Omeka IDOmeka URLTitleSubjectDescriptionCreatorSourcePublisherDateContributorRightsRelationFormatLanguageTypeIdentifierCoveragePublisher(s)Original FormatOxford Dictionary of National Biography EntryPagesParticipantsPen NamePhysical DimensionsPosition End DatePosition Start DatePosition(s)Publication FrequencyOccupationSexSociety Membership End DateSociety Membership Start DateStart DateSub-Committee End DateSub-Committee Start DateTextToURLVolumeDeathBiographyBirthCommittee End DateCommittee of Management End DateCommittee of Management Start DateCommittee Start DateCommittee(s)Council End DateCouncil Start DateDateBibliographyEnd DateEvent TypeFromImage SourceInteractive TimelineIssueLocationMembersNgram DateNgram TextFilesTags
311https://historysoa.com/items/show/311The Author, Vol. 08 Issue 08 (January 1898)<a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=49&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=%3Cem%3EThe+Author%3C%2Fem%3E%2C+Vol.+08+Issue+08+%28January+1898%29"><em>The Author</em>, Vol. 08 Issue 08 (January 1898)</a><a href="https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015049239455" target="_blank" rel="noopener">https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015049239455</a><a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=51&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Publication">Publication</a>1898-01-01-The-Author-8-8201–228<a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=89&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=8">8</a><a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=76&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=1898-01-01">1898-01-01</a>818980101XI b e Huthot.<br /> {The Organ of the Incorporated Society of Authors. Monthly.)<br /> CONDUCTED BY WALTER BESANT.<br /> Vol. Vin.—No. 8.]<br /> JANUARY i, 1898.<br /> [Price Sixpence.<br /> CONTENTS.<br /> Oeneral Memoranda.<br /> Literary Property—<br /> 1. The Discount (Question<br /> 1. The Law of Author and Publisher<br /> 3. The CoBt of Binding<br /> 4. The Copyright Association<br /> 5. Haddock v. Blackwood<br /> 6. Shelley&#039;s Publisher<br /> Russian Copyright. By Henry Cresswell<br /> New York Letter. By Norman Hapgood<br /> PAOK<br /> ... 201<br /> ... 203<br /> ... 204<br /> ... 205<br /> ... 205<br /> ... 205<br /> ... 207<br /> ... 208<br /> ... 210<br /> Notes and News. By the Editor.<br /> A Chapter of the Past<br /> Mr. Balfour on the Novel<br /> International Relations of Authors<br /> Personal<br /> Correspondence—1. A Young Author&#039;s Grievance<br /> lished Price<br /> Book Talk<br /> Literature in the Periodicals<br /> The Books of the Month<br /> The<br /> p.* cik<br /> ... 211<br /> ... 214<br /> ... 217<br /> ... 217<br /> ... 218<br /> Pnb-<br /> ... 218<br /> ... 219<br /> PUBLICATIONS OP THE SOCIETY.<br /> 1. The Annual Report. That for January 1897 can be had on application to the Secretary.<br /> 2. The Author. A Monthly Journal devoted especially to the protection and maintenance of Literary<br /> Property. Issued to all Members, 6*. 6d. per annum. Back numbers are offered at the<br /> following prices: Vol. I., 10*. 6d. (Bound); Vols. II., III., and IV., 8s. 6d. each (Bound);<br /> Vol. V., 6s. 6d. (Unbound).<br /> 3. Literature and the Pension List. By W. Morris Colles, Barrister-at-Law. (Henry Glaisher,<br /> 95, Strand, W.C.) 3s.<br /> I. The History of the Societe des Gens de Lettres, By s. Squire Sprigqe, late Secretary to<br /> the Society. 1*.<br /> 5. The Cost of Production. In this work specimens are given of the most important forms of type,<br /> size of page, &lt;fcc, with estimates showing what it costs to produce the more common kinds of<br /> books. Henry Glaisher, 95, Strand, W.C. 2s. 6d.<br /> 6. The Various Methods of Publication. By S. Squire Sprioge. In this work, compiled from the<br /> papers in the Society&#039;s offices, the various forms of agreements proposed by Publishers to<br /> Authors are examined, and their meaning carefully explained, with an account of the various<br /> kinds of fraud which have been made possible by the different clauses in their agreements.<br /> Henry Glaisher, 95, Strand, W.C. 3*.<br /> 7. Copyright Law Reform. An Exposition of Lord Monkswell&#039;s Copyright Bill of 1890. With<br /> Extracts from the Report of the Commission of 1878, and an Appendix containing the<br /> Berne Convention and the American Copyright Bill. By J. M. Lely. Eyre and Spottis-<br /> woode. i«. 6d.<br /> 8. The Society Of Authors, A Record of its Action from its Foundation. By Walter Besant<br /> (Chairman of Committee, 1888—1892). i«.<br /> 9. The Contract of Publication in Germany, Austria, Hungary, and Switzerland. By Ernst<br /> Lunge, J.U.D. 2*. 6d.<br /> \<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 200 (#634) ############################################<br /> <br /> 11<br /> AD VER TISEMENTS.<br /> §t)e g&gt;ociete of Jtuffrors (gncotporateb).<br /> PRESIDENT.<br /> GEOBQE MEEEDITH.<br /> COUNCIL.<br /> The Eabl of Desart.<br /> Austin Dobson.<br /> A. Conan Doyle, M.D.<br /> A. W. Duboubo.<br /> Pbof. Michael Foster, P.E.S.<br /> D. W. Fbeshfibld.<br /> Kichabd Garnett, C.B., LL.D.<br /> Edmund Gosse.<br /> H. Rider Haggard.<br /> Thomas Hardy.<br /> Anthony Hope Hawkins.<br /> Jerome K. Jerome.<br /> Eudyard Kipling.<br /> Prof. E. Eat Lankester, F.E.S.<br /> W. E. H. Lecky, P.C., M.P.<br /> J. M. Lely.<br /> Mrs. E. Lynn Linton.<br /> Bev. W. J. Loftie, F.S.A.<br /> Sir A. C. Mackenzie, Mus.Doc.<br /> Prof. J. M. D. Meiklejohn.<br /> Counsel — E. M. Underdown,<br /> Sib Edwin Abnold, K.C.I.E., C.S.I.<br /> J. M. Babbie.<br /> A. W. X Beckett.<br /> Eobebt Bateman.<br /> F. E. Beddabd, F.E.S.<br /> Sib Henby Beronb, E.C.M.G.<br /> Sir Walteb Besant.<br /> Augustine Bibrell, M.P.<br /> Eev. Prof. Bonney, F.E.S.<br /> Eight Hon. James Bryce, M.P.<br /> Eight Hon. Lord Bubghclxre, P.C.<br /> Hall Caine.<br /> Egebton Castle, F.S.A.<br /> P. W. Clayden.<br /> Edwabd Clodd.<br /> w. mobbis colleb.<br /> Hon. John Colliee.<br /> Sib W. Martin Conway.<br /> F. Marion Crawford.<br /> Eight Hon. G. N. Cdbzon, P.C, M.P.<br /> Hon.<br /> Herman C. Meritale.<br /> Eev. C. H. Middleton-Wake.<br /> Sib Lewis Mobbis.<br /> Henry Norman.<br /> Miss E. A. Obmebod.<br /> J. C. Parkinson.<br /> Eight Hon. Lobd Pibbbight, P.C,<br /> F.E.S.<br /> SibFbedebick Pollock, Babt., LL.D.<br /> Walteb Hebbies Pollock.<br /> W. Baptists Scoones.<br /> Miss Flora L. Shaw.<br /> G. E. Sims.<br /> S. Squire Sprigge.<br /> J. J. Stevenson.<br /> Francis Storr.<br /> William Moy Thomas.<br /> H. D. Traill, D.CL.<br /> Mrs. Humphry Wabd.<br /> Miss Chablotte M. Yongi.<br /> Q.C.<br /> <br /> A W. X Beckett.<br /> Sib Walteb Besant.<br /> Egeeton Castle, F.S.A.<br /> W. Mobbis Colles.<br /> COMMITTEE<br /> Chairman-<br /> OF MANAGEMENT.<br /> -H. Eider Haggard.<br /> Sir W. Mabtin Conway.<br /> D. W. Freshfield.<br /> Anthony Hope Hawkins.<br /> J. M. Lely.<br /> Sir A. C. Mackenzie, Mus.Doc.<br /> Henby Norman.<br /> Fjiancis Storr.<br /> COMMITTEES.<br /> MUSIC.<br /> C. Villibrs Stanford, Mas.D. (Chairman).<br /> Jacques Blumenthal.<br /> SUB<br /> ART.<br /> Hon. John Collier (Chairman).<br /> Sib W. Martin Conway.<br /> M. H. Spielmann.<br /> f Field, Eoscoe, and Co., Lincoln&#039;s Inn Fields.<br /> \, G. Hebbebt Thbino, B.A., 4, Portugal-street. Secretary—G. Herbert Tubing, B.A. OFFICES: 4, Pobtuoal Stbeet, Lincoln&#039;s Inn Fields, W.C<br /> DEAMA.<br /> Henry Arthur Jones (Chairman).<br /> A. W. X Beckett.<br /> Edward Eose.<br /> Solicitors<br /> IP. WATT &lt;Sc SO¥,<br /> LITERARY AGENTS,<br /> Formerly of 2, PATERNOSTER SUUARE,<br /> Have now removed to<br /> HASTINGS HOUSE, NORFOLK STREET, STRAND,<br /> LONDON, W.C.<br /> THE TEMPLE TYPEWRITING OFFICE.<br /> YPEWEITING EXCEPTIONALLY ACCURATE. Moderate prioes. Duplicates of Circulars by the latest<br /> process.<br /> S OPINIONS OF CLIENTS— Distinguished Author:—&quot;The most beautiful typing I have ever seen.&quot; Lady op Titlb:—&quot;The<br /> j work was very well aud clearly done.&quot; Provincial Editor:—&quot;Many thanks for the spotless neatnesB and beautiful accuracy.&quot;<br /> MISS &amp;KNTEY, KLDON CHAMBERS, 30, FLEET STREET, E.C.<br /> T<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 201 (#635) ############################################<br /> <br /> TLhe Hutbor,<br /> (The Organ of the Incorporated Society of Authors. Monthly.)<br /> CONDUCTED BY WALTER BESANT.<br /> Vol. VIII.—No. 8.] JANUARY i, 1898. [Pbick Sixpence.<br /> For the Opinions expressed in papers that are<br /> signed or initialled the Authors alone are<br /> responsible. None of the papers or para-<br /> graphs must be taken as expressing the<br /> collective opinions of the Committee unless<br /> they are officially signed by G. Herbert<br /> Thring, Sec.<br /> THE Secretary of the Society begs to give notioe that all<br /> remittances are acknowledged by return of post, and<br /> requests that all members not receiving an answer to<br /> important communications within two days will write to him<br /> without delay. All remittances should be crossed Union<br /> Bank of London, Chancery-lane, or be Bent by registered<br /> letter only.<br /> Communications and letters are invited by the Editor on<br /> all subjects conneoted with literature, but on no other sub-<br /> jects whatever. Articles which cannot be accepted are<br /> returned if stamps for the purpose accompany the MSS.<br /> GENERAL MEMORANDA.<br /> IT^OR some years it has been the praotice to insert, in<br /> J every number of The Author, certain &quot; General Con-<br /> siderations,&quot; Warnings, Notices, &amp;o., for the guidance<br /> of the reader. It has been objected as regards these<br /> warnings that the tricks or frauds against which they are<br /> directed cannot all be guarded against, for obvious reasons.<br /> It is, however, well that they should be borne in mind, and<br /> if any publisher refuses a clause of precaution he simply<br /> reveals his true character, and should be left to carry on<br /> his business in his own way.<br /> Let us, however, draw up a few of the rules to be<br /> observed in an agreement. There are three methods of<br /> dealing with literary property:—<br /> I. That of selling it outright.<br /> This is in some respects the most satisfactory, if a proper<br /> price can be obtained. But the transaction should be<br /> managed by a competent agent.<br /> II. A profit-sharing agreement.<br /> In this case the following rules should be attended to:<br /> (1.) Not to sign any agreement in which the cost of pro-<br /> duction forms a part.<br /> (2.) Not to give the publisher the power of putting the<br /> profits into his own pooket by charging for advertisements<br /> VOL. Till.<br /> in his own organs: or by charging exchange advertise-<br /> ments.<br /> (3.) Not to allow a special charge for &quot; office expenses,&quot;<br /> unless the same allowance is made to the author.<br /> (4.) Not to give up American, Colonial, or Continental<br /> rights.<br /> (5.) Not to give up serial or translation rights.<br /> (6.) Not to bind yourself for future work to any publisher.<br /> As well bind yourself for the future to any one solicitor or<br /> doctor!<br /> (7.) To stamp the agreement,<br /> ni. The royalty system.<br /> In this system, which has opened the door to a most<br /> amazing amount of overreaching and trading on the<br /> author&#039;s ignorance, it is above all things neoessary to know<br /> what the proposed royalty means to both sides. It is now<br /> possible for an author to ascertain approximately and very<br /> nearly the truth. From time to time the very important<br /> figures connected with royalties are published in The Author.<br /> Readers can also work out the figures themselves from the<br /> &quot;Cost of Production.&quot; Let no one, not even the youngest<br /> writer, sign a royalty agreement without finding out what<br /> it gives the publisher as well as himself.<br /> It has been objected that these precautions presuppose a<br /> great success for the book, and that very few books indeed<br /> attain to this great success. That is quite true: but there is<br /> always this uncertainty of literary property that, although<br /> the works of a great many authors carry with them no risk<br /> at all, and although of a great many it is known within a few<br /> oopies what will be their minimum circulation, it is not<br /> known what will be their maximum. Therefore every<br /> author, for every book, should arrange on the ohanoe of a<br /> success which will not, probably, come at all; but which<br /> may come.<br /> The four points whioh the Society has always demanded<br /> from the outset are:—<br /> (1.) That both sides shall know what an agreement<br /> means.<br /> (2.) The inspection of those account books which belong<br /> to the author. We are advised that this is a right, in the<br /> nature of a common law right, which cannot be denied or<br /> withheld.<br /> (3.) That there shall be no secret profits.<br /> (4.) That nothing shall be charged whioh has not been<br /> actually paid—for instance, that there shall be no oharge for<br /> advertisements in the publisher&#039;s own organs and none for<br /> exchanged advertisements and that all discounts shall be<br /> duly entered.<br /> If these points are carefully looked after, the author may<br /> rest pretty well assured that he is in right hands. At the<br /> same time he will do well to send his agreement to the<br /> secretary before he signs it.<br /> a 2<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 202 (#636) ############################################<br /> <br /> 202 THE AUTHOR.<br /> HOW TO USE THE SOCIETY.<br /> I. &quot;T7WERY member has a right to ask for and to receive<br /> Fj advioe upon his agreements, his ohoioe of a pub-<br /> lisher, or any dispute arising in the conduct of his<br /> business or the administration of his property. If the advice<br /> sought is such as can be given best by a solicitor, the member<br /> has a right to an opinion from the Society&#039;s solicitors. If the<br /> case ia such that Counsel&#039;s opinion is desirable, the Com-<br /> mittee will obtain for him Counsel&#039;s opinion. All this<br /> without any cost to the member.<br /> 2. Eemember that questions connected with oopyright<br /> and publisher&#039;s agreements do not generally fall within the<br /> experience of ordinary solicitors. Therefore, do not soruple<br /> to use the Sooiety first—our solicitors are continually<br /> engaged upon suoh questions for us.<br /> 3. Send to the office oopies of past agreements and past<br /> accounts with the loan of the bookB represented. This is in<br /> order to ascertain what has been the nature of your agree-<br /> ments, and the results to author and publisher respectively<br /> so far. The Secretary will always be glad to have any<br /> agreements, new or old, for inspection and note. The infor-<br /> mation thus obtained may prove invaluable.<br /> 4. If the examination of your previous business trans-<br /> actions by the Secretary proves unfavourable, you should<br /> take advice as to a ohange of publishers.<br /> 5. Before signing any agreement whatever, send the pro-<br /> posed document to the Society for examination.<br /> 6. The Society is acquainted with the methods, and—in<br /> the case of fraudulent houses—the tricks of every publish-<br /> ing firm in the country.<br /> 7. Remember always that in belonging to the Sooiety you<br /> are fighting the battles of other writers, even if you are<br /> reaping no benefit to yourself, and that you are advancing<br /> the best interests of literature in promoting the indepen-<br /> dence of the writer.<br /> 8. Send to the Editor of The Author notes of everything<br /> important to literature that you may hear or meet with.<br /> 9. The committee have now arranged for the reception of<br /> members&#039; agreements and their preservation in a fireproof<br /> safe. The agreements will, of course, be regarded as con-<br /> fidential documents to be read only by the Secretary, who<br /> will keep the key of the safe. The Society now offers:—(1)<br /> To read and advise upon agreements and publishers. (2) To<br /> stamp agreements in readiness for a possible action upon<br /> them. (3) To keep agreements. (4) To enforce payments<br /> due according to agreements.<br /> THE AUTHORS&#039; SYNDICATE.<br /> MEMBERS are informed:<br /> 1. That the Authors&#039; Syndicate takes charge of<br /> the business of members of the Society. That it<br /> submits MSS. to publishers and editors, concludes agree-<br /> ments, examines, passes, and collects accounts, and, gene-<br /> rally, relieves members of the trouble of managing business<br /> details.<br /> 2. That the terms upon which its services oan be secured<br /> will be forwarded upon detailed application.<br /> 3. That the Authors&#039; Syndicate works only for those<br /> members of the Society whose work possesses a market<br /> value.<br /> 4. That the Syndicate can only undertake any negotiations<br /> whatever on the distinct understanding that those negotia-<br /> tions are placed exclusively in its hands, and that all<br /> communications relating thereto are referred to it.<br /> 5. That clients can only be seen by the Director by<br /> appointment, and that, when possible, at least two days&#039;<br /> notice should be given.<br /> 6. That every attempt is made to deal with all communi-<br /> cations promptly. That Btamps should, in all cases, be sent<br /> to defray postage.<br /> 7. That the Authors&#039; Syndicate does not invite MSS.<br /> without previous correspondence; does not hold itself<br /> responsible for MSS. forwarded without notice; and that<br /> in all cases MSS. must be accompanied by stamps to defray<br /> postage.<br /> 8. That the Syndicate undertakes arrangements for<br /> lectures by some of the leading members of the Society;<br /> that it has a &quot;Transfer Department&quot; for the sale and<br /> purchase of journals and periodicals; and that a &quot; Register<br /> of Wants and Wanted&quot; is open. Members are invited to<br /> communicate their requirements to the Manager.<br /> There is an Honorary Advisory Committee, whose services<br /> will be called upon in any case of dispute or difficulty. It<br /> is perhaps necessary to state that the members of the<br /> Advisory Committee have no pecuniary interest whatever in<br /> the Syndicate.<br /> NOTICES.<br /> THE Editor of The Author begs to remind members of the<br /> Society that, although the paper is sent to them free<br /> of charge, the cost of producing it would be a very<br /> heavy charge on the resources of the Society if a great<br /> many members did not forward to the Seoretary the modest<br /> 6s. 6d. subscription for the year.<br /> The Editor ia always glad to receive short papers and<br /> communications on all subjects oonnected with literature<br /> from members and others. Nothing can do more good to<br /> the Society than to make The Author complete, attractive,<br /> and interesting. Will those who are willing to aid in this<br /> work send their names and the special subjects on which<br /> they are willing to write P<br /> Communications for The Author should reach the Editor<br /> not later than the 21st of each month.<br /> All persons engaged in literary work of any kind, whether<br /> members of the Society or not, are invited to oommunioate<br /> to the Editor any points connected with their work which<br /> it would be advisable in the general interest to publish.<br /> Members and others who wish their MSS. read are<br /> requested not to send them to the Office without previously<br /> communicating with the Seoretary. The utmost practicable<br /> despatch is aimed at, and MSS. are read in the order in<br /> which they are received. It must also be distinctly under-<br /> stood that the Sooiety does not, under any circumstances,<br /> undertake the publication of MSS.<br /> The Authors&#039; Club is now open in its new premises, at<br /> 3, Whitehall-court, Charing Cross. Address the Secretary<br /> for information, rules of admission, &amp;o.<br /> Will members take the trouble to ascertain whether they<br /> have paid their subscriptions for the year P If they will do<br /> this, and remit the amount, if still unpaid, or a banker&#039;s<br /> order, it will greatly assist the Secretary, and save him the<br /> trouble of sending out a reminder.<br /> Members are most earnestly entreated to attend to the<br /> following warning. It is a most foolish and may be a<br /> most disastrous thing to enter into an agreement binding<br /> for a term of years. Let them ask themselves if they<br /> would give a solicitor the collection of their rents for five<br /> years to oome, whatever his conduct, whether he was honest<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 203 (#637) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> 203<br /> or dishonest f Of course they would not. Why then<br /> hesitate for a moment when they are asked to sign them-<br /> selves into literary bondage for throe or five years P<br /> Those who possess the &quot;Cost of Production&quot; are<br /> requested to note that the cost of binding has advanced 15<br /> per cent. This means, for those who do not like the trouble<br /> of &quot;doing sums,&quot; the addition of three shillings in the<br /> pound on this head. In other words, if the oost of binding<br /> is set down in onr book at eight pounds, to this must now be<br /> added twenty-four shillings more, so that it now stands<br /> at JE9 48. The figures in our book are as near the exact<br /> truth as can be procured; but a printer&#039;s, or a binder&#039;s,<br /> bill is so elaatio a thing that nothing more exact can be<br /> arrived at.<br /> Some remarks have been made upon the amount charged<br /> in the &quot; Cost of Production&quot; for advertising. Of course, we<br /> have not included any Hums whioh may be charged for<br /> inserting advertisements in the publisher&#039;s own magazines,<br /> or in other magazines by exchange. As agreements too<br /> often go, there iB nothing to prevent the publisher from<br /> sweeping the whole profits of a book into his own pocket,<br /> by inserting any number of advertisements in his own<br /> magazines, and by exchanging with others. Some there are<br /> who call this a form of frand; it is not known what those<br /> who practise this method of swelling their own profits call it.<br /> LITERARY PROPERTY.<br /> I.—The Discount Question.<br /> 1.<br /> THE Publishers&#039; Association having con-<br /> sidered the report of the Sub-Committee of<br /> the Society of Authors, published in The<br /> Author last month, has forwarded the following<br /> letters, which explain themselves :—<br /> &quot;H. Eider Haggard, Esq., Society of Authors.<br /> &quot;Dec. 9, 1897.<br /> &quot;My dear Haggard,—I laid the report of your<br /> Society on the discount question before our<br /> council to-day, and the following resolution was<br /> passed: &#039;That in view of the report of the<br /> Society of Authors, the council feel that it is not<br /> possible for them to proceed with the proposed<br /> scheme in its present form, but they are not<br /> without hope that some other means of meeting<br /> the difficulty may be suggested.&#039; I was requested<br /> to forward a copy of this resolution to you, and<br /> also to the Associated Booksellers.—I am, yours<br /> faithfully,<br /> &quot;(Signed) Chables James Longman,<br /> &quot;President.&quot;<br /> 11.<br /> &quot;T. Burleigh, Esq., Hon. Sec. Associated<br /> Booksellers, 370, Oxford-street, W.<br /> &quot;Dec. 9, 1897.