354 | https://historysoa.com/items/show/354 | The Author, Vol. 12 Issue 11 (June 1902) | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=49&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=%3Cem%3EThe+Author%3C%2Fem%3E%2C+Vol.+12+Issue+11+%28June+1902%29"><em>The Author</em>, Vol. 12 Issue 11 (June 1902)</a> | | | <a href="https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015006979390" target="_blank" rel="noopener">https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015006979390</a> | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=51&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Publication">Publication</a> | 1902-06-01-The-Author-12-11 | | | | | 213–236 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=89&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=12">12</a> | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=76&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=1902-06-01">1902-06-01</a> | | | | | | | 11 | | | 19020601 | The Elu tbor.<br />
(The Organ of the Incorporated Society of Authors. Monthly.)<br />
VOL. XII.-No. 11.<br />
JUNE 1, 1902.<br />
[PRICE SIXPENCE.<br />
PAGE<br />
226<br />
213<br />
226<br />
228<br />
228<br />
CONTENTS.<br />
PAGE<br />
Notices ....<br />
213<br />
The Reading Branch ... ... ...<br />
The Pension Fund of the Society of Authors<br />
Authorities ... ... ...<br />
From the Committee ...<br />
After Sunset<br />
214<br />
...<br />
..<br />
... ***<br />
Book and Play Talk<br />
215<br />
Literary Provluction in England ...<br />
Literary, Dramatic, and Musical Property ...<br />
210<br />
Two Americans...<br />
S... ... ...<br />
The Annual Dinner ...<br />
218<br />
William Black: a Biography<br />
Patchwork Legislation and Musical Performing Right<br />
219<br />
The Obligations of Art to Trade ... ...<br />
Tauchnitz Editions<br />
".. .. ... ... ... ... 221<br />
A Page from a German Publisher's Advertisements<br />
Bricks and Mortar ...<br />
223<br />
Romantic Germany... ...<br />
General Memoranda ...<br />
225<br />
The Literary Side of President Roosevelt ...<br />
Warnings to Dramatic Authors<br />
225<br />
How to Use the Society<br />
Correspondence... ... ... ... ... ...<br />
230<br />
::::::<br />
231<br />
232<br />
232<br />
233<br />
234<br />
235<br />
The Society of Authors (Incorporated).<br />
PRESIDENT.<br />
GEORGE MEREDITH.<br />
COUNCIL<br />
SIR EDWIN ARNOLD, K.C.I.E., C.S.I. | THE RIGHT Hox. THE LORD CURZON ! THE REV. W. J. LOFTIE, F.S.A.<br />
THE RIGHT Hon. THE LORD AVE OF KEDLESTON.<br />
THE REV. C. H. MIDDLETON-WAKE.<br />
BURY, P.C.<br />
AUSTIN DOBSON.<br />
SIR LEWIS MORRIS.<br />
J. M. BARRIE.<br />
A. CONAN DOYLE, M.D.<br />
HENRY NORMAN, M.P.<br />
A. W. 2 BECKETT.<br />
A. W. DUB0UᎡG.<br />
GILBERT PARKER, M.P.<br />
ROBERT BATEMAN.<br />
SIR MICHAEL FOSTER, K.C.B., M.P., J. C. PARKINSON.<br />
F. E. BEDDARD, F.R.S.<br />
F.R.S.<br />
A. W. PINERO.<br />
SIR HENRY BERGNE, K.C.M.G.<br />
D. W. FRESHFIELD.<br />
The Right Hon. The LORD PIR-<br />
AUGUSTINE BIRRELL, K.C.<br />
RICHARD GARNETT, C.B., LL.D.<br />
BRIGHT, F.R.S<br />
THE REV. PROF. BONNEY, F.R.S. EDMUND GOSSE.<br />
SIR FREDERICK POLLOCK, Bait,LL.D.<br />
THE Right Hon. JAMES BRYCE, M.P. SYDNEY GRUNDY.<br />
WALTER HERRIES POLLOCK.<br />
THE RIGHT Hon. THE LORD BURGH H. RIDER HAGGARD.<br />
E. Rose.<br />
CLERE<br />
MRS. HARRISON (LUCAS MALET). W. BAPTISTE SCOONES.<br />
HALL CAINE.<br />
THOMAS HARDY.<br />
OWEN SEAMAN.<br />
EGERTON CASTLE, F.S.A.<br />
ANTHONY HOPE HAWKINS.<br />
Miss Flora L. SHAW.<br />
EDWARD CLODD.<br />
JEROME K. JEROME.<br />
G. R. SIMs.<br />
W. MORRIS COLLES.<br />
J. SCOTT KELTIE, LL.D.<br />
S. SQUIRE SPRIGGE.<br />
THE Hox. JOHN COLLIER,<br />
RUDYARD KIPLING.<br />
J. J. STEVENSON.<br />
SIR W. MARTIN CONWAY.<br />
PROF. E, RAY LANKESTER, F.R.S. FRANCIS STORR.<br />
MRS. CRAIGIE.<br />
THE RIGHT Hon.W.E. H.LECKY,M.P. WILLIAM MOY THOMAS.<br />
F. MARION CRAWFORD.<br />
| J. M. LELY.<br />
| MRS. HUMPHRY WARD.<br />
Ilon. Counsel – E. M. UNDERDOWN, K.C.<br />
COMMITTEE OF MANAGEMENT.<br />
Chairman-A. HOPE HAWKINS.<br />
Vice-Chairman -- A. W. À BECKETT.<br />
d. CONAN DOYLE, M.D.<br />
J. M. LELY.<br />
E. Rose.<br />
D. W. FRESHFIELD.<br />
HENRY NORMAN, M.P.<br />
OWEN SEAMAX.<br />
SYDNEY GRUNDY.<br />
GILBERT PARKER, M.P.<br />
FRANCIS STORR.<br />
S.Jitme (FIELI), ROSCOE, and Co., Lincoln's Inn Fields.<br />
G. HERBERT THRING, 39, Old Queen Street, S.W.<br />
Secretary-G. HERBERT THRING<br />
OFFICES: 39, OLD QUEEN STREET, STOREY'S GATE, S.W.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 212 (#624) ############################################<br />
<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
SALE OF MSS. OF EVERY KIND.<br />
Literary Advice, Revision, Research, etc.<br />
. TeLTERARY AGENCJA<br />
ARRANGEMENTS FOR<br />
BAONDO<br />
Printing, Publishing, Illustration, Translation, etc.<br />
THE LITERARY AGENCY OF LONDON,<br />
5, HENRIETTA STREET, W.C.<br />
G. H. PERRIS.<br />
C. F. CAZENOVE.<br />
<br />
TYPEWRITING COMPANY, Oswald House, Queen Victoria Road, Coventry.<br />
Typewriting of every description, from Ninepence per Thousand Words<br />
(including good paper). Specimens on application.<br />
Unique and Artistic Specimens of Typewriting may be seen at the above Address.<br />
Testimonial.-“ Undoubtedly the finest piece of work I have ever seen produced on a Typewriter."<br />
" REMINGTON STANDARD" up-to-date Instruments.<br />
MRS. GILL,<br />
TYPE-WRITING OFFICE.<br />
35, LUDGATE HILL, E.C.<br />
DARLINGTON'S HANDBOOKS<br />
(ESTABLISHED 1883.)<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully copied from ls. per 1000 words. Duplicate<br />
copies third price. Skilled typists sent out by hour, day or week.<br />
French MSS. accurately copied, or typewritten English translations<br />
supplied. References kindly permitted to Messrs. A. P. Watt & Son.<br />
Literary Agents, Hastings House, Norfolk Street, Strand, W.C.<br />
N<br />
“Sir Henry Ponsonby is<br />
commanded by the Queen to<br />
e thank Mr. Darlington for a<br />
copy of his Handbook."<br />
"Nothing better could be wished for." - Britisu WEEKLY.<br />
“Far superior to ordinary guides."— LONDON DAILY CHRONICLE..<br />
Edited by RALPH DARLINGTON, F.R.G.S. 18. each. Illustrated,<br />
with Maps by John BARTHOLOMEW, F.R.G.S.<br />
THE WEST KENSINGTON TYPEWRITING AGENCY.<br />
SIKES and SIKES,<br />
13, Wolverton Gardens, Hammersmith Road, W.<br />
ESTABLISHED 1893.<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully and promptly copied. Usual Terms.<br />
Phonograph used. Translations.<br />
Legal and General Copying.<br />
Typewritten Circulars, etc., by Duplicator.<br />
LESSONS GIVEN. AUTHORS' REFERENCES.<br />
TYPEWRITING.<br />
THE ISLE OF WIGHT.<br />
THE CHANNEL ISLANDS.<br />
THE VALE OF LLANGOLLEN. THE NORFOLK BROADS.<br />
BRECON AND ITS BEACONS. THE SEVERN VALLEY.<br />
BOURNEMOUTH AND THE NEW FOREST. THE WYE VALLEY.<br />
BRIGHTON, EASTBOURNE, HASTINGS, AND ST. LEONARDS.<br />
ABERYSTWITH, TOWYN, BARMOUTH, AND DOLGELLY.<br />
MALVERN, HEREFORD, WORCESTER, AND GLOUCESTER.<br />
LLANDRINDOD WELLS AND THE SPAS OF MID-WALES.<br />
BRISTOL, BATH, CHEPSTOW, AND WESTON-SUPER-MARE.<br />
LLANDUDNO, RHYL, BANGOR, CARNARVON, ANGLESEA.<br />
CONWAY, COLWYN BAY, BETTWS-Y-COED, SNOW DON, &c.<br />
NORWICH, YARMOUTH, LOWESTOFT, AND THE<br />
NORFOLK BROADS.<br />
Authors' MSS. accurately copied from 8d. per 1,000<br />
words. Experienced in all kinds of scientific and<br />
difficult MSS. Reduction for large quantities.<br />
MISS CARRINGTON,<br />
27, Kelmscott Road, Clapham, S.W.<br />
THE AUTHOR."<br />
SCALE FOR ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
(ALLOWANCE TO MEMBERS OF THE SOCIETY 20 PER CENT.]<br />
"The best Handbook to London ever issued."-LIVERPOOL DAILY POST.<br />
“THE Handbook to London-it very emphatically tops them all." -<br />
DAILY GRAPHIC.<br />
4th Edition, Revised, Bs. 60 Ilustrations, 24 Maps and Plans.<br />
LONDON AND ENVIRONS.<br />
By E. C. Cook and E. T. Cook, M.A.<br />
.<br />
Front Page<br />
*" ..<br />
Other Pages<br />
...£4 0 0<br />
... ... 300<br />
Half of a Page ...<br />
... ... ... 1 10 0<br />
Quarter of a Page<br />
... 0 15 0<br />
Eighth of a Page<br />
... 0 7 6<br />
Single Column Advertisements<br />
... per inch 0 6 0<br />
Bills for Insertion<br />
per 2,000 3 0<br />
Tieduction of 20 per cent, made for a Series of Sir and of 25 per cent. for<br />
Twelve Insertions.<br />
Advertisements should reach the Office not later than the 20th for<br />
insertion in the following month's issue.<br />
All letters respecting Advertisements should be addressed to the<br />
ADVERTISEMENT MANAGER, The Author Office, 39, Old Queen Street,<br />
Storeys Gate, S.WS.<br />
Fcap. 8vo. 15. THE HOTELS OF THE WORLD.<br />
A Handbook to the leading Hotels throughout the world.<br />
Llangollen: DARLINGTON & Co. London: SIMPKIN, MARSHALL & Co.,<br />
LTD. Railway Bookstalls and all Booksellers.<br />
PHOTOGRAPHS.-BIRTHDAY and SEASON CARDS from negatives by<br />
RALPH DARLINGTON, F.R.G.S., of Scenery, Ruins, &c., in Italy, Greece,<br />
Asia Minor, and Egypt, ls., 1s. 64., 2s., and 2s. 60, List, post free, of<br />
DARLINGTON & CO., LLANGOLLEN,<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 213 (#625) ############################################<br />
<br />
The Author.<br />
(The Organ of the Incorporated Society of Authors. Jonthly.)<br />
FOUNDED BY SIR WALTER BESANT.<br />
VOL. XII.–No. 11.<br />
JUNE 1ST, 1902.<br />
[PRICE SIXPENCE.<br />
CHANGE OF ADDRESS.<br />
considered unnecessary to print the full list with<br />
every issue.<br />
Donations ......<br />
......................£1439 16 6<br />
Subscriptions ......<br />
..... 111 6 0<br />
The office of the Incorporated Society of Authors<br />
has been removed to-<br />
39, OLD QUEEN STREET,<br />
STOREY'S GATE, S.W.<br />
DONATIONS.<br />
1<br />
os<br />
.<br />
....<br />
....<br />
...<br />
....<br />
0<br />
6<br />
NOTICES.<br />
DOR the opinions expressed in papers that are<br />
signed or initialled the Authors alone are<br />
responsible. None of the papers or para.<br />
graphs must be taken as expressing the opinion<br />
of the Committee unless such is especially stated<br />
to be the case.<br />
Nov. 9, Dale, Miss .....<br />
Oct. 10, Harrison, Mrs. (Lucas Malet)<br />
Oct. 15, Rossi, Miss L.<br />
.........<br />
Oct. 25, Potter, M. H. ...... ......<br />
Oct. 30, Stanley, Mrs..<br />
Nov. 21. Balfour. A. ........<br />
Nov. 22. Risley, J..........<br />
..........<br />
Nov. 25. Walker, W. S......<br />
Jan. 24, Church, Prof. R. A. H. ...<br />
Jan. 29, Toplis, Miss Grace ..........<br />
Feb. 1, Perks, Miss Lily................<br />
Feb. 12, Brown, Miss Prince .........<br />
Feb. 15, Wilkins, W. H. (2nd donation)<br />
Feb. 15, S. G. ...............<br />
Feb. 17, Hawkins, A. Hope ............<br />
Feb. 19, Burrowes, Miss E. ............<br />
Mch. 16, Reynolds, Mrs. ...............<br />
April 28, Wheelright, Miss Ethel......<br />
April 29, Sheldon, Mrs. French,<br />
F.R.G.S.........<br />
May 5, A Beginner ...............<br />
......<br />
May 20, Nemo ........................<br />
May 20, Dr. A. Rattray<br />
2 11<br />
5 5<br />
0 10<br />
0 12<br />
0 10<br />
0 5<br />
0 5<br />
1 0<br />
2 2<br />
0 4<br />
0 10<br />
1 1<br />
cer BOERNO er er<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
1<br />
50<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
THE Editor begs to inform Members of the<br />
Authors' Society and other readers of The Author<br />
that the cases which are from time to time quoted<br />
in me Author are cases that have come before the<br />
notice or to the knowledge of the Secretary of the<br />
d that those members of the Society<br />
who desire to have the names of the publishers<br />
concerned can obtain them on application.<br />
........<br />
0<br />
1<br />
2<br />
0<br />
5<br />
1<br />
0<br />
5<br />
0<br />
(0)<br />
0<br />
0<br />
M<br />
ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTIONS.<br />
THE PENSION FUND OF THE SOCIETY Nov. 25, Vaux, P. .<br />
OF AUTHORS.<br />
Nov. 25, Lambe, Lawrence ........<br />
Jan. 17, Prelooker, J. ..........<br />
Jan. 20, Nickolls, F. C. ..........<br />
HE following is the total of donations and Jan. 22, Carey, Miss R. Nouchette ...<br />
subscriptions promised or received up to Mch. 20, Beeching, Rev. H. C. ......<br />
the present date.<br />
Mch. 25, Stroud, F. ...<br />
Further sums will be acknowledged from month Apr. 9, Kitcat, Mrs. .....<br />
to month as they come to hand. It has been May 1, Heatley, Richard Y........<br />
Vol. XII.<br />
1 1<br />
1 1<br />
0 5<br />
0 5<br />
1 1<br />
0 5<br />
0 10<br />
1 1<br />
0 5<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
0<br />
6<br />
(0)<br />
0<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 214 (#626) ############################################<br />
<br />
214<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
FROM THE COMMITTEE.<br />
Ta meeting of the Committee held on Monday,<br />
| May 12th, it was decided to close the office<br />
of the Society on Saturday, June 28th-<br />
the Saturday following the Coronation holidays.<br />
The sanction of the editors has been in many<br />
cases obtained to the form and substance of the<br />
insertion, and where this is the case a note to that<br />
effect has been appended.<br />
Three hundred copies of the revised edition<br />
have been printed, and are now for sale at the<br />
offices of the Society. The price is 6d. a cops.<br />
As the pamphlet cannot fail to be of use to all<br />
those who contribute to magazines, the Committee<br />
trust there will be no difficulty in disposing of this<br />
number.<br />
Canadian Copyright.<br />
THE Committee consider that the time has now<br />
arrived to make a full statement of their action<br />
with regard to Canadian copyright.<br />
They take this step as there appears to be mis-<br />
understanding of their position by certain trade<br />
associations in Canada which are not in sympathy<br />
with certain aspects of the Imperial view of the<br />
copyright question.<br />
Since the refusal of the Canadian Government to<br />
collect the royalties under the Foreign Reprints<br />
Act, and since the passing of the Canadian Act of<br />
1900, an Act which gives to the Canadian pub-<br />
lisher security of contract when trading with the<br />
English author, the Committee have advocated no<br />
alteration in the status quo.<br />
It was in order to place before the Canadian<br />
authorities the views of the Committee, and in<br />
order to throw the weight of the Society's in-<br />
fluence on the side of a just and liberal policy,<br />
as opposed to the narrow trade issue of a printing<br />
clause, that the Committee sent Mr. Thring, the<br />
Secretary of the Society, to Canada in 1898.<br />
His efforts were advantageously forwarded by<br />
Mr. Gilbert Parker, a member of the Authors'<br />
Society Committee, and in 1900 an Act was<br />
passed which effectually secured those points for<br />
which the Committee had been struggling.<br />
The Committee desire a free and untrammelled<br />
copyright, unbampered by trade restrictions of<br />
printing, licensing, and Government-collected<br />
royalties. Firstly, for the benefit of Canadians<br />
and Canadian literature, and, secondly, for the<br />
protection of the property of the authors in the<br />
United Kingdom and the Empire at large.<br />
To put forward anything else would be in the<br />
interests of a system of copyright legislation<br />
destructive to international agreement, and<br />
analogous to the legislation of the 18th century,<br />
prior to the existence of any international agree-<br />
ment with regard to copyright.<br />
The Work of the Society.<br />
Since the last issue of The Author, the Secretary<br />
has dealt with ten cases.<br />
Of these, five referred to the return of MSS.,<br />
two were claims for money, one for breach of<br />
contract, and two for the rendering of accounts.<br />
Of the cases taken up in previous months there are<br />
still four unsettled. Of these, three claims are for<br />
money due ; but as two are against a bankrupt<br />
magazine, it is probable that the authors will<br />
obtain nothing. The third case is in course of<br />
satisfactory settlement, and a substantial offer has<br />
been obtained from the other side.<br />
Three of the cases taken in hand during the<br />
past month have already terminated in favour of<br />
the author.<br />
Since the beginning of the year, eighty-nine<br />
members and associates have been elected to the<br />
Society. The last election registered eleven<br />
members and five associates.<br />
Besant Memorial.<br />
The Besant Memorial now stands as follows :-<br />
Up to the end of February subscrip-<br />
tions were received, according to the<br />
long list already issued, amounting to. £293 4 0<br />
During the months of March, April,<br />
and May the subscriptions received<br />
amounted to . . . . . 31 11 6<br />
Total ... £324 15 6<br />
Subscriptions received during March and April.<br />
Anonymous . . . . . £1 1 0<br />
Champneys, Basil .<br />
“ Colonia,” Natal, S. Africa<br />
1 1 0<br />
Fife Cookson, Lt.-Col. F. C.<br />
1 1 0<br />
Gunter, Lt.-Col. E. A. .<br />
0 10 0<br />
Harding, Capt. Claud, R.N.<br />
1 0 0<br />
Hurry, A. . .<br />
0 10 6<br />
Keary, C. F. (amount not to be men-<br />
tioned)<br />
Kinns, The Rev. Samuel, D.D. . . . ā 0<br />
Magazines and Contributors.<br />
THE inset in the January number of The<br />
Author, entitled “Periodicals and their contri.<br />
butors," has been considerably enlarged and<br />
republished by order of the Committee.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 215 (#627) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
215<br />
·<br />
·<br />
· ·<br />
·<br />
·<br />
·<br />
·<br />
· ·<br />
·<br />
· ·<br />
·<br />
·<br />
·<br />
·<br />
· ·<br />
·<br />
·<br />
·<br />
.<br />
· ·<br />
er oororo<br />
.<br />
.<br />
·<br />
.<br />
· ·<br />
.<br />
.<br />
·<br />
.<br />
·<br />
.<br />
·<br />
Millais, J. G.<br />
• 1 ( 0) expects to get it finished in preliminary form, and<br />
Quiller Couch, Miss M.<br />
0 5 0 the first pripting done, sometime in June. It will<br />
Sterry, J. Ashby .<br />
1 1 0 then undergo two different revisions -one for each<br />
Temple, Lieut.-Col. R. C.<br />
1 1 0 number as it comes out, and the other before it<br />
Underdown, Miss E.<br />
0 - 0 finally appears in book form.<br />
Lockyer, Sir T. Norman<br />
2 2 A translation of " Eleanor” is appearing as the<br />
Beale, Miss Mary .<br />
0 2 feuilleton in the Giornale d'Italia. It is at<br />
Bolam, Rev. C. E. .<br />
