394 | https://historysoa.com/items/show/394 | The Author, Vol. 19 Issue 09 (June 1909) | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=49&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=%3Cem%3EThe+Author%3C%2Fem%3E%2C+Vol.+19+Issue+09+%28June+1909%29"><em>The Author</em>, Vol. 19 Issue 09 (June 1909)</a> | | | <a href="https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015027638405" target="_blank" rel="noopener">https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=mdp.39015027638405</a> | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=51&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Publication">Publication</a> | 1909-06-01-The-Author-19-9 | | | | | 229–260 | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=89&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=19">19</a> | | | | | | | | | | | <a href="/items/browse?advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=76&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=1909-06-01">1909-06-01</a> | | | | | | | 9 | | | 19090601 | C be Elut bor.<br />
(The Organ of the Incorporated Society of Authors. Monthly.)<br />
Vol. XIX.—No. 9. JUNE 1, 1909. [PRICE SIxPENCE.<br />
C O N T E N T S.<br />
PAGE PAG F<br />
Notices ... * † ºn * & e tº tº e tº sº a * ºf G * † 6 tº e & ... 229 Registration of Scenarios * * * * * * & & & e º * * * ... 247<br />
Committee Notes * * * * gº º tº º º tº gº º & º º * * * ... 231 Warnings to Musical Composers ... dº º g & © a * * * ... 247<br />
Books published by Members of the Society ... ... ... 234 Stamping Music... e & as e tº sº e º & º ... ... ... 247<br />
Literary, Dramatic and Musical Notes ... ... ... ... 235 The Reading Branch ... ... * * * * * * ... ... ... 247<br />
Paris Notes tº º & tº tº & & & © s tº 9 tº º & * * * * * * ... 237 “The Author ’’ ... * * * : * * * * * * a º º * * * * g as ... 247<br />
American Copyright Again ... * * * tº s º * g e gº tº ſº ... 239 Remittances tº a gº & ºr º * * * * * * tº g e * * * * * * ... 247<br />
Cheap Editions ... * * * e tº º as gº º * * * ge tº gº & e sº ... 240 George Meredith, O.M. & © tº * & & e & e a gº º & e : ... 248<br />
The Annual Dinner ... tº gº gº & 4 & º, º º tº tº gº * * * ... 242 General Notes * & 4 * c wº tº gº º * & e tº s º * º º ... 254<br />
How to Use the Society & º & * * * tº ſº º tº e e * * * ... 246 Is He 2 ... * - © & e e * * * * * * * * * e = * gº tº e ... 255<br />
Warnings to Producers of Books ... tº º º § º º tº gº g ... 240 A Plutocrat of the Press; or, The Cynic's Success (concluded) 257<br />
Warnings to Dramatic Authors * tº ſº. tº º tº * Q & gº tº e ... 246 Correspondence ... tº º º * * * # * * & & © e E & a º e ... 259<br />
PUBLICATIONS OF THE SOCIETY.<br />
1. The Annual Report for the current year. 1s.<br />
2. The Author. Published ten months in the year (August and September omitted), devoted especially<br />
to the protection and maintenance of Literary, Dramatic, and Musical Property. Issued<br />
to all Members gratis. Price to non-members, 6d., or 5s. 6d. per annum, post free. Back<br />
numbers from 1892, at 10s. 6d. per vol.<br />
8. Literature and the Pension List. By W. MORRIS COLLEs, Barrister-at-Law. 3s.<br />
4. The History of the Société des Gens de Lettres. By S. SQUIRE SPRIGGE. 18.<br />
5. The Cost of Production. (Out of print.)<br />
6. The Warious Methods of Publication. By S. SQUIRE SPRIGGE. In this work, compiled from the<br />
papers in the Society's offices, the various forms of agreements proposed by Publishers to<br />
Authors are examined, and their meaning carefully explained, with an account of the<br />
various kinds of fraud which have been made possible by the different clauses therein. 3s.<br />
Addenda to the Above. By G. HERBERT THRING. Being additional facts collected at<br />
º office of the Society since the publication of the “Methods.” . With comments and<br />
advice. 28.<br />
7. Copyright Law Reform. An Exposition of Lord Monkswell's Copyright Bill of 1890. With<br />
Extracts from the Report of the Commission of 1878, the Berne Convention, and the<br />
American Copyright Bill. By J. M. LELY. 1s. 6d.<br />
8. The Society of Authors. A Record of its Action from its Foundation. By WALTER BESANT<br />
(Chairman of Committee, 1888–1892). 1s.<br />
9. The Contract of Publication in Germany, Austria, Hungary, and Switzerland. By ERNST<br />
LUNGE, J.U.D. 2s. 6d. <3<br />
10. Forms of Agreement issued by the Publishers' Association ; with Comments. By<br />
G. HERBERT THRING, and Illustrative Examples by Sir WALTER BESANT. 2nd Edition. 18.<br />
11. Periodicals and their Contributors. Giving the Terms on which the different Magazines<br />
- and Periodicals deal with MSS. and Contributions. 6d.<br />
12. Society of Authors. List of Members. Published October, 1907, price 6d.<br />
[All prices net. Apply to the Secretary, 39, Old Queen Street, Storey's Gate, S. W.]<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 228 (#288) ############################################<br />
<br />
ii<br />
ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
ſlie Šuriefn of Autburg (jnrurpurated).<br />
Telegraphic Address : “A UTORIDAD, LONDON.”<br />
Telephone No. : 374 Victoria.<br />
SIR ROBERT ANDERSON, K.C.B.<br />
SIRWM.REYNELL ANSON, Bart., D.C.L.<br />
THE RIGHT HON. THE LORD AVE-<br />
J. M. BARRIE. | BURY, P.C.<br />
SIR ALFRED BATEMAN, K.C.M.G.<br />
ROBERT BATEMAN.<br />
F. E. BEDDARD, F.R.S.<br />
THE RIGHT HON, AUGUSTINE BIR-<br />
RELL, P.C.<br />
MRS. E. NESBIT BLAND.<br />
THE REV. PROF. BONNEY, F.R.S.<br />
THE RIGHT HON. JAMES BRYCE, P.C.<br />
PHE RIGHT HON. THE LORD BURGH-<br />
CLERE, P.C.<br />
HALL CAINE.<br />
J. W. COMYINS CARR.<br />
EGERTON CASTLE, F.S.A.<br />
S. L. CLEMENs (“MARK TwAIN ?).<br />
EDWARD CLODD.<br />
W. MORRIS COLLES.<br />
THE HON. JOHN COLLIER,<br />
SIR. W. MARTIN CONWAY.<br />
THE BIGHT HON. THE LORD CURZON<br />
of KEDLESTON, D.C.<br />
AUSTIN DOBSON.<br />
MRS. MAXWELL (M. E. BRADDON).<br />
JUSTIN MCCARTHY. &<br />
THE REV. C. H. MIDDLETON-WAKE,<br />
SIR HENRY NorMAN, M.P.<br />
SIR GILBERT PARKER, M.P.<br />
A. W. PINERO.<br />
THE RIGHT HON. SIR HORACE<br />
PLUNKETT, K.P.<br />
ARTHUR RACKHAM.<br />
OWEN SEAMAN.<br />
G. BERNARD SHAW.<br />
G. R. SIMS.<br />
S. SQUIRE SPRIGGE.<br />
FRANCIS STORR.<br />
SIR CHARLES VILLIERS STANFORD<br />
Mus. Doc.<br />
WILLIAM MOY THOMAS.<br />
MRS. HUMPHRY.WARD.<br />
PERCY WHITE.<br />
FIELD-MARSHAL THE RIGHT HON,<br />
THE WISCOUNT Wolseley, K.P.,<br />
P.C., &c.<br />
SIDNEY WEBB.<br />
H. G. WELLS.<br />
}<br />
COMMITTEE OF MANAGEMENT.<br />
SIR ALFRED BATEMAN, K.C.M.G.<br />
MRS. E. NESBIT BLAND.<br />
J. W. COMYINS CARR.<br />
THE HON. MRS. ALFRED FELKIN.<br />
(ELLEN THORNEYCROFT FOWLER).<br />
S. SQUIRE SPRIGGE.<br />
FRANCIS STORR.<br />
SIDNEY WEBB.<br />
DRAMATIC SUB-CoMMITTEE.<br />
MRS. ALEC TWEEDI E.<br />
MRS. HUMPHRY WARD.<br />
SIR CHARLES VILLIERS STANFORD,<br />
Mus: Doc.<br />
J. H. YoxALL, M.P.<br />
ARTHUR RACKHAM.<br />
M. H. SPIELMANN.<br />
Secretary—G. HERBERT THRING,<br />
; Solicitor int England to<br />
La Société des Gems de Lettres.<br />
COUNCIL.<br />
SIR ARTHUR CONAN DOYLE.<br />
A. W. DUBOURG.<br />
DOUGLAS FRESHFIELD.<br />
THE HON. MRS. ALFRED FELKIN<br />
(ELLEN THoRNEYCROFT FOWLER).<br />
SIR. W. S. GILBERT.<br />
EDMUND GOSSE, LL.D.<br />
SYDNEY GRUNDY.<br />
H. RIDER HAGGARD.<br />
THOMAS HARDY.<br />
MRs. HARRIson (“LUCAS MALET").<br />
ANTHONY HOPE HAWKINS,<br />
E. W. HORNUNG.<br />
MAURICE HEWLETT.<br />
JEROME K. J.EROMF.<br />
HENRY ARTHUR JONES.<br />
J. SCOTT KELTIE, LL.D.<br />
RUDYARD KIPLING.<br />
SIR EDWIN RAY LANKESTER, F.R.S.<br />
THE REV. W. J. LOFTIE, F.S.A.<br />
THE RIGHT HON. SIR ALFRED<br />
LYALL, P.C.<br />
LADY IUGARD<br />
SHAw).<br />
SIDNEY LEE.<br />
(MISS FLORA L.<br />
Chairman—MAURICE HEWLETT.<br />
| Douglas FRESHFIELD.<br />
SIDNEY LEE.<br />
ARTHUR RACKHAM.<br />
G. BERNARD SHAW.<br />
Chairman—A. W. PINERO.<br />
H. GRAN VILLE BARKER.<br />
J. M. BARRIE.<br />
R. C. CARTON.<br />
MISS CICELY HAMILTON.<br />
JEROME K. J.EROME.<br />
W. J. LOCKE.<br />
CAPT. ROBERT MARSHALL.<br />
CECII, RALEIGH.<br />
Vice-Chairman—HENRY ARTHUR JONES.<br />
G. BERNARD SH Aw.<br />
ALFRED SUTRO.<br />
PENSION FUND COMMITTEE.<br />
ANSTEY GUTHRIE.<br />
ANTHONY PHOPE HAWKINS,<br />
Chairman—MAURICE HEWLETT.<br />
MORLEY ROBERTS.<br />
M. H. SPIELMANN.<br />
COPYRIGHT STUE-COMMITTEE.<br />
HAROLD HAIRDY.<br />
ANTHONY HOPE HAWKINS,<br />
THE HON. JOHN COLLIER.<br />
SIR. W. MARTIN CONWAY.<br />
E. J. MACGILLIVRAY.<br />
SIR GILBERT PARKER, M.P.<br />
ART,<br />
JOHN HASSALL, R.I.<br />
J. G. MILLAIS.<br />
FIELD, ROSCOE & Co., 36, Lincoln's Inn Fields, W.C. * * *<br />
G. HERBERT THRING, 39, Old Queen Street, Storey's Gate, S.W. Solicitors.<br />
LAWRENCE GODKIN, 30, Pine Street, New York, U.S.A., Counsel in the United States.<br />
OFFICES.<br />
39, OLD QUEEN STREET, STOREY's GATE, S.W.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 229 (#289) ############################################<br />
<br />
C be El u t bor.<br />
(The Organ of the Incorporated Society of Authors. Monthly.)<br />
FOUNDED BY SIR WALTER BESANT.<br />
Vol. XIX—No. 9.<br />
JUNE 1ST, 1909.<br />
[PRICE SIXPENCE.<br />
TELEPHONE NUMBER :<br />
374 VICTORIA.<br />
TELEGRAPHIC ADDRESS :<br />
AUTORIDAD, LONDON.<br />
NOTICES.<br />
—º-º-e—<br />
OR the opinions expressed in papers that are<br />
signed or initialled the authors alone are<br />
responsible. None of the papers or para-<br />
graphs must be taken as expressing the opinion<br />
of the Committee unless such is especially stated<br />
to be the case.<br />
THE Editor begs to inform members of the<br />
Authors' Society and other readers of The Author<br />
that the cases which are quoted in The Author are<br />
cases that have come before the notice or to the<br />
knowledge of the Secretary of the Society, and that<br />
those members of the Society who desire to have<br />
the names of the publishers concerned can obtain<br />
them on application.<br />
—e—º-e—<br />
THE SOCIETY'S FUNDS.<br />
—º-º-º-<br />
ROM time to time members of the Society<br />
desire to make donations to its funds in<br />
recognition of work that has been done for<br />
them. The committee, acting on the suggestion<br />
of one of these members, have decided to place<br />
this permanent paragraph in The Author in order<br />
that members may be cognisant of those funds to<br />
which these contributions may be paid.<br />
The funds suitable for this purpose are : (1) The<br />
Capital Fund. This fund is kept in reserve in<br />
case it is necessary for the Society to incur heavy<br />
expenditure, either in fighting a question of prin-<br />
ciple, or in assisting to obtain copyright reform,<br />
WOL. XIX.<br />
or in dealing with any other matter closely<br />
connected with the work of the Society.<br />
(2) The Pension Fund. This fund is slowly<br />
increasing, and it is hoped will, in time, cover the<br />
needs of all the members of the Society.<br />
LIST OF MEMBERS.<br />
—º-º-º- -<br />
HE List of Members of the Society of Authors,<br />
published October, 1907, can now be obtained<br />
- at the offices of the Society at the price of<br />
6d., post free 7#d. It includes elections to July,<br />
1907, and will be sold to members and associates<br />
of the Society only.<br />
A dozen blank pages have been added at the<br />
end of the list for the convenience of those who<br />
desire to add future elections as they are chronicled<br />
from month to month in these pages.<br />
—e—sº-0—<br />
PENSION FUND.<br />
—º-º-º-<br />
N the 5th of February, 1909, the Trustees of<br />
the Pension Fund of the Society, after<br />
the secretary had placed before them the<br />
financial position of the Fund, decided to invest<br />
#350 in the purchase of Corporation of London<br />
2} per cent. Stock (1927–57).<br />
The amount purchased is £438 2s. 4d., and is<br />
added to the list printed below.<br />
The Trustees are glad to report that owing to<br />
the generous answer to the circular sent round at<br />
the end of 1908, they have been able to invest<br />
more than £100 over the amount invested last<br />
year.<br />
Consols 23%.............................. #1,000 0 0<br />
Local Loans .............................. 500 0 ()<br />
Victorian Government 3% Consoli-<br />
dated Inscribed Stock ............... 29] 19 11<br />
War Loan ................................. 201 9 3<br />
London and North-Western 3% Deben-<br />
ture Stock .............................. 250 0 (0.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 230 (#290) ############################################<br />
<br />
230<br />
TFIES A DITFIOR.<br />
Egyptian Government Irrigation<br />
Trust 4% Certificates ............... #3200<br />
Cape of Good Hope 3% Inscribed<br />
Stock ..... a • * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 200<br />
Glasgow and South-Western Railway<br />
4% Preference Stock.................. 228<br />
New Zealand 3;% Stock........... 247<br />
Jrish Land Act 23% Guaranteed Stock 258<br />
Corporation of London 24% Stock,<br />
1927—57<br />
* * * * * * * * * e º e º e s tº t → * * * * * * * * * * * *<br />
Subscriptions.<br />
1909.<br />
1, Twycross, Miss M. .<br />
2, Macquarie, Arthur .<br />
4, Sproston, Mrs. Stanley<br />
4, Phipson, Miss Emma<br />
4, Middlemass, Miss Jean<br />
4, Pott, J. A.<br />
4, Miller, Mrs. e<br />
7, Marchmont, A. W..<br />
7, Sharwood, T. S.<br />
12, Durand, Ralph<br />
12, Laing, Mrs. . º<br />
14, Banks, Mrs. M. M.<br />
14, Steel, Richard<br />
16, Garnett, Edward .<br />
16, Fenn, Frederick<br />
18, Hering, Henry A.<br />
18, Fox, Archibald D.<br />
31, Anon. . e &<br />
31, Kelly, W. P. º<br />
31, Cotes worth, Miss .<br />
1, Phillipps-Wolley, Clive .<br />
1, Dawson, Warrington<br />
4, Willard, Mrs. E. S.<br />
Feb. 19, Paget, Mrs. Gerald<br />
Feb. 20, Andrews, C. C.<br />
March 5, Speed, Lancelot<br />
March 8, Calderon, George &<br />
March 8, Jackson, C. S. . * e<br />
March 9, Young, Col. George F., C.B.<br />
March 10, Sullivan, Herbert ©<br />
March 11, Merritt, Mrs. Anna Lea<br />
March 22, Dale, T. F. º e<br />
April 13, Gask, Miss Lilian<br />
May 17, Rorison, Miss Edith<br />
Donations.<br />
1909.<br />
Jan. 1, Zangwill, Israel<br />
Jan. 1, Hamilton, John A. .<br />
Jan. 4, Stopford, Francis<br />
Jan. 4, Falmouth, The Wiscountess<br />
Jan. 4, Carrel, Frederick<br />
Jan. 4, Laws, T. C. . º<br />
Jan. 4, Abercrombie, Lascelles<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
I-<br />
.O()<br />
2<br />
1<br />
1<br />
i<br />
i<br />
5, Bradgate, Mrs.<br />
6, Leach, Henry<br />
6, Cullen, H. N. º º º<br />
6, Lyall, The Right Hon. Sir<br />
Alfred, P.C., etc.<br />
7, Underdown, Miss Emily<br />
8, Omond, T. S. e e<br />
8, Paternoster, G. Sidney<br />
9, Stockley, Mrs.<br />
9, Tanner, James T. .<br />
12, Tighe, Henry<br />
12, Aitken, Robert<br />
12, Bolton, Miss Anna<br />
14, Williamson, W. H.<br />
16, Furze, Miss Bessie<br />
16, Shirley, Arthur<br />
18, “Austin Clare’” .<br />
22, Williamson, Mrs. C. N.<br />
22, Williamson, C. N.<br />
23, Brown, R. Grant ,<br />
28, Raphael, Mrs. M. . º e<br />
4, Wilson, Miss Theodore Wilson<br />
4, Cousland, W. M. . © º<br />
4, Hardy, Thomas<br />
5, Bremner, Robert L.<br />
6, Todhunter, John<br />
6, Pettigrew, W. F.<br />
8, Russell, G. H. e<br />
8, Walker, Capt. J. H.<br />
8, Dutton, Miss Annie<br />
8, Baldwin, Mrs. Alfred<br />
11, Ainslie, Miss 4.<br />
11, Steward, Miss E. M.<br />
11, Rumble, Mrs.<br />
15, Beveridge, A. S.<br />
16, Toplis, Miss Grace<br />
19, Wilkinson, D.<br />
Feb. 24, Landa, Mrs. º<br />
Feb. 26, Fitz Gerald, Mrs. . e<br />
March 2, Tadema, Miss Laurence Alma<br />
March 2, Reynolds, Mrs. Baillie.<br />
March 4, Henry, Miss Alice<br />
March 4, Wilson, Edwin .<br />
March 5, Hardy, Harold .<br />
March 9, Crozier, Dr. Beattie<br />
March 9, Ross, Mrs. Janet<br />
March 15, Gregory, Lady . º<br />
March 31, Wizzari, Leopold de S.<br />
April 5, Burchell, Sidney H.<br />
April 15, Linton, C. Stuart<br />
April 19, Loraine, Lady . & -<br />
April 19, Durand, Sir Henry Mortimer<br />
April 20, Stephens, Riccardo<br />
May 24, Lefroy, Mrs. C. P.<br />
Jam.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Jan.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
Feb.<br />
º<br />
S<br />
º<br />
1<br />
i<br />
I1.<br />
;<br />
I<br />
I<br />
1<br />
The names of those subscribers and donors which<br />
are not included in the lists printed above are<br />
unavoidably held over to the July issue.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 231 (#291) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
231<br />
COMMITTEE NOTES.<br />
—o-º-º-<br />
HE May meeting of the committee was held<br />
at the offices of the society on the 10th.<br />
As Mr. Maurice Hewlett, the chairman for<br />
the year, was abroad, Sir Alfred Bateman was<br />
elected to the chair.<br />
After the minutes of the previous meeting had<br />
been signed, the chairman proposed a vote of<br />
thanks to the retiring chairman, Mr. Douglas<br />
Freshfield, for the work he had done for the<br />
Society during the period of his chairmanship. He<br />
reminded the members present that Mr. Freshfield,<br />
prior to the reconstitution of the society, had been<br />
chairman for two years, and had again taken that<br />
position when the reconstitution came into force<br />
last year. He stated how indebted the society had<br />
been to Mr. Freshfield for the labour he had so<br />
generously given to its affairs, and laid especial<br />
stress on its obligations to him for undertaking<br />
the duties after the critical period of the society’s<br />
reconstitution. The vote was passed unanimously.<br />
Seventeen members and associates were elected,<br />
bringing the total elections for the year up to 114.<br />
The list of names appears on another page. Six<br />
resignations brought the total of resignations up<br />
to 62.<br />
Mr. H. G. Wells was elected to the society's<br />
council.<br />
The next matter before the committee—one of<br />
great importance to novelists——was a statement of<br />
the result of the circular issued by the society in<br />
regard to cheap books. The committee decided to<br />
print the statement, which appears in another<br />
column. The list of those who have no objection<br />
to the publication of their names is also set out. In<br />
close connection with the subject of cheap editions,<br />
the committee discussed the question of new copy-<br />
right novels which it was proposed to issue at the<br />
price of 2s. They had received various letters<br />
from members of the society bearing on this point.<br />
After some slight discussion the whole question<br />
was referred to the sub-committee which had been<br />
appointed to deal with the cheap 7d. novel. As<br />
members may recollect, that sub-committee consists<br />
of Mr. Maurice Hewlett, Mr. Anthony Hope<br />
Hawkins, and Mr. Bernard Shaw. It is hoped<br />
that their report will be ready for the next meeting<br />
of the committee.<br />
The committee next discussed the question<br />
contained in Mr. H. G. Wells' letter in the April<br />
issue of The Author, referring to authors’<br />
agents and insurance, and the secretary was<br />
instructed to make enquiries in the matter and<br />
report to the next meeting of the committee.<br />
Owing to one or two objections having been<br />
raised to the publication of the names of the<br />
Society's pensioners, and the amounts which they<br />
received, the committee went into the matter very<br />
fully, but came to the conclusion that it was only<br />
fair to the subscribers to the fund, as well as to<br />
members of the society who might in the future<br />
become subscribers, that this information should<br />
appear in The Author. -<br />
The secretary reported the action of the copy-<br />
right sub-committee which had met during the past<br />
month, and the desire expressed by that committee<br />
that the chairman of the Committee of Management,<br />
Mr. Maurice Hewlett, should, if necessary, give<br />
evidence before the departmental committee. He<br />
also reported the receipt of a letter from the<br />
Secretary of the departmental committee as to the<br />
points on which they desired evidence to be given.<br />
It was decided that the proofs which had been<br />
prepared by the copyright and dramatic sub-com-<br />
mittees should be sent in together with the names<br />
of those whom the society would suggest as wit-<br />
IłęSSéS.<br />
The committee decided, also, that the report<br />
of the action taken by the committee during the<br />
past year to assist the cause of copyright, which<br />
was to be laid before the Council in June, should be<br />
drafted by the Secretary subject to the approval of<br />
the chairman.<br />
The secretary reported that he had heard from<br />
the solicitors of Miss Alice Sargant, who had, for<br />
many years, been a member of the Society, that<br />
she had left a legacy to the Pension Fund of the<br />
society of all her copyrights and interests in her<br />
published books. The committee requested the<br />
secretary to make further inquiries and to report<br />
to the next meeting.<br />
Members of the society may remember that the<br />
question of Colonial sales was raised at the last<br />
meeting, and the Publishers' Association was com-<br />
municated with. From the answer of the Associa-<br />
tion, laid before the committee, it appeared that<br />
the publishers had appointed a small sub-committee<br />
to meet the Authors’ Society in order to discuss<br />
the situation. The matter was referred to the sub-<br />
committee which had already been appointed for<br />
the consideration of the question of cheap books.<br />
The secretary reported the action taken by the<br />
Dramatic Sub-Committee at their last meeting, and<br />
it was decided to send a notice to the papers of<br />
their approval of Mr. R. Vernon Harcourt's Music<br />
Halls and Theatres Bill.<br />
The secretary then asked for an authority to<br />
require the payment on dinner tickets from those<br />
who did not return them within a reasonable time.<br />
The committee decided that all dinner tickets<br />
returned to the secretary within four days of the<br />
date of the dinner should be paid for, and authorised<br />
the secretary to demand payment for those tickets<br />
which had only been returned on the day of the<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 232 (#292) ############################################<br />
<br />
232<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
dinner in the present year. It would obviously be<br />
impossible to organise satisfactorily a big dinner<br />
such as the society's annual function, if every<br />
member who had asked for a ticket claimed the<br />
right to return it without payment, one, two, or<br />
three days before the dinner. The committee have<br />
fixed four days as a reasonable limit.<br />
The committee then turned their attention to<br />
the legal cases which they were asked to support.<br />
Of the four cases considered, the first—a question<br />
of the infringement of an author's rights in Den-<br />
mark—the committee decided to take up and<br />
carry through the Danish courts if necessary.<br />
The second the committee felt bound to refuse as<br />
there appeared to be no legal cause of action.<br />
This view was supported by the solicitors of the<br />
society. The third case, the secretary reported,<br />
had been withdrawn that morning, as the matter<br />
had been settled in favour of the author. The<br />
fourth case, against the editor of a magazine, the<br />
committee decided to take up.<br />
The committee instructed the secretary to re-<br />
draft the prospectus of the Society and to submit<br />
it to the next meeting.<br />
Sundry letters from members were placed before<br />
the committee and considered.<br />
The committee decided to send an official letter,<br />
signed by the chairman of the society, to Mr.<br />
Thorvald Solberg, Registrar of Copyrights at<br />
Washington, to express their appreciation of his<br />
efforts towards the promotion of better American<br />
copyright legislation.<br />
—e—º-e—<br />
DRAMATIC COMMITTEE.<br />
I.<br />
A MEETING of the Dramatic Sub-Committee of<br />
the Society of Authors was held at the offices<br />