<br /> &quot;Dear Mr. Burleigh,—Tou have no doubt seen<br /> the report of the Society of Authors on the<br /> discount question. It was considered by the<br /> council of the Publishers&#039; Association to-day,<br /> and I need hardly inform you that they greatly<br /> regret the authors&#039; decision, for though the<br /> council were conscious of many difficulties in the<br /> way of carrying out the scheme, they were pre-<br /> pared to give it a fair and loyal trial if the co-<br /> operation of the Authors&#039; Society had been<br /> secured. Although the present effort must be<br /> considered to have failed, the council hope that<br /> all who are interested in the circulation of books<br /> will continue to give the matter full and careful<br /> consideration in the endeavour to discover some<br /> practicable scheme. The following resolution was<br /> carried unanimously at to-day&#039;s meeting: &#039;That<br /> in view of the report of the Society of Authors,<br /> the council feel that it is not possible for them to<br /> proceed with the proposed scheme in its present<br /> form, but they are not without hope that some<br /> other means of meeting the difficulty may be<br /> suggested.&#039;—I am, yours faithfully,<br /> &quot;Wm. Poulten, Secretary.&quot;<br /> in.<br /> Mr. Burleigh, hon. secretary of the Associated<br /> Booksellers, has addressed the following letter to<br /> the secretary of the Publishers&#039; Association:—<br /> 370, Oxford-street, London, W.<br /> Dec. 13,1897.<br /> Dear Mr. Poulten,—I beg to acknowledge the<br /> receipt of your letter of the 9th inst., with the<br /> copy of resolution of the Publishers&#039; Council.<br /> The disappointing condition of affairs will be<br /> considered at our next council meeting early in<br /> January.<br /> I trust the council and booksellers generally<br /> will support me in the determination to continue<br /> the struggle, until literature of a higher class can<br /> be profitably placed upon our shelves, and many<br /> authors, now smothered, obtain a better chance<br /> with the public.—Yours faithfully,<br /> Thomas Burleigh.<br /> Hon. Sec. Associated Booksellers.<br /> W. Poulten, Esq., Secretary,<br /> The Pubhshers&#039; Association.<br /> IV.<br /> The following letters also explain themselves.<br /> The first is addressed to the secretary:—<br /> Dec. 5, 1897.<br /> Deab Sib,—I have belonged to the Society of<br /> Authors for some years, and I am much indebted<br /> to it for valuable advice given me on one occasion<br /> when I was in a position of great difficulty. But<br /> I so entirely disagree with the Report of the Sub-<br /> committee on the Discount Question, and am so<br /> anxious to dissociate myself from it, that I am<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 204 (#638) ############################################<br /> <br /> 204<br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> forced to resign my membership of the Society, as<br /> I now do.<br /> There is hardly any kind of business in which<br /> the evils of reckless competition have not been<br /> felt during the la&gt;t half century, and remedies of<br /> various kinds have been sought after and adopted<br /> with success in many trades. To take their stand,<br /> as the Committee do, on the formulae which were<br /> current in 1852 about the &quot; freedom which ought<br /> to prevail in commercial transactions,&quot; seems to<br /> me an absurd anachronism.<br /> Had it been clear that the Committee had<br /> accepted Mr. Longman&#039;s offer, and had met with<br /> the publishers&#039; sub-committee in conference on the<br /> subject, I should attach more importance to their<br /> contention that the proposed organisation could<br /> not be carried out.<br /> I am sending a copy of this letter to the presi-<br /> dent of the Publishers&#039; Association.—I remain,<br /> yours sincerely,<br /> (Signed) Wm. Cunningham.<br /> v.<br /> Dec. 6, 1897.<br /> The Rev. W. Cunningham.—Dear Sir,—I am<br /> in receipt of your letter, and have removed your<br /> name from the books of the Society for the reason<br /> that you disapprove of the Report of the Com-<br /> mittee on the Discount Question. The Committee<br /> did not take their stand &quot;on the formute which<br /> were current in 1852.&quot; They have had a great<br /> amount of evidence before them, and it is on this<br /> evidence that they have come to draw their present<br /> conclusions. We did not meet the sub-committee<br /> of the publishers, because we had already the<br /> publishers&#039; views in the fullest manner before us<br /> from the documents we had collected. We did,<br /> however, as you will see by the Report, have the<br /> views of booksellers of all classes, who surely are<br /> more concerned in the affair than the publishers.<br /> I must apologise, however, for going into these<br /> details now.—Tours truly,<br /> G. Herbert Thring.<br /> II.—The Law of Author and Publisher.<br /> An order was made last week by the Lord<br /> Chief Justice of considerable interest to authors<br /> and the publishing trade. It related to the deal-<br /> ing with copies of books remaining unsold upon<br /> the bankruptcy of a publisher. The decision<br /> come to was in the nature of a compromise, and<br /> lacks the authority of a judgment; but it is<br /> probable that the case may become a precedent,<br /> and the facts have therefore a special interest to<br /> those connected with literature. The plaintiff<br /> was Mr. Frederick Wicks, and the defendants<br /> Remington and Co. (Limited), Mr. Sidney Cronk,<br /> the liquidator of the company, and Mr. John<br /> Grant Macqueen, the purchaser of Remington&#039;s<br /> business. The company and its predecessors,<br /> Eden, Remington, and Co., had published and<br /> sold three editions of &quot;The Veiled Hand,&quot; of<br /> which Mr. Wicks is the author, and had printed<br /> a fourth edition of 5000 copies. Between 2000<br /> and 3000 of these remained unsold when the<br /> company went into liquidation. The company<br /> had also printed 5000 of &quot;The Broadmoor<br /> Patient&quot; and 5000 of &quot; The Infant,&quot; by the same<br /> author, and had sold about 2000 of each. The<br /> defendant Macqueen therefore acquired posses-<br /> sion of some 8000 copies of the three works. The<br /> agreements made by Mr. Wicks with Messrs.<br /> Remington were agreements to print and publish<br /> only, and in each case the author retained the<br /> copyright. It is part of the established law that<br /> agreements of this kind are not assignable with-<br /> out the consent of the owner of the copyright,<br /> and that they do not pass to an assignee in bank-<br /> ruptcy nor to a liquidator of a company. Mr.<br /> Cronk, however, assigned the agreements, and<br /> sold the stock to Mr. Macqueen, who gave him an<br /> indemnity for all the consequences of this act. The<br /> correspondence showed that Mr. Wicks en-<br /> deavoured to procure from Mr. Macqueen some<br /> acknowledgment of his rights and some arrange-<br /> ment for the continuance of the sales; but his<br /> title to any participation in the proceeds of the<br /> sale was denied in the first instance by both<br /> parties. Later an endeavour to make an arrange-<br /> ment was promised by Mr. Macqueen, but Mr.<br /> Wicks was requested to wait until full considera-<br /> tion could be given to the matter. A few months<br /> later, nothing having been arranged, Mr. Wicks<br /> found his books on sale at Messrs Smith and<br /> Son&#039;s bookstalls at a slightly reduced price. He<br /> ascertained that some 1200 copies had been<br /> bought and paid for three months before without<br /> any consent on his part, and when he applied for<br /> an account it was refused. Some months after<br /> he was offered a third of the royalty stipulated by<br /> the original agreement on a part of the sales only,<br /> and the court was applied to. Pressure being<br /> put upon the parties by the Lord Chief Justice<br /> to make an arrangement, it was ultimately decided<br /> to take an order requiring Mr. Macqueen to bind<br /> the books to the satisfaction of Mr. Wicks, to<br /> sell them at prices agreed to by Mr. Wicks, to<br /> expend a reasonable amount in advertising the<br /> books, which amount would be fixed by a third<br /> person, and to pay to Mr. Wicks the amount<br /> acknowledged in the account rendered, and a<br /> royalty on future sales as stipulated in the origi-<br /> nal agreement respecting &quot;The Veiled Hand.&quot;<br /> This agreement fixed the royalties at 1*. lod. per<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 205 (#639) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> 205<br /> copy on the 10s. 6d. edition, and 9^. on the<br /> 3s. 6d. edition, to be increased to 2*. 3d. and io\d.<br /> respectively after the sale of 5000, which has been<br /> the case with &quot;The Veiled Hand.&quot; The liquida-<br /> tor of the company, who, the Lord Chief Justice<br /> said, had assigned agreements that he had no<br /> power to assign, was ordered to leave in the hands<br /> of .the plaintiff five guineas paid into court.—The<br /> Athenmum, Dec. 25.<br /> m.—The Cost of Binding.<br /> Exception has been taken to our estimate of t,d.<br /> as the cost of plain binding. We have called<br /> attention to an increase in the cost of binding.<br /> This increase seems to belong to small orders.<br /> Those who have sufficient business to give large<br /> orders for cloth can still bind very cheaply. The<br /> following taken from a publisher&#039;s account shows<br /> what is actually paid for binding. There were<br /> 1328 copies bound, viz.:—<br /> 262, in paper, at id.<br /> 150 at 31*. 6d. a hundred, or $zd. a volume.<br /> 916 at 38s. 6d. the hundred, or $\d. a volume.<br /> The average amounts to 3^m«?.—i.e., a little<br /> over 3|rf.<br /> It is pleasant, after hearing frantic declarations<br /> that the work cannot be done at the price, to<br /> receive actual accounts showing that the work has<br /> been done at the price.<br /> IV.—Thk Copyeight Association.<br /> A service of plate was presented to Mr. Daldy<br /> on Dec. 9 by the Copyright Association in recog-<br /> nition of his services in the cause of copyright.<br /> The association, as is well known, has been in<br /> existence a long time. It consists of a few<br /> authors and some publishers: of late it has been<br /> working with the Society. It is now very much<br /> to be desired that the authors who are in the<br /> association should remember that the Society has<br /> done a great deal of solid work in connection with<br /> * copyright, and that a continuance of their<br /> membership might lead to complications with<br /> the Society, which should have the first claim<br /> upon their support.<br /> V.—Muddock v. Blackwood.<br /> (Before Mr. Justice Kekewich.)<br /> This was a copyright case of some importance.<br /> Two copyright actions had been brought, one<br /> having been commenced in the Chancery Division<br /> and the other in the Queen&#039;s Bench Division, but<br /> they had since been consolidated by an order in<br /> the Chancery action. The writ in the Chancery<br /> action was issued on Nov. 24, 1896, by the plain-<br /> tiff, Mr. James Edward Muddock, the author or<br /> and the registered proprietor of the copyright in<br /> a work called &quot;A Wingless Angel,&quot; against Mr.<br /> James Blackwood, a publisher, and a firm of pub-<br /> lishers called J. Blackwood and Co., claiming an<br /> injunction, an account of profits, and delivery-up<br /> of copies in respect of a work published by the<br /> defendants under the same title, and being, in<br /> fact, a reprint of the plaintiff&#039;s work. On Dec. 10<br /> the principal defendant, Mr. James Blackwood,<br /> wrote to the plaintiff offering to submit to an in-<br /> junction, to pay =£10 as damages, to deliver up all<br /> copies in his hands, and to pay the plaintiff&#039;s<br /> costs as between party and party. The plaintiff,<br /> however, refused the offer, and on Dec. 18 made a<br /> demand in writing on the defendants under sect.<br /> 23 of the Copyright Act, 1842 (5 &amp; 6 Vict. c. 45),<br /> for all copies of the book unlawfully printed or<br /> imported; and then, on Dec. 23, 1896, issued the<br /> writ in the Queen&#039;s Bench action, claiming<br /> damages for wrongful conversion of copies of the<br /> book unlawfully printed without the consent of<br /> the plaintiff. Then he delivered a statement of<br /> claim in that action, and on Feb. 1,1897, obtained<br /> an order in chambers in that action transferring<br /> it to the Chancery Division, but expressly reserv-<br /> ing the costs of that action to be dealt with by<br /> the Chancery judge at the trial. On Feb. 8 Mr.<br /> Justice Kekewich, on the plaintiff&#039;s application,<br /> made an order that the two actions should be<br /> consolidated and proceed as one action, and in the<br /> consolidated action the plaintiff delivered a state-<br /> ment of claim, claiming an injunction, delivery up<br /> of all copies in the defendants&#039; possession, an<br /> account of profits made by the defendants by the<br /> infringement, or, alternatively, damages in respect<br /> of the infringement, with an inquiry as to the<br /> amount thereof, £2 50 damages for conversion as<br /> in an action of trover, and costs. It appeared<br /> that the plaintiff had not published any copies of<br /> his work since 1875; that in 1886 the defendant<br /> Mr. James Blackwood bought the stereotyped<br /> plates of the work at an auction sale at Messrs.<br /> Puttick and Simpson&#039;s, of Leicester-square, and<br /> had used them without demur until last year. An<br /> account furnished by the defendant showed that<br /> in 1886 he sold 1010 copies at a total price of<br /> ■£38 199. g^d., and at a profit of £8 lot. 4$&lt;Z.;<br /> also that in 1896 he sold 29 copies at a profit of<br /> £1 4«. 2d., his total profits thus amounting to<br /> =£9 148. 6\d. -. also that, after taking into account<br /> the purchase of the plates and repairs, amounting<br /> altogether to &lt;£io, there had been a net loss on<br /> production and sale of the book of 58. $\d.<br /> Warrington, Q.C., and J. G. Joseph for the<br /> plaintiff, relied on sect. 23 of the Copyright Act,<br /> 1842 (5 &amp; 6 Vict. c. 45) (Scrutton on Copyright,<br /> p. 246), which provides that &quot;all copies of any<br /> book wherein there shall be copyright, and of<br /> which entry shall have been made in the said<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 206 (#640) ############################################<br /> <br /> 206<br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> registry book, and which shall have been unlaw-<br /> fully printed or imported without the consent of<br /> the registered proprietor of such copyright, in<br /> writing under his hand first obtained, shall be<br /> deemed to be the property of the proprietor of<br /> such copyright, and who shall be registered as<br /> such, and such registered proprietor shall, after<br /> demand thereof in writing, be entitled to sue for<br /> and recover the same, or damages for the deten-<br /> tion thereof, in an action of detinue, from any<br /> party who shall detain the same, or to sue for and<br /> recover damages for the conversion thereof in an<br /> action for trover.&quot;<br /> Renshaw, Q.C. and J. W. Baines, for the<br /> defendant Blackwood, referred to sect. 15, which<br /> enacts that &quot; if any person shall, in any part of<br /> the British dominions, after the passing of this<br /> Act, print or cause to be printed, either for sale<br /> or exportation, any book in which there shall be<br /> subsisting copyright, without the consent in<br /> writing of the proprietor thereof, or shall import<br /> for sale or hire any such book so having been<br /> unlawfully printed from paits beyond the sea, or,<br /> knowing such book to have been so unlawfully<br /> printed or imported, shall sell, publish, or expose<br /> for sale or hire, or cause to be sold, published,<br /> or exposed for sale or hire, or shall have in his<br /> possession, for sale or hire, any such book so un-<br /> lawfully printed or imported, without such con-<br /> sent as aforesaid, such offender shall be liable to a<br /> special action on the case at the suit of the pro-<br /> prietor of such copyright, to be brought in any<br /> court of record in that part of the British<br /> dominions in which the offence shall be com-<br /> mitted.&quot; They submitted that the two sections<br /> were inconsistent, and that the plaintiff was wrong<br /> in claiming, as he had done, both in detinue and<br /> in trover, for, under sect. 23 he must select the<br /> one mode of action or the other, not both. As to<br /> the alleged profits made by the defendant, when<br /> the price of the plates and the usual trade dis-<br /> count were taken into consideration, it was clear<br /> there could be no profits. [Mr. Justice Kbke-<br /> wich.—I should think wingless angels would<br /> require some discount to make them fly. (Laugh-<br /> ter.)] The plaintiff had resorted to a &quot;multi-<br /> plicity&quot; of actions, when he might have sought<br /> relief by one action. The action had been, in<br /> fact, continued without any necessity, the defen-<br /> dant having offered all the plaintiff could justly<br /> claim.<br /> Mr. Justice Kkkkwich said it was somewhat<br /> strange that in the end of the year 1897 he should<br /> be called upon for the first time to say what was<br /> the meaning of sect. 23 of the Act 5 &amp; 6 Vict,<br /> c. 45—whether the remedy given by that section<br /> was inconsistent with that given by sect. 15; but<br /> he supposed he was really called upon to do that<br /> because no counsel had suggested to him that<br /> there was any decision; and, moreover, the book<br /> on copyright which was in the bands of the pro-<br /> fession, and to which reference was usually made<br /> on all questions of copyright, did not give any<br /> case on the subject. Two points had been raised.<br /> First, it was said on behalf of the defendant<br /> that sect. 15 gave the proprietor of copyright a<br /> remedy by special action on the case: that that<br /> meant that this was the remedy which he was<br /> intended to pursue, except so far as his remedies<br /> at common law were not interfered with; that<br /> the offender under sect. 23 was a different person<br /> to the offender under sect. 15; that under sect. 15<br /> he was dealing with a person who had &quot; unlaw-<br /> fully printed or imported &quot; a book in which there<br /> was a subsisting copyright, and that the other<br /> Kect., 23, provided a remedy against the accidental<br /> possessor of the infringing book, so as to give a<br /> right of action against that accidental possessor<br /> independently of his being otherwise a wrong-<br /> doer. That might b-j the right view, but the<br /> language of the sections was not sufficiently clear<br /> to compel his Lordship to adopt it. No doubt<br /> there were words in sect. 15 which were not to be<br /> found in sect. 23, and he was unable to suggest<br /> why the two sections should not have been put<br /> into one, and why they should have been sepa-<br /> rated as they were. But, on the other hand, he<br /> did not see why, because the proprietor of copy-<br /> right had a remedy under sect. 15 against the<br /> wrong-doer, he could not sue that wrong-doer, if<br /> so advised, under sect. 23. Then the next point<br /> was this. The book being vested in the pro-<br /> prietor of the copyright, sect. 23 said he &quot;shall,<br /> after demand in writing, be entitled to sue for<br /> and recover the same or damages for the deten-<br /> tion thereof, in an action of detinue, from any<br /> party who shall detain the same, or to sue for and<br /> recover damages for the conversion thereof in an<br /> action of trover.&quot; That provided an alternative<br /> remedy; and the argument on behalf of the<br /> defendant was that the plaintiff claiming to sue •<br /> under that section must elect to sue either in<br /> detinue or in trover, and could not sue in both.<br /> That was an easier point than the other.<br /> There was an alternative remedy. It would,<br /> in his Lordship&#039;s opinion, be adopting an<br /> extremely narrow construction of the Act to say<br /> that the proprietor of the copyright in a book,<br /> knowing that a person had a certain number of<br /> copies in his hands and that he had sold other<br /> copies, could not sue that person in respect of<br /> the copies that he had detained, and also in<br /> respect of those that he had converted to his own<br /> jise. It seemed tolerably plain upon the Act<br /> itself, and in accordance with what was the appa-<br /> rent intention of the Legislature, that the two<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 207 (#641) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> 207<br /> actions might be reduced to one action distributed<br /> in the way he had suggested—that is to say, the<br /> plaintiff might sue in detinue in respect of the<br /> copies the defendant had detained, and might<br /> sue in trover in respect of the copies he had<br /> sold and converted to his own use. Having got<br /> so far, the plaintiff in the present case, who was<br /> the proprietor of the registered copyright in a<br /> book called &quot;A Wingless Angel,&quot; was entitled to<br /> sue under sect. 23, and to sue the defendant not-<br /> withstanding that he might have brought what<br /> was called &quot; a special action on the case &quot; under<br /> sect. 15; and he might have exercised his privi-<br /> lege of bringing an action on the case by pro-<br /> ceeding in the Chancery Division. What, then,<br /> was the plaintiff&#039;s remedy? In his Lordship&#039;s<br /> opinion he was entitled to the delivery-up on<br /> oath of all books in the possession of the<br /> defendant—that is to say, delivery-up, and also<br /> damages as in an action of trover for the books<br /> the defendant had sold. The defendant had sold<br /> twice. In 1886 he sold 1010 copies and realised<br /> .£38 19*. g^d., or, say, .£39, making a profit of<br /> £8 10s. 4%d.; and then he published the book<br /> again in 1896, and sold twenty-nine copies, and<br /> made a profit of &lt;£i 40. 2d., which on his own<br /> showing was rather more than one-eighth of<br /> what he had made in 1886. His Lordship de-<br /> clined to order an inquiry as to damages. It<br /> would be almost wicked to send the case to the<br /> master or to an official referee to find damages<br /> for conversion; if necessary, he should have the<br /> inquiry before himself. Mr. Warrington had<br /> asked him to fix a sum, and if he added forty<br /> guineas for the whole, he thought he was giving<br /> the plaintiff as much as he was entitled to. The<br /> plaintiff was also entitled to an injunction as<br /> part of the order. Upon the question of costs,<br /> his Lordship said that the plaintiff might have<br /> obtained all the relief he sought by one action in<br /> the Chancery Division. He seemed, however, to<br /> have determined to multiply costs in every<br /> possible way, and his Lordship would do his best<br /> to mark his sense of that proceeding. He should<br /> therefore give him only the costs of the Chancery<br /> action; the costs of the other proceedings he<br /> must be ordered to pay.—The Times, Nov. 17.<br /> SHELLEY&#039;S PUBLISHES.<br /> CHARLES OLLIER began his working life<br /> in Messrs. Coutts&#039;s bank, but a classical<br /> education had developed literary tastes, and<br /> these he first indulged by becoming a publisher.<br /> He had not been a year in business when, through<br /> Leigh Hunt—whose &quot;Foliage,&quot; &quot;Hero and<br /> VOL. VIII.<br /> Leander,&quot; and the second edition of &quot; The Story<br /> of Rimini&quot; he published—he was introduced to<br /> Keats, and the acquaintance led to his publishing<br /> the first poems of Keats in 1817. The book was<br /> not a success; Keats blamed the inactivity of the<br /> publisher, and went over to Taylor and Hessey<br /> with his subsequent works. With Shelley the<br /> case was different. It was due to Oilier that<br /> Shelley&#039;s &quot;Laon and Cythna&quot; was altered and<br /> converted into &quot;The Revolt of Islam&quot;; and,<br /> although the poet complained of that proceeding,<br /> all his subsequent works published in his life-<br /> time, except &quot;Swellfoot the Tyrant,&quot; were<br /> brought out by Oilier. When Shelley sent his<br /> &quot;Defence of Poetry&quot; to Oilier in 1821, indeed, he<br /> wrote that &quot; if any expressions should strike you<br /> as too unpopular, I give you the power of omit-<br /> ting them; but I trust you will, if possible,<br /> refrain from exercising this.