0 5 0 present uncertain when the dramatised version of<br />
Egbert, Henry . .<br />
0 5 0<br />
* Eleanor” will be produced.<br />
16 Floone" willen<br />
Eccles, Miss O'Connor<br />
1 1 0<br />
Mr. Arthur Morrison's new novel, “ The Hole in<br />
Darwin, Francis .<br />
1 1 0<br />
the Wall,” is to be published in the autumn. by<br />
Campbell-Montgomery, Miss F. F. 1. 1 0<br />
Messrs. Methuen & Co., and in America by<br />
Medlecott, Cecil<br />
0 10 6<br />
Maclure, Phillips & Co. It is a story of London<br />
Saxby, Mrs. .<br />
1 1 0<br />
life. The scene is laid in Wapping and Ratcliff<br />
Caine, T. H. Hall .<br />
10 0 0<br />
Highway, with the docks and river, about thirty-<br />
Marris, Miss Murrell<br />
0 5 0<br />
five years ago, when that neighbourhood was one of<br />
S. B.<br />
0 5 0<br />
the most picturesque in the world, despite its squalor.<br />
Bloomfield, J. H. .<br />
1 0 0<br />
F. 0. B. (Coventry).<br />
“ Fuel of<br />
0 5 0<br />
Fire," Miss Ellen Thorneycroft<br />
Seton-Karr, H. W..<br />
1 0 0<br />
Fowler's new novel, is to be published in book<br />
Heriot, Cheyne<br />
( 5 0<br />
form at 6s. next October, by Messrs. Hodder and<br />
Charley, Sir W. T.,<br />
. 1 1 0<br />
Stoughton.<br />
Mr. Louis Zangwill has been working at a long<br />
novel entitled “One's Womenkind,” which will<br />
BOOK AND PLAY TALK,<br />
probably be published in the autuin.<br />
There is a strong article in the May number of<br />
The New Liberal Review by Mr. I, Zangwill under<br />
“ CYEVEN Years' Legislation " is the title given<br />
the title “ Why Jews Succeed.” He begins by<br />
O by Mr. J. M. Lely to the just published<br />
saying, “I welcome the task of answering this<br />
supplemental and fourteenth volume of the<br />
question, Why Jews Succeed, if only for the<br />
fifth edition of “ Chitty's Statutes of Practical<br />
opportunity of explaining that they do not.”<br />
Utility” (Sweet & Maxwell, Limited ; Stevens &<br />
Sons, Limited). It contains more than two hundred<br />
Mr. John Huntly Skrine, Warden of Glenalmond,<br />
and author of "A Memory of Edward Thring,"<br />
Acts, from 1895 to 1901, both inclusive.<br />
“Joan the Maid,” etc., etc., has just published a<br />
The Acts selected and annotated include the<br />
volume entitled “Pastor Agnorum : A School-<br />
Friendly Societies Act, 1896 ; the Workmen's<br />
master's Afterthoughts” (Longmans, 58. net).<br />
Compensation Acts of 1897 and 1900 ; the Bene-<br />
fices Act, the Criminal Evidence Act, and the<br />
Mr. Foster Fraser's new work, “ The Real<br />
Vaccination Act of 1898; the London Govern-<br />
Siberia,” has just been published by Messrs.<br />
ment Act of 1899; the Commonwealth of Australia<br />
Cassell & Co. It contains eighty-seven illustra-<br />
Constitution Act : the Companies Act, and the tions from photographs.<br />
Agricultural Holdings Act of 1900 ; and the Civil The serial rights of Mr. G. S. Layard's novel.<br />
List Act of 1901. The work is a consolidation, "Rupert the Mummer," have been purchased by<br />
with additional notes up to date, of the seven Messrs. Pearson.<br />
annual issues which followed the publication of the Miss Jetta S. Wolff, author of “Les Français<br />
fiſth edition in 1894.<br />
en Ménage,” “Les Français en Voyage," etc., etc.,<br />
In the Preface attention is drawn to the curious and of the recently-published novel, “No Place<br />
facts that the Ballot Act and about 100 other Acts for Her," has just brought out a third volume of<br />
are still temporary only; and that our twice- the series illustrative of French life and language.<br />
revised Statute Book still treats Calais as part of It gives a succession of scenes from child-life in<br />
England, still consigns perjurers to the pillory (to France, under the title “Français pour les tous-<br />
which they are to have both their ears pailed), and petits.” Like the preceding volumes, it is<br />
Sunday traders to the stocks; and is still in admirably illustrated by Mr. W. Foster (Edward<br />
various other ways strangely in conflict with Arnold, is.).<br />
modern legislative views.<br />
Miss Rosa Nouchette Carey's new novel is to be<br />
Mrs. Humphry Ward is still at work on her new published in the autumn by Messrs. Macmillan.<br />
novel, “ Lady Rose's Daughter,” which has begun The same publishers have just issued a sixpenny<br />
to appear in Harper's this month. Mrs. Ward edition of Miss Carey's first novel, “ Nettie's<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 216 (#628) ############################################<br />
<br />
216<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
ixpenny seringillan, and added een purchased by<br />
Memories.” It has been abridged by Miss H. M. Queen,” published by Mr. Edward Arnold, bas<br />
Burnside, the poetess.<br />
just been produced by Messrs. Appleton & Co. in<br />
“ Other People's Lives," another of Miss Carey's America. The New York Press have given it<br />
novels, which was formerly in the hands of Messrs. good reviews.<br />
Hodder & Stoughton, has been p:irchased by In a recent interview (" The Young Man ") Dr.<br />
Messrs. Macmillan, and added to the three-and- Garnett speaks hopefully of the literary future.<br />
sixpenny series of Miss Carey's works.<br />
He does not think that there is any decline in the<br />
In her new novel, “ The Blood Tax: A Military proportion of students of the best literature. The<br />
Romance,” Dorothea Gerard deals with the spread of culture is preparing the taste of the<br />
question of conscription. The authoress, whose people for something better, and the demand for<br />
real name is Madame Longard de Longgarde, is higher quality will produce those capable of satisfs-<br />
the wife of an Austrian officer, and as such she ing the demand. The writers of to-day are paving<br />
has had special opportunities of studying the<br />
opportunities of studying the the way for the approach of a grander and more<br />
various Continental military systems at close<br />
brilliant literature than has hitherto been known.<br />
quarters. Messrs. Hutchinson & Co. are the Miss Mary Cholmondeley has nearly completed<br />
publishers.<br />
a new novel. Miss Cholmondeley is a most pains-<br />
- “ The Night Side of London," by Mr. Robert taking writer, every sentence being carefully<br />
Machray, consists of a series of sketches describing weighed, and if necessary rewritten.<br />
London night life, and it is illustrated with about The first edition of Mr. Aylmer Maude's book,<br />
a hundred original pictures by Tom Browne, “Tolstoy and His Problems," has been out of print<br />
R.I., R.B.A.<br />
for some time. A second and cheaper edition will<br />
This book has been in preparation for more shortly be issued by Mr. Grant Richards.<br />
than a year, and is a faithful record by pen and Mr. Richard Whiteing has written an introduc-<br />
pencil of things seen in London at night during tion for the new edition of “ No. 5, John Street,"<br />
1901—2. There is an édition de lure at one which Mr. Grant Richards is issuing as the first<br />
guinea. The price of the popular edition - the volume of a new three-and-sixpenny series of<br />
first impression consists of 10,000 copies—is 6s. select novels. The volume has been re-set from<br />
Mr. John Macqueen is the English publisher, and fresh type.<br />
Messrs. Lippincott are publishing it in America. We must not expect to see any drama from the<br />
Mr. Robert Cromie has published, through pen of Mr. Sydney Grundy produced this season.<br />
Messrs. Digby, Long & Co., a romance called “Pilkerton's Peerage” will be withdrawn at the<br />
“ A New Messiah.” The story is crowded with Garrick on June 6th. Mr. Arthur Bourchier will<br />
exciting incidents. Mr. Cromie is known as the produce a new comedy by Mrs. Craigie and Mr.<br />
author of “The Crack of Doom,”. “Kitty's Murray Carson, called “ The Bishop's Move."<br />
Victoria Cross,” “A Plunge into Space,” etc., etc.<br />
Early in October Messrs. Marlborough & Co.<br />
will publish a companion or supplement to Eastern<br />
guide-books, entitled, “Hints for Travellers in the LITERARY, DRAMATIC, AND MUSICAL<br />
Near East.” It is written by Mr. E. A. Reynolds-<br />
PROPERTY.<br />
Ball, and it will contain all kinds of practical<br />
advice, hints, maxims, wrinkles (exploring, sport-<br />
Reduction of Postage on Authors' MSS.<br />
ing, medical, etc.), likely to be of use to those<br />
travelling in Morocco, Algeria, Tunis, Egypt,<br />
CANADIAN, writing from the standpoint of<br />
Palestine, Greece, Malta, Cyprus and the Levant.<br />
a patriot and an Imperialist, brought forward<br />
“Horrors at Holmlands," by J. Harris Brig.<br />
this question in The Author—the question<br />
of reduced postage on MSS. From other motives<br />
house, a member of our Society, is a short,<br />
the American Authors' Society has prepared and<br />
exciting tale in pamphlet form. The mysteries<br />
brought forward a Bill before Congress. It has been<br />
have, we understand, a scientific solution.<br />
introduced by the Hon. Amos J. Cumming, and<br />
Mr. Hamilton Aïdė's new volume is a collection referred to the Committee on Post Offices and Post<br />
of seven little plays, called “We are Seven : Half Roads.<br />
Hours on the Stage, Grave and Gay.” One of The American Author says :<br />
these little pieces has been acted by Madame “ Perhaps there is nothing in which writers are so uni-<br />
Sarah Bernhardt; another has been played by versally interested as in this movement. The lengthening<br />
Mrs. Kendal, and another by Madame Modjeska. of the duration of copyright appeals only to the few who<br />
Mr. John Murray is the publisher.<br />
have been long in the field, and who tind the period of<br />
forty-two years insufficient for the full realisation of profit<br />
Miss Theodora Wilson - Wilson's “ T'Bacca from their classic productions, and to those who hope their<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 217 (#629) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
217<br />
efforts may live to be classic for the benefit of their the very essence of this case, that has been con-<br />
descendants.<br />
stantly brought before the members of the Society<br />
“ It is the young writer particularly who sees the fruit of :<br />
his toil eaten up, often before it is earned, by the amount<br />
in other forms and with a bearing on other matters.<br />
which he must expend for the frequent trips to be made It is essential in the publication of a book, in the<br />
by his manuscript before it reaches favourable consider. publication of an article in a magazine, in an<br />
ation, and is returned accompanied by the printed arrangement between an author and agent, in all<br />
reproduction.<br />
in the arguments in favour of the Bill are many, and it matters of business, to have a precise contract<br />
is difficult to think of any reasonable cause for opposition. clearly defined and clearly expressed. Fully half<br />
The postal revenues are large, and but for extensively the disputes that arise are due to this lack of<br />
subsidised star routes and many abuses of second-rate finality,<br />
matter, which might easily be remedied, there would be a<br />
.<br />
"M<br />
Mr. Heinemann, in the article he wrote for The<br />
namonn in the in<br />
considerable surplus revenue.<br />
" The question has been asked, How could the privilege Author some months ago with regard to agents,<br />
once granted be safeguarded ?<br />
said that the work done by an agent could be<br />
“ That a law may be violated is no reason why it should<br />
settled as easily by a solicitor. This statement we<br />
fail of enactment. The regulations of the Post Office<br />
Department now provide for the examination of all mail<br />
have grave reasons for doubting. Many contracts<br />
matter not sealed, and it would be easy, if necessary, to have come to the office settled by the ordinary<br />
formulate additional rules to prevent letter writers availing solicitor which were by no means final. There<br />
themselves of manuscript privileges; then, too, a severe<br />
were many omissions which might give rise to<br />
penalty would act as a deterrent.<br />
“ When accompanied by proof manuscripts are now<br />
difficulties and quarrels owing to the solicitor's<br />
carried at third-class rates—why not when alone ?<br />
ignorance of the technical side of copyright law<br />
"His manuscript is the author's merchandise. Why and publishing contracts.<br />
should he be discriminated against when all other mer Mr. Longman, at the same time, suggested that<br />
chandise goes for third-class rates ? England has seen her<br />
way clear to make this reduction, and many other foreign<br />
agents were useful in that they took away the<br />
countries have followed suit. They have been able to<br />
business part of the contract from the author, and<br />
prevent its abuse-why not the United States ?<br />
thus enabled the author and the publisher to meet<br />
. “Manuscript can be sent to, or returned from, publishers together on more friendly grounds, to discuss<br />
in foreign countries at third-class rates, why should it cost<br />
other questions dealing with the publication of<br />
more to send them from Dobbs Ferry to New York, or<br />
from point to point in the city? To send ten ounces of the book.<br />
manuscript to a publisher in England costs five cents. To We are inclined to agree with Mr. Longman.<br />
send it to one in Twenty-third Street costs twenty cents. Many authors go to publishers because they<br />
** An author must pay two postages on every manuscript<br />
know them personally.<br />
in<br />
to carry it to a publisher and bring it back if rejected, and<br />
this process is ordinarily repeated many times before the Some sort of contract is entered into either by<br />
final resting place is reached. On the other hand, the dry word of mouth or contained in a series of letters.<br />
goods stores deliver small packages of goods which are<br />
The exact terms are obscure, misty, and indefinite.<br />
The exact terms are obscure misty and<br />
handled but once, and pay but once, one cent for every Thors or omissions about which the author<br />
There are omissions about which the author<br />
two ounces. In the interests of fair play and justice, the<br />
change should be made, and now,<br />
knows nothing. He does not take advice, he is<br />
• Every one interested should unite with the Society in dealing with a friend. Even on some points that<br />
its effort for the benefit of the craft, and promptly impor- are clearly antagonistic to his interest he is silent.<br />
tune his, or her, representative in Congress to carry the Why? fe is dealing with a friend.<br />
measure through at this session."<br />
The result is often disastrous. The author,<br />
Whatever motive prompts those who are agitating perhaps, is dissatisfied on some minor question, and<br />
in this cause, this point is clear, that the greater finds that the contract is ill expressed. He loses<br />
facilities given to authors throughout the world faith in his friend's honesty, when as a matter<br />
for the transport of their MSS., the greater will be of fact with a little business precision at the<br />
the benefit to those who live by their pen.<br />
commencement everything might have been<br />
“ His MS. is the author's merchandise.” Cheap clear.<br />
transport of merchandise must benefit the producer. Something beyond mere honesty is desired on<br />
both sides in order to avoid disputes, namely, that<br />
everything should be settled on a business footing<br />
by those who understand the business. The<br />
Contracts.<br />
publisher, the editor, and the agent as a rule<br />
THE case of Fitzgerald 2. Newnes was decided understand the business, when, probably, the<br />
in the Courts at the end of April, and judgment author does not. The moral from the author's<br />
was given for the defendants.<br />
point of view is clear-<br />
There were many points in dispute bearing on (1). Have a thoroughly sound contract.<br />
literary property and the work of literary pro- (2). Hare some one who is thoroughly versed in<br />
ducers. These were fully set forth and discussed dealing with literary property to advise you on the<br />
in the judgment. There is one point, however, contract.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 218 (#630) ############################################<br />
<br />
218<br />
TJIE AUTHOR.<br />
Nett Prices.<br />
we do, where should we be, without the Society ?<br />
An article from the pen of Mr. Maclehose, of<br />
The chairman pointed out, with a passing gibe at<br />
Glasgow, on the above subject, was printed in<br />
the Academy of Letters, that, with the exception<br />
The Author of November, 1901. The American<br />
of the body he represented that evening, literature<br />
standpoint has been ably treated by Mr. Charles<br />
had no corporate existence. Time was when the<br />
Scribner, President of the American Publishers'<br />
individual author stood absolutely alone—a shorn<br />
Association.<br />
lamb exposed to the untempered wind. After a<br />
The American Author has had several interesting<br />
rapid and comprehensive review of the work of<br />
articles on the same subject, dealing with the<br />
the Society (in which he hinted that the com-<br />
methods employed in America for enforcing the<br />
mittee were not infrequently expected to perform<br />
system, and the success which has attended those<br />
impossibilities), he laid some stress upon the<br />
methods. To all authors, of whatever nationality,<br />
improved position to which this much-abused<br />
the welfare of the Booksellers—those who put their<br />
body had now attained. Serene in conscious merit,<br />
wares before the public is a matter of primary<br />
it could now afford to disregard insulting para-<br />
importance, and both in England and America<br />
graphs. It continued to fight—so long as it<br />
the nett system appears to have worked with<br />
existed it would continue to fight; but it was<br />
satisfactory results.<br />
noticeable that it could now afford to fight, so to<br />
speak, with more urbanity than before. It had no<br />
intention of relaxing its efforts in the cause of<br />
authors' rights, but certainly in the relations<br />
between author and publisher matters were now<br />
THE ANNUAL DINNER.<br />
more harmonious than they used to be. We<br />
understood Mr. Hawkins to say at this point that<br />
COME two hundred members and guests of the when he died the words “Canadian Copyright "<br />
D Society met together at the Hôtel Cecil on would be found engraved upon his heart.<br />
