The French are proverbially a light-hearted<br />
nation, and it is no wonder therefore that the<br />
majority of the answers obtained show that the<br />
French author would have a decided objection to<br />
death, and would leave this world with consider-<br />
able regret. The reasons put forward are varied,<br />
some serious, some satirical, some amusing.<br />
<br />
The author who writes under the well-known<br />
pseudonym of “ Gyp” merely replies, “ Oh, pas du<br />
tout.”<br />
<br />
It would be interesting to know what opinions<br />
British authors would express in answer to the<br />
same question.<br />
<br />
One author living this side of the Channel<br />
has given his answer: That his only object in<br />
living was that he might contrast the pleasure of<br />
death. He did not therefore regret to die. It<br />
might be as well to remark that this author was<br />
not an Irishman.<br />
<br />
At a jovial gathering of members and guests of<br />
a certain club frequented by followers of the<br />
literary profession, an argument arose between<br />
two Oxford men as to whether, given a previous<br />
<br />
choice, the majority of men, knowing the life<br />
they would have to go throngh, would consent to<br />
be born into this world. The younger contestant<br />
argued strongly, that no one would have been<br />
born into the world under these circumstances.<br />
As the point obtained some show of interest<br />
among the company, it was finally decided to<br />
take the opinion of a dozen of those present.<br />
Each was allowed to choose his victims. The<br />
party was composed of men of mixed views, but<br />
among the number were one or two decadents,<br />
and others whose lives had not been what, on<br />
the whole, could be called cheerful. With careful<br />
choice the younger member thought that his vic-<br />
tory was assured, but what was his disappointment<br />
when he found that, after having chosen the most<br />
unfortunate men in the room, there was no one to<br />
support him. The question, though not similar to<br />
that put forward by the French editor, carries with<br />
it some analogy.<br />
<br />
The performing rights of a song have been again<br />
before the public. A case has just been tried in<br />
the High Courts where this point was in dispute. *<br />
<br />
We have from time to time impressed upon<br />
those composers who are members of the Society<br />
the importance of reserving to themselves the<br />
performing rights. Publishers generally answer,<br />
if a composer in his temerity makes the demand,<br />
that performing rights have no money in them in<br />
England. The composer’s answer to this is quite<br />
clear : “Then, there is no reason why they should<br />
be transferred to the publisher.”<br />
<br />
It is possible that under the present system<br />
there is no money in performing rights, but the<br />
case tried in the High Court tends to show the<br />
contrary.<br />
<br />
Even if there is no money, it is vastly important<br />
that the composer himself should have, if it seems<br />
good to him, the right of veto, so that a song, on<br />
which he may set great store, should not be pro-<br />
duced and sung in public at times and in places<br />
which might appear to him unfit.<br />
<br />
The publisher’s statement is by no means true.<br />
In the performing rights of certain kinds of songs<br />
produced in comic operas, at music halls and under<br />
other circumstances, there is a considerable amount<br />
of money. ‘These songs are often not written as<br />
part of the opera, but pitchforked into the opera,<br />
in order to make it more attractive, so that an<br />
individual song may obtain a great vogue. Of<br />
course, the composer obtains some kind of com-<br />
pensation from the advertisement, but there is<br />
something far beyond this.<br />
<br />
The French composer has already proved this.<br />
It is time that his English confrére should also<br />
stand firm.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
74<br />
<br />
An Epigram.<br />
Publisher : Th’ agreement’s signed; the profits<br />
<br />
we divide—<br />
A half to each; applaud a just<br />
decision.<br />
Author: Peace and good will to all at<br />
Christmastide—<br />
<br />
Clearly, *twixt you and me there’s<br />
no division.<br />
<br />
———__1—>_+—___——_<br />
<br />
A LITERARY ACADEMY.<br />
<br />
ee<br />
TI. A Quotation from Zola on Academies.<br />
<br />
HILE the subject of an Académy of Letters<br />
is once again, for a brief moment, before<br />
us in England, I should like to draw<br />
<br />
attention to the views of Zola—the earlier Zola—<br />
on Academies in general: partly because of their<br />
intrinsic interest, and partly because it is just now<br />
well worth while to point out to English readers<br />
that, before the unliterary moralist who wrote<br />
« Trayail ” and “ Fécondité ” made himself known,<br />
there existed a really powerful man of letters,<br />
author of the “ Conquéte de Plassans,” of “'Thérese<br />
Raquin,” and of more than one volume of vigorous<br />
criticism.<br />
<br />
In his “L’Argent dans la Littérature” (‘Le<br />
Roman Expérimental,” 1880), Zola traces the<br />
Academy of the present to the literary salons of<br />
the past, and shows what an article de luxe these,<br />
in their time, had made of literature. Speaking<br />
of what one may call the Augustan age of French<br />
writing, he says :—<br />
<br />
“Tt is now ” (say 1700) ‘ the salons which are at<br />
work upon the literary spirit and which determine<br />
its course. Books are dear and rare; the mob does<br />
not read, the bourgeoisie hardly reads ; we are far<br />
from that great current of literature which to-day<br />
sweeps along with it the whole of society, It is the<br />
exception to meet a passionate reader, who devours<br />
all that the publishers set before him. Thus the<br />
great public—what we call ‘ opinion,’ universal<br />
suffrage, so to speak, does not exist in literary<br />
matters : and the salons, a few groups of chosen<br />
people, have alone to pronounce a decisive judg-<br />
ment. These salons really reigned over literature.<br />
It was they who decided on language, the choice of<br />
subjects, and the manner of treating them. They<br />
sorted out words, adopting some, condemning<br />
others ; they established rules, set fashions, made<br />
their great men. Thence came the character of<br />
literature, as I have tried to indicate it above: a<br />
fleur desprit, an amiable pastime, a_high-class<br />
amusement for well-bred people. Picture to<br />
yourself one of these salons which laid down the<br />
laws of letters. A woman gathered round her a<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
set of writers whose sole care was to please her ;<br />
manuscripts were read in a select committee, there<br />
was much conversation, carried on with all the<br />
delicacy and all the conventions in the world.<br />
Genius, as we understand it nowadays, with its<br />
irregular power, would have found itself very ill<br />
at ease there; but mere talent flourished in the<br />