&quot; Although his<br /> brother James was the man of business, the firm<br /> of Charles and James Oilier, of Vere-street, did not<br /> prosper. Li 1819 he published &quot; The Literary<br /> Pocket Book,&quot; in which Shelley&#039;s poem of &quot; Mari-<br /> anne&#039;s Dream&quot; was first printed; and in 1820<br /> he brought out the first part of &quot; Oilier&#039;s Literary<br /> Miscellany, in Prose and Verse, by Several<br /> Hands.&quot; This publication, which, as the title-<br /> page said, was &quot;to be continued occasionally,&quot;<br /> contained a remarkable article on the German<br /> drama by Archdeacon Hare, and another by<br /> Peacock on &quot;The Four Ages of Poetry.&quot; As<br /> the latter, in which the writer regarded poetry as a<br /> worn-out delusion of barbarous times, provoked<br /> Shelley&#039;s &quot;Defence of Pcetry,&quot; the following<br /> entertaining passage may be quoted as a taste of<br /> its quality. The year of writing is 1820:—<br /> In the origin and perfection of poetry, all the associa-<br /> tions of life were composed of poetio materials. With us it<br /> is decidedly the reverse. We know, too, that there are nu<br /> Dryads in Hyde Park nor Naiads in the Regent&#039;s Canal<br /> Bat barbaric manners and supernatural interventions are<br /> essential to poetry. Either in the scene, or in the time, or<br /> in both, it must be remote from our ordinary perceptions.<br /> While the historian and the philosopher are advanoing in<br /> and accelerating the progress of knowledge, the poet is<br /> wallowing in the rubbish of departed ignoranoe, and raking<br /> up the ashes of dead savages to find geegaws and rattles<br /> for the grown babies of the age. Mr. Scott digs up the<br /> poachers and cattle stealers of the anoient border. Lord<br /> Byron cruises for thieves and pirates on the shores of the<br /> Morea and among the Greek islands. Mr. Southey wades<br /> through ponderous volumes of travel and old chronicles,<br /> from which he carefully selects all that is false, useless,<br /> and absurd, as being essentially poetioal; and when he has a<br /> oommonplace book, full of monstrosities, strings them into<br /> an epic Mr. Wordsworth picks up village legends from old<br /> women and sextons; and Mr. Coleridge, to the valuable<br /> information acquired from similar sources, superadds the<br /> dreams of crazy theologians and the mysticisms of German<br /> metaphysios, and favours the world with visions in verse,<br /> in whioh the quadruple elements of sexton, old woman,<br /> Jeremy Taylor, and Emanuel Kant are harmonised into a<br /> T<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 208 (#642) ############################################<br /> <br /> 208<br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> delicious poetical compound. Mr. Moore presents as with<br /> a Persian, and Mr. Campbell with a Pennsylvanian tale,<br /> both formed on the same principle as Mr. Southey&#039;s epics,<br /> by extracting from a perfunctory and desultory perusal of a<br /> collection of voyages and travels, all that useful investiga-<br /> tion would not seek for and that common sense would<br /> reject.<br /> &quot;Very clever, but false,&quot; said Shelley of Pea-<br /> cock&#039;s tilt against poetry. Shelley&#039;s &quot; Defence&quot;<br /> was originally intended to appear in the second<br /> part of &quot;Ollier&#039;s Miscellany,&quot; but no second part<br /> ever appeared. Then Ollier&#039;s business was wound-<br /> up, and the &quot; Defence&quot; came into the possession<br /> of John Hunt, who prepared it for publication<br /> in the &quot; Liberal,&quot; but that periodical also expired<br /> before it could be published.<br /> Meanwhile Oilier had become a literary adviser<br /> to Bentley, and he continued long in this position.<br /> He also contributed to magazines, and occasion-<br /> ally gave lectures on celebrated writers. He<br /> admired Shakespeare to such a degree, and held<br /> himself under such a loyal weight of obligation<br /> to him, that, says Hunt, &quot;I have known him<br /> involuntarily measure persons, whom he other-<br /> wise respected, from head to foot if tbey ventured<br /> to maintain the least objection to the great poet;<br /> as though, in default of some possible intellectual<br /> cause for it, he was trying to discover some cause<br /> physical.&quot;<br /> As an author, Oilier possessed two faults in<br /> Leigh Hunt&#039;s eyes. First, he should have written<br /> more; and, secondly, he should have taken more<br /> pains to keep what he did write before the public.<br /> His first work was &quot;Altham and His Wife: a<br /> Domestic Tale&quot; (1818). Shelley wrote of this:<br /> &quot;It is a natural story, most unaffectedly told in a<br /> strain of very pure and powerful English.&quot; Sir<br /> Walter Scott, in a critique which he wrote in the<br /> Quarterly Review on the novel of &quot; Haggi Baba&quot;<br /> in England, refers to the story of &quot;Altham and<br /> His Wife&quot; as furnishing pleasant authority for<br /> the telling of love-tales under umbrellas during a<br /> shower. Ollier&#039;s second book, &quot;Iuesilla; or, the<br /> Tempter: a Romance, with Other Tales&quot; (1824),<br /> Hunt said was &quot;the best bit of diablerie in the<br /> language.&quot; So high an opinion was entertained<br /> of it by the authoress of &quot;Frankenstein,&quot; that a<br /> publisher having proposed to piece out the requi-<br /> site size of a volume of stories from her pen by<br /> one worthy of its companionship, she said she<br /> should prefer this production of Mr. Oilier. Then<br /> followed &quot;Ferrers&quot; (1842), a romance on the<br /> execution of Earl Ferrers in 1760; &quot;Fallacy of<br /> Ghosts, Dreams, and Omens, with Stories of<br /> Witchcraft, Life-in-Death, and Monomania&quot;<br /> (1848), reprinted from Ainsworth&#039;s Magazine,<br /> and published by the author himself. Edmund<br /> Oilier, author, who died in 1886, was a son of<br /> Charles Oilier.<br /> EUSSIAN COPYBIGHT.<br /> AT present, no international copyright exists<br /> in Russia. Not only is the Russian<br /> Empire by far the largest and by far the<br /> most important of the European States outside<br /> the Berne Convention, but it is also without any<br /> private copyright convention with any other<br /> State. The readers of The Author will not<br /> require to be told what that implies. The<br /> results are, of course, as unsatisfactory to Russian<br /> authors as they are to the authors of other<br /> countries, all whose works are at the free disposal<br /> of the subjects of the Tsar. Even editors and<br /> publishers do not find it always convenient to be<br /> unable either to inhibit the unlimited introduction<br /> of translations of foreign works, or to get any<br /> protection for those which they have themselves<br /> brought out. In fact, the situation appears<br /> to be rapidly becoming intolerable. The object,<br /> however, of the present article is not to<br /> explain that the results of unlimited piracy<br /> are as unsatisfactory in Russia as elsewhere.<br /> That is a matter of course. But it is pleasant<br /> to be able to mention, on the other hand,<br /> that the Russians are beginning to realise that<br /> piracy is unsatisfactory, and that, in consequence,<br /> some steps in a more hopeful direction have been<br /> recently taken.<br /> For some time past pleas have been urged in<br /> favour of the renewal of the copyright conven-<br /> tion formerly existing between Russia and France.<br /> This lapsed upon the denunciation, in 1887, of<br /> the treaty of 1861. In 1893 M. Zola published in<br /> the Temps, &quot;An Open Letter to the Russian<br /> Press.&quot; In 1894 both the St. Petersburg Society<br /> of Authors and the St. Petersburg Association of<br /> Publishers named commissions to consider pro-<br /> posals for some new legislation. The Musical<br /> Society of St. Petersburg and the Society of<br /> Artists took also similar steps. In the meantime<br /> the Russian Government had instituted under the<br /> presidency of Count Muravieff, then Minister of<br /> Justice, but at present of Foreign Affairs, a com-<br /> mission for the revision of the Russian code.<br /> Upon reaching the section relating to copyright,<br /> certain new regulations, in accordance with<br /> modern views, were proposed and submitted for<br /> consideration to various Russian societies com-<br /> petent to give opinions concerning them. More<br /> recently the text of the proposed legislation was<br /> communicated to the congress at Monaco, accom-<br /> panied by a letter from the Chancellor of the<br /> Russian Imperial Commission. This letter ex-<br /> plained that the projected regulations were<br /> by no means to be regarded as final, and<br /> that the right of translation, at present<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 209 (#643) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> 209<br /> treated in a manner altogether inconsistent<br /> with the spirit of the Berne Convention,<br /> would probably be reconsidered and placed<br /> upon an entirely different basis. The Monaco<br /> Congress was naturally much gratified by the<br /> compliment paid it by the Russian Government,<br /> and a special commission of the association was<br /> nominated to study the proposals laid before it.<br /> Those who are specially interested in the subject<br /> will find lengthy and highly instructive articles<br /> upon it in the recent numbers of Le Droit<br /> d&#039;Auteur, to which publication we are indebted<br /> for the facte briefly summarised in the following<br /> paragraphs.<br /> All literary, musical, and artistic works are to<br /> be protected. With some restrictions, copyright<br /> is accorded also to collections of national ballads,<br /> and of other folk-lore, hitherto orally transmitted<br /> (an excellent provision in a country so rich in<br /> folk-lore as Russia), and to editors of ancient<br /> manuscripts—the last without prejudice to editors<br /> of other manuscripts of the same work. Lectures,<br /> sermons, and public discourses are also to be<br /> copyright. Of judicial, municipal, and other<br /> public speeches of the same kind, the authors<br /> are to have a copyright, but the newspapers<br /> to be free to report. Laws and public regula-<br /> tions are not copyright. Both writer and<br /> receiver, or their heirs, have control over private<br /> letters. Amongst artistic works the following<br /> are particularly specified as protected—maps,<br /> plans, and architectural and technical designs.<br /> Photographs are protected, with some restric-<br /> tions.<br /> Unpublished literary and artistic works cannot<br /> be seized. Damages can be claimed for infringe-<br /> ment of copyright, whether wilful or uninten-<br /> tional. In the latter case the culprit is respon-<br /> sible only for a sum representing his actual gain.<br /> Proceedings before either civil or criminal<br /> tribunals will be easily taken. The owner of the<br /> copyright can proceed within a limit of three years<br /> after his discovery of the infringement of his<br /> rights. The penalty for illicit production of<br /> dramatic works will be forfeiture to the author of<br /> the whole of the gross receipts. Cession of a<br /> work does not include cession of the right of<br /> translation. Cession of right to publish a drama<br /> does not include right to perform.<br /> The author&#039;s rights are subject to certain<br /> restrictions. The entire reproduction of works<br /> of insignificant extent is permitted if they are<br /> reproduced in voluminous works of an original<br /> character. Reproduction in chrestomathies, or<br /> in similar works of a scientific or educational<br /> character, is also allowed. Periodicals are allowed<br /> to copy matter from the columns of others, pro-<br /> vided that the extracts are of small extent, not<br /> VOL. VIII.<br /> of a literary character, and not continuously<br /> drawn from the same source. All such extracts<br /> are to be accompanied by an indication of their<br /> origin. The interests of the author are also<br /> sacrificed to those of the musical composer.<br /> Words for music may be taken freely from any<br /> published work, unless the words have been<br /> written exclusively for setting to music, and the<br /> composer may sell the words with the music<br /> without restriction. For restrictions on the rights<br /> of artiste we must refer the rt ader to Le Droit<br /> d&#039;Auteur. A literary work may be dramatised<br /> without the author&#039;s consent after a lapse of ten<br /> years from its publication.<br /> Respecting translation much remains to be<br /> desired. The author of a work published in<br /> Russia enjovs an exclusive right of translation for<br /> ten years, if this right is expressly reserved by a<br /> declaration on the title or in the preface, and if<br /> he publishes a tsanslation within three years after<br /> the appearance of the original work. Works<br /> simultaneously published in different languages<br /> are to be considered as original works in every<br /> one of these languages.<br /> When the right of translation has become<br /> public property, a translator has no power to<br /> inhibit any other translation of the same work.<br /> The duration of copyright will be the same as<br /> at present, the life of the author and fifty years<br /> afterwards. This applies also to music. Fifty<br /> years from the death of the author is the dura-<br /> tion of the copyright of posthumous works.<br /> Fifty years from the date of publication will be<br /> the duration for—<br /> (a) First editions of folk-lore;<br /> (6) First editions of ancient manuscripts;<br /> (c) The publications of universities, academies,<br /> educational institutions, and learned societies.<br /> The copyright of an anonymous or pseudony-<br /> mous publication has a duration of thirty years<br /> from the date of publication, unless the author<br /> declares himself within that period, in which case<br /> he acquires his ordinary rights.<br /> The duration of copyright for a photograph is<br /> five years only; for a translation it is the life of<br /> the translator and thirty years afterwards.<br /> The editors of periodicals, encyclopaedias,<br /> almanacks, and similar works, composed of the<br /> writings of different authors, have a fifty years&#039;<br /> copyright commencing from the date of publi-<br /> cation. The contributors, without prejudice to<br /> their rights in the miscellany, may, unless the<br /> contrary has been expressly stipulated, reprint<br /> their works two years after their appearance in<br /> the miscellany.<br /> The author who has ceded his right for a single<br /> edition may, unless the contrary has been ex-<br /> pressly stipulated, publish a new edition as soon<br /> t 2<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 210 (#644) ############################################<br /> <br /> 2IO<br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> as the first is exhausted, or, even if it be not<br /> exhausted, after five years; or at any time, if the<br /> work has undergone such modifications as will<br /> make it really a new book.<br /> These regulations will apply to all works pub-<br /> lished in Russia, whether the author be a Russian<br /> or a foreigner. They apply also to the works of<br /> a Russian subject published in a foreign country.<br /> No protection is given to the works of foreigners<br /> published outside the Russian Empire. Nor is<br /> any hint given of conventions ultimately to be<br /> concluded with other States. This would appear<br /> to indicate that complete non-recognition of the<br /> rights of foreigners is to be the rule. Happily,<br /> the letter of the Chancellor of the Imperial Com-<br /> mission leaves some hopes of an ultimate more<br /> liberal arrangement.<br /> Henby Cbesswell.<br /> NEW YORK LETTER.<br /> New York, Dec. 17, 1897.<br /> ANUMBER of interesting changes in the<br /> tendencies of publishing are visible in the<br /> Christmas books this year, and they are<br /> nearly all encouraging. All of the leading houses<br /> are publishing less of those books which, intended<br /> exclusively for Christmas sale, are of flimsy and<br /> ephemeral character, with slight real interest.<br /> Trifles for children, and gift-books full of cheap<br /> illustrations and decorations, are not published<br /> by any but some of the weaker houses. Instead<br /> of that we see the solid books being advertised as<br /> especially suitable for gift-books. A few of the<br /> smaller houses, however, have just as large a<br /> supply of tinsel as ever. Among the solid books<br /> which seem to be especially popular for this par-<br /> ticular purpose are those on the popular aspects<br /> of science and philosophy, and especially on those<br /> branches of those subjects which can be treated<br /> in a half pictorial way, which explains an un-<br /> common amount of literature about birds and<br /> plants this year, and also explains the big<br /> Christmas demand for books on art and travel.<br /> The decoration is improving in the same way as<br /> the contents. Really rich and luxurious paper<br /> and binding are taking the place of the cheaper<br /> devices, although one wasteful tendency is notice-<br /> able—that of making the books so delicate that<br /> any reasonable amount of handling would ruin<br /> them. Perhaps of all the Christmas books,<br /> properly speaking, the two most conspicuous are<br /> Gibson&#039;s book on London (published by tbe<br /> Scribners) and &quot;Joan of Arc,&quot; by Boutet de<br /> Mouvel, published by the Century Company.<br /> John Li Farge&#039;s &quot;Artist&#039;s Letters from Japan&quot;<br /> has attracted a good deal of attention, and<br /> it is a reminder that the growing familiarity<br /> with Japanese and French ideas in regard to<br /> decoration is responsible for much of the im-<br /> provement.<br /> One of the most interesting of all the solid<br /> books is the history of dancing from the earliest<br /> stages to our own times, published by Appleton<br /> and Co. as a translation from the French. The<br /> text itself is complete and intelligent, and the<br /> illustrations reproduce some of the finest works of<br /> art from the earliest times down to Sargent,<br /> Degas and Cheret.<br /> Among the books which will appear before a<br /> great while it must be said, to the credit of the<br /> cheap magazines and the cheap publishing houses,<br /> that the most interesting, to my mind at least, will<br /> be given by Mr. Munsey. It will be made up of<br /> a series of articles now running in the magazine<br /> which give the judgment of various writers of<br /> fiction on their favourite novelists. The date of<br /> the issue cannot be fixed until it is known when<br /> the series will be completed. Anthony Hope&#039;s<br /> article on Sterne, in the November number of the<br /> magazine, struck me as being the best piece of<br /> literary criticism of recent publication that I have<br /> seen anywhere. It suggested one rather gloomy<br /> conclusion for the professional critic, which is,<br /> that the man who sits down occasionally to<br /> express ideas which he has thought of for many<br /> years gives something more permanently worth<br /> while than most of the criticism which is written<br /> by men who turn everything they know into<br /> copy.<br /> This observation, by-the-way, has its relations<br /> to an article which Professor H. T. Peck has<br /> recently written, in which he says that the<br /> influence of the magazine on authors has been<br /> generally deteriorating, by inducing them to write<br /> too constantly. Except in the cases of genius,<br /> he thinks it makes no difference to the author,<br /> because he wouldn&#039;t do anything anyway; but<br /> where a man has genius he is ruined by the in-<br /> ducement to hasty work. The corresponding<br /> harm to the public is obvious.<br /> Mr. Howells, who has just returned from<br /> Europe, said while abroad that there was no one<br /> in this country whose good opinion was like that<br /> of Mr. Gladstone, able to make a reputation, and<br /> that Lowell&#039;s opinion in his closing years would<br /> have done more in that way than any other.<br /> Seeking the reason for this truth, the Nation<br /> thinks that it is because criticism here is too<br /> gentle, and that Mr. Lowell&#039;s influence lay largely<br /> in his freedom from the fault of indiscriminate<br /> praise, which is surely an explanation altogether<br /> insufficient to explain the lack of strong criticism<br /> here—-ather the effect than the cause.<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 211 (#645) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> 211<br /> One queBtion that might with profit be dis-<br /> cussed fully in this country is the ethics of<br /> editing, which has received such thorough treat-<br /> ment from The Author. The degree to which<br /> some of the magazine editors change the words<br /> and ideas in signed articles, not only in those<br /> written by the less known men, but often in<br /> those written by some of the most prominent<br /> authors in the world is very marked. It would<br /> not he safe for me to give the facts too specifically.<br /> A subject about which I have found marked<br /> differences of opinion lately is that of dating<br /> books. One writer of long experience held that<br /> in publishing a book of essays it was decidedly<br /> better to date each essay, in order that the earlier<br /> ones might be recognised as not the latest<br /> product of the author&#039;s mind. Another man,<br /> of equal ability and almost equal experience, said<br /> that to date the essays, or in any way, as by an<br /> acknowledgment in the front of the book, to show<br /> that they had been published, would injure the<br /> sale, so strong is the desire for &quot; something new.&quot;<br /> The literary success of the last few weeks in<br /> New York belongs to England. The enthusiasm<br /> with which intelligent people have received &quot; The<br /> Princess and the Butterfly&quot; is as much due to<br /> Mr. Pinero&#039;8 literary qualities as to the dramatic<br /> ones. There is no doubt that the play has made<br /> a stronger impression on the minds of the intelli-<br /> gent people of New York than anything else<br /> which has been given here this year.<br /> Norman Hapoood.<br /> NOTES AND NEWS.<br /> THE Speaker once more kindly devotes two or<br /> three columns of abuse to this Society. It<br /> appears that we contain few men of recog-<br /> nised standing: that we are run by a small clique<br /> of busybodies: that we claim to determine the<br /> conditions upon which books shall be sold: that<br /> nine-tenths of the known authors of the country<br /> know nothing about the Society: that it is the<br /> desire of the Society to establish a fixed royalty<br /> for the author: that our Report on the Discount<br /> System is a masterpiece of inconsequential<br /> reasoning: and so on. Of course they put<br /> my name forward as the supposed leader in<br /> all this wickedness: to that I am quite accus-<br /> tomed. It is the old trick of representing the<br /> Society as consisting of one man. I only<br /> wonder that they ever allow any others to be<br /> connected with it at all. There are others, how-<br /> ever: the writer acknowledges so much, though,<br /> as he assures his readers, my friends, like myself,<br /> only &quot; cater for the middle class.&quot; This is a very<br /> terrible charge. How is one to get out of it?<br /> Since, however, the middle class of this country<br /> furnishes the great bulk of readers: since from<br /> the middle class come all our men of science,<br /> of art, of literature; all our preachers, most<br /> of our leaders, all our engineers, lawyers,<br /> merchants—in fact, all the people who ever do any-<br /> thing— I really see no disgrace in &quot;catering&quot;<br /> for them. The Speaker, of course, &quot; caters &quot; for<br /> the aristocracy alone. I wonder how it is done.