of the society on Tuesday, May 4. The first<br />
business of the meeting was to elect a chairman<br />
for the current year. On the proposal of Mr. Cecil<br />
Raleigh, seconded by Mr. Henry Arthur Jones,<br />
Mr. A. W. Pinero was elected chairman, and on<br />
the proposal of Mr. Alfred Sutro, seconded by Mr.<br />
R. C. Carton, Mr. Henry Arthur Jones was elected<br />
to the post of vice-chairman.<br />
After the minutes had been read and signed, the<br />
secretary laid before the meeting a formal proof of<br />
the notes which had been passed at the last meet-<br />
ing. This proof embodied those points dealing<br />
with the alteration of the law as it affected dramatic<br />
authorship, which the committee desired should<br />
be laid before the Departmental Committee now<br />
sitting on the Berlin Convention. The proof was<br />
formally approved by the committee. The secre-<br />
tary then reported that Mr. Grundy had been<br />
their consideration.<br />
unable to undertake the duty of giving evidence<br />
before that committee, and that from Mr. Comyns<br />
Carr he had not, as yet, received a final answer.<br />
As the chairman represented that owing to urgent<br />
private reasons he would be unable to give evidence,<br />
at the request of the committee Mr. Bernard Shaw<br />
stated that he would undertake the duty if required<br />
to do so.<br />
The next matter before the committee was the<br />
consideration of the Theatres and Music Halls<br />
Bill, Mr. Cecil Raleigh, who had taken great<br />
interest in and had made a close study of the<br />
Bill, explained at length to the committee all the<br />
points which it covered and their bearing on<br />
dramatic authorship. Considerable discussion<br />
ensued. As a result two points presented them-<br />
selves for the final approval of the committee.<br />
The first, whether the committee was in favour of<br />
free trade in amusements. The second, whether<br />
the office of Censor of Plays should be abolished,<br />
and the power of licensing theatres and music<br />
halls be left entirely to the county authorities,<br />
subject to the clauses of the Bill set forth.<br />
The committee unanimously agreed to the first<br />
point. Proposed by Mr. Cecil Raleigh and seconded<br />
by Mr. R. C. Carton, the second point was carried<br />
776/77. C07?). r<br />
As the discussion of these important matters<br />
had taken a considerable time, it was decided that<br />
the other questions before the committee—the<br />
Managers' Treaty and the Dramatic Pamphlet–<br />
should be adjourned to the next meeting.<br />
II.<br />
A MEETING of the Dramatic Sub-Committee<br />
was held on Thursday, May 20, at the Society's<br />
office, to consider the various questions ad-<br />
journed from the former meeting. After the<br />
minutes had been read and signed the Secretary<br />
reported that the appeal lodged by the society<br />
on behalf of Mr. Frederick Fenn in the case<br />
of Scholz v. Amasis, Ltd., had been successful,<br />
the judgment of the three judges of the Appeal<br />
Court being unanimous. The Dramatic Com-<br />
mittee congratulated the society on the result of<br />
its efforts in this case.<br />
The Managers' Treaty and the Dramatic<br />
Pamphlet then came before the committee for<br />
Mr. Shaw made a long<br />
statement explaining the difference between the<br />
two documents and the work the former Committee<br />
during the past years had expended upon them.<br />
It was decided, after some discussion, that the<br />
Dramatic Pamphlet should be taken first and<br />
finally settled before the Managers' Treaty, Was<br />
discussed. Accordingly Mr. Pinero, as chair-<br />
man, began the reading through of the Dramatic<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 233 (#293) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
Pamphlet, and the clauses in the first agreement<br />
which it contained were discussed one by one.<br />
The substance of the treatise was fully con-<br />
sidered. The secretary described the basis on<br />
which it had been drafted, and the reasons for<br />
its being put forward in the present shape. The<br />
committee were only able in the time at their<br />
disposal to get through a few of the clauses of<br />
the first agreement, and the matter was further<br />
adjourned to the next meeting, which will be held<br />
this month.<br />
The committee trust to be able to settle the<br />
final form of the Pamphlet and to put it before the<br />
dramatic members of the Society in the autumn.<br />
—e-C-6–<br />
COPYRIGHT COMMITTEE.<br />
A MEETING of the Copyright Committee was held<br />
at the offices of the society on Tuesday, May 18.<br />
After the minutes of the previous meeting had<br />
been read and signed, the final proof of Mr. Mac-<br />
Gillivray's evidence was laid before the committee<br />
and, after some discussion, was accepted. The<br />
secretary then read to the committee letters received<br />
from the Departmental Committee, and was in-<br />
structed to write to those members of the society who<br />
had promised to give evidence, informing them of the<br />
contents of the letters, of the dates when they<br />
might be called, and the evidence they would be<br />
required to give. r f<br />
The secretary reported that he had already<br />
despatched the proofs to the Departmental Com-<br />
mittee. - -<br />
The next question before the committee was a<br />
small Bill drafted by Mr. E. J. MacGillivray, at the<br />
suggestion of Sir Charles Williers Stanford, for the<br />
protection of musical composers. After considera-<br />
tion, the committee thought it would be best that<br />
the matter should be referred to the Committee of<br />
Management to inquire whether the committee<br />
would be ready to support the principles contained<br />
in the Bill. -<br />
: - - - —t-sº-º-<br />
Cases.<br />
SINCE the last issue of The Author nine cases<br />
have been in the hands of the secretary. The first<br />
was a claim against a publisher for the infringe-<br />
ment of an author's rights. This has been<br />
settled. The position has been explained and the<br />
author advised as to the course which he should<br />
take. There have been four cases for the recovery<br />
of money. In three of these the money has come<br />
to hand and been forwarded to the author. The<br />
last has only just come into the office for settle-<br />
ment. There were four cases for the recovery of<br />
MSS. One has been successful, and the three<br />
remaining are still in course of negotiation.<br />
Only two cases remain open from former months.<br />
One is a case of infringement of copyright in New<br />
Zealand. In this case a reply has been received<br />
from the infringer, who is asking for a settlement<br />
on lower terms than those asked for by the society.<br />
The other is a difficult case in connection with<br />
a press-cutting agency. It may be worth while to<br />
mention here that authors should be very careful of<br />
their dealings with press-cutting agents. No press-<br />
cutting agent is absolutely perfect, or will supply<br />
the author with everything that he desires, but<br />
Some agents take the fee, supply a few cuttings and<br />
nothing more, and the author, who may have know-<br />
ledge that his book has been reviewed in many<br />
quarters, finds that the fee has been paid in vain.<br />
Authors should be warned to be extremely careful<br />
to what press-cutting agency they contribute, and<br />
should never subscribe without obtaining advice in<br />
the first instance as to the position and reliability<br />
of the agent.<br />
The secretary has to report the settlement of one<br />
case of infringement where the full amount asked for<br />
has been paid through the society's solicitors in<br />
Spain, and one case of infringement in New Zealand,<br />
where the sum asked has also been received. - -<br />
Three other matters in the hands of the society's<br />
solicitors have been settled satisfactorily.<br />
—t-º-º-<br />
May Elections. s<br />
Wade-<br />
Argyll-Saxby, A., M.A., “Brooklyn,”<br />
F.R.G.S., etc. (Argyll- bridge, Cornwall.<br />
Sawby). - .<br />
Baines, Lady * Kidlington, Oxon.<br />
Barnard, Edmund 50, Erpingham Road,<br />
George, M.A. Putney, S.W.<br />
Cook, Mrs. Thornton 45, Finsbury Square,<br />
(Maorilanda). E.C. -<br />
Ferguson, J. C. M. G. .<br />
Fleurot, George G.<br />
Gerrard, Mrs. Edith C.<br />
Lambert,<br />
(Mrs.).<br />
Lubbock, Mrs. Monta-<br />
gue.<br />
McEwen, John B.<br />
O’Brien, The<br />
Georgima.<br />
Agnes H.<br />
Hon.<br />
Rorison, Edith S. . •<br />
Schwarz, Prof. Ernest,<br />
H.L.<br />
Southfield House, Wat-<br />
ford, Herts.<br />
17, Avenue Montaigne,<br />
Paris.<br />
Glenburnie,<br />
N. Devon.<br />
Fairlawn House, Wood-<br />
manstern, Surrey.<br />
127, Mount Street,<br />
Berkeley Square, W.<br />
The Doon, Pinner.<br />
Bideford,<br />
The Deanery, Perth,<br />
N.B.<br />
Box 116, Grahamstown,<br />
S. Africa. -<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 234 (#294) ############################################<br />
<br />
234<br />
THE Arra HoR.<br />
Sheeby-Skeffington, 11, Grosvenor Place,<br />
Francis. Rathmines, Dublin.<br />
30, Philbeach Gardens,<br />
Earl's Court, S.W.<br />
Williams, Mrs. Leonora 4, Whitehall Court,<br />
Bruce. S.W.<br />
(One member does not desire publication of his<br />
name or address.)<br />
Shillingford, Osmond .<br />
—e—º-e—<br />
BOOKS PUBLISHED BY MEMBERS OF<br />
THE SOCIETY.<br />
—º-º-e—<br />
WHILE every effort is made by the compilers to keep<br />
this list as accurate and as exhaustive as possible, they have<br />
some difficulty in attaining this object owing to the fact<br />
that many of the books mentioned are not sent to the office<br />
by the members. In consequence, it is necessary to rely<br />
largely upon lists of books which appear in literary and<br />
other papers.<br />
co-operate in the compiling of this list and, by sending<br />
particulars of their works, help to make it substantially<br />
accurate.<br />
ASTRONOMICAI).<br />
FARTHEST SouTH. By E. E. MIDDLETON, Tower House,<br />
St. Matthew's Gardens, St. Leonards-on-Sea. 1d.<br />
It is hoped, however, that members will<br />
THE WAR OF THE SPANISH SUCCESSION, 94 pp.<br />
DEFOE : CAPTAIN SINGLETON's EARLY ADVENTURES.<br />
126 pp. (Blackie's English Texts.) Edited by W. H. D.<br />
ROUSE. 63 × 23. Blackie. 6d. each.<br />
AN ENGLISH CHURGH HISTORY FOR CHILDREN. By MARY”<br />
E. SHIPLEY, With Preface by THE BISHOP OF<br />
GIBRALTAR. 339 pp. Methuen & Co.<br />
ENGINEERING,<br />
ENGINEERING WONDERS OF THE WoRLD. Edited by<br />
A: WILLIAMS. Part I, 11 × 8%. 64 pp. Nelson.<br />
7d. m.<br />
FICTION.<br />
ROSE OF THE WILDERNESs. By S. R. CRoCKETT. 8 × 54.<br />
336 pp. Hodder & Stoughton, 6s.<br />
AN IMPENDING SWORD : An Adventure by the Sea. By<br />
HORACE ANNESLEY WACHELL. 74 × 5, 186 pp.<br />
Murray. 2s. 6d. n.<br />
THE SHOW GIRL. By MAX PEMBERTON. 8 × 5. 343 pp.<br />
Cassell. 6s.<br />
THE GIRL IN THE BLUE DRESS. By RICHARD MARSH.<br />
7; X 5. 318 pp. John Long, 6s.<br />
GERVASE. By MABEL DEARMER.<br />
Macmillan. 6s.<br />
JEANNE OF THE MARSHIES. By B. PHILLIPS OPPENHEIM.<br />
7# × 5. 320 pp. Ward Lock. 6s.<br />
SET IN. SILVER, By C. N. WILLIAMSON and A. M.<br />
WILLIAMSON. 73 × 5. 445 pp. Methuen. 6s.<br />
SAMSON UNSHORN. By REGINALD TURNER. 73 × 5.<br />
371 pp. Chapman & Hall. 68. .<br />
THE RED SAINT. By WARWICK DEEPING, 8 x 5. 376 pp.<br />
Cassell. 6s. -<br />
THE WREATHED DAGGER. By MARGARET YouNG. 8 ×<br />
5. 340 pp. Cassell. 6s.<br />
THE STRANGE DISAPPEARANCE OF JOHN HAVERSBAM.<br />
7# × 53.<br />
443 pp.<br />
By IZA DUFFUS HARDY. 74 × 5. 320 pp. Digby<br />
Long. 6s.<br />
“MEG OF THE SALT-PANs.” By MAY ALDINGTON. 8 × 5.<br />
320 pp. Everett. 63.<br />
THE TEARS OF DESIRE. By Cora LIE STANTON and<br />
HEATH HOSKEN. 73, x 5. 324 pp. Werner Laurie.<br />
68.<br />
TOM GENUFLEX. By JANE Rowl,AND (“Aunt Cherry.”)<br />
7; X 5. 288 pp. Ouseley. 6s. .<br />
EMMA HAMILTON : THE TARIFF REFORMER. By<br />
WINIFRED GRAHAM. 84 × 5%. 128 pp. Digby<br />
Long. 6d.<br />
BARBARY SHEEP. By ROBERT HICHENs. 73 × 53.<br />
236 pp. Methuen. 3s. 6d.<br />
PRISCILLA OF THE GooD INTENT. By HALLIWELL<br />
SUTCLIFFE. 73 × 5. 332 pp. Smith Elder. 68.<br />
THE SHUTTLES OF THE LOOM. By K. M. EDGE. (MRs.<br />
C. T. CAULEEILD). 7% x 5. 343 pp. Murray. 6s.<br />
BIOGRAPHY.<br />
FAIR WOMEN AT FONTAINEBLEAU.<br />
Eveleigh Nash. 15s. n.<br />
THE LIFE OF MAJOR-GENERAL SIR JOHN ARDAG.H. By<br />
his WIFE, SUSAN COUNTESS OF MALMESBURY (Lady<br />
Ardagh). With portraits and illustrations from drawings<br />
by Sir John Ardagh. 9 × 53. 479 pp. Murray.<br />
158. In.<br />
By FRANK HAMEL.<br />
BOOKS FOR THE YOUNG.<br />
THE BIOGRAPHY OF A SILVER-FOX, OR DOMINO REYNARD<br />
OF GoLDEN Town. By E. T. SETON. 8 × 6. 209 pp.<br />
Constable. 5s. n.<br />
BOOKS OF REFERENCE.<br />
DICTIONARY or NATIONAL Biography. Edited by<br />
SIDNEY LEE. New Edition. Vol. 15. Oatens—Pockrich.<br />
93 × 64. 1,352 pp. Smith Elder. 153.<br />
DRAMA.<br />
THE FEUD : A Play in Three Acts. By EDWARD GARNETT.<br />
7+ x 4%. 67 pp. A. H. Bullen. 18. n.<br />
ECONOMICS.<br />
THE INDUSTRIAL SYSTEM. AN INQUIRY INTO EARNED<br />
AND UNEARNED INCOME. By J. A. Hobson.<br />
328 pp. Longmans. 7s. 6d. n.<br />
MAKERS OF OUR CLOTHES : A Case for Trade Boards.<br />
By MRs. CARL MEYER and CLEMENTINA BLACK. 94.<br />
× 53. 304 pp. Duckworth. 58. n.<br />
EDUCATION.<br />
PRINCIPLES AND METHODS OF UNIVERSITY REFORM :<br />
Being a Letter Addressed to the University of Oxford.<br />
By LoRD CURZON OF KEDLESTON, Chancellor of the<br />
University. 9 × 53. 220 pp. Oxford : Clarendon Press.<br />
London : Frowde. 2s. 6d. n.<br />
LORD MACAULAY : ESSAY ON JOHN HAMPDEN, 94 pp.<br />
ESSAY ON SIR WILLIAM TEMPLE, 125 pp. ESSAY ON<br />
93 × 6.<br />
PETER HOMUNCULUs, T8y GILBERT CANNAN. 73 × 53.<br />
327 pp. Heinemann. 6s.<br />
BEYOND. By F. T. BULLEN. 73 × 5. 310 pp. Chapman<br />
& Hall. 6s.<br />
FHEALTH.<br />
120 YEARS OF LIFE, AND How To ATTAIN THEM. By<br />
CHARLES REINHARDT, M.D. 50 pp. London Publicity<br />
Co., 379, Strand, W.C. 1s.<br />
LITERARY,<br />
DANTE IN ENGLISH LITERATURE. FROM CHAUCER TO.<br />
CARY (c. 1880-1844). By PAGET TOYNBEE. Two.<br />
volumes. 9 × 53. 638 + 757 pp. Methuen. 218. m.<br />
IENGLISH LITERATURE IN THE NINETEENTH CENTURY.<br />
By LAURIE MAGNUs. 409 pp. Andrew Melrose,<br />
7s. 6d. n.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 235 (#295) ############################################<br />
<br />
TRIE AUTISIOR,<br />
235<br />
LONDON'S LURE : An Anthology in Prose and Verse. By<br />
HELEN and LEWIS MELVILLE. 64 × 4}. 328 pp.<br />
Bell. 3s.6d. n.<br />
MILITARY.<br />
BRITISH MILITARY PRINTs. By RALPH NEVILL.<br />
11 × 8%. 72 pp. The Connoisseur Publishing Co.<br />
MISCELLANEOUS,<br />
SELECT READINGS AND RECITATIONs: Adapted and<br />
arranged for the Class-room, the Drawing-room and the<br />
Platform. By J. Forsyth. 74 × 5. 200 pp. Paisley:<br />
Gardner.<br />
MUSIC.<br />
MUSICAL MONSTROSITIES. By C. I. GRAVES. Illustrated<br />
by GEORGE MoRRow. 7 × 43. 217 pp, Sir Isaac<br />
Pitman. 13. n.<br />
ORIENTAL.<br />
THE INDIAN CRAFTSMAN. By A. K. CoomfARASWAMY'<br />
D.Sc. 73 × 5%. 130 pp. Probsthain. 3s.6d. m.<br />
PHILOSOPHY.<br />
BEYOND GOOD AND EVIL: Prelude to a Philosophy of the<br />
JFuture. By NIETZSCHE. Translated by HELEN<br />
ZIMMERN. 8 × 5+. 268 pp. Foulis. 3s.6d. n.<br />
SCIENCE.<br />
£ARENTHOOD AND RACE CULTURE : An Outline in<br />
Eugenics. By C. W. SALEEBY, M.D. 9} x 6. 331 pp.<br />
Cassell. 7s. 6d. m.<br />
THE ETHER OF SPACE. By SIR OLIVER LODGE, F.R.S.<br />
73 × 4%. 156 pp. Harper. 2s. 6d.<br />
THEOLOGY.<br />
ORIGIN AND FAITH. AN ESSAY OF RECONCILIATION. By<br />
J. COMPTON-RICKETT. 83 × 5%. 272 pp. Hodder &<br />
Stoughton. 6s. -<br />
TOPOGRAPHY.<br />
THE HEART OF SCOTLAND. Painted by SUTTON PALMER.<br />
Described by A. R. HoPE MONCRIEFF. 104 × 7#.<br />
206 pp. Black. 7s.6d. n.<br />
ESSEX. Painted by L. BURLEIGH BRUHL, A.R.C.A.<br />
Described by A. R. HoPE MonCRIEFF. 9 × 64. 262 pp.<br />
Black. 20s. n.<br />
MEMORIALS OF OED LANCASHIRE. Edited by LIEUT.-COL.<br />
FISHWICK and the REV. P. H. DITCHFIELD. Two<br />
Wols. 9 × 6. 286 -– 314 pp. (MEMORIALS OF<br />
THE COUNTIES OF ENGLAND. General Editor, REV.<br />
P. H. DITCHFIELD, F.S.A., &c.). Bemrose. 25s. n.<br />
TRAVEL.<br />
THE BRETONS AT HOME. By FRANCES M. GOSTLING.<br />
With an Introduction by ANATOLE LE BRAY.<br />
304 pp. Methuen. 10s. 6d. n.<br />
QUAINT SUBJECTS OF THE KING. By JOHN FOSTER<br />
FRASER. 73 x 5. 304 pp. Cassell. 68.<br />
9 x 5%.<br />
—e—º-e—<br />
LITERARY, DRAMATIC, AND MUSICAL<br />
NOTES.<br />
—e-e–<br />
BIOGRAPHY.<br />
- R. C. R. HAINES has published, through<br />
Messrs. Barnicott & Pearce, a little volume<br />
on “Joan of Arc.” The object of the book<br />
is ethical rather than purely historical, though the<br />
Writer has endeavoured at the same time to be<br />
perfectly accurate and impartial.<br />
HEALTH.<br />
“120 Years of Life and How to Attain Them,”<br />
by Dr. Charles Reinhardt, is a treatise upon the<br />
use of lactic ferments for the prevention and cure<br />
of disease and the prolongation of life. The book<br />
is published by the London Publicity Company of<br />
379, Strand, W.C.<br />
EDUCATIONAL.<br />
Miss Mary E. Shipley’s “English Church His-<br />
tory for Children, A.D. 1066–1500,” published by<br />
Messrs. Methuen & Co., contains a preface by the<br />
Bishop of Gibraltar, William Edward Collins, D.D.<br />
The present work is a companion volume to Miss<br />
Shipley's first volume on “English Church History<br />
for Children,” and the reader is carried from the<br />
Norman Conquest to the eve of the Reformation.<br />
Twelve illustrations and one map have been<br />
included in the work, which contains also an index.<br />
Mr. Andrew Melrose has recently issued Mr.<br />
Taurie Magnus' book dealing with “English Litera-<br />
ture in the Nineteenth Century.” The author states,<br />
in a preface to the work, that he has attempted to<br />
present rather a survey of English literature as a<br />
whole than a history of that literature between<br />
1784 and the present day. There is an index to<br />
the book. -<br />
A new edition of “The Children's Study’”<br />
History of France, of which Miss Mary C. Rowsell is<br />
the author, has just been issued by Mr. Fisher<br />
Unwin. The edition is published at 1s. 6d.<br />
Mr. Ferrar Fenton has in the printers' hands an<br />
eighth edition of his modern English version of the<br />
New Testament. This edition, in paper covers, is<br />
published at 1s. Over 74,000 copies of Mr.<br />
Fenton’s “Complete Bible in Modern English ’’<br />
have left the press.<br />
FICTION.<br />
“The Tears of Desire” is the title of a new<br />
novel by Coralie Stanton and Heath Hosken, which<br />
Mr. Werner Laurie issued last month.<br />
K. M. Edge, the author of “Ahana,” has just<br />
published, through Mr. John Murray, “The<br />
Shuttles of the Loom,” a novel which deals with<br />
the life and work of a forest officer in Southern<br />
India. It is concerned with the claim made upon<br />
India by those who serve her faithfully. The life<br />
of the hero contains elements of tragedy, but the<br />
author shows the place which these elements have<br />
in the scheme of things evolved by the “Fixed<br />
Power for Good" that moves towards ultimate<br />
perfection.<br />
Robert Aitken's new volume of short stories,<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 236 (#296) ############################################<br />
<br />
236<br />
TISIES A UTEIOR.<br />
which Mr. John Murray recently issued here, has<br />
been published in America by Mr. B. W. Huebsch.<br />
Mr. Harold Wintle's new novel, “The Waking<br />
Hour,” will shortly be published by Mr. Fisher<br />
Unwin. -<br />
Mrs. Fred Reynolds' new book, which Messrs.<br />
Hurst & Blackett are publishing, is entitled<br />
“The Lady in Grey,” and, like her previous novel,<br />
“S. David of the Dust,” has its setting in the<br />
heart of Wales amongst the Welsh people.<br />
Messrs. Alston Rivers' announcements include<br />
new novels from the following members of our<br />
society : Marjorie Bowen, E. Nesbit, Eva Lath-<br />
bury, and Mrs. Havelock Ellis.<br />
Miss Bowen's tale, “Black Magic,” is described<br />
as mediaeval and picaresque, and has to do with<br />
the rise and fall of antichrist. The opening<br />
scenes are laid in Flanders, whence a journey<br />
is made to Frankfort and on to Rome, Many<br />
strange adventures, from which the distinctive<br />
violence of the period is rarely absent, befall the<br />
wanderers with whom the story is concerned.<br />
“Salome and the Head”—the story by which<br />
E. Nesbit is represented — has for its heroine<br />
a famous dancer who attracts a young officer on<br />
the point of leaving England for foreign service.<br />
On his return, after some years' absence, he finds<br />
her firmly established in London as a dancer.<br />
The complications on which the story turns are<br />
consequent upon a rather eccentric education<br />
which has left her involved in relations with<br />
another man, and the story culminates in a strange<br />
crime with a no less strange dénouement.<br />
Miss Lathbury's novel is called “The Desert<br />
Island.” We have received no information from<br />
the publishers respecting this book, but Miss<br />
Lathbury will be remembered as the author of<br />
two others published, we believe, by the same<br />
firm, “Mr. Meyer's People” and “The People<br />
Downstairs.”<br />
“Attainment,” Mrs. Havelock Ellis' first attempt<br />
at a long novel, is a story founded on experi-<br />
ments Socialistic, philanthropic, and realistic, and<br />
points to the value of a natural life in every<br />
respect.<br />
“Lords of the Sea,” which Messrs. Methuen &<br />
Co. will publish at six shillings on August 12, is<br />
a new novel by Mr. Edward Noble, written round<br />
the life of a shipowner who has climbed from small<br />
beginnings to greatness through the operation of a<br />
transaction which is now known as P.P.I. in the<br />
shipping world and elsewhere ; of the stress he<br />
endures in consequence, and the manner in which<br />
he faces it, together with an incident which grows<br />
from other actions committed in early youth. The<br />
first and last Sections of the book are laid on board<br />
the Atlantic “flyer,” the Mauretania.<br />
“The Lady Calphurnia Royal” is the title of a<br />
book which Messrs. Mills & Boon are to publish in<br />
June. Mr. Albert Dorrington, who wrote it in<br />
collaboration with A. G. Stephens, late of the<br />
S/dney Bulletºn, journeyed from Rockhampton in<br />
a three-quarter deck yacht, in 1906, to the French<br />
penal settlement of Ile Nou, in order to obtain local<br />
colour and impressions. A big half of the book<br />
deals with convict life in and around Noumea.<br />
The rest contains a very close study of Australian<br />
life and conditions on a big cattle station “outback.”<br />
In spite of her long and severe illness last year,<br />
Miss R. N. Carey has completed a novel entitled<br />
“The King of the Unknown,” which will be issued<br />
as usual in September by Messrs. Macmillan &<br />
Co., and simultaneously in America by Messrs.<br />
Lippincott.<br />
Mr. John Long will publish early this month a<br />
new novel by Mr. Henry Tighe, entitled “The<br />
Four Candles.” The story opens, and for three-<br />
quarters of the book remains, in a prospector's<br />
Valley in Australia, and the circumstances of such<br />
isolation creates the theme of the book, in which<br />
four candles play, an important part in deciding<br />
who shall take the heroine to wife—since her<br />
husband and child have both died in the pro-<br />
Spector's camp. The result of this act to the hero.<br />
and to the Woman is told in detail. -<br />
“Peggy Gainsborough,” Miss Emily Baker's<br />
new book, published this month by Mr. Francis<br />
Griffiths, is a story of the great painter's daughter<br />
and the times in which she lived. The illustra-<br />
tions are from portraits and pictures by Thomas<br />
Gainsborough, R.A.<br />
Messrs. Milner & Co., of 15A, Paternoster Row,<br />
are the publishers of two plays for children by<br />