April 30 for the double purpose of discussing an The Committee, he complained once more, did<br />
excellent dinner, and of listening to some very their best, but could not always give satisfaction.<br />
admirably expressed after-dinner oratory. In fact, They were asked not only to shut the stable door<br />
the speeches were distinctly above the average. after the horse had been stolen, but even to<br />
Post-prandial eloquence is not commonly held to recover the steed and restore it to its careless<br />
be an English characteristic, but the Society of owner. What the committee really liked, he<br />
Authors is exceptionally fortunate in possessing explained, was a good, hard, dry point of law.<br />
in Mr. Anthony Hope Hawkins a master of On such they had always hitherto scored successes.<br />
polished phrase who, whether he has anything of Mr. Hawkins concluded a very interesting speech<br />
importance to say or not, always says it in the with an eloquent appeal on behalf of the Pension<br />
best possible manner ; while it would be difficult Fund.<br />
to find in any country speakers more agreeably The composite toast of “Literature and the<br />
fluent and incisive than Mr. W. L. Courtney, Mr. Drama” was allotted to Mr. W. L. Courtney, who<br />
Pett Ridge, and Captain Marshall.<br />
opened by observing that cynics might say the<br />
After the customary loyal toasts, Mr. Hawkins two were strangers. However pleasant they might<br />
rose to explain his position in the chair and to sound in conjunction, it was rare to find them<br />
propose the health of the Society. We gathered comfortably mated in real life. In favour of<br />
that the committee of management, finding itself “Pilkerton's Peerage” he made a gracious excep-<br />
happy in the possession of an ideal chairman, had tion. Many flashes of epigram and paradox<br />
skilfully contrived a jesolution that the director decorated the remarks of the eminent critic who<br />
of its own councils for the time being should proposed this toast. Pessimism, par esemple, “the<br />
preside also at the annual dinner. In former occasional solace of age and the perpetual privilege<br />
years it had been the custom to pounce upon stray of youth.” He turned out his Pandora's Box of<br />
men of eminence-a practice that naturally gave giſts literary and dramatic, and was gratified by<br />
rise to envy and all uncharitableness. It was finding Anthony Hope at the bottom thereof. It<br />
perhaps a good sign, he modestly explained, that might be a paradox, but he thought literature and<br />
the Society felt itself able now to contemplate with the drama did meet, perhaps, in criticism : that is<br />
equanimity the selection of so undistinguished a to say, they joined readily enough in abusing the<br />
chairman as himself. By an easy transition he critic, as husband and wife, though apt to quarrel,<br />
passed on to review the work of the Society, will combine to repel any meddlesome intruder.<br />
founded twenty years ago by the eminent novelist Of critics in general he remarked that they<br />
and man of letters whose death last year still cast generally agreed upon two things—the very good<br />
a shadow over all who were present. What should and the very bad. An Eastern legend was quoted<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 219 (#631) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
219<br />
in support of the proposition that criticism was while besides Mr. Hawkins (chairman) and the<br />
one of the oldest of all professions. Adam's first other speakers mentioned above, the list also com.<br />
recorded remark (uttered presumably while naming prehended Mr. R. Garnett, Mr. A. Colquhoun, Sir<br />
his subjects) is said to have been, “ This is an Joshua Fitch, Mr. S. S. Sprigge, Mr. A. P. Graves,<br />
Ass.” The Oriental fable was provocative of much Mr. E. H. Lacon Watson, and Mr. G. Herbert<br />
laughter, as was also the story of a certain Thring, secretary.<br />
American dramatic critic who proposed that a<br />
performance of “Hamlet” which he had just<br />
witnessed should be utilised to solve the Shake- PATCHWORK LEGISLATION AND MUSICAL<br />
speare-Bacon controversy. “Open the tombs of<br />
PERFORMING RIGHT.<br />
the two celebrated men,” he wrote, “and see which<br />
has turned in his grave.” Mr. Courtney's was per-<br />
(Continued.)<br />
haps the speech of the evening-excellently turned<br />
and full of humorous touches. He coupled with TN striking contrast to the condition of English<br />
his toast the names of Mr. Pett Ridge (literature) 1 copyright legislation, with its chaotic<br />
and Captain Marshall (drama).<br />
jumble of Acts, are the broad and simple<br />
The genial humorist who rose in reply affected principles governing French legislation on the<br />
to believe that the gentleman who arranged the same subject.<br />
toast-list invariably looked round for the least So far back as 1791 the importance of conserving<br />
eminent writer present to fill the position he now and protecting the performing right in that<br />
occupied. Nevertheless, so great a respect had he country was recognised and comprehensively<br />
for a self-confident manner and a sonorous voice dealt with by law, enabling the establishment<br />
that he believed, if the toast-master had called of a Society for the collection of royalties and<br />
upon him for a song and dance, he would have fees on dramatic works.<br />
complied to the best of his ability. As a fact, he This Society was established for the protection<br />
spoke at some length, fluently and with plenty of of the author's rights of dramatic performance,<br />
fun. Captain Marshall, who followed, delivered and the collection was limited to theatres only.<br />
a carefully prepared harangue in delightfully Outside such dramatic performance all frag-<br />
polished language. He had the air of reciting a ments of operas, symphonic music, light or classical<br />
written speech, which perhaps rather marred the music, dance music, songs, and chansonnettes<br />
effect of his deftly-turned periods ; but this was no could be freely sung in public without any<br />
doubt an illusion due to his excellent delivery. restriccion.<br />
Mr. A. W. à Beckett next proposed the guests There was suitable provision in the law of<br />
with extreme cheerfulness, taking occasion to France for their protection, but no effort had been<br />
introduce a story of a Highlander, out of compli- made to systematically control the rights of<br />
ment, no doubt, to Dr. Robert Farquharson, M.P., performance in musical compositions.<br />
who responded. The doctor spoke rapidly and composer could not by himself protect his<br />
vivaciously in reply, but so indistinctly that we performing rights, and in addition to that dis-<br />
failed to catch any of his remarks except a re-issue ability there was the opposition of publishers to<br />
of the time-honoured jest about Daniel in the lions contend against; so that before anything could be<br />
den. The health of the chairman was proposed done as regards the formation of a Society, it was<br />
by Mr. W. W. Jacobs, who was understood to necessary to obtain some decision from the French<br />
express a wish that Mr. A. H. Hawkins would in Tribunals to show that the law of 1791 applied to<br />
future confine himself to after-dinner speaking, performing rights of all musical works, whether<br />
and give less popular writers a chance. The dramatic or not.<br />
chairman returned thanks in a few suitable In 1818 two chansonnette writers were passing<br />
phrases, and the meeting slowly dissolved into the a café concert in the Champs Elysées, and catch-<br />
adjoining room.<br />
ing a few notes of a chansonnette of which they<br />
It was a successful evening, perhaps one of the were the authors, they decided to go in and hear it.<br />
pleasantest of the annual reunions held under thc The proprietor of the establishment claimed an<br />
auspices of the Society, and the speeches, as we admission payment of two francs from each of<br />
have indicated, were decidedly above the average. them. “But," said they, “it is our song and we<br />
Mr. Hawkins is always an admirable chairman. want to hear it.” “ That does not matter to me,”<br />
Among those present we noticed the names of replied the proprietor, “ you must either pay or<br />
Miss Ellen Thorneycroft Fowler, “Helen Mathers,” go.” They paid, vowing that the disbursement of<br />
“ Rita," Mrs. Alec Tweedie, Mrs. Mona Caird, their four francs should be an expensive affair for<br />
Miss May Sinclair, Mrs. Belloc Lowndes, Mrs. R. him in the long run.<br />
Connor Leighton, representatives of the fair sex ; One of the song-writers in question, with the<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 220 (#632) ############################################<br />
<br />
220<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
help of his collaborateur, another composer, and a catalogues, to create agencies and draft out a<br />
publisher, discussed the subject from a practical policy of administration capable of enabling the<br />
point of view, finally coming to an understanding work of the Society to be efficiently controlled in<br />
not to allow their works to be performed in future all its branches, and to secure its extension and<br />
at public places without their consent, which continued prosperity.<br />
would only be given on payment of a reasonable fee. This control was to extend to every form of<br />
The little committee of four obtained two other performing right which up to that time had been<br />
adherents, and a campaign was opened by inter unprotected, and to every class of establishment<br />
viewing the publishers in order to try and get that had hitherto compiled its programmes free of<br />
them to co-operate in the new undertaking. Pro- all restrictions ; to all forms of concerts, music.<br />
prietors of public places of entertainment were halls, public balls, musical societies, municipal<br />
interviewed in order to feel the ground in that entertainments, circuses, fragments of dramatic<br />
direction, and to find out the nature and strength works, and musical works in theatres, in which<br />
of the opposition which might bave to be encoun latter establishments the Dramatic Society (up to<br />
tered ; and opposition very speedily made itself that time) alone had collected fees.<br />
manifest, bitter and uncompromising, both from It was not easy to make it clear to the minds of<br />
entertainment managers and publishers.<br />
all public caterers that the Society had right on its<br />
Nothing daunted, however, the little band of side, and that it was fully justified in charging<br />
reformers struggled on, and in the course of the fees for the performance of the works of its<br />
years 1848, 1849, and 1850 actions were taken in members.<br />
the names of authors and composers against concert Violent opposition continued to be met with on<br />
and music hall entrepreneurs for unauthorised all sides, and during the first period of twenty<br />
performances.<br />
years actions at law were taken in every part of<br />
The various Tribunalsin every instance recognised France against concert promoters, proprietors of<br />
that the principle of the performing right con- café concerts, and of public balls. Each and all<br />
tained in the law of 1791 extended to all works had to be dealt with in turn, but with the result<br />
without distinction, whether dramatic or musical. that the Society, whose receipts for the year 1851-<br />
Strengthened by these decisions, the little group no 52 amounted to the small sum of 14,000 francs,<br />
longer hesitated, but it was not till 1851 that had increased in the year 1861-62 to 115,400<br />
owing to numerous new adherents, they became francs for the year.<br />
sufficiently important to think of forming a Society. The opposition of the theatrical managers was<br />
At that period, with the exception of one pub- very great, for although they had been in the habit<br />
lisher, Colombier, the music trade was stubbornly of paying fees for the dramatic works since 1789,<br />
hostile to the Society and the principle of the they could not understand why they should now<br />
reservation of the performing right. But in spite be made to pay for the works which had been per-<br />
of all opposition, the authors and composers held formed freely at their establishments before 1851.<br />
their meetings, drew up rules and regulations, and Many actions had to be taken before this opposition<br />
on the 31st of January, 1851, the Société des was finally laid to rest.<br />
Auteurs, Compositeurs et Editeurs de Musique, of As a result of the collection of fees at theatres<br />
France, was definitely established.<br />
by the new Society, authors of dramatic works<br />
The new Society had for its object the placing also hastened to become members.<br />
in common of the rights of the members.<br />
But all these results were not reached without<br />
By their adhesion to the rules of the Society, grave difficulties, inside the Society as well as out-<br />
the members made over their rights to it; this side of it, for the members had incessantly to<br />
was the only possible way to successfully establish encounter and combat the opposition of their<br />
a new form of property, and to appoint a Syn- publishers, and it required unceasing labour to<br />
dicat (or Board of Directors) having full and bring them little by little to look more favourably<br />
exclusive power in itself, or through its power of upon the subject of the reservation of the performing<br />
attorney, an agent-general, to authorise or forbid right.<br />
the public performance of the works of its mem. It was not till 1854 that the publishers at last<br />
bers, and to collect fees in France and abroad. gave way, and seeing that the authors and com-<br />
Since the 31st of January, 1851, the Society has posers were determined to control their performing<br />
been working regularly. It had from the start to rights, they agreed to become members of the<br />
provide for every contingency, to regulate every- Society,<br />
thing, to establish catalogues for the formation of The founders of the Society had already foreseen<br />
the repertoire, to distribute the fees among the and provided for this contingency, and the statutes<br />
inembers, to establish a system for the declaration of the Society admitted the publisher to a share of<br />
of works to the Society, to help to form the the revenues ; this explains how it came to be<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 221 (#633) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
221<br />
named the Society of Authors, Composers and<br />
Music Publishers."<br />
From year to year the receipts of the Society<br />
have steadily increased. The war of 1870–71 only<br />
produced a temporary break in the scale of pro-<br />
gress, and as figures are more eloquent than words,<br />
the best way to summarise the work of the Society<br />
will be to give the amounts of its revenue year by<br />
year from 1851 to 1900.<br />
ANNÉES SOCIALES<br />
DE 1851<br />
au 30 Septembre, 1900.<br />
TOTAUX<br />
DES<br />
Recettes brutes.<br />
10<br />
13<br />
Tre Année 1851-52<br />
1852–53<br />
1853–54<br />
1854–55<br />
1855–56<br />
1856–57<br />
1857-58<br />
1858-59<br />
1859—60<br />
1860-61<br />
11<br />
1861--62<br />
12<br />
1862-63<br />
1863-64<br />
14<br />
1864-65<br />
15<br />
1865-66<br />
1866–67<br />
1867-68<br />
18<br />
1868-69<br />
1869–70<br />
18704-71<br />
1871-72<br />
1872–73<br />
23<br />
1873-74<br />
24<br />
1874–75<br />
1875–76<br />
1876–77<br />
1877–78<br />
IIIII!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!<br />
14.408 50<br />
24.689 75<br />
28.818 30<br />
40.789 85<br />
51.800 55<br />
64.953 45<br />
71.991 44<br />
96.678 72<br />
107.448 31<br />
115.434 67<br />
129.455 42<br />
148.830 12<br />
170.903 88<br />
200.776 19<br />
246.209 51<br />
294.775 49<br />
384.408 13<br />
360.110 12<br />
376.820 60<br />
203.717 64<br />
325.023 28<br />
412.191 41<br />
462.552 17<br />
505.534 45<br />
531.258 75<br />
562.656 37<br />
600.237 21<br />
It will be seen from the above that it took the<br />
Society thirty-five years, from 1851 to 1886, to<br />
reach the total collection of 1,000,000 francs in<br />
the year—i.e., £40,000 per annum, The Berne<br />
Convention coming into force in 1887, agencies<br />
were founded in such of the European countries as<br />
it was found possible to do so, and within the last<br />
fifteen years the Society has more than doubled<br />
that first million.<br />
The revenue for 1901-2 exceeded 2,500,000<br />
francs, or £100,000 for the year, a truly stupendous<br />
result when it is remembered that no capital has<br />
been furnished to bring it about. The Society has<br />
been from the first to the last self-supporting ; its<br />
only capital has been drawn from the fees collected.<br />
The enormous revenue of £100,000 per annum<br />
would represent the return on an invested capital<br />
of £2,000,000 sterling at five per cent. per annum.<br />
This magnificent sum may fairly be said to repre-<br />
sent at the very least the amount which English<br />
authors and composers permit their publishers to<br />
throw away annually in England, for there is no<br />
doubt that had a similar Society been established<br />
in England for the same period as in France, its<br />
annual revenue to-day would be equal to if not<br />
surpassing that of the French Society.<br />
Thanks to their powerful organisation, the<br />
Society has been strongly represented at all the<br />
International Congresses, and has been able to<br />
voice its opinions and make its influence felt to<br />
the benefit and the extension of international<br />
rights.<br />
Its immense revenue is regularly distributed<br />
quarterly and pro rata among all its members<br />
whose works have been performed in public during<br />
that period. A small percentage of the funds is<br />
put on one side annually as a pension fund. All<br />
members of twenty-five years' standing over sixty<br />
years of age are entitled to a pension, and there<br />
are now 168 bénéficiaires.<br />
There is also a fund for the relief of impecunious<br />
members and for medical aid.<br />
Since 1851 more than 40,000,000 francs, or over<br />
£1,600,000, has been collected, and if the income<br />
of this French Society continues to increase at its<br />
present rate, it bids fair before very long to exceed<br />
the entire revenue of the London publishing trade<br />
-an income earned without capital !<br />
ALFRED MOUL.<br />
- - -<br />