pleasant atmosphere of a hothouse. Even in the<br />
earliest days of French culture, when the salons<br />
had scarcely begun and great seigneurs contented<br />
themselves with keeping in their pay a poet as<br />
they kept a cook, the state of domestic servitude<br />
in which letters found themselves put them at the<br />
mercy of a privileged class, which they flattered<br />
and whose taste they had to consult. This gave<br />
them all kinds of pleasant qualities—tact, measure,<br />
a balanced pomp, an artificial construction and<br />
language; and, again, all the charms which are to<br />
be found in a society of well-bred women, subtleties<br />
and refinements of brain and of the heart, delicate<br />
conversations on delicate subjects, touching lightly<br />
on all without bearing heavily on anything—those<br />
fireside chats which are like musical airs, and which<br />
are confined to the melodies, gay or sad, 6f the<br />
human being. This was the literary spirit of the<br />
last two centuries.<br />
<br />
“Naturally, the salons led to academies ; and it<br />
was there that the literary spirit blossomed forth in<br />
a fine flourish of rhetoric. Disengaged from the<br />
society element, having no longer women to con-<br />
sider, it became above all things grammatical and<br />
rhetorical, buried in questions of tradition, of rules<br />
and recipes. You should hear Sainte Beuve, with<br />
his free spirit, still speaking of the Academy with<br />
all the importance and indignation of an industrious<br />
clerk who has gone to his office and has been<br />
shocked by the conduct and the work of his<br />
colleagues. Many men of letters loved these<br />
sittings devoted to disputes about words, these —<br />
gatherings at which one squabbled in the name of<br />
the oracles of antiquity. ‘There they hurled Greek<br />
and Latin at your head, they revelled in a com-<br />
munity of pedantry, in the midst of an extra-<br />
ordinary complication of hates and jealousies, of<br />
petty battles and petty triumphs. There is no<br />
porter’s lodge in which more blows have been<br />
exchanged than in the Academy. For two cen-<br />
turies, statesmen fallen from power, bilious poets<br />
boiling over with conceit, bookmen with their<br />
heads stuffed with folios, have gone there for relief,<br />
to enjoy the illusion that they were famous, bitterly<br />
discussing their own merits, without ever carrying<br />
the public with them.”<br />
<br />
In these words, and many more of the same kind, ©<br />
Zola sets forth his opinions on the nature, and the —<br />
effect upon literature, of the Academy, to which at<br />
that time—presumably—he did not wish to belong.<br />
<br />
EpWARD Rose.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
iT.<br />
<br />
I am strongly in favour of the establishment<br />
of an Academy of Letters, because I believe<br />
that there is at the present time a practical<br />
piece of work that very much requires to be done<br />
in the domain of letters, and that nothing but an<br />
Academy can do it.<br />
<br />
I do not regard the project, as some regard it,<br />
as the establishment of a species of Order of<br />
Literary merit, because I should feel that the<br />
tendency now-a-days is rather to overdo the<br />
recognition of public services than the reverse.<br />
<br />
But I believe that literature in England just at<br />
present is rather in an unsatisfactory condition.<br />
There is a great demand for literature of a certain<br />
kind, and there is a strong tendency among writers<br />
to regard monetary rewards as the test of success.<br />
I imagine that there are a far larger number of<br />
people who make a living by writing than there<br />
were fifty years ago, and | suppose that the incomes<br />
made by successful writers reach a far higher<br />
average than ever before. Thisisa state of things<br />
which has its dangers ; for there is not, among the<br />
consumers of literature, at all a high instinctive<br />
standard of literary merit, or at all a cultivated<br />
appreciation of literary form.<br />
<br />
It is not for the sake of the Academicians them-<br />
selves that I should like to see an Academy estab-<br />
lished ; but there should be, I believe, a strong<br />
central body of eminent writers, whose duty it<br />
should be to be on the look-out for work of high<br />
<br />
jiterary merit, and to commend such work with all<br />
the authority which such a body would naturally<br />
command.<br />
<br />
There are, I suppose, a few writers of high in-<br />
stinctive vocation in each generation who would<br />
work independently of reward of any kind. But the<br />
tendency at present in belles lettres is for writers<br />
to write with the hope of a large circulation<br />
before their eyes, and gradually to desert those<br />
paths in literature which do not lead either to<br />
honour or to money.<br />
<br />
At present the only people who can afford<br />
to write with the sincere aim of producing litera-<br />
ture of a high order are the fortunate people who,<br />
either by the inheritance of wealth, or by the fact<br />
that they hold a professional position which makes<br />
them independent, and provides them with a cer-<br />
tain amount of leisure, are able to disregard the<br />
ultimate tangible results of their work.<br />
<br />
Such people receive a certain amount of recog-<br />
nition from reviews in journals of high standing ;<br />
but the number of literary journals is not very<br />
great, and the tendency of such writers is to grow<br />
discouraged, and to feel that after all they are not<br />
wanted, and that no one very much cares whether<br />
they speak or hold their peace.<br />
<br />
It is certainly a remarkable fact that the purely<br />
<br />
15<br />
<br />
literary element in magazines and journals has<br />
lately decidedly decreased. A pessimist would say<br />
that this was owing to the fact that the number of<br />
writers whose works were worth literary considera-<br />
tion had decreased; but if this is so, it is, I believe,<br />
because literary activity is turned into other chan-<br />
nels, not because our literary energy is in any way<br />
diminished.<br />
<br />
_An Academy would then perform the office of<br />
authoritative literary criticism. They would ap-<br />
<br />
“point, I imagine, a small literary committee, whose<br />
<br />
duty would be to examine current literature, and re-<br />
commend acertain number of books for commenda-<br />
tion. It would be impossible for the Academicians<br />
themselves to desert the work of composition which<br />
had placed them in the forefront of letters, in<br />
favour of the exhausting task of reading the litera-<br />
ture of the day and adjudicating on its merits, but<br />
they could nominate a small committee of critics,<br />
not necessarily Academicians, men of wide cultiva-<br />
tion and catholic taste, who would make it their<br />
aim to discern what was likely to be of permanent<br />
value, and to recommend the work of rising writers<br />
to the commendation of the central body.<br />
<br />
I believe that this would be of the highest prac-<br />