Miss L. Budgen. The plays are “Hay Time,” a<br />
cantata with action, and “Winter,” a little action<br />
play for children. Both plays are published at<br />
threepence.<br />
MISCELLANEOUS.<br />
Sir Isaac Pitman & Sons, Ltd., are the publishers<br />
of “Musical Monstrosities,” being the collected<br />
articles which Mr. C. L. Graves has contributed<br />
at intervals, dealing with the atrocities committed<br />
in the musical world. Mr. George Morrow has<br />
illustrated the work.<br />
“Glimpses of Hidden India’’ is a new book by<br />
John Law, published by Messrs. Thacker & Co.<br />
Among the aspects of Indian life which are dealt<br />
with may be mentioned Hindu lawyers, modern<br />
Calcutta, the Hindu student, marriage and women,<br />
Indian progress on western lines, and editors and<br />
newspapers. s<br />
Messrs. Black in their series of colour books,<br />
which already includes several on gardens, have<br />
found room for another on “Dutch Bulbs and<br />
Gardens,” in which three ladies collaborate, Miss<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 237 (#297) ############################################<br />
<br />
TISIES A UTFIOR.<br />
237<br />
Mima Nixon as artist, and the Misses Una<br />
Silberrad and Sophie Lyall as authors. -<br />
NAVAL. -<br />
The 1909 edition of Jane’s “Fighting Ships” is<br />
announced to appear early this month. Mr. Jane has<br />
succeeded in securing plans of the German Dread-<br />
noughts, including those of which the Government<br />
has just confessed complete ignorance. There are<br />
altogether three distinct types of German Dread-<br />
noughts building. The latest designs for German<br />
Dreadnought cruisers are also given, including the<br />
famous “Von der Taun.” The new edition con-<br />
tains a variety of other improvements and additions.<br />
A point of interest in connection with Part 2 is<br />
that Commander Hovgaard, the famous Danish-<br />
American expert on ship design, has joined the staff<br />
of “Fighting Ships,” and contributes for the 1909<br />
edition an article on underwater protection against<br />
torpedoes. Mr. Charles de Grave Sells, M.Inst.C.E.,<br />
deals with the progress of warship engineering.<br />
THEOLOGICAL.<br />
We have received a copy of the second edition of<br />
“A Commentary on the Holy Bible,” which has<br />
been produced by Messrs. Macmillan & Co. under<br />
the editorship of the Rev. J. R. Dummelow. The<br />
object of the originators of the work has been to<br />
make clear to the reader many of the circumstances<br />
under which the various books of the Bible were<br />
composed, to present a clear statement of the<br />
mental habits of the people to whom they were<br />
addressed, and to indicate the actual needs which<br />
they were designed to meet. Introductions and<br />
notes have been supplied to the various books with<br />
a view to explaining the principal difficulties,<br />
textual, moral or doctrinal, which may arise in con-<br />
nection with them.<br />
Messrs. Mowbray announce an edition of 50,000<br />
copies of the Rev. Percy Dearmer's work, “Every-<br />
man’s History of the English Church.” Mr.<br />
Dearmer is also publishing this month, through<br />
Messrs. Pitmans, a volume entitled “Body and<br />
Soul,” which traces the practice of faith healing<br />
from the early Church downwards through the<br />
works of the saints, and healings at famous shrines<br />
down to the new developments in our scientific age.<br />
POETRY.<br />
“The Red King's Dream,” and other poems, by<br />
E. M. Rutherford, is a collection of pieces, many of<br />
which have been published already in various<br />
magazines. Mr. Henry Drane is the publisher.<br />
DRAMATIC.<br />
A statutory performance on April 30, at<br />
the Bijou Theatre, was given of Mr. Melchior<br />
MacBride's mystery play, “The Story of Glaston-<br />
bury and the Grail.” The work deals with the<br />
arrival in England of Joseph of Arimathea and his<br />
party, bearing the Grail and other emblems of<br />
Christianity; with their reception by the Druids;<br />
with the adoption of Christianity in Britain. The<br />
reading was directed by Mr. Geoffrey Besant, who<br />
was assisted by Miss Gertrude Bibby; Mrs. Edward<br />
Stirling, as Gladys (the chief Druidess), and the<br />
Arch-Druid Cymnitin, Mr. A. F. Jones, Miss<br />
Margaret Hardy, and others.<br />
Mr. A. E. W. Mason's comedy “Colonel Smith ”<br />
was produced at the St. James’ on April 23. The<br />
play is based on the action of a young lady who<br />
invents a lover as the speediest means of obtaining<br />
one, and shows the measure of success which<br />
attended her deception. The cast included Miss<br />
Irene Wamburgh, Mr. George Alexander, and Mr.<br />
William Farren.<br />
Mr. W. Somerset Maugham's play “The Ex-<br />
plorer '' was revived at the Lyric Theatre last<br />
month. Mr. Lewis Waller, Miss Fanny Brough,<br />
and Mr. A. E. George are in the cast.<br />
“At a Junction,” the new one-act play in which<br />
Miss Ellen Terry is appearing this season, is<br />
written by Miss Margaret Young, whose first<br />
novel, “The Wreathed Dagger,” came out last<br />
month.<br />
A new one-act play by Mr. W. W. Jacobs and<br />
Mr. Horace Mills was produced in front of “The<br />
Arm of the Law,” at the Garrick Theatre, on<br />
May 25. It is an episode between two simple-<br />
hearted sailors and a widow, to whom one of them<br />
is paying attentions. The cast includes Mr. Leon<br />
Quartermaine, Miss Mary Weigall, and Mr. Arthur<br />
Whitby.<br />
——º-e——<br />
PARIS NOTES.<br />
—e-Q-0–<br />
HE death of George Meredith is universally<br />
regretted here by all lovers of English litera-<br />
ture. Unfortunately very few of his books<br />
have been translated into French, and one of them,<br />
“The Egoist,” has appeared in a poor translation.<br />
Those French readers who know Meredith’s works in<br />
the original greatly appreciate the psychology to be<br />
found in them. Strangely enough, the last portrait<br />
for which George Meredith posed, the medallion by<br />
Spicer-Simson, is now being exhibited in the Salon.<br />
This is naturally of great interest now, and attracts<br />
a great deal of attention. Spicer-Simson also did<br />
an excellent medallion of Watts shortly before his<br />
death. This, too, was the last portrait for which<br />
the great artist posed, and just after George<br />
Gissing's death an admirable portrait of him by<br />
this same sculptor was to be seen in the Paris Salom.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 238 (#298) ############################################<br />
<br />
238<br />
TISIE A DITISIGDR.<br />
René Doumic's book on George Sand is perhaps<br />
the most interesting of the recently published<br />
volumes. He goes back to the genealogy of the<br />
family on the maternal and paternal side and, by<br />
this study in atavism, much that may have hitherto<br />
seemed incomprehensible in this celebrated woman's<br />
character is, more or less, accounted for. René<br />
Doumic has studied his subject thoroughly. He<br />
gives us, in the first chapter, an excellent Summing<br />
up of the psychology of this “child of Rousseau,”<br />
as he calls her. He shows us the various influences<br />
with which she, as a girl, had to contend. In the<br />
next chapter she is married to Baron Dudevant,<br />
and in the third chapter the author considers her<br />
“a feminist of 1832.” After this we have the<br />
series of her various romances with Alfred de<br />
Musset, Chopin, and her other lovers. Later on<br />
there is a chapter on the humanitarian dream and<br />
her acquaintance with Pierre Leroux. In 1848<br />
she is deeply interested in politics, and in the<br />
closing chapters, we find her in her country home<br />
at Nohant. Her friendship with Flaubert, her<br />
letters to him, and a study of her later writings are<br />
the last subjects on which M. Doumic touches.<br />
The whole book is intensely interesting. The<br />
subject is a very big one, but the author of this<br />
volume has that rare quality, the Science of selec-<br />
tion, in a marked degree. There is never a word<br />
too much, and yet all sides are considered before<br />
the critic draws his conclusions. In these days of<br />
literary, or rather unliterary, rush and Scramble,<br />
it is refreshing to find a book that one feels<br />
has been carefully and studiously thought out,<br />
a book which brings new light on a subject<br />
which has tempted and will ever tempt so many<br />
Writers. -<br />
“Les Unis,” by Edouard Rod, is another roman<br />
à thèse. In this author's last book, “Aloyse<br />
Valérien,” it seemed as though the writer of it<br />
had left himself with a problem to solve. In this<br />
new work he appears to have solved it. The<br />
subject of the novel is the question of free love.<br />
A certain astronomer and philosopher, who has<br />
himself been fortunate in his love affairs, considers<br />
an unfettered union infinitely more ideal and<br />
elevated than an official marriage. He educates<br />
his children according to his theories, and the<br />
consequence is that, out of the four free unions in<br />
his family, three prove disastrous, and the fourth<br />
couple decide that it will be preferable to legalise<br />
their marriage. The conclusion of the book seems<br />
to be an attempt to prove that, in the present<br />
state of Society, free unions cannot be substituted<br />
for legalised marriages. This does not perhaps<br />
prevent the author from sympathising with the<br />
idealist in his theories. The conclusion is rather<br />
that such an ideal is too premature for the Sordid<br />
times in which we live.<br />
5<br />
The questions of marriage, divorce, and free<br />
unions have furnished subjects for numbers of<br />
novels within the last few years. “Le Couple<br />
invincible,” by M. Louis Lefebvre, is another novel<br />
on the same theme. In 1629, a band of French<br />
emigrants set out with their families, hoping to<br />
find peace and tranquillity in other lands. They<br />
are shipwrecked, and only a boat laden with<br />
children, the eldest of whom is five years old,<br />
reaches a little island inhabited by fishermen. It<br />
is the first time that the natives of the island have<br />
ever seen any Europeans, and as their habits and<br />
customs are Very simple, they adopt the newcomers.<br />
The children, of course, have a language of their<br />
own. They live on very friendly terms with the<br />
inhabitants of the island, but as a colony quite<br />
apart. Time passes by, and as these children grow<br />
up they gradually educate themselves and make<br />
their own rules, and later on laws. Three hundred<br />
years later this little colony has developed into a<br />
community of twenty thousand people. One of<br />
the most curious of their laws is the one concerning<br />
marriage. A register is kept of marriages and of<br />
démariages. As soon as a husband wishes to<br />
change his wife he gives notice to the Governor,<br />
and the dissolution of his marriage is at once<br />
pronounced. At the time when the story opens<br />
there is great excitement in the island. A certain<br />
Professor and his wife have promised each other to:<br />
be faithful for life, and not to contract a marriage<br />
With another person. This is considered criminal<br />
and illegal, and the would-be reformer is thrown<br />
into prison. He pleads his cause most eloquently,<br />
but this idea of absolute fidelity to one wife is con-<br />
sidered rank heresy, and he is condemned to.<br />
imprisonment for life. Gradually, though, the<br />
idea is discussed in the island and, as time goes<br />
on, the advantages of such a custom are seen by<br />
Some of the more important members of the com-<br />
munity. Finally, there is a reaction in favour of<br />
the Professor, and it is decided that he shall be set<br />
free, and that his principle shall be adopted.<br />
When the Governor goes to the prison with these<br />
good tidings it is too late, as the prisoner has just<br />
died. Great sympathy is felt for his widow, but,<br />
she tells the Governor that she will never be alone,<br />
as she is sure of her husband’s love even after<br />
death. Some little time after this a French boat<br />
touches at the island and, on comparing notes, it<br />
is discovered that this little colony belongs to<br />
France. The Governor, in his pride, tells of the<br />
new law that has just been passed, and is delighted<br />
that the colony will be worthy of the mother<br />
country. The officer replies in an evasive manner.<br />
It is 1915, and in France the law has just decreed<br />
that all marriages shall be dissolved at will.<br />
“Le Mariage de Mlle. Gimei, dactylographe,” is<br />
the title of René Bazin's latest book. -<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 239 (#299) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
239<br />
“Une Tragédie d’Amour” is a work by Ernest<br />
Seillière, giving the details of the suicide of<br />
Charlotte Stieglitz. The whole story is very<br />
curious, and several volumes have already been<br />
written on the subject. Henri Stieglitz was a poet<br />
of an extremely melancholy and nervous disposition.<br />
His wife finally committed suicide, hoping that a<br />
real trouble might arouse her husband from his<br />
imaginary sorrows, and enable him to produce the<br />
masterpieces of literature of which they both<br />
appear to think he was capable. The whole book<br />
is a study of psychology and of German mentality<br />
during the 1830 period.<br />
Among other recent books are:—“Sur les deux<br />
Rives,” by Leon de Timseau; “Le soldat Bernard,”<br />
by Paul Acker; “Simone la Romanesque,”, by<br />
Lucien Trotignon; “La Course à l’Abime,” by<br />
Ernest Daudet.<br />
“Un Concert chez les Fous” is the title of the<br />
volume of short stories which Charles Foley, the<br />
author of “Heard at the Telephone,” has just<br />
brought out. The first story, which gives its name<br />
to the volume, is the one from which the play that<br />
has had such success in Paris this winter was taken.<br />
The translation of this story has already appeared<br />
in an English magazine, and several of the others<br />
will be published shortly in English.<br />
The lectures given at the Sorbonne by the<br />
American professor, Henry Van Dyke, have been<br />
translated by E. Sainte Marie Perrin, and are<br />
now published in book form as “Le Génie de<br />
l’Amérique,” with a preface by A. Ribot, of the<br />
French Academy. A translation of a book by<br />
Benson has just appeared, entitled “Par quelle<br />
Autorité P.”<br />
“Douze Histoires et un Réve" is the title of a<br />
translation recently published of a book by Wells.<br />
In the Revue de Paris of the 15th of May, there<br />
is an article by Jacques Blanche on the “Hundred<br />
English and French Portraits.” In the last three<br />
numbers of La Revue hebdomadaire there has<br />
been a series of articles on “Le Dépeuplement de<br />
la France.” Mademoiselle Chaptal, who has done<br />
such fine work in the war that is being waged<br />
against tuberculosis, writes an extremely interesting<br />
article entitled “Histoire d'un Faubourg.” Through<br />
her efforts great changes have taken place in one<br />
of the most populous districts of Paris. She has<br />
built a model lodging-house for the working man,<br />
and she is now engaged in the founding of a very<br />
modern hospital, which she will supply with<br />
trained nurses. In the same review M. De<br />
:Quirielle gives a study of “The Evolution of<br />
Maurice Barres.”<br />
In Paul Hervieu's play at the Théâtre Français,<br />
entitled “Connais-toi,” we have one of the finest<br />
feminine characters which this author has given<br />
sus. In Clarisse, the wife of the Général de Sibéran,<br />
We have an extremely feminine, charming woman,<br />
a distinct relief from the ultra-modern woman<br />
now in vogue. All the other characters are living<br />
and real; there is nothing of the marionette about<br />
them. They have not been invented merely to<br />
figure in a play written to instruct us. It is quite<br />
refreshing to have either a play or a novel at<br />
present in which we have no long tirades on the<br />
rights and requirements of women. “Le Scan-<br />
dale,” by Henri Bataille, is being played at the<br />
Renaissance. At the Porte Saint-Martin the play<br />
by MM. Gustave Guiches and François de Nion,<br />
entitled “Lauzun,” is having success.<br />
ALYS HALLARD.<br />
“George Sand” (Perrin).<br />
“Les Unis” (Fasquelle).<br />
“Le Couple invincible " (Perrin).<br />
º # Mariage de Mlle. Gimel, dactylographe " (Calmann-<br />
evy).<br />
“Une Tragédie d'Amour” (Plon).<br />
“Sur les deux Rives” (Calmann Lévy).<br />
“Le Soldat Bernard” (Fayard).<br />
“Simone la Romanesque " (Perrin).<br />
“Un Concert chez les Fous” (Ollendorf).<br />
a – A – a<br />
v-º-w<br />
AMERICAN COPYRIGHT AGAIN.<br />
—º-O-0–<br />
A COINCIDENCE.<br />
TT is surely a singular coincidence that the<br />
April number of The Author, which contains<br />
my suggestion that Great Britain and the<br />
United States should give their respective authors<br />
the protection granted willingly to patentees,<br />
should also publish a brief digest of a new United<br />
States Copyright Bill which actually takes a step in<br />
the direction I indicated. But it is only a step—a<br />
weak effort to break away from earlier trammels.<br />
I proposed a protected period of six months after<br />
publication, and a further period of one year on<br />
payment of a small fee. The new American Act<br />
gives one month for filing the copy of a British<br />
book and one month for applying the type-setting<br />
clause. Now, with all deference to The Author's<br />
adverse opinion, I hail this as a real benefit, but<br />
the absurdly inadequate time limits prove clearly,<br />
to my thinking, that the Act was drawn up by<br />
someone who had very little practical experience<br />
of the difficulty he was trying to solve. Will you<br />
permit me to point out some phases of this<br />
difficulty 2<br />
I am not concerned about the leading authors of<br />
either country. The very drawbacks imposed by<br />
this copyright muddle are good for them. Their<br />
books are accepted eagerly, and publishers are<br />
naturally prepared to fulfil the provisions of the<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 240 (#300) ############################################<br />
<br />
240<br />
TISIE AUTISIOR.<br />
law, whether simultaneous publication is insisted<br />
on or not. It is the beginner, the unknown writer<br />
—the man or woman with a story to tell that shall<br />
hold spellbound the multitude when once its atten-<br />
tion is caught—who suffers most grievously under<br />
existing conditions. To such a one this slight<br />
relaxation of the “simultaneous publication ”<br />
clause is nearly, though not quite, useless. Take,<br />
for instance, a novel that is published serially ;<br />
before it appears in book form it may have been<br />
running six months: what becomes then of the<br />
two months' grace allowed by the United States ?<br />
Again, let a non-serialised book by a new writer<br />
be head and shoulders over its contemporaries of a<br />
season, it cannot leap into prominence SO Suddenly<br />
that all the reading public shall know of it, and an<br />
American house be ready to adopt the needed safe-<br />
guards almost before the circulating libraries have<br />
made up their minds to order a second supply.<br />
It seems to be only too clear that the two<br />
months period was determined by legislators who<br />
meant to act fairly, but lacked knowledge of print-<br />
ing and publishing exigences. The concession is<br />
a real boon to publishers and authors whose<br />
arrangements are already made. It saves anxiety<br />
and doubt on such a vitally important matter as to<br />
what does actually constitute “simultaneous”<br />
publication. But it does not give proper protec-<br />
tion to the author who is unable to Secure a pub-<br />
lisher on both sides of the Atlantic. It helps, I<br />
admit. There may be some few cases where the<br />
transcending merits of a book (probably overlooked.<br />
by a round dozen of wideawake publishers when<br />
in MS.) will demand such prompt attention that<br />
an American edition can be rushed into print.<br />
within the time.<br />
far between.<br />
I hope, therefore, that The Author will withdraw<br />
its ban, and advocate the extended period I described<br />
a month ago. By payment of 4s. the owner of<br />
the copyright should be able to secure protection<br />
for eighteen months. If, in that time, he has not<br />
persuaded an American publisher to take up his<br />
book—well, he must write another and a better<br />
one—or, at any rate, one more suited to the<br />
American market. -<br />
LOUIS TRACY.<br />
—e—º-e—<br />
CHEAP EDITIONS.<br />
—º-º-º-<br />
RESULT OF THE SOCIETY's CIRCULAR.<br />
HE committee desire to put before the<br />
members of the society the result of the<br />
postcard circular which was sent round<br />
to all the members in April.<br />
But such cases will be few and<br />
As members will call to mind, this circular ran<br />
as follows:– -<br />
“The committee desire to call your attention to the<br />
report of the sub-committee on bookselling in the April<br />
issue of The Author, and will be glad—should the matter<br />
under discussion affect you as a writer of fiction—if you<br />
would be kind enough to fill up, sign, and return the<br />
accompanying postcard. It is most important for the<br />
booksellers to know the names of those authors who<br />
approve of the time limit and are willing to assist in<br />
enforcing it.”<br />
and that the following was the form of card for<br />
reply :— -<br />
“* (1) I am (OT am not) a writer of novels.<br />
“” (2) I undertake (do not undertake) not to publish<br />
either myself, or through my agents or assigns, an edition<br />
of any novel first issued at the price of 6s. or over in a<br />
cheaper form at any time within two years from date of<br />
its first publication,<br />
“” (3) I have no objection (I object) to the publication<br />
of my name in The Author or otherwise.<br />
“* Please delete these portions not applicable.”<br />
The list of those who are willing, and those who<br />
are unwilling, to give the undertaking will be of<br />
interest, not only to all writers of fiction, but to<br />
all the booksellers when purchasing their stock of<br />
68. novels, and also to the publishers.<br />
It should be borne in mind that this under-<br />
taking could not possibly bind members in the<br />
matter of those contracts which have already been<br />
entered into either by themselves or their agents,<br />
and it should be stated that some of the signatories<br />
who gave this undertaking made an exception in<br />
favour of 38. 6d. editions, or, conversely, limited the<br />
undertaking to non-production at 1s. or under.<br />
From many of the novelist members of the<br />
Society, as a careful perusal of the list will at<br />
once show, no answers have been received—this<br />
point should be kept in mind by any statistician<br />
who desires to make logical deductions—but if<br />
any other names come in to the offices of the<br />
Society of Authors after this list has gone to<br />
press, they will, with the consent of the authors,<br />
be inserted in the July number.<br />
About six hundred answers have so far been<br />
received. Of these 290 were from those members<br />
of the Society who did not claim to be novelists,<br />
and 310 were from novelists. -<br />
We only propose to deal with a classification of<br />
the latter. Of these the majority gave the under-<br />
taking suggested by the sub-committee and<br />
approved by the committee of management, the<br />
exact proportions being as follows: 203 in favour<br />
of the undertaking and 28 against. In fourteen<br />
cases the writers expressed their views in general<br />
terms, neither binding nor refusing to bind them-<br />
selves. Twelve cards were returned unsigned, and<br />
in consequence cannot be identified.<br />