TAUCHNITZ EDITIONS.<br />
16<br />
17<br />
19<br />
20<br />
21<br />
22<br />
1878-79<br />
1879--80<br />
- du 16/3 au 30/9 1880<br />
701.028 74<br />
682.306 89<br />
376.023 46<br />
31<br />
35<br />
|||||||||||||||!!<br />
1880--81<br />
1881-82<br />
1882-83<br />
1883-84<br />
1884-85<br />
· 1885-86<br />
1886-87<br />
1887--88<br />
1888-<br />
1889 -90<br />
1890-91<br />
1891-92<br />
1892-93<br />
1893–94<br />
1894—95<br />
1895–96<br />
1896–97<br />
1897--98<br />
1898–99<br />
1899-1900<br />
812.678 02<br />
841.540 86<br />
882.771 74<br />
928.473 33<br />
990.419 08<br />
1.045.386 00<br />
1.057.315 88<br />
1.095.057 29<br />
1.212.735 51<br />
1.228.068 01<br />
1.382.798 94<br />
1.405.614 11<br />
1.518.130 06<br />
1.564.900 18<br />
1.624.883 51<br />
1.694.992 59<br />
1.734.775 73<br />
1.862.160 42<br />
2.017.570 61<br />
2. 234.347 81<br />
N<br />
HE prices that authors receive for their books<br />
1 in England from royalties and other methods<br />
of payment have, from time to time, been<br />
quoted in The Author, and compared with the<br />
profits obtained by the publisher.<br />
-<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 222 (#634) ############################################<br />
<br />
222<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
....<br />
...<br />
1450<br />
Sir Walter Besant has several times tabulated taken as the price paid to the most successful<br />
the profits of both parties, taking into account authors. The average price runs between £10<br />
large sales, small sales, large costs of production, and £25. Let us take £20 on which to base our<br />
small costs of production.<br />
calculations.<br />
Though these matters have been exhaustively<br />
Marks.<br />
dealt with, the questions of authors' other rights in £20 at 21 marks to the £ equals ... 420<br />
America, in translations and in Tauchnitz editions Publisher's profit on the sale of 3,000<br />
have never been tabulated on the same principle. copies<br />
The following statement, therefore, may afford Less average amount paid to author... 420<br />
some information to those authors who are selling<br />
their rights in the Tauchnitz editions of their<br />
Profit to the publisher ... ... 1030<br />
works.<br />
Even supposing that a certain amount of this<br />
Take the ordinary book of about 80,000 words. sum, say 10 per cent., be taken off for what is<br />
This would be produced from the Leipsig house<br />
commonly called "publisher's expenses, sundries,<br />
in one volume. At the lowest computation, 3,000<br />
&c.," there is still a profit to the publisher of over<br />
copies would be printed. The numerous markets twice the amount received by the author.<br />
covered by these books must be considered. They Authors should consider the position.<br />
circulate in France, Germany, Spain, Italy, Austria, Take again the same example, only substitute<br />
Russia, from China to the North Sea, Egypt, £50 as the amount paid to the author instead of<br />
South America, and many other large book-buying £20. The following result is obtained :-<br />
countries. If we take, as a basis of calculation, an<br />
Marks.<br />
edition of 3,000 copies, the number may be safely<br />
£50 taking 21 marks to the £ ... 1050<br />
reckoned as a small edition.<br />
The cost of production of 3,000 copies, roughly Deducting this from the cost of production,<br />
reckoned, amounts to 1,400 marks (the roughness 1,400 marks, the balance in favour of the pub.<br />
is in the publisher's favour), and these 3,000 copies lisher is 350 marks, no mean return for the capital<br />
are sold to the trade (very few being sent out for invested.<br />
review) at the following prices :-<br />
It is not likely, however, that the book of an<br />
author whose reputation is so large as to be able<br />
Mark. Per Cent.<br />
to obtain a price of £50 for the Tauchnitz edition,<br />
Single copies on credit ...<br />
would only sell to the extent of 3,000 copies, or<br />
For ready money ...<br />
•05<br />
that only 3,000 copies would be printed.<br />
For 7 vols, at a time<br />
.95<br />
The next case to be considered occurs when an<br />
For 100 , „ ...<br />
edition of 5,000 copies is printed.<br />
For 500 , „ ..<br />
.85<br />
Roughly speaking the cost of production is 1,800<br />
marks. This is an excessive calculation, but we<br />
The same price rules when francs are paid, the<br />
only difference being that between the value of the<br />
gladly give the publisher the benefit of the<br />
difference.<br />
franc and the value of the mark.<br />
For instance-<br />
Taking the sale price of the book to be the<br />
Franc. Per Cent. same as in the former case,<br />
Marks.<br />
Single copies on credit<br />
•50<br />
5,000 copies will sell for... ... 4750<br />
The same for cash..<br />
.25<br />
For 7 copies<br />
•20<br />
Deducting the cost of production<br />
For 100 ,<br />
from the sales ... ... ... 1800<br />
For 500 ,,<br />
6<br />
Profit<br />
2950<br />
The average price, however, can be taken at<br />
Again reckoning the average price<br />
.95 marks, or in francs, 1.20.<br />
given to the author for the book 420<br />
An edition of 3,000 copies would therefore<br />
Profit to the Publisher ... ... 2530<br />
bring in -<br />
Reducing the same to £'s, about £120.<br />
2850<br />
If we take the author's remuneration at £50,<br />
Less cost of production ... 1400 the sum will work out as follows :-<br />
Marks.<br />
Profit ... ... ... 1450<br />
Profit by sale<br />
...<br />
2950<br />
To author of book<br />
1050<br />
The next point is the price that is given to<br />
English authors for these rights. £50 may be Profit to the publisher ...<br />
1900<br />
20<br />
.90<br />
...<br />
Marks.<br />
...<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 223 (#635) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
223<br />
Reducing it again to £'s, about £90.<br />
of figures, an author with a moderate reputation,<br />
One inore example.<br />
on the sale of 5,000 copies would obtain half of<br />
The cost of production of 10,000 copies is 2,950 marks, or 1,475 marks. These marks turned<br />
approximately 2,800 marks.<br />
into £'s would amount to £70 58., or between 30.<br />
The sale of the 10,000 copies at the average and 4d, a copy royalty on every copy sold ; 3d.<br />
price as before, ·95 marks, would bring in 9,500 a copy amounting accurately to £62 108., 4d.<br />
marks.<br />
a copy to £83 6s.<br />
Deduct from this the sum of 1,050 marks paid to In the case of the successful author the profits<br />
the author, a profit of 8,450 marks is left to the on the sale of an edition of 10,000 copies would<br />
publisher.<br />
amount, after the cost of production had been<br />
It is necessary now to sum up the question from deducted, to 4,750 marks, or £226—between 5d.<br />
the facts displayed in this article. On an edition and 6d. a copy on every copy sold. The royalty of<br />
of 3,000 copies, which may be reckoned when the 5d. a copy amounts to £208 68., a royalty of 6d. a<br />
huge extent of the Tauchnitz markets are taken copy to £250.<br />
into consideration, an average sale for an average As the figures in the cost of production and on the<br />
author, the profit to the publisher is 980 marks, sales of the books have been taken slightly in favour<br />
and the profit to the author is 420 marks.<br />
of the publisher, an author would not be asking by<br />
If erery advantage in the figures is given to any means too high a figure if he demanded 3d.<br />
the publisher, and every possible expenditure is a copy royalty on the sale of 3,000 copies, 4d. a<br />
taken into consideration, the publisher's profit is copy on the sale of 5,000, and 6d. a copy on the<br />
twice as large as the author's. Even in the case of sale of 10,000.<br />
an exceedingly popular author, and a small edition, The reader should also bear in mind that these<br />
the profit to the publisher is not at all unreasonable, figures are worked out on the understanding that<br />
when the capital invested is considered.<br />
the book is produced as one volume. When a<br />
As the editions grow larger, the profits to the novel runs to more than 80,000 words it is usually<br />
publisher also grow in proportion, for it is quite produced in two volumes, and the profit is propor-<br />
the exception that a royalty is ever paid to an tionately increased. It follows, therefore, that the<br />
author on this form of issue. At last, when an royalty should be paid on every volume. The fact<br />
edition of 10,000 copies is published, the profit to that the firm of Tauchnitz act as their own printers<br />
the publisher is 8,450 marks against the sum paid no doubt enables them to put the books on the<br />
to the author of 1,050 marks. It follows, there market at a cost smaller than that shown by the<br />
fore, that the publisher's profits are to the author's figures printed above. This is a further advantage<br />
remuneration in the proportion of 8 to 1.<br />
that this firm obtains.<br />
After a careful consideration of these figures, it English authors would do well to make a study<br />
is clear that some effort should be made by authors of these figures, and to approach the head of the<br />
in order that matters may be arranged on a more great firm with a view to obtaining, if possible,<br />
equitable basis.<br />
some equitable basis on which to found future con-<br />
It will afford no small advantage to look at tracts. It is quite possible that Baron Tauchnitz<br />
the position from an entirely different point of has never looked at the figures from this point of<br />
view.<br />
view, and has never had his attention drawn to<br />
Take, for instance, the case of the ordinary a comparison between the profits of author and<br />
author, who can obtain a sale of 3,000 copies. publisher.<br />
According to the figures that have already been put The great reputation of the firm is well known.<br />
forward, there would be a profit of 1,450 marks, No doubt if the case is clearly stated, authors will<br />
after deducting the cost of production from the find their views favourably considered.<br />
amount realised by sales. If the author takes a<br />
G. H. T.<br />
half-share of these profits he would obtain 725<br />
marks. (It must not be considered that half-<br />
profits to the author is essentially a fair return,<br />
but it is a good basis on which to build a calcula-<br />
BRICKS AND MORTAR.<br />
tion.) Seven hundred and twenty-five marks if<br />
turned into English money at the rate given<br />
above, of twenty-one marks to the £, would W HEN an architect undertakes to work out a<br />
work out to £34 10s., or between 2 d. and 3d. a W design for a house it is not sufficient that<br />
copy on every copy of the edition. 24d. a copy " he should bring into play his imagination<br />
royalty works out to £31 58., 3d. a copy to for the lines of beauty in the scheme of the out-<br />
£37 10s.<br />
side structure or his technical skill in satisfying<br />
If the same principle is applied to the next set the needs and comforts of men in the internal<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 224 (#636) ############################################<br />
<br />
224<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
development. He needs more than this. He “ royal octavo.” This portion of the book is no<br />
needs full knowledge of the different materials doubt one of the most important parts to him who<br />
out of which the house is built-of the wood, of would gain full knowledge of the “ bricks and<br />
the bricks, of the slates and tiles, of the pipes, of mortar.”<br />
the mortar.<br />
“Methods of Illustration ” comes next. Nowa.<br />
It is quite true that an author, unless he is days illustration in books is distinctly on the<br />
publishing on commission, has no call for the increase. It follows then that the maker of books<br />
same intricate knowledge of materials, and does should understand some of the methods by which<br />
not need to handle the details of structure in the his work is rendered more fascinating to the<br />
same intimate way; yet this knowledge, though general public. The days have gone by when the<br />
not absolutely essential, may be exceedingly useful. addition of the simplest picture was looked upon<br />
It is curious what a lack of information most as a serious and expensive item. Nowadays<br />
authors have. They cannot tell what a book costs beautiful and artistic work can be reproduced at a<br />
to print, or what kind of type should be used, very moderate rate. The different processes are<br />
although in an indefinite kind of way they may here fully explained.<br />
know what kind of type they prefer. The same Chapter V. deals with papers. If “ Types and<br />
remark applies with equal force to the paper and Margins ” was one of the most important portions,<br />
binding.<br />
“Papers” is the most important. Upon the<br />
An author's answer may well be that the Society quality of the paper depends the longevity of the<br />
has at its command all the information that is book. Paper is sold by weight. It sounds a<br />
requisite. To a certain extent that answer is simple transaction, but in fact is complicated by<br />
justifiable, but the man who can do a thing for technicalities. Paper is of many kinds, of which<br />
himself has always more power than the man who the two main classes are machine made and hand<br />
has to employ an agent.<br />
made. The subdivisions are numerous; the most<br />
Detailed information concerning the “bricks important are dealt with.<br />
and mortar” that go toward book production has The chapters on “The Sizes of Books" and<br />
been collected by Mr. C. T. Jacobi.* He first “Binding" cannot be passed orer. Knowledge of<br />
deals with the manuscript, and puts forward some these points is essential.<br />
useful suggestions. On this point it is possible that It is doubtful whether there was any need in a<br />
the author may need but little assistance. He has book of this kind to deal with “Publishing" and<br />
most probably learnt his lesson by bitter experi- “ Copyright." These subjects bear but little on<br />
ence, but he may well take to heart the paragraph the questions of the “bricks and mortar," apper-<br />
on page 8:-<br />
taining to the solicitor's rather than the architect's<br />
“ The charges made for corrections are based on department. They are involved and highly<br />
the time consumed in making them, and are very technical. To deal with them in these short<br />
difficult to check even by an expert." This sub- chapters is impossible, and a mere superficial state-<br />
ject has been dealt with exhaustively in The ment is likely to do more harm than good.<br />
Author, and with the exception of advertisements, To sum up, there is very little to be said against<br />
is the most frequent cause of dispute between the method the author has employed in dealing<br />
author and publisher.<br />
with his subject. He shows full knowledge; he<br />
The next chapter, “ The Index,” is hardly has placed it clearly before the public. The cost<br />
satisfactory. To many books no index is neces- of many of the items has not been touched upon<br />
sary. But the author who desires to compile an except in a few general statements. This, the only<br />
index needs fuller instructions to make the result fault, is a serious one. It is not enough to know<br />
reliable.<br />
that one paper is good and another bad, or one<br />
“Types and Margins.” Those who are dwellers form of illustration more expensive than another.<br />
in the printing chapel have a wondrous language The writer who goes so far in his study of<br />
of their own. To the ordinary mortal it is as a “bricks and mortar" will certainly demand inore<br />
foreign tongue. Let him then, if he thinks of details of finance. This side ought to be dealt<br />
turning author, carefully digest these pages. He with in some other issue.<br />
will be able to stand the test of the severest The Glossary is instructive. Pages full of type<br />
examination and puzzle himself and his hearers by<br />
varying in shape and make, leaded and solid, and<br />
discussing learnedly about “founts," “ems,” others made up of different samples of paper, com-<br />
"ens," "pica," "double pica," “crown,” and plete a treatise really useful and satisfactory to all<br />
those—and there should be many—who are<br />
interested in the details of the material side of<br />
* “Some Notes on Books and Printing," by C, T. Jacobi.<br />
Published by the Chiswick Press, Took's Court, Chancery book production.<br />
Lane.<br />
A. C. B.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 225 (#637) ############################################<br />
<br />
• THE AUTHOR.<br />
225<br />
GENERAL MEMORANDA.<br />
STERE are a few standing rules to be observed in an<br />
agreement. There are four methods of dealing<br />
with literary property S<br />
1. Selling it Outright.<br />
This is in some respects the most satisfactory, if a proper<br />
price can be obtained. But the transaction should be<br />
managed by a competent agent, or with the advice of the<br />
Secretary of the Society.<br />
II. A Profit-Sharing Agreement (a bad form of<br />
agreement).<br />
In this case the following rules should be attended to:<br />
(1.) Not to sign any agreement in which the cost of pro-<br />
duction forms a part without the strictest investigation.<br />
(2.) Not to give the publisher the power of putting the<br />
profits into his own pocket by charging for advertisements<br />
in his own organs, or by charging exchange advertise.<br />
ments. Therefore keep control of the advertisements.<br />
(3.) Not to allow a special charge for “office expenses,"<br />
unless the same allowance is made to the author.<br />
(4.) Not to give up American, Colonial, or Continental<br />
rights.<br />
(5.) Not to give up serial or translation rights.<br />
(6.) Not to bind yourself for future work to any publisher.<br />
As well bind yourself for the future to any one solicitor or<br />
doctor!<br />
III. The Royalty System.<br />
It is above all things necessary to know what the<br />
proposed royalty means to both sides. It is now possible<br />
for an author to ascertain approximately and very nearly<br />
the truth. From time to time the very important figures<br />
connected with royalties are published in The Author.<br />
Readers can also work out the figures themselves from the<br />
"Cost of Production."<br />
IY. A Commission Agreement.<br />
The main points are :<br />
(1.) Be careful to obtain a fair cost of production.<br />
(2.) Keep control of the advertisements.<br />