tical utility. here are authors who would gladly<br />
forego the tangible monetary rewards of writing,<br />
if they could be dignified by the honourable<br />
recognition of the best writers of the time.<br />
<br />
I believe that the literary energy existing in<br />
England now-is very great, and that the one thing<br />
that is required to turn this in the right direction<br />
is the creation of a high standard of literary value.<br />
Authors would be encouraged to write deliberately<br />
rather than hurriedly, to study form and construc-<br />
tion rather than superficial attractiveness ; and it<br />
might possibly create a school of literary artists of<br />
a kind which England just now, considering its<br />
literary output, conspicuously lacks.<br />
<br />
It is idle to point to bygone centuries and to<br />
say that works of high literary merit were then<br />
produced without the assistance of any central<br />
literary body. What formerly existed in England,<br />
and what has ceased to exist, was a high degree of<br />
respect, felt and expressed by notable persons, for<br />
great literary performance. That has nowadays<br />
been completely over-ridden by the popular verdict,<br />
and by the fact that so far more people consider<br />
themselves competent to express opinions on litera-<br />
ture. I should look upon an Academy rather as<br />
a fort established to try and uphold the higher<br />
standard of respect for literature that formerly<br />
existed, than a new departure, a morbid attempt<br />
to confer a dignity on literature which it had not<br />
earned, and which it did not deserve.<br />
<br />
Artuur OC. BENSON.<br />
<br />
1<br />
<br />
<br />
76<br />
<br />
IIL.<br />
<br />
Srr,—The help offered by the Society of Authors<br />
is practical and possible ; what is looked for from<br />
an Academy of Letters is neither. Does anyone<br />
seriously believe that the rise, say of Scott, Dickens,<br />
or Macaulay, in public estimation, would have been<br />
in the smallest degree either hastened or enhanced<br />
by such an institution ; or that under its influence<br />
Keats would have been encouraged to live, or<br />
Robert Montgomery sooner and more effectually<br />
dethroned? Sir Walter Besant in “ The Fourth<br />
Generation” made one of the characters say, that<br />
through the sins of the father a descendant might,<br />
for instance, be prevented by poverty from taking<br />
the place in literature his talents fitted him for.<br />
What would or could an Academy do for such a<br />
case? It is the natural and inevitable tendency<br />
of all such bodies to settle down into coteries and<br />
to turn the republic of letters into an oligarchy.<br />
Mr. Herbert Trench says an English Academy<br />
would have to be made better than the one here.<br />
But how? Is England so especially the abode of<br />
academic rectitude ? An Academy of Letters would<br />
have condemned Shakespeare’s works on account<br />
of their irregularities. The surpassing merits of<br />
the greatest genius of our literature would have<br />
been ignored because of academical defects.<br />
Imagine “Hamlet” or “Macbeth” depending<br />
for success on the decision of the French Academy!<br />
If still publicly unknown, they would be even more<br />
contemptuously spurned by it to-day than in the<br />
days of Mazarin, its founder. When a master-<br />
spirit appears with new means to break new<br />
ground, it is an instinct of self-preservation in<br />
an Academy to frown upon him. It is only when<br />
he has been adopted by the multitude, and a new<br />
school has arisen, that the close corporation of<br />
Olympians condescends to recognize him. In<br />
Shakespeare’s time men ventured boldly in the<br />
new world of letters because there was no Academy<br />
to chill their ardour. The work that succeeds with<br />
an Academy is one that, while deferentially con-<br />
ciliating the predilections of one or two of its more<br />
active members, offends the susceptibilities of none<br />
of them—which means, something tamely correct.<br />
Lucas Malet says that “genius is sooner or later<br />
bound by right divine to conquer.” That is very<br />
pretty, but, alas, it is not true. There is abso-<br />
lutely no room for all the genius in the world to<br />
get a hearing. Like everything else in Nature,<br />
there is much more of it than mankind has need<br />
of. A new writer’s most legitimate, though not<br />
<br />
perhaps his commercially best, chance of succeed-<br />
ing with the public is in strong originality—by<br />
which, of course, I do not mean eccentricity, but<br />
originality governed by strong common-sense and<br />
by modest observance of universally accepted<br />
models.<br />
<br />
But strong originality is the very thing,<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
I submit, to which an Academy would, even from<br />
the nature of its constitution, be least likely to be<br />
favourable. Appoint six men as a beginning, with<br />
power to add, say, thirty-four to their number.<br />
They choose as far as possible only men of their<br />
own way of thinking. And being constituted, the<br />
forty affix the hall-mark of their approval only<br />
when neither the public needs it for guidance nor<br />
the author for encouragement. The Academies of<br />
Painting and Music cannot be cited as analogous<br />
cases. With regard to the first, it is practically a<br />
necessity for painters to have their works viewed<br />
in a public exhibition of repute, for which it is<br />
equally necessary that there should be some sort of<br />
selection by some sort of committee. Writers are<br />
not subject to these necessities. Again, Painting<br />
and Music must both be very exactly taught, and<br />
Academies of these arts are or, like universities,<br />
ought to be not merely examining but also teaching<br />
bodies. Now, I boldly assert that the writer’s art<br />
cannot be taught. It can be learnt, and must be,<br />
but chiefly by much reading and practice on the<br />
part of the learner. If the young author has “ got<br />
it in him,” he will know how to educate himself ;<br />
if he has not, uo education in the world will bring<br />
out what isn’t there. As to the alleged need of a<br />
standard of criticism founded on the judgment<br />
of experts, a book may show indisputable signs<br />
of care and exceptional knowledge, but if its<br />
author does not possess the gift of infusing the<br />
fire of interest into his work, it is not an Academy<br />
of Letters or the applause of a few specialists that<br />
can make the public read it or even buy it. Still,<br />
it is insisted that an Academy’s guidance is really<br />
required. But is it gravely assumed that an<br />
official approval now and then of a new book would<br />
have any appreciable effect in a young author’s<br />
self-education or on publictaste? The assumption<br />
seems to me out of all proportion. The reading<br />
public in France, as a mass, pays not the slightest<br />
heed to the occasional “crowning” of a book by<br />
the Academy. I do not believe with Mr. Herbert<br />