The lists produced below naturally only include<br />
those who have allowed their names to be published.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 241 (#301) ############################################<br />
<br />
TFIES A CITISIOR,<br />
241<br />
Authors who undertake not to Publish an Edition<br />
of any Novel first issued at the price of 68, in a<br />
cheap form at any time within Two Years from<br />
date of its first Publication.<br />
Ansell, Evelyn<br />
Armstrong, Miss Julien<br />
Askew, Claude<br />
Atherton, Mrs. Gertrude<br />
Baker, Miss Emily<br />
Baker, James<br />
Bancroft, Francis<br />
Banerjea, S. B.<br />
Barclay, Armiger<br />
Barrington, Michael<br />
Battersby, H. F.<br />
Prevost<br />
Begbie, Harold,<br />
Bell, R. S. Warren<br />
Benson, E. F.<br />
Black, Miss Clementina<br />
Booth, Edward C.<br />
Bloundelle-Burton,<br />
John<br />
Boggs, Miss Winifred<br />
Boore, Miss E.<br />
Bourke, Lady Florence<br />
Brighouse, J. H.<br />
Briggs, Miss Ada E.<br />
Brooke, Miss Emma<br />
Burgess, J. J. Haldane<br />
Calderon, George<br />
Cameron, Mrs. Charlotte<br />
Capes, Bernard<br />
Carey, Miss<br />
Nouchette<br />
Carroder, Conrad H.<br />
Castle, Egerton<br />
Canman, Gilbert<br />
Chorley, Herbert<br />
Clarke, Allen<br />
Cobbett, Miss Alice<br />
Coleridge, The Hon.<br />
Gilbert<br />
Coleridge, Mrs. Marion<br />
Connell, Norreys<br />
Corelli, Miss Marie<br />
Cowley, Miss J. M. R.<br />
Craig, Lieut.-Col. R.<br />
Manifold<br />
Crommelin, Miss May<br />
Dawe, Carlton<br />
De Crespigny, Mrs.<br />
Delaire, Mrs. Jean<br />
De la Pasture,<br />
Henry<br />
Deeping, Warwick<br />
Dickson, F. Thorold<br />
Rosa<br />
Mrs.<br />
Digges, The Rev. J.<br />
C<br />
Dixon, William Scarth<br />
Dorrington, Albert<br />
Doyle, Sir A. Conan<br />
Drummond, Mrs. Annie<br />
Drummond, Hamilton<br />
Düring, Mrs. Stella M.<br />
Dutton, Miss Annie<br />
V<br />
Eccles, Miss O'Conor<br />
Ellis, Mrs. Havelock<br />
Fetherstonhaugh, W.<br />
FitzRoy, Isobel (Mrs.<br />
Arthur Hecht)<br />
Forbes, Lady Helen<br />
Forrest, R. E.<br />
Forster, E. M.<br />
Fountain, Paul<br />
Fowler, Ellen Thorney-<br />
croft (The Hon. Mrs.<br />
Alfred Felkin)<br />
Fox, S. M.<br />
Free, The Rev. Richard<br />
Freeman, R. Austin<br />
Fuller, Captain J. F.<br />
C<br />
Garvice, Charles<br />
Gaunt, Miss Mary<br />
Gay, Mrs. Florence<br />
Gibson, L. S.<br />
Gilliat, The Rev. E.<br />
Gilson, Captain Charles<br />
Godfrey, Miss Elizabeth<br />
Goldring, Miss Maude<br />
Grace, Stephen<br />
Grand, Madame Sarah<br />
Granville, C. .<br />
Graves, Frederick<br />
Grey, Rowland<br />
Gribble, Francis<br />
Grier, Sydney C.<br />
Guthrie, Anstey (F.<br />
Anstey)<br />
Hachblock, Miss Emily<br />
M. -<br />
Hamel, Frank<br />
Hamilton, Anthony<br />
Hamilton, The Rev.<br />
John A.<br />
Harding, Commander<br />
Claud<br />
Harker, Mrs. L. Allen<br />
Harraden, Miss Beatrice<br />
Harrison, Mrs. Darent<br />
Harte, Mrs. Bagot<br />
Heath, Miss Helena<br />
Henderson, Miss<br />
Florence L.<br />
Henoch, Mrs. Emily I.<br />
Hewlett, Maurice<br />
Hill, J. Arthur<br />
Hinkson, Mrs. Katha-<br />
rine Tynan<br />
Hodgson, Randolph Ll.<br />
Holland, Clive<br />
Holmes, Arthur H.<br />
Holmes, Miss Eleanor<br />
Home, Miss M. C.<br />
Hope, Anthony<br />
Hope, Graham<br />
Horniman, Roy<br />
Hughes-Gibb, Mrs.<br />
Humphreys, Mrs. Des-<br />
mond (Rita)<br />
Hunt, Miss Violet<br />
Hussey, Eyre<br />
Jacobs, W. W.<br />
James, Miss S. Boucher<br />
Jepson, Edgar<br />
Jones, W. Braunston<br />
Reary, C. F.<br />
Keating, Joseph<br />
Kenealy, Miss Arabella<br />
Rinross, Albert<br />
Ripling, Rudyard<br />
Koch, Mrs. Mary<br />
Rnowles, R. B. S.<br />
Landa, Mrs. Gertrude<br />
Lathbury, Miss Eva<br />
Layard, G. S.<br />
Le Blond, Mrs. Aubrey<br />
Lechmere, Mrs. (Cecil<br />
Haselwood)<br />
Lee, The Rev. Albert<br />
Lees, Robert James<br />
Lennox, Lady William<br />
Locke, W. J.<br />
Lodge, Juliane de<br />
Lowndes, Mrs. Belloc<br />
Louth, Alys<br />
Lynn, Miss Eve<br />
Machray, Robert<br />
Mackellar, C. D.<br />
MacLeod, G. Hamilton<br />
Mann, Mrs. Mary E.<br />
Marchmont, A. W.<br />
Marks, Mrs. Mary A. M.<br />
Marriott, Charles<br />
Marsh, Charles Fielding<br />
Marshall, Archibald<br />
McChesney, Miss Dora<br />
Greenwell<br />
McCraith, L. M.<br />
Methley, Miss Alice A.<br />
Miller, Miss E. T.<br />
Miniken, Miss Bertha<br />
M. M.<br />
Moberley, Miss L. G.<br />
Moore, Miss Leslie<br />
Morrah, Herbert A.<br />
Morrison, Arthur<br />
Munro, Neil<br />
Needham, Raymond<br />
Nesbit, E.<br />
Noble, E.<br />
Norris, W. E.<br />
O'Donnell, Elliott<br />
Oliphant, P. L.<br />
Ollivant, Alfred<br />
Ormsby-Johnson, Major<br />
Frederick C.<br />
Panting, J. Harwood<br />
Parks, H. C.<br />
Parr, Miss Olive Kath-<br />
arine<br />
Paternoster, G. Sidney<br />
Paull, H. M.<br />
Pemberton, Max<br />
Penn, Rachel<br />
Penny, Mrs. Frank<br />
Phillimore, Mrs. C. E.<br />
Phillipps-Wolley, Clive<br />
Pickering, Sidney<br />
Pollitt, Milton<br />
Porritt, Norman<br />
Prichard, Mrs. Hesketh<br />
Prichard, H. Hesketh<br />
Prowse, R. O. -<br />
Ralli, Constantine<br />
Ramsden, Lady Gwen-<br />
dolen<br />
Randall, F. J.<br />
Reid-Matheson, E.<br />
Reynolds, Mrs. Fred.<br />
Rhys, Ernest<br />
Richardson, Frank<br />
Roberts, R. Ellis<br />
Rose, Algernon<br />
Rowland, Mrs. Jane<br />
Rowsell, Miss Mary C.<br />
Russell, Fox<br />
Russell, G. Hansby<br />
Sanford, Miss Mary<br />
Bouchier<br />
Schwartz, Herr van der<br />
Poorten<br />
Sedgwick, Anne Douglas<br />
Shaw, G. Bernard<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 242 (#302) ############################################<br />
<br />
242<br />
THE AUTISIOR.<br />
Shepheard - Walwyn,<br />
EI. W.<br />
Sieveking, J. Giberne<br />
Silberrad, Miss Una L.<br />
Sinclair, Miss May<br />
Smedley, Constance<br />
(Mrs. Maxwell Arm-<br />
field)<br />
Smith, Miss Edith A.<br />
Smith, W. H. Byron<br />
Snaith, J. C.<br />
Soan, The Rev. R. Y.<br />
Spencer, Alfred<br />
Stacpoole, Miss Flor-<br />
€0Cé<br />
Stayton, Frank<br />
Stephens, Riccardo<br />
Stevenson, Mrs. M. E.<br />
Strae, S.<br />
Stuart, Esmé<br />
Sutcliffe, Halliwell<br />
Swallow, The Rev. Henry<br />
J<br />
Swan, Miss Myra<br />
Todd, Miss Margaret,<br />
M.D.<br />
Tomlinson, Miss Ella<br />
Tracy, Louis<br />
Trelawny, Paul<br />
Troubetzkoy,<br />
(Amelie Rives)<br />
Tuite, Hugh<br />
Wachell, Horace An-<br />
nesley<br />
Warty - Smith,<br />
Augusta A.<br />
Walker, William S.<br />
Watson, E. H. Lacon<br />
Way, Miss Beatrice<br />
Weekes, Miss R. K.<br />
Westrup, Miss Mar-<br />
garet<br />
Weyman, Stanley J.<br />
White, Miss Hester<br />
White, Percy<br />
Whiteing, Richard<br />
Willcocks, Miss M. P.<br />
Williamson, C. N.<br />
Williamson, Mrs. C. N.<br />
Williamson, W. H.<br />
Willis-Swan, Miss W. M.<br />
Wilson - Wilson, Miss<br />
Theodora<br />
Wood, Frances Harriett<br />
Yolland, Miss E.<br />
Zangwill, Israel<br />
Miss<br />
Members who do not undertake to refrain from<br />
publishing an edition of any novel first issued at the<br />
yrice of 6s. in a cheap form at any time within two<br />
ſyears from the date of its first publication —<br />
Aitken, Robert<br />
Cobb, Thomas<br />
Cornford, L. Cope<br />
Crouch, A. P.<br />
Drake, Maurice<br />
Gray, Maxwell<br />
Greener, W. O.<br />
Haes, Hubert<br />
Hornung, E. W.<br />
Hyland, Miss M. E.<br />
F.<br />
Hyne, C. J. Cutliffe<br />
Relly, W. P.<br />
Little, Mrs. Archibald<br />
Lucas, E. W.<br />
March, Miss A. Mollwo<br />
Marshall, Mrs. Agnes<br />
Marchbank<br />
Montgomery, Miss K. L.<br />
Montresor, Miss F. F.<br />
Portman, Lionel<br />
Punshom, E. R.<br />
Ridge, W. Pett<br />
Smythe, Alfred<br />
Thomas, Annie (Mrs.<br />
Pender Cudlip)<br />
Tweedale, Wiolet<br />
Vance, Louis Joseph<br />
Weaver, Mrs. Baillie<br />
Willmore, Edward<br />
v-v-w<br />
THE ANNUAL DINNER.<br />
–0-6-0–<br />
YTY HE Annual Dinner of the<br />
Society of Authors, commemorating the<br />
25th anniversary of its foundation, was<br />
held on Thursday, April 29, at the Criterion<br />
Princess<br />
Incorporated<br />
Restaurant, about two hundred members and<br />
guests being present. The chair was taken b<br />
Mr. EDMUND GOSSE, who, at the conclusion of the<br />
dinner, proposed the usual loyal toasts.<br />
After the healths of the King and of the Queen<br />
and the Royal Family had been drunk with<br />
enthusiasm, the chairman rose again in order to<br />
propose “The Society.”<br />
After referring to the occasion, the “first jubilee<br />
anniversary in the history of the society,” Mr.<br />
Gosse declared himself, although not like Queen<br />
Constance a creature “naturally born to fear,”<br />
seriously alarmed at the task of addressing a<br />
body of professional people on a subject intimately<br />
connected with their profession—a large and dis-<br />
tinguished body of authors, on authorship. He<br />
was able, however, as a very old member of the<br />
Society, as One of the very first, to share in the<br />
pleasure and comfort felt by all in the favourable<br />
situation in which they found themselves. He<br />
recalled the first meeting of the society in Mr.<br />
Scoones's room, when they listened to the ardent<br />
eloquence of Walter Besant, and little imagined<br />
that his grain of mustard-seed would bourgeon<br />
and push forth branches into all parts of the<br />
habitable globe. Among those before him who<br />
had taken part in the foundation of the society he<br />
referred to Dr. Squire Sprigge (who presided at one<br />
of the tables). Of the rise and growth of the<br />
society Mr. Gosse proceeded to say: “The thrilling,<br />
the tremendous point is the fact itself, namely,<br />
that after a laborious ascent of no fewer than<br />
twenty-five years, the members of the society have<br />
reached a turn in the hill road. I daresay you<br />
remember, in “Pilgrim's Progress,” that when<br />
Christian had been a long while clambering up<br />
the hill Difficulty, he came to a turn in the hill,<br />
where was a pleasant arbour, when he pulled his<br />
roll out of his bosom and fell to reading therein to<br />
his comfort. It is only right that we should pause,<br />
after our climb of a quarter of a century, and fall<br />
to reading our roll. When we look out from our<br />
arbour half way up the hill Difficulty, we may see<br />
ourselves, in the fashion of old Italian pictures, as<br />
we were in the year of our incorporation. What<br />
we see is a little group of twelve or fifteen<br />
men, full of zeal for the protection of literature,<br />
and we see them set forth to fight against all<br />
manner of gryphons and dragons, under the generous<br />
leadership of our dear old friend and comrade<br />
Walter Besant.” Mr. Gosse went on to refer to the<br />
ridicule and opposition which the Society had<br />
lived down, to its growth from sixty-eight members<br />
at the close of its first year to an army of two<br />
thousand in the present day; to its prosperity, to<br />
its power for helping others and protecting itself;<br />
and mentioned in this connection its indebtedness<br />
to the energy of its secretary, Mr. Herbert Thring.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 243 (#303) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR,<br />
243<br />
It was not a charitable society, nor a mere debt-<br />
collecting institution, but a corporation of the<br />
owners of literary copyright in the kingdom,<br />
strengthening and defending their rights through-<br />
out the world. The pirate waved his raw-head and<br />
bloody bones, but the society ran him down upon<br />
the high seas in true British style. At that<br />
moment, he informed his hearers, in response to<br />
an invitation from the Board of Trade Mr. Thring<br />
was collecting evidence to be laid before the<br />
Departmental Committee on the results of the Berlin<br />
International Copyright Convention, over which<br />
Lord Gorell will preside. The society took<br />
cases through the Courts and, as in one instance,<br />
to the House of Lords, not concerning itself. So<br />
much with the amount as with the principle of<br />
law involved, with the result that every case<br />
fought successfully, every modification obtained in<br />
a publisher's agreement, enabled all British authors<br />
to make better terms for themselves. The society,<br />
once sneered at by its enemies as a coterie of<br />
amateurs, included in its membership of two<br />
thousand the vast majority of the professional<br />
authors in this country, and in a quarter of a<br />
century had had but two presidents: Tennyson<br />
and George Meredith. He asked them in con-<br />
clusion to drink to the health of the Society, a<br />
toast which by custom needed no reply.<br />
The next toast, that of “Iliterature and The<br />
Drama,” was proposed by “Maarten Maartens’’<br />
(Mr. J. M. W. Van der Poorten-Schwartz), who<br />
in expressing his distrust of his own powers as an<br />
orator, said: “Some men are born to speech-<br />
making ; some men achieve it ; and some men<br />
have it kindly and firmly thrust upon them. It<br />
was Talleyrand—was it not ?—who said that “a<br />
speech was allotted to a man so that he might not<br />
be able to say what he meant.' Talleyrand was<br />
one of the half-a-dozen fortunate persons in the<br />
last century who are credited with all the clever<br />
things they forgot to say. He is the favoured<br />
French personage of that time, as Sidney Smith<br />
was the English one, and Saphir the German one.<br />
Lucky indeed are the wits and authors whose<br />
plagiarism is done for them by the rest of man-<br />
kind.” Referring to the old American jest as to<br />
the relief of Daniel in the lion's den at the reflec-<br />
tion that he would have to make no after-dinner<br />
speech, Mr. Maartens observed that on that<br />
occasion there was in fact no dinner but only<br />
speeches, Daniel himself proposing the King's ever-<br />
lasting health. He himself was thus to propose the<br />
health of the lions, some of whom had to roar in<br />
their own wilderness, with none to say, “Well roared,<br />
lion l’” After all, however, it was better to do<br />
your roaring in the wilderness than in any popular<br />
shilling zoo. The speaker paid a personal tribute<br />
to English literature as it reached him in Holland<br />
in the shape of books forwarded by English literary<br />
friends, referring to it as “a link in love of letters<br />
across the sea,” and describing “down in the<br />
Village, the workboys, after a day's often weari-<br />
Some and unhealthy labour—the village boys,<br />
Strange of costume and uncouth of language,<br />
bending with sparkling eyes over the latest magic<br />
possibility, the latest world-wonder—by Wells.”<br />
He hesitated to continue with a list of English<br />
Writers widely read in Holland, after the chairman's<br />
reference to foreign piracy. Turning again to the<br />
Village already mentioned and to the topic of<br />
The Drama, he spoke of its delight in its theatrical<br />
Society, saying, “You must come and see how<br />
through the endless winter evenings in the quiet,<br />
frost-bound, frost-bitten country these dull peasants,<br />
Who are beyond the reach of a theatre, find exist-<br />
ence brightened and gladdened by their slow<br />
learning and simple costuming, their little sacri-<br />
fices, their triumphant results.” He had spoken<br />
of literature brought to him by the post; he<br />
would also recall the sad tidings it might bear.<br />
Recently it had brought him news of the death of<br />
Swinburne ; paying an eloquent tribute to the<br />
poet's memory, he observed that it should not be<br />
said that “Swinburne was no more.” “In the<br />
literary firmament, at any rate, the fixed star shines<br />
on.” Coupling the toast with the name of Mr.<br />
H. G. Wells, he proposed the toast of “Literature<br />
and The Drama.” He had hoped to join the name<br />
of Mr. Henry Arthur Jones, but he regretted that<br />
information had been received that Mr. Jones<br />
was prevented by indisposition from being<br />
present.<br />
Replying to the toast of “Literature,” Mr.<br />
H. G. Wells said that perhaps for the first time<br />
in his life he had heard that toast proposed without<br />
the accompaniment of a lament that literature was<br />
at present in a bad way—that the books that were<br />
written to-day were not comparable in merit with<br />
the books that were written in the past. This<br />
was an almost invariable statement on such<br />
Occasions, but it was an unkindly statement—it<br />
wounded the living, and quite possibly never<br />
reached the ears of the dead. But it was true,<br />
nevertheless. Literature always had been in a<br />
bad way. The books that were written at any<br />
time were never equal in depth and richness of<br />
association, and a certain indefinable quality that<br />
everyone understood and no one could explain, to<br />
the books of the past. They never would be until<br />
new wine and new cheese, new furniture and new<br />
history, were as good as the old. But Mr. Maarten<br />
Maartens, with a juster appreciation of the case<br />
had taken it for granted that in the achievements<br />
of literature at the present time there was as good<br />
promise of a noble vintage for the future as had<br />
been made by any previous age.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 244 (#304) ############################################<br />
<br />
244<br />
TFIE A Dr’TFIOR.<br />
Mr. Wells went on to say that when it was<br />
conveyed to him that he was to speak upon the<br />
subject of literature, his mind began at once to<br />
run upon the question : “What is literature ?”<br />
Was it art, for instance 2 It might perhaps be<br />
called so, if one were willing to talk of uncon-<br />
scious art—which was absurd ; but arts swam in<br />
literature like waves and eddies in a flood, and<br />
there was literary art that was not literature.<br />
Was it philosophy All literature, Mr. Wells<br />
contended, was formally or informally philosophy,<br />
inasmuch as it had reference to the broad and<br />
fundamental things of life. But it was true that<br />
some philosophy was not literature. Was it<br />
science 2 Literature was informed with knowledge,<br />
but there was indeed knowledge which had no claim<br />
to be considered literature. Literature consisted<br />
of the whole written expression of a people that<br />
was not simply either the reiteration of things<br />
already said, or bare records, or shallow insincerity.<br />
It was the conscious thought of the community,<br />
and nothing less, said Mr. Wells, that he found<br />
himself sustaining in that toast—just as a page-<br />
boy might carry a crown and the symbol of the<br />
empire of the world. For his own part, he took<br />
literature very seriously indeed. It was the<br />
greatest thing in life to him. He would rather<br />
leave a living book behind him than die rich or<br />
honoured, and rather add a new vein of thought<br />
to the nation's thinking than add a province to<br />
her empire. He claimed for literature, before all<br />
things, freedom ; it was the fundamental duty of<br />
literature to express thought with the completest<br />
freedom and frankness; the idea, that one heard<br />
of sometimes, of a censorship of literature, was the<br />
most foolish and mischievous imaginable. It was<br />
not for those who had not thought and dared not<br />
think to control the thought of those who did. It<br />
was doubtful if anyone had ever been really injured<br />
by a bad book, unless the mischief was already<br />
done by suppressions and timidities and secrecies<br />
that made the victim morbidly susceptible to<br />
strange suggestions. The way to counteract bad<br />
books was to print good Ones.<br />
Mr. Wells said he would also like to claim for<br />
literature something else : a living wage. It was<br />
extremely puzzling to see how this could be pro-<br />
vided, and for his own part he had no scheme to<br />
offer. It seemed possible that hard times were<br />
coming for writers, perhaps as a consequence of the<br />
great production of cheap literature, but they would<br />
have to show their faith in their calling by going<br />
on writing in spite of that, by adapting themselves<br />
to the new conditions and by making any alterations<br />
in their scale of living that might be necessary.<br />
Authors were a peculiar class, creatures at once<br />
favoured and doomed. No writer could tell with<br />
certainty whether he was producing literature—or<br />
piffle. For his own part, he knew—and he believed<br />
that here he spoke for the majority present—that<br />
whatever happened to their fortunes in the future,<br />
he was going on writing, and very largely he was<br />
going on Writing what he wanted to write, if<br />
necessary on a pound a week, or in hiding or in<br />
jail for debt, or in whatever circumstances might<br />
be in store for him, so long as paper and pens were<br />
provided. The only way to stop a writer who had<br />
Once really tasted ink and the sense of authentic<br />
creation was to shoot him. That was the peculiar<br />
weakness of the author's economic position, a<br />
position that Mr. Thring and the society had,<br />
nevertheless, done so much to improve.<br />
Mr. Anthony Hope Hawkins, in proposing “The<br />
Guests,” said that he had been in a certain amount<br />
of difficulty in ascertaining who were the guests of<br />
the Society on that evening and who were its<br />
members, and that if he should praise anyone who<br />
should not be praised and leave out anybody who<br />
should be mentioned, he must ask to be forgiven.<br />
In his peculiar position he must hold out a high<br />
diplomatic welcome to the representative of the<br />
Publishers' Association, and being quite unaccus-<br />
tomed to high diplomatic functions, he felt rather<br />
like a Sovereign addressing a brother potentate and<br />
saying, “I am very glad to see you. Now come<br />
and see my army and fleet.” This, however, at the<br />
present time of day was a rather hard way of<br />
putting it. It was one of the fervent hopes of the<br />
founder of the society that relations of friendship<br />
would reign in the future between authors and<br />
publishers. They were now getting nearer to that<br />
ideal. They had found many points as to which<br />
they could act together; such points were<br />
increasing, and the cordiality of co-operation was<br />
heightened through there being on both sides a well<br />
Organised body. There were men and women<br />
familiar with the issues and able to discuss them<br />
in a business-like way. The extremists on both<br />
sides had become of less account, and the business<br />
was the more likely to be carried on upon lines of<br />
justice and of harmony. For these reasons, not less<br />
than for what he had done for literature, he bade<br />
Mr. Heinemann a hearty welcome. As regards a<br />
great many of the other guests, his pleasure in<br />
welcoming them would only be greater if he could<br />
greet them as members, distinguished as so many<br />
of them were in the fields of literature. The society<br />
was honoured by the presence of Lady Dorothy<br />
Nevill, who, secure herself in immortal youth,<br />
linked the present with the great men of the past.<br />
Mr. Henry Newbolt needed no introduction to<br />
members—a gifted craftsman in prose and poetry.<br />
With real pleasure he greeted Kate Douglas Wiggin,<br />
a member as well as, on that night, the guest of<br />
the chairman. In claiming for her, as such, the<br />
full token of the society's respect, Mr. Hope dis-<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 245 (#305) ############################################<br />
<br />
TFIE A CITISIOR.<br />
245<br />
claimed any reflection upon Lord Collins. He<br />
could well understand that if Lord Collins were a<br />
member of the society he might, as occupant of a<br />
high judicial office, soon find himself sitting in<br />
judgment on himself. The society were incorri-<br />
gible litigants, and as they always had an unanswer-<br />
able case he would feel himself obliged to give<br />