(3.) Keep control of the sale price of the book,<br />
General.<br />
All other forms of agreement are combinations of the four<br />
above mentioned.<br />
Such combinations are generally disastrous to the author.<br />
Never sign any agreement without competent advice from<br />
the Secretary of the Society.<br />
Stamp all agreements with the Inland Revenue stamp<br />
Avoid agreements by letter if possible.<br />
The main points which the Society has always demanded<br />
from the outset are :-<br />
(1.) That both sides shall know what an agreement<br />
means.<br />
(2.) The inspection of those account books which belong<br />
to the author. We are advised that this is a right, in the<br />
nature of a common law right, which cannot be denied or<br />
withheld,<br />
3. There are three forms of dramatic contract for PLAYS<br />
IN THREE OR MORE ACTS :<br />
(a.) SALE OUTRIGHT OF THE PERFORMING RIGHT.<br />
This is unsatisfactory. An author who enters<br />
into such a contract should stipulate in the con-<br />
tract for production of the piece by a certain date<br />
and for proper publication of his name on the<br />
play-bills.<br />
(6.) SALE OF PERFORMING RIGHT OR OF A LICENCE<br />
TO PERFORM ON THE BASIS OF PERCENTAGES<br />
on gross receipts. Percentages vary between<br />
5 and 15 per cent. An author should obtain a<br />
percentage on the sliding scale of gross receipts<br />
in preference to the American system. Should<br />
obtain a sum in advance of percentages. A fixed<br />
date on or before which the play should be<br />
performed.<br />
SALE OF PERFORMING RIGHT OR OF A LICENCE<br />
TO PERFORM ON THE BASIS OF ROYALTIES (i.c.,<br />
fixed nightly fees). This method should be<br />
always avoided except in cases where the fees<br />
are likely to be small or difficult to collect. The<br />
other safeguards set out under heading (6.) apply<br />
also in this case.<br />
4. PLAYS IN ONE ACT are often sold outright, but it is<br />
better to obtain a small nightly fee if possible, and a sum<br />
paid in advance of such fees in any event. It is extremely<br />
important that the amateur rights of one-act plays should<br />
be reserved.<br />
5. Authors should remember that performing rights can<br />
be limited, and are usually limited, by town, country, and<br />
time. This is most important.<br />
6. Authors should not assign performing rights, but<br />
should grant a licence to perform. The legal distinction<br />
of great importance.<br />
7. Authors should remember that performing rights in a<br />
play are distinct from literary copyright. A manager<br />
holding the performing right or licence to perform cannot<br />
print the book of the words.<br />
8. Never forget that AMERICAN RIGHTS may be exceed-<br />
ingly valuable. They should never be included in English<br />
agreements without the author obtaining a substantial<br />
consideration.<br />
9. Agreements for collaboration should be carefully<br />
drawn and executed before collaboration is commenced.<br />
10. An author should remember that production of a play<br />
is highly speculative : that he runs a very great risk of<br />
delay and a breakdown in the fulfilment of his contract.<br />
He should therefore guard himself all the more carefully in<br />
the beginning.<br />
11. An author must remember that the dramatic market<br />
is exceedingly limited, and that for a novice the first object<br />
is to obtain adequate publication,<br />
As these warnings must necessarily be incomplete on<br />
account of the wide range of the subject of dramatic con-<br />
tracts, THOSE AUTITORS DESIROUS OF FURTHER INFORMA-<br />
TION ARE REFERRED TO THE SECRETARY OF THE SOCIETY.<br />
HOW TO USE THE SOCIETY.<br />
WARNINGS TO DRAMATIC AUTHORS.<br />
N EVER sign an agreement without submitting it to the<br />
Secretary of the Society of Authors or some com-<br />
petent legal authority.<br />
2. It is well to be extremely careful in negotiating for<br />
the production of a play with anyone except an established<br />
manager.<br />
1. DIVERY member has a right to ask for and to receive<br />
advice upon his agreements, his choice of a pub-<br />
lisher, or any dispute arising in the conduct of his<br />
business or the administration of his property. If the<br />
advice sought is such as can be given best by a solicitor,<br />
the member has a right to an opinion from the Society's<br />
solicitors. If the case is such that Counsel's opinion is<br />
desirable, the Committee will obtain for him Counsel's<br />
opinion. All this without any cost to the member,<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 226 (#638) ############################################<br />
<br />
226<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
Communications for The Author should be addressed to<br />
the Offices of the Society, 39, Old Queen Street, Storey's<br />
Gate, S.W., and should reach the Editor NOT LATER<br />
THAN THE 21st OF EACH MONTH.<br />
All persons engaged in literary work of any kind,<br />
whether members of the Society or not, are invited to<br />
communicate to the Editor any points connected with their<br />
work which it would be advisable in the general interest to<br />
publish.<br />
COMMUNICATIONS AND LETTERS ARE INVITED BY THE<br />
EDITOR on all subjects connected with literature, but on<br />
no other subjects whatever. Every effort will be made to<br />
return articles which cannot be accepted.<br />
2. Remember that questions connected with copyright<br />
and publishers' agreements do not generally fall within the<br />
experience of ordinary solicitors. Therefore, do not scruple<br />
to use the Society.<br />
3. Send to the Office copies of past agreements and past<br />
accounts, with a copy of the book represented. The<br />
Secretary will always be glad to have any agreements, new<br />
or old, for inspection and note. The information thus<br />
obtained may prove invaluable.<br />
4. BEFORE SIGNING ANY AGREEMENT WHATEVER, send<br />
the document to the Society for examination.<br />
5. Remember always that in belonging to the Society<br />
you are fighting the battles of other writers, even if you<br />
are reaping no benefit to yourself, and that you are<br />
advancing the best interests of literature in promoting the<br />
independence of the writer.<br />
6. The Committee have now arranged for the reception<br />
of members' agreements and their preservation in a fire-<br />
proof safe. The agreements will, of course, be regarded as<br />
confidential documents to be read only by the Secretary,<br />
who will keep the key of the safe. The Society now offers :<br />
-(1) To read and advise upon agreements and to give<br />
advice concerning publishers. (2) To stamp agreements<br />
an readiness for a possible action upon them. (3) To keep<br />
agreements. (4) To enforce payments due according to<br />
agreements.<br />
7. No contract should be entered into with a literary<br />
agent without the advice of the Secretary of the Society.<br />
Members are strongly advised not to accept without careful<br />
consideration the contracts submitted to them by literary<br />
agents, and are recommended to submit them for inter-<br />
pretation and explanation to the Secretary of the Society.<br />
8. Many agents neglect to stamp agreements. This<br />
must be done within fourteen days of first execution. The<br />
Secretary will undertake it on behalf of members.<br />
THE SECRETARY OF THE SOCIETY begs to give notice<br />
that all remittances are acknowledged by return of post,<br />
and he requests members who do not receive an<br />
answer to important communications within two days to<br />
write to him without delay. All remittances should be<br />
crossed Union Bank of London, Chancery Lane, or be sent<br />
by registered letter only.<br />
AUTHORITIES.<br />
9. Some agents endeavour to prevent authors from<br />
referring matters to the Secretary of the Society; so do<br />
some publishers. Members can make their own deductions<br />
and act accordingly.<br />
U ITH the assistance of that valuable society,<br />
the Association Littéraire et Artistique<br />
Internationale, the brass-workers of Paris<br />
have been successful in their endeavours to put<br />
their designs under the protection of the French<br />
copyright law. The protection which this law will<br />
now give them is of a very extensive character,<br />
and will prevent piracy of designs of every kind.<br />
France was and is always in the forefront when<br />
it is necessary to protect works of literary or<br />
artistic merit.<br />
THE READING BRANCH.<br />
M EMBERS will greatly assist the Society in this<br />
branch of their work by informing young writers<br />
of its existence. Their MSS. can be read and<br />
treated as a composition is treated by a coach. The term<br />
MSS. includes NOT ONLY WORKS OF FICTION, BUT POETRY<br />
AND DRAMATIC WORKS, and when it is possible, under<br />
special arrangement, technical and scientific works. The<br />
leaders are writers of competence and experience. The<br />
fee is one guinea.<br />
While mentioning the subject of artistic copy-<br />
right, it is interesting to call to mind the case of<br />
Brittain and Others v. Hanks Bros. & Co., which<br />
has recently been decided in the Courts.<br />
hos<br />
In this case the plaintiff brought an action<br />
against the defendants for copying the design of<br />
a tin soldier which the plaintiff was selling as a<br />
toy for children.<br />
After hearing the case the Judge decided that<br />
the model had artistic merit, and that therefore,<br />
as the plaintiff had complied with the other<br />
provisions of the Act, an injunction must be<br />
granted.<br />
The real position of these cases must depend<br />
upon the fact how far the production is a work of<br />
NOTICES.<br />
THE Editor of The Author begs to remind members of<br />
T the Society that, although the paper is sent to them<br />
free of charge, the cost of prodncing it would be a<br />
very heavy charge on the resources of the Society if a great<br />
many members did not forward to the Secretary the modest<br />
58. 6d. subscription for the year.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 227 (#639) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
227<br />
art. It is quite possible that a tin soldier might Hawkins say to a Society of Orators ? " Well,<br />
be as high an artistic production as the statues what would he say? Where is the “fundamental<br />
that are set up in the prominent squares of absurdity”? Are all trade and professional com-<br />
London.<br />
binations absurd ? Where is the analogy ? Oratory<br />
is neither a trade nor a profession. And lastly,<br />
where is the logic ?<br />
A WRITER in the Pall Mall Gazette commented<br />
a little bitterly on the statements of our Chairman<br />
at the dinner of the Society.<br />
"The author,” he says, scoffing at an assertion of<br />
An intricate question came before a member of<br />
Mr. Hawkins', “was always as free as any other<br />
the Society. How should it have been answered ?<br />
citizen to consult and instruct a solicitor." True,<br />
The details of the case are as follows :-<br />
At the desire of a certain wealthy American, a<br />
but the writer has not taken the trouble to<br />
remember that the Copyright Acts are difficult<br />
member of the Society was employed to compile a<br />
and involved, and that the dealings with copyright<br />
book. A limited number of copies of the book,<br />
property are peculiar and technical<br />
which was an expensive work, were printed, bound,<br />
We have seen agreements for the publication of<br />
and delivered in completed form in England. The<br />
books and for the performance of plays prepared<br />
book was not for publication, but for the private<br />
by the family solicitor ; they were interesting<br />
use of the American.<br />
curiosities. Technical information on a highly<br />
A number of copies, amounting in all to 500 or<br />
technical subject is essential; this the Society<br />
so, had to be forwarded to America, and, under<br />
the American Tariff Act, it is necessary to state<br />
affords. The number of its Members is a fair<br />
proof that its work is appreciated.<br />
the value of the book as merchandise. Ought the<br />
Secondly, he states, “as the case of Macdonald<br />
books to have been valued at their actual cost of<br />
v. the National Review showed, the Society had<br />
production, or at the probable amount they would<br />
bring in if offered for sale in the open market ?<br />
been too ready to disturb men as honest as them-<br />
The actual wording of the law is that dutiable<br />
selves by vexatious litigation.” A man may be<br />
honest; he may also be unbusinesslike. The<br />
articles " should be appraised at their fair market<br />
value.”<br />
Society deals with the business side of literary and<br />
dramatic effort, and in endeavouring to obtain<br />
We believe it has been the custom for pub-<br />
lishers to invoice books to America at the cost of<br />
proper business methods between editor or publisher<br />
and author, is doing good to all three parties.<br />
manufacture. In this case, however, there was no<br />
Some of the present Members may forget the<br />
market value, as the books were for private<br />
details of the case.<br />
circulation.<br />
An author sent an MS. to the National Review.<br />
It was set up in type and returned for correction.<br />
The author returned the MS. Subequently the A purposed notable feature in the coming St.<br />
article was rejected.<br />
Louis World's Exposition is an exact reproduction<br />
The Judge held that the setting up in type of the birth-homes of two or three of the greater<br />
was such a dealing with the article as to constitute English and Scotch writers—littérateurs who are<br />
acceptance, and the proprietor had to pay ; that is recognised as “the world's men of letters.” The<br />
the rough outline of the facts.<br />
suggestion is that exact facsimiles of the buildings<br />
This is distinctly not vexatious litigation. The and the chief historic relics they contain shall be<br />
editor had merely to write a business letter pointing made. It is proposed that these shall be rebuilt<br />
out that the article was not accepted. The author in permanent form, so that they may remain in<br />
would then have had the option of withdrawing Forest Park, St. Louis, long after the less stable<br />
the article or waiting the editor's pleasure. What portions of the World's Fair have done their<br />
did the editor expect the author to conclude? Did duty and disappeared. Recent talk on these sub-<br />
he expect him to wait calmly and indefinitely for jects has now become a fact. The Burns' Cottage<br />
the editor's decision?<br />
Association has been organised in America, with<br />
The editor's side is “vexatious litigation,” the John V. Dick as President, and James Muir<br />
author's “ vexatious delay"; and the Society's Dixon, Secretary<br />
point of view is finality in business as well as The “Auld Clay Buggin," the very humble<br />
honesty. The Society's standpoint is justifiable. cottage under the thatch of which Robert Burns<br />
The third “Occasional Note” is amusing in its was born on the 25th of January, 1759, is of clay,<br />
illogical deduction, “Only let it be remarked that with a sanded front, whitewashed, and was built<br />
there is something fundamentally absurd in the mainly by the hands of the poet's father while<br />
idea of a Society of Authors. What would Mr. he was working as a gardener for Ferguson of<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 228 (#640) ############################################<br />
<br />
228<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
LITERARY PRODUCTION IN ENGLAND.<br />
Doonholm. The house, as all pilgrims to Ayr know,<br />
is one storey high, and consists of a kitchen in one<br />
end and a best parlour in the other. In the latter<br />
is a fireplace, and, in a niche by its side, is a bed.<br />
As to Bobbie, it is the opinion of the old wives of<br />
the town that,<br />
66 The bed in which he first began<br />
To be that various thing called man,'<br />
was in the tiny kitchen. Replicas of the bed and<br />
of the other important items in the little white<br />
house in Ayr are included in the St. Louis<br />
scheme.<br />
The co-operation of the leading Burns' Societies<br />
and other Scottish associations, both here and in<br />
America, has been promised. A suggestion has<br />
been made that the replicas of the cottage and<br />
relics shall be free gifts from the sons of Scotland<br />
-Whether at home or abroad-to St. Louis.<br />
Further, if permissible, it is proposed also to build<br />
some other historic Scottish structure on the Fair<br />
Grounds, as room will be needed for the accumula-<br />
tion of Scottish relics that promises to pour in.<br />
The Scotch element is strong and influential in<br />
American life, and keeps itself in closer relations<br />
with the old home than any other foreign strain<br />
to be found there.<br />
The address of Mr. George F. Parker, the Resi-<br />
dent British Representative of the World's Fair,<br />
is Sanctuary House, Tothill Street, Westminster,<br />
S.W.<br />
THE Editor of The Author has asked me to give<br />
1 some statistics relating to the production of<br />
books in this country. Books, of all things,<br />
are essentially individual entities whose qualitative<br />
worth interests more than a quantitative view of<br />
them, but despite this obvious disadvantage, it is<br />
possible that the following facts concerning books<br />
in bulk may have some interest. Moreover, a not<br />
inconsiderable proportion of the books may per-<br />
haps be regarded more appropriately in bulk than<br />
as separate existences.<br />
Every year the Publishers' Circular contains an<br />
analytical table of the new books published during<br />
the preceding year. I have summarised these<br />
tables for the last ten years, so as to get a broad<br />
fact-base into which are merged the accidental<br />
fluctuations of individual years. The following<br />
statement contains the essence of these ten years'<br />
facts, and it relates only to new books, not to new<br />
editions of books.<br />
NEW BOOKS PUBLISHED IN THE UNITED KIxGDOM<br />
DURING THE TEN YEARS 1892–1901.<br />
Class of Book.<br />
Number<br />
published.<br />
Percentage<br />
of each Class,<br />
upon the total<br />
number<br />
published.<br />
per cent.<br />
299<br />
16,434<br />
6,269<br />
114<br />
AFTER SUNSET.<br />
9.5<br />
5,206<br />
4,540<br />
8.2<br />
3,572<br />
5:1<br />
1. Novels, tales, and juvenile<br />