<br /> However, the true meaning of all this wrath<br /> presently appears when the writer wanders from<br /> his subject in order to talk about royalties. It is<br /> the increase of the royalty which inspires this real<br /> and genuine indignation. Now, it is certainly not<br /> true, as the writer says, that we have ever advo-<br /> cated a fixed royalty. We have, however, pub-<br /> lished the meaning of royalties—what they give to<br /> authors and what they give to publishers. These<br /> truths have given a great deal of dissatisfaction.<br /> It is undoubted that, thanks to the action of the<br /> Society, royalties have very greatly advanced; it<br /> is also true that certain publishers who used to<br /> offer a sweating royalty, say, of 5 per cent., have<br /> had to treble, and more than treble, their terms,<br /> or else to see books taken elsewhere. Other little<br /> trifles have also been secured to the author, such<br /> as dramatic rights, American rights, Continental<br /> rights, through the action of the Society in pub-<br /> lishing the facts of the case.<br /> Authors, again, have been kept out of certain<br /> hands to the great loss and detriment of those<br /> hands: light has been poured upon the meaning<br /> of production and its cost. In this way it is<br /> possible that dividends may have fallen in this or<br /> that company. Such a consideration suggests a<br /> very simple explanation if a paper should happen<br /> to be controlled by a publishing house. But, if<br /> the Speaker can reason at all on the subject, one<br /> would ask if any purpose is gained by all this<br /> invective? Is the Society one whit the worse for<br /> these attacks \ I believe not. Never has any associa-<br /> tion been more savagely attacked than the Society of<br /> Authors. Yet it is larger, stronger, and of better<br /> repute to-day than ever before. And the editor<br /> of the Speaker may ask himself if, by any of his<br /> previous attacks upon the paper, he has injured the<br /> Society in the slightest way? And we may ask,<br /> generally, all these persons, publishers or other-<br /> wise, who attack the Society, whether they find<br /> their own position improved by these attacks?<br /> And we may ask the whole world whether authors,<br /> like other people, are prepared to give up an asso-<br /> ciation which has so enormously advanced their<br /> own interests? .<br /> Let us remind our members that ten or twelve<br /> years ago a 10 per cent, royalty was the utmost<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 212 (#646) ############################################<br /> <br /> 212<br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> ever offered. Generally it was less—a 5 per<br /> cent, with something down. A certain very<br /> popular novel was once given to a publisher for<br /> .£50 in advance and a 5 per cent, royalty. That<br /> author&#039;s terms would now be 25 per cent. Look<br /> at the difference on a sale of a thousand.<br /> On a 5 per cent, royalty .£15 per thousand<br /> copies.<br /> On a 25 per cent, royalty ,£75 per thousand<br /> copies.<br /> On a sale of fifty thousand—it was more than<br /> that—there was a difference — clear gain — of<br /> £3000. And this is evidently the work of the<br /> Society which was the first to investigate the<br /> meaning of the figures and the corresponding<br /> meaning of royalties. Take, however, a more<br /> common case, the old royalty of 10 per cent,<br /> compared with that of 25 per cent.<br /> On 10 per cent, the sum of ,£30 for every<br /> thousand copies.<br /> On 25 per cent, the sum of J675 for every<br /> thousand copies.<br /> On a sale of fifty thousand—I repeat that the<br /> book in question was very popular—the author is<br /> a gainer of £1250. As to other services of the<br /> Society, we may speak of them at another time.<br /> Let the reader only consider that if the Society<br /> were to become extinct these figures would very<br /> speedily be lost and forgotten—and the old con-<br /> dition of things would be restored.<br /> I have before me certain remarks upon our<br /> estimates and figures in a new paper of which<br /> this is only the second number. It is called the<br /> Qtiilldriver. The writer speaks well of the<br /> Society, but complains that in The Author young<br /> writers are led to believe that the average circu-<br /> lation of a novel is 3000. Not so: the average<br /> is not spoken of; in preparing these figures we<br /> have nothing to do with the average, we have to<br /> deal with the possibilities. In dealing with, or<br /> speaking of, literary property we must consider<br /> actual, substantial literary property — which<br /> means the achievement of popularity: we must<br /> prepare agreements for possibilities — never,<br /> perhaps, to be realised, yet always possible.<br /> That is the meaning of our figures. When we<br /> assume a circulation of 3000 it is in order to<br /> provide for the possibility of that number. Nor<br /> can I believe that anyone is so foolish as to<br /> think that the majority of novels do actually<br /> attain this figure. When a young barrister enters<br /> upon his profession he considers the prizes:<br /> the great practice possible: the great reputa-<br /> tion; he then lays himself out, so to speak, for<br /> the attainment of this great practice: he does not<br /> consider the many failures which are, of course,<br /> possible for him as for any other. So a young<br /> writer should, and does, consider the great<br /> prizes open to him, though he may never arrive<br /> at them. That is, again, the meaning of the<br /> thousands introduced into our figures.<br /> The writer before me goes on to say that he<br /> has made a list of 150 writers well known to the<br /> public; that he applied to their publishers for<br /> information as to the circulation of their books;<br /> and that this information was actually supplied!<br /> This is a most wonderful thing. Publishers are<br /> confidential agents; they have no more right to<br /> reveal the secrets of their authors than lawyers<br /> those of their clients. It is conceivable that such<br /> a revelation might damage a writer very seriously,<br /> say, when one of deserved name and reputation<br /> was found to enjoy a very limited circulation.<br /> However, for some unknown consideration, all the<br /> publishers of the Hundred and Fifty are said to<br /> have betrayed their trust, and to have given the<br /> information asked for. The average circulation<br /> of the lot, says my writer, was 4535 volumes.<br /> Yes, perhaps. But is this the average of the<br /> whole army of novelists? Can it be considered<br /> as even approximately the average? Let us just<br /> examine the figures. There were 150 novelists<br /> selected; their average was 4535. This represents<br /> no more than 68,025 volumes. Consequently<br /> it cannot include Hall Caine, whose last novel<br /> circulated to the tune of 150,000 copies at least.<br /> Put him in: the average rises to 1444 copies for<br /> every one of the 151. Nor does it include<br /> Rider Haggard, whose most successful story<br /> means at least 120,000. Add Eider Haggard<br /> and the average for 152 goes up to 2224. Add<br /> &quot;Treasure Island&quot; with, I believe, 80,000, and<br /> the average for 153 is 2732. Add Marie Corelli<br /> with 80,000 (say) and the average goes up to<br /> 3234 for 154. Putin adozen others with a circula-<br /> tion of only 10,000 each and the average for 166<br /> amounts to 3723. With these figures before us<br /> it becomes evident that the figures quoted cannot<br /> represent an average, which must include the<br /> successful as well as the unsuccessful: and that<br /> if, in The Author, we were to claim 3000 as an<br /> average we might perhaps be justified. We do<br /> not, however, advance any such claim. We are<br /> quite prepared to admit that most novelists fail<br /> to catch the public ear: in all professions it is<br /> only the small minority that succeeds; we are<br /> also prepared to admit that if we take the lower<br /> half of living novelists their average is very small.<br /> But then the lower half includes the unhappy<br /> people who believe that by paying for production<br /> they pay for publication, and that a printed book<br /> is a published book, and that every novel is a<br /> mine of gold.<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 213 (#647) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> The report of the Sub-Committee to consider<br /> the proposals made by certain publishers for the<br /> enslaving of the bookseller has been received by<br /> the world with apparent satisfaction. Our own<br /> members, with one exception, have not expressed<br /> any dissatisfaction at the result of the inquiry.<br /> The one exception sent a letter to the secretary,<br /> which he also forwarded to the Publishers&#039; Asso-<br /> ciation. It is printed in another column. One<br /> would not deny to every member the right to his<br /> own opinion; but in cases where, as in that lately<br /> before us, the independence of literature, the<br /> dignity of men and women of letters, and their<br /> material interests, were all together threatened<br /> under cover of coercing booksellers: when, under<br /> the same pretence, it was sought to raise the price<br /> of books upon a public which already pays too<br /> much: in such a case it is above all things neces-<br /> sary that authors should stand together, and that<br /> they should sink their individual opinion and<br /> think only of the general good. That means that<br /> they should accept the decision of the Committee,<br /> which alone, remember, was able to hear the<br /> evidence.<br /> Mr. Cunningham says that the decision was<br /> arrived at by adhering to old arguments. That is not<br /> a correct statement of the case. The whole report<br /> has been published in this paper, so that readers<br /> may judge for themselves. Weight was certainly<br /> given to the opinions of the men of 1852—distin-<br /> guished men—all of whom have a right to be<br /> considered, even fifty years after the event. But<br /> the Committee were chiefly guided by the evidence<br /> before them, rather than by the arguments of 18 5 2;<br /> they learned and recognised the absolute impos-<br /> sibility of coercion: the degradation of the book-<br /> seller, who, if the proposed plan succeeded, would<br /> become a mere clerk and servant of the publisher:<br /> and the absolute certainty that the next step would<br /> be the degradation of the author. Indeed, the<br /> Times, in making a precis of the report, left out<br /> altogether the statement of the case in 1852, so<br /> little importance was attached by their reader to<br /> that part of the report.<br /> Mr. Cunningham disagrees with the report.<br /> That is to be lamented; but everyone must form<br /> his own opinion. He then, after acknowledging<br /> the valuable aid which he has received from the<br /> Society, withdraws from membership. This step<br /> shows that he has not the least esprit de corps,<br /> and that he owes no sense of duty or of brother-<br /> hood to others engaged in literary work. How<br /> could the Society have assisted or advised him but<br /> for the association of a great many who by their<br /> collective subscriptions enable us to provide offices,<br /> collect cases, get legal advice, and maintain a<br /> staff? How can such a Society be kept up if every<br /> member who disagrees with a report or with the<br /> action of the Committee immediately withdraws?<br /> Surely a certain amount of loyalty is required in<br /> the defence and the advancement of every cause—<br /> in our case more than any other, on account of<br /> the fierce resentment which has always met it on<br /> every side, and the unscrupulous falsehoods with<br /> which it is constantly assailed. The first thing<br /> necessary, however, is the feeling that every<br /> writer ought to support the Society not so much<br /> for the assistance which he may receive, or for<br /> gratitude for the assistance which he has received,<br /> so much as for the solid work which the Society<br /> has rendered to the material interests of litera-<br /> ture, and for the assistance which it is constantly<br /> giving to writers in trouble or in doubt. To do<br /> this effectively, we ought to have at least 2000<br /> members—that is, 600 more than our present<br /> number. .<br /> Literary men will do well to take legal advice<br /> before accepting employment under the city of<br /> New York, if the experience of Mr. Charles Burr<br /> Todd, the historian of the city, counts for any-<br /> thing. In 1895 the Common Council was desirous<br /> of printing the early records of Dutch Man-<br /> hattan and English New York which were<br /> stored in ancient safes in the city library, and<br /> were fast going to pieces with age and handling.<br /> The Mayor appointed a committee to superintend<br /> their publication, the members of which previous<br /> to appointment met the Mayor in his office, and<br /> agreed to serve without pay provided they could<br /> have a secretary and editor to do the work, who<br /> should be paid, and they named Mr. Todd as such<br /> editor. The Mayor said he had wished Mr. Todd<br /> on the committee, but it was pointed out that the<br /> latter could not afford to serve without pay; to all<br /> of which the Mayor agreed. Mr. Todd was soon<br /> after appointed on the committee, and, with the<br /> understanding that he should be paid, accepted.<br /> Later the committee appointed him editor, agree-<br /> ing to pay him, though no sum was fixed. He<br /> served eight months and resigned, whereupon the<br /> committee voted him 150 dollars per month. The<br /> city refused to pay on the ground that the com-<br /> mittee were to serve for nothing, whereupon Mr.<br /> Todd sued for the amount. The case was tried<br /> before Judge Russell in the Supreme Court of<br /> New York, on Nov. 18, and the learned judge<br /> held that as Mr. Todd was a member of a com-<br /> mittee which was appointed to serve without pay<br /> he could recover nothing. Mr. Todd says that<br /> while this may be good law it is very poor equity<br /> and justice; that somebody laid a trap for him<br /> in order to get his services as editor for nothing,<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 214 (#648) ############################################<br /> <br /> 214<br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> and that altogether it is pretty small business for<br /> the second largest city in the world.<br /> He worked five years preparing his history of<br /> the city, for which he has received about one<br /> hundred and fifty dollars, and thinks if he per-<br /> forms other services for the city it should be<br /> willing to remunerate him. Waltee Be8ANT_<br /> A CHAPTER OF THE PAST.<br /> THE following extracts from Babbage&#039;s<br /> &quot;Economy of Machinery &quot; are interesting<br /> at present:—<br /> (295.) . . . &quot;A powerful combination, of<br /> another kind, exists at this moment to a great<br /> extent, and operates upon the price of the very<br /> pages which we are now communicating informa-<br /> tion respecting it. A subject so interesting to<br /> every reader, and still more so to every manu-<br /> facturer of the article which the reader consumes,<br /> deserves an attentive examination.<br /> &quot;We have shown in Chapter XX., p. 166, the<br /> component parts of the expense of each copy of<br /> the present work; and we have seen that the<br /> total amount of the cost of production, exclusive<br /> of any payment to the author for his labour, is<br /> 28. tfd.<br /> &quot;Another fact, with which the reader is more<br /> practically familiar, is, that he has paid, or is to<br /> pay, his bookseller six shillings for the volume.<br /> Let us now examine into the distribution of these<br /> six shillings, and then, having the facts of the<br /> case before us, we shall be better able to judge<br /> of the merits of the combination and to explain<br /> its effects.<br /> Distribution of the profits on a six-shilling hook.<br /> BayB at.<br /> Sells at.<br /> Profit on<br /> capital<br /> expended<br /> No. 1. The publisher, who<br /> s. d.<br /> s. d.<br /> accounts to the author for<br /> every copy received<br /> 3 10<br /> 4 2<br /> 10 per<br /> No. 2. Bookseller, who retails<br /> cent.<br /> 4 2<br /> 6 0<br /> 44 per<br /> cent.<br /> Or<br /> 4 6<br /> 6 0<br /> 33i Par<br /> cent.<br /> &quot;No. 1, the publisher, is a bookseller, he is in<br /> fact the author&#039;s agent. His duties are to receive<br /> and take charge of the stock, for whieh bo sup-<br /> plies warehouse room, to advise the author about<br /> the times and methods of advertising, and to<br /> insert the advertisements. As he publishes other<br /> books, he will advertise lists of those s^ld by him-<br /> self; and thus by combining many in one adver-<br /> tisement, diminish the expense to each of his<br /> principals. He pays the author only for the<br /> books actually sold, consequently, he makes no<br /> outlay of capital, except that which he pays for<br /> advertisements, but he is answerable for any bad<br /> debts he may make in disposing of them. His<br /> charge is usually 10 per cent, on the returns.<br /> &quot;No. 2 is the bookseller, who retails the work<br /> to the public. On the publication of a new book<br /> the publisher sends round to the trade to receive<br /> subscriptions from them for any number of<br /> copies, not less than two. These copies are usually<br /> charged to the subscribers, on an average, at<br /> about 4 or 5 per cent, less than the wholesale<br /> price of the book, in the present case they pay<br /> 4«. 2d. for each copy. After the day of publica-<br /> tion, the price charged by the publisher to the<br /> booksellers is 4*. 6d. Different publishers offer<br /> different terms to the subscriber, and it is usual<br /> after intervals of about six months for the pub-<br /> lisher again to open a subscription list, so that if<br /> the work be one for which there is a steady<br /> demand, the trade avail themselves of these oppor-<br /> tunities of purchasing at the reduced rate enough<br /> to supply their probable demand.<br /> (296.) &quot;The volume thus purchased of the<br /> publisher at 4*. 2d. or 4*. 6d. is retailed by the<br /> bookseller at 6s. In the one case he makes a<br /> profit of 44, in the other of 33 per cent Even<br /> the smaller of these two rates of profit on the<br /> capital employed certainly appears too large. It<br /> sometimes happens, when a purchaser inquires<br /> for a book, the retail dealer sends across the<br /> street to the wholesale agent, and receives for<br /> this trifling service one-fourth part of the money<br /> the purchaser pays; and perhaps the retail dealer<br /> also takes six months&#039; credit for the price which<br /> the volume actually costs him. It is stated that<br /> all retail books&gt; Hers allow their customers a dis-<br /> count of 10 per cent, upon orders above .£20;<br /> and that, therefore, the nominal profit of 44 or 33<br /> per cent, is considerably reduced. H this is the<br /> case, it may fairly be inquired why the price of<br /> £2, for example, is printed upon the back of a<br /> book when every bookseller is ready to sell it at<br /> £1 16s.; and why those who are unacquainted<br /> with that circumstance should be made to pay<br /> more than others who are better informed?<br /> Another reason has been assigned for the great<br /> profit charged upon books, namely, that the pur-<br /> chasers take long credit. This is probably a fact,<br /> and, admitting it, no reasonable person can object<br /> to a proportionate increase of price. But certainly,<br /> it is equally clear that gentlemen who do pay<br /> ready money should not be charged the same<br /> price as those who defer their payments to a very<br /> remote period. In the country there is a greater<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 215 (#649) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> 215<br /> appearance of reason for a considerable allowance<br /> between the retail dealer and the public, because<br /> the profit of the country bookseller will be<br /> diminished by the expense of the conveyance of<br /> the books from London; but even in this case it<br /> appears to be too large when compared with the<br /> rate of interest which capital produces in other<br /> trades.<br /> (297.) &quot;That the profit in retailing books is<br /> really too large is proved by two circumstances:<br /> First, that the same nominal rate of profit<br /> existed in the bookselling trade for a long series<br /> of years, notwithstanding the great fluctuations<br /> in the rate of profit on capital invested in every<br /> other business; secondly, that until very lately a<br /> multitude of booksellers in all parts of London<br /> were willing to be satisfied with a much smaller<br /> profit, and to sell, for ready money, or at short<br /> credit, to persons of uudoubted character, at a<br /> profit of only 10 per cent., and in some instances<br /> even at a still smaller percentage instead of that<br /> of 25 per cent, on the published prices.<br /> &quot;It cannot be pretended that this high rate of<br /> profit is necessary to cover the risk of the book-<br /> seller having some copies left on his shelves,<br /> because he need not buy of the publisher a single<br /> copy more than he has orders for; and even if<br /> he do purchase more at the subscription price, he<br /> proves, by that very purchase, that he himself<br /> does not estimate that risk at above from 4 to 8<br /> per cent. . It should also be remarked, that the<br /> publisher is generally a retail as well as a whole-<br /> sale bookseller; and that beside the profit which<br /> he realises on every copy sold by him in his<br /> capacity of agent, he is allowed to charge the<br /> author as if every copy had been subscribed for<br /> at 4«. 2d., and of course he receives the same<br /> profit as the rest of the trade for those retailed<br /> in his shop.<br /> (298.) &quot;Now a certain number of the London<br /> booksellers have combined together. One of their<br /> objects is to prevent any bookseller from selling<br /> a book at less than 10 per cent, under the pub-<br /> lished price; and, in order to enforce this prin-<br /> ciple, they refuse to sell books, except at the<br /> publishing price, to any bookseller who declines<br /> signing their agreement. By degrees many were<br /> prevailed upon to join this combination; and the<br /> effect of the exclusion it inflicted left the small<br /> capitalist no option between signing or having his<br /> business destroyed. Ultimately nearly the whole<br /> trade, comprising about two thousand four<br /> hundred persons, have signed the agreement.<br /> &quot;As might be naturally expected from an agree-<br /> ment so injurious to many of the parties to it,<br /> disputes have arisen, several booksellers have<br /> been placed under the ban of the combination,<br /> who allege that they have not violated its rules,<br /> and who accuse the opposite party of using spies,<br /> &amp;c, to entrap them.<br /> (299.) &quot;The origin of this combination has<br /> been explained by Mr. Pickering, of Chancery-<br /> lane, himself a publisher, in a printed statement<br /> entitled, &#039; Booksellers&#039; Monopoly.&#039;<br /> &quot;The following list of booksellers has been<br /> copied from that printed at the head of each of<br /> the cases published by Mr. Pickering of the<br /> booksellers who form the committee for conduct-<br /> ing this combination: Allen, J., 7, Leaienhall-<br /> street; Arch, J., 61, Cornhill; Baldwin, R., 47,<br /> Paternoster-row; Booth, J.; Duncan, J., 37,<br /> Paternoster - row; Hatchard, J., Piccadilly;<br /> Marshall, R., Stationers&#039;-court; Murray, J.,<br /> Albemarle-street; Rees, O., Paternoster-row;<br /> Richardson, J. M., 23, Cornhill; Rivington, J.,<br /> St. Paul&#039;s Churchyard; Wilson, E., Royal<br /> Exchange.