judgment in his own favour. As Master of the<br />
Rolls, Lord Collins might well be claimed as an<br />
author, but he had more definite qualifications.<br />
In his earlier days, he (Mr. Hope Hawkins)<br />
became acquainted with two ponderous tomes”<br />
bearing Lord Collins' name on their title pages,<br />
and from his recollection of their contents, he<br />
wentured to say that Lord Collins was as glad to<br />
have finished with them as he himself.<br />
Replying first for the guests, Kate Douglas<br />
Wiggin (Mrs. George Riggs, Litt.D.) made a speech<br />
in verse, referring in a humorous vein to literary<br />
incidents and personalities of the day, and con-<br />
taining the following passages:—<br />
>k >k × >k >k<br />
“Do you know what I see as I stand here the guest<br />
Of the flower of London, its cleverest, best,<br />
Its poets, its editors, novelists, sages —<br />
I see you as you are, then as heirs of the ages<br />
Your laurels are green, I see others unfaded<br />
Tho' centuries cold are the brows they once shaded,<br />
See ghosts of immortals whose eloquent words<br />
Made England a forest of rare singing birds ;<br />
Magicians whose tales are still fresh to the ear,<br />
They spoke, they still speak, and the world bends to hear.<br />
I own the same tongue, so I share in the glory<br />
That makes Britain famous in Song and in story.<br />
(We imperilled our heritage slightly, you’ll say,<br />
When we ventured from out your dominion to stray,<br />
But not one Pilgrim sailed for his bleak Plymouth Rock<br />
Till Shakespeare was born, so we're stock of his stock I)”<br />
× × × × >k<br />
“Poor John Davidson's gone ; he was hopeless and sad :<br />
If now he's at peace we can only be glad<br />
That the ‘weariest river,' when once it flows free,<br />
Finds somehow and somewhere its path ‘to the sea.”<br />
Now from sorrow to gratitude—blessings are many,<br />
Tho' up to this moment I’ve not mentioned any<br />
There's one splendid voice that is still ringing true,<br />
One worthy to rank with the immortal few,<br />
Old or young, he's as full as a reed is of pith,<br />
. Your president, God bless him George Meredith !”<br />
× Sk - X sk >:<br />
‘These then, fellow scribes, are the thoughts of a guest<br />
Who tacitly in her first sentence confessed<br />
She hadn't a notion of speeches at dinners,<br />
For on these occasions the men are chief sinners<br />
I thank dear Edmund Gosse for the honour conferred<br />
In letting me speak for the guests this brief word.<br />
Lord Collins I thank for dividing the toast,<br />
Especially when in himself he's a host.<br />
And last, friends and authors, I'm glad to be here,<br />
Not alone for the wit and the mirth and good cheer,<br />
But because we are sounding the praises to-night<br />
Of an art in whose service lies keenest delight.<br />
{<br />
* Smith's Leading Cases,<br />
Talk of angels Poor angels, they play and they sing,<br />
But never a quill do they pluck from a wing !<br />
They’ve only their harps; no paper, no ink,<br />
I’d rather be author than angel, I think<br />
I’m nearly submerged in a crowd of my betters,<br />
But proud to be known as a woman of letters ''<br />
Lord Collins, following Kate Douglas Wiggin,<br />
declared his enjoyment of the advantage, shared<br />
that evening by no previous respondents, of being<br />
a “junior.” It was well known that the province of<br />
a “leader’ in the law courts was to say all that<br />
needed no research, and to leave his junior to fill<br />
in the details. His leader had, however, adopted<br />
a different course, taking the whole burden<br />
of the case, and he was grateful that at least<br />
it was not obligatory upon him to say ditto<br />
in an extempore poem. Most men, especially<br />
professional men, ended by obliterating from<br />
their constitutions all that belonged to the<br />
domain of imagination, and by reducing to<br />
complete inertness the most brilliant faculty<br />
bestowed by Providence upon mankind. There<br />
authors came in and preserved that which other-<br />
wise would become extinct in a generation or two.<br />
Among authors, he observed, a new disease had<br />
recently sprung up ; it was called “ telepathy,” a<br />
different name from the old days when it was<br />
known by the simpler title of “plagiarism.” There<br />
seemed now to be an epidemic of this telepathy, so<br />
that people who otherwise would incur penalties<br />
for appropriating the work of others, had only to<br />
get their nerves into a condition to be permeated<br />
with the ideas of others in order to evade all<br />
consequences. This appeared to him to be a new<br />
and formidable difficulty with which authors had<br />
now to contend, and he hoped that they would be<br />
able to find some means of meeting it.<br />
In conclusion, Sir Alfred Bateman proposed the<br />
health of the chairman, referring to his first acquaint-<br />
ance with Mr. Edmund Gosse in the office of the<br />
Board of Trade, and to this commencement of<br />
their friendship of many years' standing. In those<br />
early days, he reminded the society, there were<br />
working for the Board of Trade Mr. Gosse, Mr.<br />
Cosmo Monkhouse, and Mr. Austin Dobson, all<br />
distinguished since in literature, with the result<br />
that the Board had become a most perfect depart-<br />
ment. Mr. Gosse had now left the Board of Trade<br />
for the House of Lords, and as the result of his<br />
translation had given the Upper House a catalogue.<br />
He concluded by paying a warm tribute to the<br />
qualities of Mr. Edmund Gosse, and by asking all<br />
present to join in drinking his health with<br />
enthusiasm.<br />
The company responded warmly to Sir Alfred<br />
Bateman’s invitation, and after Mr. Gosse had<br />
made a brief reply, adjourned to an adjoining<br />
room, where the proceedings closed with coffee and<br />
conversation.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 246 (#306) ############################################<br />
<br />
246<br />
TISIES A UITISIOR.<br />
HOW TO USE THE SOCIETY.<br />
—e—º-0–<br />
1. VERY member has a right to ask for and to receive<br />
advice upon his agreements, his choice of a pub-<br />
lisher, or any dispute arising in the conduct of his<br />
business or the administration of his property. The<br />
Secretary of the Society is a solicitor; but if there is any<br />
special reason the Secretary will refer the case to the<br />
Solicitors of the Society. Further, the Committee, if they<br />
deem it desirable, will obtain counsel's opinion without<br />
any cost to the member. Moreover, where counsel's<br />
opinion is favourable, and the sanction of the Committee<br />
is obtained, action will be taken on behalf of the aggrieved<br />
member, and all costs borne by the Society,<br />
2. Remember that questions connected with copyright<br />
and publishers' agreements do not fall within the experi-<br />
ence of ordinary solicitors. Therefore, do not scruple to use<br />
the Society.<br />
3. Before signing any agreement whatever, send<br />
the document to the Society for examination.<br />
4. Remember always that in belonging to the Society<br />
you are fighting the battles of other writers, even if you<br />
are reaping no direct benefit to yourself, and that you are<br />
advancing the best interests of your calling in promoting<br />
the independence of the writer, the dramatist, the composer.<br />
5. The Committee have arranged for the reception of<br />
members' agreements and their preservation in a fire-<br />
proof safe. The agreements will, of course, be regarded as<br />
confidential documents to be read only by the Secretary,<br />
who will keep the key of the safe. The Society now offers:<br />
(1) To stamp agreements in readiness for a possible action<br />
upon them. (2) To keep agreements. (3) To enforce<br />
payments due according to agreements. Fuller particu-<br />
lars of the Society's Work can be obtained in the<br />
Prospectus.<br />
6. No contract should be entered into with a literary<br />
agent without the advice of the Secretary of the Society.<br />
Members are strongly advised not to accept without careful<br />
consideration the contracts with publishers submitted to<br />
them by literary agents, and are recommended to submit<br />
them for interpretation and explanation to the Secretary<br />
of the Society.<br />
This<br />
7. Many agents neglect to stamp agreements.<br />
The<br />
must be done within fourteen days of first execution.<br />
Secretary will undertake it on behalf of members.<br />
8. Some agents endeavour to prevent authors from<br />
referring matters to the Secretary of the Society; so<br />
do some publishers. Members can make their own<br />
deductions and act accordingly.<br />
9. The subscription to the Society is £1 1s.<br />
per<br />
annum, or £10 10s. for life membership. -<br />
—º-<br />
w-v-w<br />
WARNINGS TO THE PRODUCERS<br />
OF BOOKS,<br />
—e-O-0–<br />
ERE are a few standing rules to be observed in an<br />
agreement. There are four methods of dealing<br />
with literary property:—<br />
I. Selling it Outright. -<br />
This is sometimes Satisfactory, if a proper price can be<br />
obtained. But the transaction should be managed by a<br />
competent agent, or with the advice of the Secretary of<br />
the Society.<br />
II. A Profit-Sharing Agreement (a bad form of<br />
agreement).<br />
In this case the following rules should be attended to :<br />
(1) Not to sign any agreement in which the cost of pro-<br />
duction forms a part without the strictest investigation.<br />
(2) Not to give the publisher the power of putting the<br />
profits into his own pocket by charging for advertisements<br />
in his own organs, or by charging exchange advertise-<br />
ments. Therefore keep control of the advertisements.<br />
(3.) Not to allow a special charge for “office expenses,”<br />
unless the same allowance is made to the author.<br />
(4.) Not to give up American, Colonial, or Continenta}<br />
rights.<br />
(5.) Not to give up serial or translation rights.<br />
(6.) Not to bind yourself for future work to any publisher.<br />
As well bind yourself for the future to any one solicitor or<br />
doctor |<br />
III. The Royalty System.<br />
This, is perhaps, with certain limitations, the best form<br />
of agreement. It is above all things necessary to know<br />
what the proposed royalty means to both sides. It is now<br />
possible for an author to ascertain approximately the<br />
truth. From time to time very important figures connected<br />
with royalties are published in The Author.<br />
IV. A Commission Agreement.<br />
The main points are :—<br />
(1.) Be careful to obtain a fair cost of production.<br />
(2.) Keep control of the advertisements.<br />
(3.) Keep control of the sale price of the book.<br />
General. -<br />
All other forms of agreement are combinations of the four<br />
above mentioned.<br />
Such combinations are generally disastrous to the author.<br />
Never sign any agreement without competent advice from<br />
the Secretary of the Society. -<br />
Stamp all agreements with the Inland Revenue stamp.<br />
Avoid agreements by letter if possible.<br />
The main points which the Society has always demanded<br />
from the outset are:—<br />
(1.) That both sides shall know what an agreement<br />
In ea.InS.<br />
(2.) The inspection of those account books which belong<br />
to the author. We are advised that this is a right, in the<br />
nature of a common law right, which cannot be denied or<br />
withheld.<br />
(3.) Always avoid a transfer of copyright.<br />
*—º-—a<br />
w—v-w<br />
WARNINGS TO DRAMATIC AUTHORS,<br />
—º-º-º-<br />
EVER sign an agreement without submitting it to the<br />
Secretary of the Society of Authors or some com-<br />
petent legal authority.<br />
2. It is well to be extremely careful in negotiating for<br />
the production of a play with anyone except an established<br />
manager. - .<br />
3. There are three forms of dramatic contract for plays<br />
in three or more acts:—<br />
(a.) Sale outright of the performing right. This<br />
is unsatisfactory. An author who enters into<br />
such a contract should stipulate in the contract<br />
for production of the piece by a certain date<br />
and for proper publication of his name on the<br />
play-bills.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 247 (#307) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE A LITHOR,<br />
247<br />
(b.) Sale of performing right or of a licence to<br />
perform on the basis of percentages on<br />
gross receipts. Percentages vary between 5<br />
and 15 per cent. An author should obtain a<br />
percentage on the sliding scale of gross receipts<br />
in preference to the American system. Should<br />
obtain a sum in advance of percentages. A fixed<br />
date on or before which the play should be<br />
performed. - -<br />
(c.) Sale of performing right or of a licence to<br />
perform on the basis of royalties (i.e., fixed<br />
nightly fees). This method should be always<br />
avoided except in cases where the fees are<br />
likely to be small or difficult to collect. The<br />
other safeguards set out under heading (b.) apply<br />
also in this case.<br />
4. Plays in one act are often sold outright, but it is<br />
better to obtain a small nightly fee if possible, and a sum<br />
paid in advance of such fees in any event. It is extremely<br />
important that the amateur rights of one-act plays should<br />
be reserved.<br />
5. Authors should remember that performing rights can<br />
be limited, and are usually limited, by town, country, and<br />
time. This is most important.<br />
6. Authors should not assign performing rights, but<br />
should grant a licence to perform. The legal distinction<br />
is of great importance.<br />
7. Authors should remember that performing rights in a<br />
play are distinct from literary copyright. A manager<br />
holding the performing right or licence to perform cannot<br />
print the book of the words.<br />
8. Never forget that United States rights may be exceed-<br />
ingly valuable. They should never be included in English<br />
agreements without the author obtaining a substantial<br />
consideration.<br />
9. Agreements for collaboration should be carefully<br />
drawn and executed before collaboration is commenced.<br />
10. An author should remember that production of a play<br />
is highly speculative : that he runs a very great risk of<br />
delay and a breakdown in the fulfilment of his contract.<br />
He should therefore guard himself all the more carefully in<br />
the beginning.<br />
11. An author must remember that the dramatic market<br />
is exceedingly limited, and that for a novice the first object<br />
is to obtain adequate publication.<br />
As these warnings must necessarily be incomplete, on<br />
account of the wide range of the subject of dramatic con-<br />
tracts, those authors desirous of further information<br />
are referred to the Secretary of the Society.<br />
~~<br />
REGISTRATION OF SCENARIOS.<br />
—º-º-º-<br />
CENARIOS, typewritten in duplicate on foolscap paper<br />
forwarded to the offices of the Society, together with<br />
a registration fee of two shillings and sixpence, will<br />
be carefully compared by the Secretary or a qualified assis-<br />
tant. One copy will be stamped and returned to the author<br />
and the other filed in the register of the Society. Copies<br />
of the scenario, thus filed may be obtained at any time by<br />
the author only at a small charge to cover cost of typing.<br />
WARNINGS TO MUSICAL COMPOSERS,<br />
–0–42-e—<br />
ITTLE can be added to the warnings given for the<br />
assistance of producers of books and dramatic<br />
authors. It must, however, be pointed out that, as<br />
& rule, the musical publisher demands from the musical<br />
C9mposer a transfer of fuller rights and less liberal finan-<br />
cial terms than those obtained for literary and dramatic<br />
Property. , The musical composer has very often the two<br />
rights to deal with—performing right and copyright. He<br />
should be especially careful therefore when entering into<br />
an agreement, and should take into particular consideration<br />
the warnings stated above.<br />
STAMPING MUSIC.<br />
—º-º-º-<br />
The Society undertakes to stamp copies of music on<br />
behalf of its members for the fee of 6d. per 100 or part<br />
of 100. The members’ stamps are kept in the Society's<br />
safe. The musical publishers communicate direct with the<br />
Secretary, and the voucher is then forwarded to the<br />
members, who are thus saved much unnecessary trouble.<br />
THE READING BRANCH,<br />
—º-º-º-<br />
EMBERS will greatly assist the Society in this<br />
branch of its work by informing young writers<br />
of its existence. Their MSS. can be read and<br />
treated as a composition is treated by a coach. The term<br />
MSS. includes not only works of fiction, but poetry<br />
and dramatic Works, and when it is possible, under<br />
Special arrangement, technical and scientific works. The<br />
Readers are writers of competence and experience. The<br />
fee is one guinea.<br />
* *<br />
—º-<br />
w-r-w<br />
“THE AUTHOR.”<br />
—º-º-º-<br />
HE Editor of The Author begs to remind members of<br />
T the Society that, although the paper is sent to them<br />
free of charge, the cost of producing it would be a<br />
very heavy charge on the resources of the Society if a great<br />
many members did not forward to the Secretary the modest<br />
5s. 6d. Subscription for the year.<br />
Communications for “The Author” should be addressed<br />
to the Offices of the Society, 39, Old Queen Street, Storey's<br />
Gate, S.W., and should reach the Editor not later than the<br />
21st of each month.<br />
Communications and letters are invited by the<br />
Editor on all literary matters treated from the stand-<br />
point of art or business, but on no other subjects whatever.<br />
Every effort will be made to return articles which cannot<br />
be accepted.<br />
—e—º-e—<br />
REMITTANCES,<br />
The Secretary of the Society begs to give notice<br />
that all remittances are acknowledged by return of post.<br />
All remittances should be crossed Union of London and<br />
Smith's Bank, Chancery Lane, or be sent by registered<br />
letter only.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 248 (#308) ############################################<br />
<br />
ºf the “Daily Mail.”<br />
1881.071, O<br />
d permi<br />
cin<br />
By 1<br />
GEORGE MEREDITH, O.M.<br />
1828–1909.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 249 (#309) ############################################<br />
<br />
TISIES A UTISM OR.<br />
249<br />
GEORGE MEREDITH, O.M.<br />
LL those who love the glory of English<br />
literature must have heard with the deepest<br />
regret of the death of Mr. George Mere-<br />
dith, O.M., but to members of the society the<br />
knowledge must have come with special force,<br />
because they have looked upon Mr. Meredith not<br />
only as a writer of the grandest English fiction,<br />
but as the father of their profession.<br />
As soon as it was ascertained at the offices of<br />
the society that the family of Mr. Meredith had<br />
no opposition to raise to the interment of their<br />
father in Westminster Abbey, Mr. Maurice Hew-<br />
lett (the chairman of the society) gave authority<br />
that no stone should be left unturned to obtain<br />
this object, both as an honour to the late president<br />
and as an honour to English literature. Application<br />
was at once made to the Dean, and when it became<br />
evident that the formal application by a body of<br />
2,000 authors might be insufficient to bring about<br />
the desired result, support was asked from other<br />
Quarters. The formal application of the society<br />
and the personal application of a large number of<br />
the Society's most important members and the<br />
weight of the public Press was only sufficient to<br />
obtain the sanction of the Dean to a memorial<br />
service in the Abbey. It is impossible, and it<br />
would be unseemly, to discuss the reasons that<br />
may have prompted this decision, for we feel that<br />
our late president, through his works and by his<br />
life, needs no further honour to add to the glory<br />
of his position. Mr. Meredith’s connection with<br />
the Society is, to some extent, distincte from<br />
his position as the greatest writer of fiction of<br />
the late Victorian period. Though he was not<br />
one of the original members of the society, which<br />
was founded in 1884, he joined the union of his<br />
brother authors in 1885, and was immediately<br />
elected on the council. On the death of Lord<br />
Tennyson he was nominated president.<br />
great honour to the society to have had two such<br />
presidents as Lord Tennyson and Mr. George<br />
Meredith, both of whom showed their sincere<br />
sympathy with its work. Ever since Mr. Meredith<br />
held the position he has been most active in<br />
supporting, both publicly and privately, the<br />
various efforts which the Committee of Manage-<br />
ment have taken for the body of members. He<br />
was one of the first contributors to the pension<br />
fund. On the many points put before him by the<br />
Committee of Management his interest and co-<br />
operation was of the greatest value. The Society<br />
must deeply regret that Mr. Meredith's health in<br />
these later years prevented him from being present at<br />
many of those meetings which he would gladly have<br />
attended, and with which he was in full sympathy.<br />
It is a<br />
During the present year the society has lost a<br />
good many of its oldest members and warmest<br />
supporters, but in none has it lost a more sym-<br />
pathetic friend than its president. When the<br />
Qrder of Merit was established by the King,<br />
Mr. Meredith was chosen as one of the first<br />
members.<br />
We desire on behalf of all the members to<br />
express to the family the deepest sympathy with<br />
them, in the loss that they and the country have<br />
sistained by the death of our president, George<br />
Meredith, O.M.<br />
Miss May Sinclair has been kind enough to<br />
Write an appreciation of his work, which we print<br />
below.<br />
THE FUNERAL.<br />
On Friday, May 21, the remains of Mr. George<br />
Meredith were taken from Dorking to Woking and<br />
Cremated. The members of the family alone were<br />
present at the sad ceremony. The urn containing<br />
the ashes was then re-conveyed to Dorking, and<br />
on the day following was interred in Dorking<br />
Cemetery. *<br />
The funeral was attended by Mr. Meredith's<br />
intimate friends, including several members of the<br />
Society of Authors, among whom we may mention<br />
J. M. Barrie, A. Hope Hawkins, A. E. W. Mason,<br />
Hall Caine, Charles Garvice, Mrs. W. K. Clifford,<br />
and Miss May Sinclair.<br />
A memorial service was held at 12 noon on<br />
Saturday, the 22nd, in Westminster Abbey. The<br />
north transept, allotted to members of the Society<br />
of Authors, was very nearly full.<br />
Amongst those present were the following :-<br />
Maurice Hewlett (chairman of the society),<br />
William Archer, Alfred Austin, Mackenzie Bell,<br />
Lewis Benjamin, A. C. Benson, Hall Caine, J. W.<br />
Comyns Carr, Egerton Castle, Mrs. W. K. Clifford,<br />
Edward Clodd, James Douglas, Sir Arthur Conan<br />
Doyle, Walter Emanuel, H. W. Esmond, Mrs.<br />
Frankau, Edmund Gosse, A. P. Graves, Francis<br />
Gribble, Lady Grove, Anstev Guthrie, H. Rider<br />
Haggard, Thomas Hardy, E.W. Hornung, Laurence<br />
Housman, Miss Violet Hunt, Henry James, Rud-<br />
yard Kipling, Robb Lawson, W. J. Locke, Mrs.<br />
Belloc Lowndes, Lady Lugard, Sir Alfred Lyall,<br />
J. A. Fuller Maitland, Edward Morton, A. W.<br />
Pinero, Richard Pryce, Ernest Rhys, Frank<br />
Richardson, Mrs. George Christopher Riggs, Owen<br />
Seaman, Miss May Sinclair, Keighley Snowden,<br />
Alfred Sutro, Mrs. Thurston, John Todhunter,<br />
Mrs. Alec. Tweedie, Humphry Ward (representing<br />
Mrs. Humphry Ward), Percy White, Richard<br />
Whiteing, J. H. Yoxall, M.P., Israel Zangwill.<br />
Many other distinguished ladies and gentlemen<br />
were also present ready to pay the last honour to<br />