works. .<br />
2. Educational, classical, and<br />
philological . .<br />
3. Theology, sermons, bib-<br />
lical, etc. . . .<br />
4. History, biography, etc. .<br />
5. Year-books and serials in<br />
volumes .<br />
6. Political and social eco-<br />
nomy, trade, etc. .<br />
7. Poetry and the drama .<br />
8. Belles - Lettres, essays,<br />
monographs, etc.<br />
9. Arts, sciences, and illus-<br />
trated works . .<br />
10. Voyages, travels, geo- i<br />
graphical research .<br />
11. Medicine, surgery, etc..!<br />
12. Law, jurisprudence, etc..!<br />
13. Miscellaneous, including<br />
pamphlets, not sermons<br />
2,822<br />
2,460<br />
2,38+<br />
2,294<br />
-<br />
-<br />
-<br />
-<br />
2,056<br />
1,415<br />
895<br />
3.7<br />
2.6<br />
1.6<br />
[Reprinted, by kind permission of the Author, from<br />
* Sonnets of this Century,” edited by William Sharp.]<br />
V OCAL, yet voiceless, lingering, lambent,<br />
white<br />
With the wide wings of evening on the fell,<br />
The tranquil vale, the enchanted citadel,-<br />
Another day swoons to another night.<br />
Speak low : from bare Blencathra's purple height<br />
The sound o' the gbyll falls furled ; and, loath<br />
to go,<br />
A continent of cloud its plaited snow<br />
Wear's far away athwart a lake of light.<br />
Is it the craft of hell that while we lie<br />
Enshaded, lulled, beneath Heaven's breezeless<br />
sky,<br />
The garrulous clangours and assoiled shows<br />
Of London's burrowing mazes haunt us yet ?<br />
City, forgive me : Mother of joys and woes,<br />
Thy shadow is here, and lo ! our eyes are wet.<br />
HALL CAINE.<br />
-<br />
-<br />
4,650<br />
8:53<br />
i<br />
Total, new books published,<br />
1892-1901 . . .<br />
54,997<br />
1<br />
100.0<br />
We see that during the last ten years 55,000<br />
new books have been published in England.<br />
An average of 5,500 per annum, or, taking 300<br />
working days to the year, eighteen new books per<br />
diem without cessation.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 229 (#641) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
229<br />
the output of new books during the two five-yearly<br />
periods was-<br />
1892-1896 ... ... ... 26,059<br />
1897—1901 ... ... ... 28,938<br />
It is impossible to conceive that there has been<br />
a demand for this vast supply of new books. I,<br />
myself, am responsible for four of these 55,000<br />
books, and only two of the four books have<br />
justified their existence. It is not unlikely that<br />
à considerable proportion of them-in Class 1,<br />
novels, etc., for example-have been published at<br />
the authors' expense, without regard to adjusting<br />
supply to demand.<br />
But although we may not be able to regard this<br />
supply of new books as balancing the demand for<br />
them, it is not improbable that the foregoing<br />
widely-based facts do give a fairly reliable indica-<br />
tion of the relative degrees of demand for each<br />
class of book. Looking at the facts in this light,<br />
we see that novels, etc., make up 30 per cent. of<br />
the total number, educational books coming second,<br />
and books on theology, etc., third. These three<br />
principal classes, merged into one group, supply<br />
more than one-half of the total output of new<br />
books—their combined share being 50-8 per cent.<br />
Of the ten other classes, books of history,<br />
biography, etc., lead with 8 per 100 new books<br />
published. Books on political and social economy,<br />
etc., have a slight lead over poetry and the drama,<br />
each of these two classes coming near to 5 per cent.<br />
of all new books. Medical books and law books<br />
are, as might be expected, the last two classes on<br />
the list.<br />
Looking at the output of new books in each year<br />
of the ten now under survey, without classification<br />
of the books published, the facts are as follows :-<br />
Total... ... 54,997<br />
This is an increase of nearly 3,000 books, i.e., of<br />
11 per cent., during the later period as compared<br />
with the earlier five years, and we may ascertain<br />
how this rate of increase compares with the increase<br />
in the number of persons who—to use an actuarial<br />
term-have been “at risk” of reading the books<br />
produced. The use of this technical term is per-<br />
haps justified, for although the readers of the<br />
books have not read them at the risk of death,<br />
they have certainly read some of the new books at<br />
the risk of injury to themselves.<br />
Taking the population of the United Kingdom<br />
as the number of persons at risk of reading the<br />
books, the increase in this number from the earlier<br />
to the later period was at the rate of under 5 per<br />
cent., and this is a smaller rate of growth than the<br />
rate of growth of the output of new books.<br />
If during 1897—1901 the growth of new books<br />
had coincided with the growth of the population<br />
during the same period, the number of new books<br />
published during 1897—1901 would have been<br />
27,290. But the actual number of new books<br />
published during 1897—1901 was 28,938, and<br />
thus the actual output exceeded the “expected”<br />
output by nearly 1,650 new books. This is not a<br />
very large difference between theory and actuality,<br />
in the matter of new books published; but it<br />
suffices to show that, despite all disturbing causes,<br />
the output of new books during the last five years<br />
has exceeded the normal expectation.<br />
This last point reminds me that the editor of<br />
The Author has asked me to make a statement with<br />
regard to the output of books at the beginning of<br />
the nineteenth century as compared with the output<br />
of to-day. I am not able to do this, for 'lack of the<br />
facts. But we can go back as far as seventy years<br />
ago, thus including the whole of the Victorian era.<br />
The following statement shows the average<br />
yearly number of new books published in this<br />
country during the periods named, and also the<br />
average yearly number of new books per million<br />
of the population.<br />
Year of<br />
Publication.<br />
Number of new<br />
books published.<br />
1892<br />
1893<br />
189+<br />
189.7<br />
1896<br />
1897<br />
1898<br />
1899<br />
1900<br />
1901<br />
4,915<br />
5.129<br />
5.300<br />
5,481<br />
5,23+<br />
6,24+<br />
6,008<br />
5,971<br />
5,760<br />
4,955<br />
Total<br />
1892–1901<br />
54,997<br />
After fluctuation during the period 1892-1896,<br />
the maximum was reached in the year 1897, when<br />
6,244 new books were published. From 1897 to<br />
1901 there was a continuous decline in the output<br />
of books, until in 1901 the number was only<br />
slightly in excess of the output in 1892. Reviewers<br />
may perhaps have thanked the war for mercies<br />
other than the consolidation of the British Empire.<br />
Ignoring the fluctuations in individual years,<br />
Period.<br />
Average Yearly<br />
Number of New<br />
Books published.<br />
Average Yearly<br />
Number of New Books<br />
published, per million<br />
of our population.<br />
1828–1832<br />
1866—1869<br />
1892–1896<br />
1897-1901<br />
1,060<br />
3,220<br />
5,212<br />
5,788<br />
105<br />
13+<br />
143<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 230 (#642) ############################################<br />
<br />
230<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
The growth of books bas, we see, largely ex- his death, sprang into fame so long ago as the year<br />
ceeded the growth of population. Seventy years 1870, when “ The Heathen Chinee" first captured<br />
ago, the yearly output was only 45 new books per the ear of the public, and a mighty peal of laughter<br />
million of population. To-day, the yearly output ran rippling from one end of the English-speaking<br />
is 143 new books per million of population—a world to the other. Bret Harte never, to our<br />
more than three-fold growth in the output of knowledge, wrote a successful long book, but he<br />
books per million of population. And this has was a master of the conte, and not until Kipling<br />
occurred during the last seventy years.<br />
appeared can his supremacy in this line be said to<br />
I am tempted to suggest that the vast produc- have ever been seriously assailed. “The Luck of<br />
tion of new books which has now been stated Roaring Camp," “ The Outcasts of Poker Flat,"<br />
would not have occurred if the makers of the “ The Idyll of Red Gulch," may be cited as in-<br />
books had pondered the words of the popular stances of his supreme excellence in the difficult<br />
Latin poet, written more than 1900 years ago, art of the short story. He combined, perfectly, a<br />
whose admirable sense of propriety causes his wonderful pathos, fine descriptions of camp life<br />
ancient thought to be a valuable working-maxim and western scenery, vivid and masterly delineation<br />
for authors of to-day :-<br />
of character, and a humour which was often irre-<br />
“Ye authors, choose a subject suited to your sistible. “The Heathen Chinee” may be said to<br />
abilities, and long ponder what your strength have been unknown and unappreciated by the<br />
is equal to, what it is too weak to support. Anglo-Saxon race until Bret Harte discovered him<br />
He who chooses a theme according to his in the rude mining camps of California, labelled<br />
powers, will find neither command of language him, and introduced him to the American and<br />
nor lucid arrangement fail him. And herein British world. Who that takes up that inimitable<br />
lies, unless I deceive myself, the power and picture in verse, even after this long interval of<br />
beauty of arrangement ; if a writer says at time from its first appearance in print, can resist<br />
once only what ought to be said at once, its trenchant satire and abounding humour ?<br />
reserving most points, and omitting them for For thirty years had Bret Harte continued to<br />
the present."<br />
pour forth tales, poetry, and sketches. It was in-<br />
J. HOLT SCHOOLING.. evitable that some of his later work should have<br />
lost the freshness and force of his earlier writings;<br />
yet the reader will find, even in his last book of<br />
stories, published in the very month of his death,<br />
TWO AMERICANS.<br />
work which showed distinctly that his hand had by<br />
no means lost its ancient cunning. He never could<br />
forget the scenes and the characters of that strange,<br />
EATH has, within these last few weeks,claimed wild Californian life which in his early and im-<br />
two notable figures from the ranks of litera- pressive youth laid such a hold upon his imagina-<br />
ture. Frank R. Stockton and Bret Harte, tion. In his last book he returns, and returns with<br />
whose loss the whole reading public have to lament, success, to the old familiar ground, stakes out his<br />
bad long since established their fame. Both claim, and quarries good ore. Bret Harte will<br />
died elderly men ; yet neither had retired from live, if only for his “Plain Language from Truthful<br />
the great army of active workers ; nor can it be James,” his inimitable “Heathen Chinee," his<br />
said that either had outlived his reputation. “ Poker Flat," and "The Luck of Roaring Camp.”<br />
Frank Stockton, who died a week or two before We should like to see a good anthology of his<br />
his fellow countryman, had never attained quite poems, and a couple of volumes of his best short<br />
the world-wide popularity of Bret Harte; nor stories. Upon these his fame would stand assured<br />
probably will his writings linger so long in the for many a long day.<br />
public mind. Yet he had accomplished much good The death of Bret Harte only serves to accentuate<br />
work, and the present generation will still cherish the extraordinary dearth of anything like real<br />
in their minds pleasant recollections of “ Rudder humour in the literature of the present day. Is<br />
Grange,” and others of his books. That curious this quality to become extinct ? Are the con-<br />
little study, “ The Lady or the Tiger,” will, from ditions of life so onerous, so stern, or so re-<br />
its very incompleteness, and the problem which it pellent, that humour, always a delicate plant, is<br />
leaves to the reader, live, probably, longer than not now to be raised among us? It is a curious<br />
any other of Stockton's writings. An admirable problem. Upon the whole, we are inclined to<br />
humorist of the quieter sort, Frank Stockton's think that the next decade or two may see a<br />
death is sincerely to be regretted.<br />
marked revival of this lost art of amusing people,<br />
Bret Harte, whose last volume of stories, “On of creating hearty laughter. Just such a revival<br />
the Old Trail," was published about the time of took place after the Restoration. Purged, of<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 231 (#643) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
231<br />
course, of its grossness, we could welcome such an author had such a tribute paid to him as was<br />
a rejuvenescence of an almost lost art. At present paid to Black by the artists who jointly illustrated<br />
we can count our lumorists easily upon the his“Macleod of Dare.” Pettie, Graham, Boughton,<br />
fingers of one hand. The sudden rise and success Orchardson, Colin Hunter, MacWhirter, C. E.<br />
of Mr. W. W. Jacobs indicates very clearly how Johnson, Aitken, and Thomas Faed, all contributed<br />
eagerly the advent of any writer capable of stirring to translate into pictures Black's written words,<br />
genuine laughter is welcomed among the publishers. the greatest possible compliment to his descriptive<br />
Yet Mr. Jacobs' example seems as yet to attract powers from those best able to judge.<br />
few followers into the same field.<br />
He also possessed what Sir Wemyss Reid well<br />
describes as a “sympathetic insight which enabled<br />
him to depict the characters and temperaments<br />
of pure and beautiful women in such a manner<br />
WILLIAM BLACK. A BIOGRAPHY.*<br />
as to command universal assent and appreciation.”<br />
The artist's eye and sympathetic insight are,<br />
however, most commonly accompanied by a retiring,<br />
TROM all those who enjoyed the privilege of almost secretive, disposition, and Black's best<br />
intimate friendship with William Black qualities must, therefore, be sought in his own<br />
Sir Wemyss Reid's Biography will receive books, and not in books about him ; consequently,<br />
a welcome in which there will be no suggestion to say that one is conscious of some chose qui<br />
of reserve. His straightforward account of a life<br />
manque in Sir Wemyss Reid's life of his friend is,<br />
which, without being eventful, was still a full one, perhaps, tantamount to saying that one wishes the<br />
will serve as a storehouse of memories for all who<br />
book were other than it is. This particular reader<br />
participated, however slightly, in it. I cannot help<br />
would have preferred a biographical and critical<br />
thinking, however, that thosc, like myself, who study to a biography pure and simple, but doubtless<br />
never saw Black, but derived a rare pleasure from Sir Wemyss Reid preferred to let Black's work be<br />
his work, will be conscious of a certain sense of judged by all upon its merits, and confine himself<br />
disappointment when they lay the volume down. to a mere record of his old friend's daily life.<br />
It has, it is true, the essential merit of being<br />
Black was a member of the Society of Authors<br />
interesting, but somehow in Sir Wemyss Reid's<br />
from its very early days, and while he did not<br />
work the touch of the great portrait painter is identify himself with it in the same way that Sir<br />
missing, and the picture does not seem alive.<br />
Walter Besant did, it is interesting to seek in this<br />
This is not to suggest that it could have been “life” of the one some corroboration of what is to<br />
done better by any other hand. I do not, indeed,<br />
be found in the “autobiography” of the other, in<br />
at all suppose it could, for Black's principal<br />
the shape of advice to those of us who are still at<br />
characteristic seems to have been an unusual faculty<br />
the bottom of the ladder.<br />
of detaching himself from the world while he was The first lesson taught in practice by both men<br />
at work, and an equally unusual faculty of detaching<br />
is that no one should embark upon the struggle<br />
himself from his work when that was done; add for life as a man of letters unless he has something<br />
to this a reserve amounting almost to austerity, fixed and definite in the way of income to fall back<br />
except where his most intimate friends were upon. In Besant's case the something was com-<br />
concerned, and it becomes sufficiently obvious that paratively easy to find because of his academic<br />
Sir Wemyss Reid's self-imposed task of showing qualifications ; in Black's case it was less easy,<br />
the real man would have been beyond the power of because he never had “any systematised education<br />
almost any one else to perform.<br />
to speak of "—the words are his own—and his<br />
The “artistic temperament” is a phrase so youthful work for the Glasgow newspapers was not<br />
commonly abused that one is loth to use it in sufficiently remarkable to gain him a journalistic<br />
connection with any author for whose works one appointment in London at the outset. He took<br />
has great admiration. Of Black it is better, the first post that offered--a clerkship in Birchin<br />
perhaps, to say that he had the artist's eye for<br />
Lane--and there remained, devoting all his spare<br />
nature, and a rarely developed power of reproducing time to the production of copy, until he got his<br />
natural beauty through the medium of words. first journalistic appointment on the editorial staff<br />
He appropriated the Hebrides as Hardy appro- of The Morning Star.<br />
priated “Wessex” and Blackmoor Devonshire,<br />
The second lesson taught by both, as it is taught<br />
and his fine word-painting was inspired by love by all who succeed in any and every department<br />
of the region he described. Seldom, if ever, has of life, is the necessity of work, of unflagging<br />
industry and perseverance. Success is only won<br />
* By Wemyss Reid (Cassell & Co., Limited, London,<br />
that way, and, what is perhaps more important to<br />
1902)<br />
remember, it is only kept that way. Sir Wemyss<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 232 (#644) ############################################<br />
<br />
232<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