Trench that there is a thirst among teachers for<br />
guidance in matters of general literature. As to<br />
school and college books, they just use those<br />
which give pupils the best chance of passing this<br />
or that examination, not forgetting the examiner’s<br />
own productions, where such exist. Ce n’est pas<br />
plus malin que ca. As to charlatans, with capital<br />
to foist rubbish on the public, there are humbugs<br />
who block the way in every line of life ; it is not<br />
an Academy that would suppress them. But, it<br />
may be urged, even if an Academy did no good, it<br />
could not after all really do much harm. Well,<br />
that is not a very strong reason for calling it into<br />
existence.<br />
A. HEFFER.<br />
Paris.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
S<br />
bot<br />
<br />
Ati<br />
<br />
*<br />
<br />
KI<br />
<br />
:<br />
<br />
if<br />
ig<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
eet<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Pun<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
IV.<br />
<br />
Dear Srir,—A strange wind blew. Beneath it<br />
a mighty sea rose and raged, this way and that,<br />
in a most ‘‘ anarchic” fashion. On the beach was<br />
descried dimly the figure of a man_ groping.<br />
“ What,” Heaven asked him, in its own name,<br />
“are you doing?” “Looking for forty fossils”<br />
was his answer. ‘ And what,” Heaven asked him,<br />
in its own name, “are you going to do with them<br />
when you have found them?” ‘Calm the sea<br />
with them ”’ was his answer.<br />
<br />
The wind (need I add ?) is popular education.<br />
The sea is the book-reading public. The groping<br />
figure is that of Mr. Herbert ‘Trench. The forty<br />
fossils . . . but I, like Mr. Trench himself, prefer<br />
to devolve the task of naming ‘hem.<br />
<br />
Yours obediently,<br />
Max BEERBOHM.<br />
<br />
$< __—_<br />
<br />
A HISTORY OF GERMAN LITERATURE. *<br />
<br />
— ><br />
<br />
T is, perhaps, a platitude to assert that the<br />
chief snare in the path of the literary historian<br />
is the difficulty of properly subordinating<br />
<br />
detail to general development. In his admirable<br />
history of the great literature that extends from<br />
Ulfilas and the earliest Nibelungen sagas to Suder-<br />
mann and Nietzche, Mr. Robertson has avoided<br />
this pitfall with complete success. His work is<br />
one that should meet with nothing but praise, both<br />
for his complete comprehension of the growth and<br />
decline of all the various movements of Germanic<br />
thought and his lucid exposition of the elements<br />
common to all of them, and also for his admirable<br />
criticism in a space necessarily limited of the<br />
intellectual giants of the eighteenth and nineteenth<br />
centuries. While he is careful to trace the influence<br />
and to estimate the importance of Kant, Fichte, and<br />
Hegel in a literature which has always been and<br />
always will be connected with philosophy by the<br />
firmest of bords, he is not forgetful of the form<br />
which, after all, is the eternal element in all art,<br />
and his lyrical selections are most happy. A<br />
literary historian who can sum up the “ Kritik der<br />
reinen Vernunft”’ and the “ Kritik der praktischen<br />
Vernunft” in two pages, and praise with enthusiasm<br />
Heine’s<br />
“Thalatta ! Thalatta !<br />
Sei mir gegriisst, du ewiges Meer !”<br />
<br />
is indeed one in whom we may rejoice.<br />
<br />
The first period of German literature, as Mr.<br />
Robertson points out in his Introduction, falls<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
* “A History of German Literature,” by John G.<br />
Robertson (Blackwood : MCMII.).<br />
<br />
77<br />
<br />
approximately between the period of Anglo-Saxon<br />
poetry in which Beowulf reached its final form,<br />
and the tiny golden age of the prose of Alfred<br />
and Ailfric. It was a monastic age, and Germany<br />
was slower than other nations in breaking loose<br />
from the ascetic trammels that have always proved<br />
so inimical to literature, if not to learning. The<br />
age of the Migrations (875—500, ca.) naturally<br />
failed to produce a written literature, although the<br />
struggles of Ostrogoth, Vandal, and Hun, and the<br />
characters of Ermanrich, Odoaker, and Dietrich,<br />
afforded material for the national epics which<br />
developed later. The second sound-shifting was<br />
fatal to alliterative verse, and Otfrid’s theological<br />
poems (ca. 830—850) followed the early Church<br />
hymns in the use of rhyme. The Middle High<br />
Germany poetry was late in setting in, but by the<br />
twelfth century the bonds of monasticism relaxed,<br />
and the secular themes of the wandering singers<br />
became popular. French influence began to appear ;<br />
the old sagas were remodelled, and the lyric fol-<br />
lowed the form set by the Provencal troubadours..<br />
The courtly Middle High German poetry, however,<br />
declined with knighthood ; as the middle classes<br />
rose to power, literary art subsided. Not until<br />
Luther’s genius had placed his nation in the van of<br />
European progress, and Luther’s Bible had fixed<br />
the standard of modern German, did this period of<br />
decadence end, as all periods of decadence do, in<br />
regeneration.<br />
<br />
terman culture in the sixteenth century was<br />
entirely due to the Reformation, and was at first<br />
completely out of reach of the Latin renaissance.<br />
When, however, it might have benefited by the<br />
latter, the horror of the Thirty Years’ War over-<br />
whelmed it absolutely. Germany was the intel-<br />
lectual outcast of Europe until the end of the<br />
seventeenth century, until the appearance of the<br />
genius of Leibnitz. The first period of German<br />
literature in the eighteenth century was character-<br />
ised by imitation of English and French models,<br />
the second was a period of national originality.<br />
Klopstock, Wieland, Lessing, respectively laid the<br />
foundations of the modern German lyric, novel,<br />
and drama, so that by the middle of the century<br />
Germany had passed far beyond the former dark-<br />
ness, and at the beginning of the nineteenth<br />
century German classical literature had reached<br />
its zenith. ‘The Romantic movement, and the.<br />
“young German epoch” that followed, were’<br />
really periods of decadence which produced a few<br />
men of genius and a vast number of fanatical<br />
mediocrities.<br />
<br />
Such is the scheme of development to which Mr.<br />
Robertson adheres. Through all its ramifications<br />
we may trace the element which is the dominant<br />
note of the Teutonic character—mysticism. It is<br />
apparent in the Old High German poetry of Otfrid<br />
<br />
<br />
78<br />
<br />
and the idea of retribution in the Nibelungen<br />
Lied ; ‘if it disappears in the “ Beast Epics and<br />
the didactic works which are characteristic of the<br />
decline of chivalry, in ‘Reinke de Vos” and<br />
Brant’s “Narren Schyff,” it is handed on by<br />
Luther and reappears widely in the seventeenth cen-<br />