the great author. We may mention the Prime<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 250 (#310) ############################################<br />
<br />
250<br />
TISIES A CITES OF.<br />
-Eºº-º-º-m<br />
Minister, Sir Philip Burne-Jones, Miss Ellen Terry,<br />
Beerbohm Tree, Sir Squire Bancroft, Forbes<br />
Robertson, and Holman Hunt. -<br />
The service was most impressive. It opened<br />
with Beethoven's Funeral March from the Sonata<br />
in A flat, followed by the 51st Psalm.<br />
Then followed other psalms and prayers chosen<br />
for the occasion. The service closed with Watts'<br />
beautiful hymn, “O God, our Help in ages past,”<br />
which was sung by the whole congregation, and<br />
after the Benediction Chopin's Funeral March<br />
in B flat minor was played—all the congregation<br />
standing till the last notes of the organ had died<br />
away.<br />
GEORGE MEREDITH.*<br />
BY MAY SINCLAIR.<br />
EORGE MEREDITH was born before his<br />
time, and he has died before it, as a young<br />
man dies. For fifty-five years he laboured,<br />
bringing forth the long and splendid procession of<br />
his masterpieces, from “The Ordeal of Richard<br />
Feverel,” a novel of absolute and incomparable<br />
greatness, to “The Amazing Marriage,” which<br />
would alone have proved greatness in a lesser man.<br />
And he has not yet come into his own. He is<br />
king to the kings and the great lords of literature,<br />
but he can in no way be said to reign by the voice<br />
of the Sovran people. After a long period of<br />
obscurity he has passed into the eternal possession<br />
of the few. But, although by a dreadful fate he<br />
became for a time the prey of the cultured who are<br />
fairly numerous, the great heavy mass of people<br />
who read, or think they read, cannot stand Meredith.<br />
And to-day, among the cultured and the critical<br />
who do read him, there is a reaction against him.<br />
Nobody doubts his greatness, nor the divinity of<br />
it. Nobody dares suggest that he did not produce<br />
great literature: the tendency is to complain that<br />
it was literature that he insisted on reproducing<br />
and not life. Some of us deny that he was either<br />
a great novelist or a great poet.<br />
The younger generation of novelists are all for a<br />
conscientious realism, and we have a few young<br />
critics who are conscientious too. And Meredith<br />
is peculiarly baffling to these. He eludes all their<br />
attempts to catch and label him. He seems to<br />
them now a realist of considerable piety and now a<br />
romantic of the kind they most abhor. Already,<br />
before his death, they were trying to place him.<br />
They are painfully anxious, elaborately careful<br />
not to place him wrong. And he refuses to be<br />
placed.<br />
sº-<br />
* Copyright in the United States.<br />
He did away with their preposterous labels once<br />
for all twenty-three years ago when, in the first<br />
chapter of “Diana of the Crossways,” he proclaimed<br />
himself a prophet of “the real,” and at the same<br />
time told us that our realists were our “castigators<br />
for not having yet embraced philosophy.”<br />
He defined fiction as “the summary of actual<br />
life, the within and the without of us.” It was as a<br />
novelist, a Writer of fiction, that he came forward<br />
for judgment, and it is as a novelist that they<br />
arraign him to-day, allowing him to be a philosopher<br />
and, perhaps, as it were by the skin of his teeth,<br />
a poet. -<br />
Now, to measure his greatness, not as a philoso-<br />
pher, nor yet as a poet, but as a novelist, we must<br />
remember the position of the novelist in the<br />
Victorian age. He found himself between the<br />
devil of realism and the deep sea of sentiment : a<br />
horrible position. It distorted his whole attitude<br />
to life and his view of the real. Meredith was the<br />
first to deliver the English novel from that degrada-<br />
tion. He was the first to see that it is sentiment<br />
and not conscience that makes novelists cowards.<br />
He recognised sentimentalism for what it is : the<br />
“fine flower of sensualism,” and through its very<br />
fineness the subtlest source of spiritual corruption.<br />
He knew that sentiment—early Victorian senti-<br />
ment—piled to its height, topples over into the<br />
mire. He saw it as the mother of all shams and all<br />
hypocrisies, the nurse of monstrous illusions.<br />
Thackeray, the greatest novelist of his time, who<br />
stood nearest to Meredith in sincerity and fear-<br />
lessness, and hatred of shams—Thackeray was<br />
afraid, and put it on record that he was afraid, to<br />
tell the truth about a man. He said it in his<br />
preface to “Pendennis,” and he laid his cowardice<br />
to the account of the society who had brought<br />
fiction to this pass.<br />
Meredith knew nothing of that fear. “Imagine,”<br />
he said, “the celestial refreshment of having a<br />
pure decency in the place of sham, real flesh, a<br />
Soul born active, wind-beaten, but ascending.<br />
Honourable will fiction then appear; honourable, a<br />
fount of life, an aid to live, quick with our blood.<br />
Why, when you behold it you love it—and you<br />
will not encourage it—or only when presented by<br />
dead hands 2"<br />
His message to his generation was, “ Follow the<br />
real. To not be led by the tainted sentimental<br />
lure. Trust yourselves to Nature, though she<br />
make havoc of your sentiment.” For, at the<br />
heart of Nature he discerned the fiery spiritual<br />
pulse, through and beyond Nature the purifying<br />
liberated flame. Thus he escapes his captors who<br />
Would hold him to pure paganism.<br />
The unity of Nature and spirit, and the return<br />
to spirit through Nature, is Meredith’s philosophy<br />
He found his generation sickly, and for the cure of<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 251 (#311) ############################################<br />
<br />
A UTISIOR.<br />
251<br />
its sickliness he prescribedſº By passages express his own emotions, and not the<br />
philosophy he did not mean/anything abstract, emotions of his characters, and this is why he fails<br />
anything in the least metapºsical, anything really<br />
incomprehensible to Quraíbiter of letters, the man<br />
in the street. Mgredith’s philosophy is brain-<br />
stuff, thought tha; makes up half of the fabric of<br />
the world. “Idéa,” he said, “is vital.” He was<br />
an idealist only to that extent. Brains, to be any<br />
good, mºtist have blood in them, and that is where<br />
the heart comes in. No man, no writer, had a<br />
greater and a fierier heart at the service of his<br />
brain. And so again he escapes the grasp of those<br />
who would place him among the unhumanised,<br />
inaccessible exponents of the cold idea, who say<br />
that his appeal, was not to the universal human<br />
heart but to the by no means universal human<br />
intellect.<br />
Now our conscientious young critics have no<br />
quarrel with Meredith's philosophy as a philosophy.<br />
Their contention is that, as a novelist, he had no<br />
right to have any philosophy at all. They resent<br />
it as an unwarrantable interference with his drama,<br />
an irritating interruption to his story. They<br />
attack it on artistic grounds, and because of it<br />
they persuade themselves that Meredith was not a<br />
great novelist. Which only proves that they have<br />
forgotten their Meredith. ...Nobody who reads his<br />
novels with any care will find his philosophy<br />
intruding where it can do harm. You will not<br />
come across it at any of the intenser psychological<br />
moments, in any of the great dramatic scenes, or<br />
in any of his inspired passages. It is at its height<br />
in “Diana” and “The Egoist,” but even there it<br />
is confined to the prologue and the interludes.<br />
Except by way of comment, it is almost entirely<br />
absent from “Richard Feverel,” “Rhoda Fleming,”<br />
“Evan Harrington,” “Harry Richmond,” and<br />
“Beauchamp's Career.”<br />
For Meredith was before all things a great<br />
dramatist and a great psychologist, if he was not<br />
always a straightforward teller of his tale. And to<br />
be those two things is, I take it, to be a great<br />
novelist, even if a man happens to have at the<br />
same time an irritating philosophy.<br />
Other and more serious charges have been<br />
brought against him by our cautious and yet<br />
irritable young men. We are all tired of hearing<br />
that Meredith is obscure, that he sins by excess,<br />
by a vice of temperament, by all sorts of exuberance<br />
and eccentricity. It tires us, and it annoys us,<br />
too; for we feel that there is a certain truth in it.<br />
But we are also told that he is not a great novelist,<br />
not a novelist at all, for the simple reason that he<br />
is a poet. And that is interesting. To be a poet,<br />
it would seem, is even more disastrous than to be a<br />
philosopher. For, after all, Meredith's philosophy<br />
embraced the real. But his poetry, they tell us,<br />
spoils all that. Because, you see, his lyrical<br />
though he knows it not.<br />
to produce the “illusion of reality.”<br />
It sounds plausible ; it looks as if there might<br />
be a certain amount of truth in it. But that is<br />
only at first sight. Meredith's lyric passages are<br />
there precisely because they do express as nothing<br />
else could the emotion of his characters. For<br />
emotion, at its climax, is powerless to express<br />
itself or anything. Lucy in love, Richard in love,<br />
are dumb, but all heaven is sounding through<br />
them, and it is that sound of all heaven which<br />
Meredith’s prose gives us. True, his method<br />
destroys the spectacular illusion for a moment, but<br />
it does so that it may preserve the illusion of<br />
emotion, of passion, of reality at its highest<br />
intensity. Compare him with Dickens in this<br />
matter of emotion. Dickens, working himself up<br />
into blank verse over the death of little Nell, is<br />
Dickens feeling something about little Nell and<br />
trying to express his feeling. But Meredith in his<br />
“Diversion Played on a Penny Whistle” is<br />
rendering the song of the souls of Richard and<br />
Lucy. They, poor dears, can only say:<br />
“Lucy, my beloved l’’<br />
“Oh, Richard ’’<br />
It is all part of his art, his very perfect art.<br />
And it is the same with the “Comic Spirit.”<br />
The Comic Spirit is not Meredith. It is the Spirit<br />
immanent in the world, and akin to Mr. Hardy's<br />
immortal Ironies. It is part-creative. Even in<br />
“The Egoist,” where it is rampant, its play is not<br />
the play of the author intoxicated by his own wit,<br />
13.aking merry over the behaviour of Sir Willoughby<br />
Patterne. It is not doing anything over or about<br />
or around Sir Willoughby. It is really in him,<br />
The Comic Spirit is an<br />
aspect of the cosmic reality in which Sir Willoughby<br />
has his being. For the essence of Sir Willoughby<br />
is to be absurd, and the Comic Spirit, exposing his<br />
absurdity, is the revealer of the eternal verity<br />
in him.<br />
Meredith never destroys the “illusion of<br />
reality.” It is the illusion of actuality that he<br />
tampers with. It may be conceded at once that he<br />
had not a very keen sense of the actual or of local<br />
atmosphereandsurroundings. His characters appear<br />
to be surrounded only by the cosmic spaces. He<br />
does not present them circumscribed by any<br />
parochial or urban or suburban boundary. He<br />
seldom if ever paints an interior. His scenic<br />
effects we remember best are always of the open<br />
air. At the same time he has a profound sense of<br />
the bonds, restrictions, distinctions of society and<br />
race and class. For these things work in the flesh<br />
and blood of a man : they are part of the drama of<br />
his soul. That is what Meredith shows us in<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 252 (#312) ############################################<br />
<br />
252<br />
TRIES A [ſ'ſ<br />
“Rhoda Fleming,” in “Beauchamp's Career,” in<br />
“Harry Richmond,” and in “Evan Harrington,”<br />
all masterly reproductions of English social and<br />
provincial life in the Victorian age.<br />
But they tell us that it is not Meredith’s method<br />
only that is all wrong. Art, they sav, is concerned<br />
only with the average, the normal (let it pass),<br />
and Meredith wrote of extraordinary people in an<br />
extraordinary way. This, we are to believe, applies<br />
especially to his women. They are all goddesses,<br />
or if not goddesses, all women six feet high. In<br />
this, they tell us, his art is inferior to that of Mr.<br />
Hardy. If he desired immortality he should have<br />
written about simple people in a simple way. He<br />
should have chosen for his tragedies the elemental<br />
passions, and treated them elementally. He should<br />
have written, in short, like Mr. Hardy.<br />
On the other hand we also hear that, setting out<br />
as he does to be subtle, he is not half subtle<br />
enough. He should, to produce the perfect illusion<br />
of reality, have written more like Mr. Henry James.<br />
As it is, he is a victim to the fallacy of the master-<br />
passion, the dominant note in character, and thus<br />
he gives us bare types, instead of the rich, intricate<br />
web of inconsistencies, the splendid irrelevancies<br />
and surprises which make up individuality in real<br />
life. Sir Willoughby Patterne, for instance, is an<br />
egoist and nothing but an egoist ; and no man ever<br />
was nothing but one thing.<br />
This is strange criticism of a man who knew<br />
more than any other how to reproduce the very<br />
accent and gesture of the soul. What justice<br />
there is in it applies only to “The Egoist.” There<br />
Meredith comes perilously near to the artificial<br />
comedy of Molière where the misanthrope is always<br />
a misanthrope, and Tartuffe for ever Tartuffe. In<br />
real life, that is to say, in the eyes of the omniscient or<br />
of Mr. Henry James, Sir Willoughby Patterne would<br />
not perhaps appear so manifestly and invariably the<br />
egoist he is. It is equally true that in real fife if a<br />
man is an egoist he will believe and he will<br />
feel remarkably like Sir Willoughby Patterne.<br />
And our critics have forgotten Clara Middleton,<br />
Cecilia, and all the irrelevancies and inconsistencies<br />
of the divine Diana. Mr. Henry James would be<br />
the first to take off his hat to them.<br />
As for the everlasting comparison with Mr. Hardy,<br />
it is futile, as any comparison must be between two<br />
masters equally supreme in their separate territories.<br />
But it raises interesting questions: Are their<br />
territories, after all, so separate 2 Is it true that<br />
Meredith did not understand elemental men and<br />
women It is certainly true that he wrote mostly<br />
about people in whom either breeding, or education,<br />
or the possession of a restless intellect obscures the<br />
working of the large tragic passions. The modern<br />
world is full of such—full, above all, of such women.<br />
And Meredith claimed to have discovered the<br />
modern woman, “animated . . . with the fires of<br />
positive brain-stuff.' He was the first to see that<br />
the sentimentalism \{again ) of his time was<br />
degradation to its women, s.<br />
Even Thackeray, with his exceeding tenderness<br />
and chivalry, Thackeray who owned himself afraid<br />
to tell the truth about a man, did not know as<br />
Meredith knew the truth about a woman. Or<br />
perhaps he knew it, and was still more afraid.<br />
Meredith knew the truth and the whole truth, and<br />
dared to tell it, dared to give the leading role to<br />
those large-brained, large-hearted women of his— .<br />
Diana and Clara, and Ottila and Cecilie Halkett,<br />
and Rose Jocelyn, Aminta and Carinthia Jane.<br />
Charlotte Brontë's Shirley, and the great women of<br />
George Eliot–Maggie Tulliver, Dorothea Brooke<br />
and Dinah Morris—are small beside them. They<br />
are modern women, and we cannot complain of<br />
their stature as abnormal, for modern women are<br />
often six feet high.<br />
These are his extraordinary women. But when he<br />
chose he could draw very ordinary women, and men<br />
too, and drew them as the masters draw. Look at<br />
Ripton Thompson, Algernon Blancous, Mrs. Lovell,<br />
“Emmy" and Sir Lukin, Jenny Denham ; even<br />
Nevil Beauchamp is not extraordinary in our critics’<br />
sense ; and the list could be extended indefinitely.<br />
As for the elemental and the simple people, Tess<br />
is not more elemental in her tragedy than Clare<br />
Doria Forey or Dahlia Fleming or even poor Juley<br />
in “Evan Harrington.” And Thomas in “Yeo-<br />
bright” is not more divinely simple than Lucy<br />
Feverel, nor is Rhoda Fleming less captivating in<br />
her moral beauty than Marty South. For the rest,<br />
Hardy's women and Meredith's women are “sisters<br />
under their skin.”<br />
Still, it is inevitable to place Hardy and Meredith<br />
side by side, for they are the last of our great<br />
novelists, and in many ways they are akin. Both<br />
are philosophers, both poets, and in both philosophy<br />
is, like their poetry, the result of temperament.<br />
Mr. Hardy's genius is bound to make for the<br />
simpler and the larger tragedy, seeing that he<br />
regards the lives of men and women as so many<br />
sacrifices to the eternal, insatiable lust of Nature,<br />
and they themselves as the playthings of an<br />
implacably ironic Destiny.<br />
But to Meredith, Nature, for all her darkness and<br />
austerity, is the mother of all joy, of all the sanities<br />
and sanctities. The natural love of men and<br />
women was to him of all things the sanest and most<br />
sacred. Their tragedy is not their subservience to<br />
Nature, but their falling from her, their sins against<br />
her immanent deity.<br />
His poems sprang from this joy of his genius in<br />
Nature, its adoration of all the robust and splendid<br />
energies of life. Our young critics, more con-<br />
Scientious than ever as they approach this divinest<br />
l—<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 253 (#313) ############################################<br />
<br />
i<br />
7<br />
#<br />
THE AUTHOR. 253<br />
side of him, have suggested that his philosophy<br />
spoils his poems as it spoils his novels. They cite<br />
“The Reading of Earth” and “The Woods of<br />
Westermain.” To be sure in all his great Nature<br />
poems there are aisles and dells of darkness, inter-<br />
minable secret mazes, lost ways of “The Questions”<br />
traversing the Enchanted Woods. Yet every way<br />
faithfully followed leads us into almost intolerable<br />
light. Something happens, and we find the<br />
Meredithian philosophy (which was, after all, more<br />
an instinct than a philosophy) transmuted into the<br />
Meredithian mysticism as by fire. His message sings<br />
clear :<br />
“Then your spirit will perceive<br />
Fleshly seed of fleshly sins,<br />
Where the passions interweave<br />
How the serpent tangle spins<br />
Of the sense of Earth misprised<br />
Brainlessly unrecognised<br />
She being Spirit in her clods<br />
Footway to the God of Gods.”<br />
But besides “The Woods of Westermain '' and<br />
“The Reading of Earth,” Meredith wrote “The<br />
Lark Ascending,” that continuous, lucid, liquid<br />
song of rapture:—<br />
“Shrill, irreflective, unrestrained,<br />
Rapt, ringing, on the jet sustained<br />
Without a break, without a fall,<br />
Sweet-silvery, sheer lyrical.”<br />
He wrote “Love in the Walley,” and that pro-<br />
foundest, subtlest, most concentrated of human<br />
tragedies, “ Modern Love.” There are lines there<br />
that gleam and cut like steel, dividing the intricate<br />
web of soul and body. It is the dissection of heart-<br />
nerves and brain-cells, a lacerating psychology<br />
masquerading in a procession of linked quatrains.<br />
Yet the same genius, so delicately analytic,<br />
brought forth with a stupendous and Titanic<br />
energy the “Ballads and Poems of Tragic Life.”<br />
Among these is “The Nuptials of Attila,” where<br />
the verse rushes downwards in tumult and in<br />
torrent like the hosts of the armoured Huns, a<br />
poem barbaric, superb, resonant with the clamour<br />
of battle. There is “IXing Harald's Trance,” a<br />
masterpiece of grim and terrible simplicity. And<br />
there is “The Song of Theodolinda,” that supreme<br />
hymn of the passion of martyrdom, of divine<br />
ecstasy in torture, of torture perishing in ecstasy.<br />
The most perfervid passages of Crashaw's<br />
Hymn to Saint Teresa are cold beside Meredith's<br />
fire. And the art of it is transcendent. Every<br />
line glows with furnace heat, and beats in its<br />
terrible assonances, with the strokes of the<br />
hammer :<br />
“This that killed Thee, kissed Thee, Lord<br />
Touched Thee, and we touch it : dear,<br />
Dark it is ; adored, abhorred,<br />
Wilest, yet most sainted here.<br />
Red of heat, 0 white of heat,<br />
In it hell and heaven meet,<br />
× × :: :::<br />
Brand me, bite me, bitter thing !<br />
Thus He felt, and thus I am<br />
One with Him in suffering<br />
One with Him in bliss, the Lamb.<br />
Red of heat, O white of heat,<br />
This is bitterness made sweet.<br />
Now am I who bear that stamp<br />
Scorched in me, the living sign<br />
Sole on earth—the lighted lamp<br />
Of the dreadful day divine.<br />
White of heat, beat on it fast<br />
Red of heat, its shape has passed.<br />
>{< >}. >k *:<br />
Rindle me to constant fire,<br />
Lest the nail be but a nail<br />
Give me wings of great desire,<br />
Lest I look within and fail<br />
Red of heat, the furnace light,<br />
White of heat, fix on my sight.<br />
Never for the chosen peace<br />
Know, by me tormented know,<br />
Never shall the wrestling cease<br />
Till with our outlasting Foe<br />
Red of heat to white of heat<br />
Roll we to the Godhead's feet !<br />
Beat, beat White of heat,<br />
Red of heat, beat, beat l”<br />
w<br />
If he had written nothing else, that one poem<br />
would be enough to ensure his immortality.<br />
And some of the younger generation, which is<br />
so conscientious and so cautious, are wondering<br />
whether Meredith will live. Posterity, they think,<br />
is hardly likely to tolerate what his contemporaries<br />
cannot endure. There is much in him, they say,<br />
which is intolerable.<br />
Well, there is much in Fielding, in Scott, in<br />
Thackeray which is intolerable. And yet they<br />
live. We still read Fielding, in spite of his per-<br />
petual digressions and the essays with which he<br />
dislocates his chapters. We read Scott in spite<br />
of his interminable descriptive passages; and<br />
Thackeray in spite of his digressions, and of his<br />
mortal tendency to moralise in all places of his<br />
narrative. It is only reasonable to suppose that<br />
Meredith will be read in spite of everything, even<br />
of his obscurity. For nothing can kill the novelist<br />
if the novelist is there ; and in all Meredith’s<br />
novels the novelist is supreme. Who when he<br />
thinks of “The Egoist" really remembers anything<br />
but the sublime performances of Sir Willoughby<br />
Patterne or the ways of Clara Middleton 2 Who<br />
would dream of judging the terrible and poignant<br />
tragedy of Richard Feverel by fragments from the<br />
pilgrim's scrip Who as he sees Diana keeping<br />
her watch by her dead friend, or kneeling by the<br />
hearth of Crossways House, will be unchivalrous<br />
enough to remember her as a woman who attempted<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 254 (#314) ############################################<br />
<br />
254<br />
TriB A UTHOR.<br />
more epigrams than she ever brought to perfection ?<br />
And there is Emmy under the surgeon's knife and<br />
Sir Lukin raving in his remorse. There is Emilia<br />
forsaken and Dahlia betrayed, and they are flesh<br />
and blood that no “idea,” no philosophy can<br />
destroy. And flesh and blood they had need be to<br />
stand in the presence of their creator. Meredith’s<br />
personality is so overpowering that at times it<br />
comes between us and his creations. He has not,<br />