Reid makes it plain that although literary work when the publisher waited for the unknown author<br />
was congenial to Black-was, indeed, his true to come to him with his manuscript. But of late<br />
vocation--it was real and even hard work, during the unknown has so frequently developed under<br />
the doing of which everything in the shape of exploitation, and by direct solicitation of the pub.<br />
amusement was laid aside, and with which nothing lisher, into a “money-making proposition" of such<br />
was allowed to interfere. That is an interesting formidable proportions that there is hardly a pab-<br />
part of Sir Wemyss Reid's book in which he lishing house that does not now hunt him out with<br />
describes Paston House, and Black's mode of all the resources at its command. Certain fields<br />
work—the pains he took over his descriptive pas- are worked with the thoroughness, almost, of a<br />
sages, minutely sketched in note-books on the spot; political canvass, and if a given State-say, for<br />
the care with wbich he thought out every detail instance, Indiana-has suddenly evolved into a<br />
in a chapter before committing it to paper ; the region of great literary activity, it is open to<br />
silent seclusion in which he passed the alternate suspicion that it is not because there is any<br />
days devoted to the actual task of writing ; and the inherent literary quality in the people of the place<br />
severely simple room in which he conjured up the greater than in other States, but that certain firms<br />
visions that have charmed so many people since of publishers are “ working the ground.”<br />
There are few writers to whom the existence of the<br />
creatures of their brain has been more intensely<br />
real than it was to William Black ; but men make<br />
worlds for themselves only by infinite pains, and<br />
Black was no exception to the rule.<br />
A PAGE FROM A GERMAN PUBLISHER'S<br />
For the rest, it is enough to say that this bio-<br />
graphy is characterised by good taste and restraint.<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
It shows the vigour and virility of Black's nature,<br />
his scorn of affectation and insincerity, and the<br />
reticence and reserve which had been inculcated in<br />
Literary Hints for the Wealthy and Cultivated.<br />
him as a child. If it fails at all, it fails in reveal-<br />
ing to those who did not know the man the lovable A GENTLEMAN does not give his daughter<br />
qualities wbich evoked such a friendship as endured<br />
a dowry of from five to fifty thousand<br />
between Villiam Black and Sir Wemyss Reid<br />
pounds and forget to provide her with a<br />
himself.<br />
book-case.<br />
V. E. M.<br />
A gentleman does not have a full wine cellar<br />
and empty book-shelves.<br />
A gentleman does not use eau-de-cologne and<br />
THE OBLIGATIONS OF ART TO TRADE.<br />
read greasy volumes from a circulating library.<br />
A gentleman does not borrow good works which<br />
he is in a position to buy.<br />
A gentleman does not talk about the latest<br />
[TAE following paragraph is taken from an article<br />
entitled "Salt and Sincerity,” by Frank Norris, published<br />
literature when he is acquainted only with what<br />
1<br />
in the American Critic for May. We print it without has been said of it by the reviewers.<br />
comment à propos of the article in the last issue of The A gentleman does not cut books with his fingers,<br />
Author, entitled - The Obligations of Art to Trade."- even after having washed his hands.<br />
Ev.]<br />
A gentleman does not possess a box of carpenter's<br />
T present the stimulus to, and even the tools, but no paper-knife.<br />
A manner of, production of very much of A gentleman does not receive books for review<br />
American fiction is in the hands of the pub- and give them away or sell them without opening<br />
lishers. No one not intimately associated with any them.<br />
of the larger more important“houses” can have any A gentleman does not make presents only of<br />
idea of the influence of the publisher upon latter-day things which are entirely without intellectual<br />
fiction. More novels are written-practically-to value.<br />
order than the public has any notion of. The pub. A gentleman does not send to his bookseller for<br />
lisher again and again picks out the man(one speaks, a parcel of books on approval, and, after having<br />
of course, of the younger generation), suggests the read them, return them saying that none of them<br />
theme, and exercises in a sense all the functions of suit him.<br />
instructor, during the period of composition. In A gentleman does not buy only sixpenny cheap<br />
the matter of this “ picking out of the man ” it is editions.<br />
rather curious to note a very radical change that A gentleman does not depend for his reading<br />
has come about in the last five years. Time was upon the daily journals and illustrated weeklies.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 233 (#645) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
233<br />
ROMANTIC GERMANY."<br />
Romanticism in Germany was the result of a<br />
definite movement, or rather, a definite conspiracy,<br />
whereas in England the members of the Romantic<br />
TROM the point of view of literature, the School worked independently. The Germans were<br />
T Romantic movement in Germany may be intimate friends; they worked together, and had<br />
summed up in the outworn phrase, “ Much their common art theories and programmes.<br />
cry, but little wool.” This, at any rate, is the Novalis and Wackenroder were edited by<br />
impression given by the second volume of Dr. Tieck and Friedrich Schlegel ; Arnim married<br />
Brandes' great work, and though, as he says in Brentano's sister Bettina — Goethe's Bettina ;<br />
conclusion, the School possesses permanent literary Caroline Böhmer was the wife of A. W. Schlegel<br />
interest, and compares favourably with equivalent and, later, of Schelling. And in Germany the<br />
groups in other lands, he rather discounts this reaction, as a recent critic has shown, was not<br />
judgment by observing in his introduction that merely literary: it concerned itself also with religion<br />
“ of all that the German Romanticists produced,<br />
in Romanticists produced and with the affairs of actual life. Schleiermacher,<br />
little will endure-some masterly translations by Friedrich Schlegel, and many others, had decided<br />
A. W. Schlegel, a few of Tieck's productions, a theories on the marriage laws, and did not hesitate<br />
handful of Hardenberg's and another of Eichen- to reduce them to practice ; Tieck and Wacken-<br />
dorff's lyrics, some of Friedrich Schlegel's essays, roder were the apostles of Roman Catholicism,<br />
a few of Arnim's and Brentano's smaller works,<br />
and Brentano passed six years in ecstatic con-<br />
a select number of Hoffmann's tales, and some<br />
templation of the stigmata of the nun Catherina<br />
very remarkable dramas and tales from the pen<br />
Emmerich. One and all were the apostles of<br />
of that eccentric but real genius, Heinrich von freedom, though to the majority the word seems<br />
Kleist."<br />
to have meant nothing but thraldom in the dungeon<br />
It is not, perhaps, a very imposing group ; to of their own hallucinations and desires.<br />
the present writer, at least, it seems to compare<br />
To Lessing, the liberator of German thought,<br />
unfavourably with the movement in France which the Romanticists really owed little; as Dr. Brandes<br />
could boast such names as Chateaubriand, Hugo, says,<br />
Gautier, de Musset, and Baudelaire. One is<br />
“The Romanticists could not possibly claim a champion<br />
tempted to think, too, that one “St. Agnes' Eve"<br />
of reason, pure and simple, as their forerunner, hence they<br />
is worth all the terrors that a host of Hoffmanns attempted to characterise the nutritive element in Lessing's<br />
could conjure up, and that the “Undine" or the works as mere seasoning, as the salt which preserves from<br />
“ Sigurd ” of de la Motte Fouqué, whose heroes, as<br />
corruption. They owed far more to Herder.... In Herder<br />
Heine wittily said, have the courage of a hundred<br />
the new century germinated, as in Lessing the old had<br />
come to its close. Herder sets genesis and growth above<br />
lions and the sense of two asscs, cut a sorry figure thought and action. To him the true man is not only a<br />
beside " Ivanhoe” and “The Talisman." And thinking and moral being, but a portion of nature. ...<br />
these impressions are strengthened rather than The man of intuitions is to him the most human.”<br />
diminished by a study of Dr. Brandes' book. His<br />
aim, as he avows, is “to treat the history of<br />
Herder excluded the idea of purpose ; he was<br />
literature as humanly as possible, to seize upon<br />
the foe of all i posteriori reasoning, and this<br />
the remotest innermost psychological movements<br />
attitude appealed most powerfully to the Romanti-<br />
which prepared for and produced the various<br />
cists. Their philosophy of aimlessness is only a<br />
literary phenomena." The defect of this method<br />
caricature of his theory, but, wretched though it<br />
lies in the fact that when it is applied to a<br />
seens, it owed its origin to his wide intellectual<br />
movement consisting of one or two great writers<br />
powers and quick, clear-sighted genius. Indeed,<br />
and a swarm of neurotic nonentities, it inevitably<br />
from the philosophical standpoint, the history of<br />
results in a mode of criticism that is pathological<br />
German romanticism is the history of distorted<br />
rather than literary. Dr. Brandes has shown us<br />
ideas, and a lamentable example of how the<br />
the brain-sickness, the neurosis, the feeble intellects<br />
theories of genius may be reduced to absurdity<br />
and morbidly excitable senses of a great number<br />
by the stupid zeal of fanatics.<br />
of interesting ladies and gentlemen with such<br />
From Goethe the Romanticists derived their<br />
wonderful skill that we are almost forced to regard<br />
theory of the rights of the free personality. The<br />
the literary aspect of these people as that which<br />
early works of Goethe and Schiller had been<br />
possesses the least iinportance.<br />
inspired by the “ Freigeisterei," the antinomian<br />
demand for freedom ; both “Götz” and “Die<br />
Räuber” are declarations of war against society.<br />
• "Main Currents in 19th Century Literature: II. The<br />
But the Romanticists' strife against convention<br />
Romantic School in Germany," by George Brandes<br />
was not for the sake of the rights of humanity, but<br />
(Heinemann, 1902).<br />
for the rights of the heart; “not against the<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 234 (#646) ############################################<br />
<br />
234<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
wrongs of life, but against its prose.” And here THE LITERARY SIDE OF PRESIDENT<br />
we may discover the secret of that antinomian<br />
ROOSEVELT.<br />
attitude which the school adopted. They were<br />
angry because actual life did not resemble the<br />
finer, shadowy existence of their dreams ; they (Reprinted from the “Bulletin of the Society of<br />
could not understand that the romantic glamour American Authors.")<br />
which they admired so greatly was a purely literary<br />
CINCE the days of Thomas Jefferson, no literary man<br />
product.<br />
D has held the office of chief magistrate until the<br />
Goethe, Schiller, Herder, and the philosophy of coming of Theodore Roosevelt, who for twenty years<br />
Fichte, with its doctrine of the absolute authority has been a most prolific writer on out-door life and historical<br />
of the Ego-these are the great fountain-heads<br />
topics. The Times says that Mr. Roosevelt's writing is at<br />
its best when it approaches the most nearly to action :<br />
from which flowed the so troubled stream of “In his histories and biographies Roosevelt the writer is<br />
German romanticism. From these it derived most successful when Roosevelt the man is most completely<br />
(with how little real authority from the first two enlisted, and when his subject is of the sort to which his<br />
sources !) its defiance of order, its exaltation of<br />
multiform activities have been most closely related. They<br />
are best, certainly they are most interesting, where they<br />
selfish caprice, and its amusingly deliberate aim-<br />
are the unconscious representation of the author's mind<br />
lessness. These qualities, and the enmity to and character. He misses, for instance, some of the most<br />
Hellenism, that it learned froin Hölderlin (for significant phases of the curious and original nature of<br />
whom Dr. Brandes, to us, at least, seems to<br />
Gouverneur Morris, one of the strongest, most penetrating,<br />
and most strangely limited minds in our early or later<br />
possess a strangely exalted admiration), may be<br />
history, but he grasps firmly and renders clearly the<br />
traced in the critical work of A. W. Schlegel, the working of the essential forces that went to the · Winning<br />
dreary, ostentatiously naughty “Lucinde ” of his of the West.' These he feels ; he has been in active alliance<br />
brother. Tieck's “ William Lovell." Jean Paul's and co-operation with them, and has had to wrestle with<br />
them. He has known in personal intimacy the survivors<br />
“Titan”; indeed, in almost every work of the<br />
and present representatives of the victors in that mighty<br />
members of the School, and in most of their lives. struggle, and the men who are developing what their<br />
Such qualities, of course, cannot harm a great ancestors or forerunners won. His sympathies are intense<br />
artist; Fichte's philosophy finds its most melodious and so is his imagination, but they are also somewhat<br />
limited, and his estimate of men and events when his<br />
echo in Shelley, and there are not a few who prefer<br />
sympathies are not awakened or his imagination kindled<br />
Swinburne the antinomian to Mr. Swinburne the is sometimes defective and even unjust.<br />
serenader of infancy; but it was the misfortune of “ His essays are models of their kind, and their kind is<br />
Germany that her romantic movement possessed<br />
an extremely difficult and risky one. They are direct in<br />
narrative, clear and succinct in description, well weighed<br />
few men of real genius.<br />
and convincing in their judgments, moderate in temper<br />
Dr. Brandes' second volume is especially remark and simply indispensable to the reader who wishes to study<br />
able for the way in which he has attained minute the subjects with which they deal. They reveal directly,<br />
historical detail without endangering his usual fine<br />
as the histories and biographies reveal indirectly, the mind<br />
and character of the writer. They are almost entirely free<br />
critical standpoint. Especially interesting are his<br />
from the extreme criticism and sweeping theorizing which<br />
studies of Wackenroder and of Novalis, with the dis for this hater of mere critics and theorists seem to have a<br />
tinction drawn between the instability of the latter fascination that he can resist only when his mind is engaged<br />
strange, chaotic genius and Shelley's championship<br />
on facts with which he himself has dealt. Of his defects<br />
and temptations there are also examples in the essays,<br />
of truth. The account of the mysticism of the<br />
especially in those that suggest lay sermons, in which the<br />
romantic arama, with the " plays within plays O preaching is strikingly inferior to the author's practice."<br />
Werner and Kleist, is far more amusing than the His first publication, an historical work, appeared when<br />
most fantastic collection of dreams, and the chapter he had been only a year out of Harvard, where he was<br />
graduated, in 1880 ; * The Naval War of 1812 ; or, The<br />
on Romantic Politicians contains a very interesting<br />
mg History of the United States Navy during the Last War<br />
criticism of Gentz. But though the book is a with Great Britain," was published in 1882.<br />
part of one of the classics of European literature, Mr. Roosevelt's next work, published three years later,<br />
one closes it with a sigh. The story of German<br />
was entitled “Hunting Trips of a Ranchman ; Sketches<br />
of Sport on the Northern Cattle Plains, together with<br />
romance is infinitely more pathetic than their most<br />
Personal Experiences of Life on a Cattle Ranch." It was<br />
tearful volume. One feels that it should have illustrated by A. B. Frost, R. Swain Gifford, J. C. Beard,<br />
been published by the Psychical Research Society. Fannie E. Gifford, and Henry Sandham.<br />
Still, like all people who possess a deficient sense<br />
In 1887 Mr. Roosevelt wrote the "Life of Thomas Hart<br />
Benton," and in the following year “ Gouverneur Morris,"<br />
of humour, the German Romanticists are very<br />
both duodecimo volumes published in the “ American<br />
amusing.<br />
Statesmen " series. In the same year another duodecimo<br />
Sr. J. L. volume by him was published by the Putnams under the<br />
title “Essays on Practical Politics." It was in the series,<br />
“Questions of the Day." His most important work<br />
appearing that year, 1888, however, was “Ranch Life and<br />
the Hunting Trail," illustrated by Frederick Remington.<br />
The first two volunes of the work which has been called<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 235 (#647) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
235<br />
perhaps Mr. Roosevelt's most substantial literary achieve.<br />
ment, the-Winning of the West," were issued by the Putnams.<br />
The whole work is in five volumes, octavo, with maps.<br />
The third volume came out in 1894. Its sub-title is “The<br />
Founding of the Trans-Alleghany Commonwealths,” and it<br />
deals with the period from 1784 to 1790.<br />
In the fourth volume, issued in 1996, he was still engaged<br />
with this phase of American development. The volume is<br />
" Louisiana and the Northwest, 1791 to 1807."<br />
In 1891 Mr. Roosevelt published his “ New York" in the<br />
“ Historic Towns," a new edition with a postscript appearing<br />
in 1895 ; 232 pages, duodecimo. .....<br />
“ The Wilderness Hunter ; An Account of the Big Game<br />
of the United States, and its Chase with Horse, Hound<br />
and Rifle," was published in 1893, illustrated by Frost,<br />
Beard, Sandham and Remington. Many of the illustrations<br />
are not ideal drawings, but studies of animals which Mr.<br />