tury ; if it is blotted out by the Thirty Years’ War,<br />
it is apparent in the great work of Leibnitz, and<br />
has been paramount in almost every branch of<br />
German literature since his day. The Teutonic<br />
temperament has always been romantic, 1n the true<br />
sense of the word ; the literature which enshrines<br />
its power is the literature of subjectivity and<br />
individualism.<br />
<br />
In surveying the growth of any branch of art,<br />
we cannot fail to notice how many works have<br />
survived on account of their historical value,<br />
although they are wxsthetically worthless. It is<br />
greatly to Mr. Robertson’s credit that he has never<br />
confused art and archeology, and that, on the<br />
other hand, he has recognised the real beauty of<br />
archaic “first beginnings, so dim and dewy,” as<br />
Browning rather unhappily called them. Modern<br />
criticism is far too apt to regard anything written<br />
in an obsolete dialect as the lawful prey of the<br />
philologist.<br />
<br />
Sr. Joun Lucas.<br />
—_—_—_—__-__<br />
<br />
MR. G. A. HENTY.<br />
<br />
— ts<br />
<br />
HE death of Mr. G. A. Henty, war corre-<br />
spondent and author, has come rather<br />
suddenly. There is no doubt that he<br />
<br />
supplied a certain type of literature which may<br />
entirely disappear with his death. He combined<br />
adventure with instruction, and wrote on lines<br />
that no modern author seems to touch.<br />
<br />
He was a most prolific writer, and certainly<br />
found amongst the boys to whom he appealed a<br />
class as eager for his productions as he was prolific<br />
in his writings.<br />
<br />
All his books were healthy, strong, and vigorous,<br />
full of life and full of “ go,” and all his writings<br />
advocated the strenuous life which he himself lived.<br />
<br />
It is with much regret we chronicle the sad<br />
event.<br />
_<br />
<br />
A LITERARY HISTORY OF PERSIA.*<br />
<br />
oe<br />
<br />
‘bee Tranis (of whom the Persians and Medes<br />
were the leading tribes) and their language<br />
and literature afford us an example unique<br />
<br />
in the annals of nations. The language used by<br />
<br />
* “A Literary History of Persia” (Prof. E. G. Browne).<br />
T, Fisher Unwin.<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
the Achzemanian kings in the sixth century B.o,<br />
would be easily understood by an educated Persian<br />
of to-day, and yet there have been breaches in<br />
their history and literature so wide as would have<br />
drained the life-blood of most other races.<br />
<br />
The Achemanian (Hakhamanish), or Old Persian —<br />
period, extended from about 560 B.C. to the over- |<br />
throw of the Iranian Empire by Alexander of<br />
Macedon in 330 3.c. The only remains of that<br />
literature are the royal acts and proclamations<br />
engraven on stone, and they possess the sonorous<br />
dignity and simplicity to which we are accustomed<br />
in edicts, by members of the same dynasty, re-<br />
corded in the Bible. The national cult and<br />
literature was practically suspended for the five<br />
centuries extending to about 200 .c., only linger-<br />
ing in Magian temples or inaccessible fastnesses<br />
of some reputed descendant of Hakhaman. The<br />
national awakening gave rise to what is known as<br />
the Sassanian period, or Pahlevi literature, which<br />
cannot be disconnected from what some scholars<br />
have defined, artificially, as the Avestic literature.<br />
The Avesta, or sacred books of Zoroastrianism, of<br />
which only about one-fourth are known, have come<br />
down to us in the forms imparted to them between<br />
200 and 350 a.c., but must necessarily include the<br />
oral traditions of the most ancient period, and,<br />
indeed, contains vestiges of practices and super-<br />
stitions from ante-Aryan times, common to all<br />
races. The Avestic literature is only interesting<br />
to him who quarries for the evolution of ideas in<br />
the childhood of the human race. The Pahlevi as<br />
applied to the national resurrection under the<br />
Sassanide dynasty, flourished from about 200—<br />
650 A.c. ; the remains of this literature, although<br />
principally religious (Zoroastrian), contain some<br />
40,000 words of historical romance, which with<br />
other remains, now only extant in Arabic transla-<br />
tions, supplied the subject-matter of that stupen-<br />
dous National Legend moulded by the genius of<br />
Firdusi during the Second Renaissance in about<br />
1000 A.C. d<br />
<br />
The Sassanide dynasty fell in 650 a.c., when the<br />
Empire was overwhelmed by the Arabs, and Persia<br />
became an Arabian province for 300 years, when<br />
Arabic became the language of literature, and<br />
Persian men of genius devoted their talents and<br />
knowledge to the enrichment of Arabic literature<br />
and the glories of Islam.<br />
<br />
The Second Awakening dawned in about<br />
850 A.c., but did not begin to shine until about<br />
950, and then only in distant provinces of the<br />
Caliphate and, chiefly, under the patronage of<br />
Turkish adventurers, who nurtured the Persian<br />
cult and made themselves more Persian than the<br />
Persians for the purpose of strengthening them-<br />
selves against their suzerains, the Caliphs of Bag-<br />
dad. I must refer the reader to Prof. Browne’s<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
ood<br />
<br />
book for the many other causes which assisted the<br />
<br />
40098 Second Birth. This period, which is undoubtedly<br />
» aff the Golden Age of Persian literature, flourished<br />
me and expanded until the Tartar flood burst and<br />
<br />
» 79 overwhelmed Asiatic civilisation at the beginning<br />
to of the fourteenth century. Prof. Browne, in the<br />
oy volume before me, stops at 1000 4.c. and promises<br />
-7 us another one on the “Golden Age,” which will<br />
a) include such well-known names as Nizami, Sadi,<br />
O Omar Khaydm, etc. He has already dealt with<br />
4) the translation of Tabari’s great commentary into<br />
<br />
{ Persian; Assadi, the teacher of Firdusi, and in-<br />
<br />
»y ventor of the “ Romance of the Joust”; Rudaki,<br />
<br />
* “piquant in expression and fluent in verse,” so<br />
<br />
f fluent that he is credited with the composition of one<br />
<br />
' + millionthreehundredthousand verses! The greatest<br />
+8 figure is, of course, Firdusi, with his monumental<br />
»/@ Shah name (“Book of the Kings”); this stupendous<br />
4 National Legend, comprising some 60,000 couplets,<br />
'@ embraces the traditional primeval legends, the<br />
** Romance of Iamshid”’ (a sort of combination of<br />
* Solomon and King Arthur), the historical chronicles<br />
<br />
of the Sassanide dynasty and all that is romantic<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
and tuneful down to his own day, coloured, of<br />
course, with Moslem pigment and showing the<br />
grain of Chaldean imagery which the older Pahlevi<br />
writers had assimilated.<br />
<br />
The third Great Trance extended from the<br />
Mongol conquest to about the beginning of the<br />
last century ; but this Third Renaissance has, so far,<br />