as lesser men have had, the habit of detachment.<br />
No novelist has it completely, nor can have it.<br />
He betrays his own nature more subtly or more<br />
inevitably than any other artist, for he handles<br />
directly the stuff of life, and we know him by the<br />
manner of his handling. It is impossible to read<br />
Meredith without seeing him to be before all things<br />
clean-souled and courageous and passionately<br />
sincere. We divine that there is no greatness and<br />
no splendour in his work that had not its match in<br />
him. His powers were finely mingled.<br />
intellect was blood-warm and had a heart in it,<br />
beating like a pulse of flame, and emotion in him<br />
was a spiritual thing, as if the courses of his blood<br />
flashed light. To feel with him was to see more<br />
and not less clearly.<br />
It is not conceivable that he will not live, he<br />
who had more life, more virile, fertilising energy<br />
than any Writer of the two generations that he<br />
saw rise round him and pass away before him. Our<br />
own generation will return to him, wearied of the<br />
lucid excellencies of the lesser men, their finished<br />
perfection within the limits of the little. He was<br />
too great for us. If some of us have lost sight of<br />
him it is not because they have left him behind<br />
them with the Victorian era ; it is because they<br />
have not yet “caught up.” He was too swift for<br />
us. He has passed us by, and only thus can we<br />
conceive of him as passing. He has not yielded<br />
up his fire to any one of us. He is on far<br />
ahead with his torch, holding high for us the<br />
inextinguishable flame.<br />
MAY SINCLAIR.<br />
—e—º-e—<br />
GENERAL NOTES.<br />
—0-0-0–<br />
THE Editor of The Author would be much<br />
obliged if any member who happens to possess a<br />
copy of the November (1907) issue would forward<br />
the same to the office for the benefit of the society's<br />
file, which is short of this issue.<br />
*- -<br />
SCHOLZ v. AMASIS.<br />
WE are pleased to chronicle that the appeal in<br />
the Scholz v. Amasis case, supported by the Society<br />
His .<br />
of Authors, has been successfully upheld. The<br />
judges of the Court of Appeal were unanimous<br />
that Mr. Fenn's version was not an infringe-<br />
ment of Mr. Scholz's rights. Members of the<br />
Society may call to mind that when Mr. Fenn<br />
put the matter into the society’s hands the com-<br />
mittee took the opinion of counsel, Mr. Eldon<br />
Bankes, before deciding what course should be<br />
taken. The members of the committee themselves<br />
were of the opinion that no infringement had<br />
occurred, but they considered it necessary that their<br />
opinion should be supported. The opinion of the<br />
society’s counsel has been amply justified by the<br />
result of the case.<br />
All infringements of copyright or performing<br />
right must depend upon the facts of each individual<br />
case, and are matters of evidence rather than of<br />
law. It is too late to report the case fully in this<br />
month's Author, but we hope to be able to publish<br />
any points of special interest in the July number.<br />
*-<br />
THE CENSOR.<br />
MEMBERS of the Society may call to mind that<br />
Mr. Harcourt's Theatre and Music Hall Bill was<br />
carefully studied by the Dramatic Sub-Committee<br />
and approved by them. It appears that a question<br />
was raised in Parliament on May 27 owing to the<br />
recent action of the Censor. Mr. Asquith, in reply,<br />
said that he thought the position of Dramatic<br />
Censorship was a most important matter, and that<br />
it was receiving careful consideration. He stated<br />
further that he thought the time had come for<br />
establishing a Select Committee to consider the<br />
position.<br />
INJUSTICE TO CANADIAN BOOKSELLERS.<br />
IN The Bookseller and Stationer, published in<br />
Toronto, there is an article headed “Injustice to<br />
the Canadian Bookseller.” On reading the article,<br />
we see the writer complains that there are certain<br />
books copyrighted in Canada which are now out of<br />
print, that the copyright owners refuse, or, for<br />
reasons of their own, do not desire to publish<br />
further editions. The booksellers think that there<br />
are still sales for the books, but they are unable to<br />
import cheap United States reprints, because by<br />
so doing they would be infringing the copyright of<br />
the Canadian holder.<br />
Two points suggest themselves. The first is,<br />
why should the Canadian bookseller think he has<br />
any right in the property of another person It is<br />
the old, old story. For so many years authors'<br />
rights were not recognised at all that the public<br />
began to consider the property was not the<br />
author's, but belonged to them. To this day the<br />
limitation of the term of copyright makes it clear<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 255 (#315) ############################################<br />
<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
255.<br />
that the same feeling still exists. According to<br />
the Canadian bookseller's argument, supposing<br />
Jones purchases a book, reads it and puts it on the<br />
shelf of his library, and does not use it, and has no<br />
intention of using it again, he is sinning against<br />
the public, for he ought, of course, either to give it<br />
away or to sell it to Some other person. Or, again,<br />
Supposing Jones bought a nice bit of freehold in<br />
the country, and found, for certain reasons, that<br />
he was unable to utilise it in any way, the book-<br />
seller would argue, other people might come and<br />
demand that they had a right to use it whether he<br />
liked it or not. So long as there are any private<br />
rights in property the argument cannot stand. If<br />
it does not apply to property in land or to personal<br />
property, it applies still less to that property which,<br />
of all others, is the outcome of a man's personal<br />
effort. . If, therefore, the Canadian copyright<br />
owner doesn't want to publish a cheap edition of a<br />
book, there ought to be no power which could force<br />
him to do so, and the Canadian bookseller has no<br />
more right to complain than he would have in the<br />
instances quoted. This is the first point.<br />
The Second point refers to the Canadian<br />
trade. Most of the Canadian copyrights are, we<br />
believe, held by the Canadian publishers. If,<br />
therefore, the Canadian tradesman who is living<br />
by the exploitation of his property, chooses to lose<br />
a considerable income by the non-exploitation of<br />
this property, it only tends to prove that he is a<br />
bad tradesman. If American publishers and<br />
Canadian booksellers can make profits by selling<br />
cheap editions, Canadian publishers should be able<br />
equally to make profits by exploiting their pro-<br />
perty in the same way. That they do not do so<br />
shows a lack of enterprise which we should have<br />
hardly expected in that advancing colony, but we<br />
have on former occasions suspected something of<br />
the same kind when the question of Canadian<br />
Sales of the works of English authors has arisen.<br />
An enterprising Canadian publisher, with some<br />
capital behind him, could make better terms and<br />
find a better market by contracting with the<br />
English author direct than he could by purchasing<br />
plates or by purchasing the right for the Canadian<br />
edition, using the American publisher as middle-<br />
man. It might be worth while for the Canadian<br />
publisher to consider the position seriously.<br />
MISS RACHEL CHALLICE.<br />
WE regret to record the death of Miss Rachel<br />
Challice, who has for some time past contributed<br />
the Spanish Notes to the columns of The Author.<br />
Although a busy journalist, as well as a writer of<br />
books, she found time month by month, without<br />
any hope of reward beyond the appreciation of her<br />
fellow members, to assist with her work the aim<br />
and objects of the society. She was an enthusiastic<br />
Supporter of the best interests of the members of<br />
her profession, and was well known in the literary<br />
circles of Spain about which she wrote. She<br />
represented the Society of Authors on the occasion<br />
of the Cervantes celebration in Spain, and placed<br />
a Wreath from the society on the author's<br />
monument. Her last work, “The Secret History<br />
of the Court of Spain,” will appear shortly. It is<br />
taken entirely from Spanish sources.<br />
—º-—-<br />
~-sº-w<br />
IS HE 2<br />
–0-º-e-<br />
WO or three months ago Mr. H. G. Wells<br />
referred in the columns of this paper to<br />
the literary agent as “that indispensable<br />
middleman.” Ever since reading that expression,<br />
I have been wondering if the literary agent really<br />
is “indispensable,” and lately I have looked<br />
through my books to remind myself of my own<br />
past experiences. I found them interesting, for I<br />
had never before viewed them “in bulk,” so to<br />
speak, and under the impression that they may be<br />
of interest to others, they are here set down.<br />
Let me begin by saying that while for obvious<br />
reasons I do not give names, every detail is taken<br />
exactly from my books, for of course I keep a<br />
record of every manuscript, of the 700 word articles<br />
as of the 100,000 word novel. Let me also say<br />
that I have no complaint against my agent, whom<br />
I found invariably courteous and business-like, and<br />
who is also one of the best known men in his pro-<br />
fession. Of course I paid him, and he asked for,<br />
nothing except what he earned by commission on<br />
stories placed, for I hold the agent who demands.<br />
an advance fee to be nothing more than an open<br />
freebooter, living on the Vanity or ignorance of the<br />
struggling aspirant.<br />
During my connection, then, with my agent, I<br />
placed in his hands five long stories. He succeeded<br />
in selling the serial rights in one, obtaining for<br />
them the sum of £30. He made no attempt to<br />
place the story as a volume, and, the serial publica-<br />
tion having been completed, I am now offering it<br />
myself to a publisher. The other four stories,<br />
when I severed connection with him, the agent<br />
returned to me.<br />
The first of these he had offered in fourteen<br />
quarters without success. I offered it myself to<br />
one firm, who refused it. I then offered it to.<br />
another firm, who bought the serial rights for £45.<br />
I then disposed of the volume rights, and it has<br />
recently been published in volume form on a 15 per<br />
cent. royalty, and a promise of 20 per cent. should<br />
it reach a sale of 2,000 copies, which I am afraid.<br />
it shows no signs of doing.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 256 (#316) ############################################<br />
<br />
256<br />
THE AUTISIOR.<br />
The second of these long stories my agent<br />
had offered in nine quarters. The first firm<br />
to whom I offered it after its return to me gave<br />
me £80 for the serial rights. I have not yet<br />
offered it for volume publication.<br />
The third story my agent had offered ten times<br />
without success. I have offered it to three editors,<br />
but have not yet effected a sale, but it is going out<br />
again next month.<br />
The fourth story the agent offered twelve times,<br />
and I have offered it four times. This I am<br />
inclined to withdraw permanently, but may offer it<br />
again if a suitable opening occurs.<br />
So much for long stories. In addition I sent<br />
the agent a number of short stories. I will take<br />
them one by one. - -<br />
No. 1. Agent sold it for £10 10s. for British<br />
serial rights.<br />
No. 2. The agent offered it to nine editors.<br />
The first editor to whom I offered it gave me<br />
f1 10s. for the copyright.<br />
No. 3. The agent sold this for £4 12s. 6d. for<br />
British serial rights. -<br />
No. 4. This was offered by my agent ten times<br />
in vain. I offered it sixteen times equally in vain,<br />
and then sold it to a leading magazine for £8 5s.<br />
for British serial rights, and have since received a<br />
fee of 10s. 6d. for translation into Danish.<br />
No. 5. Offered nine times in vain by the agent,<br />
then returned to me. I offered it twenty times<br />
more, and then sold it for a guinea, which I was<br />
very glad to get.<br />
No. 6. My agent offered this to six editors, and<br />
then returned it to me. The first editor to whom<br />
I sent it gave me £2 2s. for it.<br />
No. 7. Neither the agent nor I succeeded in<br />
disposing of this. -<br />
No. 8. The agent offered this to nine editors,<br />
and then returned it to me. I sold it to perhaps<br />
the best known popular magazine in the world,<br />
receiving £15 15s. for all serial rights. ;<br />
No. 9. This, too, neither the agent nor I<br />
succeeded with.<br />
No. 10. My agent had this declined eight times.<br />
I sold it for three guineas at the fourth attempt.<br />
No. 11. My agent informed me that this had<br />
been lost by an editor to whom he had submitted<br />
it. I re-typed the story, and submitted it direct<br />
to the same editor, who gave me £3 3s? for the<br />
copyright.<br />
No. 12. The agent disposed of this for £7 18. 94.<br />
for British serial rights.<br />
No. 13. Both the agent and I failed with this.<br />
One editor told me it was too funny. -<br />
No. 14. Both the agent and I failed with this.<br />
One editor told me it was too gruesome.<br />
No. 15. Another failure for us both.<br />
No. 16. Also a failure for both of us.<br />
Therefore with regard to my long stories, the<br />
agent disposed of one MS. out of five ; that is, he<br />
sold 20 per cent. of my work. Of the four MSS.<br />
he returned, I have so far sold two, or 50 per cent.<br />
He obtained £30, I obtained £125, with more to<br />
come for royalties. •<br />
Of the sixteen short stories I placed in his hands<br />
he sold three, for a total of £22 4s. 3d. Of the<br />
thirteen short stories he failed with and returned<br />
to me, I have sold seven for a total of £35 9s. 6d.<br />
These figures are slightly more complicated than<br />
those for the long stories, so I will leave the<br />
comparative percentages to be worked out by<br />
Somebody more mathematically gifted than I am.<br />
I perceive, however, that I secured £13 5s. 3d.<br />
more than did my agent.<br />
The agent could claim, though, that he secured<br />
on the average, not invariably, a higher rate per<br />
thousand than I got for myself. Also I had<br />
generally to sell copyright or all serial rights. My<br />
agent never sold anything but British serial rights,<br />
all minor rights thus being retained by me. They<br />
have never been any good to me, but it is comforting<br />
to possess them.<br />
Then, too, the agent's dealings with my MSS.<br />
were confined to fifteen months—one year's agree-<br />
ment, and three months’ motice to terminate it.<br />
My own operations with the MSS. he returned me<br />
have extended over a longer time, from then to<br />
now, in fact, while some of the MSS. still left me I<br />
yet hope to dispose of ultimately. So that I have<br />
had the advantage of more time ; but I suppose I<br />
can say that it was the cream of my work that he<br />
disposed of, so that he had a great advantage there.<br />
I am left wondering if the agent be really<br />
indispensable. That he is indispensable to himself<br />
I can well believe. That when an author has<br />
achieved fame and fortune an agent is indispens-<br />
able, may also be the case. No doubt motor-cars<br />
become indispensable then. I do not know, but<br />
shall be happy to give a personal opinion at the<br />
earliest possible moment. It is different, however,<br />
from the point of view of the mere average rear<br />
rank and filer—the man to whom his cheques are<br />
not as the accustomed tribute of the triumphant<br />
conqueror, but are rather each one the record of a<br />
doubtful and hardly won success.<br />
From my own small experience I am inclined to<br />
say that perseverance is indispensable ; that the<br />
Postmaster-General is certainly indispensable ;<br />
but as for the agent being indispensable—Well,<br />
is he<br />
X Y. Z.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 257 (#317) ############################################<br />
<br />
\ .<br />
}<br />
.." /<br />
A PLUTOGRAT OF THE PREss; OR, THE<br />
- CYNIC'S SUCCESS.<br />
—º-º-e—<br />
(Continued.)<br />
D before a handsome writing-table, piled<br />
ith papers, documents, and copies of the<br />
rous publications his will controlled,<br />
was th § man. Great in one sense only, be it<br />
unders bysically he cut rather a poor figure,<br />
with hy Nagne-bottle shoulders, pale com-<br />
Male eyes, and hay-coloured hair. His<br />
demeanour, however, was self-assured, as every<br />
prosperous man's must be.<br />
We exchanged rather searching glances.<br />
Something in the famous publisher's manner<br />
recalled a once familiar personage; but I could not<br />
“place " him right away.<br />
Then he spoke. His was a thin voice, yet it<br />
served to give me the cue I wanted.<br />
“Why,” I exclaimed half involuntarily, “you are<br />
Wynyard Graves.”<br />
“The same !”<br />
His tone was quick and short.<br />
I stared at him in speechless surprise for a moment.<br />
He returned my scrutiny. w -<br />
Presently a sickly sort of smile played round his<br />
mouth. “We meet again under rather changed<br />
circumstances,” he said.<br />
Recalling that night when he had made an end<br />
of the manuscripts that were to have brought him<br />
name, fame and fortune, I could but assent.<br />
Wynyard Graves, the erstwhile hard-up free-lance,<br />
and Gregory Grub the publisher, who paid twenty-<br />
five per cent. to his shareholders, sweated his<br />
authors, and owned the largest and most expen-<br />
sively fitted-up place of business of its kind in<br />
England, one and the same individual I couldn't<br />
realise it. -<br />
“Did you happen upon Aladdin's lamp any-<br />
where P’’<br />
I ventured to ask after taking stock of his<br />
sumptuously furnished sanctum.<br />
Graves favoured me with one of his dreamy smiles.<br />
“Not exactly.”<br />
“Then how on earth did you do it 2"<br />
“Do it 2 ” he repeated, leaning back in his arm-<br />
chair, beating his desk with a paper-knife, “Do it 2<br />
Oh It was not so very difficult. Nothing near so<br />
'hard as trying to place outside contributions.”<br />
“But the start—how did you begin P”<br />
Wynyard Graves paused a moment.<br />
“Well,” he said slowly, “I’ll be candid with you.<br />
I began by picking the brains of a man who had<br />
made a hit with rather a novel idea. After rather<br />
a wobbling start the thing went. I had struck the<br />
public taste while the iron was hot.<br />
“Before, I had been engaged in furnishing ide<br />
TFIOR. 257<br />
for others without recompense. By annexing some-<br />
body else's schemes, I beheld myself feathering my<br />
Own nest.”<br />
“And then P”<br />
“Then I determined to tap an unbroached section<br />
of the reading public. Somebody had circulated a<br />
rag made up of stale jokes, idiotic drawings, and<br />
morbid sensationalism. I went one worse in the<br />
Same line ; as I expected, that also struck oil.<br />
“So in order to make cash breed faster, I<br />
launched out with another paper—to catch flies of<br />
a different kind this time. I concocted a penny<br />
jumble of fashion diagrams, millinery notes, love<br />
stories, in which lords woo servant girls, villains are<br />
Wanquished and virtue triumphs, bits of advice on<br />
love, marriage, the household, and so forth.<br />
“With this net I enmeshed half the shop-girls,<br />
housemaids, and other young women of the class<br />
known at present as “ladies’ in the kingdom. The<br />
fashion plates were evolved out of the brain of a<br />
clever, but lowly born, artist, who couldn't speak<br />
the King's English. I myself instructed the readers<br />
of this precious hotch-potch on connubial problems,<br />
doing so with the greater assurance because I have<br />
never married.<br />
“I had now catered to please the ignorant, the<br />
Vulgar and the silly. , My next venture supplied<br />
youthful hooligans with a long-felt want. I brought<br />
out a half-penny Weekly mass of blood and thunder<br />
—Jack the Ripper—Charles Peace literature. It<br />
Went—and still goes—like hot rolls. More than<br />
once juvenile offenders have thrown blame upon<br />
the tone of this wonder when questioned before<br />
the magistrate. A few weak-minded ragamuffins<br />
have gone so far as to commit suicide, urged thereto,<br />
So ran the evidence, by devouring pernicious litera-<br />
ture, in which my property played a leading<br />
part.” - - -<br />
“Are you in no dread of incurring a penalty for<br />
circulating a periodical of such a character P’” I<br />
interposed. -<br />
Graves laughed.<br />
“Penalty The law confines its labours to<br />
running-in second-hand booksellers for exposing<br />
authors like Aristotle, Byron, Zola. It never by<br />
any chance interfered with a journal that incites<br />
lads to crime—or men either, for the matter of<br />
that.”<br />
The speaker laughed cynically. -<br />
“Though tinged with bitterness, there is some<br />
truth in what you say,” I replied.<br />
“My dear fellow,” responded Graves, looking at<br />
me steadily, “you found by experience—as I did<br />
—What encouragement there is for writers of high<br />
* ſou know as well as I what demand there<br />
§ of scholarly type who use elegant<br />
quote Occasionally from the<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 258 (#318) ############################################<br />
<br />
258<br />
“Not much, to be sure, I regret to say.”<br />
“Well When a lad is thrashed for telling the<br />
truth he often turns liar. When a writer begins<br />
to understand that conscientious matter is a drug<br />
in the market, he either renounces his ideals with<br />
a view to scooping in the coin, or abandons the<br />
game in disgust.”<br />
“As you did.”<br />
“As I did, when I informed you on a memorable<br />
evening some ten years ago that I should go into<br />
trade. Now I am a linited liability company with<br />
a capital ; but I will spare you details. Nearly all<br />
my ventures have prospered.”<br />
“You will pardon what I am going to say,” I<br />
began. “Why, with the wealth your firm can<br />
command, have you never undertaken the issue of<br />
some standard work P. So far as I am aware, nothing<br />
but the veriest rags emanate from your house.”<br />
Graves opened his eyes in real or feigned<br />
Surprise.<br />
“You ask me such a question—you who know<br />
how generously the public patronises any man who<br />
tries to improve it, mentally or morally. Have I<br />
not already declared that when I abandoned writing<br />
I entered business 2 Business If I could raise<br />
the standard of public taste to-morrow by merely<br />
lifting my little finger, I wouldn’t do so. If I<br />
could instruct every street-arab, clerk or shop-girl<br />
in the world up to the level of a University gra-<br />
duate, by the expenditure of a halfpenny, I would<br />
keep the copper in my pocket. No, sir, I am not<br />
a schoolmaster or parson—most assuredly not a<br />
philanthropist. Indeed, I have even gone so far<br />
as to engender a delight for reading matter of a<br />
kind never before supplied.”<br />
“You do not allude to—to indecency.”<br />
“No. My policy is to stultify, not to shock.”<br />
4 & Ah ! 22<br />
We both maintained silence for a few seconds ;<br />
I broke it by asking him if he still adhered to his<br />
former expressed views on democracy.<br />
A sardonic grin contorted Graves' mouth as he<br />
replied.<br />
“The nation has for political purposes found it<br />
expedient to worship a little mud image which it<br />
calls Demos. Anything breathed against this<br />
image is rank heresy. Times gone by saw practical<br />
inventors, engineers and scientists springing from<br />
the class it stands for—poor men who thought out<br />