Roosevelt himself killed.<br />
In the same year came “ American Big Game Hunting ;<br />
the Book of the Boone and Crockett Club." In this Mr.<br />
Roosevelt and G. B. Grinnell collaborated in the editing.<br />
It is devoted to big game hunting in this country and to<br />
questions of forest reservation, different papers having<br />
been contributed by various members of the club. An<br />
appendix gives a short account of the literature of American<br />
big game hunting, a list of forest reservations, etc.<br />
* Hunting in Many Lands." also a part of the book of the<br />
Boone and Crockett Club, in which Mr. Roosevelt again<br />
collaborated with Mr. Grinnell, was published in 1895, and<br />
in 1897 still another volume of this club book appeared,<br />
from the same editorial hands, entitled “Trail and Camp<br />
Fire." Also in 1897, Mr. Roosevelt published “ American<br />
Ideals, and other Essays, Social and Political.” Its con-<br />
tents are : - American Ideals : True Americanism; The<br />
Manly Virtues and Practical Politics : The College Graduate<br />
and Public Life ; Phases of State Legislation ; Machine<br />
Politics in New York City: Six Years of Civil Service<br />
Reform ; Administering the New York Police Force; The<br />
Vice-Presidency and the Campaign of 1896 ; How not to<br />
Help our Poorer Brother; The Monroe Doctrine ; Wash-<br />
ington's Forgotten Maxim ; National Life and Character;<br />
Social Evolutions ; Laws of Civilization and Decay."<br />
Two years before this Mr. Roosevelt, in conjunction<br />
with Serator Lodge, of Massachusetts, had prepared a<br />
volume of “ Hero Tales from American History.”<br />
In 1899 appeared “The Rough Riders," followed by<br />
“ Oliver Cromwell” and “ The Strenuous Life."<br />
There may be omissions in this list, which certainly is a<br />
remarkable output from a man who has also been soldier<br />
and statesman, and is only in his forty-fourth year.<br />
It is my practice to write a polite letter of<br />
inquiry as to MS. of mine which has been<br />
retained by editors for more than six weeks, and,<br />
if necessary, a week hence to write again; and they<br />
are usually returned within a few days, but never<br />
with one word of apology for their retention. Is<br />
this politeness?<br />
I do not think it fair or reasonable for any<br />
editor to retain MS. for longer than a month<br />
without first asking the permission of the con-<br />
tributor. In social life it would be bad manners.<br />
to do otherwise. But editors are a law to<br />
themselves.<br />
Editors declare they are not responsible for lost<br />
MS. I doubt if that would hold good at law. A<br />
case should be tried in the county court; and the<br />
editor's books requisitioned to show if the MS.<br />
was received, etc. Such books are, or should be,<br />
1<br />
kept. A jury would be more likely to decide<br />
against the editor than for him. And certainly, if<br />
anthors were to register their MS. and enclose<br />
with it postace for return registration editors<br />
would not have a leg to stand on. But so long as<br />
authors are willing to be snubbed by editors, so<br />
long do they deserve the scant courtesy and civility<br />
they occasionally receive.<br />
I have before me the MS. of an article recently<br />
returned by the editor of a first-class magazine.<br />
It is scored in places with blue pencil marks, and<br />
my gra!nmar has been altered in two places, though,<br />
in my humble opinion, without improvement. No<br />
sort of apology was offered me for this act of<br />
impertinence; and before I can submit the article<br />
elsewhere, I shall have to rewrite the MS.<br />
(1,500 words). Is this the act of a gentleman<br />
editor or of a common fellow?<br />
Yours faithfully,<br />
SCRIBBLER.<br />
Jay 8th, 1902.<br />
CORRESPONDENCE.<br />
EDITORS AND CONTRIBUTORS.<br />
I.<br />
SIR, -I don't doubt others better qualified than<br />
me will reply to your correspondent, “ Another<br />
Editor.” But if you can find space for a few<br />
remarks of mine, I should be obliged.<br />
I agree with him that editors are human, by<br />
which I understand, amongst other things, that<br />
they can put on their worst manners when it suits<br />
them. As to polite letters from editors to polite<br />
letters from contributors, it is not my invariable<br />
experience.<br />
SIR, I imagine many of your readers must<br />
share my amusement at the ingenuous letter of<br />
“ Another Editor” in your May issue. The descrip-<br />
tion of this poor harassed creature, “full of good<br />
intentions," and occupied in despatching“ prompt”.<br />
and “polite” notes to the unreasonable authors<br />
who expect him to read and decide upon their<br />
unsolicited contributions within a few days—“per-<br />
haps a week '—would be both impressive and<br />
pathetic, did it not, alas ! compel an unbelieving<br />
chuckle. Unfortunately “ Another Editor” pro-<br />
tests his promptitude and politeness a little too<br />
much.<br />
In the first place, the incident he quotes hardly<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 236 (#648) ############################################<br />
<br />
236<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
seems worthy of the importance be assigns to it. discussed and disputed authorship. It would be<br />
No one but either the crudest amateur, whose interesting to know whether it has been declared<br />
doings it were unprofitable to discuss, or a writer in any other way more likely to reach the general<br />
of such eminence as to have a right to an imme- public, and if not, why any further attempt at<br />
diate decision, would dream of expecting any editor concealment should be kept up. In Mudie's new<br />
to decide on a MS. within a week. The ordinary catalogue published this year neither of the two<br />
contributor, conversant with the habits of the works referred to are inserted under the name of<br />
ordinary editor, knows better than to expect any Housman, but both under that of the author of<br />
such supernaturally prompt attention. If he the “ Love Letters.” It is to be presumed that it<br />
received it he would be sure that the editor was is only with Mr. Housman's sanction and consent<br />
too good for this world, and might reasonably feel that the authorship has been disclosed in the<br />
anxious as to his state of health.<br />
Literary Year Book, and one wonders why the<br />
The real fact of the matter—which “ Another “Englishwoman's Love Letters” was not also<br />
Editor" ignores-is, that authors are subjected to included in the list of his works given there.<br />
a great deal of annoying delay at the hands of<br />
N. C.<br />
editors which cannot possibly be necessary, at any<br />
May 12th, 1902.<br />
rate in the case of a writer whose name is in any<br />
way known. Personally, I do not ask for polite<br />
notes and good intentions. What I do ask is, that<br />
AUTHORS' LETTERS.<br />
an editor shall read a contribution submitted to SIR, À propos of the complaint raised by a<br />
him within a reasonable time, and either accept or<br />
accept or member of the Society in your last issue, “that a<br />
reject it without further delay. If his hands are<br />
communication received through his publisher had<br />
so full of copy that he is unable to consider MSS.<br />
been opened,” an experience of my own may not be<br />
until several months after receiving them, then he<br />
without interest.<br />
should notify that fact on the front page of his<br />
A few years ago I contributed an article to one<br />
magazine, and return all contributions unread.<br />
of the leading magazines published by an “old and<br />
No one, I should think — except " Another responsible firm.""<br />
Editor's” important contributor-expects to receive Within a week or two I received a flattering<br />
an editorial decision within a week of submitting letter from the head of 7<br />
MSS., but on the other hand a delay of, say, two<br />
lunch at his country house to discuss the writing of<br />
Innch at his conn<br />
months over the consideration of a few short stories<br />
a book which he had long held to be a necessity,<br />
is surely as ridiculous as it is uncalled for. Yet a<br />
but for which he had not hitherto found a com-<br />
case of this kind is at present engaging my own petent author. I was to have two years for the<br />
attention, and, though I have already written twice<br />
task, generous remuneration, and a fine advertise-<br />
on the subject, I have received none of the polite<br />
ment. Then the publisher died, the scheme fell<br />
notes which “Another Editor" is always despatching<br />
through, and the book has not been written by<br />
to his more fortunate contributors. Neither do I<br />
me or any one else.<br />
expect to do so. But, when the gentleman I refer<br />
Two or three years later I contributed another<br />
to receives my third letter--which he will do shortly · article to another leading magazine. In sending<br />
---requesting the immediate return of my MSS.<br />
me a cheque for the contribution, the Editor<br />
unless he wishes me to apply for the assistance of<br />
incidentally asked me how it was I had never<br />
your Society to recover them, I have not the slightest<br />
answered a letter which he had addressed to me,<br />
doubt that he will wonder aggrievedly why I am<br />
care of the first-named publisher, on the occasion<br />
in such an extraordinary hurry, and consider him-<br />
of the publication of the first-named article, in<br />
self as much an innocent and misunderstood martyr which he had asked me whether I was willing to<br />
as “ Another Editor."<br />
undertake for him the writing of a book on the<br />
Yours faithfully,<br />
very subject discussed by me with the first-named<br />
publisher at his country house.<br />
I replied that I had never received his letter,<br />
and he then informed me that the envelope which<br />
A MODERN ANTÆUS.<br />
covered it had borne the device of his firm.<br />
SIR.—May I draw attention to the fact that in The conclusion to be gathered was obvious, and<br />
the Literary Year Book for 1902, “A Modern I was thus deprived of a commission which I<br />
Turray, 1901), is given in the list of could, at that time, ill afford to lose.<br />
books by Mr. Laurence Housman ? Now as " A<br />
Modern Antæus” is published by the author of an<br />
I am, yours truly,<br />
“ Englishwoman's Love Letters,” this is, of course, Malvern,<br />
G. S. LAYARD.<br />
equivalent to an announcement of the much May 2nd, 1902.<br />
USCRIPT.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 236 (#649) ############################################<br />
<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
ESTABLISHED)<br />
[XVIII. CENT<br />
The Athenæum Press, Taunton.<br />
BARNICOTT & PEARCE<br />
INVITE ENQUIRIES RESPECTING PRINTING.<br />
ESTIMATES OF COST, AND OTHER DETAILS, PROMPTLY GIVEN.<br />
TYPEWRITING.<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully and accurately copied. Plays and Scientific MSS. a speciality. Contract prices for books or<br />
permanent work. Machines and operators sent out to all parts of London or the Provinces.<br />
Miss RANSOM, 2, Westbourne Grove, London, W.<br />
Close to Paddington, Royal Oak, and Queen's Road Stations (Tube and Metropolitan).<br />
THE BUSH LANE HOUSE TYPEWRITING & SHORTHAND OFFICE,<br />
Principal:<br />
Bush Lane House, Bush Lane,<br />
MISS MORGAN.<br />
Cannon Street, London, E.C.<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully and promptly copied from 10d. per 1,000 words. General Typewriting, Shorthand and<br />
Translations executed by skilled workers. Privacy and accuracy guaranteed.<br />
Special Terms for large quantities or contract work. Estimates and Specimens free on application.<br />
In One Volume, Crown 8vo, Scarlet Cloth. Published Price, 3/6. Usual Discount.<br />
"FRITHIOF THE BOLD." By F. 1. WINBOLT,<br />
Author of "King Helge," "Aslog,"<br />
" In stirring blank verse. Mr. Winbolt recounts the ancient Scandinavian legend. Frithiof the Bold.' The drama is in three acts, and besides<br />
providing an interesting and enthralling story, is calculated to convey to the reader an excellent idea of the primitive motives which prevailed<br />
among the Norse and similar hardy races. Frithiof is of humble birth, but, like the typical hero, he is bold and brave, and graceful of<br />
limb...."-Nottingham Guardian.<br />
LONDON: SWAN SONNENSCHEIN & CO., LTD.<br />
AUTHORS' TYPEWRITING,<br />
ITO AUTHORS.—Young man (28), well-educated, lengthy<br />
1 Press experience, desires appointment as Assistant to<br />
Novels typewritten, from 9d. per 1,000 words; Literary Gentleman (whole or spare time). Could revise<br />
two copies, 11-.<br />
proofs. Typing, Shorthand. Could undertake Typing at<br />
PRICE LIST AND AUTHORS' OPINIONS ON APPLICATION. home. Any MSS. deciphered. Accuracy guaranteed.<br />
L. A. ST. JOHN, 104, Churston Av., Upton Park, E.<br />
Ex. refs.--W. MEREDITH, 33, Hubert Grove, Stockwell,<br />
S.W.<br />
TYPEWRITING.<br />
Miss M. T. DOYLE, 31, Gracechurch St., E.C.<br />
From 201, BARCOMBE AVENUE, S.W.<br />
Authors' MSS., Plays from 10d. per 1,000 words.<br />
CARBONS HALF THE ABOVE.<br />
ACCURACY AND DESPATCH.<br />
A LADY (Experienced) undertakes Researches in British<br />
Museum Reading Room. 21. an hour; 8/6 a day.<br />
Also French and German, and Translations.<br />
E. B., 17, OWEN MANSIONS,<br />
QUEEN'S CLUB GARDENS, W.<br />
Literary Agents.--Authors are warned against dealing with<br />
any Literary Agent without referring to the Society for infor-<br />
mation. Authors are also warned not to sign Agreements on the<br />
advice of Literary Agents alone. All Agreements should be<br />
submitted to the Society for advice.<br />
By Order, G. HERBERT THRING,<br />
Secretary Society of Authors.<br />
39, Old Queen Street, Storey's Gate, s.w.<br />
TYPEWRITING<br />
With Accuracy and Despatch.<br />
Authors' MSS. 9d. per 1,000 words. In duplicate, 19.<br />
per 1,000. Plays, Translations, General Copying, Samples<br />
and References on Application.<br />
MISS JANET WAY,<br />
33, Ossian Road, Stroud Green, N.<br />
The “ Forms of Agreements" issued by the Publishers'<br />
Association can be obtained at the Office, with a full explanation<br />
of heir meaning, price 18. post free. Authors are warned not<br />
Lo sign any agreement which may embody the Clauses exposed<br />
without submitting it first to the Society.<br />
By Order, G. HERBERT THRING,<br />
Secretary Society of Authors,<br />
39, Old Queen Street, Storey's Gate S.W.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 236 (#650) ############################################<br />
<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
Part II. of LADY FLORENCE DIXIE'S BOOK<br />
"THE SONGS OF A CHILD,"<br />
WITH WHICH WILL BE PUBLISHED<br />
A THIRD EDITION OF PART 1.<br />
It may be ordered of Messrs. W. H. SMITH & SON, 186, Strand, W.C.;<br />
J. D. MENZIES, Edinburgh; or any other Bookseller or Library.<br />
• · PRICE 5s, ..<br />
IT CONTAINS THREE COLOURED PORTRAITS.<br />
PUBLISHERS-<br />
THE LEADENHALL PRESS, 50, Leadenhall Street, E.C.<br />
CHARLES SCRIBNER'S SONS, New York.<br />
Reviewing an advance copy of this book, The Literary Guide for May says:-. The perusal of the SECOND PART of<br />
Lady Florence Dixie's poems increases our astonishment at the extraordinary development of her mental powers in<br />
early life. The present volume possesses special interest. . . . Her poetic drama · Abel Avenged 'was written at the<br />
age of fourteen, and one knows not whether to be the most astounded at the boldness of her language or the fact that<br />
at so early a period of life the doubts and the obstinate questionings which the work reveals should have arisen at all.<br />
The chief personage is Cain, whose character is conceived with striking power and sympathy. ... Lady Florence<br />
Dixie is a writer who dares to think for herself-one who can, moreover, express her ideas with refreshing vigour and,<br />
in most cases, unmistakable clearness. The Poetry of Revolt and the Poetry of Sympathy with animal life are<br />
distinctly enriched by the publication of this volume. To have performed such a service is an achievement of which<br />
any author might be proud. That it should have been done by a child is one of the most remarkable facts in<br />
present-day literature."<br />
In a long review of an advance copy of the book in The Agnostic Journal of May 10th, “ Saladin" remarks in his<br />
"At Random” sketch :--The lyric of the poem “Saladin ') is deft and musical, but it is the little schoolgirl's<br />
chivalrous treatment of he who was Christendom's most formidable foe that entitles it to distinction. To try a person<br />
or a cause by his or its intrinsic merits, and not in the light of the extrinsic prejudices with which it has come to be<br />
encrusted, is, in addition to the function of a poet, the deed of a heroine. ... The child's precocious rejection of<br />
religious orthodoxy is recorded in the ambitious dramatic effusion, `Abel Avenged,' an earnest and gifted child's<br />
succedaneum for Byron's Cain,' and in • The Sceptic's Defence. The assault on Orthodoxy is from the moral side.<br />
The teaching of the Church is impugned on the ground of its incompatibility with truth and justice, and-nobly<br />
characteristic of the writer--for its disregard of the sufferings of sentient creatures. . . . Any educated lady of rank<br />
and fashion can secretly hold unpopular tenets; it takes a Douglas to avow them. The volume here is of gold.”<br />
AN ADVANCED CHRISTIAN'S VIEWS OF PART II.<br />
In a letter dated May 1st the Editor of The Golden Age writes :—“ Please accept my warmest thanks for the<br />
pleasure you have given me, and let me offer you my sincerest congratulations. The world has been certainly the<br />
poorer in consequence of the delay in the publication of the poems, for they are both beautiful and remarkable in<br />
many ways, to say nothing of the helpful thought and sentiment contained in them. If · Abel Avenged' had been<br />
issued as a lost manuscript (re-discovered) by Milton, no one would have doubted the authenticity. Are you Milton<br />
re-incarnated ? I wonder! The manner in which you have thought out the deepest problems of Life and handled<br />
them in this poem and in The Sceptic's Defence'is remarkable."<br />
Printed by BRADBURY, AGNEW, & Co. LD., and Published by them for THE SOCIETY OF AUTHORS (INCORPORATED)<br />
at 10, Bourerie Street, London, E.C. | https://historysoa.com/files/original/5/354/1902-06-01-The-Author-12-11.pdf | publications, The Author |