concerned itself with recovering the treasures of<br />
the past, translations of foreign books, and—poetry.<br />
<br />
Their poetical forms, the couplet and quatrain,<br />
are borrowed from the Arabic, and from the ninth<br />
to the present century are dirge-like.<br />
<br />
The philosopher is naturally sad, but the senti-<br />
mental Persian wails in his loves, his hates, and his<br />
adorations. When he can spare time from sobbing<br />
a divine hymn to some petty kingling and patron,<br />
he weeps a melancholy dirge about wine, music,<br />
and woman. His eyes are so dimmed with tears<br />
that his Trinity must be brilliantly coloured and<br />
sensuous ; the “ruby wine,” the “heart-exploding<br />
erash of music,” “the ruby lips,’ and so forth.<br />
When a kingling (generally of Turkish extraction)<br />
rhymes, he sighs for “ red-hot blood” and “ nostril<br />
attacking incarmined cuirass.”<br />
<br />
It may be noted en passant that poets made<br />
money in A.C. 1000, for we are told that Rudaki<br />
possessed 200 slaves (some, let us hope, with<br />
‘ruby lips” and other strongly-coloured physical<br />
attractions) and 100 camel-loads of luggage.<br />
<br />
Prof. Browne holds a brief for Persia and devotes<br />
two-thirds of his book to Arabian literature, which<br />
he attempts to prove to be Persian, because many<br />
Persians, half-Persians, fractional-Persians and<br />
Arabs of “reputed” Persian descent wrote in<br />
Arabic. It would be just as easy to class the<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
79<br />
<br />
numerous works published in Latin throughou<br />
Europe during the last two centuries as “ Roman”<br />
literature. No! Arabian literature and Islam<br />
are no more Persian than the northern Sagas are<br />
the vapourings of a Baboo who has “failed B.A.<br />
Calcutta.”<br />
<br />
I shall look forward to Prof. Browne’s next<br />
volume dealing with the great Poet-Philosophers<br />
of the Golden Age, and should feel grateful if he<br />
would veil his profound erudition by massing his<br />
references in an appendix.<br />
<br />
M. M.<br />
<br />
ae<br />
<br />
CORRESPONDENCE.<br />
<br />
—— ———e— —<br />
<br />
“RUTHOR AND EDITOR.”<br />
<br />
Sir,—Mr. F. J. Winbolt is not complimentary !<br />
First he calls me “ An unknown author,” when my<br />
nameis very well known. Every London editor of any<br />
note knows it, I should say, and I have been called<br />
by an eminent living critic “one of the sweetest<br />
singers in Devon now alive”; besides being one of<br />
Mr. H. D. Traill’s “ Poets in the (late) Nineteenth<br />
Century.” Then he implies that 1am “ an obscure<br />
poet,” which again is wide of the mark, as not<br />
only have I had hundreds of reviews in London<br />
and provincial papers, but my poems have been<br />
extensively copied into the Indian, African, San<br />
Franciscan, and Canadian papers. Besides, he will<br />
find my name in “ Who’s Who.”<br />
<br />
Mr. Winbolt misses the point—i.c., that several<br />
(10) of the poems were from the Westminster Gazette,<br />
and that the editor had reviewed all my inferior<br />
books! Besides, other London papers noticed it—<br />
Pall Mall Gazette, The Queen, Field, Pictorial<br />
World, and others.<br />
<br />
Yours truly,<br />
F. B. Dovueton.<br />
<br />
Kirsfield, Torquay.<br />
<br />
P.S.—Again! What did the editor mean by<br />
saying “He had given my Vol. due considera-<br />
tion ’—a future review or none ?<br />
<br />
F. B.D.<br />
So ee<br />
INCOMPETENT REVIEWERS OF BOOKS—A<br />
PROTEST.<br />
<br />
Srr,—There are two abuses which no author—<br />
not even a young one—is obliged to tolerate. — he<br />
first is having his English cavilled at by a reviewer<br />
who has no grammar; and the second is the<br />
misquoting or mutilating of his printed work with<br />
a view to holding hit up to ridicule.<br />
<br />
Case number one. Discussing “The Land of<br />
the Dons,” my recent work on Spain, the Daily<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
78<br />
<br />
and the idea of retribution in the Nibelungen<br />
Lied ; ‘if it disappears in the “ Beast pies and<br />
the didactic works which are characteristic of the<br />
decline of chivalry, in “ Reinke de Vos” and<br />
Brant’s “Narren Schyff,” it is handed on by<br />
Luther and reappears widely in the seventeenth cen-<br />
tury ; if it is blotted out by the Thirty Years War,<br />
it is apparent in the great work of Leibnitz, and<br />
has been paramount in almost every branch of<br />
German literature since his day. The Teutonic<br />
temperament has always been romantic, 10 the true<br />
gense of the word ; the literature which enshrines<br />
its power is the literature of subjectivity and<br />
individualism,<br />
<br />
In surveying the growth of any branch of art,<br />
we cannot fail to notice how many works have<br />
survived on account of their historical value,<br />
although they are esthetically worthless. It is<br />
greatly to Mr. Robertson’s credit that he has never<br />
confused art and archeology, and that, on the<br />
other hand, he has recognised the real beauty of<br />
archaic “ first beginnings, so dim and dewy,” as<br />
Browning rather unhappily called them. Modern<br />
criticism is far too apt to regard anything written<br />
in an obsolete dialect as the lawful prey of the<br />
philologist.<br />
<br />
Sr. Joun Lucas.<br />
<br />
i<br />
<br />
MR. G. A. HENTY.<br />
<br />
a od<br />
<br />
HE death of Mr. G. A. Henty, war corre-<br />
spondent and author, has come rather<br />
suddenly. ‘There is no doubt that he<br />
<br />
supplied a certain type of literature which may<br />
entirely disappear with his death. He combined<br />
adventure with instruction, and wrote on lines<br />
that no modern author seems to touch.<br />
<br />
He was a most prolific writer, and certainly<br />
found amongst the boys to whom he appealed a<br />
class as eager for his productions as he was prolific<br />
in his writings.<br />
<br />
All his books were healthy, strong, and vigorous,<br />
full of life and full of “ go,” and all his writings<br />
advocated the strenuous life which he himself lived.<br />
<br />
It is with much regret we chronicle the sad<br />
event.<br />
<br />
————_+-—<>—_e —___—__<br />
<br />
A LITERARY HISTORY OF PERSIA.*<br />
aes<br />
| Tranis (of whom the Persians and Medes<br />
were the leading tribes) and their language<br />
and literature afford us an example unique<br />
in the annals of nations. The language used by<br />
<br />
* “A Literary History of Persia” (Prof. E. G. Browne).<br />
T. Fisher Unwin.<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
the Achzmanian kings in the sixth century B.c.<br />
would be easily understood by an educated Persian<br />
of to-day, and yet there have been breaches in<br />
their history and literature so wide as would have<br />
drained the life-blood of most other races.<br />
<br />
The Achemanian (Hakhamanish), or Old Persian<br />
period, extended from about 560 B.c. to the over-<br />
throw of the Iranian Empire by Alexander of<br />