discoveries in their cottages and taught themselves<br />
the rudiments of education. We have changed all<br />
that. The class Demos represents to-day, consists<br />
chiefly of men whose aim is to work as little for as<br />
much pay as possible. Their leisure is passed mainly<br />
in public-houses. Their ambition is to oºº Yº<br />
latest ‘tips’ for a race meeting. They ay<br />
part loud, self-assertive, impudent,<br />
ape all the worse qualities of the<br />
majority.”<br />
t<br />
If they haven't reached the pitch of playing<br />
on Sunday, they are fast converting the s<br />
into a day of rowdy excursions or senseles<br />
thus are neither so industrious or de<br />
their grandfathers, yet their liberty i<br />
greater, their chances in life incompa<br />
numerous. Yet if you were to se<br />
opinion to me as proprietor of the Sp<br />
should do what every editor in Lond<br />
and stick it on the coals.”<br />
& 4 Why 2 ” •.<br />
“Because this class is in a prep<br />
golf<br />
bath<br />
“Its strikes dislocate trade. Its centralisation<br />
generates slums. Physical deterioration bids fair<br />
to make us a nation of cripples and paralytics.<br />
Idleness swells our rates. Rash and immature<br />
unions fill our hospitals, asylums, refuges and<br />
reformatories. We know it, but it would not pay<br />
us to express a candid opinion. So with our<br />
tongue in Our cheeks we allude to this little mud<br />
image as the “backbone of the country.”<br />
Graves paused a moment for breath.<br />
It was all I could do to keep from looking aghast<br />
at his utterances.<br />
“The democracy is never tired of throwing stones<br />
at the profligacy of the rich,” he burst out afresh,<br />
“but where do you find immorality so atrocious as<br />
among the denizens of mean streets 2<br />
“Another clause in my indictment, and I have<br />
done.<br />
“The son of a gentleman goes to a public<br />
school. He is cheeky to a master, misses his<br />
lessons or sins in some other way incident to boy-<br />
hood. He is flogged. Many a duke's son has<br />
been flogged at Eton, and will be again, I hope and<br />
believe.<br />
“The son of a labourer goes to a board School.<br />
He uses foul language in his teacher's hearing, or<br />
refuses to learn his task, and if he is chastised there<br />
is the whole country in an uproar. His parents<br />
assault and batter the poor pedagogue, and when<br />
they’ve done with him, the law prosecutes him.<br />
“Did any man ever know such absurdity ?<br />
Yet we are called an enlightened and progressive<br />
people !” e<br />
It was amazing to hear the editor and proprietor<br />
of one of the most democratic organs published<br />
thus expressing himself.<br />
“Open confession is good for the soul, I find, so<br />
I will continue to make you my father confessor<br />
for a few moments longer in order that you may<br />
take a close view of the machinery which has made<br />
me a success. I pander to society as well as Demos.<br />
There is no bit of scandal too Outrageous, no per-<br />
sonal interview too fulsome, no tittle-tattle too<br />
paltry for the columns of one or another of my<br />
ublications. Nobodies believe themselves some-<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 259 (#319) ############################################<br />
<br />
|<br />
259<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
bodies because it suits my purposes to print their<br />
photographs and biographies occasionally, at a price.”<br />
“Let us pass on to the next point,” I suggested.<br />
“Ah, yes! Let me see—the next point. Oh<br />
cruel and ghastly posters. And what my posters<br />
do for my budgets of fiction my contents bills do<br />
for my sheets of fact.”<br />
“I have seen them,” I said, “and I think it an<br />
infernal shame that while a poor newspaper lad<br />
may be run in for crying false news, editors may<br />
print misleading, grossly exaggerated bills in order<br />
to dispose of large editions with impunity.”<br />
“I agree with you,” assented Graves. “Blame<br />
that ridiculous old ass, the law—not us who profit<br />
by its stupidity. Business is business.”<br />
“Do you take up any position with regard to<br />
religion ?” I asked. -<br />
“Religion ? No! It is played out in England.”<br />
He regarded me with an inscrutable cast of<br />
visage as he finished the last sentence. His utter-<br />
ances had been, here and there, so startling that I<br />
found myself beginning to wonder whether he was<br />
speaking in jest or earnest. He belonged to a set<br />
of men whom it is difficult or impossible to<br />
“weigh up.”<br />
“How in the world do you manage to procure .<br />
ideas for new papers, for articles, for novel com-<br />
petitions P One brain, no matter how fecund,<br />
could never breed them all, I am sure,” I began<br />
after a pause. -<br />
Graves gazed at the ceiling absently for a<br />
moment. Then his sickly smile played about his<br />
mouth. “You would like to know P’’<br />
“I WOuld.”<br />
“Well, then, you shall. First the law of copy-<br />
right. Here we have a muddle so confusing that<br />
any smart man may avail himself of its absurdities<br />
to annex ideas from authors, from rivals, from a<br />
hundred sources, without let or hindrance.”<br />
“Dishonest ” I exclaimed.<br />
“Certainly,” agreed Graves readily. “But<br />
business. What is to prevent me from advertising<br />
for an assistant in my literary department—whether<br />
I want one or not ? Mr. Pen—shall we call him 2<br />
—answers my advertisement together with some<br />
scores of others. He, and the most likely among<br />
them, are accorded interviews.<br />
“‘Mr. Pen,' I say, ‘what suggestions would you<br />
make to improve my journal should you be<br />
appointed to the post applied for P’<br />
“Mr. Pen, poor guileless creature, unbosoms him-<br />
self. Some of his notions are good and feasible.<br />
My shorthand clerk in attendance takes notes of<br />
them, as of the others emanating from the<br />
applicants I review.<br />
“I close each successive interview with a gracious<br />
promise that the departing penman shall hear<br />
from me.<br />
“So he does. To the effect that the appointment<br />
has been filled up.<br />
“Shameful ' " I shouted as I grasped his<br />
meaning.<br />
Graves slowly stroked his chin.<br />
“The law allows it. What more is to be said.”<br />
“You are an unscrupulous fellow,” I answered.<br />
Graves laughed, a harsh, cackling, disagreeable<br />
laugh.<br />
“I have gone into trade.”<br />
I put on my hat and prepared to quit the place,<br />
sº moral atmosphere I began to find growing<br />
etid.<br />
“Before I go,” I said, “will you be good<br />
enough to inform me for what purpose you have<br />
bought manuscripts of an ethnographical nature<br />
from me? I should like to know this particularly,<br />
Seeing that no publication of a character available<br />
for their insertion appears to figure on your rather<br />
extensive list.”<br />
Graves stood up behind his writing-table, and<br />
Once again repeated his detestable grin.<br />
“You have a right to ask what purposes your<br />
manuscripts serve in our business. I’ll tell you.<br />
They are of use in supplying local colour to some<br />
of the tales of adventure our boy subscribers love<br />
so dearly. We can offer you even better terms to<br />
continue your papers on the same subject.”<br />
I was too disgusted to make any rejoinder.<br />
Turning on my heel, I left Wynyard Graves or<br />
Gregory Grubb—as the reader prefers—to his<br />
papers, his schemes, his success, his huge fortune.<br />
The last I heard of him was his return to<br />
Parliament as the “Champion of the Working<br />
Classes.”<br />
CORRESPONDENCE.<br />
—e—sº-e—<br />
UNITED STATES COPYRIGHT.<br />
DEAR MR. THRING, I have been reading the<br />
United States Copyright Act and your interesting<br />
article upon it. It seems a curious innovation to<br />
give such preference to foreign countries and<br />
exempt all from the burden of the manufacturing<br />
clauses, with the exception of England.<br />
May I call your attention to your paragraph<br />
about dramatic and musical compositions, wherein<br />
you say that they must be printed from type set<br />
in the United States if they are produced for sale<br />
in book form. This would be a serious alteration<br />
in the law, which does not appear to me to have<br />
been intended or enacted. It is only “books” and<br />
“periodicals” which are mentioned in (a) and (b)<br />
of section 5, to which the manufacturing clauses<br />
apply. A dramatic composition, even if it is pub-<br />
lished in book form, should be described as a<br />
“dramatic composition ” under (d) and not as<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 260 (#320) ############################################<br />
<br />
260<br />
THE AUTHOR.<br />
a “book,” and if it is so described the manufac-<br />
turing clauses would not be applicable. I hope<br />
you do not mind my comment upon this point,<br />
because it seems to me that the statement “then<br />
the type-setting clause takes effect ’’ is inaccurate,<br />
and may give rise to misunderstanding.<br />
Yours very truly, HAROLD HARDY.<br />
—º-º-º-<br />
MAGAZINE WRITERS AND THE INCOME TAx.<br />
SIR,--I have only to-day, March 28th, seen the<br />
article on this subject signed by Alfred Smythe ;<br />
and although it contains much with which one<br />
cannot fail to sympathise, yet being fully aware, to<br />
my cost, of the hard struggle which magazine and<br />
newspaper writers often have, I totally fail to see<br />
why we should be freed from the payment of<br />
income tax any more than any other class of<br />
professional men or women are.<br />
not rather be thankful that they make sufficient by<br />
their pen to be taxed at all !<br />
barrister or doctor has quite as many difficulties to<br />
contend with for some years, and often for ever, as<br />
the writer of magazine articles | A long Univer-<br />
sity education usually is essential in his case, while<br />
it is by no means so in the case of Writers.<br />
Compared with many other professional men,<br />
e.g., Solicitors, architects,l and agents, accountants,<br />
writers of magazine articles need not have had to<br />
pay a heavy premium to learn their profession,<br />
nor when in practice is there the same professional<br />
—apart from personal –expense, nor is there any<br />
capital expenditure required as is frequently the<br />
case in business, unless, indeed, some writers are<br />
disposed to look upon a few “postage stamps" as<br />
capital expenditure.<br />
H. STUART THOMPSON.<br />
IS THE 6s. NOVEL DOOMED 2<br />
SIR,-My temperament is neither gloomy nor<br />
pessimistic, but, on the contrary, it is of the most<br />
optimistic character ; yet I cannot help saying that<br />
in my humble opinion the outlook of the profession<br />
of novelist is very grave. I have spent a few days<br />
interviewing booksellers, and to sum up briefly<br />
what passed between us, I was informed by more<br />
than one prominent bookseller that the clamour on<br />
the part of the public for cheap reprints is daily<br />
growing more intensified, and that the 6s. novel<br />
of even prominent writers is becoming less and<br />
less in demand.<br />
One bookseller exclaimed, “Oh, as for the new<br />
writer, he has, poor devil no chance at all.” The<br />
position is not only serious for the latter, but it is<br />
even more serious for the former class of writer,<br />
and there is internal evidence to show that the<br />
cheap reprints have come to stay.<br />
Whom is the author to blame 2 Is it the public,<br />
Should writers<br />
Surely the struggling<br />
2<br />
who apparently find it more entertaining to read<br />
cheap reprints than new fiction ; or is the blame to<br />
be fixed upon the trade 2 It would be a difficult<br />
thing to trace the evolution of the cheap reprint,<br />
but it is obvious to the author, and also to the<br />
trade, that in spite of the evidence that the<br />
“enemy’’ has come to stay, the present is a diffi-<br />
culty which must somehow be overcome both for<br />
the sake of the publishing trade and also for the<br />
profession of novelist. Publishers' travellers will<br />
tell you that they are quite unable to excite the<br />
curiosity of booksellers with regard to new 63.<br />
novels, and that the trade will not look at them.<br />
On the other hand, these same gentlemen have<br />
their order books crammed with orders running<br />
into three and four figures for “mixed” reprints,<br />
at 7S. per dozen, less 10 per cent.<br />
It would be really very interesting to know<br />
whether the person to put in the pillory is the<br />
bookseller or our old friend the publisher. Or<br />
perhaps it is the taste of the public which has<br />
become so depraved, eh?<br />
Yours faithfully, A NovKLIST.<br />
—º-º-o-<br />
MAGAZINE PROPRIETORS.<br />
SIR,--I should like to bring to the notice of the<br />
Authors’ Society the responsibilities of the pro-<br />
prietors of certain second-class periodicals and<br />
papers, and should like to inquire whether there is<br />
a satisfactory solution for the following difficulty.<br />
A magazine engages a contributor and offers to<br />
pay him a fixed rate for articles. After a short<br />
period, the contributor experiences a difficulty in<br />
obtaining payment, and finally, on threatening to<br />
bring an action, is informed that the magazine<br />
has changed hands and that the proprietors are not<br />
liable for the work published before the date they<br />
took over the responsibilities. The contributor is<br />
in the following position : he has to find out what<br />
has become of the former proprietors and where he<br />
can apply for payment. In many cases this is<br />
exceedingly difficult, and in many cases impossible.<br />
Should he discover the whereabouts of the former<br />
owners he is very often unable to obtain payment.<br />
owing to the fact that they have no money and no<br />
assets. Two points seem to be very hard upon the<br />
author. First, that the original owner, who has<br />
most probably obtained something for the sale of<br />
his magazine, should not meet the just demands of<br />
his creditors. Secondly, that the magazine should<br />
be allowed to go on under the same title without<br />
notifying the creditors of the change in the<br />
responsibilities.<br />
I should be glad if the members of the Authors’<br />
Society could give any information as to , the<br />
course which it is advisable to adopt in these<br />
Circumstances.<br />
Yours truly, A SUFFERER.<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 260 (#321) ############################################<br />
<br />
AD VERTISEMENTS.<br />
iii<br />
THE TIDE MILL SECRET. -<br />
By PERCY YoUNG. Handsomely produced, 320 pp., with<br />
Frontispiece, 2s. 6d. net.<br />
“A readable novel . . . life is vividly depicted.”—Dundee<br />
Advertiser.<br />
“A pleasant tale.”—The Universe.<br />
GARDEN SONGS, and other Poems.<br />
By MARGARET E. FoED. A capital book of poetry, highly<br />
commended to all lovers of fresh and stimulating verse.<br />
Printed on thick antique paper, with uncut edges, and bound in<br />
attractive brochure cover, with flaps, 1s.6d. met. NOW READY.<br />
THE LONG RUN : A Novel.<br />
By ROBERT B. MoRENO. With Frontispiece on art paper.<br />
Bound in half red and half blue, in cloth, 2s. 6d. met.<br />
“A very curious novel.”—Publishers Circular.<br />
“This novel is unusual and distinctly original.”—What's On.<br />
GERMAN THE VIKING : A Story of Ancient<br />
England.<br />
By JAMES STUART. Handsome bevelled boards, 1s. 6d. net.<br />
“A vigorous and interesting tale of the stormy life of the old<br />
Norsemen.”—Scotsman.<br />
“The author writes pleasantly and with clearness of expres-<br />
sion; he has managed to bring the old-world atmosphere into his<br />
story.”—IIull Daily Matil.<br />
MON CA OF ESSEBURNI : A Novel.<br />
By MARGARET F. Osborn E. Contains splendid photograph as<br />
frontispiece, and is bound with attractive design. 2s. met.<br />
“The story of a girl who fell in love with her sister's lover . . .<br />
Includes some pretty description of the village.”—Christictim.<br />
World.<br />
MSS.<br />
LONDON :<br />
ARTHUR. H. STOCKWELL,<br />
29, L'UIDGATE HILL, E.C.<br />
Full lists on application, post free.<br />
Authors should forward MSS. of any description<br />
(Novels, Stories, Poems, Essays, &c.) direct to Mr.<br />
STOCKWELL, Who Will immediately advise, free<br />
of charge, as to publication.<br />
SANG|M|GNAND OF WAL D'ELSA<br />
|N TUSGANW.<br />
AN ART HISTORICAL WORK.<br />
Y<br />
Jean Carlyle Graham and Elizabeth M. Derbishire.<br />
With 27 Pen and Ink Drawings, many hitherto<br />
unpublished Documents from Tuscan State<br />
Archives, a Bibliography, and numerous Copy-<br />
righted Photographs.<br />
ERMAN NO LOESCHER & CO.<br />
(Bretschreider & Regenberg), ROME.<br />
MRS. GILL, Typetoriting Office,<br />
(Established 1883.) 35, LUDGATE HILL, E.C.<br />
Authors' MSS. carefully copied from 1s, per 1,000<br />
words. Duplicate copies third price. French and German<br />
MSS. accurately copied ; or typewritten English trans-<br />
lations supplied. References kindly permitted to Messrs.<br />
A. P. Watt & Son, Literary Agents, Hastings House,<br />
Norfolk Street, Strand, W.C. Telephone 8464 Central.<br />
TYPEVVRITING<br />
OF EVERY DESCRIPTION, 9d. PER 1,000 WoRDs.<br />
Two COPIES, 1s. PER 1,000 WORDS.<br />
Authors’ MSS., I,egal Documents, Reports, &c., carefully and<br />
accurately copied. Orders by Post promptly attended to.<br />
Mrs. SOUTHEE, 273, Francis Rd., LEWION, LONDON, E.<br />
TYPEWRITING.<br />
MISS BARRETT,” ºve.<br />
Telephone : 9677 Central.<br />
Literary Work, Plays, &c., promptly & accurately copied.<br />
- Orders by post quickly carried out.<br />
Efficient Clerks supplied to Clients by day, week, or maonth.<br />
Terms and specimen of work on application. IHighest References.<br />
TYPEYWRITING:<br />
ALL KINDS FROM 9d. PER 1,000.<br />
Authors', Playwrights’, Clergy men's, &c.,<br />
Correctly and efficiently executed.<br />
Good Work combined with cheapness and cuickness.<br />
In English, French, or German. Good References.<br />
SEND A SMALL ORDER NOW!<br />
MSS RALLING, 175, Loughborough Rd., London, S.W.<br />
Rd.,<br />
§º wº-,e, sº sº -> ...," ºr sº *.*, *, *, * * *R*, * * * * > * ºf ºx * * *<br />
§ §§§ ‘. . . 5 * º tº 2:<br />
Two HUNDRED AND FIFTY<br />
(GUINEAS AWARD.<br />
The Literary Agency of London has pleasure<br />
in announcing that it has been instructed<br />
by M.Y. ANDREW MELROSE to conduct an<br />
open competition For THE<br />
- BEST NOVEL --<br />
tº submitted before November i. 1909. The Adjudicators<br />
will be D<br />
MRS. FLORA ANNIE STEEL, .<br />
MISS MARY CHOLMONDELEY, and<br />
MRS. HENRY DE LA PASTURE.<br />
Particulars may be had by sending Starmped Addressed<br />
Envelope to -<br />
: THE LITERARY AGENCY OF LONDON, ;<br />
º 5, Henrietta Street, Covent Garden, W.C.<br />
*...º.º.<br />
MSS.<br />
2.<br />
sº tº<br />
5 . .”<br />
º' ---<br />
". . . . . . . .<br />
| Tim T<br />
carefully and quickly done on good paper.<br />
References to leading Publishers.<br />
Miss G. BLAXELLE, King-Potter, Clements & Co. Ld.<br />
56, Ludgate Hill, H. C.<br />
NO AUTHOR<br />
be he amateur or expert, can afford to be without<br />
HINTS THAT HELP.<br />
A Book of sound advice and<br />
instruction on the way to write<br />
and sell Short Stories.<br />
There is, of course, a right way and a wrong way,<br />
and the writer who is not fully versed in his profes-<br />
sion is handicapped to the extent of his inexperience.<br />
“HINTS THAT HELP’’: 1s. 6d. post free from<br />
The Literary Typewriting Bureau,<br />
46, Earlham Grove, Forest Gate, ESSEX.<br />
(Please mention “The Author.”)<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
## p. 260 (#322) ############################################<br />
<br />
iV ADVERTISEMENTS.<br />
T0 AUTHORS AND JOURNALISTS.<br />
* The writer, whether he aspires to write novels,<br />
short stories, or articles, often spends years in<br />
uncongenial work, rebuffs and drudgery being<br />
the only return for the time and labour spent.<br />
• THE COURSE OF LITERARY TRAINING<br />
promoted by the Literary Correspondence College<br />
teaches the aspirant to serve his apprenticeship<br />
to Literature in the briefest time possible.<br />
* The College also undertakes Literary Agency<br />
business of all kinds.<br />
For full particulars write at once for pamphlet<br />
D.M. to the LITERARY CORRESPONDENCE CollBGE,<br />
9, Arundel Street. Strand, W.C.<br />
| FIRST LEssons INSTORY WRITING.<br />
By BARRY PAIN.<br />
2s. 6d. net; 2s. 8d. post free.<br />
*|| Of this work the Westminste?' Gazette writes: “The<br />
beginner who takes these lessons to heart may be<br />
quite assured of an advantage over his competitors.”<br />
HOW TO BECOME AN AUTHOR.<br />
By ARNOLD BENNETT. A Practical Guide; full of<br />
useful hints. 5s. net; 5s. 4d. post free.<br />
THE LITERARY CORRESPONDENCE COLLEGE,<br />
S, Arundel Street, Strand, W.C.<br />
Typexyriting,<br />
can guarantee good work at reasonable charges.<br />
Orders by post receive prompt attention.<br />
Duplicating,<br />
SEP for Estimate if you require any MSS. typed or Circulars duplicated.<br />
TWO popular Hotels in Gentral London.<br />
Opposite the British Museum.<br />
THAGKERAY HOTEL;<br />
Great Russell Street, London.<br />
Near the British Museum.<br />
KINGSLEY HOTEL;<br />
Hart Street, Bloomsbury Square, London.<br />
Passenger Lifts. Bathrooms on every Floor. Lounges<br />
and Spacious Dining, Drawing, Writing, Reading, Billiard<br />
and Smoking Rooms. Fireproof Floors, Perfect Sanita-<br />
tion. Telephones. Night Porters.<br />
Bedrooms (including attendance) from 3/6 to 6|=.<br />
Inclusive Charge for Bedroom, Attendance, Table d'Hote,<br />
Breakfast and Dinner, from 8/6 to 10/6 per day.<br />
Full Tariff and Testimonials on application.<br />
Telegraphic Addresses :<br />
Thackeray Hotel—“Thackeray, London.”<br />
Kingsley Hotel—“Bookcraft, London.”<br />
arid Copying.<br />
It will cost you nothing, and I<br />
Price List and Testimonials on application.<br />
C. HERBERT CAESAR, Homefield, Woodstock Road, St. Albans.<br />
Special terms to Authors if you mention this paper.<br />
E8TABLISHED]<br />
The Wessex Press,<br />
[XVIII. CENT.<br />
Tattºtozz.<br />
BARNICOTT & PEARCE<br />
INVITE ENQUIRIES RESPECTING PRINTING.<br />
ESTIMATES OF COST, AND OTHER DETAILS, PROMPTLY GIVEN.<br />
SIPKES and SIFKES,<br />
The West Kensington Typewriting Offices,<br />
(Established 1893)<br />
223a, Harm mersmith Road, LONDON, W.<br />
Authors' MSS. ; Translations; Duplicating; Plays and Actors' Parts ;<br />
Legal, General and Commercial Documents. Private Rooms for<br />
Dictation. Usual Terms. Iłeferences.<br />
TYPEWRITING OFFICES.<br />
(Established 1897.)<br />
COVENTRY. — Please note Change of<br />
Address to “WESTLEIGH,” KING RICHARD<br />
STREET, from Oswald House, Queen<br />
Victoria Road. TYPEwBITING OF EVERY<br />
DESCRIPTION, from 9d. per 1,000 words.<br />
Eccellent Testimonials from Plrt iſ JJ’rifers.<br />
** TELE ATUTIEIOIER,.”<br />
scALE FOR AD VERTISEMENTS.<br />
[ALLOWANCE TO MEMBERS OF THE SOCIETY 20 PER CENT.]<br />
Front Page ...#4 0 0<br />
Other Pages . ... 3 0 0<br />
Half of a Page ... tº º ſº. • ? , 1 10 0<br />
Quarter of a Page tº - - tº o 0 @ 9 tº a tº a • so tº e & ... 0 15 0<br />
Eighth of a Page * * - * - - ... . ... Q 7 6<br />
Single Column Advertisements per inch 0 6 0<br />
Reduction of 20 per cent. made for a Series of Sia, and of 25 per cent. for<br />
Twelve Imsertions.<br />
Advertisements should reach the Office not later than the 20th for<br />
insertion in the following month's issue.<br />
All letters respecting Advertisements should be addressed to the<br />
ADVERTISEMENT MANAGER, The Author Office, 39, Old Queen Street,<br />
Storey's Gate, S.W. - -<br />
--Pºw<br />
Printed by BRADBURY, AGNEW, & Co. LD., and Published by them for THE SocIETY OF AUTHORS (INCORPORATED),<br />
at 10, Bouverie Stleet, London, E.C. | https://historysoa.com/files/original/5/394/1909-06-01-The-Author-19-9.pdf | publications, The Author |