<br /> (300.) &quot;In whatever manner the profits are<br /> divided between the publisher and the retail<br /> bookseller, the fact remains, that the reader has<br /> paid for the volume in his hands 6s., and that the<br /> author will receive only 3s. ioe?.; out of which<br /> latter sum the expense of printing the volume<br /> must be paid, so that in passing through two<br /> hands this book has produced a profit of 44 per<br /> cent. This excessive rate of profit has drawn<br /> into the book trade a larger share of capital than<br /> was really advantageous, and the competition<br /> between the different portions of that capital has<br /> naturally led to the system of underselling, to<br /> which the committee above-mentioned are en-<br /> deavouring to put a stop.*<br /> &quot;There are two parties who chiefly suffer from<br /> this combination—the public and authors. The<br /> first party can seldom be induced to take an active<br /> part ag linst any grievance; and, in fact, little is<br /> required from it except a cordial support of the<br /> authors in any attempt to destroy a combination<br /> so injurious to the interests of both.<br /> &quot;Many an industrious bookseller would be glad<br /> to sell for 5«. the volume which the reader holds<br /> in his hand, and for which he has paid 6*.; and,<br /> in doing so for ready money, the tradesman who<br /> paid 4*. 6c?. for the book would realise, without<br /> the least risk, a profit of 11 per cent, on the money<br /> he had advanced. It is one of the objects of the<br /> combination we are discussing, to prevent the<br /> small capitalist from employing his capital at<br /> that rate of profit which he thinks most advan-<br /> * The monopoly cases, Nos. 1,2, and 3 of those published<br /> by Mr. Pickering, should be oonsulted; and as the pnblic<br /> will be better able to form a judgment by hearing the other<br /> side of the question, perhaps the chairman of the 00m-<br /> mittee (Mr. Richardson) would print those regulations<br /> respecting the trade, a copy of which Mr. Piokering states<br /> is refused by the committee even to those who sign thorn.<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 216 (#650) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> tageous to himself; and such a proceeding is<br /> decidedly injurious to the public.<br /> (301.) &quot;Having derived little pecuniary advan-<br /> tage from my own literary productions ; and being<br /> aware that from the very nature of their subjects<br /> they can scarcely be expected to reimburse the<br /> expense of preparing tbem, I may be permitted to<br /> offer an opinion which I believe to be as little<br /> influenced by any expectation of advantage from<br /> the future, as it is by any disappointment at the<br /> past.<br /> &quot;Before, however, we proceed to sketch the plan<br /> of a campaign against Paternoster-row, it will be<br /> fit to inform the reader of the nature of the<br /> enemy&#039;s forces and his means of attack and defence.<br /> &quot;Several of the great publishers find it con-<br /> venient to be the proprietors of reviews, maga-<br /> zines, journals, and even of newspapers. The<br /> editors are paid in some instances very hand-<br /> somely for their superintendence, and it is<br /> scarcely to be expected that they should always<br /> mete out the severest justice on works by the<br /> sale of which their employers are enriched. The<br /> great and popular works of the day are, of course,<br /> reviewed with some care, and with deference to<br /> public opinion. Without this the journals would<br /> not sell, and it is convenient to be able to quote<br /> such articles as instances of impartiality. Under<br /> shelter of this a host of ephemeral productions<br /> are written into a transitory popularity; and by<br /> the aid of this process the shelves of the book-<br /> seller, as well as the pockets of the public, are<br /> disencumbered. To such an extent are these<br /> means employed, that some of the periodical pub-<br /> lications of the day ought to be regarded merely<br /> as advertising machines. That the reader may<br /> be in some measure on his guard against such<br /> modes of influencing his judgment, he should<br /> examine whether the work reviewed is published<br /> by the bookseller who is the proprietor of the<br /> review, a fact which can sometimes be ascertained<br /> from the title of the book as given at the head of<br /> the article. But this is by no means a certain<br /> criterion, because partnerships in various publica-<br /> tions exist between houses in the book trade,<br /> which are not generally known to the public; so<br /> that, in fact, until reviews are established in<br /> which booksellers have no interest, they can<br /> never be safely trusted.<br /> (302.) &quot;In order to put down the combination<br /> of booksellers, no plan appears so likely to succeed<br /> as a counter-association of authors. If any con-<br /> siderable portion of the literary world were to<br /> unite and form such an association; and if its<br /> affairs were directed by an active committee much<br /> might be accomplished. The object of this union<br /> should be to employ some person well skilled in<br /> the printing and in the bookselling trade, and to<br /> establish him in some central situation as their<br /> agent. Each member of the association to be at<br /> liberty to place any or all of his works in the<br /> hands of this agent for sale; to allow any adver-<br /> tisements or list of books, published by members<br /> of the association, to be stitched up at the end<br /> of each of his own productions, the expense of<br /> preparing them being defrayed by the proprietors<br /> of the books advertised.<br /> &quot;The duties of the agent would be to retail to the<br /> public for ready money, copies of books published<br /> by members of the association. To sell to the<br /> trade, at prices agreed upon, any copies they may<br /> require. To cause to be inserted in the journals,<br /> or at the end of works published by members, any<br /> advertisements which the committee or authors<br /> may direct. To prepare a general catalogue of the<br /> works of members. To be the agent for any<br /> member of the association in treating respecting<br /> the printing of any work.<br /> &quot;Such a union would naturally present other<br /> advantages, and as each author would retain the<br /> liberty of putting any price he might think fit on<br /> his productions, the public would still have the<br /> advantage of reduction in price produced by com-<br /> petition between authors on the same subject, as<br /> well as of that arising from a cheaper mode of<br /> publishing the volumes sold to them.<br /> (303.) &quot;Possibly one of the consequences re-<br /> sulting from such an association would be the<br /> establishment of a good and an impartial Review,<br /> a work whose want has been felt lor several years.<br /> The two long-established and celebrated Reviews,<br /> the unbending champions of the most opposite<br /> political opinions, are, from widely different<br /> causes, exhibiting unequivocal signs of decrepi-<br /> tude and decay. The Quarterly advocate of<br /> despotic principles is fast receding from the<br /> advancing intelligence of the age, and the new<br /> strength and new position which that intelligence<br /> has acquired for itself demands for its expression<br /> new organs, equally the representatives of its<br /> intellectual power and of its moral energies;<br /> whilst, on the other hand, the sceptre of its<br /> Northern rival has passed from the vigorous<br /> grasp of those who established its dominion into<br /> feebler hands.<br /> &quot;A difficulty has been stated that those most<br /> competent to supply periodical criticism are<br /> already engaged. But it is to be observed that<br /> there are many who now supply literary criticisms<br /> to journals whose political principles they disap-<br /> prove, and that, if once a respectable and well-<br /> supported Review* were established, capable of<br /> * At the moment when this opinion aa to the necessity<br /> for a new Review was passing through the press, I was<br /> informed that the elements of snoh an undertaking were<br /> already organised.<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 217 (#651) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> 217<br /> competing, in payment to its contributors, with<br /> the wealthiest of its rivals, it would very soon be<br /> supplied with the best materials the country can<br /> produce.f&quot;<br /> ME. BALFOUR ON THE NOVEL.<br /> MR. ARTHUR J. BALFOUR, M.P., pro-<br /> posed the toast of &quot;Literature&quot; at the<br /> fourth annual dinner of the Sir Walter<br /> Scott Club, held in Edinburgh on the 20th ult.<br /> He said it was hard to believe there was a time<br /> when the world did without novels, and, in its<br /> own opinion, did well without novels. Like<br /> tobacco and the daily Press, novels had now<br /> become a general necessity. It was an interest-<br /> ing speculation to reflect what the future of the<br /> novel was to be. He took it that there was<br /> hardly any instance in literature of any sub-class<br /> of composition being cultivated with success for<br /> an indefinite period. The cause of decay was<br /> commonly to be found either in the habit of<br /> driving peculiarities to excess so that the whole<br /> species of composition seemed weighed down by<br /> its own exaggerations, or else dying away in a<br /> kind of senile imbecility and perishing slowly<br /> amid general contempt. An example of the first<br /> kind they found in the death of the Elizabethan<br /> drama, and of the second in that particular<br /> kind of literature of which Pope was the<br /> greatest ornament. But as to the novel, if<br /> there were any signs of decadence, peihaps<br /> they should look for it in the obvious difficulty<br /> which novelists now found in getting hold<br /> of appropriate subjects for their art to deal<br /> with. Scott, however, had not only his unique<br /> genius to depend upon; he had the specially<br /> good fortune to open an entirely new vein.<br /> Where was the modern novelist to find a new<br /> vein? Every country had been ransacked to<br /> obtain theatres upon which their imaginary<br /> characters were to show themselves. They had<br /> stories of civilised life, of semi-civilised life, of<br /> barbarous life. They had novels of the natural<br /> and the supernatural; they had scientific novels,<br /> and they had thaumaturgic novels. So hardly<br /> set were they for subjects that even the quint-<br /> essence of dulness was extracted from the dullest<br /> t It baa been suggested to me that the doctrines main-<br /> tained in this chapter may subject the present volume to the<br /> opposition of that combination which it has opposed. I do<br /> not entdrtain that opinion, and for this reason—that the<br /> booksellers are too shrewd a class to supply such an admirable<br /> passport to publicity. But, should my readers take a diffe-<br /> rent view of the question, they can easily assist in remedy-<br /> ing the evil by each mentioning the existence of this little<br /> volume to two of his friends.<br /> localities, and turned into a subject of artistic<br /> treatment. Yet there was one aspect of human<br /> nature, and perhaps the most interesting of all,<br /> which for obvious reasons had been very<br /> sparingly treated by the novelists—the develop-<br /> ment of character extending through the life of<br /> the individual. A novel seldom or never—not in<br /> one case in a thousand—attempted to take an<br /> individual and trace what in natural science<br /> would be called his life history. It would be<br /> very inappropriate and very unnecessary to dwell<br /> upon reasons why this biographical form of<br /> fiction was difficult—he would not say impossible<br /> —and he certainly did not venture to foretell that<br /> any artist would be found who would be able to<br /> overcome them. Whatever be the future of the<br /> novel, they might always console themselves with<br /> the reflection that every great literary revival had<br /> been preceded by a period in which no revival<br /> could by any possibility have been anticipated by<br /> the closest critics of the time. He doubted<br /> whether any contemporary of Sydney could have<br /> foreseen Shakespeare; he doubted whether any-<br /> body living in the Commonwealth was likely to<br /> have foreseen Dry den in his maturity. He felt<br /> sure nobody living in the time of Johnson could<br /> really have foreseen Wordsworth, Coleridge, and<br /> Scott. But though the provinces of literature<br /> were many, the kingdom of literature was one;<br /> however diverse were the fields, they all furthered<br /> one cause. He did not pretend that literature<br /> necessarily softened the manners or carried all<br /> the cardinal virtues in its train. But it was the<br /> greatest engine for the production of cultivated<br /> happiness. It was daily producing more innocent<br /> and refined pleasure in every class in every<br /> country where education was known than any<br /> other source of pleasure.<br /> INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS OF AUTHORS.<br /> IN the recent &quot; Memoir&quot; the evidences given of<br /> good feeling toward America and Americans<br /> on the part of Lord Tennyson have been<br /> noted in the papers. To be sure, one might ask,<br /> &quot;Why not r And yet there were special annoy-<br /> ances from American sources which must have<br /> been particularly trying.<br /> An American man of letters visiting England,<br /> years ago, spent some time not far from Fresh-<br /> water. Knowing many of Tennyson&#039;s American<br /> and English friends, it would have been natural,<br /> perhaps, for him to obtain an introduction; yet<br /> he even kept away from Tennyson&#039;s end of the<br /> Isle of Wight. Meeting once, in London, the<br /> younger son of the Laureate, he told him he could<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 218 (#652) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> tell his father that at least one American was not<br /> peering over his fences or shying stones at his<br /> Farringford chickens.<br /> The prying English tourist made himself a<br /> nuisance to the Laureate; but the tourist who<br /> came across the seas was, perhaps, a little more<br /> likely to be troublesome, owing to his greater<br /> enthusiasm and enterprise.<br /> But, however a sensitive bard may have resented<br /> intrusion upon his privacy, and whatever com-<br /> plaints of their inconsiderate countrymen some<br /> visiting Americans may at times have had to listen<br /> to, it is evident that good feeling for &quot; kin across<br /> sea &quot; was at the bottom of the poet&#039;s large heart.<br /> Some of his American friends are named in the<br /> book, but there were other American acquaint-<br /> ances, some of an earlier date than certain of<br /> those chronicled. There were Americans unknown<br /> to fame who met with warm welcome from the<br /> master of Farringford, and gained there a<br /> genuine, helpful, and lasting friendship.<br /> A pleasant chapter in the curiosities of English<br /> literature could be made of international literary<br /> relations—those between Scott and Irving, Emer-<br /> son and Carlyle, for instance. Such a chapter<br /> might include the friendship of American and<br /> English writers with individuals less distinguished<br /> of the opposite country. Some of the most inti-<br /> mate friends of the Brownings were Americans,<br /> and Lowell had English friends true and stead-<br /> fast.<br /> International relations of this kind do not<br /> depend upon any treaty; they ought to, and do,<br /> favourably affect the public opinion of the two<br /> countries. While writers on both sides have done<br /> much to fan the flames of unreasoned prejudice,<br /> men of letters, being often, fortunately, men of<br /> imagination, insight, and goodwill, have also stood<br /> for brotherhood, and not for the brutal inherited<br /> instinct of fight.— &quot; Topics of the Time,&quot; Century<br /> Magazine Christmas number.<br /> PERSONAL.<br /> THE American Ambassador, Colonel John<br /> Hay, was the guest of the Omar Khayyam<br /> Club at its first dinner of the season, held<br /> in Frascati&#039;s Restaurant on Dec. 8, Mr. Henry<br /> Norman, the president, in the chair. His Excel-<br /> lency passed an eloquent eulogy upon FitzGerald&#039;s<br /> translations of the Quatrains. Omar was a Fitz-<br /> Gerald before the letter, or FitzGerald was a<br /> reincarnation of Omar. Each seemed greater<br /> than his work. Omar sang to a half barbarous<br /> province, FitzGerald to the world. Wherever the<br /> English speech is spoken or read the Rubaiyat had<br /> taken their place as a classic. He heard Omar<br /> quoted once in one of the most lonely and desolate<br /> spots of the high Rockies. Certainly, Omar could<br /> never be numbered among the great popular<br /> writers of all time. The suffrages of the crowd<br /> were not for the cool, collected observer, whose<br /> eye no glitter could dazzle, no mist suffuse.<br /> Mr. Augustine Birrell, Q-O, M.P., delivered an<br /> address at the Commemoration Service of Brown-<br /> ing, held at the Robert Browning Settlement,<br /> Walworth, on the 12th ult. The obscure poet of<br /> the obscure &quot; Sordello,&quot; he said, had an influence<br /> on literature which was indescribably majestic.<br /> Like Carlyle and Tennyson, he never bowed the<br /> knee to Baal. Poverty they knew, and depression<br /> of spirit, but no one of them abated a jot or tittle<br /> of his pretensions, or ever asked the people what<br /> they wanted. Browning&#039;s religious belief was<br /> not attained through the dark and mystical<br /> passage of the Sacraments, but rather was the<br /> result of a firm belief in a personal God, and his<br /> strong faith in the soul of man. To call him a<br /> cheerful poet would be wrong. He was too well<br /> read in the literature of hell. But he was indeed<br /> a cheering poet.<br /> The Christmas dinner of the New Vagabond<br /> Club took place in Holborn Restaurant on the<br /> 10th ult. The company was very numerous, and<br /> included many ladies. Mr. Israel Zangwill pre-<br /> sided, and Lord Charles Beresford was the<br /> particular guest.<br /> Lord Rosebery, speaking at the annual meeting<br /> of the Scottish History Society, suggested that<br /> there should be a book of those dignities which<br /> were conferred by the Stuarts after their depar-<br /> ture from England in 1689.<br /> Owing to the pressure of the Jubilee year, the<br /> committee charged with the project of a memorial<br /> to Robert Louis Stevenson in Edinburgh did not<br /> make an urgent appeal for subscriptions in the<br /> year just closed. They will now shortly do so.<br /> As to the form the memorial shall take, a<br /> monument in St. Giles&#039;s Cathedral and another<br /> on Calton Hill are suggested.<br /> Professor Masson, who for thirty years occupied<br /> the chair of English Literature in the University<br /> of Edinburgh, has been presented with his portrait<br /> painted by Sir George Reid.<br /> CORRESPONDENCE.<br /> I.—A Young Author&#039;s Gbievancb.<br /> IRECENTLY read some letters in The Author<br /> complaining of the time taken by editors in<br /> returning rejected MSS. Personally I have<br /> always found that rejected MSS. were returned<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 219 (#653) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> within a reasonable time, and it must be remem-<br /> bered that contributions sent in on chance are<br /> not invited. When, however, an editor has<br /> personally interviewed an author, and verbally<br /> arranged with him to accept a certain article for a<br /> certain number of a magazine, the author natu-<br /> rally looks for his article in—let us say, the<br /> number for June.<br /> The proof is sent to the writer some time in<br /> May, but on looking at the magazine in June he<br /> is often doomed to disappointment—at least if he<br /> is a young author feeling his way. None of his<br /> work appears. He calls on the editor, and is told<br /> that his article was &quot;crowded out,&quot; but that it<br /> will appear in July. He looks again in the July<br /> number, but to no purpose.<br /> He is put off with the same excuse for three,<br /> four, or even six months.<br /> All this time he is obliged to stand out of his<br /> money. Of course such a thing could not<br /> happen to a well known man, but most of us<br /> must climb the ladder of fame by degrees. This<br /> is essentially a young author&#039;s grievance, and is<br /> felt by those who are entirely dependent on their<br /> pens. C. B. B.<br /> II.—The Published Peice.<br /> It is satisfactory to learn from Mr. Millar&#039;s<br /> letter in your last issue that the Dundee Adver-<br /> tiser, as well as Literature, the Literary World,<br /> and the Bookman, announces in the reviews<br /> themselves the prices of all b &gt;oks reviewed. It<br /> may, perhaps, be hoped that this at present very<br /> rare practice may gradually become more general,<br /> and that publishers and authors will combine to<br /> encourage it by procuring the price to be marked<br /> on the binding, or a notification of the price to<br /> be sent out with the review copies, and by<br /> selecting as recipients of review copies those<br /> newspapers which adopt the practice.<br /> By the way, of the 379 &quot;books of the month&quot;<br /> catalogued in your last issue at page 198, I<br /> observe that no less than thirty-seven—about<br /> one-tenth of the whole—have no price affixed to<br /> them. How are the prices of the omitted thirty-<br /> seven to be ascertained? J. M. Lely.<br /> Dec. 20.<br /> BOOS TALE.<br /> ME. MACKENZIE BELL&#039;S memoir of<br /> Miss Christina Rossetti will be pub-<br /> lished by Messrs. Hurst and Blackett<br /> early this month. Two offers of marriage, we<br /> are told, were made to Miss Rossetti, but the<br /> charming lady simply chose to be an &quot;old maid.&quot;<br /> This volume will give for the first a little Italian<br /> &quot;octave &quot; written by her father, Gabriele Rossetti,<br /> in celebration of his &quot; dear daughters&quot; Christina<br /> a.nd Maria—&quot; fresh violets, opened at dawn.&quot;<br /> Mr. Bell also records that Miss Rossetti and her<br /> brothers and sisters were accustomed to address<br /> their father invariably in Italian, his native<br /> language. Several portraits of the poetess will<br /> appear in the memoir, including, as frontispiece,<br /> a reproduction of the chalk drawing of his sister,<br /> which Dante Rossetti executed in 1866.<br /> The scene of Mr. Rider Haggard&#039;s new<br /> historical romance is laid in Holland in the days<br /> of William of Orange. He has also engaged to<br /> write for the Graphic a story of the Boers at the<br /> time of their great trek in 1836. It will be called<br /> &quot;Swallow,&quot; and will commence in the above<br /> journal in the latter part of this year.<br /> Mr. Gilbert Parker has written a storv called<br /> &quot;Mrs. Falchion.&quot;<br /> Mr. Max Pemberton has gone to the Balearic<br /> Isles, which will be the scene of his next<br /> story.<br /> Mr. E. L. Voynich, author of &quot;The Gadfly,&quot;<br /> is about to visit Austria in order to collect<br /> material for a work dealing with contemporary<br /> life there.<br /> Mr. Henry Seton Merriman has written for<br /> Harper&#039;s Magazine, beginning with the January<br /> number, a novel entitled &quot; Roden&#039;s Corner.&quot;<br /> The score or so letters which passed between<br /> Emerson and Sterling, and which were briefly<br /> noticed in The Author a few months ago, are<br /> now to be published by Messrs. Gay and Bird<br /> in book form, edited by Edward Waldo Emerson,<br /> and entitled &quot;A Correspondence between John<br /> Sterling and Ralph Waldo Emerson.