Macedon in 330 3.c. The only remains of that<br />
literature are the royal acts aud proclamations<br />
engraven on stone, and they possess the sonorous<br />
dignity and simplicity to which we are accustomed<br />
in edicts, by members of the same dynasty, re-<br />
corded in the Bible. The national cult and<br />
literature was practically suspended for the five<br />
centuries extending to about 200 a.c., only linger-<br />
ing in Magian temples or inaccessible fastnesses<br />
of some reputed descendant of Hakhaman. The<br />
national awakening gave rise to what is known as<br />
the Sassanian period, or Pahlevi literature, which<br />
cannot be disconnected from what some scholars<br />
have defined, artificially, as the Avestic literature.<br />
The Avesta, or sacred books of Zoroastrianism, of<br />
which only about one-fourth are known, have come<br />
down to us in the forms imparted to them between<br />
200 and 350 A.c., but must necessarily include the<br />
oral traditions of the most ancient period, and,<br />
indeed, contains vestiges of practices and super-<br />
stitions from ante-Aryan times, common to all<br />
races. The Avestic literature is only interesting<br />
to him who quarries for the evolution of ideas in<br />
the childhood of the human race. The Pahlevi as<br />
applied to the national resurrection under the<br />
Sassanide dynasty, flourished from about 200—<br />
650 A.c. ; the remains of this literature, although<br />
principally religious (Zoroastrian), contain some<br />
40,000 words of historical romance, which with<br />
other remains, now only extant in Arabic transla-<br />
tions, supplied the subject-matter of that stupen-<br />
dous National Legend moulded by the genius of<br />
Firdusi during the Second Renaissance in about<br />
1000 A.C.<br />
<br />
The Sassanide dynasty fell in 650 A.c., when the ex:<br />
Empire was overwhelmed by the Arabs, and Persia 7 az<br />
became an Arabian province for 300 years, when<br />
Arabic became the language of literature, and<br />
Persian men of genius devoted their talents and<br />
knowledge to the enrichment of Arabic literature<br />
and the glories of Islam.<br />
<br />
The Second Awakening dawned in about<br />
850 A.c., but did not begin to shine until about<br />
950, and then only in distant provinces of the §<br />
Caliphate and, chiefly, under the patronage of §<br />
Turkish adventurers, who nurtured the Persian 3<br />
cult and made themselves more Persian than the<br />
Persians for the purpose of strengthening them-<br />
selves against their suzerains, the Caliphs of Bag-<br />
dad. I must refer the reader to Prof. Browne’s<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
ee<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
&<br />
<br />
ios<br />
ig.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Cowes S<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
book for the many other causes which assisted the<br />
<br />
v0 ? Second Birth. This period, which is undoubtedly<br />
<br />
the Golden Age of Persian literature, flourished<br />
and expanded until the Tartar flood burst and<br />
overwhelmed Asiatic civilisation at the beginning<br />
of the fourteenth century. Prof. Browne, in the<br />
volume before me, stops at 1000 4.c. and promises<br />
us another one on the “ Golden Age,” which will<br />
include such well-known names as Nizami, Sadi,<br />
Omar Khaydm, etc. He has already dealt with<br />
the translation of Tabari’s great commentary into<br />
Persian ; Assadi, the teacher of Firdusi, and in-<br />
ventor of the “ Romance of the Joust” ; Rudaki,<br />
“piquant in expression and fluent in verse,” so<br />
fluent that he is credited with the composition of one<br />
million three hundred thousand verses! The greatest<br />
figure is, of course, Firdusi, with his monumental<br />
Shah name (“Book of the Kings”); this stupendous<br />
National Legend, comprising some 60,000 couplets,<br />
embraces the traditional primeval legends, the<br />
“ Romance of Iamshid”’ (a sort of combination of<br />
Solomon and King Arthur), the historical chronicles<br />
of the Sassanide dynasty and all that is romantic<br />
and tuneful down to his own day, coloured, of<br />
course, with Moslem pigment and showing the<br />
grain of Chaldean imagery which the older Pahlevi<br />
writers had assimilated.<br />
<br />
The third Great Trance extended from the<br />
Mongol conquest to about the beginning of the<br />
last century ; but this Third Renaissance has, so far,<br />
concerned itself with recovering the treasures of<br />
the past, translations of foreign books, and—poetry.<br />
<br />
Their poetical forms, the couplet and quatrain,<br />
are borrowed from the Arabic, and from the ninth<br />
to the present century are dirge-like.<br />
<br />
The philosopher is naturally sad, but the senti-<br />
mental Persian wails in his loves, his hates, and his<br />
adorations. When he can spare time from sobbing<br />
a divine hymn to some petty kingling and patron,<br />
he weeps a melancholy dirge about wine, music,<br />
and woman. His eyes are so dimmed with tears<br />
that his Trinity must be brilliantly coloured and<br />
sensuous ; the “ruby wine,” the “heart-exploding<br />
erash of music,” “the ruby lips,” and so forth.<br />
When a kingling (generally of Turkish extraction)<br />
rhymes, he sighs for “ red-hot blood ” and “ nostril<br />
attacking incarmined cuirass.”<br />
<br />
It may be noted en passant that poets made<br />
money in A.c. 1000, for we are told that Rudaki<br />
possessed 200 slaves (some, let us hope, with<br />
‘ruby lips” and other strongly-coloured physical<br />
attractions) and 100 camel-loads of luggage.<br />
<br />
Prof. Browne holds a brief for Persia and devotes<br />
two-thirds of his book to Arabian literature, which<br />
he attempts to prove to be Persian, because many<br />
Persians, half-Persians, fractional-Persians and<br />
Arabs of “reputed” Persian descent wrote in<br />
Arabic. It would be just as easy to class the<br />
<br />
79<br />
<br />
numerous works published in Latin throughou<br />
Europe during the last two centuries as ‘‘ Roman”<br />
literature. No! Arabian literature and Islam<br />
are no more Persian than the northern Sagas are<br />
the vapourings of a Baboo who has “failed B.A.<br />
Calcutta.”<br />
<br />
I shall look forward to Prof. Browne’s next<br />
volume dealing with the great Poet-Philosophers<br />
of the Golden Age, and should feel grateful if he<br />
would veil his profound erudition by massing his<br />
references in an appendix.<br />
<br />
M. M.<br />
<br />
————<br />
<br />
CORRESPONDENCE.<br />
<br />
—<br />
<br />
“AUTHOR AND EDITOR.”<br />
<br />
Srr,—Mr. F. J. Winbolt is not complimentary !<br />
First he calls me ‘An unknown author,” when my<br />
nameis very wellknown. Every London editor of any<br />
note knows it, I should say, and I have been called<br />
by an eminent living critic “one of the sweetest<br />
singers in Devon now alive ” ; besides being one of<br />
Mr. H. D. Traill’s “ Poets in the (late) Nineteenth<br />
Century.” Then he implies that lam “an obscure<br />
poet,” which again is wide of the mark, as not<br />
only have I had hundreds of reviews in London<br />
and provincial papers, but my poems have been<br />
extensively copied into the Indian, African, San<br />
Franciscan, and Canadian papers. Besides, he will<br />
find my name in “ Who’s Who.”<br />
<br />
Mr. Winbolt misses the point—i.c., that several<br />
(10) of the poems were from the estminster Gazette,<br />
and that the editor had reviewed all my inferior<br />
books! Besides, other London papers noticed it—<br />
Pall Mall Gazette, The Queen, Field, Pictorial<br />
World, and others.<br />
<br />
Yours truly,<br />
F. B. Doveton.<br />
<br />
Kirsfield, Torquay.<br />
<br />
P.S.—Again! What did the editor mean by<br />
saying “He had given my Vol. due considera-<br />
tion ”’—a future review or none?<br />
<br />
EF. B.D.<br />
Sg<br />
INCOMPETENT REVIEWERS OF BOOKS—A<br />
PROTEST.<br />
<br />
Srr,—There are two abuses which no author—<br />
not even a young one—is obliged to tolerate. The<br />
first is having his English cavilled at by a reviewer<br />
who has no grammar; and the second is the<br />
misquoting or mutilating of his printed work with<br />
a view to holding him up to ridicule. 7<br />
<br />
Case number one. Discussing “The Land of<br />
the Dons,” my recent work on Spain, the Daily<br />
80<br />
<br />
Chronicle’s reviewer says, “It would not be fair to.<br />
<br />
make’ these strictures without giving specimens.”<br />
He then takes a sentence of sixteen words from<br />
my book, strikes out two commas, puts in a dash<br />
of his own, and, after completely changing the<br />
emphasis and the sense, prints his own travesty as<br />
my production. :<br />
<br />
‘Case number two. Says Zruth’s reviewer,<br />
“<Tmperative to,’ suggests that Mr. Williams’<br />
profuse and profound knowledge of Spanish has a<br />
little impaired his English.” Yet, a moment later,<br />
Truth’s reviewer produces a grammatical tit-bit of<br />
his own. He asks, “ What voice in literature has<br />
(sic) had the dim millions which in all ages and<br />
countries have lain out of sight like bees in the<br />
darkness of a hive from which we extract the<br />
honey ?” :<br />
<br />
Truth’s ingenious reviewer, therefore, while<br />
straining at the gnats of other people, seems to<br />
digest his own camels with singular complacency.<br />
Possibly, however, I am myself in error. It isa<br />
fact, as Truth is good enough to remind me, that<br />
I have long been absent from England ; but when<br />
I was there, a plural noun, unless my memory 1s<br />
very much at fault, was considered to demand a<br />
plural in its verb. \<br />
<br />
I am quite aware that by far the greater number<br />
of our reviewers of books are intelligent and<br />
<br />
kindly ; but from time to time an exception crops<br />
<br />
up and cries aloud for the pillory. The reviewer<br />
who repunctuates my writings in order to cast<br />
derision on them, imposes upon his readers and<br />
calumniates me. And the “reviewer,” such as<br />
Truth’s, who commits a grammatical blunder for<br />
which a schoolboy of ten would be soundly<br />
whipped, is incompetent to pass judgment on any<br />
book, whether written by me or by anyone else.<br />
<br />
LEONARD WILLIAMS.<br />
<br />
Madrid.<br />
<br />
—1~>—+ —<br />
<br />
THE RUSKIN MEMORIAL SCHEME.<br />
<br />
Dear Sir,—I should be grateful if you will<br />
allow me on behalf of the Ruskin memorial com-<br />
mittee to place before your readers a brief state-<br />
ment respecting the scheme.<br />
<br />
The Ruskin Society of Birmingham has existed<br />
for some seven years to do honour to the great<br />
teacher whose name it bears. It has endeavoured<br />
Lo promote the study of his works and make them<br />
a real power in the land, and it has sought to draw<br />
together men of all parties and creeds, the bond of<br />
union being the common desire to share the<br />
spiritual impetus arising from the study of the<br />
works of one, who preached a true philosophy, and<br />
the recognition that his profound genius was<br />
wholly used for the benefit of mankind.<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
<br />
But since the death of Mr. Ruskin the Society :<br />
decided to be no longer content to exist as an —<br />
academic body only ; and they thought that the<br />
best memorial they could raise in Mr. Ruskin’s<br />
honour was to carry out a practical scheme on the<br />
lines and in the spirit of his teaching.<br />
<br />
It was not difficult to choose such a scheme,<br />
The master’s love for country life is known to his<br />
most casual reader, as also are his magnificent<br />
experiments to foster it ; and the advice which in<br />
his later years he gave to those who sought his<br />
guidance as to practical work was to found a<br />
village institute to promote the higher life of the<br />
community around it.<br />
<br />
The Society resolved to act on this advice, and<br />
they believed that in the district of Bournville, if<br />
they could secure the necessary facilities, they had<br />
a most suitable place for their experiment, for here<br />
some of those social reforms, notably the housin<br />
one, about which (to quote Mr. Frederic Haram<br />
Mr. Ruskin had written long years before the<br />
statutes, conferences and royal commissions of our<br />
own generation, had been carried out. They there-<br />
fore ventured to approach the trustees of the<br />
Bournville Village Trust and sought their co-opera-<br />
tion. With a generosity only comparable to that<br />
shown on many occasions by Mr. Ruskin himself,<br />
the trustees offered to present, for the purposes of<br />
the memorial, a site of upwards of two and a half<br />
acres. Here we are building the memorial, of<br />
which Lord Avebury laid the foundation stone of<br />
the first portion on the 21st inst. That portion<br />
will embrace a library, museum and lecture room,<br />
and rooms for classes in arts and crafts.<br />
<br />
The site is a central one, not only for residents<br />
here, but for a group of thickly populated villages ~<br />
around. We seek to make the memorial building<br />
a centre of effort for the betterment of the con- —<br />
ditions of village life, and to bring to bear upon<br />
that life some of those influences which have now<br />
to be sought for in our large cities.<br />
<br />
We raise this memorial to Mr. Ruskin remember- —<br />
ing that he taught us that “There is no wealth<br />
but life—life including all its powers of love, of<br />
joy, and of admiration,” and that “That country<br />
is the richest which nourishes the greatest number<br />
of noble and happy human beings.” :<br />
<br />
For the completion of our present scheme we<br />
require a further sum of upwards of £3,000, and<br />
we most earnestly appeal to your readers for their<br />
assistance. We shall welcome all letters of enquiry,<br />
and shall be pleased to give any further informa-<br />
tion.<br />
<br />
Yours faithfully,<br />
<br />
J. H. WHITEHOUSE.<br />
Honorary Secretary.<br />
Bournville, Birmingham. | https://historysoa.com/files/original/5/478/1902-12-01-The-Author-13-3.pdf | publications, The Author |