&quot; The<br /> letters appeared during last year in the Atlantic<br /> Monthly.<br /> Mr. William Black has completed his new<br /> novel, and entitled it &quot;Wild Eelin; otherwise<br /> called Eelin of the Eyes like the Sea Wave.&quot;<br /> It will begin its course as a serial this month.<br /> Miss Lilian Goadby is retelling the story of<br /> Homer&#039;s Iliad for bovs and girls. The book,<br /> entitled &quot;The Wrath of Achilles,&quot; will be pub-<br /> lished shortly by Messrs. Edwin, Vaughan and<br /> Co.<br /> Mr. Anthony Hope has written a sequel to<br /> &quot;The Prisoner&#039; of Zenda,&quot; entitled &quot;Rupert of<br /> Hentzau.&quot; It is now running serially in the Pall<br /> Mall Magazine.<br /> Miss Emily Lawless is publishing with Messrs.<br /> Methuen a volume of Irish stories, entitled<br /> &quot;Traits and Confidences.&quot;<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 220 (#654) ############################################<br /> <br /> 2 20<br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> Mr. Bram Stoker has written the first story—<br /> &quot;Miss Betty,&quot; a seventeenth century romance—<br /> for a new fiction series, which Messrs. C. Arthur<br /> Pearson and Co. are projecting. This series<br /> aspires to give in each volume six shillings&#039; worth<br /> of material for half-a-crown. Mr. Stoker&#039;s<br /> volume will appear this month. Succeeding<br /> volumes, to be issued at monthly intervals, will be<br /> by Messrs. W. L. Alden, Clive Holland, Joseph<br /> Hatton, Douglas Sladen, George Griffith, Fred.<br /> Whishaw, and others.<br /> Miss Adeline Sergeant has completed a novel<br /> called &quot;The Lady Charlotte &quot; for publication by<br /> Messrs. Hutchinson shortly.<br /> Mr. Grant Allen has written a story entitled<br /> &quot;The Incidental Bishop.&quot;<br /> Mr. William Le Queux is staying at Milan, and<br /> writing a novol to be called &quot;Scribes and<br /> Pharisees.&quot;<br /> Mr. Robert H. Sherard is writing the story of<br /> the Dreyfus case for an American magazine.<br /> &quot;David Lyall&#039;s Love Story&quot; is a volume of<br /> Scotch idylls which Messrs. Hodder and Stough-<br /> ton are publishing immediately. There has been<br /> much speculation as to the identity of &quot;David<br /> Lyall,&quot; the author of this work and of &quot; The Land<br /> o&#039; the Leal.&quot; We believe she is a sister of Annie<br /> Swan (Mrs. Burnett Smith).<br /> The Christmas number of Good Words con-<br /> sisted of a novel entitled &quot; The Looms of Time,&quot;<br /> by Mrs. Hugh Fraser. It will be published in<br /> book form by Messrs. Isbister during the spring.<br /> Mrs. de Courcy Laffan (&quot; Mrs Leith Adams &quot;) is<br /> writing a novel called &quot; The Prince&#039;s Feathers: a<br /> Story of Leafy Warwickshire in the Olden Time,&quot;<br /> and a story of public school life entitled &quot;The<br /> Gift of God.&quot;<br /> &quot;A Voyage of Consolation&quot; is the title of a<br /> new story by Mrs. Everard Cotes.<br /> Mrs. Pendler Cudlip (&quot; Annie Thomas &quot;) has a<br /> novel, &quot;Dick Rivers,&quot; about to be published by<br /> Messrs. F. V. White and Co. She is engaged<br /> upon another, to be called &quot;Between the Devil<br /> and the Deep Sea,&quot; and also upon a group of<br /> stories for Messrs. Tillotson.<br /> Mrs. Lovett Cameron&#039;s new novel &quot;Devil&#039;s<br /> Apples,&quot; will be published this month by Messrs.<br /> White.<br /> Mr. R. Andom has written of cycling incidents<br /> and misadventures in a volume entitled &quot;Side<br /> Slips&quot; which Messrs. Pearson will publish.<br /> &quot;Scenes from the Suburbs &quot; is another humorous<br /> work by the same author, which will be published<br /> by Messrs. Jarrold. The books will appear in<br /> the spring, the former illustrated by Mr. A.<br /> Frederick, the latter by Mr. A. Carruthers<br /> Gould.<br /> A volume of Stories from soldier fife, by Mr.<br /> E. Livingston Prescott, will be published this<br /> month by Messrs. Warne. The author has now<br /> in hand a romance (not military), entitled &quot; Dearer<br /> than Honour.&quot;<br /> Mr. Archibald Forbes&#039;s &quot;Life of Louis Napo-<br /> leon&quot; will be ready about the middle of the<br /> month. It will contain, among other illustrations,<br /> a drawing of the house which, prior to 1848, the<br /> future head of the Third Empire occupied in<br /> London.<br /> Mr. Richard Kearton, F.Z.S., is writing a series<br /> of sketches and tales of open-air life in the North<br /> of England.<br /> Dr. W. G. Blaikie is writing the life of the late<br /> Principal David Brown, of the Free Church<br /> College, Aberdeen.<br /> Professor Max MUller&#039;s recollections of royalty,<br /> and of musical, literary, and social life, which<br /> have appeared in Cosmopolis, will be published<br /> shortly in a volume by Messrs. Longmans, Green,<br /> and Co., under the title &quot; Auld Lang Syne.&quot;<br /> The features of Cosmopolis this year will<br /> include, in English, unpublished letters of John<br /> Mill and notes of Coleridge; in French, the<br /> letters of Emile Ollivier to Richard Wagner, the<br /> correspondence of Marshal Magnan, and the<br /> memoirs of the painter Ingres; and in German,<br /> further correspondence of Tourguenieff. Mr.<br /> Meredith has written three &quot; Odes in Contribu-<br /> tion to the Song of French History,&quot; entitled<br /> &quot;The Revolution,&quot; &quot;Napoleon,&quot; &quot;Alsace-<br /> Lorraine,&quot; which will appear in the numbers for<br /> March, April, and May.<br /> The manuscript of &quot;In Memoriam,&quot; given by<br /> the poet to the late Sir John Simeon, has been<br /> presented by the Hon. Lady Simeon to the library<br /> of Trinity College, Cambridge, Tennyson&#039;s own<br /> college, to which he intended it should fall.<br /> A volume of sporting reminiscences by Mr.<br /> Thomas Haydon will shortly be published by<br /> Messrs. Bliss, Sands, and Co.<br /> Mr. R. Farquharson Sharp, of the British<br /> Museum, has compiled &quot; A Dictionary of English<br /> Authors, Biographical and Bibliographical,&quot; being<br /> a compendious account of the lives and writings<br /> of 700 British writers from the year 1400 to the<br /> present time. Mr. George Redway will publish<br /> the work.<br /> English translations of two notable French<br /> works will be published shortly, simultaneously<br /> with the appearance of the originals in Paris.<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 221 (#655) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> 221<br /> These are M. Zola&#039;s new novel &quot;Paris,&quot; trans-<br /> lated by Mr. Vizetelly; and M. Huysman&#039;s &quot; La<br /> Cathedrale,&quot; whose translator is Mrs. Clara Bell.<br /> Mr. William Archer and Miss Diana White<br /> have completed their translation, from the<br /> Danish, of Dr. Georg Brandes&#039;s critical study<br /> of Shakespeare.<br /> The important work &quot;Industrial Democracy,&quot;<br /> upon which Mr. and Mrs. Sidney Webb have<br /> long been engaged, is to be issued by Messrs.<br /> Longmans on the 4th.<br /> Prince Henry of Orleans&#039;s book of travels,<br /> &quot;Tonkin to India,&quot; is due this week from Messrs.<br /> Methuen.<br /> Sir Martin Conway&#039;s &quot;Climbing and Explora-<br /> tion in the Karakoram Himalayas&quot; (Unwin,<br /> 1894) having been translated into French and<br /> published serially in the Tour du Monde, is now<br /> issued, abridged, in book form, by MM. Hachette<br /> et Cie. Several of Mr. A. D. McCormick&#039;s<br /> pictures to the work are reproduced in the French<br /> volume.<br /> A propos the teaching of English literature in<br /> schools, the Academy notes that a recent school<br /> edition of Carlyle&#039;s essay, &quot; The Hero as Divinity&quot;<br /> (George Bell and Sons) is composed as follows:<br /> Introduction, 90 pages; Carlyle&#039;s Essay, 42<br /> pages; Notes, 53 pages; Index, 4 pages. The<br /> essay thus forms about 22 per cent, of the whole,<br /> and our contemporary asks whether it is the<br /> powder or the jam.<br /> America sent over a story the other day, which<br /> had some appearance of actuality, telling of a<br /> popular music-hall artiste having been subjected<br /> to a kissing test. How many kisses could a<br /> woman stand? The limit of endurance was<br /> reached, if we remember the story rightly, at 547<br /> or thereabouts. Our brisk Chicago contemporary,<br /> the Chap-Book, on the other hand, has just been<br /> discovering what it calls &quot;the most thoroughly<br /> kissed young woman in English fiction.&quot; This<br /> curiosity, it avers, is the heroine Birdalone in<br /> William Morris&#039;s posthumous romance &quot;The<br /> Water of the Wondrous Isles.&quot; She is pissed<br /> eighty-six times according to the analysis of the<br /> Chap-Book—fifty-two by men, and thirty-four by<br /> women and children. Here is a summary and<br /> description of the men&#039;s kisses :—<br /> 1 Merchant<br /> 4 Peasants<br /> 8 Servants<br /> Hands.<br /> Feet<br /> Face.<br /> Mouth.<br /> 4 ...<br /> ... 2 ...<br /> ... 0 ...<br /> ... 1 ..<br /> 0 ...<br /> ... 1 ...<br /> » ...<br /> ... 0 ...<br /> 6 ...<br /> 13<br /> t<br /> 3<br /> 33<br /> Mr. A. C. Benson is writing a biographical<br /> history of Eton and leading Etonians.<br /> Mr. Edward Marston will shortly have ready<br /> another book on outdoor life. There will be an<br /> Edition de lujce. The publishers are, of course,<br /> Messrs. Sampson Low, Marston and Co.<br /> Mr. E. F. Benson is preparing for publication<br /> by Messrs. Methuen his story called &quot;The<br /> Vintage,&quot; which has been appearing in the<br /> Graphic. It deals with the opening year of the<br /> Greek War of Independence in 1820.<br /> A new publisher. He is John Long, 6, Chandos-<br /> street, Strand. Mr. Long&#039;s programme is:<br /> &quot;Fiction by popular authors; fiction by new<br /> writers of undoubted promise; works of travel;<br /> medical works; poetry that may appeal to the<br /> public.&quot;<br /> A re-edited and enlarged edition of Dickinson&#039;s<br /> &quot;Glossary of Cumberland Words and Phrases&quot;<br /> is to be published, by subscription, by Dr. E. W.<br /> Prevost, of Newnham, Glos. The work was origi-<br /> nally published by the English Dialect Society.<br /> Many words and phrases are being added in the<br /> re-issue.<br /> A special sub-committee of the Publishers&#039;<br /> Association is considering the subject of title-<br /> pages.<br /> The late strike of printers in Edinburgh caused<br /> delay in the appearance of a number of books<br /> during the past month. One that has suffered<br /> postponement from this cause is the biography of<br /> the Prince of Wales, which Mr. Grant Richards<br /> now expects to publish early this month. The<br /> narrative is said to exhibit &quot;a truly loyal and<br /> intelligent appreciation of His Royal Highness&#039;s<br /> career and his services to his country.&quot;<br /> The first representation of the play &quot; Admiral<br /> Guinea,&quot; by Messrs. W. E. Henley and Robert<br /> Louis Stevenson, took place on Nov. 29 at the<br /> Avenue Theatre, London. It was produced by<br /> the New Century Theatre Company, and got a<br /> favourable reception. Immediately before the<br /> rising of the curtain Miss Elizabeth Robins<br /> delivered a prologue written for the oocasion by<br /> Mr. Henley, of which the following is a part:<br /> Once was a pair of Friends, who loved to chance<br /> Their feet In any by-way of Romance.<br /> They, like two vagabond schoolboys, unafraid<br /> Of stark impossibilities, essayed<br /> To make these Penitent and Impenitent ThieveB,<br /> These Pews and Oaunts, each man of them with his sheaves<br /> Of humour, passion, cruelty, tyranny, life,<br /> Fit shadows for the boards: till in the Btiifo<br /> Of dream with dream, their Slaver-Saint came true,<br /> And their Blind Pirate, their resurgent Pew<br /> (A figure of deadly farce In his new birth)<br /> Tap-tapped his way from Hades back to earth;<br /> And so, their Lover and his Lass made one.<br /> In their beat prose this Admiral here was done.<br /> One of this Pair sleeps Ull the crack of doom<br /> Where the great ocean-rollers plunge and boom,<br /> The other waits and wonders what his Friend,<br /> Dead now, and deaf, and silent, were the end<br /> Revealed to his rare spirit would find to say<br /> If you, his lovers, loved him for this Play.<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 222 (#656) ############################################<br /> <br /> 222<br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> Mrs. Sara H. Dunn has written &quot;Sunny<br /> Memories of an Indian Winter,&quot; which Messrs.<br /> Walter Scott Limited will publish.<br /> Mr. W. E. Henley has resigned the editorship<br /> of the New Review, which hereupon ceases to be<br /> a monthly magazine. Uncertain health and the<br /> necessities of his own literary work have com-<br /> pelled Mr. Henley&#039;s retirement. The Review,<br /> completely transformed, will appear shortly as a<br /> weekly journal, price 3c?.<br /> Mr. James Britten retires from the editorship<br /> of Nature Notes, which he has conducted for six<br /> years.<br /> Mr. E. Heron-Allen is translating Omar<br /> Khayyam&#039;s &quot; Rubaiyat,&quot; from the original Persian,<br /> Many quatrains not hitherto translated will be<br /> included, and the original Persian text will also<br /> be given page for page. Messrs. H. S. Nichols<br /> and Co. are the publishers.<br /> Early in the year an illustrated book of<br /> &quot;Allegories,&quot; by Dean Farrar, will be published<br /> by Messrs. Longmans, Green, and Co. He has<br /> in hand a more important work which will be<br /> called &quot;Texts Rightly Interpreted.&quot;<br /> Gallant little Wales now comes in for its<br /> volume in the series of Stories of the Nations,<br /> published by Mr. Unwin. The writer of the<br /> history is Mr. Owen M. Edwards, Fellow of<br /> Lincoln College, Oxford. The same publisher<br /> will shortly issue a volume entitled &quot; The Welsh<br /> People,&quot; consisting of a series of essays, by Pro-<br /> fessor Rhys and Mr. Brynmor Jones, on the<br /> history, antiquities, ancient laws and customs, and<br /> the social characteristics of Wales.<br /> Mr. Oscar Browning is to write a life of Charles<br /> XII. of Sweden, which Messrs. Hurst and<br /> Blackett will publish. The same writer&#039;s Life<br /> of Peter the Great is on the point of publication<br /> by Messrs. Hutchinson and Co.<br /> A century and a half is a long life for a news-<br /> paper. The Aberdeen Journal first appeared on<br /> Jan. 5, 1748, so that in a day or two it will have<br /> completed its 150th year. Some time ago it<br /> published a pamphlet recording its life-history.<br /> It was founded by a fellow-apprentice of Benjamin<br /> Franklin; its conductors bore an exciting patt in<br /> the romantic rebellion of &#039;45; it chronicled the<br /> visit of Dr. Johnson and Boswell to Aberdeen<br /> and the north; and its office was visited by<br /> Robert Burns. In the United Kingdom only<br /> four other daily newspapers of to-day can call up<br /> a longer flight of years than the Aberdeen Journal.<br /> They are Leeds Mercury (1718), Bristol Times<br /> and Mirror (1735), Be/fast News Letter (1737),<br /> and Birmingham Gazette (1741). The oldest<br /> existing newspaper in the world is the Gazette de<br /> France (1631), for which Louis XIII. wrote an<br /> article.<br /> Mr. Inderwick W. Foster has published<br /> (Biscoke and Son, Richmond) a Bibliography<br /> of Lawn Tennis (1874-1897). The work contains<br /> titles and particulars of nearly 250 books,<br /> pamphlets, &lt;fec, on the game of lawn tennis.<br /> Professor Buchheim, who has already contri-<br /> buted two popular volumes to Macmillan&#039;s &quot; Golden<br /> Treasury Series,&quot; viz., &quot;Deutsche Lyrike&quot; and<br /> &quot;Balladen und Romanzen,&quot; will shortly add a<br /> third volume, entitled, &quot;Heine&#039;s Lieder und<br /> Gedichte,&quot; selected, and edited with notes and an<br /> introduction. We also hear that the professor,<br /> who, by-the-bye, has recently received the honorary<br /> degree of M.A. from the University of Oxford, is<br /> engaged on a monograph treating of the attempts<br /> made in this country and America to popularise<br /> Heine as a poet and a prose writer.<br /> Mr. Rider Haggard, at the request of the Com<br /> mittee of Management, has writteu a Christmas<br /> appeal for the Victoria Hospital for Children at<br /> Chelsea. It is called &quot;A Visit to the Victoria<br /> Hospital.&quot;<br /> The Daily Chronicle has discovered a new<br /> poet—Mr. Henry Newbolt (London: Elkin<br /> Matthews, ii.) I have sent for a copy of his<br /> poems. Meantime, I venture to extract one poem<br /> from the columns of the Daily Chronicle in the<br /> belief that it will send all our readers straight<br /> to their booksellers to order a copy.<br /> DRAKE&#039;S DRUM.<br /> Drake he was a Devon man, an&#039; ruled the Devon seaa<br /> (Capten, art tha sleepin&#039; there below P),<br /> Rovin&#039; tho&#039; his death fell, he went wi&#039; heart at ease,<br /> An&#039; dreamin&#039; arl the time 0&#039; Plymouth Hoe.<br /> &quot;Take my drum to England, hang et by the shore,<br /> Strike et when your powder&#039;s runnin&#039; low;<br /> If the Dons sight Devon, I&#039;ll qnit the port o&#039; Heaven,<br /> An&#039; drum them up the Channel as we drummed them long<br /> ago.&quot;<br /> Drake he&#039;s in his hammock an&#039; a thousand mile away,<br /> (Capten, art tha sleepin&#039; there below ?),<br /> Slung atween the round shot in Nombre Dios Bay,<br /> An&#039; dreamin&#039; arl the time o&#039; Plymouth Hoe.<br /> Yarnder lames the island, yarnder lie the ships,<br /> Wi&#039; sailor lads a-danoin&#039; heel-an&#039;-toe,<br /> An&#039; the shore-lights flashin&#039;, an&#039; the night-tide dashin&#039;,<br /> He sees et arl so plainly as he saw et long ago.<br /> Drake lies in his hammock till the great Armadas oome,<br /> (Capten, art tha sleepin&#039; there below P),<br /> Slung atween the round shot, listenin&#039; for the drum,<br /> An&#039; dreamin&#039; arl the time o&#039; Plymouth Hoe.<br /> Call him on the deep sea, call him np the Sound,<br /> Call him when ye sail to meet the foe;<br /> Where the old trade&#039;s plyin&#039; an&#039; the old flag flyin&#039;,<br /> They shall find him ware an&#039; wakin&#039;, as they found him<br /> long ago.<br /> Early this year Sir Charles Alexander Gordon&#039;s<br /> &quot;Recollections of Thirty-uine Years in the Army&quot;<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 223 (#657) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> 223<br /> will be published by Messrs. Swan Sonnenschein.<br /> Sir Charles was in the Mutiny, with Lord Elgin<br /> in China, and in Paris during the siege.<br /> A new edition of Whitman is to be published<br /> by Messrs. Putnam, with thirteen short poems<br /> that did not appear in the edition prepared by<br /> the poet shortly before his death. &quot;Though you<br /> have put the finishing touches on the &#039;Leaves,&#039;&quot;<br /> said one of his friends to Whitman, &quot; you will go<br /> on living a year or two longer and writing more<br /> poems. The question is, what will you do with<br /> these poems when the time comes to fix them in<br /> the volume?&quot; &quot;I am not unprepared,&quot; said<br /> Whitman, and I have a title in reserve—&#039; Old Age<br /> Echoes&#039;—applying not so much to things as to<br /> echoes of things reverberant, an aftermath.&quot;<br /> A translation of the Italian masterpiece, the<br /> &quot;Pecorone&quot; of Ser Giovanni Fiorentino, has<br /> just been published by Messrs. Lawrence and<br /> Bullen. Although it was published in 1558, this<br /> novel has never before been done into any tongue.<br /> The translation will be by Mr. W. G. Waters,<br /> and illustrations will be by Mr. E. R. Hughes,<br /> R.W.S.<br /> Here is a tale of literary appropriation from<br /> America. Mr. George Cable has been correcting<br /> an American editor as to the authorship of a<br /> certain poem. The editor had credited it to some<br /> one named George Cooper, but Mr. Cable recog-<br /> nised the poem, and wrote to the editor as<br /> follows:<br /> I have an impression that it was Coopered by quite<br /> another George. My impression is that it was written by<br /> myself twenty-seven years ago, on the occasion of the birth<br /> of my first child. If yon can&#039;t take my word for it, I can<br /> show yon the child. I am not a frequent versifier, and<br /> never should have prized this bit if it had not immediately,<br /> upon its first publication (in the New Orleans Picayune),<br /> begun a mad career of getting stolen—like &quot; Helen of Troy&quot;<br /> and others. It is only three days since I wrote to a Chicago<br /> publishing house to say that it was not written by Mortimer<br /> M. Thompson, as accredited in a volume called &quot;The<br /> Humbler Poets.&quot; Let me tell you, oven the humblest poet<br /> &quot;will turn.&quot; And I wish my consoious or unconscious<br /> trespassers would give this much-stolen trifle a respite.<br /> Zounds, man! have I done nothing else worth stealing?<br /> It&#039;s mortifying.<br /> Mr. Walter Wood has completed and delivered<br /> to Messrs. Tillotson and Son, for serial publica-<br /> tion, a military story which deals largely with<br /> Frontier warfare. The story will run for about<br /> three months and publication is to begin at an<br /> early date. This is the second military serial<br /> which has been written of late for Messrs. Tillot-<br /> son by Mr. Wood, who has just published a series<br /> of short stories in To-day.<br /> The issue of the &quot;Literary Year Book&quot; for<br /> 1898 will be edited by Mr. Joseph Jacobs. This<br /> annual, published by Mr. George Allen, now<br /> makes its second appearance. The editor this<br /> year has been assisted by two eminent bookmen,<br /> a popular novelist, and a well-known editor. Mr.<br /> Buskin&#039;s portrait will be the frontispiece.<br /> At the sale of the second portion of the library<br /> formed by the late Earl of Ashburnham, a remark-<br /> able price was paid for a Caxton. This is &quot; Le<br /> Fevre (R.), a Boke of the Hoole Lvf of Jason,<br /> translated out of the French by William Caxton,&quot;<br /> circa 1477, black letter, small folio, a rare Caxton<br /> book, one of the earliest productions of the press<br /> at Westminster. The whole of the volume is<br /> genuine throughout, sound, and clean. It was<br /> formerly Richard Heber&#039;s, and was sold in 1817<br /> for .£162 15s., afterwards for .£95 11*., and at the<br /> Heber sale for £87. The late Earl bought it<br /> from Payne, the bookseller. It now fetched the<br /> record price of .£2100, the purchaser being Mr.<br /> Pickering.<br /> Mr. John LI. Warden Page has written two<br /> papers, which he has also illustrated, for<br /> Travel. One is a description of the Great Fair<br /> of Nijni Novgorod, the other is callled &quot; Up the<br /> Volga.&quot;<br /> The same author&#039;s new book on the &quot;North<br /> Coast of Cornwall&quot; (Simpkin, Marshall, and Co.)<br /> is now ready, with twenty-one vignettes by the<br /> author, and a map. The price is 6*. net.<br /> Her Majesty the Queen has been graciously<br /> pleased to accept a copy of Miss H. M. Burnside&#039;s<br /> volume of verses and ly rics, &quot;Drift Weed&quot;<br /> (Hutchinson and Co).<br /> Messrs. Nelson and Son have just published<br /> two stories for children, written by Miss Burn-<br /> side, entitled &quot;The Little V.C.&quot; and &quot;The Lost<br /> Letter.&quot;<br /> LITERATURE IN THE PERIODICALS.<br /> Authors, Publishers, and Booksellers. Leading<br /> articles: The Times, Deo. 6; Daily Chronicle, Dec. 4;<br /> Publishers&#039; Circular, Deo. 11 ; The 8peaker (&quot; A Question<br /> of Discount&quot;) Dec. 11. Letters: &quot;Z&quot; and &quot;Economist&quot;<br /> in Times, Deo. 4; &quot;Country Bookseller&quot; in Daily<br /> Chronicle, Deo. 27; &quot;Z.&quot; in Daily News, Dec. 7; Mr.<br /> Frankfort Moore, Mr. Frederick Evans, and &quot; A Publisher&quot;<br /> in Chapman&#039;s Magazine for December.<br /> What the Trade Thinks. Interviews with Mr.<br /> Burleigh, Mr. Frederick Evans, and others, regarding<br /> Society of Authors&#039; Committee Report on Discounts: Daily<br /> Chronicle, Deo. 6.<br /> BOOKBELLINO: A DECAYING INDUSTRY. Neville<br /> Beeman. New Century Review for January.<br /> Literary Grievances. From various standpoints.<br /> And leading article. Morning Post for Deo. 18.<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 224 (#658) ############################################<br /> <br /> 224<br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> The Payment and Fostering) op Poetry. Glasgow<br /> Herald for Nov. 20.<br /> The Comino Litebabt Bevival. II. J. S. Tunison.<br /> Atlantic Monthly for Dooember.<br /> The Importation of German. Leslie Stephen.<br /> National Review for December.<br /> Commenting upon the &quot;carefully-prepared<br /> report&quot; of the Society of Authors&#039; special Com-<br /> mittee on book-discounts, the Titnes agrees that<br /> &quot;no compact can restore the country bookseller<br /> to his old position,&quot; and advises him to reshape<br /> his way of doing business and be to his customers<br /> more than a mere transmitter of orders. The<br /> contingency of an author publishing his books<br /> through a bookseller, through a printer, through<br /> a literary agent, or through a draper, the Times<br /> says &quot; is not so very probable,&quot; although &quot; there<br /> are authors powerful enough to defeat any<br /> attempt to fix the terms on which their books are<br /> to be sold.&quot; But, finally, our great contemporary<br /> states that &quot; both authors and publishers are apt<br /> to overlook the interests and bias of the reader,<br /> who never was less disposed to fall in with<br /> proposals to put things right at his expense. For<br /> good books, which are rare, he does not probably<br /> pay enough, but for indifferent and ephemeral<br /> productions he is satisfied that he pays too much.&quot;<br /> The Daily Chronicle, in placing the facts and<br /> issues of the report before its readers, confesses<br /> also that it sees no way to an artificial enhance-<br /> ment of prices, and reads the country bookseller<br /> the lesson that if he would survive &quot; he will be<br /> wise to lay to heart the suggestions made to him<br /> by the Society of Authors.&quot; In anticipating the<br /> concurrence of the Publishers&#039; Association with<br /> the finding of the Committee, it observes that the<br /> relations between authors and publishers were<br /> never closer or more sympathetic than at the<br /> present moment; and &quot;never was a mere author<br /> of the least merit so certain of a publisher and<br /> therefore of a chance to win for himself an<br /> audience &quot;:<br /> Therefore neither publishers nor authors stand in need of<br /> any adventitious helps. The; would both oommit a fatal<br /> error if in an attempt to turn back the stream of irresis-<br /> tible economic forces, they tried to help a section of<br /> the retailers at the cost of the multitude of readers.<br /> &quot;Economist,&quot; writing in the Times, thinks that<br /> if it is the interest of the author and the publisher<br /> to have their books on show in shops all over the<br /> country, surely the necessary steps ought to be<br /> taken by them and at their expense. As to any<br /> idea of restrictions upon the price at which a<br /> bookseller shall offer books to the public, we quote<br /> &quot;Economist&#039;s &quot; own words:<br /> The druggist is more necessary to the well-being of a<br /> country town than the bookseller, and, nowadays at least,<br /> he is usually a man more expensively educated. Yet he has<br /> to go outside his proper sphere, selling tobacco, hair-<br /> brushes, and any &quot; fal-lals &quot; that he can find room for. The<br /> reason is that the turnover even of his indispensable goods<br /> is not great enough to occupy all his time, or to furnish<br /> the inoome that he desires. The country bookseller merely<br /> suffers under a general disadvantage. It there are to be<br /> trade combinations to supply him with an inoome greater<br /> than the market affords, why not go back to pure medievalism<br /> and put on restrictions all round to make every tradesman<br /> happy.<br /> &quot;A Country Bookseller&quot; says that publishers<br /> could stop the anomalies to-morrow if they would<br /> forget the superstitious age and call twelve a dozen,<br /> giving to the poor what they give to the rich; if<br /> copyright publishers would sell five copies at the<br /> same rate each as twenty-five; and the non-copy-<br /> right man would sell twenty at the same rate<br /> as 200.<br /> We are assured by the Publishers&#039; Circular<br /> that although &quot; publishers have done all in their<br /> power to aid the retail trade,&quot; booksellers will not<br /> cease to agitate. Mr. Burleigh, the secretary of<br /> the Associated Booksellers, has said as much,<br /> indeed, to an interviewer. The booksellers—who<br /> are, of course, disappointed with the report—<br /> cannot give up the movement, he said, &quot;unless<br /> they are to relinquish all prospects for them-<br /> selves.&quot; Mr. Frederick Evans spoke to the same<br /> effect. Mr. F. Stoneham, on the other hand, who<br /> represents the discount side of the trade, thought<br /> the report a very fair statement of the whole case.<br /> &quot;It got together the essential facts governing<br /> bookselling, and, that done, its conclusions were<br /> inevitable.&quot; The recommendation of greater<br /> energy and enterprise in the bookselling trade is<br /> not, the Publishers&#039; Circular considers, &quot;to be<br /> taken seriously.&quot; The remaining criticisms<br /> which the organ of the publishing trade passes<br /> upon the report are contained in the following<br /> passage:<br /> Publishers are told they would do well to remember the<br /> development of the system of serial publication; in other<br /> words, they are asked to pay attention to a method of pub-<br /> lication whioh they have themselves called into existence<br /> and are carrying on. Collective wisdom could not go beyond<br /> that. Whether the bookseller can be converted into a news-<br /> agent, or the newsagent into a bookseller, readers may<br /> decide for themselves. It is true there are houses which<br /> now handle both books and newspapers in large quantities;<br /> but the results of a general adoption of the principle are, to<br /> say the least, a little doubtful.<br /> The Speaker acknowledges, in the name of the<br /> world, that the report is an &quot;amusing document.&quot;<br /> Hasn&#039;t seen anything so amusing for a long<br /> time. The writer hurls at the Society of<br /> Authors, after some personalities, the state,<br /> ment that the whole question is one of<br /> money; and concludes with the assertion that the<br /> people of Great Britain begrudge every shilling<br /> which they spend upon literature, and the pro-<br /> phecy that&quot;the middleman will disappear, leaving<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 225 (#659) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> 225<br /> as his only memorial a thousand desolated homes,<br /> and the wholesale publishers will become more<br /> and more the masters of the great trade in<br /> books.&quot;<br /> Mr. Neville Beeman tells booksellers that they<br /> are chiefly responsible for their impecuniosity.<br /> They are incompetent to buy cautiously, and<br /> unable to sell in an intelligent manner. But in<br /> defence of the bookseller it must be said that<br /> many pitfalls are laid for him by those who<br /> should be his best friends. To take the author:<br /> he writes a good book; he becomes known by it;<br /> he is seized by the wicked literary agent, who<br /> &quot;proceeds to make arrangements with as many<br /> publishers as possible, who are all keen to secure<br /> a rising man, and one fine morning the author<br /> wakes up to find he is bound to write so many<br /> words a day, whether he feels inclined or not, to<br /> fulfil the contracts which his master has concluded<br /> for him.&quot; Mr. Beeman uses the word &quot;master&quot;<br /> advisedly, his one objection to the literary agent<br /> (&quot;a useful and even necessary adjunct to the<br /> literary man&quot;) being that he is &quot;master&quot;<br /> instead of &quot;servant.&quot; The author, then, having<br /> scored a success with his first book, proceeds to<br /> turn out hurried and slipshod work; meanwhile<br /> the bookseller, buying on the original reputation,<br /> finds himself saddled with dead stock. Moreover,<br /> &quot;there is no device, however low, that an author<br /> will not stoop to in order to puff and advertise<br /> himself to the notice of the bookseller.&quot; Mr. A.<br /> rides on his bicycle in velvet knickerbockers and<br /> lace frills. Mr. B. always drinks toddy while<br /> writing. Mr. De Bow sends a notice to the<br /> papers saying that he is off to Monte Carlo to<br /> study up local colour, but Mrs. De Bow secretly<br /> divulges the fact that poor Mr. De Bow is<br /> really at the British Museum getting h*8<br /> local colour! The bookseller&#039;s grievance against<br /> the publisher is even more serious. &quot;The<br /> bookseller has no one to blame so much for his<br /> present position than [sic] the publisher.&quot; In<br /> his selection of MSS. the publisher is guided, as a<br /> rule, by his readers, the greater number of<br /> whom — so Mr. Neville informs us — &quot; are<br /> authors who have failed to make a living them-<br /> selves at writing.&quot; Readers, then, are full of cranks<br /> and fads in their choice of books. A publisher<br /> is perhaps unable to fill his autumn list with<br /> books of good merit, so he makes up with<br /> second-rate books. And as the publisher&#039;s<br /> traveller is persuasive, and the bookseller easily<br /> persuaded, the latter in the end is stocked up<br /> with books that do not suit him, and suffers a<br /> serious loss. A third sinner arraigned alongside<br /> the author and the publisher, is the Press,<br /> against whom Mr. Beeman makes charges in<br /> connection with reviewing. But we pass to the<br /> panacea which the writer suggests to the Book-<br /> sellers&#039; Association:<br /> Instead of trying to mnlct the pnblio of extra pennies,<br /> which do the trade no good, and only drive away business,<br /> they should suggest to the publishers that they should<br /> Bupply a oopy of every new book to the Booksellers&#039; Asso-<br /> ciation one clear fortnight before issue. The Association<br /> should appoint an expert to examine each book and<br /> report on its merits. Then to each member of the Asso-<br /> ciation a report would be sent, and, in the event of the<br /> book proving saleable, a short epitome of the plot should<br /> be printed on a leaflet for the bookseller&#039;s guidance. This<br /> would get over to a large measure, the item of bad stock.<br /> Following up Mr. Lang&#039;s article of the previous<br /> month, an author — Mr. Frankfort Moore — a<br /> publisher (anonymous), and a bookseller (Mr. F.<br /> Evans) give their views in Chapman&#039;s. Neither<br /> Mr. Moore nor Mr. Evans thinks that the reduc-<br /> tion of discounts to the public need necessarily<br /> mean a diminution of sales; and the publisher<br /> remarks that his class has nothing to gain by<br /> proposing to enforce &quot; 2d. in the is.,&quot; but they<br /> wish to save the booksellers from ruin. An<br /> author, a publisher, and a critic air their re-<br /> spective grievances, by request, in the columns<br /> of the Morning Post, which devotes a leading<br /> article to their views. The author says the<br /> London publisher is &quot; very much of a sheep; he<br /> lacks initiative.&quot; If one publisher gets a &quot; boom&quot;<br /> with a certain kind of novel, then nothing will<br /> serve either him or his publishing brethren but<br /> that kind of novel written by Tom, Dick, and<br /> Harry, till the reader is gorged. Publishers do<br /> not know how to advertise their books, and they<br /> do not offer them to the dying country bookseller<br /> on the principle of sale or return. The critic, too,<br /> is given over to a belief in fashions; and he is<br /> too generous to the established popular favourite,<br /> too grudgini; to the deserving writer who has<br /> not quite arrived. The critic, on his part, implores<br /> authors to lighten his labours by making their<br /> work either very good or very bad. Most of the<br /> books that come under his notice are pretty good,<br /> and he is overwhelmed by the the monotony of<br /> their average excellence. Finally, the publisher<br /> is on the whole well content except that he is<br /> troubled about the retail bookseller&#039;s condition.<br /> His remedy for this is suggested by the following<br /> confident conclusions: &quot;To advertise a book at<br /> a fixed price and then to tell buyers privately that<br /> that is not the price is a sham and a delusion<br /> unworthy of our honourable calling. The price<br /> at which a book is published and advertised is<br /> the price the public should pay for it. The true<br /> solution is to fix a net price which the public<br /> must pay, and from which no bookseller can<br /> make any allowance whatever—and live. That is<br /> the conclusion of the whole matter.&quot; The Post<br /> finds the most interesting feature of these letters<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 226 (#660) ############################################<br /> <br /> 226<br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> the fact that the author and the publisher<br /> think poorly of the criticisms of the periodical<br /> Press, while the reviewer&#039;s complaint is merely<br /> that great works are rare, and bad work not so<br /> common as is supposed. It suggests that the<br /> general public would welcome &quot;selection,&quot; and<br /> the practice of curtailing reviews of most books<br /> to a few words, saying whether they are worth<br /> reading or not. Anyhow, &quot; there is evidently at<br /> present a magnificent opportunity for critics<br /> whose judgments can win the public confidence.<br /> To no man is a greater reward offered in the<br /> literary world than to him who can prove his<br /> judgment is so true and so fair that the public<br /> will be ready to read the books which he recom-<br /> mends.&quot;<br /> We noticed in this column some months ago<br /> the proposal of Mr. Le Gallienne that millionaires<br /> should endow the genuine poets of the country.<br /> He had thought, of course, of the State doing<br /> something, but abandoned the idea as hopeless,<br /> and turned persuasively to the millionaires, and<br /> offered them the opportunity of immortality by<br /> providing for the material wants of our singers.<br /> The Glasgow Herald, however, harks back to the<br /> State. The apathy of the public to poetry at the<br /> present day is very plain, and yet, says our<br /> Scottish contemporary, &quot;there is probably no<br /> one among us that is so much of a Philistine or<br /> so pronounced a Platonist as to wish to see poetry<br /> starved out.&quot; To place all the proved poets<br /> of the day beyond the reach of want, and thus<br /> enable them to cultivate their poetical gifts with<br /> their whole mind, a not very extravagant annual<br /> sum would be required. The question arises,<br /> how to prove them; and here the Glasgow<br /> Herald writer sees the possible use of some body<br /> like the French Academy, which would raise the<br /> higher criticism from the slough of sheer com-<br /> mercialism into which it has fallen within the<br /> last quarter of a century. &quot;If such a body were<br /> formed, the State would find in it, and ready to its<br /> hand, a committee of selection which would guide<br /> as to who are and who are not proved poets.<br /> Here, at all, events, is a suggestion for adding<br /> to the beneficent powers of the State which has<br /> in it no taint of Socialism.&quot;<br /> THE BOOKS OF THE MONTH.<br /> [Nov. 24 to Dec. 23.—299 Books.]<br /> Abcrnethy, J. S. Life and Work of James Abernethy, 0. E. 7/6.<br /> Abbott, Jones.<br /> Abney, Captain. Scientific Requirements of Colour Photography.<br /> 1/- net. Frowde.<br /> Adye, General Sir J. Indian Frontier Policy. 3/6. Smith. Elder.<br /> Ainslie, Noel. Among Thorns, 6/&#039;- Lawrence.<br /> Alcock, D. By Far Euphrates. A Tale. 5/- Hodderand Stoughton.<br /> Allen, A. M. Gladys in Grammarland. 8/6. Boxburghe.<br /> Andrews, W. (ed.). Bygone Durham. 7/6. Andrews.<br /> Anonymous. AH About Animals. For Old and Young. 10/6. NewneB.<br /> AnonjmouB. (&quot; H. M.&quot; and &quot; M. A. R. T.&quot;). Handbook to Chris-<br /> tian and Ecclesiastical Borne. Part 11. 5/- Black.<br /> Anonymous. The Official Guide to the Klondyke Country. 2/-<br /> Bacon.<br /> Anonymous. (&quot; O. B. P.&quot;). The Soul in Paradise. Poem. 1/6.<br /> Church Printing Company.<br /> Anonymous. The Print Gallery. Reproductions of Eugravings<br /> from end of XVth to beginning of XlXth Century. Vol. I. 21/-<br /> Grevel.<br /> Anonymous. Victorian Art. Reproduction of Pictures. 91/6 net.<br /> Blades.<br /> Anonymous. MrB. Turner&#039;s Cautionary Stories. 1/6. Richards.<br /> Anst«d,A. A Dictionary of Sea Terms. 7/6. Upcott Gill.<br /> Armstrong, Jessie. Through Rosamund&#039;s Eyes. 3/6. Jarrold.<br /> Atlay, J. B. Trial of Lord Cochrane before Lord EUenborough.<br /> 18/- Smith, Elder.<br /> Bacon, E. M. Chronicles of Tarry town and Sleepy Hollow. 5/-<br /> Putnam.<br /> Bain, R. Nisbet. The Pupils of Peter the Great. 1 6 - net Constable.<br /> Baldwin, J. H. Social and Ethical Interpretations in Mental Develop-<br /> ment. 10/- net. Macmillan.<br /> Baly, E. Eur-Aryan Roots, with their English Derivatives, Ac.<br /> 50/- net. Kegan Paul.<br /> Banbury, G. A. L. On the Verge of Two Worlas. 8/6. Boxburghe.<br /> Barkly, F. A. From the Tropics to the North Sea. 8/6. Roxburghe.<br /> Barrett, Wilson. The Harlequin&#039;s Last Leap, Ac. 1/- Saxon.<br /> Barstow, 0. H. Natty&#039;s Violin. 1/6. Warne.<br /> Becke, Louis. Wild Life in Southern Seas. 6/- Unwin.<br /> Baoby, 0. E. Creed and Life. Beverley: Wright<br /> Bellot, H. L. and Willis, B. J. The Law relating to Unconscionable<br /> Bargains with Moneylenders. 7/6. Stevens and Haynes.<br /> Berenson, B. The Central Italian Painters of the Renaissance. 4/6.<br /> Putnam.<br /> Rerridge, Ruth. The Baby Philosopher. 3/6 Jarrold.<br /> Bickford-Smith, R. A. H Cretan Sketches. 6/- Bentley.<br /> Bicknell, Anna L. The Story of Marie Antoinette. 12/- Unwin.<br /> Binns, Charles F. The Story of the Potter. 1/- Newnes.<br /> Black, Hugh. Friendship. 2/6. Hodder and Stoughton.<br /> Boas, Mrs. F. English History for Children. 2/6. Nisbet.<br /> Boulger, D. C. The Life of Sir Stamford Raffles. 21/- net Horace<br /> Marshall.<br /> Brewer, H. W. Medissval Oxford: a Bird&#039;s Eye View. D. Fonrdrinier.<br /> Briggs, U. M. By Roadside and Biver. 4/- Stock.<br /> Brockman, Louisa. Bright Thoughts. 2/6. Digby.<br /> Bryant, Emi&#039;y M. Norma: A School Tale. 3/6. Digby.<br /> Budd, A , and others. Football. 1/- Lawrence.<br /> Budge, E. A. Wallis (ed.). The Book of the Dead: The Chapters of<br /> Coming Forth by Day. 60/- Kegan Paul.<br /> Builder, The. Album of Royal Academy Architecture, 1897. Builder<br /> Offlce.<br /> Butcher, E. L. Story of the Church of Egypt. 16/- Smith, Elder.<br /> Butler, Life and Letters of William John. 12/6 net<br /> Macmillan.<br /> Carey, R. Nouchette. Other People&#039;s Lives. 6/- Hodderand Stoughton.<br /> Chambers, C. H. An Underground Tragedy, Ac. 1/- Saxon.<br /> Channing, F. A. The Truth about Agricultural Depression. 6/-<br /> Church, Dean. Village Sermons Third Series. 6/-<br /> Clark, W. Eras of the Christian Church: The Anglican Revival. 6/-<br /> Olark.<br /> Clarke, H. B. The Cld Campcador and the Waning of the Orescent<br /> in the West 6/- Putnam.<br /> Cochrane, B. (ed.). Four Hundred Animal Stories. 2/6. Chambers.<br /> Cohn, J., and Swales, F. Practical Horse Dentistry. 3/6. Vinton.<br /> Coillard, Francois (tr. by 0. W. Mackintosh^. On the Threshold of<br /> Central Africa. 15/- Hodder and Stoughton.<br /> Collins, W. E. Beginnings of English Christianity. 8/6. M&lt;&quot;<br /> Conrad, Joseph. The Nigger of the &quot; Narcissus.&quot; 6/- Heini<br /> Conybcare, Edward. A History of Cambridgeshire. 7/6. Stock.<br /> Ooonley, L. A. (worda by). Singing Verses for Children. 8/6 net.<br /> Cooper, E. H. The Marchioness against the County. 6/- Chapman.<br /> Cordery, J. G. (tr.). The Odyssey of Homer. 7/6. Methnen.<br /> Cotton, A. E. Queer Creatures. 2/6. Simplrin.<br /> Couch, M. Qulller. Some Westora Folk. 8/6. Horace Marshall.<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 227 (#661) ############################################<br /> <br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> 227<br /> Cox, the father of Rev. W. S. Evly Promoted: A Memoir. 2/6. Low.<br /> Oragg, A. B. HintB to Young Valuers. Land Agent s Record.<br /> Crawford, Arthur. Our Troubles in Poona and the Deccan. 14/-<br /> Constable.<br /> Greswlcke, Louis. Love&#039;s Usuries. 3/6. Drane.<br /> Crosland, N. Bumbles Round my Life, 1819-96. 7/6. E. W. Allen.<br /> Cuthbertson, Evan J. William Shakespeare. 1/- Chambers.<br /> D&#039;Ache, C., and Wolseley, Hon. F. The Story of Marlborough. 10/6.<br /> Grevel.<br /> Danvers, F. C. (ed.). Letters Received by the East India Company<br /> from its Servants in the East. 21&#039;- net. Low.<br /> Derbyshire, A. An Architect&#039;s Experiences. Manchester: Cornish.<br /> Dawson, W. J. The Endless Choice, 1/6. Nisbet<br /> De la Pasture, Mrs. H. Deborah of Tods. 6/- Smith, Elder.<br /> De Nolhac, Pierre* (from the French of). Marie Antoinette the<br /> Dauphine. 63/-net. Simpkin.<br /> De Salis, Mrs. Art of Cookery, Past and Present. 2/- Hutchinson.<br /> D&#039;Esperance, E. Shadow Land. 6/- net Redway.<br /> Dircks, Rudolf. Verisimilitudes. 3/6. Unicorn Press.<br /> Dixon, Charles. Onr Favourite Song Birds. 7/6. Lawrence.<br /> Douglas, Sir Goo., Bart. Poems of a Country Gentleman. 3/6.<br /> Longmans.<br /> Drummond, Henry. The Ideal Life, and other Unpublished Addresses.<br /> 6/- Hodder and Stoughton.<br /> Drummond, Henry. The Monkey that Would Not Kill. 2/6.<br /> Hodder and Stoughton.<br /> Dubois, AbM J. A. (ed. by H. K. Beaucbamp). Hindu Manners,<br /> Customs, and Ceremonies. 21/- net. Frowde.<br /> Duggan, J. Steps Towards Reunion. 61- Eegan Paul.<br /> Ebbs, Ellen H. The Inner Light and Other Poems. 1/6 net. Digby.<br /> Egerton, George. Fantasias. 3/6. Lane.<br /> Ellis, Havelock. Affirmations. 6/- Scott.<br /> Erskine, the Hon. Stuart. Lord Dullborougb. 3/6. Arrowsmith.<br /> Evans, late Rev. E. H. True and False Alms, 6/- Hodder and Stn.<br /> Evans, T. J. Notes on Carpentry and Joinery.—I. 7/6. Chapman.<br /> Furrar, Dean. Sin and Its Conquerors. 1/6. Nisbet.<br /> Ferguson, R. Art of Elocution and Public Sp aking. 1/- Greening.<br /> Field, Eugene (selected by E. Grahame). Lullaby Land. 6/- Lane.<br /> Fields, A. Life and Letters of Harriet Beecher Stowe. 7/6 Low.<br /> Fincham, H. W. Artists and Engravers of British and American<br /> Book Plates. 21/- Eegan Paul.<br /> Fiske, John. Old Virginia and Her Neighbours. 16/- Macmillan.<br /> Fltchett, W. H. (&quot; Vedette &quot;). Deeds that Won the Empire 6/-<br /> Smith, Elder.<br /> Flu-Gerald, S. J. Adair. Fame the Fiddler. 6/- Greening.<br /> Fitzgerald, P. Pickwickian Manners and Customs. 2/6. Roxburghe.<br /> Fitzgi-rald, P. The Real Sheridan. F. J. Griffiths.<br /> Fletcher, B. F. and H. P. Carpentry and Joinery. D. Fourdrinier.<br /> Fletcher, J. S. The Making of Matthias. 5/- Lane.<br /> Forman, H. B. The Books of William Morris. 10/6 net. Boilings.<br /> Fowler, G. H. On the Outside Edge. (Skating.) field Office.<br /> Fox, John, jun. The Kentuckians. 5/- Harper.<br /> Francis Beam. The Gentlemanly Giant, Ac. 3/6. Hodder and Stn.<br /> Francis, Henry. The White Cat. 4/6. Beeves.<br /> Fulleylove, John (text by H. W. Nevinson). Pictures of Classic Greek<br /> Landscape and Architecture. 31/6 net. Dent<br /> lepenkerl, Maj<br /> Tactics. 81-<br /> Goimaraens, M. P. Portugese Rita. 1/-<br /> Harrison, Benjamin. Constitution and Administration of U.S.A.<br /> 2/6. Nutt.<br /> Harrisse, Henry. Diplomatic History of America, 1452-93-94.<br /> B. F. Stevens.<br /> nanff, W. (tr. by B. J. Craig). Mary of Lichtenstein. 6/- Digby.<br /> Haweis, H. R. Ideals for Girls. 2/6. Bowden.<br /> Headlam, A. C. The Teaching of the Russian Church. 1/6 Rivingtons.<br /> Heath, Sidney. Songs for the Children. 6/- Chapman.<br /> Herrick, Robert, Ten Songs gathered from the Heaperides of. Set<br /> into music by Joseph S. Moorat 61- G. Allen.<br /> Higginson, E. A Forest Orchid, and other Stories. 6/- Macmillan.<br /> Hill, G. B. Letters of D. G. Rossetti to William Allingham, 1854-70.<br /> 12/- Unwin.<br /> Hobbes, John Oliver. The School for Saints. 6/- Unwin.<br /> Hodder, Edwin. In Strange Quarters. SI- Hodder and Stn.<br /> Horner, Susan. Greek Vases: Historical and Descriptive. 3/6.<br /> Sonnenschein.<br /> Hovenden, Frederick. What is Life? 6/- Chapman.<br /> Humphry, Mrs. Manners for Women. 1/- Bowden.<br /> Hurry, J. B. District Nursing on a Provident Basis. 2/- Scientific<br /> Hyde, W. D. Practical Idealism. :&gt;&#039;,-net. Macmillan.<br /> Isabell, John. Wonderland Wonders. 5/- Home Words Office.<br /> Jenkins, W. H. J. How Tom Jeffrey Saw the World. 6/- Simpkin.<br /> Johnson, Robert U. Songs of Liberty and Other Poems. 4/6. Unwin.<br /> JoneB, 0. G. Rock Climbing in the English Lake District, 15.- net.<br /> Longmans.<br /> Jones, Miss Whitmore. Games of Patience. 5/- Upcott Gill. ■&#039;&#039; &#039; 8/6.<br /> Garland, Hamlin. Wayside Courtships. 61-<br /> Gerard, FranceB. Picturesque Dublin, Old and Now. 12/-<br /> Hutchlnson.<br /> Gerard, John. Gunpowder Plot and the Gunpowder Plotters. 1/-<br /> Harper.<br /> Gethen, H. F. Partners. A School Story. 2/6. Nelson.<br /> Giberne, Agnes. A Modern Puck. 5/- Jerrold.<br /> Gibson, Charles Dana. London, as seen by. 20/- Lane.<br /> Gibson, Charles Dana. People of Dickens. 20/- Lane.<br /> Gilbert, W. S. Bab Ballads, and Songs of a Savoyard. Complete<br /> odition. 7/6. Routledge.<br /> Giovanni, Ser. (tr. by H G. Waters). The Pecorone. 42/- net.<br /> Lawrence<br /> Golechmann, L. (tr. from the Russian). Adventures of a Siberian<br /> Cub. 3/6. Jarrold.<br /> Gomme, G. L. Lectures on the Principles of Local Government. 12/-<br /> Oonstable.<br /> Gordon, H. L. Sir James Y. Simpson and Chloroform. 3/6.<br /> Unwin.<br /> Grsjme, Roland. From England to the Back Blocks. 3/6.<br /> Sonnenschein.<br /> Grlepenkerl, Major (tr. by a retired officer). Letters on Applied<br /> Digby.&#039;<br /> Hadow, W. H. A Croatian Composer. Haydn. 2/6 net Seoley.<br /> Hamerton, Philip G. The Quest of Happiness. 6/- Sceley.<br /> Harbottle, T. B. Dictionary of Quotations (Classical). 7/6.<br /> Sonnenschoin.<br /> Hardy, F. H. The Mills of God. «/- Smith, Elder.<br /> Harraden, Beatrice. Untold Tales of the Past. 6/- Blackwood.<br /> Longmans.<br /> Joyce, O. W. A Chlld&#039;B History of Ireland.<br /> 14 Eay Jay.&quot; Rose: A Romance of 192—. 2/- Arrowsmith.<br /> Eemble, E. W. The Blackberries and their Adventures. 6/-<br /> Eegan Paul.<br /> Kemp, Geraldine. A Modern Merfbah. 3/6. Skefflngton.<br /> Eennedy, H. Angus. The Story of Canada. 1/6. Horace Marshall.<br /> Kennedy. T. History of Irish Protest against Over-Taxation, 1853-<br /> 97. 57- Dublin: Hodges, Figgis.<br /> Kenyon, Edith C. The Hand of His Brother. 6/- Gay and Bird.<br /> Kenyon, F. G. (ed.). The Poems of Bacchylides. 21/-<br /> British Musoum.<br /> Kerr. A. W. Scottish Banking, 1865-96. 5/- E. Wilson.<br /> Knight, Arthur Lee The White Ensign. 6/- Jarrold.<br /> Lang, Andrew (ed ). The Nursery Rhyme Book. 6/- Warne.<br /> Langton, C&#039;ara. The Light of Shakespeare. Stock.<br /> Lebon, Andre*. Modern France, 1789-1895. 5/- Unwin.<br /> Le Conte. C E The Stttue in the Air. 3/6. Macmillan.<br /> Lee, Sydney (ed.). Dictionary of National Biography. Vol. 53.<br /> 15/- net. Smith, Elder.<br /> Lee, Krimund. Hinemoa, and other PoemB. Clarke.<br /> Lees, B. J. A Corner Wall Mystery. 6d. Arrowsmith.<br /> Leighton, the late Lord. DrawingB snd Studies in Pencil, Chalk,<br /> and other Mediums. &#039;&#039;Facsimiled.&quot; 63/-net. Fine Art Society.<br /> Lehmann, R. C. Bowing 5/- Innes.<br /> L&#039;Epine, Charles. The Devil in a Domino. 1/- Greening.<br /> Letchford, Albert, reproduced from pictures by. A Series of Seventy<br /> Original Illustrations to Burton&#039;s •■ Arabian Nights.&quot; 63/-net.<br /> Nichols.<br /> Leyland, John. The Thames, Illustrated. 10/6 Newnes.<br /> Lloyd-Taylor, N. By Still Harder Fate. 3/6. Sonnenschein.<br /> Lock, Prof., and Sanday, Prof. Two Lectures on the &quot;Sayings of<br /> Christ.&quot; 1/6 net. Frowde.<br /> Lockyor, Sir N. The Sun&#039;s Place In Nature, 1*/- Macmillan.<br /> Lord. Walter Frewen. Sir Thomas Maitland. 5/- Unwin.<br /> Lummis, C. F. The King of the Broncos. 6/- Newnes.<br /> Lutoslawski, W. Origin and Growth of Plato&#039;s Logic. 21/-<br /> Longmans.<br /> M&#039;Crlndlo, J. W. (ed. and tr.) The Christian Topography of Cosmos,<br /> an Egyptian Monk. The Hakluyt Society.<br /> MacGregor, B. King Longbeard, Fairy Tales. 6/- Lane.<br /> Mcllwraitn, F. W. A Book about Shakespeare. 2/- Nelson.<br /> Macklnnon, James. Leisure Hours in the Study. 6/- Unwin.<br /> Mahan, A T. The Interest of America in Sea Power. 10/6. Low.<br /> Malcolm, C. H. Justitia; or Result of Obstinacy. 3/6. Roxburghc.<br /> Martin, David. The Glasgow School of Painting. 10/6 net. Bell.<br /> Maxtee, J. Popular Dog-Keeping. 1/- Upcott Gill.<br /> Mayson, W. H. The Stolen Fiddle. 8/6. Warne.<br /> MeUone, S. H. Studies In Philosophical Criticism and Construction.<br /> 10/6 net. Blackwood.<br /> Melrose, C. J. Modern Scientific Whist. 6/- Upcott Uill,<br /> Metcalfe. W. E. On the Other Tack. 3/6. Jarrold.<br /> Meyer, F. B. Workaday Sermons. 2/6. Bowden.<br /> Miles. Alfred H. (ed.) The Household Oracle. 8/6. Hutchinson.<br /> Miller, J. A. Practical Handbook for Working Miner and Pro-<br /> spector. Spon.<br /> Milne, J. The Gordon Highlanders. 1/- Macqueen.<br /> Moborly, R. C. Ministerial Priesthood, 14/- Murray.<br /> Moffat, Douglas. Crickety Orioket. 2/6. Longmans.<br /> Montgomery, Florence. Tony. A Sketch. 2/- Bentley.<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 228 (#662) ############################################<br /> <br /> 228<br /> THE AUTHOR.<br /> Morris, the Hon. Martin. Transatlantic Traits. 6/- Stock.<br /> Muir, Sir. W. The Hon. James Thorn.!son 2/- Clark.<br /> MQller, F. Max (ed.). The Sacred Books of the East.—Vol. 43. The<br /> Satapatha-Brahmana. Part 4 (tr. by J. Eggoling.) 12/6. Frowde.<br /> Naegely, H. J. F. Millet and Rustic Art. 6/- Stock.<br /> Neale, C. M. Index to Pickwick. 8/- Printed for the anthor by J.<br /> Hitchcock, Streatham.<br /> Nicholson, W. (words by R. Kipling). An Almanac of Twolve Sports.<br /> 2/6, Heinemann.<br /> Nye, G. H. F. Our Island Home. 8/6. Bemrose.<br /> O&#039;Donoghae, D. J. Life and Writings of James Clarence Mangan.<br /> Edinburgh : Geddea.<br /> Ohlson, J. L. Outlines of the Art of Elocution. 1/0. E. W. Allen.<br /> O&#039;Sullivan, Vincent. The Houses of Sin. 5/- net. Smithers.<br /> Otterbnrn, Helton. Nurse Adelaide. 6/- Digby<br /> Overton, Canon Tho Anglican Revival. (Victorian Era Series.)<br /> 2/6. Blackle.<br /> Oxenham, F. N. The Validity of Papal Claims. 2/6. Longmans.<br /> Paget, Stephen. Ambroiae Pare&quot; and His Times. Putnam.<br /> Parker, E. D. Opera under Augustus Harris. Saxon.<br /> Parker, J. Are the Writings of Dionysius the Areopagite Genuine?<br /> 1/- Parker.<br /> Parkyn, E. A. The Law of Master and Servant. 7/6. Butterworth.<br /> Patrick, P.. and Groome, F. H. (eds.). Chambers&#039;s Biographical<br /> Dictionary. 10/6. Chambers,<br /> Penn, Rachel- Cherriwink. «/- Macqueen.<br /> Pennell, Joseph. Pen Drawing and Pen Draughtsmen. 42&#039;- net.<br /> Macmillan<br /> Pennell, Joseph. The Work of Charles Keene. 78/6. Unwin.<br /> Penton, Stephen. The Guardian&#039;s Instruction; reprinted from 1688<br /> edition. 2/6. Robinson.<br /> Phelps, E. S. The Story of Jesus Christ. 6/- Low.<br /> Phillips, J. G. Flora Macdonald, the Maid of Skye. 6/- Digby.<br /> Filial, G. Paramaswaran. Representative Indians. Boutledgc.<br /> Pollard Bedford. Elsie&#039;s Adventures in Fairyland. */- Stock.<br /> Poors, Lady. My Sister Barbara. 1/- Downey.<br /> Powers, G. W. England and the Reformation, 1485-1603. 1/. Blackle.<br /> Purey-Cust, Dean A. P., and others. Our English Minsters. Second<br /> Series. 7/6. Isblster.<br /> Qnaile, E. Illuminated Manuscripts. 21,<br /> Quaritch&#039;a (B.) Catalogue Monuments of<br /> Liverpool: Young.<br /> 7/6. Quaritch.<br /> Suffolk and Berkshire, Earl of; Peek, H.; and Aflalo. F. G-<br /> (editors). The Encyclopiodla of Sport. Vol. L A.—Leo. 25,-<br /> Lawrence.<br /> Symons, A. (ed.). A Selection from the Poems of Mathilde Blind.<br /> 7/6. Unwin.<br /> Synge, M. B. Brave Men and Brave Deeds. 2/6. Nelson.<br /> Temple, Sir B. (ed.). Life of Sir John Hawley Glover, B.N. 14/-<br /> Smith, Elder.<br /> Thomas, Rose H. Pan. A Collection of Lyrical Poems. 6/- Bliaa.<br /> &quot;Thormanby.&quot; Kings of the Turf. 16/- Hutchinson.<br /> Thorne. George. Jots. 1/- Arrowsmith.<br /> Thorold, Bishop. Selections from the Works of. 5/- Isbister.<br /> Tomkins.H. G. Abraham and His Age. 6/- Eyre and Bpottiswoode.<br /> Toogood, W. Pastures anil Pasture Plants. 1/6 net Macmillan.<br /> Tovey, D. C. Reviews and Essays in English Literature. 5/- net<br /> Bell.<br /> Trevor, John. My Quest for God. {/- Labour Prophet Office.<br /> Trotter, L. J. Life of John Nicholson, Soldier and Administrator.<br /> 14/- Murray.<br /> Twain, Mark. More Tramps Abroad. 6/- Chatto.&quot; t Shall It ] •<br /> Ramsay, Mrs. W. M. Everyday Life in Turkey. 5/- Hodder and<br /> Stoughton.<br /> Ramsden, Lady G. A Smile Within a Tear, and Other Fairy Stories.<br /> 8/6. Hutchinson.<br /> Ratiigan, II. A. B. Law of Divorce applicable to Christians In India.<br /> 18/- net. Wlldy.<br /> Rawnsley, H. D. Henry Whitehead, 1825-1896. MacLehose.<br /> Raymond, Harry. B. I. Bamato. A Memoir. 6/- Isbister.<br /> Rhoades, Walter. A Houseful of Rebels. 4/6. Constable<br /> Rhys, Ernest (ed.). Hampstead Annual, 1897. 2/6 net. S. C. Mayle.<br /> Roberts, Morley. Strong Men and True. 3/6. Downey.<br /> Robertson, 0. Grant Voces Academics]. 3/6. Methuen.<br /> Root, J. W. Tariff and Trade. 10/6 net. Abbott, Jones.<br /> Rothenstein, Will. English Portraits. Part VHI. 2/6 net Richards.<br /> Runk, E. J. Washington. A National Epic. Putnam.<br /> Russell, J. M. Geordie the Black Prince. 2/- Jarrold.<br /> Bnssell-Jeaffreson, J. The Faroe Islands. 7/6, Low.<br /> St Aubyn, Alan. A Fair Imposter. A Story of Exmoor. 6/- White.<br /> St. John, Henry. The Voyage of the Avenger. 5/- Jarrold.<br /> Salvation Army. Progress. Work of &quot; Darkest England&quot; Scheme<br /> in 1897. Salvation Army Headquarters.<br /> Sanderson, E. The British Empire in the 19th Century. VoL IV.<br /> Blackle.<br /> Scott, Edward. Dancing a Pleasure. 2/- Drane.<br /> Seymour, Gordon. Cui Bono. 31- Richards.<br /> Sharp, Evelyn. All the Way to Fairyland. 6/- Lane.<br /> Sienkeewicz, Henry (tr. G. J. Ourtin). Hania. 4/6. Dent.<br /> Singer, H. W., and Strang, W. Etching and Engraving, and tho other<br /> Methods of Printing Pictures. 16/- net Kegan Paul.<br /> Smith, E. G. Songs from Prudentlus. 6/- net Lane.<br /> Sola, A. E. I. Klondyke. 6/- Mining and Geog. Institute.<br /> Somervell, B. (arranged by). Parallel History of Jewish Monarchy.<br /> Part I. 2/- Clay.<br /> Bpencer, Herbert. Various Fragments. 4/- WflliamB and Norgato.<br /> &quot;Sphinx.&quot; To All Whom It May Concern. 1/6 net Wisbech:<br /> Gardiner.<br /> Spurgeon&#039;s (C. H.) Autobiography. VoL I. 1884-1854. 10/6.<br /> Passmore and Alabaster.<br /> Stead, W. T. Satan&#039;B Invisible World Displayed. II-<br /> Reviev of Reviews Office.<br /> Stein, O. Self and Comrades. Tales by a Soldier. 3/6. Vinton.<br /> Stockton, Frank B. The Great Stone of Sardis. 6/- Harper.<br /> Studio, The. The Art of 1897. Studio Office.<br /> Tweedale, Violet. What t<br /> Profit a Man? 6/-<br /> Digby.<br /> Von Beber, F., and Bayersdorfer, A. Classical Sculpture Gallery.<br /> 21/- Grevcl.<br /> Venahles, Canon. Lincoln Cathedral. 1/- Isbister.<br /> Vivian, Herbert. Servia, the Poor Man&#039;s Paradise. 15/- Longmans.<br /> Vuilller, Gaston, from the French of. A History of Dancing.<br /> 36/- net. Heinemann.<br /> Walkley, 8. Io Quest of Shoba&#039;s Treasure. 3/6. Warne.<br /> Wallace, L. Wooing of Malkatoon and Oommodns. 10/6. Harper.<br /> Warborough, M. L. Tom Unlimited. 5/- Richards<br /> Ward, A. W. Sir Henry Wootton. 3/6. Constable.<br /> Ward, W. Life and Times of Cardinal Wiseman. 24/- Longmans.<br /> Warden, Florence. Dolly the Romp. 3/6. White.<br /> Warden, Florence. Girls will be Girls. 6/- White.<br /> Wardle, O. S. Voices of the Day. 3/6. Stock.<br /> Waterhouse, J. M. The Medhursts of Mindala. 6/- Stock.<br /> Watson, William. The Hope of the World, and other Poems.<br /> 8/6 net Lane.<br /> Way, T. R. and Wheatley, H. B. Later Bellquea of Old London.<br /> 21/- net BeU.<br /> Westlake, N, H. J. An Authentic Portraiture of St. Francis of<br /> Assisi. 7/6. Parker.<br /> White, Walter. The Journals of. «/- Chapman.<br /> Whitehead, Mrs. A E. (tr. from the French.) Dealings with the<br /> Dead. 8/6 net, Redway.<br /> Wilson, Ernest. Electrical Traction. 5/- Arnold.<br /> Winter, C. Gordon. The Crime of Vivian Carr. 6d. Roxburghe.<br /> Wister, Owen. Lin McLean. 6/- Harper.<br /> Wood, James L. Unveiling the Papacy. 1/- Marshall Bros.<br /> Woodhouse, W. J. Aetolia: Its Geography, Topography, Ac.<br /> 21/- not Frowde.<br /> Wyndham, Eric. Revelation. A Romance. 6/- Digby.<br /> Younghusband, G. J. Indian Frontier Warfare. 10/6. Kegan Paul.<br /> &quot;THE AUTHOR.&quot;<br /> SCALE FOR ADVERTISEMENTS.<br /> Front Page<br /> Other Pages<br /> Half of a Page<br /> Quarter of a Page<br /> Eighth of a Page<br /> Single Column Advertisements<br /> Bills for Insertion<br /> per inch<br /> per 2000<br /> .£400<br /> 3 0 0<br /> 1 10 0<br /> . 0 15 0<br /> 0 7 6<br /> 0 6 0<br /> 8 0 0<br /> Reductions made for a Series of Six or Twelve Insertions.<br /> All letters respecting Advertisements should be addressed either to<br /> the Advertisement MANAGER, The Author Office, 4, Portugal-street,<br /> W.O.; or to the Publisher (Hoaaoi Oox),1<br /> buildings, E.O.<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 228 (#663) ############################################<br /> <br /> AD VER TISEMENTS.<br /> iii<br /> <br /> A Charming Gift-Book.<br /> &quot;What would not the intelligent tourist in Paris<br /> or in Borne giro for such a book as this?&quot;—The<br /> Timet,<br /> &quot;A brilliant book.&quot;—The Sketch.<br /> ** Particularly good.&quot;— The Academy.<br /> &quot;The result of long experience and careful<br /> study.&quot;—Qlangov Herald.<br /> *&#039; written in a delightful literary style.&quot;—Dundce<br /> Courier.<br /> *&#039; In this neatly bound book will be found all the<br /> interesting features, old and new, of the richest,<br /> largest, wealthiest, and most populous city in the<br /> world. —Manchester Courier.<br /> Claret Roan, Gilt, 6s. net.<br /> LOUDON<br /> in the Time of the<br /> DIAMOND<br /> JUBILEE.<br /> By EMILY CONSTANCE COOK<br /> AHD<br /> E. T. COOK, M.A.,<br /> Author of &quot; Studies in Rustin&quot; «Crc.<br /> DARLINGTON&#039;S<br /> &quot;Nothing better conld<br /> be wished for.&quot;—Britith<br /> Weekly.<br /> &quot;Far superior to ordi-<br /> nary guides.&quot; — London<br /> Daily Chronicle.<br /> <br /> HANDBOOKS<br /> M Sir Henry Ponsonby is commanded<br /> by the Queen to thank Mr. Darlington<br /> for a copy of hie handbook.&quot;<br /> Edited by RALPH DABLHSQTON, F.BM.S. Is. each. IUuttrated.<br /> Maps by John Bartholomew, F.B.Q.S.<br /> THE ISLE Of WIGHT. I THE CHANNEL ISLANDS.<br /> THE TALE OF LLANGOLLEN. THE NORTH WALES COAST.<br /> BRECON AND ITS BEACONS. I THE SEVERN VALLEY.<br /> BOURNEMOUTH AND THE NEW FOREST. I THE WYE VALLEY.<br /> BRIGHTON, EASTBOURNE, HASTINGS, AND ST. LEONARDS.<br /> LLANDUDNO, RHYL, BETTWSYCOED, BANGOR, AND SNOWDON.<br /> ABERYSTWITH, TOWYN, BARMOUTH, AND DOLGELLY.<br /> MALVERN, HEREFORD, WORCESTER, AND GLOUCESTER.<br /> LLANDRINDOD WELLS AND THE SPAS OF MID-WALES.<br /> BRISTOL, BATH, CHEPSTOW, AND WESTON-SUPER-MARE.<br /> 3s. 6d. net, 60 Illustrations, 24 Maps and Plans.<br /> LONDON and Environs.<br /> Lokdoh: 8IMPKIN, MARSHALL, AND CO.<br /> Llisoollis: DARLINGTON AND CO.<br /> THE<br /> Fcap. 8to., 1b.<br /> HOTELS OF THE<br /> WORLD.<br /> Llaxoollkk: DARLINGTON &amp; CO. Londoh: 8IMPKIN. MARSHALL, ft CO. Ltd.<br /> Railway Bookstall * and all Booksellers.<br /> PHOTOGRAPHS-BIRTHDAY and SEASON CARDS from negatives by Ralph<br /> Dablinoto&#039;i, F.R.G.8.. of ocenery. Ruins, ftc, in Italy, Greece, Asia Minor, and Egypt, Is.,<br /> Is. 6d., 2s., 2s. Od. Mounted Specimen, post free, with complete list. Is.<br /> DARLINGTON &lt;&amp;e CO., LLANGOLLEN.<br /> Demy 8vo., cloth boards, price 10a. 6d.<br /> IN NEW SOUTH AFRICA.<br /> Travels in the Transvaal and Rhodesia.<br /> With Map and Twenty-six Illustrations.<br /> By II. LINCOLN TANGYE.<br /> Introductory.<br /> CONTENTS.<br /> PABT L<br /> Cuaptkr I.—The Land of Gold and the Way there.<br /> II.—Across Desert and Veldt.<br /> III. —Johannesburg the Golden.<br /> IV. —A Transvaal Coach Journey.<br /> V.—Natal: the South African Garden.<br /> VL—Ostracised in Africa. Home with the Swallows.<br /> PAST IX—EAMBLES IN BHODESIA.<br /> Chapter I—Eendragt Maakt Magt.<br /> ,, II.—Into the Country of Lobengula.<br /> „ m.—The Trail of War.<br /> ,, IV.—Goldmlning, Ancient and Modern.<br /> ,, V.—Sle Transit Gloria Mundl.<br /> „ VL—To Northern Mashonaland.<br /> „ VIL—Primitive Art. The Misadventures of a Wagon.<br /> London: Horace Cox. Windsor House, Bream&#039;a-buildings, E.C.<br /> Crown 8to., with illustrations, price 6s., to be had of all booksellers.<br /> FOE HIS COUNTRY&#039;S SAKE; or, Esca, a British<br /> Prince at the Court of Trajan. By L. M. P. BLACK.<br /> HORACl COX, Windsor House, Bream&#039;s-bulldlngs, London, E.O.<br /> RECENT VERSE.<br /> Cloth lettered,<br /> By HENBY TODD.<br /> LYRICS. By Dr. J. A. GOODCHILD.<br /> price 5s.<br /> NOBTH COUNTRY BALLADS.<br /> Price 6s.<br /> TALES IN VERSE. By Dr. J. A. GOODCHILD. Cloth<br /> lettered, price 5s.<br /> SONGS OF THE CASCADES. By ERL VIKING.<br /> Fcap. 8vo., cloth boards, 3s. 6d.<br /> SONGS OF THE PLNEWOODS. By ARTHUR CAMP-<br /> BELL. Price 3s. 6d.<br /> THE FAIREST OF THE ANGELS, and Other Verse.<br /> By MAEY COLBOBNE-VEEL. Fcap. 8vo., cloth boards, 3s. Cd.<br /> Some of the shorter lyrics are much above the average, being<br /> s of the collec-<br /> tion aro considerable.&quot;— The Bookman.<br /> clear in thought and musical In expression. The meritB t<br /> THE WANDERER IN THE LAND OF CYBI, and other<br /> Poems (1886-93). By CLIFFORD BROOKS. Fcap. 8vo., cloth<br /> boards, 3s. 6d.<br /> POEMS. By THOMAS BARLOW. Crown 8vo., beveUed<br /> boards, gilt edges, price 5s.<br /> POEMS. By LEWIS BROCKMAN. Crown 8vo., oloth<br /> boards, 5b.<br /> 11 The ballads are full of the spirit and directness of style proper to<br /> the ballad.&quot;—Saturday Review.<br /> 11 Mr. Brockman is a writer of good poetic mettle, and no doubt the<br /> reading world will hear more of him yet.&quot;—aicugov Herald.<br /> &quot;The graceful smoothness of Mr. Lewis Brockman&#039;s poems.&quot;—<br /> Daily Telegraph.<br /> M He is decidedly inventive, and often highly Imaginative. . . .<br /> The element of originality pervades the book. . . . His long poem,<br /> 1 Ronald&#039;s Cross,&#039; is well BUBtalned . . . it is like the plaint of the<br /> ♦ Mariner,&#039; and it holds us.&quot;—Queen.<br /> &quot;A reader who values cultured sentiments and flawless versifica-<br /> tion will find much to admire.&quot;—Scotsman.<br /> London: Horace Cox, Windsor House, Bream&#039;s<br /> E.C.<br /> <br /> <br /> ## p. 228 (#664) ############################################<br /> <br /> iv<br /> AD VER TISEMENTS.<br /> MERCANTILE TYPEWRITING OFFICE.<br /> (Manageress-MISS MOEGAN.)<br /> 158, LEADENHALL STREET, LONDON, E.C.<br /> Authors&#039; MSS. carefully copied from lOd. per 1000 words. Special Terms for Contract Work. All descriptions of Typewriting. Shorthand, and Translation work executed with accuracy and despatch.<br /> TYPEWRITING.<br /> Authors&#039; MSS. accurately Copied from IOd. per IOOO words.<br /> EIOHTY unsolicited testimonials.<br /> MBS. BRAY, 53, BEDFORD BOAD, CLAPHAM, S.W.<br /> T Y IF E -W RITIITG<br /> With Aoouraoy and Despatch.<br /> Authors&#039; MSS. 9d. per IOOO words.<br /> Plays, Translations, Indexing, General Copying.<br /> MISS WAY, 33, OSSIAN ROAD, STBOUD GBEEN, LOUDON, N.<br /> MRS. Q- ILL<br /> TYPB-WBITINO OFFICE,<br /> 35, LUDGATE HILL, E.C.<br /> (ESTABLISHED 1883.)<br /> Authors&#039; MSS. carefully copied from Is. per 1000 words. Duplicate<br /> copies third price. Skilled typists sent out by hour, day. or week.<br /> French MSS. accurately copied, or typewritten English translations<br /> supplied. References kindly permitted to Sir Walter Besant: also<br /> to Messrs. A. P. Watt and Son, Literary Agents, Hastings House.<br /> Norfolk-street. Stniml, W.O.<br /> Stick in your Soraps with<br /> STICKPHAST PASTE.<br /> Heaps better than gum.<br /> 6d. and Is., with strong, useful brush.<br /> Sold by Stationers, Chemists. Stores, Ac.<br /> Factory, 8TJGAK LOAF COUKT, K.C.<br /> Miss G-. XXA/\TI£.S,<br /> 178, OAKLET STREET, CHELSEA, S.W.<br /> Typewriting Accurately and Promptly Executed.<br /> A Floating Policy of Insurance.<br /> All MSS. received are Insured against loss or damage<br /> while being copied and on transit.<br /> Published every Friday morning; price, without Reports, 9d.; with<br /> Eeporta, Is.<br /> THE LAW TIMES, the Journal of the Law and the<br /> Lawyers, which has now been established for over half a century,<br /> supplies to the Profession a complete Record of the Progress of Legal<br /> Reforms, and of all matters affecting the Legal Profession. The<br /> imports &quot;i the Law Times are now recognised as the moat complete<br /> hteaor, «. 1. ,eries published.<br /> o. , r, a ,. , .Windsor House, Bream&#039;s-buildings, E C<br /> Stem, O. Self and (Tom.-—<br /> Stockton, Frank R. The Gi\».<br /> Typewriting bt Ci.rrsyman&#039;s Daughter add Assistants.<br /> MISS E. M. SIKES,<br /> The West Kensington Typewriting Agency,<br /> 13, Wolverton Gardens, Hammersmith, W.<br /> (Established 1893.)<br /> Authors&#039; MSS. carefully and promptly copied. Usual Terms.<br /> Legal and General Copying.<br /> Typewritten Circulars by Copying Process.<br /> Authors&#039; References.<br /> MISS<br /> PATTHX,<br /> TYPIST.<br /> 44, Oakley Street Flats, Chelsea. S.W.<br /> Authors&#039; MSS. cabkfully transcribed. References kindly<br /> permitted to many well-known Acinous.<br /> Fire - Proof Safe for MSS.<br /> Particulars on application. Telegraphic address: &quot;Patikn, London.&quot;<br /> AUTHOR&#039;S HAIRLESS PAPER-PAD<br /> (The LBADENHALL PRESS LTD., Publishers &amp; Printers<br /> 50, Leadenhall Street, London, E.C.)<br /> Contains hairless paper, over which the pen slips with perfect<br /> freedom. Sixpence each. 5s. per dozen, ruled or plain.<br /> Authors should note that Ths Leadenhall Press Ltd. oannot be<br /> responsible for the loss of MSS. by Are or otherwise. Duplicate<br /> copies should be retained.<br /> A N Elderly MAN, who for some years had a School<br /> in Hampstead, would thankfully<br /> UNDERTAKE TRANSLATION,<br /> or work of any kind requiring good classical scholarship,<br /> for the most modest remuneration.<br /> Address &quot;A. B.,*&#039;<br /> Care of The Author.<br /> TheTh? Artof I89?nd PubUahed °y Hobacb Cox, Windsor House, Bream&#039;s-buildings, London, E.C.https://historysoa.com/files/original/5/311/1898-01-01-The-Author-8-8.pdfpublications, The Author